41 Spoilerific Reasons Why I Loved That Beautiful Disaster Cloud Atlas

true detective /hannibal / dc movies / snl / mindhole blowers / netflix / celebrity facts / marvel

41 Spoilerific Reasons Why I Loved That Beautiful Disaster Cloud Atlas

By Joanna Robinson | Seriously Random Lists | October 31, 2012 | Comments ()


Tom Tykwer and The Wachowski's cinematic gamble, Cloud Atlas, opened this weekend to divisive reviews and a disappointing box office haul. My Pajiba colleague, Dan Carlson, didn't spare any scathe or bitch in his review of the film. And while I respect both Dan's view of this specific movie and his general philosophy that any film adaptation should be able to stand on its own, I cannot help but admit that I fell head over *ss for this gorgeous mess of a film. Did it have flaws? Oh, hell to the yes. Could the filmmakers have avoided the yellowface controversy by casting the same actors without "asian" make-up/special effects on their face? Indeed. That particular setting is a fantastical, futuristic South Korea. If Tykwer and The Wachowskis were committed to using the same actors to maintain the narrative thread, then white people could easily have populated the various echelons of society. Why, then, am I willing to overlook the flaws? Quite possibly my love is a residual one left over from the hours I've spent with David Mitchell's incomparable novel. But all I can do is offer my honest reaction: unabashed admiration. Even for the sh*tty bits. So here, folks, is some (spoilerific) Cloud Atlas love. Choke on it.

Because Although There Was Regrettable Yellow Face

There Was Also White Face

And...Green Face?

Because If Short Skirts Don't Do It For You

Then Low Slung Pants Surely Will

Because Of The Astonishing New Faces

Thumbnail image for bQuV0kJrqBtsBCsBFVM1bacv0Xe.jpeg

And The Reliable Old Ones

Because Of The West Side Story References
Screen Shot 2012-10-30 at 8.51.52 PM.png

And That Thing He Did

Because, Aw, David Keith Keith David!

Because Tom Hanks Works Really Well With Kids

And Children Too

Because Fellow Ben Whishaw Fans Should Form An Orderly Q

Because, Listen, We All Loved Blade Runner

And That First Matrix Movie

Because Of The Pretty Women

And The Prettier Dudes

Because Of The Awkward Way Tom Hanks Smokes Cannabis

And The Badass Way Halle Berry Smokes Cannibals

Because Hugo Weaving Let Them Do This

And Hugh Grant Let Them Do This

And, Most Of All, Halle Berry Let Them Do That

Because The Soundtrack Alone Will Crack Open Your Heart

But Bae Doona's Tears Will Tear It To Pieces

Because Of The Way The Film Rallies Around Underrepresented Minorities Like Homosexuals

And The Elderly

And, Uh Replicants


Because Of Old Souls

And Old Seoul

Because Of The Vulcans

Because Of The Daleks

Because Of The Happy Endings That Weren't In The Book

And The Sad Endings That Were

Because Of The Terrible British Accents

And The Seamless American Ones

Because Of The Actors You Expect To Play Villains

And The Ones You Never Would

Because Of The Bits Of David Mitchell's Writing That Didn't Translate Well To The Screen

And The Ones That Most Definitely Did
Screen Shot 2012-10-30 at 9.03.08 PM.png

Fevre Dream by George R. R. Martin | X-Men: Days of Future Past Mutates from Vaughn to Singer

Are you following Pajiba on Facebook or Twitter? Every time you do, Bill Murray crashes a wedding.

Comments Are Welcome, Bigots and Trolls Are Not

  • denesteak

    i liked it. I didn't think I would since I love the book, but I really, really enjoyed the movie.

    (still think Halle Berry is a shit actress and Tom Hanks was miscast.)

  • duckandcover

    What in God's name.

  • HMDK

    Yes. Let me throw "deep" sounding pompous idiocy at the audience while plying them with pretty pictures... Aha! Sound and fury signifying fuck all, still works!

  • Love this, Johanna! Atlas is a high point / for 2012.

  • John G.

    and because you're incapable of disliking anything.

  • melissa82

    I loved it too. I had very low expectations though, so that may have helped.

  • I'll see in recognition of the gloriousness of the book, like you, Joanna. Truly a wonderful novel. If it is a train wreck, it'll be beautiful, worth the try and have enough lovely moments to make it worth the time. People who try to do something as challenging as make this movie deserve some response beyond the simple 'consumer' satisfying reflex, IMHO.

    Also, Tykwer - we want him to make more movies. For those who only know of him via 'Run Lola Run', I point you to 'Winter Sleepers', made before that Lola goodness. Go!

  • Natallica

    Pigmy goats! I'm sold. Because pigmy goats. And pigmy goats.

  • Slash

    Eh, maybe I'll go see it in the cheapo movies. But I'm not paying $8 to see pretty pictures. I can see those for free any day. I will give them credit for trying something new and different, as opposed to a sequel. Any time someone makes an effort to make a cool movie, that's worth mentioning. Maybe it'll win some Oscars for art direction and editing. It does look like a beautiful mess.

  • Rocabarra

    Never read the book but I loved this movie. I was confused as hell for the first two hours but it did come together in the end. I found it quite compelling and look forward to seeing it a second time.

  • Nicolae

    This was horrible. I went in expecting a bad movie, but not to be tortured for hours. Constantly left hoping something would happen to make up for the time lost. Dante had no idea there was a tenth circle in hell, and that's because this movie was too horrible for his nightmares.

  • e jerry powell

    Because Hugo Weaving Let Them Do This

    What do you mean by that, Joanna? I mean, it's hardly the first time he's been in drag, and he didn't look particularly sexy that first time, either.

  • BWeaves

    Besides Pricilla, he was almost a woman as Elrond. Dress, hairdo, elven tiara.

  • e jerry powell


  • JoannaRobinson

    How DARE you malign the sexiness of Mitzi Del Bra.

  • Aratweth

    Because Felicia Jollygoodfellow has better legs, and he damn well knows it.

  • e jerry powell

    *snap* *snap*

  • Aratweth

    Great post; almost makes me want to see it for the sheer pretty...however, it's really, REALLY bothering me that if one threw a beret on Lady Weaving, he/she's a dead ringer for Mama Fratelli from The Goonies. I keep waiting to hear something about Francis and a toupee...

  • Lee

    I'll probably see it, despite the bad reviews, and I'll probably be disappointed. But it still looks way more interesting than all the remakes, sequals, prequels, reboots and rip-offs out there in Hollywoodland.

blog comments powered by Disqus