iron_giant.jpg
The Ten Biggest Animated Flops of All Time


A Seriously Random List / Dustin Rowles

Seriously Random Lists | October 26, 2009 | Comments (50)


Animated films are a huge risk proposition — the production budgets on most animated films run in the $50 to $100 million range, and the good ones take several years to produce. It very often pays off — of the top grossing 100 films of all time, 17 of those are animated (and many of those old-school Disney animated films would break the top 100, if adjusted for inflation). But because of those budgets, animated films — more than most blockbusters — need really strong marketing pushes. These aren’t movies that a studio can risk dumping into theaters on slow weekends. They need big openings and a lot of legs. Fortunately, most animated films are situated in the release schedule to give themselves two or three weeks with little or no family-film competition, which gives them a small advantage over other releases, with less defined audiences. But then again, animated films have to make back their budgets based largely on children’s admission prices, which is why — to do really well at the box-office — most animated films need, on some level, to appeal to adults, as well.

Look no further than Astro Boy, this weekend’s animated disaster, a movie with a budget of $65 million that only managed a $7 million opening weekend. When all is said and done, Sony is staring at a $40 million loss, or so, which would only put it in the bottom of the ten worst animated flops of all time. Even last year’s Delgo, considered to be the biggest animated flop ever (it made less than $1 million at the box office, on a $40 million budget), wouldn’t break the top ten in terms of financial losses.

Here are the Ten Biggest Animated Flops of All Time. Be mindful, however, that this includes only domestic grosses, and does not take into consideration DVD sales. But then again, the production budgets don’t take marketing into account, either, which often adds $10 to $30 million to the budget.


10. The Road to El Dorado
Production Budget: $95 million
Box Office Gross: $50 million
Financial Loss: $45 million

9. The Wild
Production Budget: $80 million
Box Office Gross: $37 million
Financial Loss: $47 million

8. The Iron Giant
Production Budget: $70 million
Box Office Gross: $23 million
Financial Loss: $47 million

7. Titan A.E.
Production Budget: $75 million
Box Office Gross: $22 million
Financial Loss: $53 million

6. Home on the Range
Production Budget: $110 million
Box Office Gross: $50 million
Financial Loss: $60 million

5. Looney Tunes: Back in Action
Production Budget: $80 million
Box Office Gross: $20 million
Financial Loss: $60 million

4. Osmosis Jones
Production Budget: $75 million
Box Office Gross: $13 million
Financial Loss: $62 million

3. Arthur and the Invisibles
Production Budget: $86 million
Box Office Gross: $15 million
Financial Loss: $71 million

2. Flushed Away
Production Budget: $149 million
Box Office Gross: $64 million
Financial Loss: $85 million

1. Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within
Production Budget: $137 million
Box Office Gross: $32 million
Financial Loss: $105 million


Astro Boy Review | Collapse Trailer



Comments

Aww, damn! But I LOVE Flushed Away! Osmosis Jones was gross, but funny and who the fuck doesn't love the Iron Giant? Bitch, please? Vin Diesel's greatest performance ever, a sadly named kid, and Harry Connick,Jr? Seriously, love.

Posted by: dammitjanet at October 26, 2009 3:20 PM

Wow! Ten movies, 575 million dollars. I hope somebody got fired. I've seen some of these and they never struck me as particularly good movie. FF:TSW sure was pretty but the story was too strange for non Final Fantasy players. It was also the first time I ever saw "possible sex off screen" as a warning on the rental box.

Posted by: admin at October 26, 2009 3:28 PM

With the exception of Iron Giant ('natch) and Road to El Dorado aaaand maybe Titan A.E. the rest of those: STUNK, on ice. TERRIBLE, terrible films, ooof especially Osmosis Jones (that shit should carry an "unwatchable" warning).

There was an animated flick titled Delgo?

/first I've heard of it

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at October 26, 2009 3:29 PM

Osmosis Jones has been a weird inside joke between me and my brother for years. Occasionally, when bored, we just raise our fists in a Superman-like way and yell, "OSMOSIS JONES" like a radio announcer. It works best on planes.

Posted by: esme at October 26, 2009 3:35 PM

The story was strange even for Final Fantasy players admin. I didn't even know what the fuck was going on. Then I was like "Ohhhhhhhh." I also agree with dammitjanet...Iron Giant is the shit!!! I just want to know why any animated film needs a budget that large...really. Maybe you should have less people on the pay roll. Like "guy who delivered water to the animators" or "chick who went and got breakfast...lunch...and dinner" or "jackass that stood there and cheered the animators on." People need to refocus so that credits don't last ten minutes. Maybe that could help with production costs.

Posted by: DeistBrawler at October 26, 2009 3:36 PM

I have never even heard of Delgo. Was my head under a rock at Christmas, or did that have a little something to do with why it was such a miserable failure?

Posted by: Puffts253 at October 26, 2009 3:37 PM

Fuck the uncanny valley. I loved Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within. I ain't scurred.

Posted by: branded at October 26, 2009 3:39 PM

SQUEE Ricky Gervais is hosting the Golden Globes this year!

HIGHJACK!!

Posted by: amanda47 at October 26, 2009 3:46 PM

The Final Fantasy movie had a shitty, shitty script. The dialogue was just heinous.

And it fairly tanked the company too, leading to brilliant decisions to send FF7 to the corner until there's nothing left to whore out, and the amazingly impressive "we will not do anything new" state-of-the-company address.

Good thing there's Atlus, Naughty Dog, Ubisoft, etc.

(Also, lord, grant me a failure like The Iron Giant.)

Posted by: twig at October 26, 2009 3:52 PM

This list is bafflingly weird. It doesn't take into account foreign grosses, so a film like "Arthur and the Invisibles" which was a foreign production that earned $92 million overseas and was greenlit for two sequels ends up here...and so does Looney Tunes which took in 70% of its gross in foreign, and Flushed away which took in over $100 million overseas. On the other hand Osmosis Jones bombed overseas.

Meanwhile, Beowulf, which made $82 million domestically on a $150 million budget isn't included...huh?

Posted by: Ethan_G at October 26, 2009 3:55 PM

It makes me SO sad that Iron Giant was a financial flop. But it was totally an animated movie WIN in my book!!

Posted by: Jelinas at October 26, 2009 3:56 PM

DUDE, Ethan, I completely forgot about Beowulf!!! What a piece of crap!!!!

Posted by: Jelinas at October 26, 2009 3:58 PM

Titan A.E. was pretty cool, and Iron Giant/Looney Tunes Back In Action are two of my favorite animated films of the last decade or so.

I'm surprised Cats Don't Dance didn't make the list, seeing as it was a big enough bomb that it launched and sank Turner Feature Animation. (It was budgeted at $60,000,000 and only made $3,566,637.) If you love the old Gene Kelly musicals (or if you love Scott Bakula's singing voice) you'd love this movie.

Posted by: Doctor Controversy at October 26, 2009 3:59 PM

I have never even heard of Delgo.
Puffts253, you just stole my comment. So here I come, out of the closet:
I've never heard of Osmosis Jones, either.(Judging by what I'm reading about it that's not a big loss for me, though.)
And... I've only seen the two biggest flops in this list of very big flops indeed.
And... I kinda liked them both! Especially the Flushed-away-slugs...

Posted by: Padame at October 26, 2009 4:01 PM

It surprises me how many people haven't heard of Delgo, but have heard of the Final Fantasy movie...Was I mentally checked out when FF came out, or is this turning into a gamer haven?

Posted by: mae at October 26, 2009 4:11 PM

I've only seen four of these. Happens to be 1 through 4. And I enjoyed each differently. Of course, I didn't lose 323 million dollars on them. Ouch. Oh, and I stole the FF:SW dvd, so that didn't help them out any. That $105,000,000.00 clusterfuck would've only been $104,999,979.03, give or take.

Posted by: Xtreme at October 26, 2009 4:16 PM

I own Flushed Away and The Iron Giant. The Iron Giant's failure had NOTHING to do with its quality and everything to do with Warner Brothers taking a massive dump on it and not advertising it properly.

And I like Flushed Away's comedy as it's almost a send-up of those traditional English rom-coms that Hugh Grant would star in.

What's that urge from deep inside
The need to hurl won't be denied
That isn't rice!
That's maggots you're eating!

Larvae! Larvae! Larvae!

Posted by: Fredo at October 26, 2009 4:27 PM

Mae, FF was a huge deal when it came out, not because of the gamer demographic but because it represented huge leaps in CGI technology. Even SPIN did a huge feature on it because of the rendering of individual hairs on the main character's head. Seriously.

Posted by: caroline at October 26, 2009 4:32 PM

i had completely forgotten os. jones.

i have to rent that soon. i seem to remember it being funny.
but yeah, props to iron giant (HOGARTH!), titan and road to eldorado (which i JUST rented last week, if you'll remember).

Posted by: gp at October 26, 2009 4:37 PM

Aww poor Flushed Away. My fam loves that movie, especially Hugh Jackman's character.

"It's TOM JONES!!"

Posted by: Empress of All the Russias at October 26, 2009 4:51 PM

Treasure Planet isn't one of the ten biggest animated flops of all time? I'm shocked. People actually saw Treasure Planet. Then why has Disney pretty much disowned it? Color me confused.

Posted by: Robert at October 26, 2009 4:57 PM

I'm glad Home on the Range is on here, I saw that when I was still young, (not saying much in numbers, but saying a lot in metal development) and even then, I though it blew. Keep in mind, that was coming from a kid who watched the Steven Sommers stinkbomb, Van Helsing, with a smile on his face the whole time.

Posted by: George at October 26, 2009 5:10 PM

Fact: I actually bought the soundtrack to Titan AE when that movie came out. I could blame it on being 13, but it's actually not bad: Jamiroquai, Fun Lovin' Criminals, Lit.

Posted by: kelsy at October 26, 2009 5:18 PM

Iron Giant was good and Titan A. E. is a guilty pleasure of mine, both inherently and for its place in Whedon's trail of half-realized sci-fi visions on the way to Firefly. Final Fantasy was pretty and about 2/3 of the way to a decent script.

As for the rest, I could swear that each one of those films was one of 3 with similar themes that came out within 2 months of each other; farm animals, big city zoo critters, goofy eurotoons and half-assed live-action shitfests.

What about Dinosaur? I know that shit was esspensive. Though it was beautifully made, the choice to have the dinosaurs talk was velociraptarded.

Posted by: laredo at October 26, 2009 5:39 PM

The Iron Giant is a fucking shame. The moving-viewing public should be collectively shat upon for making Brad Bird's debut a flop.

Posted by: hater from siloam springs at October 26, 2009 6:02 PM

Ditto Ethan: factoring in foreign grosses, at least 3 of these films made small profits and and one broke even against production. On behalf of NotAmericans everywhere, I'm curious to know why our money is apparently not good enough?

Posted by: Squirrelgripper at October 26, 2009 6:12 PM

and I second the sentiments on Iron Giant. I don't hold it in quote the same esteem as some around here, but it deserved a way better result than that.

Posted by: Squirrelgripper at October 26, 2009 6:19 PM


I'll usually watch any animated movie with my young cousins, but goddamn I could not stay awake during The Wild. It was bad enough that it was a blatant copy of the moronic Madagascar (though to be fair I don't know who copied who. they're both awful), it was just boring and one seriously ugly movie. Some of the worst animation ever. Not even Keifer Sutherland's voice could save it. Eeeeech what a crap movie.

Hmmm...you know what I would like for this list? The studios that made each movie. Always good to poke fun at dumb movie studios.

Posted by: figgy at October 26, 2009 6:33 PM

I mean, I suppose I COULD look it up myself, but I'm in lazy bimbo mode today.

Posted by: figgy at October 26, 2009 6:36 PM

Wow, a rare list where I've actually SEEN the movies!

2 children + rarely get babysitter to see grown-up movies + ex-boyfriend from days of yore who liked cartoons = 6/10.

I actually saw Flushed Away twice in the theater -- once in the reg. theater, once in the discount theater when we were looking for something to do. And my 2 year old just watched it again this morning. So... they got MY money.

Posted by: Sara at October 26, 2009 6:45 PM

I completely forgot "The Wild" existed.

figgy, my curiosity is stronger than my laziness:

10. DreamWorks SKG
9. Disney
8. Warner Brothers
7. Fox Animation Studios (final movie made before it closed)
6. Disney (their last traditionally animated film until The Princess & the Frog)
5. Warner Brothers
4. Warner Brothers
3. MGM/The Weinstein Company
2. DreamWorks Animation/Aardman Animation (the Wallace & Gromit folks)
1. Square Pictures/Squaresoft

Posted by: MelBivDevoe at October 26, 2009 7:02 PM

What, no slams at Cameron's forthcoming Avatar?

I kid, we all know the frickin' advertising blitz will guarantee the POS will at least break even domestically.

Posted by: idiosynchronic at October 26, 2009 8:57 PM

I remember going to the FF movie website weeks prior to the release, getting all excited at the animation samples. I saw it opening weekend, and I was so jazzed. The movie, however, was exactly like watching someone else playing a game. The suspense sequence with a timer, I think you had to launch or disarm a bomb or who cares...it literally was game play on screen, which makes for bad movies, of course.

The cut scenes in FF games don't bore me, but looped for 90 minutes with no player interaction whatsoever, I guess they do.

Posted by: lawnjart at October 26, 2009 8:58 PM

Mel, you're awesome.

And yeeeeouch. Warner Brothers? How low they've fallen. They seriously need to stop trying.

Posted by: figgy at October 26, 2009 9:09 PM

Where the hell have I been? I think I've only heard of 3 of those movies (a few sound familiar), and only seen Titan A.E.

Posted by: Brenton at October 26, 2009 9:34 PM

They all needed more musical numbers.

Posted by: Daniel Hall at October 26, 2009 10:37 PM

Other than being from the same company, FF:SW was nothing like any of the games.

Only vague similar in essence. It was like that Dragonball movie to the cartoon (bad comparison but I can't think of anything else right now). The whole post-apocalyptic vibe felt nothing like FF ... more like resident evil.

But at the time it was evolutionary and paved the way for the much prettier CGI that we see today, so we should really thank the company for taking on such a high risk.

And if you want good FF CGI watch FFVII: advent children.

Posted by: Lydia at October 27, 2009 12:01 AM

Titan AE and Final fantasy would do better now, i think, than when they came out. both animation and sci-fi have become huge draws and dominate theatres. i enjoyed both of them. i never understood why people dumped on final fantasy so much.

i'm surprised the iron giant didnt do well, i thought it was a popular flic. its an amazing movie and i'm sure, as the years go by, will be remembered as a classic.

Posted by: idleprimate at October 27, 2009 12:16 AM

Wow, Final Fantasy, I remember that. Saw it with my brother. Such a disappointment, I remember thinking that you could tell what characters the animators liked. That movie tanked the company. Goodbye Squaresoft, hello Square Enix. It was when Square and Enix merged that they started whoring out FF7, oh and let us not forget 10-2.
*shudder*

Posted by: Jenny at October 27, 2009 1:59 AM

Here is one of the biggest flops.

Treasure planet:
Budget 140 mil
domestic 38.178 mil
loss 101.822 mil

Posted by: 13thduke at October 27, 2009 7:27 AM

I remember wanting to see Final Fantasy in theaters, but the local wasn't showing it. My best friend and I opted for Shrek instead. I don't know which would have been more painful.

Posted by: Doctor Controversy at October 27, 2009 10:11 AM

10. The Road to El Dorado
Saw it with a free movie pass. Hated it.

9. The Wild
WTF is this?

8. The Iron Giant
Most underrated animated film ever. I saw this with a free movie pass and loved it. I went back and paid to see it twice more and bought the DVD. No children or significant other involved at all, either. Excellent animation, story, humor and sorrow without being patronizing or cloyingly sweet.

7. Titan A.E.
Saw it with a free movie pass. Silly, but ok. Love the "Planet Bob" part. It wasn't worth buying on DVD, though. As someone else mentioned, I have to admit digging the soundtrack. A coworker at my Evil Former Employer had it and shared a rip through our network.


6. Home on the Range
I think I recall this release. I think I recall the advertisements looking stupid. I didn't see it.

5. Looney Tunes: Back in Action
Just didn't look like the real thing. I left this alone because what more do we need than the classic Looney Tunes?

4. Osmosis Jones
Looked stupid, didn't see it.

3. Arthur and the Invisibles
Didn't look like it would interest me so I never saw it.

2. Flushed Away
Didn't this release the same year as Ratatouille? It looked like a sad rip off of the Pixar effort and I never bothered.

1. Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within
Saw it with a free movie pass. Never played the games, because I don't care for turn based play. The movie made absolutely no sense to me and I haven't seen it since. It sure looked pretty though.

Posted by: Lubeg at October 27, 2009 10:35 AM

Lubeg how are you getting all these free movies passes?

Posted by: Jeni at October 27, 2009 2:02 PM

It really speaks volume of our culture when a mail-it-in, derivative flick like Ice Age 3 can gross close to $200mm in the US ($900mm worldwide!) with a $90mm budget and a quality movie like Iron Giant can't even get half of what IA3 made on the opening weekend. It's all about aggressive marketing and dumbing it down.

Posted by: MrMJ at October 27, 2009 3:00 PM

Why only use the US market? Flushed Away made a small profit worldwide, doesn't seem fair to call it a bomb just based on one market, when films like 'Road to El Dorado' and Final Fantasy: SW really did bomb and lose money (although the latter was virtually Japanese)

Idleprimate - FF:SW really was awful, it's true that just because it's a financial flop doesn't mean it's a bad film, but aside from alienating it's gaming fanbase (and sullying their name by association), it also had a really bad plot and script, written by a guy who didn't speak English (though I guess it worked for FFVII)

but it did look really pretty...

Posted by: Tarquin at October 27, 2009 7:56 PM

Oh man, The Wild. What a piece of crap. At the end the animals all start breakdancing on a boat for no reason at all, I couldn't believe what I was seeing.

Posted by: Steph at October 28, 2009 3:35 PM

If FF:TSW had just been labeled "The Spirits Within" and was in no way attached to the Final Fantasy name, it *might* have done better. But then again, there's a lot of gamer dorks (like me) that saw it, BECAUSE it had the Final Fantasy name.

Sure, it was a very pretty movie, but I spent the entire time waiting for a "fantasy" element. Magic, gods and monsters, some sort of weird middle age/technology hybrid, maybe something steam punk, . . . FUCKING SUMMONS!!!! There were none. It was a sci-fi movie, and completely left everything (except for Cid) that had become a trade-mark of the FF series. Hence why we all hated it. Except that one friend of mine that I don't really talk to anymore.

Posted by: Rowen at October 29, 2009 10:09 AM

Wait. What about Disney's Dinosaurs? I could have sworn that was a big flop. Terrible movie.

Posted by: kayla at October 29, 2009 11:53 PM

I am really pleased to post my comment on this blog .I love your blog by the way, I am gonna have to add you to my list of watched blogs.

Posted by: Here at December 8, 2009 10:14 AM

This is such a marvelous explanation, Thx you demistified what I was very unsure of. Thanks once again.

Posted by: music desktop wallpapers at December 17, 2009 2:47 PM





Post a comment

 (required)

 (required)


Preview of your comment: