web
counter
 

Wake Up Dead

By TK | Posted Under TV Reviews | Comments (51)



walkingdead12.jpg

It’s been a long time since I’ve actually arranged my schedule around a television show. But Frank Darabont’s “The Walking Dead,” based on the graphic novel series of the same name by Robert Kirkman (and drawn by Tony Moore and Charlie Aldard) changed that. As a huge fan of the gripping, heartrending series, the news that Darabont was making it into a televised series seemed terrific. Given the serial nature of the books, television, particularly cable television, is the perfect medium. As such, we’ve been gobbling up every bit of “Walking Dead” news to be found, and with each news item, video clip and trailer, I’ve been filled with a steadily increasing combination of anticipation and dread.

One of those feelings was wholly justified. “The Walking Dead” starts out simply, with two southern cops, Shane and Rick (Jon Bernthal and Andrew Lincoln), talking about random things as friends do. They get pulled into the middle of a high speed chase that devolves into a shootout, and Rick takes a bullet and lapses into a coma. Cut to an undisclosed amount of time later, and Rick wakes up in an empty hospital, its corridors filled with destruction and locked doors that ominously read “Don’t Open. Dead Inside.” Rick, dazed and disoriented, staggers outside to find a town filled with nothing but wrecked infrastructure and dead bodies.

Lost in his own hometown and completely baffled as to the ruination surrounding him, Rick heads home only to find his home abandoned. He’s taken in by Morgan and his son Duane, and eventually learns of the inexplicable and horrifying plague of the undead, and that survivors headed towards Atlanta, a supposed safe haven, and thus Rick’s journey through the new, undead-inf. The pilot episode is essentially the setup for the series, and it’s the perfect introduction to this new world.

The zombie trope is rapidly reaching vampire-like levels of saturation and overuse, but “The Walking Dead” takes it in a somewhat different direction. In fact, if I had to compare it to any of the legion of zombie films that have proliferated over the past 40-odd years, it’s an unlikely pairing that springs to mind. It’s certainly an honest homage and throwback to George Romero’s original Night Of The Living Dead. The undead are mindless shamblers, lurching with a horrific gnawing hunger towards anything that moves, but unexplained and shocking. At the same time, the humanity of the cast immediately brought to mind, oddly enough, Edgar Wright’s Shaun Of The Dead. Not for comedic purposes — humor is the one thing you absolutely won’t find in “The Walking Dead.” Rather, the character-focused plotting, which uses the undead as a vehicle to tell the stories of its players, rather than making the undead the story. It’s a precarious balance between the gore and horror of the zombie genre, and the deep characterization and dramatic elements of the lives and interactions of the characters.

The cast, what little we see of them, are overall perfect. Andrew Lincoln struggles a bit with the Kentucky accent (given that he’s British and all), but he’s a strong lead who conveys a wealth of emotion in the episode, most notably in his first terrified, confused moments after waking up, and in his complete breakdown upon finding his house empty. His keening, stomach-clenching anguish is palpable and that moment served as the perfect connection to the audience. Morgan and Duane are both quite good, particularly the elder as a harried, desolate man trying to simply keep it together for his son (and it’s not made easier by the fact that his undead wife wanders the streets of the house they’ve barricaded themselves inside of).

However, it’s the writing and direction that shines most of all. AMC, most recognized for the renowned “Mad Men” and “Breaking Bad,” really let Darabont off the leash for the production, and as a result his dedication and admiration of the source material is clear. The sets are replete with a sense of ragged grandiosity, filled with numerous wide shots that show a society that completely broke down and dissolved. The zombies themselves are incredible, ranging from a handful of newly dead, tattered “walkers” to mangled, rotted things that are mere husks of what they once were. Yet Darabont (and make up artist Gregory Nicotero — a student of Tom Savini’s and a past collaborator with both Darabont and Romero) have done something different with their creations — made them human. They’re mindless creatures, to be sure, but they’ve somehow managed, through the recognition their eyes show, the movements of their jaws, the gut-roiling moans they emit, to make them seem less monstrous and make you truly understand that these are people. This near-humanizing adds a layer of complexity to the struggle and one can sense the hunger that compels them. Maybe it’s just me, but you also get the sense that they are, brain-dead or not, flesh-eaters or not, suffering. It makes for an interesting interplay between Rick and the first undead that he encounters, but also makes the conflicts, the hunting and killing by both the living and the dead, even more affecting and terrifying.

There’s little to criticize, particularly so early in the series when so few of the characters have manifested. Rick’s acknowledgment and acceptance of Morgan’s zombie outbreak explanation seemed a bit too quick and unquestioning, but otherwise, “The Walking Dead” seems to be set to make another strong run for AMC. Darabont and company have clearly demonstrated a love of the source material, and the changes that they made are all solid, and in some cases, serve to make the story even better. The production, sets and effects are summarily terrific (OK, some of the CGI blood is a little glaring), and the music is especially enjoyable. It’s sparely used and never resorts to cheap, melodramatic crescendos. Instead, it’s used to move us through the film’s quiet moments, or, in the case of their unusual yet brilliant use of Wang Chung’s “Space Junk,” to heighten tension without detracting from the scene.

“The Walking Dead” will run for six episodes, with Darabont stating that a full 13 episode second season is in the works. If it shows strong ratings, AMC may have another unlikely success on their hands. The graphic novels are replete with drama, emotion and unflinching displays of humanity at its best and worst. The stories, set against the backdrop of a world torn asunder as the dead reduce it to chaos and carnage, should captivate not just fans of the genre, but all viewers. The pilot episode, “Days Gone Bye,” is a powerful and unsettling opener that promises great and terrible things to come.

TK writes about music and movies. He enjoys playing with dogs, raising the dead, and tacos. You can email him here.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Pajiba After Dark 11/1/10 | Is President Obama an Elitist? | Pajiba Debates









Comments

As a long time fan of the comic, I thought it was excellent. The 90 mintues flew right on by.

I thought the show did a good job of setting up the tension between Rick and his wife and Shane's lovelife troubles right away to better explain why Lori shacks up with Shane. They did so in a very natural, unobstrusive way.

Morgan and Duane's back story, which wasn't present in the original comic (though, I have heard is explored in some extra), was heart breaking and probably the most emotionally powerful part of the first episode.

The final shot of the zombies crawling all over the tank and then slowly losing interest in it and going for the horse was awesome and eerie to see.

I re-read the first trade paperback during the week, so it would be fresh in my head. And, based on an apples-to-apples comparison, so far, the show is better than the comic.

Better dialogue, better tension, better pacing.

Top notch stuff all around.

Posted by: FordbiddenDonut at November 1, 2010 1:08 PM

Though I've never read the graphic novel, the hype sucked me in and the quality of the show will keep me hanging 'round. Andrew Lincoln is superb.

Posted by: Cindy at November 1, 2010 1:15 PM

WOWOWOWOW“....!!!~~~~ B l a c k W h i t e S i n g l e 。。c 00o m ~~~ which is a hot community for whites and blacks to find their interracial love.,there has been thousands of single members online and many black and white single girls or guys waitting for you maybe you will like it.

Posted by: carl2z2 at November 1, 2010 1:15 PM

I don't think I took a breath between the time Rick woke up in the hospital and when he woke up in Morgan's house. I only have very minor nit-picks and that due to me wanting the show to be as real as it could possibly be. For an example, rick wakes up in the hospital and I thought, "he should be pulling out a catheter." The sets and the zombies are so gritty and real that it was fantastically immersive. I did think some of the acting was a bit over the top, but I think that will stop once the actors get more comfortable with their roles. Short as they may be.

Posted by: admin at November 1, 2010 1:19 PM

Exceeded my expectations by FAR.

My favorite moment, I think, is when Rick peers through the hospital doors and sees the bloody corpse lying in the hallway. Seriously creeped me right the fuck out. That whole sequence of Rick wandering through the silent hospital was just fantastic.

I do wonder who shaved his neck into a nicely-cropped beard while he convalesced in the zombie apocalypse, though :)

Posted by: Paul Southworth at November 1, 2010 1:21 PM

Excellent write-up (you're really getting good at this) douchebag.

Are we getting a weekly recap?

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at November 1, 2010 1:28 PM

Planned my entire day around this, so I could keep an arranged viewing time/location with a few friends.

FUCK. YES.

The terror was palpable. The drama was riveting (dudeman with his wife tore my heart out). And the camera work...top fucking notch. I loved the feeling of being stuck in the dark starewll with only a match lighting my way for 9 seconds at a time.

Needless to say...standing man-date night, every Sunday for the next 5 weeks.

Posted by: PissBoy at November 1, 2010 1:32 PM

My problems are, I admit, kind of nitpicky. It annoys me when people find themselves in this kind of situation and let their guard down for even an instant -- I would've had my gun on that soldier in the tank for five straight minutes before relaxing. Also, I find it implausible that the U.S. Army could possibly lose to a bunch of shambling, mindless corpses when they have machine guns and helicopters and everything. How could zombies stop a tank? Other than that, though, I'm fully on board.

Posted by: Todd at November 1, 2010 1:33 PM

If this thing makes it to season 3 or 4, it will go down in history as the most emotionally destroying pieces of tv ever. I'm looking forward to it.

Posted by: The_wakeful at November 1, 2010 1:36 PM

I actually didn't really love the show that much...

I think, as a fan of the series, that it just didn't do it for me. Not to mention I already know everything that happens to the cast...enough so for about 3-4 seasons in. So the drama doesn't really matter to me.

I'd also have to disagree with the comparison to Night of the Living Dead. Romero's zombies were flat out creepy, and they were terrifying to watch through the survivors eyes. I felt like Rick was...bored...when he looked at the zombies. So, in a way, it also made me bored. That and they were actually, if such a thing is possible, too polished for my taste. Like the make-up was almost too good.

I don't know...I just didn't feel anything "scary" in the pilot.

Posted by: DeistBrawler at November 1, 2010 1:38 PM

I waited ALL DAY for this and even convinced my non-horror loving boyfriend to watch with me. I really enjoyed the tension and the makeup effects (the torso of the woman crawling was both remarkable AND horrifying.) And I loved the small moments that spoke volumes, like their pleasure in taking a hot shower.

Can't wait for the rest. And I REALLY can't wait until I can get my hands on the graphic novel.

Posted by: Julie at November 1, 2010 1:39 PM

Also, I find it implausible that the U.S. Army could possibly lose to a bunch of shambling, mindless corpses when they have machine guns and helicopters and everything. How could zombies stop a tank?

-----------------------------------------------

Zombies don't really need to stop the tanks (or planes or helicopters for that matter) all of those vehicles are notorious gas-guzzlers. Meaning they require a whole support/refueling infrastructure to keep going. Once the Zombies take down the support that spiffy Abrams tank is about as effective as a paperweight.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at November 1, 2010 1:45 PM

Todd -
I wondered the same thing when I first started reading the comics. Later in the series (SPOILER...maybe?)

Rick and company meet up with an ex-soldier and he explains that the majority of the soldiers were more concerned about the well-being of their families than securing a city, so the troops that were in Atlanta were severely under-manned and overwhelmed by the zombies.

Posted by: henchman for hire at November 1, 2010 2:05 PM

That pilot ep was awesome. God I hope it gets good ratings so that maybe other good genre shows will be made.

Posted by: John W at November 1, 2010 2:11 PM

Back to back with Sherlock on Masterpiece Theater - it's going to be a great couple of weeks...

Posted by: jakers at November 1, 2010 2:12 PM

"Better dialogue, better tension, better pacing." - Forbiddendonut

Totally agree, but it still felt like the comic book. Sort of like, well, Robert Kirkman and Tony Moore didn't have time in the book to show us this, but we have all the time in the world to let these scenes and moments breathe. As much as I love comic books, one of its biggest weaknesses as a format is pacing. It's just hard to get right without overdoing it.

That said, some of the best moments in the comic are silent. Mainly because Kirkman just does not have a... knack... for writing dialogue. That was one of my biggest fears for this TV series, but they seemed to have solved the problem: re-write it.

Well done, slow cap for everyone on board. Now bring on Glenn!

Posted by: RobP at November 1, 2010 2:17 PM

This was far more gritty than I expected from non-pay cable. Kudos to AMC for letting them go that far (although from the second he eyed the horse I was begging him not to take it into harms way). I've never read the source material so I can't speak to that but in the PaddyDog household Masterpiece just got relegated to DVR in favor of this. And that's really saying something.

Posted by: PaddyDog at November 1, 2010 2:22 PM

I was really impressed by the whole thing, but one thing I was particularly impressed by was the numerous wide shots of empty, destroyed buildings and streets. That couldn't have been easy to do on the show's budget.

I'm talking about, for example, when he wanders out of the hospital and sees the helicopter and the destroyed building; then again as he's going down the highway towards Atlanta; and then, when he's in Atlanta, different streets, different angles, different levels of "zoom", all looking completely empty and destroyed. I don't know what combination of location filming, sets, and CGI was involved, but it all looked fantastic to me.

Posted by: MM at November 1, 2010 2:25 PM

Also, I find it implausible that the U.S. Army could possibly lose to a bunch of shambling, mindless corpses when they have machine guns and helicopters and everything. How could zombies stop a tank?

That was something that Max Brooks' tackled in World War Z during his fabled "Battle of Yonkers" chapter. Basically, he put the might of the US Army in full combat gear and positions as if they were fighting a regular army. When the new equipment transmitted the fear and terror of some soldiers to all, things went bad to worse. The army couldn't respond to lines breaking and the dead overran them. End result: carpet bombing as the last desperate act that let everyone know "you're fucked now!"

Posted by: Fredo at November 1, 2010 2:32 PM

It was great overall. Something about the first scene with the little girl, which I don't think is in the book, did not sit right with me. It seemed a little cheap and gratuitous. This is especially so because the focus of the book is not on the gore. Scariest moment was the walk down 10 hospital steps to the exit. That was nicely done.

Posted by: DRE at November 1, 2010 2:36 PM

Just caught it. (Had to record it while watching the football game).

I agree that it feels more like a sequel to "Night of the Living Dead" than any other movie. I liked that, although they're "zombies", no one calls them that. They're just the dead or the walkers.

I also liked that they're not idiotic dead. They still retain some semblance of basic motor skills -- open doors, kneel down, crawl. I wonder if they'll say that goes away after a while or if they'll let the dead keep their abilities.

And what happens when Rick reaches Lori and Duane, I wonder. Don't recall many zombie movies detailing that.

Posted by: Fredo at November 1, 2010 2:39 PM

BTW, I liked the little touches: how a hot shower can mean so much or how a radio signal that doesn't connect can be the difference.

Posted by: Fredo at November 1, 2010 2:46 PM

Disclaimer: I haven't read the source material. I've tried to keep in the dark about the show as much as possible so I could enjoy it.

I really enjoyed the tension of the show. I really enjoyed it overall.

Many little details really pleased me. Other little details really annoyed me.

I wrote up a long post discussing them all and realized it contained too many spoilers. Oh well. I'm going to keep watching and accept the fact that an interesting story is being told here in spite of the small things that bugged me.

Posted by: lubeg at November 1, 2010 2:53 PM

This show won me over when Rick went downstairs using matches; how can I not love that attention to detail? I mean, when I read that issue of the comics I never wondered how can you walk through dark areas like emergency stairs, that was awesome.
Also, Morgan is a lot more badass now, I'd like to see him appear more in the series

Posted by: Radlum at November 1, 2010 3:00 PM

Alright, I wasn't entirely happy with this. The look and tone of the show is fantastic, amazing special effects. But I'm almost worried that the adaptation is going to be Too close to the comic. No offense to the fans of the comic but I don't really care for seeing a replica of that plot drawn out for years. I'd love to see Darabont take at least a few liberties with the material and really make it his own.

There's ALOT that bothered me about this story. How much time supposedly passed while Rick was in the hospital? It looked like maybe a week? His wife and child ditched him in the hospital after a week? How is it possible he is the only thing in that hospital that hasn't been ravaged? Why would he stroll into a major city on a meat popsicle? That whole scene just seemed incredibly cruel. In real life the horse would have sensed predators much earlier and wouldn't have gone near that city. The silly radio voice and cutsey music playing at the end? What was that? Total tone shift for the last 2 minutes? I dont remember the exact details from the comic, but my main concern is that there aren't enough character's to kill off to satisfy my need to see the zombies in action. Zombie vs horse attack is not satisfactory.

Overall, the show was kind of a bummer- constant sadness and dumb choices. I really hope there's good progression with the characters that makes this worth sticking to.

Posted by: valerie at November 1, 2010 3:10 PM

*SOME SPOILERS but not if you read the books*
I really enjoyed. It certainly lived up to all the hype. It's pretty rare these days.

I read the first issue before I saw the show and the show was 100x better. I love the art direction. Art direction really goes unnoticed a lot of the time. I'm glad people are noticing it.

My only complaint was self-inflicted. Since I read the first issue, it kind of ruined the tension for me. Plus I totally knew that Rick would get hit with a shovel. And that he would come back to kill that half-zombie.

I planned on reading the rest of the books but now I don't think so.

Posted by: junierizzle at November 1, 2010 3:28 PM

I just saw the premiere ratings at 5.3 million, and adding in the repeat of the premiere directly after, it comes up to 8.1 million. And that's not even counting DVR numbers, I don't think.

So AMC is pretty happy with that. (Yay!)

Posted by: MM at November 1, 2010 3:49 PM

Well, it's not surprising that a group of soldiers would have a hard time holding back wave after wave of undead inside an already infected city. That other cop, Shane?, has it right by staying out in the country away from the mass population of the cities. I don't know much about how the "infection" works in this series but if it spreads and turns you into a "walker" at a decent speed, by the time the army would realize they need to lock down the city, the city's population would already be heavily infected and thus you'd have to not only control the borders but also fight hundreds of thousands of potential infected in the city itself while also exposing holes in your border to allow non-infected persons into your "safe zone". From what we saw in the show, it looked like the army was only trying to control blocks within the city and there's simply no way to do that and survive for any length of time. I would think the best way to setup any sort of "safe zone" would be to find a defensable medium sized town with ample food stores and sustainable water supply. Something bordering a fresh water lake or possibly a damned river where you can control the quality of the water and possibly use it to generate electricity. Anything other than that and you're simply creating another problem because by the time the probably is recognized as something that would cause you to isolate and protect populations by city, you would have most likely missed the opportunity to do so. This sounds cruel but the best chance the army would have at this point to setup "safe zones" and rebuild would be to pull their troops back into the bases they already have (families, food stores, electrical generation, weapons, ammunition are all available and on site in most cases) and wait until the hysteria dies. Then they could move out in an organized fashion and clean towns/villages one by one while rescuing survivors.

Other than that, it's a great show!

Posted by: Bus at November 1, 2010 3:57 PM

I liked it. It was tense rather than scary, everytime the main guy lit a match in the dark corridor I expected to see a zombie standing behind him. Also, I assume the comics pre-date 28 Days Later, otherwise the hospital scene was kind of a blatent rip off.

Posted by: Steph at November 1, 2010 4:02 PM

possibly a damned river

Best typo ever.

Posted by: MM at November 1, 2010 4:10 PM

I enjoyed it and will continue watching it but can't help being reminded of 28 Days Later. And looking at the dates 28 came earlier. I'm not saying that didnt reference or take from other things too, but the hospital scene was hard to ignore. (wouldnt the people in a coma need a catheter? They never have those in films). I love that film though and if this is half as good I'll be happy. It's nice (but weird) to see Andrew Lincoln in a big American series. I wonder how it came about.

Posted by: Carrie at November 1, 2010 5:44 PM

The scariest part of this episode for me was the peephole scene. Few words, just the dawning horror as you watch the creature slowly focus on the peephole. Short and simple, but I broke out in goosebumps.

Posted by: MaryB at November 1, 2010 5:49 PM

Wow, this is extra-eerie if you know the locations. The trash blowing on Marietta Street? I go down there for client meetings on a regular basis. The picture of Rick riding up I-85 on the horse? Even though that had to be CGI, it was pretty frickin' accurate.

I wonder where they actually filmed the "country" scenes...'cause I'd have to guess in the Newnan area if I was a betting person....

Posted by: Wednesday at November 1, 2010 6:43 PM

The pilot was simply excellent and keeps w/ the character-driven tone of the source material. I'm a fan of the series and I know what happens, but that didn't ruin a thing for me. Still plenty of tension and terror to be had.

Posted by: stryker1121 at November 1, 2010 7:22 PM

I hate zombies and I loved the show. It's that simple.

Posted by: Az at November 1, 2010 7:39 PM

It was pretty excellent. I was creeped the fuck out throughout the 90 min. My only qualms were why the fuck would you go to a city!?! Jeebus that seemed like the worst idea ever. I imagine he does it in the comics, but still.

I will be watching next week even though the southern accents were awful and the whole women don't know how to turn off lights/not say inappropriate things in front of children was annoying. Otherwise I enjoyed it and will be watching next week.

Posted by: Mebe at November 1, 2010 8:24 PM

Having read the comics, I believe they improved on the pacing, tension and scares. Excellent job. I have no idea how they are going to handle some of the serious depravity that happens later in the comics (and if they don't go as far as the comics, I for one would be pleased).

Posted by: TrickyHD at November 1, 2010 10:01 PM

Weepy during a Zombie show, I'm in.

I also enjoy all the liberties they've taken. They make perfect sense.

Posted by: Jackseppelin at November 1, 2010 10:08 PM

I've never read the comics but I really enjoyed this pilot episode. I like that there was very little that was stupid about these characters. I can understand the scene with the little girl at the beginning because you would want so desperately for her not to be a walker and maybe the fact that she picked up her toy means she's a real girl after all. Although, no matter how tempting a shower might be, I'm not so sure I would have wanted to be naked with creepy undead things roaming around. Fighting naked seems 10x worse than fighting with clothes on.
I'll most likely watch this whole series.

Posted by: king at November 1, 2010 10:34 PM

If you're going to start breaking down whether or not the army would be able to maintain control then you've already lost any suspension of disbelief so quit watching the show.
"When the new equipment transmitted the fear and terror of some soldiers to all, things went bad to worse" Posted by: Fredo at November 1, 2010 2:32 PM
What the fuck kind of equipment does the US Army have that transmits terror to other soldiers?
And the other guy that posted about the logistics breaking down, how the fuck would the lines break down due to unorganized zombies when our entire military is built around maintain supply lines under direct and organized assault by another military?

Posted by: Jack Random at November 2, 2010 1:04 AM

Great review TK. As for the show - first thing I got excited about this year.

Posted by: Sarah Barkai at November 2, 2010 3:14 AM

And the other guy that posted about the logistics breaking down, how the fuck would the lines break down due to unorganized zombies when our entire military is built around maintain supply lines under direct and organized assault by another military?
Posted by: Jack Random at November 2, 2010 1:04 AM

--------------------------------------------

Dude it's either that or the story ends within the first five minutes. Maybe Zombie stories are not for you.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at November 2, 2010 6:24 AM

Just saw the episode on DVR, and those were some hardcore zombies, like the one in the park that was basically a torso but still had facial expressions. Some people seem upset that the little girl zombie would pick up a doll, but I say it made for a better encounter. I'm hooked.

Posted by: Uriah Creep at November 2, 2010 6:30 AM

I'm addicted to the comic so I've been waiting for this with 2 parts excitement, 1 part apprehension. It was basically everything they needed to do with the pilot, establishing Rick and the dire situation outside of the hospital without trying to cram in as much as the comics do in a short space of time.
I think it ticked all my boxes but I have a feeling that getting the first episode out of the way was a bit of a 'bridge to be crossed' and now it's going to get really, REALLY good.

No doubt we won't see her in this 6-episode series but I cannot wait for Michonne....

Posted by: DeadlyMiho at November 2, 2010 6:51 AM

I don't think they screwed up the accents at all.

I've lived here for 28 years, and they sounded pretty accurate to me.

Posted by: Wednesday at November 2, 2010 8:40 AM

I don't know about the other guys but Andrew seemed to be struggling with his accent, not a deal breaker by any means just, you know, funny.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at November 2, 2010 8:44 AM

We were thrilled to hear Space Junk on this - AND we have a new double EP out (jag)

http://www.wangchung.com

Posted by: Wang Chung at November 2, 2010 10:27 AM

Watched this last night. Thought it was fantastic. The Main Squeeze was so freaked out he thought he might die from the stress. So, I think I may be watching the next 5 episodes by my lonesome.

Posted by: tamatha at November 2, 2010 11:20 AM

I loved the focus on character: what does humanity do when faced with the end of the world? My only quibble was that I want to see more of Morgan and Duane, who were just guest stars (on other sites, other commenters thought my mentioning that fact constituted an actual spoiler, so I'm guessing that, like me, they felt Morgan's story—and Lennie James' acting—was at least as compelling as Rick's). My impression from other reviewers is that there's more violence and more zombie action coming up. I wonder if the show might not have worked well as an anthology (like "Lost", the early days), where each week we had a great guest star and explored their story, with Rick as a framing device. Just an idea—pretty sure that's not happening.

I loved the tight closeups—really visceral. In general, there was a real economy with this that let us fill in the blanks (with our imagination supplying far creepier backstory than anything they could have shown us). There were a lot good choices by the production team. Some people have mentioned above the excellent establishing shots in Atlanta and outside the hospital—they told a whole story with those setups. I'm betting this show was a blast to work on, and it really shows.

Certainly there were moments when a thoughtful viewer might have quibbled with the choices (why everyone's leaving Atlanta didn't immediately make Rick turn back, why he let down his guard in the tank), but wow...it was really easy to suspend disbelief during this show, and I'm not a fan of the genre.

Some days...TV makes me happy.

Posted by: Val Vadynia at November 2, 2010 12:21 PM

ok so here it my thing.... did you have to kill the horse. do what ever you want to people i will not give a damn but why the horse. now i will have to watch this show by myself

Posted by: supergwarr at November 2, 2010 5:52 PM

i just finished the 2nd episode. overall, a decent show, but not great. too many little problems popping up, making for annoying watching:

we're in the south, a big city, and most of the dead are white. is it b/c the producers think white people make creepier looking zombies?

the survivors are predictable tv types--pretty women, 99% white, everyone seemingly well educated and well spoken and, overall, pretty bland.

adding more zombies to scenes, lurching around in crowds on the streets, lowers the creep value tremendously.

dead people don't have a lot of blood left in them to splatter.

lastly: if there were more moments like the encounter between the sheriff and the corpse in the park, i'd be far more creeped out.

Posted by: ariel at November 19, 2010 8:48 AM