Vote for the Ultimate Pajiba 10 from Members of the Last 20 Years

In case you missed it, it is Pajiba Anniversary week, as we celebrate the fact that the site is 20 years old. One of our most popular and enduring posts over the last 18 years has been the Pajiba 10, where our readers choose and celebrate their 10 favorite personalities of each year.

Early on in Pajiba 10, we discovered that many of the same names were resurfacing on the list each year, and because we didn’t want Nathan Fillion to top every year’s list (seriously, Nathan Fillion was the Ryan Reynolds of Pajiba in the mid-aughts “The Hammer Is My Penis” era of the site), we established a Pajiba Hall of Fame. Any celebrity named to the Pajiba 10 three times was kicked upstairs to the Hall of Fame and never eligible to win again.

Except now. For our 20th Anniversary, we thought it would be fun to pick the ultimate Pajiba 10. That is to say, only celebrities who have previously been named to the Pajiba 10 are eligible. Of the 101 names listed below, the 10 selected most frequently by our readers became the Hall of Fame’s Hall of Fame: The Ultimate Pajiba 10.

Here’s how it works: In the comments, list five names from among the 101 below. Only choose names from the list. And for fun: Choose the one biggest regret, the celebrity we most regret putting in the Pajiba 10. There are several eligible members.

Here are the nominations:

Tessa Thompson
Robert Downey, Jr.
Kathryn Hahn
Christina Hendricks
Dan Levy
Lena Headey
Mads Mikkelsen
James Franco
Chris Pine
Timothy Olyphant
Emma Stone
Kate McKinnon
Chris Pratt
Rahul Kohli
Winston Duke
Emma Thompson
Natalie Portman
Brett Goldstein
Tatiana Maslany
Rachel Weisz
David Tennant
Ryan Gosling
John Cho
Idris Elba
Dev Patel
Kristen Bell
Chris Evans
Ryan Reynolds
Lin-Manuel Miranda
Clive Owen
Kristen Stewart
Florence Pugh
Dolly Parton
Lauren Ambrose
Donald Glover
Pedro Pascal
Ana de Armas
Joel McHale
Alison Brie
Natalie Dormer
Phoebe Waller-Bridge
Portia de Rossi
Michaela Coel
Jodie Comer
Michael Fassbender
Jake Johnson
Jason Momoa
Tom Hiddleston
Nikolaj Coster-Waldau
Charlie Cox
Jennifer Lawrence
Oscar Isaac
Terry Crews
Maggie Gyllenhaal
Emily Blunt
Jessica Williams
Samira Wiley
Eva Green
Cate Blanchett
Jon Stewart
Joseph Gordon-Levitt
Paul Mescal
Martin Freeman
Jason Bateman
Gal Gadot
James McAvoy
Chris Hemsworth
Ruth Negga
Gina Carano
Janelle Monáe
Hayley Atwell
Salma Hayek
Jeremy Allen White
Tom Hardy
Tina Fey
Christian Bale
Jeremy Renner
Alexander Skarsgård
Michael B. Jordan
Benedict Cumberbatch
Zooey Deschanel
Viggo Mortensen
Aubrey Plaza
Mila Kunis
Riz Ahmed
Jon Hamm
Simon Pegg
Anna Kendrick
Sebastian Stan
John Oliver
Rachel Bloom
John Krasinski
Keanu Reeves
Gillian Anderson
Taika Waititi
Rosario Dawson
Paul Rudd
Jameela Jamil
Mahershala Ali
Kate Winslet
Nathan Fillion

Choose wisely, my friends!