free counter with statistics "Doctor Who," Series One | Pajiba - Scathing Reviews for Bitchy People

_42714689_rose_doc9_tardis300.jpg
Bad Wolf


"Doctor Who," Series One / Steven Lloyd Wilson

TV Reviews | May 27, 2009 | Comments (59)


“I’m a Time Lord. I’m the last of the Time Lords. They’re all gone. I’m the only survivor. I’m left traveling on my own, ‘cause there’s no one else.” —The Doctor

The original “Doctor Who” ran on the BBC for 26 consecutive years, accumulating over 700 episodes from 1963 to 1989. The series is so old that many of its earliest episodes have been lost, victims of the BBC’s policy of “junking” during the 1970s, in which old footage was wiped and the tapes reused or destroyed. The BBC has only managed to recover about half of the episodes from the show’s first six seasons, relying in part on homemade 8mm films of the television screen. Steampunk TiVo.

The show’s original run finally bowed out in 1989, after putting essentially every record related to a show’s longevity well out of any challenger’s reach. Other than a failed attempt to restart the show with a television movie in 1996, it stayed off the air until Russell T. Davies resurrected it in the spring of 2005. A bit of a Britishism, along with torches, fags, and tossers: a “season” in America is a “series” in the UK. So what the civilized world calls season one, season two, is series one, series two in Londontown.

The series begins by introducing Rose Tyler (Billie Piper), a London shop girl confronted with an uprising by her store’s suddenly murderous mannequins. The Doctor (Christopher Eccleston) arrives in a whirlwind of action and words, telling Rose to run for her life, and blows up the entire building. Rose and her soon to be erstwhile boyfriend Mickey uncover evidence of the Doctor’s presence throughout history, photos of him on the Titanic and such. Adventure ensues, explosions, saving the world. The Doctor offers Rose a place by his side, traveling in time and space. The shopgirl becomes something more.

The Doctor and Rose anchor the first series, their relationship evolving over the course of the 13 episodes from simple companionship, to something close to romantic, to that easy camaraderie of those who have fought side by side. “Doctor Who” tends to have only very loose season-long plots, allowing each individual episode (or pair of episodes in the case of two-parters) to function as more or less stand-alone stories. The over-arching story of the first series is the growth of Rose from something of a tourist tagging along with the mysterious Doctor into a full actor in the great events. The genius of the character development is that Rose does not become more powerful, or blessed with some macguffin of plot relevance. Her evolution is in realizing that she matters just as she is. Simple shopgirls can not only save the world, they are the only ones who ever do so.

That simple celebration and appreciation of what it means to be human, to be normal, is the heart of “Doctor Who,” an almost oxymoronic theme for a show that explores just how unimaginably vast the universe truly is. Time and again, it is the small things that matter. The series is interspersed with small tragedies and triumphs, grounding the stories in a more human context than the grandiose tales of the end of the world that it also features. Captain Jack tells the desperate volunteers to aim for the Daleks’ eyes to give them hope, though he knows full well that nothing they do will have any effect. A Dalek opens its murderous steel body so that it feels the sun on its withered body before dieing. The Doctor tweaks Rose’s cell phone so that she can call her mother, no matter where or when she happens to be. Rose saves the life of her father, killed by a car when she was very young, sees him for the man he was, not the hero but the small schemer, the cheater, sees him redeemed by dieing to prevent the paradox from ripping apart the world. That focus on the miniscule, even in the midst of the enormous, gives the lives of the characters a wrenching urgency. Common people caught up in a great storm.

The series exults in the hugeness of the universe, not stripping it down like so much science fiction does to its own fault. Infinite life and variety scattered over millions upon millions of years. It is a show that thinks big, holding up the vastness of time and space not to emphasize our particular insignificance so much as to chide our small-mindedness when such immensity waits to be explored. The appreciation of vastness is wrapped up with the show’s dedication to the Doctor as the scientist. He’s not mystical or magical, and while the show ofttimes relies a bit much on the technobabble, it is centered on the idea that the Doctor’s power comes from knowledge, from rational tinkering with the way things work. He’s the pinnacle of science, the point at which there are no more dark gaps left in which superstition can hide.

Rose and the Doctor form a dichotomy, the two sides playing off each other as a complementary pair. Finite vs. infinite, young vs. old, common vs. otherworldly. It works in both directions, avoiding the trap of the one way street. Rather than worshipping the Doctor as the adored solution to every problem, or letting Rose provide the down home wisdom that saves the day, the series focuses on the opposite interplay. The Doctor is obsessed with the common everyday world of small mortals, whilst being almost blind to the wonders of his travel. Rose cannot see the value of the common while she falls in love with adventure in time and space. Instead of the two characters arguing for their own perspective, the story allows each to prove the other’s worth. The finale brings that dichotomy full circle: Rose sees the turn of the universe, the Doctor tastes mortality.

The other characters are fantastic, to borrow the Doctor’s favorite exclamation. Camille Coduri plays Rose’s mother Jackie as a wonderfully dysfunctional wannabe cougar, who is nonetheless almost psychotically protective of her daughter. Noel Clarke’s Mickey grows over the course of two series from a boy too scared to travel with the Doctor to a universe-hopping soldier. John Barrowman revels in the spectacularly grandiose Captain Jack Harkness for almost half the season. He’s all id, an irrepressibly joyous font of sex and violence, who (as is later noted on his spin off “Torchwood”) is neither gay nor straight but will “shag anything if it’s gorgeous enough.” And with those well constructed characters, humor emerges amongst the tragedies organically as with the best fiction of Whedon and Gilliam.

The nuanced nobility of the Doctor slowly is drawn out over the course of the series. He is terribly sad, clutching a darkness that won’t be dispelled, more than willing to kill if absolutely necessary, though a quiet reluctance underlies even his vicious moments. There’s a disbelieving joy in Eccleston’s performance when things go right, as if he no longer believes victory is possible without gut wrenching lost: “Everybody lives, Rose! Just this once! Everybody lives!”

We learn of the Time War gradually, in references and bits of half-heard dialog, in the reverent awe accorded the Doctor by those who know his story. Picture a war fought between good and evil using time travel across all of time and space. Entire civilizations snuffed out before they evolved past microbes. Picture the power and grief of a man who single-handedly wins such a war, but in doing so destroys his own side as well as the enemy. All his friends and family dead. Everything that ever existed of his civilization gone. A man who can live forever, can travel anywhere in time or space. Anywhere but home.

Home can be a simple shopgirl.

“You know what they call me in the ancient legends of the Dalek homeworld? The Oncoming Storm. You might have removed all your emotions, but I reckon right down deep in your DNA there’s one little spark left. And that’s fear. Doesn’t it just burn when you face me?” — The Doctor


Steven Lloyd Wilson is the last scion of Norse warriors and the forbidden elder gods. He is a hopeless romantic who can be found wandering San Diego’s strip malls and suburbs looking for his mislaid soul and waiting for the revolution to come. Burning Violin is still published weekly on Wednesdays at www.burningviolin.com, along with assorted fiction and other ramblings.


Pajiba Love 05/27/09 | The Matrix Review



Comments

Talk about the rest of the seasons!
I love love LOVE Doctor Who. I didn't watch it much as a kid (unlike my girlfriend) so I consider Eccleston my "first doctor." My heart still lies with him, though I think Tenant did a brilliant job.
Such good writing and brilliant one-liners. And the entire show is just so engaging. I didn't know I liked sci-fi until I just couldn't stop watching this. It's freaking amazing.
Review the rest of the seasons, along with Torchwood!

Posted by: Sharon at May 27, 2009 2:08 PM

I started watching the reboot having never seen the original and my entire family absolutely adores the show. Rose is my kids favorite character.

One things I love about the show is the way that things are referenced subtly throughout the shows. Something that's done in an early episode may get referenced again either later in the season, or even two seasons later.

Still searching to see if I can find the old series just for comparison sake.

At least it's ONE thing that Hollywood hasn't tried to Americanize. Let's hope it stays that way!

Posted by: UncleJR at May 27, 2009 2:12 PM

I started watching the reboot

Actually it's not a reboot. It's the same show, entirely in continuity and canon.

Posted by: Jay at May 27, 2009 2:20 PM

Aye, Doctor Who is a great show, one that really captures the imagination and is rife with endless possibilities.

So it almost doesn't matter that the last couple of seasons/series have kind of lagged a bit, even downright sucked. While still making the most of exploring that vast universe of theirs, I think that the Producer/Head Writer Russell T. Davies, has gotten a bit full of himself and exploited the love of visuals and situations than a good, well structured story. It's a shame, because he wrote this first series, which I consider the best so far, because it works magnificently. RTD is stepping down, though, and a pretty good writer, Stephen Moffatt is taking over as Producer/Head Writer. Should be interesting. He makes the creepy episodes that are refreshingly original. Not free of plot holes or recurring themes, but always a good watch.

Old Doctor Who is also worth a watch, although I'd avoid the 80's. The producer for that whole decade, John Nathan-Turner (JNT; they really have a knack for three-lettered abbreviations across the pond) decided to kill off everything that was really FUN about the show and dedicate it entirely to staying within the confines of cold, hard science. Oh, and it was extremely violent. And not in a good way.

Still, Jon Pertwee and Tom Baker's portrayals of the Doctor in the 70's are among the best things to happen to television. Also, having Douglas Adams (!) as a writer and script editor was awesome. I totally recommend "City of Death."

Right, I should be careful around Who threads. I'll talk my damn head off.

Posted by: vic at May 27, 2009 2:21 PM

Er, by "recurring themes," I meant to say "repetitive themes." "Recurring themes" are not so bad in themselves...

And yes, UncleJR, let's hope Hollywood doesn't get its grubby hands on the show! Spielberg is a fan of it, but he seems to like it as it is, which is good. Rumors are milling about a film in the works, though, but not by him. It'll probably be British, anyway.

Posted by: vic at May 27, 2009 2:24 PM

Netflix (thank the gods) started offering the first three series on instant watch, and I devoured them, then suffered through having to wait for the discs to watch the 4th.

Sadly, I have no friends who will give it enough of a chance to love it, too. In the 4th series, when the Doctor was handed a gas mask and immediately asked, "Are you my mommy?" I almost died laughing.

Also, Hollywood had better keep its damned hands off of Doctor Who. It's just so perfectly British that I can't imagine it being done justice elsewhere. Someone recapping the first series mentioned that The Empty Child and The Doctor Dances told a story that couldn't have come from America...I swing back and forth as to how much I agree, but in the end, I do.

Posted by: Tyburn Blossom at May 27, 2009 2:39 PM

Words cannot express how much I love Doctor Who - I'm of the opinion that anyone who doesn't think the finale of the first series (with Bad Wolf and the time vortex and the dying - *sniff*) is one of best televisual moments ever is dead inside.

I am a sentimental geek and I love it.

Posted by: Squeeziee at May 27, 2009 2:43 PM

I'm amazed that Doctor Who has finally graced the halls of Pajiba. Count me in for the Series 2-4 recaps, as well as the Specials (once I'm current). I'll be especially interested in reading your takes on each companion as the show progresses.

Posted by: Doctor Controversy at May 27, 2009 2:52 PM

I sneak onto Pajiba for the first time since starting the new job over two months ago and what do I find???

SQUEEEEEE!

Jay, place nice with the folks.

Posted by: Nicole at May 27, 2009 2:53 PM

Also:

Doesn’t it just burn when you face me?

Easily one of my favorite Doctor lines ever, and this scene makes me a little feverish in my nethers, even though I pledge all my love and lust to Ten.

Posted by: Nicole at May 27, 2009 2:55 PM

Thank you, Steven! I only just began watching, and have made it through series 1 thus far (and, as Sharon said, I think my heart will forever adore Eccleston. Boy was I disappointed to find out he was only in the first handful of eps!), and I can't wait to see what happens next.

It's funny, around probably the 4th or 5th episode (or maybe even earlier), I was thinking to myself that Rose is probably one of the more "empowered" female characters I've ever seen, and largely for the reasons you suggest: she has no superpowers, she's not the "chosen one", she's got no sacred birthright or any other nonsense. She's only got her brain, and she learns to use it to help save the world. She learns to work with what she's got. It's not solely her responsibility, either; it's a shared responsibility, as each of us has to do our part to make the world better and safer.

So far, I love this show. (My dad loved the original series, and I think partly it makes me feel a little closer to him.) I can't wait to see the rest. I hope you do some columns on them too.

Posted by: Anna von Beaverplatz at May 27, 2009 2:55 PM

awww no everyone has beaten me to gushing about this fave of mine. Father's day and the doctor dances are simply phenomenal episodes. The family of blood in the third season is also beautiful

Posted by: jim of the lower case at May 27, 2009 2:59 PM

Got hooked on the original in college on the Chicago PBS station, late on Sunday nights (YEAH TOM BAKER and your long scarf!!!) Was super-excited about the reboot, and my kids and I are totally hooked. Eccleston was a good Doctor, but a little too angry and angsty. We want our Doctor serious, but also fun. Tennant is phenomenal, and I am VERY concerned about the new upcoming Doctor. Rose was great, and so was Martha. Was NOT that crazy about Donna.

All I have to do to scare my kids is either show them any stone angel statue, or say, "DON'T BLINK!"

Posted by: dammitjanet at May 27, 2009 3:06 PM

I've been watching Dr. Who since I moved to England in 1964. It started in 1963, so I've actually been able to catch up the first series via DVD. It's one long continuous saga. It's been cheesy and it's been a hell of a lot of fun. When I moved to America in 1970, Dr. Who eventually hopped the pond and I was able to catch up on the newer episodes. Both my PBS station and I lost interest in the 1980's and even Withnail (Paul McGann) couldn't kickstart it again with a standalone TV movie. I was thrilled when the BBC restarted Dr. Who a few years ago with Eccleston and then Tennant.

I remember sitting in front of the TV to watch the first "new" Dalek episode with my fingers crossed and my eyes closed, chanting "Please let there be a plunger, please let there be a plunger, please let there be a plunger." And lo, there was a plunger. And all was well with the world.

The only Dr. Who's I haven't seen are the 2 theatrical movies starring Peter Cushing. They are the same scripts as William Hartnell's (the first doctor) first two Dalek stories, but they change the Doctor so that he's human and calls himself Dr. Who (a real no no). They are not considered part of the Dr. Who canon, even though they made a lot of money at the time. Daleks in COLOR. And they could fly.

Posted by: BWeaves at May 27, 2009 3:13 PM

The Doctor rundown:

1. William Hartnell. Your mean old grandfather, who'll kidnap you to a distant planet rather than have you give away his secret. Also abandoned his granddaughter on Earth in 2069 and NEVER went back to visit her.

He also called a piece of equipment in the TARDIS "the fornicator." Video tape was too expensive, so they didn't reshoot the scene. The kiddies won't notice, and who would ever see it again, anyway? Rent "The Beginning" DVD to get the episode where they are trapped in the TARDIS.

2. Patrick Troughton. A cross between Chaplin's little tramp and your favorite uncle who taught you how to smoke cigars behind the garage. Invented the concept of regeneration and bottomless pockets. Played the recorder.

3. Jon Pertwee. The fop. Once married to Jean Marsh. Stranded on Earth. Loved to drive any kind of vehicle, especially Bessie (an old yellow car). First to use the sonic screwdriver, I believe. First Dr. Who in color.

4. Tom Baker. The hippie. Longest run as the Doctor. The scarf, oh the scarf. The longest scarf.

5. Peter Davison. Youngest doctor so far. A cross between Tristan Farnon and a cricketer.

6. Colin Baker. Mean, just mean.

7. Sylvester McCoy. Back to the cricket outfit. For some reason his sidekick called him "Professor."

8. Paul McGann. The George Lazenby of Doctors. For some reason they made him half human.

9. Christopher Eccleston. Looks like a guy you'd meet in a pub. The leatherette jacket just didn't say "Doctor" to me. He also pissed me off when he announced that he was quitting on the same day the first episode aired. Not cool.

10. David Tennant. Classic Doctor, if a little too huggable. Return of "the coat." The Doctor has to have a good coat.

11. Matt Smith. Geez, if the Doctor gets any younger, he'll be played by sperm.

Posted by: BWeaves at May 27, 2009 3:30 PM

A man who can live forever, can travel anywhere in time or space. Anywhere but home.

omigodomigodomigod!
Yeah. Count me in with everything everyone has said. I also didn't watch much growing up, although I did tune into Tom Baker every once in a while. But Eccleston ripped my head off. Father's Day" kicked my soul in the nuts. Dalek" made me even empathize with those ugly bastards.
But it was "The Empty Child"/"The Doctor Dances" that finally got me hooked. So dark, scary, helpless yet brave in the face of it. A particularly British story. It made me rethink all I thought I knew about Dr Who. I did grow to love and even somewhat prefer Tennant (something I didn't think possible), but it was Eccleston's semipunk Dr that got to me first.

I also could go on so I wont. I'll just say, if you haven't seen it, rent it. Love it.

Posted by: Odnon at May 27, 2009 3:34 PM

Argh. I think Withnail was actually Richard E. Grant, who ALSO played the animated Dr. Who.

Posted by: BWeaves at May 27, 2009 3:38 PM

He also pissed me off when he announced that he was quitting on the same day the first episode aired. Not cool.

He'd only signed on for one season to help kickstart the show with his much-greater-than-average-for-a-British-TV-series star power, and he and the producers had always agreed on this and not expected to be able to afford him thereafter. Then the first episode aired and it was obvious the show was going to be a monster hit, and they offered him a second season, but he'd only wanted to do one season in a sort of single-story bloc and had other plans afterwards.

Eccleston's always been totally respectful of the show and the character, and even if it was only for thirteen eps, fans were lucky to have him be the Ninth Doctor. He really brought home, in particular, the Doctor's loneliness and near-collapse after the death of his race.

Posted by: mightygodking at May 27, 2009 3:40 PM

I know, I just wish Eccleston hadn't announced it right at the start of the series.

Posted by: BWeaves at May 27, 2009 3:42 PM

Just a bit of a note on the Eccleston, one season thing: he did not make the announcement, the BBC did and attributed the statement to him without consent. Eccleston was furious, as the BBC and he had agreed months earlier to not reveal that he was only going to be in the first season. The BBC later apologized to Eccleston.

Posted by: Steven Lloyd Wilson at May 27, 2009 3:48 PM

Are you my mummy?

Posted by: dammitjanet at May 27, 2009 3:50 PM

Richard E. Grant whould rock as the Dr.
So would Hugh Laurie. Or Bill Nighy.
I am not sure about this new kid. We'll see......

Posted by: Odnon at May 27, 2009 4:06 PM

I teared up just reading this. This show hits me SO HARD.

Love it.

Posted by: gatesong at May 27, 2009 4:17 PM

Yes Yes Yes! Love me some Doctor Who. So glad you are getting the word out.

Posted by: Kizer at May 27, 2009 4:19 PM

Thank you, Steven! You've beautifully stated why I am now and will forever be a Doctor Who junkie. I've been trying for years to get my friends to watch, but they refuse because they are close-minded losers. I'm going to send them all a link to this review in a last-gasp effort. If your review doesn't convince them, nothing will.

And I may have to stop being friends with them.

Also, I concur on writing about seasons/series 2-4. Please? Oh please?...Mummy?

Posted by: ShinyKate at May 27, 2009 4:25 PM

this is brilliant Steven! i LOVE Doctor Who. my son watches with me--he started watching series 3, so i bought 1 and 2 so he could see what he had missed--and the show inspires some of the best conversations we've ever had. i grew up watching the old episodes and i love being able to share my love for The Doctor with my son--he's not quite ready for the "cheesy" special effects of the old episodes yet. The Empty Child is absolutely brilliant and my son will call or text me and say "are you my mummy" at random times. we're total Doctor dorks.

i also have the theme song as my ringtone and i love watching fellow fans freak out when they hear the theme song in public.

Posted by: pq at May 27, 2009 4:26 PM

The genius of the character development is that Rose does not become more powerful, or blessed with some macguffin of plot relevance. Her evolution is in realizing that she matters just as she is. Simple shopgirls can not only save the world, they are the only ones who ever do so.

So the whole Bad Wolf thing doesn't count? She matters just as she is and that whole "I think you need a Doctor" bit at the end was nothing?

P.S. I can't wait for Donna to come back, her relationship with the Doctor was my FAVORITE. No mooning over him, just snappy comebacks. I prefer my Doctor sans love story.

Posted by: Anne (in Reno) at May 27, 2009 4:34 PM

pq - I have the TARDIS landing sound effect as my ringtone! People either love it or are totally confused. And I have bonded with so many people over this series - I can't tell you how many I have sucked in just by making them watch "Blink". Can't wait for Moffat to take over!

Posted by: Anne (in Reno) at May 27, 2009 4:38 PM

Hugh Laurie would make an excellent Doctor. And I love some of great lines throughout the seasons: I did a big squee in the Shakespeare episode when Shakespeare propositions the Doctor and Martha.

"Ohh, 57 academics just punched the air."

And Anna, I have the TARDIS sound on my phone too!!

Posted by: Sharon at May 27, 2009 5:07 PM

My phone is unable to do that.

I pout at you.

Posted by: Jay at May 27, 2009 5:24 PM

I will always cower in fear over children with gas masks, asking me, "Are you my mummy?" To which I'll respond, "NO I'M NOT YOUR MUMMY!!!" I'd probably do a kung fu move, or I'd run around and scream.
Most likely the latter.

Posted by: Kamikaze Feminist at May 27, 2009 5:26 PM

Count me in as a huge Doctor Who geek, and have been pretty much my whole life. My phone is rife with sounds (my message tone - TARDIS engine noise).

EVERYBODY LIVES!

Posted by: Shane at May 27, 2009 5:29 PM

where did y'all get the TARDIS sounds? if i heard that out in public i would have a total geekgasm. i have a toy TARDIS--cause i'm a giant dork--and i would love to set my text tone to that sound.

Posted by: pq at May 27, 2009 5:31 PM

I suspect it would get a little confusing if the lot of us were in a room and someone got a call. I've got the theme song for my ringtone, and the TARDIS for my text message alert.

And I've gotta add another vote to the 'Hugh Laurie would make an awesome Doctor' contingent.

Posted by: Tyburn Blossom at May 27, 2009 5:31 PM

Back during my high school days, Channel 11 here in Chicago would put Doctor Who on Sunday nights at 11:00. I would barely crawl through Mondays. Tom Baker was the Doctor that I was most familiar with. I was reluctant to watch the new series until a friend made me. They are excellent.

No, Hugh Laurie must remain on House, damn it, you can't have him back!!! Its one of the few good things on American television.

Posted by: Lori at May 27, 2009 5:49 PM

That could get confusing, Matt found the original TARDIS sound effect on the BBC website years ago and saved it - recently he got me a new phone that is able to talk to my computer so I made him give me a version of the sound effect small enough for my phone, it actually took forever.

And I want to be in that room when nobody knows whose phone it is. Talk about a room full of awesome. Sorry Jay. If you come, you can borrow my phone ;)

Posted by: Anne (in Reno) at May 27, 2009 5:52 PM

OK! I will cut Eccleston some slack for the "leaving" announcement!

It's still my favorite show of all time.

I always hated weird ringtones, but I would kill to get the TARDIS ringtone.

Posted by: BWeaves at May 27, 2009 5:55 PM

Lori - I agree about House. But all good things..... And once it runs it's course and this new "Kid Dr" reaches puberty, Hugh Laurie might be wanting a new gig. And I would not be opposed to him taking over the TARDIS.

Posted by: Odnon at May 27, 2009 5:55 PM

The Blink episode is one my all time favs. Add me to the resounding list of people who love the show.
And who devoured it on Netflix and waited impatiently, so impatiently!, for the remaining seasons to arrive.

Not a huge fan of Rose or Donna, loved Martha, but am beginning to see why she was not everyone's fav. In fact I'd have to list my Companions in order: Martha, Donna, and Rose.

NEVER understood what the Doctor saw in Rose, but I sure did love the show as a whole. LOVED 9, was peeved when he left, but felt that 10 did a marvelous job, once I got used to him. 11 will not be able to live up to any of them, but I guess check back with me in a year and I may have revisit that sentiment.

Top 5 Episodes:
Blink
The Empty Child
Family of Blood
The Doctor Dances
The Library
The Doctor Dances

Posted by: Stella at May 27, 2009 6:03 PM

Count me in on "Blink". I still look twice at any statues I come across...
But the one that always reduces me to sobbing tumescence is "The Girl in the Fireplace" from Series 2.

Posted by: Odnon at May 27, 2009 6:07 PM

Odnon, my dear. No, you can't have Hugh. Not yet. I need answers! How does House leave the mad house that ended season 5? Will he ever shag Cuddy? These are pressing quesions!

When the new doctor grows a beard and his voice drops, we'll discuss this again. Until then, its off the table.

Posted by: Lori at May 27, 2009 7:02 PM

Girl in the Fireplace! that's a great episode!

Posted by: Stella at May 27, 2009 7:11 PM


Quite right, SLW: I think the Doctor's little chat with the couple getting married in Father's Day conveys the enduring grace of the show. "Two ordinary people? That's the most important thing in the world."

Ms. Theycallthewind and I have been freebasing series 1-3 for the past month. Finally won her over after furtively catching it at midnight on public television. Both wept openly at end of Doomsday (s2/e13).

Oh, and why love Rose, Stella? "She was...SO human."

Posted by: theycallthewind at May 27, 2009 8:17 PM

I would argue that anyone who doesn't sob at the end of "Doomsday" has a lump of coal in place of a heart. I've always been a Rose/Ten shipper. I'll always be a Rose/Ten shipper, and "Journey's End" nearly broke me.

Has anyone read Jacob's excellent TWoP recaps?

P.S. - Stop saying "Are you my mummy?" Jay can't take it.

Posted by: Nicole at May 27, 2009 9:03 PM

I never comment around here but I lurk. I just have to say how much I loved this review. As others have said please do the rest of the series.

Posted by: yosafbridge at May 27, 2009 9:32 PM

“Everybody lives, Rose! Just this once! Everybody lives!”
One of most poignant Dr Who moments I can remember since watching the Pertwee/ Baker episodes as a nipper.

I’ll stick my hand up for reviews of the subsequent series and you can throw in Torchwood as well. John Barrowman is the only man I would contemplate turning for- though if Gwen suddenly become available, all bets are off.

Series one was terrific, it’s a real shame Eccleston couldn’t stay on. Series two lost me for a while: Tennant was a little too cartoonish and cutesy at first and the stories leaned too heavily on “which major historical figure/event shall we tweak this week?” Three got back on track and four continued along nicely. I loved Donna, the interplay between Tennant and Catherine Tate had genuine spark.

I look forward to future episodes too, Stephen Moffat is the best of all possible replacements for Russell T Davies. Moffat wrote some of the series’ darkest and most memorable stories- Blink, the previously mentioned Girl in the Fireplace and Silence In The Library/Forest of the Dead, that subtly introduced Alex Kingston as the Doctors future “wife” Dr River Song, another gorgeously heartrending story. I just hope the new guy inhabits the role as well as his predecesssors.

Posted by: Dave Shepherd at May 27, 2009 10:34 PM

Or Bill Nighy.

Now I will forever be sad that 11 will not be played by Bill Nighy.

9 is my favorite, but that moment in Family of Blood when John/the Doctor and Joan touch the watch and see what their life in the future could have been...I just weep and weep.
Might be one of my favorite moments of TV. At least it rates at the top next to Penny and Desmond's phone call in The Constant.

Posted by: Jules at May 28, 2009 12:07 AM

I don't know what this says about me, but I have a radio controlled K-9, and a couple of Sonic Screwdrivers lying around.

I used to watch Dr. Who on the local PBS station (channel 13, which so happens to have been the first station in the US to run Monty Python). Tom Baker at first, though eventually they ran through all of the series over the course of many years.

I wasn't sure if I'd like the new series when I first heard about it. I was afaid it was going to be as lackluster as the later years of the original run. I was very glad to find that my fears were unfounded. The new Dr. Who series are just as much fun as the old series that I watched as a kid, if not better. I hope they keep up the good work.

Please, review series 2-4. And maybe throw in a review of the original series as well, or at least an overview of them and of the various incarnations of The Doctor.

Posted by: CptCrckpot at May 28, 2009 12:10 AM

When the most recent episode aired in the UK, I was invited around to watch a friend's illegal download on my mother's birthday. Am I a bad child for feeling a bit bummed that I couldn't go watch Who instead?

In a way, I think Jack developed as much as Rose. Well, maybe not developed, maybe just rediscovered that part of him that (I presume) he'd left behind when he left the Time Agents (or whatever they were). For all that con-man of leisure thing/walking Id thing he had going on, he really did care about 'the greater good', and it was nice to see that show up more as the series progressed.

Posted by: ScienceGeek at May 28, 2009 3:23 AM

2nd delurking-- this one to thank you for reviewing new Who.

Also, good to know I'm not the only one who cries while watching. I lose it at "Father's Day," "The Parting of the Ways," "The Girl in the Fireplace," "Family of Blood" (poor Martha) and the one where Donna loses her memory ("Journey's End"?). Now that I know the cool denizens of Pajiba are also sobbing softies, I won't be embarrassed anymore (although, to reference another thread, I will always be mortified by my weakness for the works of Billy Joel).

And, let's keep that crying-while-watching-Data-"kill"-his-robot-daughter incident between us please.

Posted by: rezcat at May 28, 2009 4:21 AM

I think the Master, unleashing Hell on Earth, initialising the genocide of six billion souls, with the six billion souls who would one day be descended from them...

Whilst bopping along to the Rogue Traders, Voodoo Child!

One of my favourite moments in TV history. I still get goosebumps.

Always loved The Master.

Posted by: Bane at May 28, 2009 4:50 AM

"Here come the drums!"

Posted by: Bane at May 28, 2009 4:52 AM

"Everybody lives" remains my favorite moment of the revival. Thanks for making me smile!

Posted by: JoAnna at May 28, 2009 8:36 AM

CptCrkpot, I am SO JEALOUS!!! I want a K-9!!

I also have the theme and TARDIS landing sound on my phone along with several quotes.

Posted by: dammitjanet at May 28, 2009 9:20 AM

The best writer's on Doctor Who: Mark Gatiss and Steven Moffatt. (Moffatt FTW!)

While RTD had some good episodes (Season 2's finale, Midnight, The first two episodes in Season 3's finale) he's also had some massive misfires (the last episode in season 3's finale, Runaway Bride wasn't as awesome as it could have been). Yeah, can you tell I was pissed that he let Season 3's finale peter out the way it did?

Posted by: Doctor Controversy at May 28, 2009 9:22 AM


Also, Eccleston is sexy, sexy, sexy. Check out I am Kloot's video for "Proof" for some literally in-your-face goodness:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=457mjzLidgo

Posted by: rezcat at May 28, 2009 9:29 AM

his face is just so interesting... *sigh*

Posted by: Stella at May 28, 2009 1:02 PM

I am gonna get crucified for this, but I have a different Doctor Suggestion:

Robson Green from Reckless. I know, I know, but Green is soooo cool.

Posted by: Chuck B. at May 28, 2009 1:04 PM

I've been told for years to watch the good Doctor. And for years I have maligned that advice. Your review finally forced my hand, and I have fallen in love. Doctor Who and I will be marrying on a beach in the Bahamas some time in the Cretaceous a week from Saturday. Thank you, Stipe, you've made me a very happy boy.

Posted by: Coryo at May 30, 2009 2:22 AM