web
counter
 

The Seven Best Guilty Pleasure TV Shows

By Joanna Robinson | Posted Under Seriously Random Lists | Comments (67)



american-horror-story.jpg

We spend a lot of time on this site extolling the virtues of what is great about television. We love us some “Breaking Bad,” “Sons Of Anarchy” and “Game Of Thrones.” But, let’s be honest, you’re not eating kale every night for dinner. Sometimes, just sometimes, you gotta have the cheesecake. Emphasis on the cheese. Now let me be clear, there’s a difference between a “Guilty Pleasure” and “Bad Television.” For example, the allegedly sexy, purportedly mysterious “Playboy Club”? Bad Television. The Should Have Been A Slam Dunk Guilty Pleasure “Charlie’s Angels”? Bad Television. A Guilty Pleasure may have bad, embarrassing, downright cringe-worthy elements, but there has to be something great (an actor, the dialogue, the, um, gaffering and key gripping) to keep us coming back for more. Now that the Ultimate Guilty Pleasure, “True Blood,” is off the air, here are seven current shows that keep us sneaking back for more. Full disclosure, because I can’t watch *all* the things, some lovely Pajibans helped me flesh out this list. Feel free to weigh in as well. If you love these shows, shout it out. If we missed one you love, shout that out too. Don’t worry, we won’t judge.*

“Supernatural”: This show is here in loving homage to the original Link Wench, Stacey who will, very likely, name her firstborn child Jensen. Despite my love for Cute Dean (aka Jared Padalecki, aka The One Who Is Not Jensen), I have never seen this show but, crikey, it’s been on for seven seasons. It’s somebody’s Guilty Pleasure.
supernatural-season-4-03.jpg

“The Sing-Off”: I don’t watch Reality Television. I have a pretty strict rule about that. Except, it turns out, when it comes to singing competitions. No, not “American Idol” or “The X-Factor.” Those I find shrieky. “The Sing-Off” and, even more shamefully, “The Voice,” however, got me good. It’s all Ben Folds’ fault. His goofy, affable and yet highly technical judging on “The Sing-Off” proved irresistible. It’s a slippery slope, though. Next stop? Those exclamatory channels Bravo! and E! Khrist save me from the Kardashians.
Ben-Folds.jpg

“Ringer”: Many of us loved “Buffy The Vampire Slayer.” With, you know, an unholy and rabid passion. Joss Whedon will do that to ya. So how could we not give Sarah Michelle Gellar a chance when she came back to television? The plot is preposterous, the dialogue even worse. But they’ve got Horatio Hornblower (Ioan Gruffudd) AND Logan Echolls (Jason Dohring) on there now and it’s too late to turn back.
sarah-michelle-gellar-Ringer.jpg

“The Good Wife”: But! But! It’s critically acclaimed! Well-written! Meticulously acted. Julianna Margulies wins all the Emmys! Yes, but also, it’s a CBS drama. That means my grandma watches it. Even if she does insist on calling it “The Desperate Good Wives.” It was a punchline on “Happy Endings.” It practically screams Old Lady Drama. But, dammit, it’s excellent Old Lady Drama. I can’t quit it.
THE-GOOD-WIFE-Painkillers-2.jpg

“The Vampire Diaries”: This is a favorite among the Pajibans. Me? I can’t get past the grimy looking promo photos. But it can’t be any trashier than “True Blood”…RIGHT?
the-vampire-diaries-nouvelle-promo-sexy.jpeg

“American Horror Story”: Dustin lambasted this show in his review. And he wasn’t wrong. Not a single thing he wrote was wrong. But, I’m sorry, I cannot quit this show. I came for Tami Taylor but I’m staying for the hackneyed mystery, the completely unnecessary lewdness, and, most importantly, for Jessica Lange’s bitchface. She is giving a masterclass in contempt and connive. I can’t miss a second of it.
american-horror-story5.jpg

“Revenge”: But Lange’s is not the only bitchface worth watching this season. Madeline Stowe, her sneer, and the rest of the gang are trashing up ABC on Wednesday nights, and it’s glorious. Don’t miss it. Watch it while it’s still good. And, if you’re feeling really ambitious, make it a double feature with “American Horror Story.” Don’t worry. You can have kale for breakfast.
tumblr_lr4ws66x5i1r2jlh1o1_500.jpg

*We will judge. In fact we’re judging you right now. Should you really be wearing that shirt with those pants?










Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Sherlock Holmes: A Game Of Shadows Trailer: Trading Detecting For Destroying | One Of These Five People Will Be On "Community" This Season, Can You Guess Which One?









Comments

Despite my love for Cute Dean (aka Jared Padalecki, aka The One Who Is Not Jensen)

Even more confusingly, Jensen Ackles' character is named Dean. Seven years later and I still want to call Jared Padalecki Dean.

Posted by: Even Stevens at October 20, 2011 3:02 AM

Oh, and my other guilty pleasure: Nikita. I'm going to keep talking about how fun that show is until someone listens to me, dammit.

Posted by: Even Stevens at October 20, 2011 3:03 AM

I'll tell you this much, Even Stevens, I was quite pleased to find out where Shane West had gone.

Posted by: coveredinbees at October 20, 2011 3:04 AM

I'm thinking of starting a band called Ben Folds Fault.

Posted by: peanutbutterjellytime at October 20, 2011 3:24 AM

So how could we not give Sarah Michelle Gellar a chance when she came back to television?
Very easy actually

Posted by: YesPlease at October 20, 2011 3:39 AM

USA and SciFi are home to guilty pleasures. Burn Notice, White Collar, Eureka, Warehouse 13... All pretty bad shows with at least two horrible actors, no significant overall plot even though they do a sad attempt at one and, damn it, ever so much stupid charm.

Posted by: Steve at October 20, 2011 3:58 AM

Four times YES, and I don't feel guilty about any of them!
(Except maybe Ringer. Since last episode. Oh Logan.)

Posted by: Rooks at October 20, 2011 4:05 AM

The Sing Off is fucking AWESOME, and in no way will I feel guilty for loving every minute of it. Now, some of the nasssssty dirty thoughts I have about Shawn Stockman... I am pretty sure some of THOSE are illegal in several states.

Posted by: Lindsey with an 'e' at October 20, 2011 4:44 AM

I'd like to nominate Pretty Little Liars. I still don't know how they managed to make me give a crap about those girls week after week.

Posted by: Ashley at October 20, 2011 5:06 AM

"America's Next Top Model"? Anyone? Anyone?

*bows head in shame*

Posted by: Jelinas at October 20, 2011 5:24 AM

I know I'm not the target audience for "How to make it in America" but find myself constantly keeping up to date.
Goddamned misunderstood yet highly entertaining hipsters :(

Posted by: morgaen at October 20, 2011 5:45 AM

Hey, Vampire Diaries is genuinely good! I keep explaining to my sister how the marketing is just to lure people in, and the "Catch VD" slogan is admittedly unfortunate. If anyone deserves an Emmy, it's these kids, and they nominated way worse "real" shows.

I have planned to quit watching Ringer a couple of times, but then I actually watch the show and it's fun, so I keep watching. The week before last, the ending made me excited, and then this week with the Logan Ecchols of it all.

I also love my Gossip Girl. Love isn't strong enough, I cherish it. That show gets so cracked out, but I cannot quit it because those kids are so pretty and unrealistic and I love reading the TWOP recaps afterward (They are hilarious, I love that Jacob guy).

I loved Supernatural, but the sixth season committed the sin of being BORING. The Winchesters are still pretty, and I'm probably going to tune in for the upcoming Charisma Carpenter/James Marsters episode.

Apparently, I am writing a dissertation about the subject of guilty pleasure TV. Now I will carry on with my lurking.

Posted by: Caitlin at October 20, 2011 6:41 AM

I love Vampire Diaries. It's like True Blood's less trashy but still kinda slutty kid sister in high school.

I also love Supernatural. Misha Collins (who plays the angel Castiel) is the greatest fandom troll of all time.

Posted by: Aislinn at October 20, 2011 7:44 AM

I'm enjoying 'Ringer', despite SMG. (She was the one actor I really disliked in Buffy). It's just so 80's tv movie! I used to love those, with their Meredith Baxter Birneys and their Linda Purls.
Plus it has Logan Echolls, Eyeliner Man, Hornblower - what's not to love?

I must admit, it makes me a tad nostalgic to see Gellar trot out all her old acting mannerisms again. Though I did give a little cheer when she resisted season 7's Armclutch To Collarbone of Extreme Anxiety, in a moment of emotional distress last episode.

I still enjoy 'Supernatural', even when it's bad it's still got the pretty, and when it's good, it's a whole lot of fun. I especially enjoy the fan-service (and -baiting, occasionally).

Posted by: Tarn at October 20, 2011 8:46 AM

I loved Supernatural, but the sixth season committed the sin of being BORING.

Trust me, I felt the same way. Then the last 2-3 episodes happened. They went a long way to redeeming Season 6.

And yes, on the surface, Supernatural is a show that shouldn't work. But underneath the car, the classic rock, all the hot-women-as-plain-Janes, and the humor, this show is a soap opera about brothers and trust and forgiveness. Honestly, they spend as much time on their feelings as they do killing monsters.

But the humor? Well, just">http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6pmJRX8Gc7Y">just take a look.

Posted by: Fredo at October 20, 2011 8:59 AM

I haven't watched Ringer yet but I can't say I miss SMG's angry crossed arms or sad hands. Is there anyone around with magic shiny hair for her to constantly touch a la Dawn?

I love Gossip Girl, Pretty Little liars and Project Runway as far as trashy telly is concerned but word to whoever said Vampire Diaries is actually good. It's way more consistent than True Blood and actually less trashy. No other show blows my mind with plot twists on such a regular basis, and everyone in it is SO PRETTY.

My biggest guilty pleasure is UK X Factor. I tried to watch the American version but it just wasn't as demented. My housemates and I literally have rituals built into our lives now around our obsession with this actual trash. We've made our yearly predicitions and will no doubt go meet some of the eliminated contestants at whatever Gay bar they show up in. Last year when one of the contestants was caught on camera whispering "think of how much pussy you'll get" to the winner Matt, it MADE MY LIFE.

http://youtu.be/j9VsrHQlqQU

Posted by: Katie at October 20, 2011 9:05 AM

I agree with Ringer - I feel totally guilty in enjoying that. But I feel no guilt in enjoying American Horror Story, which I find effectively creepy, or The Sing Off, which is just a brilliant show in every regard. You have to feel guilt for something to be a guilty pleasure (we were discussing this last night at my dress rehearsal, as regards Meat Loaf). I feel no guilt about AHS or Sing Off, so they are just pure pleasure for me. Haven't tuned into any of the other ones, though.

Posted by: KatSings at October 20, 2011 9:05 AM

I have recently decided to own the fact that I enjoy Gene Simmons Family Jewels. He is so ugly I find it mesmerizing, I kinda love Shannon Tweed, and the kids are funny. I used to watch because I was spellbound by the hypocrisy: Gene Simmons espouses a playboy, bang the bridesmaids lifestyle, but clearly has a satisfying domestic relationship, excellent homelife, and is faithful. Well, it turns out he was still banging other women and his family was as deluded as I originally thought. Ugly sleaziness coming and going and yet I CAN'T (won't) LOOK AWAY. Also, there is a special glory in someone as repellant as Gene Simmons botoxing his forehead to dingy alabaster and watching his gorgeous partner's face contort as she tries to manoeuvre around the botox and surgeries to show an emotion.

Posted by: Mrs. Julien at October 20, 2011 9:07 AM

Ever since '24' went off the air, if have no more "guilty" pleasures...

...come to think of it...maybe 'The Soup' is the only thing that comes close.

Posted by: OldSchool60 at October 20, 2011 9:14 AM

American Horror Story and, like Jelinas, America's Next Top Model. Don't judge me! It's bad for me, but I watch anyway. They're both deliciously trashy-- so bad, and yet so good.

Posted by: Muttley Crew at October 20, 2011 9:14 AM

I love Supernatural. I admit (due to DVR fucknuttery) we fell off track early in season 6 and haven't caught up yet (I know what the wife and I are doing when it hits Netflix Instant in January) but it was pretty good up through season 5.

Mixing supernatural + crime procedural should be a slam dunk, and I don't remember any shows that really pulled it off or even tried before this. It makes me wonder what Grimm is going to turn out like.

Also that show imrpoved 73% once Misha Collins came on board. His dry-as-hell delivery is so absolutely perfect when mixed with Sam and Dean's sarcastic banter.

Posted by: Markus at October 20, 2011 9:31 AM

Oh man, this is my post. I love "Revenge." I wrote the "American Horror Story" off as crap based on the pilot, but I keep watching it anyway.

I originally thought "The Vampire Diaries" was a lame attempt to cash in on the "Twilight" craze. I was so, so wrong. It is so damn good! I'm burning through the first season on Netflix.

So Jason Dohring is on "Ringer"? Well, damn, now I have to watch.

And I agree with KatSings and Lwae - there's no reason to feel guilty about watching "The Sing-Off." It's on a different level than the other reality competitions.

Posted by: MelBivDevoe at October 20, 2011 9:42 AM

The Sing Off definitely works because of Ben Folds *and* the Boyz II Men guy. Their critiques are much better thought out and eloquent than their equivalents in other shows. Who'duvthunkit?

Posted by: sars at October 20, 2011 9:43 AM

Dustin's review was only wrong because he considered all of those amazingly horrible things a reason not to watch the show. It's intentional camp and I love it.

It's true, Robert. And yet I, too, continue to watch. I can't fucking stop. -- DR

Posted by: Robert at October 20, 2011 9:43 AM

It's so true, you guys, what they're saying about The Sing-Off. Ben and Shawn are fantastic and they've added Sara Bareilles this year instead of that Pussycat Doll, which eliminates 20% of the "guilt" from the pleasure. Also, if you think a cappella is all super dorky, check out this awesome rendition of "Poison" from this week. UGCH. Love.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4leWD-CQ-Oc&feature=related

Posted by: Joanna Robinson at October 20, 2011 9:47 AM

I love Supernatural and I don't care who knows it. When it's funny, it's one of the funniest things I've ever seen. When it's dark, it's genuinely dark. And it's the cheapest series on God's earth, with its monsters in human form and all its scenes of people dying offscreen and someone squirting blood on the wall. (And its barfy demonic expulsions. Those are fucking tragic.)

LOVE IT.

I'm ashamed of my love for Big Bang Theory, though. I know I'm supposed to hate it, so I never cop to that one unless the other person does it first.

Posted by: Melodie at October 20, 2011 9:59 AM

I came for the Britton but I'm staying for Breckinridge

Posted by: John W at October 20, 2011 10:01 AM

I love me some Supernatural and am now hooked on Revenge. Will now have to check out these other shows too. Damn you Ms Robinson. Damn you straight to he-wait, did you say Logan? See ya.

Posted by: cinekat at October 20, 2011 10:02 AM

A lot of people bash Season 6 of Supernatural, but it had some of the best episodes of the whole series. For all you doubters who didn't make it through the season check out Weekend at Bobby's, The Man Who Would be King, Unforgiven, and Clap your Hands if You Believe. But my all time favorite is The French Mistake. That episode it awesome!
Any CW or ABCFamily Channel show is a guilty pleasure of mine...Nikita, Vampire Diaries, The Secret Circle, Ringer, Pretty Little Liars, and The Lying Game. Glad I have a DVR! My biggest guilty pleasure is watching WWE Raw and Smackdown. Just can't help myself.

Posted by: Dingle Berry at October 20, 2011 10:02 AM

I must have no class, because all my favorite shows are Guilty Pleasures...Burn Notice, Supernatural (of which I own every episode from every season so I can watch them in the off season). And now Revenge. I love seeing jerk offs get going down.* Now I must see American Horror, thanks to this list. I blame you.


*dirty

Posted by: Haystacks at October 20, 2011 10:15 AM

I don't feel guilty at all about Supernatural. It has the right balance of humor, angst, and gore. Also, it has Mark Sheppard as the demon Crowley, and I fucking adore him. The writers on that show know where their bread is buttered, so even when they mock their fans (and some are sooo mockworthy), they do it with affection. I stay right the hell away from the fan fiction, though. That's just squicky.

I don't feel bad about Vampire Diaries, either. The book series predated Twilight and both the books and shows have a better premise. I do find the advertisements a bit deceptive, but campy fun. I also find it hilarious that a town would have so very many public celebrations. Part of the reason to watch is to see what sort of gala/charity event/town-wide beautification scheme is going to bring everyone together so someone can die horribly or, at the very least, disappear mysteriously.

My guilty pleasure is truly bad TV: Covert Affairs. It is so absurd, so very NOT like what goes on at the CIA. But I love the blind guy and Sendhil Ramamurthy, and it's fun to watch folks chew scenery while waiting for someone to call them with a script for a better show.

Posted by: Reba at October 20, 2011 10:18 AM

Another Supernatural fan here, and I'm not even female. (Although that is one of the most misogynistic shows out there. Every female character staying longer than one episode dies.) I'm a sucker for supernatural stuff.

Mixing supernatural + crime procedural should be a slam dunk, and I don't remember any shows that really pulled it off or even tried before this. It makes me wonder what Grimm is going to turn out like.
Been done already. It's called Lost Girl and runs one Showtime. Pretty good dialogues in this one. Gives off a certain Buffy vibe, without the lead actress being as terrible as SMG.

Posted by: FabMax at October 20, 2011 10:30 AM

For a rather dark show about a religious apocalypse, Supernatural has some of the funniest episodes ever. The TV land one is pure genius, and "Mystery Spot" (aka the Groundhog Day episode) is easily top 5.

And the fan wink-wink is great, the Supernatural convention in an episode of Supernatural is such a ridiculously fun meta episode it simply shouldn't exist at all, but it's one of their best. The cardboard box EMF reader is one of the single funniest things I've seen on that show.

Posted by: Markus at October 20, 2011 10:31 AM

Thanks FabMax, I'll have to check it out.

One more quick Supernatural link, because it's spoiler-free and a pretty good indication of how much fun this show can be (it's an outtake from one of the earlier seasons:)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cb3G5Qj_Lo8

Also, this show is the reason Asia's "Heat of the Moment" is my ringtone. Anyone who's seen "Mystery Spot" knows exactly why.

Posted by: Markus at October 20, 2011 10:38 AM

I agree that Vampire Diaries is actually good. Incredibly better than True Blood.

VD should be replaced by Pretty Little Liars.

Posted by: silkymoonshine at October 20, 2011 10:38 AM

Caitlin, don't worry- you're not the only one who's relatively fond of Jacob's TWOP recaps.

Posted by: ruby at October 20, 2011 10:45 AM

Hawaii Five-O. Because if Alex O'Loughlin was in commercial about how to kick a puppy I would still watch it. And because my last guilty pleasure was Moonlight.

Posted by: bokchoi at October 20, 2011 10:49 AM

I love how The Good Wife is a guilty pleasure because your mom watches it. It's decently plotted, well written, and wonderfully acted, with some awesomely soapy moments. Everything Revenge is not.

So, Logan's finally on Ringer? Do I have to go back a couple episodes, or just watch this week's?

Posted by: Three-nineteen at October 20, 2011 11:38 AM

The only one on this list I watch is Revenge and it upped it's game this week (well, last week that is, I haven't seen this week's yet). Rather than destroying her victim entirely, Emily released her (like a cat with a mouse) in order to use her later for some larger grand plan. It may be guilty pleasure TV, but it's well executed. Stowe is giving a hell of a layered performance, and when Van Camp drops the facade her eyes are so damn scary there is no doubt that she will do anything to destroy these people.

Posted by: TylerDFC at October 20, 2011 11:48 AM

Surely Criminal Minds makes the list. I love that show but even I cringe and wince basically every episode, especially when I can spot repeated sets a mile off( I watch it a lot, okay. A lot. reruns too).

But it has Garcia(who is just fun, even if her whole shtick is so tired now) Morgan, who is just adorable, but most importantly it has The Guub and it has Prentiss. And they alone, are enough to make a show.

Posted by: Nadine at October 20, 2011 11:58 AM

@Three-nineteen,
just this week's episode.

Posted by: Tarn at October 20, 2011 12:07 PM

this is the first time around here I've ever heard anyone talk about supernatural with anything other than contempt. its one of the show I look forward to the most and I don't think of it as a guilty pleasure at all.

Leverage with Timothy Hutton and his robin Hood band of quipsters is a fun guilty pleasure

Posted by: idleprimate at October 20, 2011 12:35 PM

@Jelinas : holla!

Fierce & love,
Malechai

Posted by: malechai at October 20, 2011 12:43 PM

How can Supernatural be a "guilty pleasure" after they had the boys impersonating Horatio Caine, complete with scene-stopping shades?

Any show that does that gets a permanent pass, I believe. Besides it's funny, interesting and serves up generous portions of both beefcake and cheesecake.

+1 on The French Mistake episode for a brilliant take on a twist that turns up in written SF pretty regularly, but rarely visual media.

Posted by: BierceAmbrose at October 20, 2011 12:45 PM

Jensen Ackles. Hmph.

Good thing he's hot.

Posted by: superasente at October 20, 2011 12:49 PM

I'm with you jelinas. I watch ANTM e'ry week.

And while I don't watch any of these, I enjoy clips from The Sing Off and might put it on the DVR rotation. And Logan Echolls, you say? I caught one minute of Ringer and it almost made me gag, but I might try for Dohring.

Posted by: Patty O'Green at October 20, 2011 12:58 PM

idleprimate, I agree totally with the pleasures of Leverage, but I would appreciate it if they brought back Elliot's personality. The grunting thug does little for me, no matter how much fun it is to watch him hit things.

Posted by: Reba at October 20, 2011 1:12 PM

I love Supernatural unabashed. I may have started watching for the attractive people and jokes, but I really did stay for the plot.

Posted by: Delilah at October 20, 2011 1:25 PM

Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders: Making the Team. New season premieres tonight on CMT. Oh-so guilty.

Posted by: Booyah at October 20, 2011 1:44 PM

Real Housewives of Beverly Hills. I'm a sucker for Lisa's tiny dog. He should have his own show. Don't judge me.

Posted by: LB at October 20, 2011 2:14 PM

I am loving Revenge and not feeling guilty about it one whit.

Posted by: DominaNefret at October 20, 2011 2:38 PM

Please. No more vampires. just...argnsbnwndfbw

bluh!

Posted by: Alabaster Salamander at October 20, 2011 3:06 PM

Ya know, considering the VAST Misery Night contingency round these parts, I am shocked, nay STUNNED, that Intervention, Hoarders, etc, were not mentioned.

Mrs Julien
One need never apologize for love of Family Jewels. That show is delightful. DEELIGHTFUL. I am a little in love with Nick.

Posted by: Lindsey with an 'e' at October 20, 2011 3:17 PM

I enjoy "American Horror Story" and "Revenge" and am not the least bit guilty about either one.

Jessica Lange is fucking awesome and Frances Conroy is not far behind.

And Madeleine Stowe is pretty damn awesome, too.

Posted by: Slash at October 20, 2011 3:38 PM

Listen, The Good Wife is awesome. Alan Cumming is perfection, and it puts Josh Charles on my TV in a suit every week. There is NOTHING wrong with that.

This list makes me want to go catch up on Supernatural and One Tree Hill, both of which I abandoned my sophomore year of college because they didn't fit with the pseudo hipster identity that I wanted so desperately to cultivate. Well, I'm in the "real world" now, dammit, and I want a little mindless trash about pretty people with impossiblely dramatic lives.

Oh yeah, this is definitely a good idea.

Posted by: lyssie at October 20, 2011 4:13 PM

That Sarah Michelle Gellar show is still on?

I'll catch part of The Sing-Off occasionally because of the aforementioned Folds and because those groups do come up with some creative and entertaining arrangements. That's my biggest problem with Idol and its ilk: the arrangements of the songs (many of which I didn't enjoy much in the first place when they were done well) are simply not enjoyable music to me.

American Horror Story lost me a bit with that third episode, but I'll stick with it. They better kill off everyone in the season finale, though, if they want to keep me around any longer.

As I've said on Pajiba before, Degrassi is my big guilty pleasure. Now why don't I feel any guilt whatsoever about it?

Posted by: DarthCorleone at October 20, 2011 4:27 PM

Yup, I'm on the America's Next Top Model bandwagon (have been from the get go).
And I too watch The Sing-Off for Ben Folds. I hate most of the singing but damn if he isn't the most adorable nerdy judge ever.

Posted by: Lemon Poundcake at October 20, 2011 5:46 PM

I don't currently have a filth pleasure show, but I'll tell you what my biggest one was. Moonlight. Hot damn, I loved me some Alex O'Loughlin on that show. He was pretty but dumb. Oh so dumb. But PRETTY.

Posted by: stardust at October 20, 2011 6:23 PM

I have been watching Dexter on DVD and, despite a good central performance by Michael C. Hall, the show is about as schlocky as they go.

Posted by: Adam at October 20, 2011 6:25 PM

HA. Check out that typo, you guys. iPad corrected my misspelling of "guilty" as "filth" and I failed to proofread. That's probably fitting.

Posted by: stardust at October 20, 2011 6:28 PM

Criminal Minds a guilty pleasure? I'm guilty. Fun fact? Ever since I've been watching Criminal Minds I've been locking my bedroom door at night. I'm terrified of someone creeping up on me as I sleep.

Survivor is my guilty pleasure. I love that damn show and I've never missed a season. The all-time best player? Parvati. She had it all, the social game, athleticism for the challenges, and a manipulative smile and killer strategy. Hope you're enjoying your million, Parv.

Posted by: kirbyjay at October 20, 2011 7:11 PM

I LOVE Revenge. I've been an Emily VanCamp fan since Everwood and she's really showing her skills.

Pretty Little Liars is another favorite, it's so teen drama/soapy, but it sucks you in. I adore Hanna Marin.

Posted by: TWoPFan at October 20, 2011 11:46 PM

Criminal Minds for the win. No guilt whatsoever.

Posted by: westmoon at October 21, 2011 12:16 AM

What is a guilty pleasure for me is 'The X Factor'. Either flavour.
Because they do seem to put people with mental issues through to the filmed auditions just so we can all point and laugh at their deluded asses. Also, by many accounts the winners are decided in advance, so it's a cheat too.
Though I actually watch for the good performances and the occasional feel-good factor, I feel I shouldn't be watching at all. Hence, guilty pleasure.

Posted by: Tarn at October 21, 2011 8:08 AM

Hubby got me hooked on Supernatural and I can't give it up. Jensen Ackles is pretty, pretty, pretty, and Misha Collins can deliver some of the best deadpan lines you've ever heard. The pop-culture references are rife (our beloved Kaylee Frye playing a girl named AMY POND???) and the music rocks.

I also love Warehouse 13 and, Godtopus help me, Storage Wars. Dave Hester is the planet's biggest dick.

Posted by: dammitjanet at October 21, 2011 2:38 PM

I love love love Revenge! Oh so silly...but oh so good! The Hamptons...the Emily VanCamp, the others. Fun. And on a Wednesday night. So glad I'm not alone.

Posted by: blackbird at October 21, 2011 9:52 PM

Dammit, I'm with you. How can anyone not lurve Warehouse 13?

Pete & Myka (Eddie McClintock & Joanne Kelly) do a better Moonlighting throwback procedural than Fillion / Katic (Yep, I said it.), while the ensemble is one (An ensemble - keep up.) and the built-world is a riot. They even brought in pseudo-hacker chick without running off the rails. Mix in Saul Rubinek, who is a symphony in any moment he gets, and CCH Pounder, and it's a blast.

Sure it's a pleasure TV show with no aspirations of high art, but guilty not at all.

Posted by: BierceAmbrose at October 22, 2011 10:56 PM