web
counter
 

The 12 Movies We Love With All Of Our Bacon-Clogged Hearts, You Know, Despite Ourselves

By Joanna Robinson And The Manly Men Of Pajiba | Posted Under Guides | Comments (102)



notebook_45.jpeg

Bacon and leers and bottles of beers, that’s what dudes are made of. Amirite? Well that certainly appears to be what Michael Bay is banking on. You macho, straight dudes only like loose cars and fast women…or something like that. But, come on, be honest, in the in the deep recesses of your bacony hearts don’t you long to turn off the explosions, the greasy babes and endless sh*tty dialoge and put on something cute for a change? A movie that smells nice, has some sweet moments, a little romance and, if you play your cards right, endless sh*tty dialogue? It’s okay, you can tell us. This is a safe space. Last week some of the ladies shared which movies they loved against their will and this week it’s gentlemen’s choice. So here with a few of their favorite “chick flicks” are the men of Pajiba. Feel free to either chime in with your own favorite or ridicule the men for their choices down in the comments section. What? Oh, right, safe space. This is a safe space. —Joanna Robinson

k1.gifNever Been Kissed: This isn’t just about manly men; there is no goodly reason for just about anyone to like Never Been Kissed. It’s cheesy, stupid, overloaded with cheap stereotypes of high school and high school movies, pales in comparison to Just One of the Guys and, worst of all, is not particularly funny (unsurprising, as it’s directed by the man responsible for, among other travesties, Big Momma’s House and the impending smurfy smurf of smurf). But it’s the one flick I find David Arquette kinda charming and amusing in and, despite myself, I find Drew Barrymore sorta charming and adorable. There’s just this quietly stupid charm to the flick that ropes me in every fucking time and even though I know Josie gets her kiss, when she’s standing on that pitching mound and drops the mike cause she thinks her teacher man ain’t coming, I might just feel a little sadness of my own. …Also, I’d totally wait on a mound for Michael Vartan too.—Seth Freilich

singing in the rain photo.jpegSingin’ In The Rain: It would be an overestimation to say that I’ve seen 10 minutes of Moulin Rouge, Chicago, and Rent combined. Regurgitated pop songs and horribly obvious lip syncs in sequined sequences? Get that crap out of my face. But I’d surely be lying if I refused to confess that I love the dapper hell out of Singin’ in the Rain. It paints an idealized portrait of the early Hollywood days, but with an enthusiastic self-awareness. No tricks or body doubles or schizophrenic cameramen, just the simplicity of Gene Kelly’s pearly-grinned charm adding line and movement to watercolor backgrounds. It is a 103-minute smile.—Dan Saipher

ss_clueless.jpegClueless: The lead character is named Cher, there’s a makeover montage, stereotypical valley girls talk shopping and shoes at a nigh incessant rate, and there’s just so much pink. But director Amy Heckerling made this her spiritual, much more lighthearted companion piece to Fast Times at Ridgemont High, and a classic teen-coming-of-age tale in its own right (Jane Austen might share some of that credit). All that “girly” stuff is just part of an extended joke, and it’s possible a generation found its snarky tone by way of the script’s dialogue. Plus it has Brittany Murphy’s breakout first film role, Donald Faison as a proto-Turk, Paul Rudd being kind of a Baldwin. It’s clear that Cher’s best quality is her intelligence, though she does also only use her popularity for good.—Rob Payne

fried_green_tomatoes.jpegFried Green Tomatoes: My feminine fondness for Jon Avnet’s Fried Green Tomatoes (1991) has more to do with Jessica Tandy and her performance as Ninny Threadgoode than it does for the murder mystery the movie presents. Tandy’s Threadgoode always struck me as the cinematic version of my grandmother: a self-sufficient, independent, yet extremely loving woman. While Tandy and my grandmother have both joined the great gig in the sky, their ability to use unconditional love and common sense to bring the best qualities out of the people around them is what forever united the two people - and one character - in my heart. It’s rare for such a film to hold emotional sway over me but it is to novelist Fannie Flagg (whose book the film is based on), Avnet, and Tandy’s credit that the film can make most men emotionally fragile for two hours.—Drew Morton

STF1.jpegStranger Than Fiction: Though it may not elicit the typical romantic comedy smoldering shame, Stranger Than Fiction is still a semisweet yet sometimes serious film about an office drone struggling with fate and an unconventional new love. Add Frank the Tank being far from feral Ferrell and it’s not at all conducive to watching among dudebros. However, as a fellow office drone with a love of cooking, subdued performances, tattooed women, and solid writing, it never fails to draw me in. Plus, I always wanted to go to space camp, even though now I’d choose Tahiti.—branded

terms-of-endearment1.jpegTerms of Endearment: The spine of James L. Brooks’ Best Picture winner is the mother-daughter relationship between Shirley MacLaine’s Aurora and Debra Winger’s Emma, who spend much of the time that we see them gabbing about the men in their lives, and as such the film probably should not resonate with me as much as it does. I could justify my love for this movie by way of Jack Nicholson’s wisecracking, charismatic astronaut, John Lithgow’s matter-of-fact adulterer with the romantic soul, the humanity found in Jeff Daniels’ character in spite of his smarmy flaws, the sullen rebellion and innocent affection of Emma’s two sons who remind me of my own youth, or even the simple fact that cowboy writer Larry McMurtry set the story in my home state of Texas. I must acknowledge, though, that the countless little details and turns of dialogue are what put this a notch above so many other dramas, and nothing exemplifies its emotional truth more than the dependable yet strained rapport between Aurora and Emma. By the time the film leaves me with that disconsolate but oddly hopeful resolution, I find myself affected enough to be envious of that mother-daughter bond that I can never know.—C. Robert Dimitri

dvd_room06.jpegA Room With A View: Like you, I was dimly aware of the cast of A Room With A View as modern-day action-movie stars (Maggie Smith and Helena Bonham-Carter from the ‘Harry Potter’ franchise, Daniel Day-Lewis from ‘Last of the Mohicans’, Denholm Elliott from ‘Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade’ and Judi Dench from the ‘Bond’ franchise). But who knew that these rippling-muscled, machete-wielding, wise-cracking, swashbuckling heroes could also, on occasion, produce heartfelt, gentle, moving work? Not me. Honestly, you should check out their dialled-down performances in A Room With A View: these guys should try their hand at Shakespeare, they’re that good. Kidding! From the age of 6, I was basically raised on A Room With A View - the Merchant-Ivory adaptation of the E.M. Forster book about heaving bosoms, clipped accents, English stiff upper lip, lawn tennis, and passion tamed and then embraced. I love Maggie Smith’s and Daniel Day-Lewis’s incredibly brilliant performances in it, finding heart and compassion in the insufferable prigs they portray. I love the passion and violence and sex lurking behind all the immaculate appearances and cups of tea. And I basically am Lucy Honeychurch, played by Helena B-C. Channel your inner English rose like me, guys! Stop lying to yourself about wanting to go out with Cecil Vyse, man, and bag yourself a George Emerson! It’s not too late!—Caspar Salmon

bring it on.jpegBring It On: Cheerleading can be a sport, when it’s competitive. And perhaps the thought behind luring dudes to see what’s essentially Sports Competitive Movie Template #3 but with uncoordinated white girls gyrating in short skirts is the afforementioned T&A they work in. But beneath it all they managed to work in a damn entertaining little story that’s lots of fun. It’s why I still give a begrudging pass to Kirsten Dunst and Eliza Dushku.—Brian Prisco

west-side-story-de-42034554.jpegWest Side Story: True story, when I was a wee lad, I went to music camp for a summer, because apparently I have a lovely singing voice. No, seriously. Anyway, I got cast in our camp’s production of West Side Story. Of course, because I’m me, I ended up deathly ill for most of my time there and threw up every two hours, but damn it, I nailed the part of Shark #2 in that bitch (my role was downgraded since I kept barfing during rehearsal). I never went back to music camp and instead developed a preference for punk rock and death metal, but it doesn’t change the fact that to this day, I fucking love West Side Story. I’m a sucker for all things Shakespeare, and find the modern adaptations to be fascinating. But more importantly, West Side Story is good. The 1961 adaptation is goddamn brilliant, with amazing sets, some solid acting, and Natalie Wood (as well as Marni Nixon’s voice) breaking my heart every goddamn time. I love a good tragedy, and the modern interpretation, particularly with the cultural ramifications of a love story between not just warring families (or gangs, in this case), but ones of different ethnicities, elevated West Side Story and made it stunningly ahead of its time. The music, by Bernstein and Sondheim, is spectacular and the leads’ breathless, doomed depictions were, and still are, marvelous. So yes, every now and then, when no one is looking, I turn off the Hatebreed and start quietly humming “Tonight.”—TK

mean-girls.jpegMean Girls: Maybe dudes aren’t supposed to like Mean Girls because “manly men” aren’t supposed to care for female ensemble comedies written by a woman (what? Were there no female directors available for this?) set in high school about your “typical selfish, back-stabbing slut faced ho-bags.” It stars Lindsay Lohan, back before she was a disaster, and an awesomely bitchy Rachel McAdams, back before she was a brunette, and it’s a teen movie about social climbing, a next Generation Heathers (directed by the brother of the Heathers’ director). But hell if it isn’t one of the sharpest high-school comedies of the Aughts, observant and cutting with more than enough wit to rise above the gloss. It never managed to make “fetch” happen, but it did spring Tina Fey loose from “SNL” and catapult her to “30 Rock” success.—Dustin Rowles

amelie-bath.jpegAmelie: French people suck shit, especially when they try to be helpful to others, and quirky movies irritate me with their whimsical bullshit and idealized social intimacies. So Amelie should tap into my Fury Center [I read that as Furry Center. Carry on.—JR] and massage it to a right grand inferno, but it doesn’t. Audrey Tatou is the cutest little thing ever planted in front of a camera and I am but a leaf on the wind of her effervescent joie-de-vivre. A dumb grin and profound shame settle in around the time my finger hits “play” and doesn’t GTFO for days, and I hate them for making me love it.—Kballs

notebook.jpgThe Notebook: Nicholas Sparks is an asshole. He’s like that guy from college who carried his guitar EVERYWHERE just so he could impress chicks with his lazy, acoustic rendition of brown-eyed girl. Naturally, this makes him a perfect addition to the Hollywood community. Several of his novels have been adapted into saccharine-sweet, predictable melodramas, the most popular and profitable of which has been The Notebook. It’s a terrible movie, people. The plot doesn’t develop because of actual conflict; it just sort of meanders along aimlessly because all the characters are whimpering, passive-aggressive cowards. The most emotionally charged moments of the film all feature people either shrieking at each other, or making out in the rain (because of course they are), or dying. And yet…[sigh] I LOVE this movie. Despite myself, I get swept up in the impossible endurance of their love affair. I cheer for their every victory and anguish over their every misstep. I weep uninhibitedly in the peaceful stillness of their final moments. I do; I bawl like a little girl. Mock me if you must, but this enchanting movie is a long-time favorite. I strongly recommend avoiding it.—superasente

Joanna Robinson really hopes you take none of the heteronormative gender stereotypes in this column seriously. If you do, you must be one of those crazy hormonal chicks who is on her period. Comedy!









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Larry Crowne Review: The Unsettling Oprahfication of Tom Hanks | Larry Crowne Review: The Unsettling Oprahfication of Tom Hanks









Comments

I dont love any of these.

But I always watch "Uncle Buck" when it's on. RIP John.

Posted by: logan at June 30, 2011 3:09 PM

I fucking LOVE Amelie! All guys should.

Posted by: Vick at June 30, 2011 3:13 PM

I'd totally wait on Mr. Vartan on that baseball mound. He's a likely lifetime appointment on my five freebies.

Bring It On is a glorious, GLORIOUS movie that I love the everliving hell out of.

"Brrr, it's cold in here, there must be some Toros in the atmosphere..."

Posted by: Melody at June 30, 2011 3:15 PM

Oh and hating on Clueless is illegal and not allowed.

Posted by: Melody at June 30, 2011 3:16 PM

You don't really need to justify loving SINGING IN THE RAIN. Or AMELIE. I would wonder about someone who didn't love those movies. Even I love SINGING IN THE RAIN, and I hate musicals with a passion.

Posted by: Sean at June 30, 2011 3:19 PM

Just for the record, I no longer eat bacon, but there is probably some residual clogging.

Posted by: C. Robert Dimitri at June 30, 2011 3:20 PM

Love Singin' in the Rain, but it's hard to forget Gene Kelly's offscreen meanness to Debbie Reynolds.

Unlike Fred Astaire, Kelly was no gentleman.

And yes, I too was in WSS in my youth: Doc and Gladhand, the only two parts that can be played by one guy.

Posted by: SteveR at June 30, 2011 3:21 PM

I watch Never Been Kissed, Bring it On, and Fried Green Tomatoes every damned time they're on the teevee. My boobs tingle when TBS schedules them, it's a psycho thing.

Mean Girls and Singing in the Rain I don't have to wait for. I own them with pride because if I'm in a bad mood there's no better pick me up than Damien saying "That's why her hair is so big; it's full of SECRETS." or Lina Lamont screeching "I caaaaayn't staaaaaynd em!"

Posted by: Julie at June 30, 2011 3:22 PM

Holy shit. I love Pajiboys.

Posted by: Cindy at June 30, 2011 3:24 PM

Amelie is my husband's favorite movie. And I love him more for that.

Posted by: MelBivDevoe at June 30, 2011 3:24 PM

I have to admit, Prisco is ballsier than me, as I also love Bring It On -- saw it way too many times in the theater (let's just leave it at more than twice), and I also still give Dunst and Dushku a pass because of it. But Clueless holds considerably less shame, and having rewatched it for this, I'm quite satisfied with my pick. Still... spirit fingers!

Actually, I love most of these. Hm. Where's the Man who takes my Man Card?

Posted by: RobP at June 30, 2011 3:26 PM

Mock me if you must,

I MUST. Consider yourself mocked, sir. Mocked, knocked, and shocked.

Posted by: mswas at June 30, 2011 3:27 PM

I really like "Amelie" and "Clueless". Both are great. I once saw Amelie in a theater in Brussels, because Mrs. Donut, who was just the Donut's girlfriend, was visiting at the time and hadn't seen it. Note, there were Flemish but no English subtitles and I don't speak any French. I had seen the movie before, however, so I could follow along well enough and still really enjoyed it.

I find "Fried Green Tomatoes" to be amusing enough.

Haven't seen the rest of these.

Oh, and I know enough French people to safely say that they really don't "suck shit", especially when they try to be helpful to others.

Posted by: Forbiddendonut at June 30, 2011 3:27 PM

Nice try Forbiddendonut, but French people in France suck all the shit. I went there, saw them sucking it with that smug look on their face, and it's clung to me like the reek of an overturned outhouse.

Posted by: Kballs at June 30, 2011 3:31 PM

Where's the Man who takes my Man Card?

He must've been waylaid by a box of Kleenex and his DVD of Boys on the Side.

Posted by: branded at June 30, 2011 3:32 PM

Thank you so much for this list simply because you have given me something with which I can mock superasente to the end of my days.

Posted by: PaddyDog at June 30, 2011 3:35 PM

I was *justthisclose* to doing Shakespeare in Love but I've actually simmered on this one as Paltrow's and Fiennes careers and lives have progressed. Am I using their annoying acting/faces as a petty excuse to distance myself from the shameful liking of it? You know me so well.

Posted by: Kballs at June 30, 2011 3:35 PM

Kballs, I unabashedly adore everything about Shakespeare in Love. Everything. And none of that sentiment is influenced by the fact that I want to ride Joseph Fiennes and his long eyelashes like a tricycle.

Posted by: Julie at June 30, 2011 3:38 PM

I have an irrational love of "Two Weeks Notice". Ugh. Joanna, I wouldn't admit that in public unless you'd demanded it of me on Twitter. That... message was directed only to me, right?

Posted by: BrockW at June 30, 2011 3:41 PM

So Superascente is the person who likes The Notebook. That's utterly and completely mockable.

Posted by: Melody at June 30, 2011 3:41 PM

Dudes, you've all become hotter in my eyes. Even though I'm a 27-year-old female and I've never seen The Notebook. Do I have to give back my ovaries now? Do any of you guys want them?

Posted by: Internet Magpie at June 30, 2011 3:45 PM

No love for "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun" I see

PHOOEY!

I question the alleged manhood of all submitters.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at June 30, 2011 3:45 PM

The mister says he likes all of Hugh Jackman's silly romantic comedies like Someone Like You and Kate & Leopold.

Also, he liked Down With Love, that Ewan McGregor and Renee Zellweger movie. And we can reliably be trusted to rent Hugh Grant movies.

AND HE WILL NOT BE MOCKED.

Posted by: Sara H at June 30, 2011 3:45 PM

I love this. This whole thing. You big, smushy smushface boys.

Also, I'll stand beside you with that one, superasente. That movie is total, unabashed, cliche-ridden tripe, and I know it, and it annoys me, and I can't not root for them and cry for them. RIDICULOUS.

Of course, I am an *actual* girl, so...

Posted by: Anna von Beav at June 30, 2011 3:46 PM

No love for "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun" I see

Slim, these are children.

Posted by: Jay at June 30, 2011 3:49 PM

This is where one busts out the oldie but a goodie, "I'm not THAT gay".

For all of them.

Posted by: googergieger at June 30, 2011 3:50 PM

Out of all these movies I've only seen Clueless. You can prolly guess that I'm pretty tough in real life.

Posted by: asdff at June 30, 2011 3:50 PM

No, stop, I see you forming the words--

They haven't seen "Valley Girl" either.

Posted by: Jay at June 30, 2011 3:51 PM

I don't know if it counts as a chick-flick per se, but I LOVE the movie, "Drop Dead Gorgeous"! I'm also I bit of a sucker for An American President, For Love of the game and Tin Cup (despite Mr. Costner).

Posted by: SZ at June 30, 2011 3:51 PM

I really enjoy under the Tuscan sun, also French kiss and because I said so, all three are great, but Singin' in the Rain is actually my second favorite film of all time.

Posted by: Tim at June 30, 2011 3:52 PM

Love Actually, A Very Long Engagement

Posted by: thisnameisfake at June 30, 2011 3:53 PM

Singin' In The Rain. Yes.
Amelie. Yes.
Mean Girls. Always.
Clueless. Fuck Yes.
WSS: Absolutlely. But only for the Puerto Ricans because they still rock that thing. The whities still look tight..
Terms of Endearment, I can only remember Jack Nicholson riding a convertible down the beach yelling "There is wind in my hair and lead in the pencil!!"
Notebook - half and half.
As for the rest - don't know can't say.

But I do love me a good Jane Austen Fillum.

Posted by: Odnon. at June 30, 2011 3:53 PM

I bet they never heard of My Demon Lover either...

*Fist-bumps Jay*

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at June 30, 2011 3:55 PM

I'll give you Amelie, otherwise I want nothin to do with any of that.

Posted by: Seth at June 30, 2011 3:56 PM

At the end of "The Notebook" (won't "spoil"), I turn to my gf and state, "That's a stupid ending." I will probably never be forgiven. So I take immense glee in saying how much better the "dialogue" is that they add about the barfing dog at the vet in the shut yo trap commercial at the movie theatres these days...
I did like Amelie... I rip on my ex-Brother in law from loving "Hope Floats".
I will confess a love for "Ever After"... there I am human, if you cut me, will I not bleed... ,
(over ellipsis-ing today. Not sure why)

Posted by: antietam at June 30, 2011 3:56 PM

Jay:

This is a thankless task you've taken on. Sooner or later Gregory's Girl will be mentioned and you'll be weeping with rage that no-one has heard of it.

Posted by: PaddyDog at June 30, 2011 3:59 PM

My husband loves Clueless! I once found the disc in the player when I came home from a week long work trip. I turned to face him, raised my eyebrows and he preempted my mocking with (a very manly) "as if!"

True love people. It's real.

Posted by: Scully at June 30, 2011 4:04 PM

This is a great list, and I love every movie listed here that I've seen.

I was a Merchant-Ivory WHORE growing up (those all hit around my angsty, sensitive, Wuthering Heights-reading high school days) and I lapped up every tea-soaked minute of Room With A View, Howard's End, and, my favorite, The Remains Of The Day, which has a scene that absolutely destroys me every time I see it, when they meet for the last time, at the bus stop (in the pouring goddamn rain, of course), and they hold hands, saying their cordial goodbyes, and the bus pulls away, and pulls them apart, and they realize they're never going to see each other again, and they realize they've missed out on their chance at true love and true happiness, and Emma Thompson is standing in the rain, her face finally betraying the crushing grief of her missed chance, and Anthony Hopkins breaks, too, and I just want to run up to him and grab him by his immaculately tailored lapel and shout, "GO TO HER, YOU FUCKING COWARD! You've loved her your whole life! How can you watch her suffer like that???"

*takes a deep breath*

*takes a sip of tea*

Anyway, uh, good film.

And just to get out ahead of all of this gender stereotyping crap, in my book, REAL men cry when it's appropriate. REAL men are in touch with their emotions, which means that a great film with a heartbreaking scene makes us well up. That's called "being a human being".

Now if you don't mind, I need to go to Whole Foods so I can buy ingredients for the dinner I'm making my girlfriend tomorrow night.

Posted by: Dan at June 30, 2011 4:04 PM

Blue Crush, Spice World, Bring it On

Posted by: archeon at June 30, 2011 4:08 PM

If I had a nickel for every time my husband said, "Don't tell anyone I love this movie", I'd be having steak for dinner. Often.

He got sick on our honeymoon and we had to stay in the hotel (not in the fun way, either), and we watched The Last Holiday. Now it is his favorite guilty pleasure movie.

What can I say, I loves a mushy man.

Posted by: Patty O'Green at June 30, 2011 4:10 PM

When I first saw Never Been Kissed, I loved it -- right up until that last scene. Not only does she pressure this guy to -leave his fiancee- to try and kiss her, but she sets up the most public, horrifying situation in which to make that happen. I wanted, more than anything, him to come, kiss her, and then go, "OK, that was great. Thanks for putting my professional reputation on the line. I gotta go catch that plane."

Bring It On, Clueless, and Mean Girls are all -amazing-.

Singin' in the Rain: Good call, though I think its a bit ironic for you to pick on modern day musicals for lip synching on behalf of a movie about lip synching.

Posted by: Kat at June 30, 2011 4:14 PM

no-one has heard of it.

Wait....they haven't?

Posted by: Jay at June 30, 2011 4:19 PM

I'm ok with most of these movies. Meh on "The Notebook." It's boring.

Posted by: Slash at June 30, 2011 4:28 PM

I love 70% of these movies unashamedly!I would like to add baby boom, I don't know why but that movie is one of my chewing gum faves!

It is just such a cosy film.

Posted by: crisyroo at June 30, 2011 4:28 PM

I've only seen two of these movies all the way through.

Posted by: Paultera at June 30, 2011 4:37 PM

I know it's a love it/hate it movie but I love "The Hours". LOVE it. I've seen it at least 5 or 6 times. It has great performances from many of my favorite actors and actresses and I love how the whole movie is cut like a thriller. It never stops moving and the score never lets up. It's overwrought as all hell, but I like that about it too. For me it all works.

And who DOESN'T love "Bring it On"? Hell, when we rented it we watched it twice in one day.

Posted by: TylerDFC at June 30, 2011 4:40 PM

I find that, more and more, I have a weakness for truly crappy movies. Secret shames? HA! My whole movie collection is filled with them. I own a disturbingly large portion of this list. And yet, I am also incredibly passionate about films that are undeniably great, so I don't really know where this leaves me...

Maybe I'm just too egalitarian. Meh, I dunno.

Posted by: noodlestein at June 30, 2011 4:48 PM

Ditto on "Under the Tuscan Sun", though I really wish that Dianne Lane's character didn't have to "finally" find a man for the film to have a "tidy" ending. But at least he was younger than she, so the typical old-man-young-woman thing got flipped in her favor.

Posted by: Trey Shacksit at June 30, 2011 4:49 PM

Donald O'Connor has ruined me relationship-wise. Ever since the first time I saw "Singin' in the Rain," Cosmo Brown has been my ultimate man. That level of crazy talent and goofy charm has proven impossible for anyone to live up to.

Posted by: BeckEye at June 30, 2011 4:49 PM

A couple of years ago, Mr. Nonymous and I were in Costco and overheard this conversation between two male staff members:

Staffer #1: Dude, have you seen this movie? Amelia? (Holds up copy of "Amelie")

Staffer #2: No.

Staffer #1: You know how sometimes you see a girl, and she's so ugly she's cute? This movie is all about her. You should see it.

Mr. Nonymous: What? Are they talking about "Amelie"? Audrey Tatou is adorable!

Posted by: KateNonymous at June 30, 2011 4:56 PM

My boyfriend (a giant softie) recently discovered Pretty Woman and ate that shit right up. Like, regularly saying, "Big mistake. Huge." and he wouldn't watch Seinfeld reruns for a week because of Jason Alexander's presence. I did score some pancakes, though.

Posted by: jM at June 30, 2011 4:58 PM

I LOVE "A Room With A View," especially the nekkid romp round the pond. I almost broke the VCR tape rewinding and rewatching that over and over again. We really need more frontal male nudity in period movies where the women are wearing fantastic dress and tiara porn, and the men are nekkid and wet.

Posted by: BWeaves at June 30, 2011 5:01 PM

I've got a man-size box of Kleenex with your name on it Jay.

Seriously: does anyone remember when Kleenex actually used to advertise a box of tissues that was "man size"? As a child I used to wonder if men had ten times more snots than women because those tissues were huge.

Posted by: PaddyDog at June 30, 2011 5:07 PM

I am a complete and total sucker for The Holiday. That's right - THE HOLIDAY. I can NOT turn off this movie when it's on TV. It's the combination of the sweet old guy that ends up being Kate Winslet's neighbor, Jude Law playing the kind of guy I wish he was in real life (Mr. Napkinhead? I'm not made of lead, people.) and the sheer silly unlikeliness of the entire plot. Insert wistful sigh here.

Posted by: amanda at June 30, 2011 5:52 PM

Thanks to this list I no longer have to hide my secret shame(s). In no particular order:
Love Actually
The Notebook
Waiting To Exhale (eye candy, don't judge me)
The Wedding Date
Shall We Dance
I will watch every one of these every time they come on television.

Posted by: TheBlackMenace at June 30, 2011 6:00 PM

J’aime les Franҫais! These are my people. Please don’t hate on ‘em. We would not have Mardi Gras—or New Orleans—without them. The posts about Merchant-Ivory flicks reminded me of Eddie Izzard’s “Brit vs. U.S. Movies,” (plus he reminds us why all Americans should love the French).

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TjC3R6jOtUo

Tried to get the little boy Stinkies to watch Singing in the Rain with me, and they were NOT havin’ it. Perhaps the capacity of a male to love it is directly proportional to his calculated odds of getting laid by lady friend who most likely will do the deed if she perceives him a sensitive, whimsical soul. Then again, three margaritas might achieve the same effect. Worked for meeee!

Posted by: Stinky at June 30, 2011 6:02 PM

"Yes," to Clueless, Mean Girls, and Singin' in the Rain.
I would also add Love Can Build a Bridge, a television movie about the Judds.

Posted by: Rykker at June 30, 2011 6:08 PM

ahhhhhh this list has my top 3 movies of ALL TIME and i love it for tht!
terms of endearment, clueless, and mean girls

just incredible.

Posted by: akt at June 30, 2011 6:15 PM

At the risk of getting flamed beyond recognition, I just have to wonder why Sound of Music was not on the list? I blub buckets when I hear the strains of Eidelweiss.

My boyfriend in high school played Rolf in a local dinner theatre production of Sound of Music, and he was adorable. I just happened to be 16-going-on-17 at the time, and I would stand in the wings and pretend he was singing to me, but, alas, he was gay (no hard feelings; no pun intended; we're still friends). Is this why it wasn't on the list?

Posted by: Stinky at June 30, 2011 6:29 PM

I have The Gay, so my opinions here don't count for much. Swap out Heathers for Mean Girls and that's closer to my age track. I have never been able to take Alicia Silverstone seriously at all. Singin' in the Rain is great, but Gene Kelly's ass is used to much greater effect in An American in Paris. When I go all Merchant/Ivory, my tendency is to head to Maurice first. Something about the Grant/Wilby/Graves triangle just pulls my strings more than anything in A Room with a View. Bring It On only reminds me of how intensly I dislike Kirsten Dunst and that the world would be much better if all those roles had been given to Julia Stiles. I've been more or less done with Drew Barrymore since she turned thirteen, but I don't know what I'd put in that slot instead. Definitely nothing with Jennifer Garner, though. Terms of Endearment is also great, though it pains me to say -- because I loathe and despise Julia Roberts -- Steel Magnolias is the film I, along with 80% of the southern gay community, have committed to memory. Debra Winger kicks Julia's ass all around the Gulf, but it is what it is.

Posted by: Jerry at June 30, 2011 6:32 PM

I'm 28, and a girl. I LOVE Mean Girls and Clueless. As for the rest of them, I haven't seen any.

It's my life's goal to die without ever seeing The Notebook, ever. I will go out of my way to avoid that movie forever, and all movies like it.

Ryan Gosling is one of the better talents of our generation, though. He might make the Logan's Run remake worth shelling out for. Might.

Posted by: Nugs at June 30, 2011 6:34 PM

Gene Kelly is bad ass. His childhood dream was to play shortstop for the Pittsburgh Pirates. That's all I needed to know.

Posted by: Socrates_Johnson at June 30, 2011 6:35 PM

Yay for Room With a View! My husband would never admit to liking it but he's sat through it at least three times with me.

Posted by: pickled tink at June 30, 2011 6:35 PM

Where the Heart Is... my favorite Natalie Portman moive. Yeah, that's right, I said favorite.

Posted by: just me at June 30, 2011 6:44 PM

fuck...or *movie*...whichever...

Posted by: just me at June 30, 2011 6:50 PM

Hm. Now I kind of wish I'd gone with The Girl on the Bridge, but it's not old, just obscure (and also French), just to shut Jay and BSlim up. I've seen Valley Girl and Girls Just Want to Have Fun, but they don't hold a candle to any of these flicks, dudebros.

However, Earth Girls are Easy would have been aces.

Posted by: RobP at June 30, 2011 6:51 PM

Wait. I take part of that back. Those two would be better than The Notebook. Sorry, superasente, but that shit is whack.

Posted by: RobP at June 30, 2011 6:53 PM

YOU SHUT YOUR WHORE MOUTH!

Posted by: superasente at June 30, 2011 6:55 PM

It's Ho mouth, actually.

Posted by: Stinky at June 30, 2011 7:06 PM

I love Clueless, I could PowerPoint the wonders of it's delicious fluff.

*The Faison Unleashed
*Cher is a lovable, decent person. We don't care that she's sort of shallow seeming, by the end of the movie you see a lot of her father in her.
*Tai goes with her Duckie instead of her Blaine, and we love it. And seeing Brittany Murphy before she got chewed up is sweet and sad.
*Paul Rudd- never prettier. None prettier since.

Posted by: Stacy D at June 30, 2011 7:16 PM

True story. I cried my eyes out in front of my mom and sister when I first saw Fried Green tomatoes. I was about 7 years old.
The scene that did me in was when Kathy Bates was called a fat cow by that little punk in the parking lot. Every time I bring a new girl around the first thing my family does is bring that story up.

Posted by: Larold at June 30, 2011 7:33 PM

It's ok Jay - not only have I watched Gregory's Girl at least two dozen times in my younger days, I've even seen the sequel.

Posted by: Krix at June 30, 2011 7:57 PM

If any of the fellas admit their love for While You Were Sleeping, I will replace one of the spots on my 5 Freebies List with them.

No, it's not a good movie. I don't care. It's a-fucking-dorable.

Posted by: Lainey at June 30, 2011 8:43 PM

Can someone explain to me the whole Stranger Than Fiction thing? I saw that movie once when it came out, thought it was really stupid, and ever since then I hear otherwise intelligent people say that they love it. Is there more to it than a silly "what if" premise and Will Ferrell doing his usual schtick?

Posted by: John. G. at June 30, 2011 9:02 PM

My husband is one of those men who pays lip service to the grumbling man-hate of all things "chick-flickish..." and then wanders into the living room or bedroom when he senses something "chick-flickish" about to start... stands there for a good twenty minutes, and eventually finds a subtle way to sit down and watch. UNLESS I call him on it and SAY something like, "Why don't you just COMMIT already and sit the fuck down and WATCH it?" -- in which case he will REFUSE to admit to himself or anyone else that he actually WANTS to watch it, and will wander away (but remain within earshot) for a long enough period that he believes I will have forgotten he was actually paying attention, and then begin the process all over again.

It's so fucking silly.

Yesterday I caught him watching "Valentine's Day."

While working on his MLB fantasy league.

Sigh.

Posted by: Maryscott O'Connor at June 30, 2011 9:26 PM

I ALWAYS stop to watch While You Were Sleeping! I frakking LOVE that movie! I just wanna hug Sandra Bullock throughout the entire thing!

Posted by: andrew Fitzsimons at June 30, 2011 9:42 PM

I agree with Superasente on everything about The Notebook . I believe its mostly due to - and, to be clear, I hate myself for saying this about a Nicholas Sparks movie - the caliber of the performances transcending the material.

Posted by: nosio at June 30, 2011 10:05 PM

This was an amazingly awesome acclamation of celluloids and their scripts. Way to go guys, especially you superasente!

Posted by: crazybuttersnuffer at June 30, 2011 10:11 PM

Why, hello there, andrew Fitzsimons...

Posted by: Lainey at June 30, 2011 10:22 PM

As much as I hate to even hear me typing the titles, I absolutely love watching First Wives Club and She-Devil. I think it's the revenge thing (even though I have no one I want to beat down that hard).

And Matilda, but that's a good movie, right?

Posted by: funtime42 at June 30, 2011 10:27 PM

I read superasentes bit in the usually voice I read his comments in (snarky, sometimes spiteful, always hateful Gary Oldmann) and so I still can't take him seriously when he says he loves The Notebook.

I think he be trollin'

Posted by: Lennon at June 30, 2011 10:45 PM

/Goddammit, I can't do this... All right, deep breath...

I loved The Notebook, and it made me tear up. It was the performances by Rachel and Baby Goose, not the material. I think...

Now forgive me while I submit to electroshock therapy (well, what would you do if you agreed with superasente about this shit?)

Posted by: Uriah Creep at June 30, 2011 10:58 PM

Maryscott, are you married to MY husband???

Posted by: Stinky at June 30, 2011 11:50 PM

love clueless, bring it on, singing in the rain, amelie.

Although fuck Gene Kelly, O'connor makes singing in the rain.

Posted by: Ben at July 1, 2011 1:37 AM

Heh. sperasente's a dude. The more you know...

Posted by: Rest In Peace at July 1, 2011 1:40 AM

Maybe Stranger Than Fiction.

Maybe Amelie.

The rest is just a bunch of no

Posted by: Protoguy at July 1, 2011 1:53 AM

I LOVE so many of these movies!! Amelie is amazing and Stranger than Fiction was so much better than I thought it would be! But, West Side Story is one of my all time favs! I listen to the soundtrack quite frequently in my car and whenever I watch the movie I get misty during "one hand, one heart" and cry my eyes out when Tony is murdered. My favorite part of that movie is when Marni Nixon sings "A Boy Like That." Just awesome

Posted by: apsutter at July 1, 2011 2:26 AM

My chickflick is "Grease".

The first Grease.

Not Grease 2. That sucked balls

Posted by: Lenoir at July 1, 2011 5:57 AM

You guys forgot 9 to 5.

Posted by: polymixin at July 1, 2011 6:55 AM

So there are 3 on this list, that as a guys guy, i have seen and enjoyed. I enjoy Clueless, Mean Girls and Stranger Than Fiction(although i wasn't aware that was considered a "chick flick"). I must say they are great movies i can rewatch when on TV. The others i have not seem most of them, and i am quite ok with that.

I will say though, i have been "Notebooked" twice. I think with everytime i see it, i hate it more and more. That movie just makes my skin crawl.

I would like to add City Of Angels to the list. I know it is quite sad at the end, but it is a damn good movie. Just my humble opinion.

Posted by: Kluetus at July 1, 2011 11:15 AM

10 Things I Hate About You, The Sure Thing, Lucas and Pretty Woman.

Posted by: somedumbguy at July 1, 2011 11:17 AM

Okay, I'll put my neck out there...

Xanadu. I love that gorram movie. I even have the Marvel Comics Super Special of Xanadu in my collection.

Bring it, haters. My power ring is fully charged and at the ready.

Posted by: Green Lantern at July 1, 2011 11:32 AM

Ah Green Lantern, you and my husband are one of a kind then. Here's a guy who lists his top favorite movies of all time as Commando, Robocop, Die Hard, Predator, Best of the Best, so on and so on...and Xanadu. Which he loves unabashedly. He bought the super edition dvd or whatever it was, he has a copy of the movie on his droid, as well as the soundtrack.

It's really damn weird. I bet you guys are the same age too.

Posted by: Sinnh at July 1, 2011 1:48 PM

I'm not a guy, but once Stranger than Fiction has been mentioned I am constitutionally obligated to mention that it is THE WORST FUCKING MOVIE EVER MADE.

Ahem. Carry on, all. Especially with the love for Clueless.

Posted by: Artemis at July 1, 2011 2:11 PM

I love all those movies, some more than others, for different reasons. I love Clueless because I was like that way before the movie came out. I love the Notebook because it was the catalyst for a long overdue talk with my mother, I love Never Been Kissed because I always felt like Josie Grossie even though I did a semi-good job of hiding it. I love A Room With a View because I watched it in the theater and it was my first instance of male full frontal - I went to an all girl Catholic school,and said full frontal precipitated a very shrill, very loud session of giggles that got us promptly removed from the theater. But these are chick flicks, so it's easy. Let's talk about testosterone laden films that girls love next time and see what develops, mmmmkay? And logan, my all time favorite John Candy flick is Only the Lonely which is heartbreaking and heartwarming all at once and it's all because of him, may he rest in peace.

Posted by: Az at July 1, 2011 2:54 PM

Aaaand I like exactly 1/4 of these movies.

Posted by: ChristianH at July 1, 2011 6:47 PM

I really liked Never Been Kissed when I first saw it, but now that i'm older I'm seriously questioning it. Vartan is foxy and all (and always on my freebie list) but his character basically likes his STUDENT. And yea, what drew's character did to get her kiss, in such a public way... bleh. It makes my skin crawl.

I would still watch it every time is on though.

I too love While You Were Sleeping and City of Angels (which breaks my heart every time.) I really like Hugh Jackman, so Kate and Leopold and Someone Like You is ok by me (plus, I kinda love Ashley Judd.)

I sincerely think The Holiday is a stupid movie. A stupid, stupid movie.

Posted by: denesteak at July 1, 2011 7:54 PM

How the hell did Singin' in the Rain make this list? A musical that should be in the love-hate category should be Chicago, since no one (male or female) ever wants to openly admit they love Renée Zellweger, or even RENT, which is admittedly heavy-handed in its subject matter and was a movie with Chris Columbus at the helm. Even Daniel Day Lewis in Nine should be a guilty pleasure over this choice. Singin' in the Rain is an impressive, beautiful little piece that recently had Bill Hader introduce it on TMC's "Essentials Jr." this past week.

All of Singin' in the Rain's was in long shots; there are no flashy cutscenes and the only shininess were in the costumes. It even had a small appearance by Cyd Charisse, portraying a silent vamp in The Dueling Cavalier's rewrite. Gene Kelly is all that is man: smooth-skinned, pearly-teethed, silky voice, bangin' dancer's body. Donald O'Connor is the epitome of the best friend role, neither completely stealing the spotlight from Kelly nor falling flat in his reasons for being there. Debbie Reynolds is cute as a damn button, and we can't forget Jean Hagen's role as Lina Lamont, who was nominated for Best Supporting Actress that year for it.

I think this is a movie that everyone should think of fondly. Yes, it's a soft portrayal of that Hollywood era, but it was so well done. No one should be ashamed of liking this movie in any sort of way.

Also, a Mose is a Mose: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tciT9bmCMq8

Posted by: duckandcover at July 1, 2011 10:46 PM

(Seriously. This is a curse.)

Where the Heart Is... my favorite Natalie Portman moive. Yeah, that's right, I said favorite.
Posted by: just me at June 30, 2011 6:44 PM

It's one the newest additions to Netflix's Instant Queue if you need to tourniquet your arm and inject yourself with a little pre-Oscar Natalie Portman, a cutesy Ashley Judd, and a pre-True Blood James Frain.

Posted by: duckandcover at July 1, 2011 10:58 PM

These The Young Turks are sometimes dead on their political commentary. The Young Turks remain as a cynical perspective. I hope The Young Turks will always be corageous enough to tell it like it is and counter the GOP funded Fox Network conspiracy.

Posted by: Property relations in Philippines at July 6, 2011 11:27 AM

These guys are sometimes spot on their political gambits. The Young Turks continue as a informatave perspective. I pray they will always be brave enough to tell it like it is and oppose the GOP sponsored Fox Network conspiracy.

Posted by: Child abuse laws in Philippines at July 6, 2011 12:33 PM

Between me and my husband we've owned more MP3 players over the years than I can count, including Sansas, iRivers, iPods (classic & touch), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last few years I've settled down to one line of players. Why? Because I was happy to discover how well-designed and fun to use the underappreciated (and widely mocked) Zunes are.

Posted by: Carroll B. Merriman at August 29, 2011 3:43 AM