bellaedwardkiss400_2.jpg
11 Reasons Why the Twilight Phenomenon Scares the Living Sh*t Out of Me


A Seriously Random List / Dustin Rowles

Miscellaneous | October 16, 2009 | Comments (195)


I live in a relatively insular world, pop-culture-wise. In real life, I’m mostly surrounded either by similarly-minded people or people that just don’t care enough about pop-culture to keep up with it or offer much in the way of commentary (fucking snobs). Most of my interaction with the outside world’s view of pop culture, of course, comes here on Pajiba. I often forget, intellectually speaking, that the readership here is in the minority: If everyone were more like Pajiba readers, “Arrested Development” would be in its seventh season, “CSI” never would’ve been popular enough to spawn two spin-offs, our multiplexes would be dominated zombie movies and, of course, fewer people in movies and television would wear clothes.

Granted, it’s not as though I’m surprised by the popularity of “Dancing with Stars” or Paul Blart: Mall Cop. It’s just that I don’t interact with their audiences very often and, when I do, it’s often difficult to politely restrain myself when they remark that Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen was their favorite movie of the year. We have different cultural tastes, that’s all. Also, they like stupid shit. I’m not trying to dismiss the rest of America, or even thumb my nose up. It’s just, despite their protestations to the contrary, I don’t really consider myself an intellectual snob — I’m a white-trash bumpkin from the Bible belt, and in the circles I run in, I’m probably considered something of a loser, professionally speaking (you watch movies? For a living?)

To get closer to the point: 95 percent of comments on Pajiba are left within 24 hours of a post. As a result, I rarely see comments left on entries a week or two after the post has run. So, I’m often taken aback when I occasionally do revisit an old post and find comments left a week or a month after the original post, usually by drive-by commenters who found their way here by way of a Google search. While I’m certainly used to getting beat up, lectured, scolded, or mocked in the comments section, these come from an entirely different perspective. This comment from the Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen review is fairly typical:

maybe if sean penn played a draft dodging, commy pinko, dick suckin robot you would have liked it more. truth, i was in the theatre with a few hundred people and everyone seemed to enjoy the film.

More often than not, box-office figures are cited, and a reference to it being “mindless entertainment” is offered in the movie’s defense, along with a suggestion that I just “turn my brain off,” as though my wasted education has prevented me from enjoying a sweaty fat man running around the mall with a Taser and mustard on his shirt.

Which brings me to the real point of this post: Twilight.

Lookit: The Twilight phenomenon is what it is. I don’t have a huge objection to it, any more than I have an objection to most of the empty, meaningless fossilized turds I visit in theaters at least every other week. I also understand that many of our own readers have read the entire Twilight series — they fall down the rabbit hole of morbid curiosity, and they get sucked in, all the while appreciating just how awful Stephenie Meyers’ series is. It’s “meaningless entertainment.” I get that. My wife watches “Antiques Roadshow.” That’s meaningless, and it’s not even entertaining.

But the people — my God — the people who unironically love Twilight, who scour the Internet to find opportunities to defend it, who suffer weird delusions of grandeur — these people terrify me. And for whatever reason, over the last couple of years, the Google Gods send us an inordinate number of people who hate Perez Hilton (welcome! Stick around) and defenders of Twilight. This is the real reason I loathe Twilight. Not because it’s meaningless entertainment, but because these girls — these poor fucking sad teenage girls — have been infected by it. It’s not meaningless to them. It’s mind controlling. It’s somehow fucked with their heads, turned their minds to mush, and really, really affected their grammar skills.

Here are ten comments left on our site in Twilight-related posts. I’m not mocking. I’m not thumbing my nose. I’m showing concern. These girls will someday have careers (and many of them already do). They will bear children. Who will bear more children. Who will rule over America’s Idiocracy. You want to see the future of America? Look at these comments. This is why I hate Twilight.

—-


11. OMG!I Love Robbert Pattison so much and the movie was like totally awsome i cant belive people think its stupid its like totaly awsome im downloading it on my ipod and buying the movie beacause of how much i love it i just need breaking dawn to complete the book series i cant wait till new moon comes out and eclipse ohh also breakindg dawn of course lol! — Vanessa

10. all of you are so dense and lifeless.

the only reason you people are dissing Twilight is because it is so popular and amazing. all of you are just jealous because the shit you like sucks. you all just can’t deal with the fact that Twilight and everything that has to do with Twilight is beloved all over the world. well i guess haters are inevitable with something so amazing. All of you should get a life or a hobby. — *L


9. first,
twilight is amazing.
second,
it doesnt matter what you say because your a piece of CRAP!
o and three,
FUCK YOU!!! — i love edward anthony cullen :)


8. look dude! you’re absolutely and utterly full of shit!

the movie was awesome and millions of people (not just teenage girls) have seen it and loved it! As for you and many IDIOT LOSER men who hate this movie, my guess is that u guyz are all losers who don’t have the ability to comprehend any movie that doesn’t star Steven Segul or Will Ferrell!

so my advice is: next time you wanna review a movie, make a habit of actually WATCHING it instead of stalking teen girls, checking out their clothes, or eavesdropping on their convo.

EDWARD CULLEN IS HOT! EDWARD CULLEN iS HOT!! — cullen’s fan


7. twilight is beautiful..im not fond of reading a thick book but when i started to read twilight at the very beginning of the book i had felt the romance and the kilig..thanks to my cousin whom i borrowed the book..she’s so adik kasi..Edward Cullen is so handsome..I like him in how he treat Bella.. — Star Tabaquero

6. Come on do not quit the series.Who cares about the 5 th book.200 pages okay change it up.I am into the 2nd book and it is good.My ant told me that the 5th one is about how Edward feels.Change something up.I know it is a big difference,but my up session with vampires is expanding cause of your books.Keep it going.Please!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!I would know how you feel if you read this from an angry reader.I love the books and if you kept writing them I would greatly appreciate it.E-mail me please.So Stephanie Meyer please e-mail me.!!!!!!!!!! p.s. Email me back —Chloe

5. I really love all the characters of the movie the actress and actor,and I bought all the books and read them all.My doughther,My son and I addicted and watch three times a day.Could you imagined I read all this four books to know what happened for them.I liked all the actor and actress hope you will never changes them for your next movie.otherwise will never the same.We loved everyone They so beautiful and looked terrific. — katrina rose

4. have u people ever actually thought to read the books? the books are 10 times betta than the film but cum on who doesnt lyk a topless lad!and maybe if u did waste 5% of ure lame lyf u will realise what shit ure talkin —twilightlover

3. Um well forget all of yall who is haten on Twilight this has to be one good love story! all girls go throu the depressed thing in high school over a guy! HELLO their in freaking high school. Yea maybe thier are vampires in it but thats what makes it more worth watching and reading. I’ve read every single book and the one that hasn’t came out yet and seen every trailer thats out thier for New Moon its real good! you should take a min and really read the freaking book!!!! — Kim

2 hihi it’s hihi. i think they books were good. they had an interesting plot and pulled you in. and for heaven’s sake, please leave edward alone. talk about bella all you want, but DO NOT talk about edward. he can TAKE YOUR HEAD OFF. — HiHi

1. hey,i love your books but sometimes we all just get bored of reading so i think on your web page you should have something for us to sign up at and then we pick a chapter that were on and it will read us that chapter then well have to read a few more chapters then we could go back and it will read it to us


thank you!
katie

P.S. please think about this cool idea. — katie


Pajiba Love 10/16/09 | Law Abiding Citizen Review





Comments

Rowles....WHAT THE FUCK are you still doing here poting shit??!!!!!!!!! Especially about mothefucking Twilight??!!! (not worth the time to html tag)

Get thine ass to a showing of WTWTA most ricky-tick before I have to smash your face in Macho-Man Randy Savage style. You should have been in line for the first show at 11am.

Posted by: PissBoy at October 16, 2009 2:06 PM

Vasectomies for all!

Posted by: Jim Doggie at October 16, 2009 2:07 PM

EDWARD CULLEN IS HOOOOOOOOOOOOOT! And REAL! Don't destroy my masturbatory fantasies Dustin.

In all seriousness though...I was once a silly teen girl. And I had silly teen obsessions. Not to this level, but at that age it's easy to get sucked into a Twilight-esque phenomenon. The adults sadden me, but I have hope for the young 'uns.

However...I do not remember my obsessions. Hmm. That's probably because my subconscious has blocked them from my memory in order for me to go through life with a modicum of self-esteem. If I somehow DID remember how I used to tape pictures of Jonathan Brandis to my bedroom wall and rewatch Sidekicks and Ladybugs and dream that one day we would be wed because we shared the same birthday, well...the consequences would be dire.

...FUCK. Jackée!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Julie at October 16, 2009 2:16 PM

If I had a superpower, it would be to sterilize people with my mind. Screw flying and super strength and x-ray vision. I want to single-handedly control who gets to reproduce and who becomes an evolutionary standstill.

Just call me Eugenics Girl.

Posted by: Fi at October 16, 2009 2:18 PM

"maybe if sean penn played a draft dodging, commy pinko, dick suckin robot you would have liked it more. truth, i was in the theatre with a few hundred people and everyone seemed to enjoy the film.."

------------------------------------------

Hmmmm, this guy brings up a good point. And you are a huge pinko, Rowles.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at October 16, 2009 2:21 PM

Hey Julie. Know why Jonnathan Brandis killed himself?


...because one day he realized "Fuck...I'm Jonathan Brandis. Goddammit..."

Posted by: PissBoy at October 16, 2009 2:21 PM

im not fond of reading a thick book

*shakes head*

Posted by: gp at October 16, 2009 2:24 PM

Despite my seething hatred of the Twilight phenomenon and its putrid infection of young adult literature, it has been highly lucrative for my family. Just because my brother kind of sort of looks like 'ol R Patz he has carved out a career for himself impersonating Edward Cullen at Twilight Conventions (yeah.. I know). He's gotten to travel the country, see places he would he would never otherwise see like New York and Chicago and even good old Forks, and make tons of money all while making fun of the culture that writes him a nice paycheck and fawns over him as if he were the real thing.

So thanks Twilight for surprisingly changing our lives.

If anyone is interested you can check him out at http://www.thehillywoodshow.com/watch-the-show/the-hillywood-show%E2%84%A2-parodies/ and watch his parody videos.

(sorry I don't know how to create links like you fancy pants internet people)

Posted by: Wendy at October 16, 2009 2:25 PM

to be fair, I think that some of those were probably written in ESL.

I sincerely hope.

P.S. #3, I love your use of "thier" to cover both "there" and "they're". It could probably also be used for "their", couldn't it? Fantastic. Thank *you* for adding a single, new word to cover all those other stupid words that make sense. My life is so much easier now!

Posted by: Anna von Beaverpuppet at October 16, 2009 2:25 PM

And Edward Cullen would be.....?

Posted by: katy at October 16, 2009 2:26 PM

also: dick suckin robot


i am NOT a robot! i have feelings, damnit! HUMAN feelings!

Posted by: gp at October 16, 2009 2:26 PM

I second the Eugenics Girl. Hopefully some of the Twilight readers will mature out of that BS. But I suspect a majority won't; they will go on to support the paperback romance novelists (a billion-dollar industry). And if we are truly lucky, they would follow Mrs. Dugger's example and pop out 19 kids [face on desk]. We are so @#$% doomed.

Posted by: True_Blue at October 16, 2009 2:26 PM

OMG! Teenage girls get obsessive about things!! This is like no cultural phenomenon that has ever happened before!!!
or...not.

Cheer up, Dustin. Just be grateful you had a boy.

Posted by: jason at October 16, 2009 2:27 PM

too bad figgy read us all the riot act about post corrections yesterday. i SOOOO want to break out my red grading pen.

Posted by: gp at October 16, 2009 2:29 PM

PissBoy...I WILL slap you tonight. Don't soil the memory of my Brandis!

Posted by: Julie at October 16, 2009 2:29 PM

Wow, the link worked. It's like magic!

Posted by: Wendy at October 16, 2009 2:29 PM

The thought of my girls growing up and liking Twilight-like bits of pop culture doesn't bother me, since it's a phase most teenagers have to experience, but I'll be damned if I let them have such poor grammar skills. One day of grounding for every punctuation missed. You can love whoever this Edward Cullen yahoo is all you want, but be prepared to write me a 500 word essay on his merits. And it will be graded.

Posted by: katy at October 16, 2009 2:30 PM

Just wait until the Cullen Brigade gets a wind of this post, we are in a for a world of pain.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at October 16, 2009 2:34 PM

It seems cruel to laugh at the feeble-minded. Great fun, of course, and absolutely necessary if we ever hope to advance beyond the monobrowed sub-literates contained herein, but . . . I've forgotten where I was going with this.

Posted by: Tracer Bullet at October 16, 2009 2:34 PM

Antiques Roadshow is too entertaining, you dick suckin robot!

As to the rest of it, my head exploded at around #10.

Posted by: Lee at October 16, 2009 2:37 PM

Who in the fuck is Steven Segul? Sounds like a serious actor to me.

Posted by: John Denver's Wingman at October 16, 2009 2:39 PM

...nah BSlim....we are in for a world of entertainment.

These people will poke prod and argue. And as well know, arguing on the internet is like trying to be the smartest retard.

These people are just a little closer.

Posted by: PissBoy at October 16, 2009 2:39 PM

"EDWARD CULLEN IS HOT! EDWARD CULLEN iS HOT!!"

Congratulations, you have all just read the first Twilight book. Come back next week for a reading of the second book. Here's a preview (spoilers):

"OMG EDWARD LEFT! OMG EDWARD lEFT!!"

Posted by: saxyman1004 at October 16, 2009 2:40 PM

I recently had to grade a college essay about a young woman's literary coming-of-age with Twilight. Her essay was less gush-y and fluttery as these posts, granted, but I still felt sick in the pit of my stomach.

Stephenie Meyer's writing makes me want to rape it with a red pen. Seriously.

Posted by: bonnie at October 16, 2009 2:42 PM

you see that! tracer has forgotten, i told you this would happen. just Talking About twilight is making us dumb.

mark my words, this ignorance will multiply at a zombie-apocalypsian rate. i myself can feel the tug of the chipmunk's squeequel.

we MUST fire the murdertank and at least attempt to kill them all before we lose ourselves altogether. (lol) oh no! it's begun!

Posted by: gp at October 16, 2009 2:42 PM

I had one of these comments on my own blog, because I read (yes, sorry I did) the books and wrote bad things about them. It is madness!!

Posted by: Carrie at October 16, 2009 2:42 PM

If we really want to start a war we should all go google...

"Robert Pattinson found dead with his penis inside a feral cat."

Make it one of the top google searches of the day and let the triumph of "Gotcha-suckers!" begin.

I think we should reanimate Joshua Jackson (RIP) and declare Robert Pattinson dead.

Posted by: PissBoy at October 16, 2009 2:43 PM

I hope there was a cut-and-paste feature to get those comments into this post. If not, I am sorry you had to type all those out. What a mess!

Posted by: Claire at October 16, 2009 2:43 PM

Allow me to take you back about 40 years to my early tweener years.

"FAR OUT! Donny Osmond is on the cover of Tigerbeat. I love his purple socks. Mom! Can I have purple socks? He is sooooo dreamy, he almost makes me forget Bobby Sherman." (The previous sentence was written in a purple magic marker in a Peter Max font.)

I grew out of it.
This is why I won't get a tattoo.
My tastes change quite often.

Posted by: BWeaves at October 16, 2009 2:44 PM

Hey, don't be dissin' the Roadshow, bitch!
That's right, I'm calling a man a bitch.
'Cause I'm edgy.

Posted by: Lindsey with an 'e' at October 16, 2009 2:45 PM

And Julie....I didn't soil your image of Brandis. He did that for you. Right in his pants. Immediately after turning himself into a ceiling fan chain.

Posted by: PissBoy at October 16, 2009 2:45 PM

"EDWARD CULLEN IS HOT! EDWARD CULLEN iS HOT!!"

Congratulations, you have all just read the first Twilight book. Come back next week for a reading of the second book. Here's a preview (spoilers):

"OMG EDWARD LEFT! OMG EDWARD lEFT!!"


And with that, saxyman1004 just became my new favorite commenter. It's the spoilers tag that makes it art.

Posted by: Julie at October 16, 2009 2:45 PM

Touché , Pissboy. Touché.

Posted by: Julie at October 16, 2009 2:48 PM

Hey Pissboy, I did the Google.

Results 1 - 10 of about 205,000,000 for Robert Pattinson found dead with his penis inside a feral cat. (0.07 seconds)

Posted by: BWeaves at October 16, 2009 2:48 PM

I'm pretty sure the thought of a Pajiban having the final say on all human reproduction just kept me from slitting my wrists. Thanks Fi, er Eugenics Girl

Posted by: Lunchbox20 at October 16, 2009 2:50 PM

Holy God. I was once a a teenage girl. I could actually spell, construct a complete sentence,(of course, this was in the days b4 evr1 txt evrthg) and knew the difference between complete and utter shit and both a good book AND a good movie.

These comments scare the living hell out of me, and if they don't concern you, they should. These are the people who are going to TAKE OVER SOMEDAY! All we can do is pray the Zombie Apocalypse comes soon. These dimwitted twit-twats with their Bumpits on their heads and pants pulled down to their knees will be too busy texting (OMG! did u c that a zmb just 8 my mom cool!!!!!!!!!!! it was HOT!!!!!! gg brb!!! luv u!!!!!!!!!!!) to see them coming or to get away.

TK, is there any way you could hasten the zombies? Really, it's too late to stop New Moon from coming out, but maybe we could stave off the next 42 versions of this tripe.

Posted by: dammitjanet at October 16, 2009 2:51 PM

we MUST fire the murdertank and at least attempt to kill them all before we lose ourselves altogether. (lol) oh no! it's begun!

And people scoffed at me when I viewed 28 Days Later as a sort of training video.

"Look, if someone gets infected you've got between ten and twenty seconds to kill them. It might be your brother or your sister or your oldest friend. It makes no difference. And just so you know where you stand, if it happens to you, I'll do it in a heartbeat."

Posted by: branded at October 16, 2009 2:51 PM

The problem I've always had with the vampire genre is what I believe its flirtation with intimate violence. There are countless observations that women like fictional vampires because a vampire is the ultimate fantasy of a "bad boy" -- but alas, a vampire isn't just a rebel or a social outcast, but a creature whose "bad-boyism" finds its most vivid expression in severely hurting, and occasionally killing, his lovers. If a vampire is truly in love with a human, he must constantly make a conscious effort not to kill her. Inflicting injury is inextricably bound up with intimacy. The vampire's homicidal urge is the measure of the depth of his desire. And this is thought to be "romantic".

It is hard not to see a parallel between a fictional vampire-human relationship and a real-life abusive marriage. Vampire stories invariably remind me of a very old Russian saying that goes something like this: "A man beats his wife because he cares about her." And there still exists an underbelly in our culture of romance where a man's violence towards a woman is thought to embody his vulnerability, his attraction, and his need for her. I just hope teenage girls can appreciate the ironies.

Posted by: Amused at October 16, 2009 2:52 PM

I understand being kind of obsessed over a movie and a character, but for me that was The Princess Bride and Westley. Actually Cary Elwes in general was my obsession. My parents probably thought I was crazy- I watched the VHS tape of The Princess Bride so many times that I wore it out. I owned a copy of the book. And the Script. I found out that Cary Elwes lived in the same town as my aunt, and entertained fantasies of joining the Girls Scouts just so I could go door to door selling cookies in his neighborhood...

In my defense, The Princess Bride rocks, and Cary Elwes was epically hot. I don't truly know how bad the Twilight series is because I haven't read the books or watched the movies, but I respect the opions of the 'jibans, who are pretty much in agreement as to the low quality of the whole venture.

One problem with the obsession over these idealized men is the high expectations of love and romance that these girls are left with. Westley ruined me for real men, and I have yet to find one that could fuel my fire as hot as he could. These girls may be in for a disappointment when they grow up and find out that Edward Cullen just doesn't exist, but I don't think that it will be any worse than all of the other disappointments they'll have to face when life doesn't turn out the way that it does in the movies. That's just life.

Posted by: Alexandra at October 16, 2009 2:53 PM

I will support Eugenics Girl bid for reproductive domination as long as she agrees to only allow the procreation of females of the massive cans variety.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at October 16, 2009 2:54 PM

I second BSlim's motion regarding Eugenics girl.

Posted by: John Denver's Wingman at October 16, 2009 2:57 PM

Allow me to take you back about 40 years to my early tweener years.

"FAR OUT! Donny Osmond is on the cover of Tigerbeat. I love his purple socks. Mom! Can I have purple socks? He is sooooo dreamy, he almost makes me forget Bobby Sherman." (The previous sentence was written in a purple magic marker in a Peter Max font.)

I grew out of it.
This is why I won't get a tattoo.
My tastes change quite often.

Posted by: BWeaves at October 16, 2009 2:44 PM

Oh, BWeaves, we have GOT to be fairly close in age. The closest I EVER got to that level of psychotic teen-ery was to debate if Parker Stevenson or Shaun Cassidy was the hotter Hardy Boy in Jr. High. And, yes, *hangs head in shame* I DID see Shaun in concert....wearting a Shaun Cassidy t-shirt....and gold shorts.

Why my parents or someone else did not kill me then, I will never know. I am assuming it was only because they knew that someday I would be afflicted with 2 teenage daughters...one of whom (and this girl usually has excellent taste) actually said that Twilight was "AMAZING!!!!!!!!!"

Posted by: dammitjanet at October 16, 2009 2:59 PM

You're a pig, BSlim. How could you forget about the women with big round asses?

Posted by: Tracer Bullet at October 16, 2009 3:00 PM

THOSE GAY TWINS ON ROADSHOW ARE HOT! THOSE GAY TWINS ON ROADSHOW aRE HOT!

Posted by: Miranda at October 16, 2009 3:00 PM

choose your words carefully BSlim, massive does not always equal hot, have you ever seen a biggest loser weigh-in? (not that I watch, I've..uh..heard)

Posted by: Lunchbox20 at October 16, 2009 3:02 PM

The part that worries me about these girls is that they speak about the character as though he is a real living person. I think it would be easier to accept if they were running around the internets yelling about R-Patz they wouldn't seem so crazy.
But for real, they seem really crazy, I mean, I have seen some of the security they are using around here (vancouver area) to keep the teens at bay and its nuts.

Posted by: Jilly at October 16, 2009 3:02 PM

So I know you don't want to make fun of them, but it would be really entertaining for us if you did a weekly-recap of the "best" site-hater comments left in the past couple of weeks.

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 16, 2009 3:03 PM

Honestly, part of me wants to read these books (or maybe just one) to see what all the goddamn fuss is about.

I LOVED Piers Anthony's Xanth series when I was 12-14. I can't imagine the foolish things I might have gushed about them at the time.

At the end of the day, I guess I am just glad that the kids are reading.
ANYTHING. So long as they're reading. When I was in college I had professors {cough,cough, boyfriends,cough} who used to show me their 101 level papers from their students. Appalling.
And that was in the early 90's. One actually assigned a short answer question "what is your favorite book and why" and got back quite a few "I have never read a book." responses. From College students. At a State University that required a B+ GPA and decent SAT scores to get in.

Posted by: Lindsey with an 'e' at October 16, 2009 3:04 PM

There is hope for the teen set. I know quite a few young women who find the Twilight obsession distasteful, though other paranormal fiction appeals to them. It's not the subject that turned them off, it's the really, really bad writing and the creepy stalker boyfriend who REFUSES to have sex. Strangely, they seem to prefer reading about monsters who might want to consume them. Go figure.

Posted by: Reba at October 16, 2009 3:09 PM

Oh God. From now on I'm going to call everything I like an "up session." Oh God. I actually kinda blacked out after reading that, and had to take a couple minutes before I could read the rest of the column.

Up session: the new fragrunce from Kalvin Cline.

As for the rest, pubescent girls are notoriously and eternally excitable. I wouldn't worry overmuch. It's probably trite to remind you that they'll grow out of it; but they'll grow out of it. Most of them. The ones who don't were doomed from birth anyway and if it hadn't been Twilight it would've been something else, like religion or huffing spray paint.

Posted by: Jerce at October 16, 2009 3:09 PM

THOSE GAY TWINS ON ROADSHOW ARE HOT! THOSE GAY TWINS ON ROADSHOW aRE HOT!

Posted by: Miranda at October 16, 2009 3:00 PM


I KNOW!
My Ex and I used to play 'Leslie or Leigh?' when we watched (read: I made him watch) AR. I was ALWAYS right.
I'd let the Keno boys turn me over and inspect my dovetail anytime.

Posted by: Lindsey with an 'e' at October 16, 2009 3:10 PM

Yeah Rowles, you can back the hell right up before you start dissing on the Roadshow. I, um, I actually try to make it home before 7pm Mondays to get to the tv before the hubs so I can control the remote and watch a bunch of old people shake their heads and say things like, "you don't say, my goodness".

Regarding Twilight, I don't so much hate the tweens that read Twilight (ok, yes I do), as much as the ADULT WOMEN who fawn over this shit.

Here's a theory I had about who likes these books vs those who don't.
In a *very* informal survey I took of women I know who have read the books, I have drawn the following conclusions:
Those women whose significant others tended to be, shall we say, passive in the relationship (the non-pant wearers, if you will) LOVED the idea of a man who takes matters into his own hands and dominates the relationship.
Those women whose relationship with their significant other was on a more equal-footing HATED THE MOTHERFUCKING HELL OUT OF THE BOOK.

Now, I like to read TRMs (trashy romance novels) as much as the next girl, however, I like my heroines to be self sufficient and only mildly irritating. But let me just say that if Hubs ever spoke to me the way the Sparkly Boy Wonder did to Nitwit-gal, he'd get re-acquainted real quick with my left hook.

Posted by: Stella at October 16, 2009 3:10 PM

Wait, why don't we want to make fun of them? These people should be ostracized, marginalized, and pulverized by society at large. It's one thing to be accepting of people's differences, but it's something else entirely to legitimize rank and file stupidity. These people should be ashamed and I can't get behind anything that makes them feel otherwise.

Posted by: Lunchbox20 at October 16, 2009 3:12 PM

Those comments gave me a hearty laugh. And then I heaved a heavy sigh.

But you know what's sadder than the rabid teen fans? The adult fans. They ought to have enough life experience to know better. Parents are encouraging their (thier? TM AvB) children to believe that Twilight is the standard they should set for thier future relationships? I predict that the divorce rate will continue to rise in the near future.

The ESL grammar still cracks me up, though. Heeheehee!! Or as my friend Eduardo would say: ¡Ji ji ji!

(Seriously. He writes that on Facebook all the time.)

Posted by: Jelinas at October 16, 2009 3:12 PM

[big sigh] So many comment-y things went through my head whilst reading this.
One thought / rant burns brightest though.
The Mo-Fo style of "writing" of text/chat/twiddle/wtf-ing that one sees
EVERYWHERE these days! Does this yak-yak have an actual name?! Above and beyond the gushing and grammer. I truly hate that people use this for attempting
to communcate with each other. Civalization seems to be crashing down on us.
SEE how much this angers me? I'm stumbling and fumbling in how to even
properly *craft* this comment. Argh.

Posted by: Ms MoMo at October 16, 2009 3:12 PM

So I know you don't want to make fun of them, but it would be really entertaining for us if you did a weekly-recap of the "best" site-hater comments left in the past couple of weeks.

PaddyDog is a GENIUS.

Please please please, give us a hatemail column! It doesn't have to be weekly; you could do it once a month. Or you could just save 'em up until you have a batch of good ones. Let Boynton do it; it would be so ossum!

I want a hate mail column! It is my new UP SESSION!

Posted by: Jerce at October 16, 2009 3:16 PM

Oh... dear. Please tell me the majority of teenage girls don't actually speak or write like this. Please?

But seriously, these particular comments seem to be written by people who have been FAILED by the educational system. And if they're obsessed with the Twilight books? Well, at least they're reading. And maybe their love of these books will lead them to other books and that will lead to an understanding of the English language?

Hey, a girl can hope.

Posted by: Candace at October 16, 2009 3:18 PM

No. Just ... no.

Posted by: samantha at October 16, 2009 3:20 PM

I only have one thing to say to any and all Sparkletards (my pet name for the people exhibited in this article):

Avada kedavra, motherfuckers.

Posted by: Doctor Controversy at October 16, 2009 3:21 PM

I finally saw this stupid movie. It wasn't as bad as I expected, but it was still light years from good

That said, there is nothing more terrifying to me than a mother who doesn't know how to spell "daughter."

Really, Katrina Rose? "Doughther?" You should be banished from the fucking universe.

Posted by: Skewicide Blonde at October 16, 2009 3:27 PM

Much like the fans of Jhonen Vasquez, I make it a point not to poke the Twilight crazies. This cannot possibly end well.

Then again, we might be safe here. Dustin did, after all, just quote their messages on Twilight, not invoke the wrath of the fans himself. I mean, it's not like they go googling their own comments on the series, right?

Oh dear God. They do, don't they?

I smell glitter. I'm frightened.

Posted by: Robert at October 16, 2009 3:28 PM

"7. twilight is beautiful..im not fond of reading a thick book but..."

So many levels...

Posted by: laredo at October 16, 2009 3:28 PM

Two Words:

Twilight Tattoos.

http://www.bellasugar.com/3023140

(there are SIXTY of them in that gallery!)

Posted by: JenTex at October 16, 2009 3:30 PM

Glitter? The herpes of the art & crafts world? you're not scrubbing that off.

Posted by: Lunchbox20 at October 16, 2009 3:31 PM

oops...Jhonen Vasquez...um...is liking Invader Zim a "them" thing and not an "us" thing up in heeyah?

Posted by: laredo at October 16, 2009 3:31 PM

twilightlver "Who dosntlyk a topless lad."

It is as if she didn't read any of the other posts that day. Did some of them think this was Stephanie Meyer's own site? Why would Stephanie Meyers post a negative review as the main review on her site? Oh wait its Stephanie Meyers she confused vampires with sparkly pixies.

In other news VENEER to all those that like antiques roadshow.

Posted by: jim of the lower case at October 16, 2009 3:34 PM

laredo, I myself am a fan of all things Vasquez, from the original printings of Johnny to I Feel Sick, Squee, and Invader Zim. His work is not the problem.

The problem is many of the fans take it a bit too...seriously? I've gotten in hot water before for saying something tepid about a Noodleboy in the past. Not even bad: tepid. They are far more dangerous than the Twi-tards, if you will, because they understand exaggerated violence and the power of screaming. Oh, the caps-locked messages I used to get on AOL after that message board comment...I can laugh now because there's no easy way to trace my current online usership to my original AOL. I think.

Posted by: Robert at October 16, 2009 3:36 PM

I smell glitter. I'm frightened.

Oh, Robert. Let's make out.

Posted by: Skewicide Blonde at October 16, 2009 3:37 PM

Could you imagined I read all this four books to know what happened for them.
I can honestly say that no, I can't 'imagined' that you read any four books, let alone the Twilight series.

DO NOT talk about edward. he can TAKE YOUR HEAD OFF.
No he won't. He is IMAGINARY. Take your meds.

Why do all of them seem to think that posting on Pajiba is a sure-fire way to get in touch with Stephenie Meyer? Chloe and her talking 'ant' really want an e-mail from her and decided this was the best place to get her attention. Talking ants can be so short-sighted.

Posted by: Pinky McLadybits at October 16, 2009 3:37 PM

And I'm off to get sterilized.

Posted by: DD at October 16, 2009 3:39 PM

OK, you have horrified me. Thanks so much. It's Friday, fuckers. More Frog on Motorcycle, less horror landscape of the tween apocalypse.

You know, when I was college professor for about two seconds, I just referred to my students as the generation of stupid. THEY wanted to be called Generation Y. Well, fuck them. Generation Stupid. Wait Stoopid. Matches their spelling.

Did anyone else get a Pennywise size chill up their spine at the number of people in the posts who were SUPRISED they had read anything. SUPRISED at their own BEHAVIOR? I have only been surprised at my own behavior when I can't remember what I did and someone has to remind me. That's how I slept with a drug-dealer's girlfriend once. Fuck vampires, that shit was scary.

Posted by: professor_love at October 16, 2009 3:40 PM

Can I make a suggestion that Pajiba just completely ignores anything and everything Twilight-related from now on? No reviews of the movies. No links in Pajiba Love to Patterson picking his nose (or whatever he does when he's not busy being a not-vampire). Maybe implement some sort of a filter in the comments section that replaces the word "twilight" with "diarrhea" (yeah, I know it's immature, but Twilight is diarrhea…and the word just makes me chuckle).

Posted by: henchman for hire at October 16, 2009 3:40 PM

dude I need to stop seeing sarcasm where there is none.
and dustin I'm aware you must have very little experience as a teenage girl but let me ensure about this. girls have ormonal ADD, in two years tops the majority of this girls that are so very serious about Twilight will be so damn ashamed about this crazed passion that will move to the other side of the globe just to be sure that no one knows there fanatical past. the ones that will stay on this path will probably end up with an husband who will beat the living crap out of them either killing them or letting them realize that Twilight lead them to a life of depression and bruises.
plus don't diss the Twilight saga, you'll eat your words when Polanski directs "Breaking Dawn".

Posted by: rio at October 16, 2009 3:42 PM

A fairly decent argument that Twilight is dangerous to our daughters:

http://www.slate.com/id/2223486/

As our own Dan Carlson would say, the "money quote" from this piece is:

"Just as America's young men are being given deeply erroneous ideas about sex by what they watch on the Web, so, too, are America's young women receiving troubling misinformation about the male of the species from Twilight. These women are going to be shocked when the sensitive, emotionally available, poetry-writing boys of their dreams expect a bit more from a sleepover than dew-eyed gazes and chaste hugs. The young man, having been schooled in love online, will be expecting extreme bondage and a lesbian three-way."

Ha! Funny. Or not.

Posted by: Neon at October 16, 2009 3:43 PM

Polanski directing a movie aimed at tweens... is there some bizarro world or level or dimension where that doesn't seem beyond the pale fucked up?

Posted by: Lunchbox20 at October 16, 2009 3:46 PM

By the way, if you haven't read the Twilight series (smart you! lucky you!) but you are nevertheless curious as to what happens, this is both a funny and a true plot summary:

http://www.cracked.com/funny-36-twilight/

No really. This is what those books are about. You'll think they are kidding to make with the funny. But they are not.

Posted by: Neon at October 16, 2009 3:49 PM

[irony]
Impotant MemoChat to Pajeebans: Twilite is dominate. If u thought of it, u b rich now. u s gellous. Get over self. R. Pattison kick ur ass everday just by showing abs.

kthxbye
[/irony]

Posted by: TweeLight at October 16, 2009 3:49 PM

rio, I'm not so sure the ones that continue to obsess on it will have husbands when they grow up. A few months ago I saw a Scion (or was it an Element? I know it was one of those tiny, boxy cars) with the entire back covered in Twilight-related stickers. I expected to see a car full of teenage girls…nope, it was a middle-aged woman. And she looked very, very alone.

Posted by: henchman for hire at October 16, 2009 3:50 PM

"“...Arrested Development” would be in its seventh season, “CSI” never would’ve been popular enough to spawn two spin-offs, our multiplexes would be dominated zombie movies and, of course, fewer people in movies and television would wear clothes."
I want to live in this world.

Posted by: AdaHaze at October 16, 2009 3:50 PM

"extreme bondage and a lesbian three-way."

Wait, is that wrong?
Shit.

Posted by: Lindsey with an 'e' at October 16, 2009 3:52 PM

Talking ants can be so short-sighted.

It's probably because thier so short.

Posted by: Anna von Beaverpuppet at October 16, 2009 3:53 PM

...you'll eat your words when Polanski directs "Breaking Dawn".

Will this be before, after, or during his daily cornholing at the California State Penitentiary?

It seems that during would be the most unlikely seeing as how he would constantly have his head being rammed into the monitors off camera by some rough prison trick name 'Mo'.

Posted by: PissBoy at October 16, 2009 3:56 PM

"extreme bondage and a lesbian three-way."

Wait, is that wrong?

So long as everyone is of legal age, human, gives consent, and is having a good time? No, no it sure isn't. There's a sign up sheet on the wall, for those who are interested.

Posted by: Reba at October 16, 2009 3:58 PM

Taken together, the series is the 'Manos: The Hands of Fate' of literature

I just read this on that Cracked piece. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHA! It's funny 'cause it's true.

Posted by: Anna von Beaverpuppet at October 16, 2009 4:00 PM

Ok, I apologize for my previous remark. If I'm going to kill the beast, I should be crushing dreams and insulting people on a comment by comment basis. Bear with me, people, I assure you it's worth it.

11. YOU are the reason book burnings take place.

10. To quote Ralph Fiennes' character from In Bruges, "YOU'RE an inanimate fucking object".

9. To quote David Caruso's stunning performance in the masterwork Session 9, "No, FUCK YOOOOU!"

8. As someone who has actually watched the movie (like the actual reviewers on Pajiba), it was indeed a pile of shit. Furthermore, Edward Cullen isn't hot, and that's not because I'm a heterosexual male. I can admit when a man is handsome. Ewan McGregor, Pierce Brosnan in a tux, even Gerard Butler...all handsome. Robert Pattinson is so far from beautiful, he'd be able to walk the length of the moon before found it. And even then, he wouldn't know what to do with it.

7. You "like him in how he treat Bella"? Does this also mean you "love him long time"? The next FailBoat is boarding in five minutes...be on it.

6. You DO know there's only four books in the series, right? I mean I'm not a fan, and I know that. Unless this is a witty comment on how Stephenie Meyer's writing is so interchangable that "The Twilight Saga" and "The Host" are indistinguishable from each other. Which I highly doubt it is.

5. You HAVE to be a spambot. Seriously, I haven't seen writing that bad since I read the first draft of Disaster Movie, and even THAT had punctuation.

4. I read the first book and saw the first movie. Funny thing is, I didn't hate either completely seeing as parts and aspects of it were mildly entertaining. But not entertaining enough to warrant the ad space/media coverage/panty wetting these books seem to have behind them. Not even nearly enough. Try trimming the first book by 300 pages, making Bella and Edward side characters, and do a whole historical storyline with the Carlyle Clan and you'd have a halfway decent book. However, it wouldn't be written by Stephenie Meyer, so I guess we're back to zero sum, aren't we?

3. "all girls go throu the depressed thing in high school over a guy!" Where do I begin? First, learn to spell. Second, not all girls are depressed over guys in high school. I've known girls during my tenure in high school that managed to be cheery and focus on their studies while not being with a guy. Hell, I know a college girl who loves the Twilight books, but isn't mopey because she's single. In fact, she choses to be. And again with the "read the book" argument? Honey, it's not working. I'll still read the series out of morbid curiousity, but all it's going to do is make me more sharpened in my criticism and responce, which will block all of your arguments and send you crying into the next room after I've pwned you. (If you can say "y'all", I can say "pwned".)

2. Hihi hihi (say that five times fast). Ok, I'll give you your opinion on the book. You managed not to offend anyone or sound like an idiot. However, you fail in the latter once you get to the part about Edward. He can't take my head off...he's fake. Nonexistent. As real as the imagination. If anything, I could set him and all his little friends on fire four times over (five if you count the DVD of Twilight). So, I believe I'm the one Edward shouldn't be messing with.

1. Get bored of READING?! How could anyone get bored of reading?! Oh right...when reading Twilight! If you're bored of reading, don't try to defend a book series.

P.S. Please think about the cool idea of cancelling your Internet. It is of no good use in your hands, and besides...it requires reading.

SHIT! People are stupid. Bring on the Apes.

Posted by: Doctor Controversy at October 16, 2009 4:01 PM

My doughther,My son and I addicted and watch three times a day.

The fact that there is someone who cannot spell and leaves words out of their sentences has reproduced makes me want to leave the planet. I'm out. So long and thanks for all the fish.

Posted by: Jeni at October 16, 2009 4:02 PM

Ah the minority. I consider my brow sometimes lower than the mean in here but wow does the bottom drop out quickly below that. The Twilight books and movie as part of an ongoing study of popular horror were tolerable and occasionally engaging, but the language and thinking of shitty movie apologists is an even more fascinating subject. The acme of their discourse is the phrase "you have to enjoy it for what it is": as if knowing that you're eating a catshit sandwich will make it taste great. In any of its forms, "it is what it is" is the white flag of discussion. It's about 1/8" up the brain stem from "goo goo gah gah". I'm actually telling people now to just go ahead and shit their pants and suck their thumbs if they pull out "IIWII". It hasn't been well received, but I know I'm being greedy wanting people stupid enough to say such things to be smart enough to enjoy being eviscerated for it.

Yeah, it is what is, and that's what we've been discussing, you touchhole. In addition to seeing them, I also want to care about my robots, dinosaurs, monsters, spaceships, etc. and I had the silly and currently unfounded optimism to think that it was possible for more than a handful of people to imagine the relatively simple fusion of spectacle and substance, the vast gulf of daylight between moronic blockbusters and arid dramas. Why is the tippy top of that bell curve so damned slippery? Apparently it's easier to hold $11M at that point of unstable equilibrium than $120M. I know why, but it still seems odd.

Having said that, the level of discourse at which these tweens (I hope) are operating is pure entertainment.

Posted by: laredo at October 16, 2009 4:04 PM

Posted by: Anna von Beaverpuppet at October 16, 2009 4:00 PM

It's only true if several of the creative forces involved kill themselves.

It needs no punchline, it kind of works on its own.

Posted by: Doctor Controversy at October 16, 2009 4:05 PM

I dread what the post twilight society comes up with a la the unmentionable human larval stage butterfly.

Posted by: jim of ther lower case at October 16, 2009 4:11 PM

brought to you by Carl's Jr.

Posted by: stopthemadness at October 16, 2009 4:15 PM

Talking ants can be so short-sighted.

It's probably because thier so short.

That made me snortle.

Posted by: Pinky McLadybits at October 16, 2009 4:16 PM

Hey! Where did my tags go? THE INTERWEBS STOLE MY HTML TAGS!

Posted by: Pinky McLadybits at October 16, 2009 4:17 PM

I thought about posting a comment, and then I saw that 400,000 other comments had been posted, all of which have likely expressed my exact emotions (yes, I've been frequenting this site that long).

Posted by: superasente at October 16, 2009 4:20 PM

Yes, the irony of posting a comment about how I'm not going to post a comment escapes me.

As does the irony of posting a comment about that.

Posted by: superasente at October 16, 2009 4:23 PM

Christ! What's with all the Edward wet dreams?? Jacob is way hotter, and oh sooo dreamy. popewatchnow.wordpress.com featured some ridiculously gorgeous pictures of him the other day.

Posted by: benedict at October 16, 2009 4:24 PM

hi. I lov Antiques Roadshow n cnot bleev dat u tnk it's borin. u 100% suk



Confession - I had to go to this translator to generate text this stupid.

(but the roadshow rocks!)

Posted by: mswas at October 16, 2009 4:25 PM

First, in the interest of full disclosure, I have read the books. No, I didn't spend any money on them, I borrowed them from a friend who GUSHED, and they terrified me. A boy watching me sleep for months without my knowledge would not be romantic, it's fucking creepy. And the 4th one with the whole "sex almost kills her, then her unborn child almost kills her some more" was just wrong. No complaints about rough sex and some bruising, but really? Should teenage girls WANT their first time to be like that? And then be knocked up with a succubus?

But what really scares me is that GROWN ASS MEN, in suits, wearing wedding rings, read this on the subway.

Also, there's something called TwiCon. And it's coming to Toronto next year.

Posted by: kdm at October 16, 2009 4:26 PM

"it's coming to Toronto next year."

Yep. It's a geeeenius plot to get all the Twilight fans out of the country so we can slam the border shut and lock it behind them.

Suck it, Cananda!

Posted by: Lindsey with an 'e' at October 16, 2009 4:31 PM

I'm moving to another planet. Fuck this shit, I'm not haveing those fucktards in charge of my pension.

Posted by: admin at October 16, 2009 4:37 PM

Holy crap. I had some retort about how these girls would be fine when they grow up... Rowles is sexist blah blah blah...

But then I saw the tattoo gallery. And I have no words.

Because that is just fucking awful. And I have a World of Warcraft tattoo, but Twilight? Even retarded nerds have standards.

Posted by: Lola at October 16, 2009 4:51 PM

What the fuck? I'm supposed to reproduce with these people? These Twilight defenders are so retarded that there spell checker obviously committed suicide to get away from reading that shit.

If eugenics girl doesn't show up soon, I'm going to have to pull an Eli Roth, and remove there ovaries for the same of mankind.

Posted by: George at October 16, 2009 4:58 PM

If eugenics girl doesn't show up soon, I'm going to have to pull an Eli Roth, and remove there ovaries for the same of mankind.

But for the sake of gender equality, I shall castrate any male I catch ordering a Girls Gone Wild DVD

Posted by: George at October 16, 2009 5:02 PM

I read all 4 of those horrible things for YOU, Rowles. You and Phillip. It had fuck all to do with morbid curiosity.

Fucking Stephanie Mayer. Fucking hate her.

Ahem. Anyway.

I sincerely hope that at least half of those are trolls. I mean, they have to be, right? RIGHT???

But Dustin, it's not Twilight that's turning these kids' brains to mush. I was in high school not that long ago, before Twilight, and there were just as many stupid people then as there seem to be today. If it wasn't some dumb book, it would be some dumb movie or some dumb band. The dumbasses are there for the taking. They're just louder because of them there internets.

Posted by: dsbs at October 16, 2009 5:02 PM

wait, Lola - you have a WoW tattoo?

Of what? Please tell me it's the Horde Insignia...

Posted by: Stella at October 16, 2009 5:15 PM

are so retarded that there spell checker obviously committed suicide ...
... and remove there ovaries for the same of mankind.

Posted by: George at October 16, 2009 4:58 PM

George, why do you make this so easy?

Posted by: Lainey at October 16, 2009 5:17 PM

What the fuck is wrong with people?!?! If you're going to make fun of someone's intellect, please please please master the three (3) DIFFERENT words; their, they're, and there.

Please also see: your and you're.

Someone needs to create an animatronic dictionary that goes around fucking people in the ass as punishment for grammatical errors.

Posted by: Lunchbox20 at October 16, 2009 5:21 PM

Did these people ever go to school?

Posted by: Juliam at October 16, 2009 5:29 PM

Adahaze, thanks for the reminder.

I read that line and shot off into a masturbatory wish-fulfillment fantasy world wherein the television landscape reflected the celebration of quality entertainment rather than the perpetuation of stupidity.

...I saw myself hosting a watch party for the opening episode of Firefly's 8th season. Sure it's getting a little long in the tooth, having peaked in season 5, but these past couple of seasons on showtime have been pretty damned good, the scenes of Inara doing her day job are amazing. Even in space "fuck" still sounds better than "frack". Sure it's the most expensive show on tv, but the effects are great, with props and sets that stagger the imagination. Over on HBO, how about that Robin Williams as corrupt cattle rancher Angus McPeak on season 6 of Deadwood? Dude's becoming one brutal motherfucker, literally. I'm glad they did another feature film crossover between Scifi's MST3K and Mst3K:Moonbase series. Mike and Joel were cool on screen together, but Trace Beaulieu and Bill Corbett as Crow and Crow II rocked in the reactor meltdown sequence! hard to believe it's been 20 years of MST3K. And how about that Sci-fi network? No one has ever championed the cause of quality original sci-fi programming more than that awesome network...

Holy shit, I've gotta stop. That was better than a good whiskey drunk near a mountain stream.

Posted by: laredo at October 16, 2009 5:30 PM

Oh, laredo, I love you and I hate you at the same time, and both the love and the hate are for this shining vision...of what will never be.

*sob*

Posted by: Jerce at October 16, 2009 5:34 PM

"Someone needs to create an animatronic dictionary that goes around fucking people in the ass as punishment for grammatical errors."-Lunchbox20

Dammit. Now I'm going to have to do that for my Hallowen costume.

Posted by: laredo at October 16, 2009 5:48 PM

Allow me to express how much I fear the Twilight books and the havok they would wreak upon my psyche:

I intend to blog a personal threat to keep me in line and finishing NaNoWriMo this year: If I do not complete 50,000 words, I will read and review all four Twilight books in December. The thought alone has left me in a cold sweat in the middle of the night, woken up by my concerned dog who himself was woken by my screams of terror. These are worse than my Tyra Banks "Don't Eat Meeee!!!!" nightmares, but not quite as bad as my Sandra Lee "Don't Feed Meeee!!!!" nightmares.

Posted by: Robert at October 16, 2009 5:53 PM

Teenage girls are teenage girls. I had a crush on a very popular, handsome (eventually came out as gay) actor as a teenager and would have probably written some of the above nonsense had there been the Internet back then. What scares me are the adults who write in that they are 30 or 40 years old and they are mesmerized. Then they comment endlessly about Pattinson et al.

My reaction? Damn! Get your self some, peeps. Some of your own. Stop fantasizing about fictional characters and the actors who play them. This is unnatural.

Posted by: Patricia at October 16, 2009 6:01 PM

I'm way too late to this thread, but I just wanted to check in with the observation that Antiques Roadshow makes for a right passable "Price Is Right"-style drinking game.

Which I played once, about a dozen years ago -- so maybe it's not all that great. But it sure did kill the time that one afternoon....

Posted by: sansho1 at October 16, 2009 6:01 PM

Good grief. I feel much less dirty about getting sucked into reading the Twilight series than I do reading Pajiba comments.

Posted by: Team Jake at October 16, 2009 6:15 PM

lol that was really cute. those comments were so much more entertaining than the movie, and I'm sure the book though I don't have the stomach to read it.

Aww that was cutttteee! Those girls have to be like 9. I hope. If not, not so cute.

Posted by: eden at October 16, 2009 6:36 PM

I second (or third or fourth) eugenics girl. Although I admit my share of moronic crushes, how can girls who reach this level of obsession avoid becoming the kind of adults who keep the sex and the city franchise and kate hudson in business?

And yes, I have read the Twilight series. Like Dustin said, I got sucked in, having an incurable case of whathappensnext. I thoroughly enjoyed throwing the books at the wall and rolling my eyes till they hurt at the bad writing and TSTL characters.

Posted by: sodafilms at October 16, 2009 6:44 PM

"Stop fantasizing about fictional characters and the actors who play them"
I'm going to have to stop you right there, Patricia.
Plenty of Mal-related fantasies would be killed if we were to follow your suggestion. I think perhaps you meant to say, "Stop fantasizing about fictional characters and the actors who play them, unless they happen to be Fillion or #10 [or Capt Jack]"...

... fantasizing about an undead teenage boy who is just this side of a wife beater is wrong.

Posted by: Stella at October 16, 2009 6:58 PM

I think what bothers me the most about those comments isn't the grammar or spelling but the complete lack of punctuation. I mean, holy run-ons! They were so breathless in their hurry to comment on how CUTE RPatz is that they completely abandoned the English language and all its rules... and everything came out in one horribly mangled comment. I can remember being infatuated with with cute guys when I was a teen, but I can't recall ever hyperventilating and abandoning all common sense in a rush to profess my love.

Posted by: MelBivDevoe at October 16, 2009 7:01 PM

Man, I one day went to the movies to see some movie, I don't know which was but I'm sure it was a good movie because I watch good movies you know! So anyway there was a bunch of fat white chicks wearing black clothes and like ohhh it's the witch day I thought, what the hell was that?? And then I found out there was some kind of Twilight fan meeting going on there... man, that was disapointing! When I thought about these chick stuff, like oh chicks love Twilight, I thought about cute chicks who were lonely and loved reading but not these fat ugly white chicks!!! So there you see those fat ugly white chicks!

Newsflesh: the vampire boy asked me to tell you girls that the girl he is banging there in the books is not a fat ugly white chick, so if you came across your vampire prince charming he will probably not fuck you, he will go and fuck some pretty skinny girls! That's what Twilight is about, fat ugly white chicks NOT getting banged by hot vampire boy.

Posted by: zito at October 16, 2009 7:08 PM

i never finished to see this movie,i stopped after 50 min too hard for me

Posted by: carrie at October 16, 2009 7:25 PM

My entire state is stupider for my having read those, and I live in West Virginia, so that's HARD.

Posted by: , (the commenter formerly known as bucdaddy) at October 16, 2009 7:46 PM

I can't wait until people start getting diamond dust implanted in their skin so they can sparkle in the sun too.

Posted by: Pinky McLadybits at October 16, 2009 8:07 PM

Stella, OK, I'll grant you that. My fantasy days aren't entirely over yet. But undead teensies? Yuck.

Posted by: Patricia at October 16, 2009 9:08 PM

When *I* was a high school girl, my favorite books?

The Bell Jar and 1984.

What the crap.

Posted by: Gabs at October 16, 2009 9:40 PM

And people wonder why I'm a cynic. Personally I would like to pencil those ten people in for an immediate visit from the Angel of Death.

I'm not kidding. They can choke on a tailpipe, strangle themselves with their underwear, hang from a yardarm, blow their brains out, and jump off a fucking bridge.

Dustin, this is further proof of one fact: We are so FUCKED for the future. Weep now brothers and sisters of the Godtopus. Weep now.

Posted by: bignick at October 16, 2009 9:52 PM

Also one further addendum:

The only man who is allowed to sparkle is David Bowie. If you don't know who that is teens, ask your parents. If they don't know, ask your grandparents.

Posted by: bignick at October 16, 2009 9:58 PM

All right, who the hell made it through the entire list? I had to stop.

Posted by: Cindy at October 16, 2009 10:20 PM

You know why Twilight is so awesome?

Because it is just so FUCKING horrible.
It was so bad that it was a bonding moment between me and my 17 year old son.
We watched on DVD and laughed our asses off.
So. Damn. Funny.

We can't wait for the next movie to comeout on DVD.

Posted by: jules at October 16, 2009 10:23 PM

Oh calm down. Twilight is nothing more than fluffy pink brain porn for teen girls who get off on male dominance, glitter and lots and lots of khaki pants. There will always be another Donny Osmond or Backstreet Boy or Edward Anthony (snort) Cullen, and yet the world keeps spinning. They'll grow out of it.

Posted by: Dingles at October 16, 2009 10:44 PM

"Twilight" is just the teenage girls answer to the teenage boys who insist on wearing their pants down around their knees.

The fad will change as soon as some other piece of crap comes up to replace it.

(Just like poodle skirts, rat tails and the mullet).

Posted by: UncleJR at October 16, 2009 10:45 PM

Help me Dustin!

So I am interviewing for a job, and the interviewer and his wife are both friends. The wife has told me I MUST READ TWILIGHT OMG IT IS SO GOOD. I would have ignored this except that she took my book suggestion "Sunshine" and she read it and loved it to pieces. She asked me how Twilight is coming along...

So I would like a job. Anything I can do to make it more possible is better.

I bought twilight. It is sitting in my house. So far I have pulled it out to giggle at out of context quotes.

I know I am going to have to read it but I am scared Dustin. What if it hurts me? What if it makes me un-pajiba-like. What if this woman is right, what if it is actually good.

Is it possible to read Twilight and not be permanently damaged?

What do you think?

Posted by: Gigi at October 16, 2009 10:46 PM

Don't worry, Gigi... I read all four of them, and my cynicism and annoyance remains intact. As does the majority of my intellect. (I did lose a few brain cells, but no more than, say, a glass of wine would've killed anyway.)

Posted by: Anna von Beaverpuppet at October 16, 2009 11:10 PM

...oops. Forgot to finish. Maybe I killed more than I thought.

Anyway, go ahead and read them if it will help you get a job. You can talk about them (practice keeping a straight face in the mirror) and laughing at her silently, on the inside. You'll be just fine.

Posted by: Anna von Beaverpuppet at October 16, 2009 11:15 PM

The books are shit. I have no shame in admitting I read them all. It was the train wreck what is all the goddamn fuss about that compelled me (that is my story and I am sticking to it). Stephanie Meyer is a goddamn millionaire genius for somehow making the Twitard phenomenon a financial success because she is a terrible writer. She has admitted several times to not being a good writer and basically blowing her editors until she got lockjaw. The movie was absolute shit instead of the Almond Roca litter box variety it was rolled in glitter. The acting was horrible, the lighting, script, costumes, contact lenses. I made it all the way until Kristen Stewart did her spastic sputtering blinking guffawing scene in the hospital and snarfed cherry coke out of my nose.

I have a vagina, I was once a teenage girl. I recall at some point wanting to have Billy Idol's kittens and it's still an option but I keep it to myself. I never gushed over anything as psychotically as the Twitards do and Dustin is right they are absolutely terrifying. Just think... there are 3 more movies coming. I have a feeling Robert Pattinson will end up committing suicide or pulling a Joaquin Phoenix.

Posted by: Cate at October 17, 2009 12:20 AM

Wy is the standard for gothic trash literature so low these days? In MY day we read
V.C. Andrews. And that lead to Bronte. Which somehow lead to Austen. Reading trash
doesn't have to fry your brain.

I blame the WB for this.

Posted by: Sara at October 17, 2009 12:22 AM

*Why

Fuck.

Posted by: Sara at October 17, 2009 12:23 AM

OK...I drank the koolaid last year. I liked the series. They were a fun read for a little ol' housewife. Plus I had a tween reading them too. (But she reads faster than me the little smartypants). They really do stir an emotion, I don't really know what it is and if I had never felt it before like all of these little virginy shits with the comments, I might have been the same.

But really, what's the big difference between this and your fanboy shit? I mean really? Was Batman literary genius? Somehow, I don't think so. It's just comic books for girls, get over it.

Posted by: wsapnin at October 17, 2009 1:31 AM

I read them (practically at gunpoint), and I have to admit they're addictive. They suck you in, and then chew you up and spit you out feeling like an unintelligent, brainwashed, pathetic wad of cliched goop. All I can say is that you're right, Dustin. It's not so much the books (or movies) I object to...Godtopus knows there's more trashy literature out there than you can shake a stick at. It's the fans. Stay out, Cullenheads.

Posted by: esme at October 17, 2009 2:00 AM

Stella> I have a theory that the only adult women who are obsessed with Twilight are the ones who peaked in High School. Of course they love the idea of being young and having the 'hot' guy forever - those were the best years of their life (and, possibly, the years their brains stopped maturing).

That said, I don't know many obsessive adult Twilight fans. The only one is someone I'm not too sure of at the moment - she set her sights on my (still emotionally/relationship napalmed) best mate, and started using me to get to him. Ironically, he thought she was a nice person and all, until, well, I'll quote him: 'She spent all night talking about some werewolf and some vampire and how they're so hot. Freaked the fuck out of me. Why the fuck is she so obsessed with these guys when they're not real?'

Would it be bitchy for me to tell her Twilight killed her chances?

Posted by: ScienceGeek at October 17, 2009 3:32 AM

I know it's been said before... but let me recommend this
http://community.sparknotes.com/2009/07/16/blogging-twilight-index-page
to you, all my dear twi-haters. Go fetch some kleenex for the tears of laughter, too.

Also, I seriously have to admit that it's not the Twilight-fans that scare me most - at least Twilight doesn't involve singing, dancing and adoration of Zac Efron or Miley Cyrus. At least Kirsten Stewart is actually a (half)decent actress (who doesn't sing or dance even once).
(Just so you know: Kirsten plays the female protagonist in the movie. Yes, there IS someone in it who's not Robert Pattinson.)

Posted by: Padame at October 17, 2009 6:06 AM

cum on who doesnt lyk a topless lad


my favorite typo. when i was first reading this I read it as cum on...a topless lad.

Posted by: mfuchs at October 17, 2009 8:49 AM

But really, what's the big difference between this and your fanboy shit? I mean really? Was Batman literary genius? Somehow, I don't think so. It's just comic books for girls, get over it.

Depends on who is/was writing at the time. That is kinda the difference between comics and books like Twilight: if the writing sucks, you can always change the writer. And if that "feeling" ever came from a Batman comic, that child would need professional help.

Oh and there already are comic books for girls. they are called "comic books". I don't think there is any anti-estrogen technology installed in those, really.

Posted by: Vermillion at October 17, 2009 8:50 AM

*sobs*

I SOOOO want to live in laredo's fantasy world.....

Posted by: dammitjanet at October 17, 2009 9:13 AM

Never annoy Twitards too much ...

http://xkcd.com/591/

Posted by: msanthropist at October 17, 2009 9:23 AM

Sweet jesus, I weep for the future.

Posted by: Maryscott O'Connor at October 17, 2009 10:12 AM

You're a grown-up Dustin. You're not meant to understand or like teenage phenomenons. If you did, it would be a sign that there was either something wrong with you or the teenagers.

If it wasn't this rubbish it would be some other crap they'd be over-excitedly posting about and jack/jilling over every night.

Posted by: Fiona at October 17, 2009 10:33 AM

I realise it should be phenomena not phenomenons and jack/jilling to, not over, but I'm too cool to proof-read before pressing 'Post comment'.

Posted by: Fiona at October 17, 2009 10:36 AM

Oh and there already are comic books for girls. they are called "comic books". I don't think there is any anti-estrogen technology installed in those, really.

Hee hee hee hee.

Posted by: Anna von Beaverpuppet at October 17, 2009 10:37 AM

Would it be bitchy for me to tell her Twilight killed her chances?

Yes. It would. Tell her. Tell her in detail. Quote your friend's remarks word for word if you can remember them. If you can't, make stuff up.

Posted by: Jerce at October 17, 2009 10:46 AM

Now they are bringing out a sequel to the original "Dracula" novel by Bram Stoker. It's called "Dracula: The Un-Dead," and it's co-authored by the great-grand nephew of Bram Stoker Apparently, one of its characters is a lesbian vampire queen. I also read somewhere on the web (can't cite the site now; probably on yahoo) that a movie is being planned based on the book; and Catherine Zeta-Jones might play the lesbian vampire queen. Any given day, I will take Catherine Zeta-Jones for some girl-on-girl action.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2008/oct/06/dracula.dacre.stoker.undead

Posted by: Emran at October 17, 2009 11:13 AM

Posted by: Emran at October 17, 2009 11:17 AM

Did you know that The Twilight Saga is partially the reason why there's global warming?

Posted by: Rawr at October 17, 2009 11:29 AM

My favorite t-shirt:

...And then Buffy staked Edward. The End.

Posted by: Matt at October 17, 2009 12:11 PM

You're so adik kasi.

Posted by: Liz at October 17, 2009 2:32 PM

?!

You're so adik kasi.

That's the second time I've seen this. WHAT does it MEAN!?

Posted by: Anna von Beaverpuppet at October 17, 2009 2:43 PM

I don't have a problem with the drooling multitudes of fangirls in general -- we've almost all been fangirls/fanboys about something in our lives.

What bothers me about the Twilight phenomenon is how the relationship between Bella and Edward is portrayed: "Girlies, you're nothing without a big handsome boy to love you and validate your presence on this earth! And if he's totally possessive and borderline abusive, wellk that's just how he shows his love! Also, getting married at 18 is way better than having premarital sex!"

At least my big fandoms from childhood and teenhood (Star Wars, Labyrinth, Buffy) had strong women. I worry about the tween and teen girls who actually think that Bella and Edward's relationship is something they should be looking for in real life.

My favorite t-shirt:

...And then Buffy staked Edward. The End.

Posted by: Matt at October 17, 2009 12:11 PM

I have that T-shirt and love it.

Posted by: Geek Whit at October 17, 2009 3:26 PM

Oh verms....you always get so sensitive when someone brings up the comic books.

Posted by: wsapnin at October 17, 2009 3:27 PM

Aw, hell people...Esquire magazine says dickless emo vampires who never wash their hair are a metaphor for gay men.

"[V]ampires have appeared to help America process its newfound acceptance of what so many once thought strange or abnormal. Adam and Steve who live on your corner...The teenage girl who wishes that all boys could be vampires? All part of the luscious and terrifying magic of today's sexual revolution."

If I were a gay man, I'd be so offended by that. In fact, I think I'm offended by that anyway.

Posted by: Jerce at October 17, 2009 4:50 PM

I haven't read these books, but now that I think back to my teen years, I think I 'get it.'

When I was but a horny 16 year old I had a friend who was very goth, in the 'not trying to be goth' kind of way. He was tall, slender, pale, blonde, and very very dark and twisted. He used to enjoy vamping out a bit, and I Loooooooved it when he would swoop in and bite my neck. {shivers}
This was before even Bram Stokers Dracula movie or Interview with a Vampire came out, so the vampire thing wasn't really en vouge. But,
It.
Was.
HOT!

He works in a Tech support cube farm now, and has never really recovered from all the acid he took in the 90's. Not so hot.

Posted by: Lindsey with an 'e' at October 17, 2009 5:33 PM

OMG! It just hit me who Spike from Buffy has been reminding me of! My wanna-be vamp friend!
So yeah, I used to make out with Spike.
How cool was I?

Posted by: Lindsey with an 'e' at October 17, 2009 5:36 PM

"Robert Pattinson found dead with his penis inside a feral cat."
Posted by: PissBoy

*ahem*
This is pretty much a part of the saturday night sexcapade I had planned for him, so it wouldn't be that far off-base to start this rumour. If anything, it should come true within the next year or so.

Posted by: popejenn at October 17, 2009 10:02 PM

Hey! You know what they have now? BEHOLD!

They have Romeo and Juliet ones, too. They say "the original forbidden love story" or something. The interesting thing about those is that the font and margins are huge, as though they were trying to increase the page count so it would resemble Twilight even more. I saw these at Costco, too, so it's infecting the real world, not like the Edward Cullen dildo where (hopefully) few people will actually end up owning it.

Now, some might say "well, at least it gets those idiots reading real books", but at what cost? AT WHAT COST?!

Posted by: Lenina Crowne at October 17, 2009 10:14 PM

?!

You're so adik kasi.

That's the second time I've seen this. WHAT does it MEAN!?

One can only guess. I'm sure anyone who can competently translate Courtney Love can figure it out.

Posted by: Liz at October 17, 2009 11:33 PM

Confession: I liked the book the first time I read it. Lord help me, it had all that Romantic Tension that drives those mindless romance novels I can devour AND shiny vamps! I actually ordered the other 3 books from Amazon and gave the book to a friend. She gave it back and was horrified with me. Our conversation:
"Did you READ this?"
"Yeah, in like, 3 hours or something"
"You READ it, you didn't just like, fall asleep and dream a good book?"
"NO! It was romantic."
"It was NOT. It was horrible! Terrible! Did you not just give me, prior to this book, Full Frontal Feminism because you were worried about my lack of feminist ideals?"
"uh..."
"and the very next book you give me is TWILIGHT?"
"gimme it back. I will look again. God."
Oh man. OH MAN! I read it again. I did the actual reading thing, not the skip-whole-sentences-because-it's-a-stupid-romance-book-and-you-can-yadda-yadda-sex. And just a teeny tiny bit of research online about the author's religious beliefs and things that seemed like quirky accidents of a first time writer were glaringly, stupifyingly obvious. I was ashamed. I still am. The rest of the books arrived days later and I took them back to Borders where they don't give a shit. Sigh. Most Embarrassing Moment.

Posted by: lilianna28 at October 18, 2009 2:14 AM

I like him in how he treat Bella

Oh, dear God.

Posted by: duckandcover at October 18, 2009 3:34 AM

________WealthySocial. c o m________ . We have more than 1200,000 members including: lawyer, CEO, manager, model, actor, doctor, hollywood celebrities, althlets, investors...

Posted by: Jessie at October 18, 2009 9:55 AM

"You READ it, you didn't just like, fall asleep and dream a good book?"

That is a great line. I like your friend.

Posted by: Jerce at October 18, 2009 10:58 AM

Dear Justin,

I love your work, having read your comments for the past two years. You are the definite master of provocation, maybe the title of agent provocateur is more appropriate. You must enjoy that long list of negative comments.

I am not here to complete this verbal diarrhea. I just wonder what stop them to correct their spelling mistakes and second if they were reading so many books, even of poor grammatical quality, why their writings are so appalling.

It is possible we are just snobs. We have something to be proud of.

About the film itself no much to say except it is a real turd only directed to young teenage girls or unfortunately to grown women who have forgot to grow up mentally. Their reactions, you are right, are very scary.

Keep up the good work!

Posted by: Eddy Gordo at October 18, 2009 11:41 AM

twilight...is stupid. i sat at the theatre and watched it....hated it. i wasted a few hours in there.

what i dont get is how people get all riled up when you start dissing twilight.....

now you fuckers know how it feels because i could remember at one point when cats used to diss star wars......

Posted by: jaena at October 18, 2009 3:06 PM

LOL! The one that did me in was "I gets so's tiredz of the reading - it make my brain hurty. Can you pweez read us one chapter, thenz we give it all we got and read sum chaptahz by ourselves, then we gets to take a break because you read to us again so we don't get the head achez".


You know - I feel I am a pretty fair, down the middle judge of Twilight because I am only slightly older than the target audience, I have read the babysitters club as well as the sound and the fury, I read the book, and I can judge something based on its intended purpose - intellectual stimulation or entertainment value.

That being said, I actually did enjoy the book enough to read the other three. My sister couldn't get past the first book because of Bella's codependent wussy-pants-ness. Fair enough.
So anyway, the books are fun and easy reads - and being of the female gender, I am suckered in by the "I want you but we can't have each other" story line everytime. Then, after seeing True Blood's first season - I realized I'd never go back to read Twilight again as it does lack in maturity. (Don't even get me started on TB season two...what a let down embarassment).

BUT....the movie. Jesus Crap... What a piece of soap-opera-level-acting, cheezy garbage.

Posted by: mollination at October 18, 2009 3:54 PM

I think my favourite part of those comments is when it seems like the people typing them actually think they're addressing someone involved with the books/films.

Posted by: Daniel Hall at October 18, 2009 9:27 PM

Liz, it means "because she's/you're so addicted..(to twilight or whatever)." Arrggghh!! Crazy Twilight freaks get out of my country!! This includes my younger sister by the way.

Posted by: caragwapa at October 18, 2009 10:04 PM

Hi.
I arrived via vaguely-related Google search, just like you said.

The real problems with Twilight are what it says about personal responsibility, abdication of the self, the definition of love, and how relationships work. There is such a thing as an unhealthy fantasy... a fantasy that could hurt the way one looks at the world. That's Twilight in the hands of a thirteen-year-old.

Most will recover. Some will not.

The other, far less serious fear I have (which I think you were getting at), is that Hollywood is going to begin to think that Twilight is the kind of fantasy and science fiction we want.

I mean, I'm not asking for Hollywood to start making "Let the Right One In"s, but every step towards "Vampires? Oh, like Twilight?" is a terrible step.

All the best,
d

Posted by: Douglas at October 18, 2009 11:16 PM

Um... seconded.

Posted by: Daniel Hall at October 18, 2009 11:35 PM

Okay I haven't read these books, and have no intention of doing so. Most of my information comes from unreliable sources but I have a major plot hole question to ask.

So the "vampires" in this universe do not die in sunlight, they just turn into glittery fruits. Crosses, garlic, silver, and holy water don't do anything- and the only way to kill one is for a hoard of other vampires to gang up on one with their own super strength, draw & quarter and behead him, AND THEN cremate the parts to ash. So... just why are vampires as a collective whole still living in secret? It would seem with no real weaknesses they should be swarming the entire planet and gobbling people up at all hours like a world-wide Sizzler, not eternally repeating high school. The thing about vampire lore (or any other monster) was that they always had some kind of weakness to potentially exploit. Now it seems not only could they kill and eat you, or make you into one of their own, but apparently they're also capable of turning girls of all ages into horny, drooling illiterates. I think I'd rather just be sucked of my blood.

I think I'll go drown my sorrows with some nachos and a viewing of John Carpenter's Vampires, because if I'm going to be subjected to a shitty vampire movie, I still want to be entertained. Besides, James Woods telling a bloodsucker to fuck off is still infinitely cooler than all the glitter posing Robbert Pattison will do.

Posted by: bleujayone at October 19, 2009 2:26 AM

You're so adik kasi.

umm....I ran it through an online translator (not exactly the MOST accurate) of about 80 languages...to English, and this is what I got back....

Albanian - Hero kasi
Hausa - adik country
Hungarian - adik hive
Indonesian - sister kasi
Malay - younger brother castrate.

So...we can probably gleen 1 of 3 things from "you're so adik kasi."

1. The person was speaking gibberish and has no idea the meaning of a good insult.
2. The online translators don't account for conjugation of verbs or meanings of local colloquialisms.
3. Star Tabaquero and/or Liz has some weird thing with castrating their siblings. Fucking weirdo Twi'babies and their odd glittery fetishes.

Posted by: PissBoy at October 19, 2009 10:03 AM

Pissboy,
I googled 'adik kasi', and apparently it's Filipino. I didn't find a translation, but above, caragwapa says it means addicted.

So yeah, I used to make out with Spike.
How cool was I?

Actually, I was thinking about him as I was reading the comments, even before I saw yours. Spike also had a big following mostly comprising women/girls of all ages. (And he was an abusive boyfriend to Buffy, too, so may have appealed to some for the 'wrong' reasons). I know some of the 'Buffy' message boards were best avoided by those who didn't wish their brains to melt and run out their ears, because if you changed the names, the Twitards' comments would have fitted right in. Morons are not an endangered species, there's plenty to go around. But at least Spike was authentically cool, well-written, and well-acted. Plus, no fucking poofy sparklies.

As for Twilight, I read the books, and honestly don't see why people loved them. I read them all because I don't give up easily (I'm still watching Grey's Anatomy and Heroes), but in the end, I have to admit I just don't get it. The plot never really engaged me - perhaps because for me, bad writing leaps out of the page and kicks my suspension of disbelief in the nads - and the characters were either dull, or annoying, or both. The 'message' behind Edward and Bella's interactions seemed suspect. And the last book, with the bruises and the Alien-stylee baby, was downright disturbing. Take out the supposed 'romance' stuff, and the plot would be horror movie fodder for sure. So, file me under 'WTF?' on this one.

Posted by: Tarn at October 19, 2009 2:03 PM

Mr. Rowles,

You have to understand this: you are swimming against the strongest and most relentless current in our media tsunami. You seem to expect people to be thoughtful and choose their entertainment commodities for reasons they can articulate. That's not how we are conditioned to behave.

Media commodities are designed to be loved without conscious thought by people who have spent their whole lives being programmed to resist any temptation to reflect on buying decisions. That model turns out to be much better for business.

The consumer is king. If the consumer loves it, it is good. We are what we buy, so if you criticize what we buy, you criticize us. Stand between consumers and their objects of desire at your own peril.

Posted by: jontv at October 19, 2009 4:52 PM

For the same reason I read The Da Vinci Code, I decided I must read the Twilight series. No, not for the intellectual stimulation, but rather to find out what all the stupid fuss is about.

I have read the first three and getting stuck into the fourth. Yes, the plot tends to suck you in a little. Yes, I do want to find out what happens at the end. But the god-awful writing style is just about killing me. Take the first book for example - "the town of Forks is green". Lots of green stuff. The trees are green, the grass is green, the forests are green. Got it? Now I'm going to bore you with the paragraph after paragraph of adjectives just in case you missed the first time that the place is green. A couple of chapters later I'll do it all over again.

Ditto "Edward is a beautiful specimen of a man", "Mike is sorta nice, but a bit annoying", "the Cullens drive cool cars" and "I cook dinner every night for Charlie".

The repetition is nauseating. At least half the book could have been deleted and summarised by what I've written above. I think this might be the inane reason so many teenagers have for reading this book - the constant flow of adjectives leaves no "scope for imagination", as Anne Shirley would say. It's like watching a movie, where every rock, every house, every person is described in so much detail your imagination couldn't run away with you if it tried. These kids whose mental creativity has been so dulled by technology must feel like they can read the series (even if they are thick books) without being stretched or made to think too much.

This same thing that brings brainless teenage girls running is what annoys me so much. The books would be tolerable if they were written with a little - OK, a lot - less flowery language and repetition.

Posted by: Heather at October 19, 2009 10:25 PM

Bluejayone, I can answer that for you. There's a powerful vampire family called the Volturi who reside in Italy. The entire reason they exist is to enforce the rules that vampires aren't allowed to draw attention to themselves. Which means those naughty vampires who go around trying to make a super-race and take over cities by force get themselves dismembered and burned exactly as you described.

All EXTREMELY realistic, as I'm sure from the tone of your post you are aware.

Don't overthink it, you'll hurt yourself and it's not worth the pain. These books are not meant to be thought about, just mostly swallowed mindlessly.

Posted by: Heather at October 19, 2009 10:41 PM

jontv makes a valid point. We are a consumer-based culture. For the last 80 some years, our grandparents, parents, us, and in some cases our children, have been fed a steady diet of advertising with psychological tools used to create a desired response: in this case, the desire for things without the conscious mind formulating an objection.

I'm not immune to it. You're not immune to it. None of us are immune to it.

Dustin, beating your head against the wall over the stupidity of the majority of people is only going to result in one thing: severe head trauma for you. If people want to read shitty novels about really creepy one-dimensional characters (and watch movies about said characters) then let them. In all fairness, I can't give the average Twilight fan too much shit because I'm a fan of some of the Harry Potter novels.

Posted by: bignick at October 19, 2009 11:30 PM

were we supposed to be able to make it through all of those comments? (I don't mean the comments to this post. I mean the twilight comments.)

I read two and a half. and now my eyes are bleeding.

Posted by: ashby at October 20, 2009 3:43 AM

Heather, I squeed when I read "scope for imagination". Anne Shirley was my idol growing up. Part of what I find so sad about the Bella character is how repressed she is - Ann Shirley, a character written 100 years ago has more wit, intelligence and LIFE to her than a character written in this day and age. Disappointing doesn't even begin to cover it.

Posted by: Stella at October 20, 2009 10:32 AM

I was fairly obsessed with Spike when I was a teenager - I was about 13 when he appeared on the series - and will admit that I squeed a bit when he got his crush on Buffy (the actors had great chemistry), but once it got into the weird, unhealthy, basically abusive territory I bailed. I could never abide the "Spuffy" fans, and am of the opinion that it basically decimated the character, because it didn't feel like a natural progression to me, just an excuse for Marti Noxon to lust after Marsters.

What was I talking about?

Posted by: Mimi at October 20, 2009 5:29 PM

Is it possible for the internet to actually suck IQ points through my screen? It surely feels like it after reading the Twilight comments. There are some films I like, Blair Witch for example, that very few others like and often lambaste. I don't go all Chuck Norris on them with a nigh-apocalyptic spelling and grammar fit on their website, however.

And no, I did not like the Twilight movie, though my wife loves the books and movie so much I actually bought her the movie for her birthday. At least she is old enough that she does not slobber on herself when she watches the film.

I have started going to my local library to check out older authors since I find the level of writing and editing currently terrible. Spelling errors in a Times best selling book? Deplorable. I can handle some tortured grammar as that can lend a certain feel if done intentionally. I like Stephen King and love Lovecraft, both of which have some dense prose. Or you could check out Cherryh's Foreigner series of books, though I doubt most people would enjoy it.

Well, I certainly went way into left field here. Go Phillies!

Fun post, keep up the good work.

Posted by: Bryan at October 21, 2009 12:04 PM

[i]The fact that there is someone who cannot spell and leaves words out of their sentences has reproduced makes me want to leave the planet. I'm out. So long and thanks for all the fish.[/i]

Nice throwing in a reference to [i]The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy[/i]. Something much better than [i]Twilight[/i].

Posted by: Michael at October 31, 2009 10:05 PM

By the way, I got used to the HTML tagging, so here we go.

These Twilight defenders are so retarded that there spell checker obviously committed suicide to get away from reading that shit.

Are you a stand-up comedian? Seriously. That is funnier than hearing Bob Levy curse or misspell every 10 seconds.

Posted by: Michael at October 31, 2009 10:09 PM

But for the sake of gender equality, I shall castrate any male I catch ordering a Girls Gone Wild DVD

I hear you. I was unluckily enough to see this crap. Haven't these girls heard of waxing?

Posted by: Michael at October 31, 2009 10:11 PM

I'm not a fan of Twilight at all and I really wish Buffy was still around to slay this creepy ass vampire. But instead of writing a novel about how much I despise this fandom, I'll just say this: Twilight fans, I'm all for defending your fandom. I would do the same for Harry Potter and everything else I like. But at least use proper spelling and grammar. Seriously there is a difference between "your" and "you're." And people will probably take you more seriously if you do. Just saying.

Posted by: MF at November 21, 2009 5:49 AM

It disturbs me that some people think that fictional characters are real. :|

Posted by: Renee at November 21, 2009 12:39 PM

I don't think the first book is too bad, it all goes down hill from there though. The two films that have come out are just good fun.

I hear what you're saying, those comments are a very poor reflection on teenage girls, please don't think that we're all like that.

I think you should have included haters of twilight in your post too, they can be just as bad as fan-girls in expressing their opinions.

Posted by: Gloria at November 22, 2009 4:11 PM

Wow. Being a teenage girl I even find this disturbing. Sure, I read the books and saw the first movie, but obsession?! I think not. I read the first 2 books before it all became popular. I feel like I'm surrounded by crazed fans, even my mom has read the books and bought the movie Twilight. Personally, I'd rather read a Dean Koontz book or start the book I bought while out of the country. If any Twilight crazed girls (or even guys, I know there are some) happen to read this, it's not real. It's a book, it's fiction. Not even realistic fiction because vampires and werewolves don't exist.

Posted by: Kirstie at November 27, 2009 2:08 PM

"Now, I like to read TRMs (trashy romance novels) as much as the next girl, however, I like my heroines to be self sufficient and only mildly irritating. But let me just say that if Hubs ever spoke to me the way the Sparkly Boy Wonder did to Nitwit-gal, he'd get re-acquainted real quick with my left hook." By Stella.

You, Stella, are my favorite person in the whole wide world.

Posted by: Fyndy at December 18, 2009 10:17 PM

I feel bad for Bram Stoker. Imagine what crazy Mormon writers would do to your creation a century later. They fucking sparkle now!

Posted by: Zri at December 22, 2009 7:48 AM

i fucking hate twilight.

Posted by: Cindy at January 20, 2010 8:41 PM





Post a comment

 (required)

 (required)


Preview of your comment:



Video ads popping up after each page view? Try clearing your browser's cookies.