web
counter
 

"Game Of Thrones" - "Baelor"

By TK | Posted Under TV Reviews | Comments (50)



baelor2.jpg

“Baelor,” the ninth episode of “Game Of Thrones,” is the episode that I’ve been dreading from the very beginning of this series. Not because I worried that it wouldn’t be good — in fact, it was brilliant. But because I knew that it would come. Those of us that have been cursed by Martin’s novels have all been expecting this moment, with a mix of anticipation and dismay. Because it was at this moment, despite all of the violence and bloodlust and tragedy that passed in the previous episodes, that we truly realize that there can be no happy endings. That the path that lies ahead for these characters that we’ve grown to love is a path that can, at any moment, lead to a cliff and will end in tragedy.

Of course, I speak of the fate of Ned Stark. It was beautifully filmed, and conveyed every nuance and sense of terror and awfulness that it should have. Even knowing how it would end, I found myself foolishly hoping for an eleventh hour rescue, some desperate act that would spring Ned free. Instead, we’re left with twin terrors — the sight of perhaps the noblest man in the kingdom falling victim to such a terrible fate, and the knowledge that his daughters were there to watch. It was everything it should be, but all of it was grim and horrible.

It was an episode laden with horror, though. The plight of Daenerys and Drogo grows more dire, and the realization that Drogo’s condition is worsening forces Daenerys to take desperate measures. The show developed their relationship with deftness and poignancy, and the evolution from Daenerys as sacrificial prize, sobbing on her wedding night, to young queen, to a truly beloved wife, has been remarkable to observe. Emilia Clarke has proven herself to be one of the more capable actresses in the show, and it should be fascinating to see how their journey continues.

As for Robb and the bannermen of Winterfell? His growth into not just a leader, but a warlord, has been equally admirable. Gone is the uncertain teenager, and for better or worse, a man forced to make hard decisions remains. Having Catelyn there as an observer makes that transformation all the more powerful and affecting, and Michelle Fairley continues to develop the character into an able player in this game. It’s interesting how, over time, even the most unlikable of characters — Fairley’s Catelyn, Lena Headey’s Cersei, Sophie Turner’s Sansa, Richard Madden’s Robb and even Kit Harrington’s Jon Snow — have all emerged as capable, if not excellent portrayals. They may have started out weakly, but they’ve grown stronger. Sophie Turner, in particular, continues to show better range than before, and her comforting looks at her father, coupled with her hopeful little half-smile at the detestable Joffrey (my God has Jack Gleeson owned that thankless part), made her final shrieks of confusion and fear all the more stirring.

If there were favorite scenes to be had that wasn’t steeped in tragedy, it was unsurprisingly the ones that featured Tyrion. I’m almost getting tired of burying Dinklage in praise, but what the hell — he was fantastic once again, bouncing effortlessly between insouciant Imp, helpless tool, and determined, intelligent game player. Yet a healthy amount of praise should be directed towards the writers, for creating a brand new scene that was actually one of the best of the show. While I missed hearing Shae’s best line from the novel (“my name is Shae, and men call me… often”), her introduction was a winning combination of sultry and seductive, but also intelligent and damned interesting. The drinking game between her, Tyrion and Bronn was an excellent way to learn some of their respective histories, including Tyrion’s nightmarish tale of love and romance. The writers of the series have drafted some solid new scenes (absent the “Rose The Expository Whore” scenes, which at times grow tiresome), and this was perhaps the best.

But that scene was the lone source of bittersweet joy in this episode. It was sixty minutes of grim, determined buildup, culminating in a moment that likely stunned many viewers. There aren’t many well-known actors in “Game Of Thrones,” and they just beheaded arguably one of the biggest names (poor Sean Bean — destined for tragic, yet noble deaths. RIP, Boromir). “Baelor” was another episode full of excellent moments, and is one of the few episodes that I have no criticism of. Jon Snow learning about Maester Aemon and the bequeathing of Longclaw were, if anything, moments I wish could have been longer, but that’s hardly a negative. It was an episode filled with blood and tragedy, and I haven’t even been able to address all of the excellent parts (Mormont! Kicking ass!). But of course, there is terrible news, my friends.

There’s only one episode left.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



The Avengers Promo Poster | Stop. . .Talking. Al Bundy And Rob Lowe Prove They Should Never Go Off Book









Comments

I've purposely delayed watching this episode. Ugh. I'll probably watch it tonight, but it's like going to the dentist for a root canal. I just want it to be over with so I can get on with my life.

And there are several more moments I am dreading as the show progresses through the coming books. What a fantastic series that it elicits such raw emotion from my cold, dead soul.

Posted by: Kballs at June 14, 2011 12:29 PM

TK, On this penultimate review I would like to thank you for taking the time to help walk us newbies through this show. I don't think I really got all the names straight until this episode. At times I wish you would go into more detail about actual events in the episode (The stuff at the Wall mostly went over my head this week. What was the significance of the old blind guy?), but I'm glad you haven't turned these pieces into play-by-play walkthroughs. *Cough*Dr. Who*Cough*.

Cheers.

Posted by: the_wakeful at June 14, 2011 12:31 PM

I wish I could give the entire cast and casting director a great big hug for all the great work they've done. If I could personally hand out Emmys one would go to Peter Dinklage (Tyrion) and one would go to Miltos Yeromelou (Syrio)

Also the writers for doing such a great job of bringing the books to life. I just finished the second book and am now in the middle of the third. I am looking forward to season 2, and hopefully 3.

I can't wait to see the finale. I think I know what the last scene will be.

Posted by: John W at June 14, 2011 12:31 PM

I convinced my wife to read the books, she's about 1/4 the way into the 2nd. Needless to say after Ned's death she kept asking me who's going to go next.

It's tough getting attached to a character, only to have them die. That is what makes this series, Martin's work, so good, and I thought that Baelor was the best episode thus far, despite the fact that many viewers have lamented the lack of battle scenes. The later to my mind is actually beneficial, as Robb said, "This war is far from over."

Posted by: JS at June 14, 2011 12:35 PM

I hung my head when I realized that this would be THE episode. It was executed (no pun intended, I assure you) perfectly. Sansa's screams and Arya with her head still, forced to watch the birds fly overhead; it was beautifully tragic. It was rough, to be sure. When a work of fiction makes you want to pull out your heart and marinate it in a bowl of Jack Daniels while crying bitterly, THAT'S some amazing storytelling right there.

On a slightly more positive note, I nearly forgot about Tyrion's sad tale of love and loss. I'm so very glad they put that in there. I can't get tired of praising Dinklage. When an actor owns a role so COMPLETELY, when they are just that engaging, that's damn near a miracle. Skills like that don't come around every day.

The real tragedy in all of this is that it looks like we have to wait a whole year for Clash of Kings. *Sob*

Posted by: Kala at June 14, 2011 12:38 PM

@the_wakeful **Book Spoilers Ahead**

The old blind guy Aemon Targaryen was brother of the Aegon Targaryen one of the former Kings of the Iron Throne. He could had been the King but refused the throne and chose to serve the Night Watch instead.

He was explaining to Jon Snow how hard it is to sit idly by, as a member of the Watch has to do, when one's family is suffering.

Jon Snow realizes that Master Aemon had to stand by and do nothing as his family, the Targaryens, were slain at the hands of the Lannisters in the name of Robert the King.

Posted by: John W at June 14, 2011 12:42 PM

I'm finding this show heartbreaking, but I can't stop watching it. Not now. I was absolutely teary at Ned's death, but it shouldn't have come as a surprise. It did, but it shouldn't have. I too was hoping for some last-minute savior. Haven't read the books yet, but they are definitely going on my list.

And how long before season 2 airs? Another year maybe?? Too long!

Posted by: cydeleida at June 14, 2011 12:42 PM

What was the significance of the old blind guy?

He was the brother of the Mad King and was a rightful heir to the throne. But he had taken the Black instead of the throne and had to be neutral while his family was murdered.

Posted by: Paultera at June 14, 2011 12:44 PM

@ the_wakeful:

The old blind guy is Maester Aemon. He was sworn to the Citadel and the wall years and years and years ago (in the books I believe he is over 100 years old). What we find out in his episode is that he is Aemon Targaryen. The Mad King Aerys was his grandnephew. He is related to Daenerys. Technically she is not the last of the Targaryens. He swore never to take the throne and when you swear to the Wall, you say you will hold no lands or titles.

Posted by: jmd at June 14, 2011 12:44 PM

It took me until somewhere in Book 3 to finally come to grips with Ned's death. I simply couldn't believe he actually died. It was harder to watch than it was to read, especially seeing the pain in Arya's eyes as the birds fluttered overhead. I had my hands over my face the whole time, and was peeking from between two fingers.

Posted by: Kolby at June 14, 2011 12:51 PM

Having Tyrion get knocked out right before the battle was an amusing way to not have to actually SHOW the battle. I was a bit disappointed by how they revealed Robb's plan, though. I liked the book better, where they fight the battle, win, and then even Tywin is surprised when they find out Robb wasn't even there and he's off attacking Jaime.

And I'm surprised they haven't even mentioned Roose Bolton yet.

I didn't mind the change (at least I think it was a change) of having Ned point out Arya to what's-his-name.

I COULD NOT BELIEVE one of the scenes they showed, albeit very briefly, in the preview for next time, though. I'm not even going to hint at what it was, it irritated me so much as a spoiler (and I say that as someone who has read all the books and knows what's going to happen).

Posted by: Todd at June 14, 2011 12:55 PM

My bad, I could have sworn I heard him say he was his brother.

Posted by: Paultera at June 14, 2011 1:00 PM

Kickass recap, TK.

There are no words that can capture the emotions I felt at the end of the hour. This show is so well done, I felt like one of Ned's daughters, myself--and also, a mother--wanting to take Arya in my arms and console her along with myself. I've been walking around, reliving Arya's heartbreaking glances skyward.

I never expected it. In fact, while watching, even though I was shocked when Joffrey called for Ned's head, I felt confident there would be a save. Was it Arya who would rush with her sword, even just causing enough of a ruckus for an escape? Maybe Sansa would throw herself in front of her father? But no, there was nothing. Just those awful moments and I thought I couldn't go on.

I have so much praise for almost all the actors on this show, but especially for the young people - these kids are just blowing me away. And Sean Bean will be sorely missed.

Posted by: Cindy at June 14, 2011 1:07 PM

Even knowing what was coming didn't take away the shock of seeing it.

And I'm terrifically glad they wrote in Shae and didn't make Ros into some composite character. They did change up Shae a bit...I remember her as being less mysterious and more low-class...but I don't mind the change as long as her role remains the same.

Posted by: Wednesday at June 14, 2011 1:07 PM

I, too, liked the touch of having Ned point out Arya to Yoren. It wasn't in the book, but it could have happened. We only see the execution from Arya's perspective, so we really don't know if Ned had a chance to point her out to Yoren of it Yoren just spotted her himself.

Ned's death scene was fantastic. Very powerful. Wonderfully shot and acted. I did like having him spot Arya and sending Yoren to go get her. Her reaction was great, as was Sansa's. Excellent all around.

I liked both the scene where the Old Bear gives Jon Longclaw and Maester Aemon's speech. I thought both were well done. It's great to see some of these characters from the book really starting to take form on screen. Catelyn is another. At first, I wasn't convinced, but over the last two or three episodes the actress has really become her. Same with the guy playing Robb.

The actress playing Dany has also been fantastic. I liked the fight with Jorah and the dothraki, it really hit home the point that Jorah was making a few episodes earlier about how the dothraki weapon really isn't all that effective while on foot and fighting a guy in platemail.

Tyrion's recounting of his marriage was great. Shae is fantastic. She has really captured the essence of the character. The fact that she's a foreigner is beside the point. Bronn also continues to shine. He's given some great lines and has been great in the role.

I wasn't expecting to see any of the battles, so I wasn't disappointed. There was no way, from a budget and time perspective, that they could have done them any justice. Better to skip them entirely than do something weird or on the cheap. I take any battles/fight scenes as bonuses. But, even then, unless there is something exceptional (like Drogo's) or important (Syrio's last stand, Jamie attacking Ned), about a fight scene then they aren't too terribly necessary. That said, it would have been nice to see Greywind run out of the woods first when Catelyn was waiting for Robb or at least have him running along side Robb.

Posted by: Forbiddendonut at June 14, 2011 1:07 PM

I thought we were avoiding book spoilers? Some of us have just begun reading...

Posted by: Cindy at June 14, 2011 1:10 PM

That was an expertly crafted scene. For a show that ocassionally is up to it's armpits in blood and gore it was remarkably restrained and heightened the emotional beats while minimizing the gratuitous violence. I'm about 50 pages from his execution in the book, but even before I started reading I was certain Ned had to die before this was over. First, because I couldn't see Sean Bean hanging around. But also because his death is the turning point it seems. With Ned gone Robb is no longer playing war in his absence but is now the true Lord of Winterfell.

From here forward Winterfell is not going to stop until they win or until they die. Joffrey's maddening arrogance has doomed the entire kingdom to war. I have no idea what happens next but I hope it ends with the horribly painful death of Joffrey at the hands of Sansa. For the first time I'm getting a glimpse of where they are taking Sansa as a character and I have a feeling she is going to have a worse time of it than Daenerys.

Posted by: TylerDFC at June 14, 2011 1:12 PM

This one was... emotional... for sure.
Even knowing what was coming, the final few minutes still knocked me on my ass.

The deviations from the book in any of the episodes haven't bothered me up to this point, given how well they've managed this adaptation overall (I'm very impressed), but I really wish in this one that they had found a better way to handle Tyrion's part in the Battle of the Green Fork.
I understand that they can't bring every scene to the screen due to budget limits, but having him trampled by his own men and knocked out before the battle even began was just SO different than what happens in the book.
But that's my only hang-up. Overall, I remain impressed with the job they've done with this series. The hiatus will be tough to bear. However, I'm re-reading the books, and since I took a break part-way through book 3 the first time, I still have a good bit of new discovery to look forward to while I wait.

Posted by: Rykker at June 14, 2011 1:13 PM

I knew that Ned would die when I started the books and it still gutted me when I read it. Seeing it on screen had no less of an effect. Arya trying to push through the crowd, the sound dropping out, the resigned look on Ned's face, the birds... I'm wrecked all over again just thinking about it.

I'm glad we got to see more of Maester Aemon and I'm really impressed with Richard Madden’s Robb. He's grabbing me more than the character did on the page.

Tyrion and Bronn were perfect together, as usual.

Posted by: jM at June 14, 2011 1:16 PM

Loved loved LOVED this episode. I had figured out long ago how this and the next episode had to end (though the latter has yet to be proven yet). I've been watching with my fiance, TheMaskedEmu, who has not finished the books. So I spent this episode desperately trying not to give anything away facially. His reaction to the identity of Maester Aemon was awesome and well worth my silence.

I agree, there were a couple of little things I would have liked out of the battles (understanding that they couldn't show them all for budget and time). Tyrion getting knocked out by his own men before it started was disheartening. And I wanted Grey Wind with Robb somewhere, maybe snarling at Jaime. But those are small potatoes when the rest of the episode was so incredible.

I feel like one of the best developed relationships has been Dany and Drogo, and this week was a perfect example of that. Emilia Clarke is going to continue doing great things with this role, I can tell.

Watching the inevitable end of Noble Ned was so hard. In the book, I actually refused to believe it because it's told from Arya's perspective and she doesn't see it. It wasn't till chapters later that I realized it had really happened. This time there was no denying it. And Arya and Sansa were PERFECT. My heart broke into pieces for them.

One week to go and I want to say thank you, TK for these wonderful reviews! This is the most vocal I've been on the site...um...ever. Keep it up!

Posted by: KatSings at June 14, 2011 1:25 PM

Holy shit. I never get emotional for television shows...but I've been holding back the waterworks for ten minutes. I can't get that scene out of my head.

I'm glad my 'rents weren't here to see me screaming, "NOOOOO!" at the top of my lungs at my computer screen...


(I haven't read the books yet...*sob*sob*)

Posted by: Candee at June 14, 2011 1:29 PM

AND apparently Sean Bean is a bad ass in real life:

http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/43395782/ns/today-entertainment/t/game-thrones-actor-stabbed-bar-brawl/?fb_ref=story_header&fb_source=home_multiline

So if I understand correctly, he got in a fight (presumably something to do with the lady), got a shiner and stabbed in the arm, only to order a drink immediately afterward?

Don't fuck with Boromir.

Posted by: Kala at June 14, 2011 1:35 PM

Hey, the_wakeful. Friendly tip: if you don't like it, don't read it. Alternatively, go write your own Doctor Who reviews. I appreciate the feedback, though. I try to give my awful play-by-play walkthroughs a little entertainment throughout. I'm not interested in delivering traditional critique. Sorry if they aren't your thing.

Posted by: C. Robert Dimitri at June 14, 2011 1:50 PM

I agree with Rykker- my only gripe was Tyrion's "roll" in the battle. I thought the scene in the book showed the fierceness in the Imp, that he is more than a schemer, and he is definitely not craven. This was more comedic than anything.

Otherwise, an excellent ep.

Posted by: logar at June 14, 2011 1:53 PM

I wonder how people that have never read the books will relate to Ned "the hero" being killed so soon? Will it turn them off or keep them glued?

Very good episode.

Posted by: logan at June 14, 2011 2:03 PM

I was a bit confused by the Tyrion battle sequence.

Were we to assume that he got knocked out by that hammer/maul thing, never woke up and missed the entire battle? Or was that just a convenient "cut" to the post-battle scene, with the assumption being that he got up at some point, made it to the battlle, fought in the battle only to get knocked out again? (which is closer to what happened in the book.)

It looked like he was a little more dirtied and beat up and bloodied post-battle than he would have been if he had just gotten knocked out.

Posted by: Forbiddendonut at June 14, 2011 2:04 PM

He wasn't just knocked out. He was also trampled

Posted by: Minto at June 14, 2011 2:07 PM

I haven't read the books yet, so I was taken completely by surprise when it actually happened. I kept thinking someone, something, was going to sweep in and save him. He's the lead, I thought, they can't kill him! And then Arya started rushing the platform, I thought to kill Joffrey, and I was yelling at my TV "Yeah Arya! Stab that little shit in the face!"

And then Yoren stepped in front of her, and held her tight, and I knew it was going to happen. And the way it grew quiet, and the small moments that followed, were perfect. Ned looking at the statue and no longer seeing Arya (with a mixture of relief and sadness, I feel certain), Sansa and even the detestable Cersei yelling at Joffrey that was he was doing was wrong, the vile glee on his evil face, Ned slowly bowing his head and praying to his gods as the sword descended, the decency of the camera cutting away before his head actually fell, the birds taking flight and the look of absolute desolation on Arya's face...God but it was moving.

And friggin' Daenerys...every week I marvel at how strong she's become. I can't wait to see how far she'll climb. Again, I haven't read the books, so this might be a pipe dream, but I hope she routs the Lannisters and turns them into horse food. Or better yet, dragon chow.

Posted by: JustBill at June 14, 2011 2:07 PM

Great review as always, TK. You hit all the high points. I loved the scene between Aemon and Jon, and the Tyrion drinking game was a clever addition.

The end was rendered wonderfully and tragically. I tried (and failed) to convince my boss that it was not a narrative cheat and that the story is worth continuing, but he was intent on the rule that you do not kill off your protagonist like that nine episodes into the series. I told him he was operating under a misconception as to the identity of the protagonist(s) in this story. It is a natural arc that makes sense, and this tale only gets better.

I don't mind the omission of Robb's battle. We only learn about it in the book from similar description. I do have a problem with the lack of battle for Tyrion for reasons I will not discuss to avoid even mild spoilers.

My recurring regret echoed above already: where was GREY WIND?!? Would it have been that difficult to have him running from the forest next to Robb? I guess Grey Wind did not make the difference in battle that he did in the book. We'll see if these direwolves actually ever reach full-grown size. Perhaps the effects budget in season two can cover it.

Posted by: DarthCorleone at June 14, 2011 2:09 PM

When I read this scene in the book I was devastated. I instantly flipped quickly through the rest of the book to see if there was another chapter told from Ned's POV in case I misread. Alas there was nothing.

The scene in the show was masterful. Sean Bean looks confused, betrayed, hurt, and worried for his children all at once. Bean is an amazing actor and I absolutely love him in this role.

Posted by: greenblue at June 14, 2011 2:18 PM

They can kill every character in this story, but if they kill Arya, I will find George RR Martin and kill him.

Posted by: John G. at June 14, 2011 2:32 PM

Durrrrr. Last visit to this site. Cue your heartbroken states.

Posted by: Gitley at June 14, 2011 2:48 PM

Don't kill him until he finishes the books please.

Posted by: danielrandkai at June 14, 2011 2:50 PM

The moment I saw the title of the episode I knew what was going to happen. All the same, they've managed to wrench every bit of emotion out of Ned's fate -- between Sansa's desperate pleas and Arya's plight (who knew she'd be using her dancing skills to feed herself?)

I did miss the end of Tyrion's story and I hope it's introduced sometime next season (or maybe the one after that). It's too tragic and horrific to not make the show.

My one plea to HBO: 13 episodes in Season 2! You're going to need them! We're going to go all over the map next season and add major new characters (Stannis, Melisandre, Davos, Balon, Qhorin, Mace and Margaery Tyrell, Breanne, the long-missing Brynden). This needs room to breathe in order to work.

Posted by: Fredo at June 14, 2011 2:52 PM

Buh-BYE, Gitley.
Good riddance.

Posted by: Rykker at June 14, 2011 3:04 PM

Fredo:
One of the producers of GoT has released a statement that season two will follow the same 10 episode format. He said that because filming is pretty grueling, adding a few more episodes would likely cause the writing and performances to suffer.

That said, where has been Renly Baratheon been since the knob job he received from Knight of the Flowers? I gather he's assembling a rebel army to overthrow Prince, erm King douchewazzle? Do the Lannisters consider the potential threat he brings to J-dog?

As livid as I was a number of weeks ago when someone made the heartbreaking reveal of Ned's fate on this site, it was necessary for me to know ahead of time. While I enjoy the occasional surprise, I can not bear when the protagonist suffers a fatal blow (mentally, emotionally or physically) -- not to mention a protagonist who is so universally loved and serves as a moral compass in a shit-filled sea. I was dreading this episode, and had to watch it a few times to know what happened bc I just got up and left two times in a row I was so upset. When I finally made it through I was crying uncontrollably. I don't remember crying that hard since whoever it was that died in Backdraft (yeah...I was like 6). Ultimately I think it has everything to do with the kind good natured father figure that he was. Sonofabitch that Al Swearagen was, I fancied him a bit of a fatherly figure as well, and if he'd died I would have thrown my tv out the window.

I understand that many of the non book-saavy viewers of the show are so outraged at Bean's departure they're threatening not to come back. I myself have yet to read the books, and while I will truly miss Bean's presence, I remain hopeful that a strong, respectable and reliable type figure will take his place. With all of the chaos, I think there has to be some degree of balance -- the presence of some true good, otherwise I could see it getting thrown way off balance.

Sorry for writing a book here, folks.

Posted by: beet salad at June 14, 2011 5:39 PM

That said, where has been Renly Baratheon been since the knob job he received from Knight of the Flowers? I gather he's assembling a rebel army to overthrow Prince, erm King douchewazzle? Do the Lannisters consider the potential threat he brings to J-dog?

Actually that follows the book closely. Renly makes the offer to Ned so he can get his support for the throne. When Ned refuses him, he runs south with Loras Tyrell. Next thing you know, it's Book 2[edited for spoilers -TK]

beet salad, I hear you. On the central character figure, a few do kind of step up (Jon, Dany, Robb). Just know that it's not an easy journey for anyone and least of all for them.

Posted by: Fredo at June 14, 2011 5:43 PM

No, NO, NOOOOO!!!!!

That's what I yelled at the TV at the end of the episode.

But as much as I was so sad to see the end of Ned (and Sean Bean), the unpredictability of the plot is one of the many things I love about this show.

And count me among the admirers of Peter Dinklage's performance, but I have to ask: Does his accent seem a bit off to anyone else? I'm an American, so I really can't say, but his accent never sounds quite right to me.

Posted by: jimbob at June 14, 2011 5:48 PM

@jimbob

I thought so as well! But I'm also American so I figured it was just me. It seems to have gotten better than the first episode...but honestly, I have no idea where he's from anyway.

Posted by: Candee at June 14, 2011 5:58 PM

I'm hoping the success of this season allows for a budget next season to embellish some of the battles. I want to see Beric vs the Mountain!

Posted by: Cory at June 14, 2011 6:59 PM

I have to admit that I read a synopsis of this episode before viewing. So I knew what was coming. While it is disappointing to see that Lord Stark was killed, I am glad that it wasn't a surprise. I wouldn't have gotten any sleep at all after that! Now I am left wondering who the he'll else will be killed off. But that does make a really great story. And I suppose if I wanted a happy ending I would go watch something stupid...like Ever After.

Posted by: MRod at June 14, 2011 7:58 PM

I started reading the books about a month ago and I can't put them down. Seriously, if you are just watching and haven't read the books...go read them. They are so well done. I read the first book in 2 days. Ah-MAZING!!! So much detail. I am in the second book now. I love this world that Martin made.

Posted by: swellegant at June 14, 2011 8:00 PM

Thank you, HBO for exceeding my expectations.

And I shall Joffrey, "King Nellie Olsen" from now on.


*look up the TV series, "Little House on the Prairie"*

Posted by: pkittie at June 14, 2011 9:25 PM

TK, excellent write-ups. Well done. I think you know how much I look forward to them, but in case you're a touch feeble and you haven't picked up on it from my whining to you, I LOVE THEM and I love this show. Thank you for getting me excited to watch it (and now to read the books).

This episode totally threw me for a loop. I really didn't see it coming. In retrospect, I don't know *how* I didn't see it, but I didn't. I was sobbing like a child and yelling "NOOOO" at my tv and yet, it happened anyway. Ugh. Ripped my heart out. And as much as I loved Ned and I'm sad to see him go, I rather like knowing that they're not kidding when they say "When you play the Game of Thrones you win or you die. There is no middle ground." That level of stakes makes it that much more involving and makes me appreciate just how dangerous their lives are ALL the time.

I'm about halfway through the first book now and Ned's fate has definitely colored the way I'm reading it going forward. I'll miss Sean Bean and I'll miss Ned's interaction with Arya the most, but I'm excited to keep reading & to watching the final episode.

Posted by: Lainey at June 14, 2011 9:31 PM

I think this is the strongest episode yet. I did miss Tyrion telling the very end of his story though. It's that bit that pushed the whole thing over the edge for me and... well. Enough said.

I'll miss Sean Bean cause he's a great actor, but Ned Stark really isn't the protagonist at all. He was just a moral compass and a way for us to experience the grim reality of Westeros, where being noble and just isn't always enough. These people are ruthless.

"A Song of Ice and Fire" (the story cycle) doesn't abide by the normal rules of fiction though. Characters you like (heroes and villains both) will die and/or have truly horrible things happen to them. This is not a story that you'll be able to easily predict.

@John W: I think I know what the final scene of the season will be, too. Crackle. Hiss. Hint hint. ;)

Posted by: foolsage at June 14, 2011 10:19 PM

Re: the end of Tyrion's story...

I could speculate why they omitted it. I've read some Internet discussion claiming that last detail pushes Tyrion too far into the unlikable end of the spectrum after such a sympathetic tale. In order to fully discuss it, though, you really need to know the entire story, and that is definitely a spoiler for those who have not read the books. Of course, Tyrion was only 16, and the television Tyrion himself says that he was a stupid kid, so he probably deserves a little leeway.

Posted by: DarthCorleone at June 14, 2011 11:20 PM

If Dinklage is denied the Emmy I will throw a crystal bowl through my television set.

Posted by: Maryscott O'Connor at June 15, 2011 12:19 AM


And count me among the admirers of Peter Dinklage's performance, but I have to ask: Does his accent seem a bit off to anyone else? I'm an American, so I really can't say, but his accent never sounds quite right to me.

It doesn't matter if you're American or not. No one knows what all the proper accents of Westeros are, so there is no way for Dinklage to get it wrong.

Posted by: John G. at June 15, 2011 1:52 AM

I had a feeling Ned was going to die. I mean, I read up on Martin and he said he will kill off a main character whenever to give his story more of a thrill, because that way the reader can never feel safe and comfortable when a character is put anywhere remotely close to danger.

Anyhow, I just did not expect Ned to get so cheesed. I was hoping he would stand up to Jeoffery and spit in his face, or call him out for the little inbred bastard that he is. You know, so he could have died with dignity. But nope, he took it up the ass, and then across the neck.

Poor, poor Ned.

Posted by: Muteki at June 15, 2011 9:38 AM

C. Robert Dimitri, I like the Doctor Who reviews. Don't change a thing.

Posted by: BWeaves at June 15, 2011 10:55 AM