web
counter
 

There Is No More Unreason Left

By | Posted Under Think Pieces | Comments (82)



Happier times2.jpg

What do you do with a wedding portrait when the marriage is over?

Throwing it out seems inappropriate. That portrait two smiling kids in their mid-20s represents a lot of good times had and a lot of miles traveled. Ten years seems like a very long time ago.

We never hung that portrait. We were sharing a house with friends when we got married so we had no place to hang it. We should have hung it when we bought that condo in Las Vegas, but we didn’t and, like the man said, life happens when you’re making other plans.

I was going to finally have it matted and framed as an anniversary present this year but the frame shop was closed when I got there and I never got around to getting it done. She was supposed to book the trip for our second honeymoon but never did. Were I a man given to finding ominous portents in everyday life, I might say that all of this was a bad omen.

I was 19 when we met. She was a week short of her 19th birthday. It started off inauspiciously. I was hitting on her friend and she was play-fighting with some guys who lived upstairs from me. We were supposed to hang out as a group, but they all dropped out for one reason or another. She and I ended up alone. She and I ended up laying on the floor of her dorm room watching “Annie” and “The Nightmare Before Christmas.”

That’s where we had our first kiss. When I really want to be sappy, I say that we’re still on our first date.

A week or two before Christmas, she told me she didn’t know if she still loved me. Last week she told me she didn’t.

We’re working on staying together. Officially, we’re not making any final decisions for another three weeks. But I don’t know if it’s possible to get over that hurdle. Love doesn’t cure everything, but it’s a good place to start.

Which leads to the central question: Is love something that grows from “like?” Can you charm someone into loving you? Or is love something that just happens? Is it beyond reason? A bolt from the blue, an all-or-nothing proposition that either happens or doesn’t?

We’ve all known people we SHOULD have been attracted to but … the magic wasn’t there. All the ingredients were in place, but the alchemy didn’t work. There was no “unreason” to fall in love.

I think it’s the latter and, if that’s the case, then … Then I don’t much like where all this is heading.

There’s no anger, really. Nobody did anything wrong. Frankly, anger would be easier. If she had something to point to, some irritating thing I could stop doing or some action I should START doing, that would be a step in the right direction. I can work with hate. Hate is an emotion of passion. A friend named Bridgettte once told me that a man had to spark an immediate, visceral reaction in her before she would date him. She could like him or she could despise him, but she had to have some strong feeling.

My wife doesn’t hate me. She doesn’t feel anything at all. Beyond a shared personal history and some vestigial remnants of what once was, I’m just another face in the daily parade. A pretty face, don’t get it twisted. (I didn’t want you to think I’d gone all emo.)

I don’t want to suggest this has been at all easy for her. The woman is at risk for dehydration from crying. It’s probably worse for her, to be honest. I’m mostly confused and sad. She adds guilt to that mix. There is no joy here.

I wish I could take that pain away from her. There was a time when I might have been able to.

So, what’s next? According to life expectancy charts, I’m middle-aged for a black man, so I’m thinking of getting a convertible and dating a 22-year-old. I’m gonna be that old guy at the club — five buttons on my shirt undone, several gold chains dangling into my graying chest hair - hitting on women half his age.

Hmm, that’s an unattractive image.

Before I hit the Infiniti dealer (oh, G37, someday you’ll be mine) I’ll focus on Wondergirl, my chief henchman and assistant chef. Odds are I’m going to be a single father soon, so we’re going to be working the malls and playgrounds to meet chicks. In the meantime, I’ll remind her that I love her and her mother loves her and that, as always, my bullshit is not her problem.

I’m going to let Keely Smith play us out. We had a wedding song, why not a break up song?

I still love you Debra Harris. A part of me always will.

Jason Harris has learned that “heartbroken” is a word that has to be experienced to be understood.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Pajiba After Dark 1/12/11 | The Strange Case Of Angelica Trailer | Who Knew Falling In Love With The Dead Could Be So Charming?









Comments

I'm sorry. Things working out or not don't take the place of love being gone. It really is one of the worst ways for things to end. At least it's ending amicably. Best of luck with the situation.

Posted by: Nicolae at January 12, 2011 8:11 PM

*sob*

Posted by: Cindy at January 12, 2011 8:15 PM

I probably just cried more over this than over my own breakup. Thirteen years, ended this December. You're not alone in wondering where the hell it went and why - and especially - what the hell is next? That part is hard to care about for a while yet, I think. You write beautifully and you're a brave man. And again, not alone.

Posted by: replica at January 12, 2011 8:18 PM

I haven't the words to appropriately convey how upset I am for you. I think Cindy got it right with her *sob*.

Posted by: Pinky McLadybits at January 12, 2011 8:19 PM

So sorry you're going through this, man. I've been there as have so many people as well. All I can tell you is that even though it seems harder to not have that hate (and it quite probably is, there was much hate in my divorce so I can't relate to its absence in the process) it will make it incredibly better for your child if you can get along through it all.

I hope that the next few weeks turn around and that things heal between you but if they don't, stay strong and remember that being a single father can be a source of great pride even if the process becoming one is more than difficult.

Posted by: Paultera at January 12, 2011 8:19 PM

Damn. Sorry.

Posted by: Sad Rockstar at January 12, 2011 8:20 PM

Maybe it's crass, maybe it's inappropriate, but this is you at your best, sir. I hope, whatever happens, it's as painless as possible. Keep writing like this and things will at least feel a little easier in the moment.

Posted by: RobP at January 12, 2011 8:21 PM

Yeah, the "I don't hate you, I just don't love you anymore" is the worstest worstest, because there is no WHY.

Why is useful. Why can be reasoned with, why can be bargained with. A concrete "Why" means real problems, and therefore, possible solutions.

I wish you strength and send good thoughts your way.

PS You're bumming me out, man.

Posted by: MM at January 12, 2011 8:22 PM

I don't know you, and I can't honestly say that I know your pain. That said, I appreciate your sharing such raw emotion in this piece, and I sincerely hope that both you and your estranged partner continue to make it through this transition with the openness and dignity expressed herein.

Posted by: Dill The Devil at January 12, 2011 8:24 PM

After my divorce/exorcism, I was asked what I planned to do with my wedding band and the wedding picture.

I said I was keeping them, as reminders that there are some lessons that come at a very high cost.

Posted by: The Wanderer at January 12, 2011 8:25 PM

This got me all sorts of teary-eyed. I'm so sorry, Jason. My thoughts are with you, Debra, and Wondergirl. Hang in there!

Also, I know from experience that it's sort of beside the point when you write something as personal as this, but this really was terrific writing - heartbreaking and full of wise perspective.

Posted by: DarthCorleone at January 12, 2011 8:27 PM

In the past 15 months my marriage has been through the worst we have ever seen. We have been standing on this same brink, both of us holding our breath, afraid to move. I haven't had the courage to share it with anyone, let alone the world. I wish all of you a happier future on the other side. I so admire your strength.

Posted by: slower lower at January 12, 2011 8:35 PM

If it is meant to be over, sometimes no why is better. Nothing to hinge on. Because the hinge can drag things out until neither party is even human anymore.

When you get into these incredibly deep valleys of suck in life, I really do find comfort in remembering that at some point I WILL climb out and find joy again. It's inevitable. I'm sure I'm not the only one sending mental hugs your way right now.

As for that photo, I'd put it in a box when you're ready, and put it in the attic.

Posted by: Lindsay at January 12, 2011 8:37 PM

I'm sorry Jason. This is great writing, but it comes at too high a price.

Posted by: mrcreosote at January 12, 2011 8:38 PM

That is so hard. I don't even know what to say except hang in there, and bless you both for staying true to the fact that there was love there once. Your daughter is lucky to have parents who love her and each other so much, even if you aren't in love anymore.

Posted by: McSquish at January 12, 2011 8:39 PM

Damn. I'm sure it's no consolation, but you write beautifully.

::cyber hug::

Posted by: nosio at January 12, 2011 8:47 PM

I'm so sad for you, Jason. But thank you for having the courage to share this with us, and for getting us thinking about that ethereal, indescribable, inexorable, and elusive thing called "love."

Posted by: Jelinas at January 12, 2011 8:48 PM

I hope you, Debra and Wondergirl get through this, to whatever destination lies on the other side, with the minimum of scars.
I wish I could offer more, some advice or something, but hope is all I have to offer. I'm sorry.

Posted by: ScienceGeek at January 12, 2011 8:51 PM

This was beautiful. And I'm sorry. No snark, just love. (please don't take away my Pajiba card!)

Posted by: MelBivDevoe at January 12, 2011 8:52 PM

So sorry, Jason. No words of wisdom, just my condolences. Hang in there.

Posted by: calliope1975 at January 12, 2011 9:01 PM

No snark. Just sending hope for healing :(

Posted by: Miss Beca at January 12, 2011 9:02 PM

Mr Harris, my heart goes out to you. I always hope that a new and stronger type of love could come from two people who are committed to each other even when the "spark" has faded, because I've known relationships where it has happened. But as we all know how imperfect this world can be, I hope you can navigate to the least painful resolution for all three you.

Posted by: the cox at January 12, 2011 9:09 PM

I'm so very sorry Jason. Sending hope and good thoughts to both you and Debra.

Posted by: Kelly at January 12, 2011 9:21 PM

I hope this resolves itself, however it may fall, with a minimum of pain.

In the 11 years that my gf and I have been together, we've come close to ending it a few times.
Okay, I've come close. It was me. And yes, I've said those terrible words "I don't think I love you anymore."
But in my case, it was a combination of our not working well for long periods of time and my dealing with unhappiness by shutting off all emotion. I didn't love her because I couldn't feel much of anything. Nothing hurt much, but I didn't laugh for a few months either.
And as bad as it was to say it, it must have been a thousand times worse to hear it. I can't even explain how we got past it.

I'm so sorry, dear heart. Great gobs of love and strength to all of you.

Posted by: MyySharona at January 12, 2011 9:27 PM

If it hurt that much to read about, I can't imagine how much it hurts to being going through. Stay strong and keep you chin up.

Posted by: TheMaskedEmu at January 12, 2011 9:34 PM

dude.

I'm sorry.

I know how you feel.

My first girlfriend broke up with me unexpectedly, over IM, after we'd dating six months. Said that it was me, because I was Clingy and Possessive. Of course about a week or two later she started dating someone else.


same thing happened to a friend of mine just recently. Only his story is long and complicated.

They're both freshman at the college I just graduated from, they are both old for freshies, he's 21, she's 20. They were both in a video for a retreat that was being filmed that I was doing tech work for, they were the romantic lead. Now right there was the funny thing. But any how, she was according to him, apparently interested in someone else, but they ended up going to the opera that same night as the filming. They started dating that monday, (this was a Saturday when the filming was). This was either late September or early October. Fast forward to some point in November, I find out that they've been talking about marriage.

Yeahhhh.......between that and the fact that they'd only known each other for maybe 24 hours or less before dating, my 'this needs to be watched' senses came alive. When I wasn't a student, I was the relationship councilor. I had a show that I did, weekly on what not to do in relationships and what could be done to improve a relationship. I had a lot of listeners, including those overseas.

Anyhow, fast forward now to December somewhere between the 3rd through the 5th. they break up. Which is a surprise to all of us. I ask a few questions of both of them. from him I (the first time) get the fact that she's going to Germany for study abroad, that my mom doesn't want us dating, and a few other things. From her I got: he's spiritually immature, he's kept things from me, and a few host of other things. I get from the two sides....something's hinky in the land of "school name"

well....I was on campus today, and I run into him, I find out that the guy she was interested before him, and her are somewhat apparently interested, and that the week before the break up, that she and the other guy had held hands, and he'd been flirting and what not. ::Sigh:: this is why I try and not care. I also find out that said guy is apparently trying to turn his personality around to be acceptable to her...which reeks of a lot to me. When I find people doing that to try and get someone they like, and not be themselves, I call them on it.

So that being said ya'll.

Do not risk a relationship if you're not going to be your true self. He was, and risked everything and lost. the other guy won't be and could end up destroying her.

Posted by: Lordninja at January 12, 2011 9:44 PM

Ouch. This whole being married thing is tricky.

Posted by: Daria at January 12, 2011 9:56 PM

Today, out of the blue, my father told me that divorcing my mother 23 years ago was the biggest mistake of his life. I really didn't need him to tell me that: I see it in his eyes every time he sees her. True story.

Stick with it if you can. If there's no chance, be sure of it. And if it doesn't work out, you can always take the teaches of Peaches:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GmFp0I8AZqw

and fuck the pain away.

Posted by: logar at January 12, 2011 10:08 PM

most of mine follow me like a sticky penny, in a tupperware.

a handful, i pasted onto sturdy cardboard, for my young daughter, so she wouldn't destroy them while playing with them--she was quite fond of them.

and there is one at my sisters house, that just comes back, no matter how often she insists she threw it out. i believe her, and i believe in the creepiness of it all.

there are no words or consolation.

like the death of a loved one, it never completely quenches itself. but after enough years, you really aren't triggered very often. whether you are repaired, that i don't know.

While this piece seems really out of place in this venue, i commend you your open book.

Posted by: idleprimate at January 12, 2011 10:10 PM

I wish I could give you a big bear hug. I'd even let you cop a feel. THIS time.

XOXO

Posted by: Lainey at January 12, 2011 10:13 PM

Well, my heart goes out to you, Harris. And to the kid and even to your old lady. Serious stuff in the Pajiba column this week.

Look, I don't really feel comfortable offering advice on personal matters so I will be fighting against the urge to jam down the backspace key as I try to get this out, but here goes:

You do the best you can do with what you've got and you deal as best you can with the things that are beyond your control. Most of the time the marriage/wife/relationship stuff falls into the "what you've got" category and you take care of it, be responsible, and do the best you can. But sometimes it gets taken out of your hands and goes into the "beyond your control" category. You can't really fight against it and you can't change other people, all you can do is find the best way to deal with what life is throwing at you. Your priorities shouldn't change much, you've still got to do the best you can for the kid, for yourself, and for her.

I imagine it was incredibly difficult for her to come to you with this. How do you complain about being married to a decent guy/great father/good cook when there really isn't anything wrong? Even though it sounds like a shitty thing to (maybe) end a marriage you have to give credit for her having the balls to say something before another decade goes by, or a lifetime. Maybe it is something you can talk about and understand or maybe it is something even she doesn't fully understand about herself. I think you have to tell her you love her and support her, whatever she needs. Encourage her to be honest with you and honest with herself. Try to find out what you have together and what's best for both of you. And of course making things as stable and healthy for the kid as possible.

Getting together at 19 is tough because you never really get a chance to be an adult on your own. Realizing that you are a completely different person then the kid who made the decision to enter that relationship is a scary thing. Realizing that it might be the only relationship you ever have- even if you have a pretty good life with a pretty good guy who you get along with pretty well and you have much to be grateful for- can be terrifying. Having doubts and realizing that inertia can carry you five or ten years downstream in seconds...

But it all comes back to you. You deal with what the world throws at you, the good and the bad. Of course you will be fine, and if you need to you will walk that tightrope of parenting a child through your separation and she will be fine, too. There is a hell of a lot more living to do and a lot more surprises waiting, good and bad. (these trite words of encouragement are making my backspace finger itchy...)

Ah, fuck it. What do I know? I got together with Elisa at 19, too. Have one daughter, too. Have our ups and downs and pre-midlife crises, too. Your post kind of scares the shit out of me. Take care of yourself, TB.

Posted by: Yossarian at January 12, 2011 10:15 PM

I guess I'm the only one who feels this way, but so fucking what if she isn't in love any more. The two of you have a kid and she made a commitment. That's whats wrong with relationships now, people expect them to be hollywood perfect forever. Feelings change. And they will change again. Unless some form of abuse is involved, suck it up and carry on.

Posted by: EricD at January 12, 2011 10:25 PM

Oh buddy, I hope you guys can work it out, but however this mess turns out, I wish you the very best. The mister and I have been together since we were in our late teens as well, and it's hard to imagine life any other way--I don't even want to think about what you must be going through right now.

Damn you and your heart-tugging prose. *sniff*

Posted by: meaux at January 12, 2011 10:33 PM

I don't know you guys.
But If i knew your wife I would give her the same advice I have given to other friends.
I've been married 30 years and during our 30 years (and counting) of marriage I have gone though periods of being totally "meh" about the husband and pretty sure I no longer loved him.
These were years when I did not even want him to kiss me or sleep in the same bed let alone have sex.
But I still liked him.
And he is a patient guy who believed that a vow was a vow and we had a kid so there was no ending it.
Maybe I was just too lazy to leave, but sooner or later the bloom was back on the rose.
Right now it is almost like the honeymoon period again.

I am a very lucky lady that he stuck it out during those years.

Posted by: Jules at January 12, 2011 10:41 PM

This sucks and I'm sorry. I'll send you all the hugs.

Give the kiddo a hug. She's going to need them. Give one to yourself too.

Posted by: Melody at January 12, 2011 10:44 PM

I read this site regularly, even though I'm not all that more interested in movies than the next person. This article (like one on Gen Douchebag and a recent one on the proliferation of entertainment options) is one of those reasons. In the Digital Age, when information is superseded by the nanosecond, this I shall copy and keep on my hard drive.

Posted by: VampireSlug at January 12, 2011 10:49 PM

I'm very sad for you : (

My husband has said in the past that I was never allowed to leave him because not only would I be taking one good guy out of the world, but I would also be adding one douchebag to the world as he started the dating life all over as an adult. Above all, don't let that happen. The world needs good men.

I also fall into the camp of pushing through and staying together, since that's the promise you made at the beginning (except in cases of abuse, of course), but I'm not one to judge the situation of others. The only two people fit to judge a marriage are the two who are in it. Everyone else should shut it. Best to all of you.

Posted by: katy at January 12, 2011 11:11 PM

Had I known that I would be reading this I would have kept a glass of water on my desk. It seems as if me and my fellow posters could collectively end a drought after this piece. I don't understand what you're going through on the surface level, but I understand (don't we all) how a deep pain can obliterate your sense of equilibrium and make you feel as though you've been given an impossible task in having to stand on your own two feet when all you're doing is falling. Lives and their composite events don't have to be identical for one or a groups of them to feel for the other, and judging by the warmth and depth of response here, it's more that clear that you've got a large and diverse cheering section. I think there's something fine about that, about resonating powerfully enough to draw that kind of response from such a seemingly unlikely source.

And consider this: this is the freaking internet! In a world where nothing can be gained by reading YouTube comments, a world of cartoon cum dribbles, Kevin Smith apologist sites, Facebook users, Twitter feeds and Canadians, it's pretty remarkable to find a place where so many people regard another with genuine affection and no fetish gear in sight (I think). I suppose you must've done something to merit that, huh?

I hope you get what you're looking for and really hope you get what you need. You're truly in my thoughts, fellow black person.

Blessings,
-M.M.M.

P.S. I'm getting a migraine so I didn't proofread this, but the sentiment and codeine still stands. Cyber-Solace.

Posted by: Jo 'Mama' Besser at January 12, 2011 11:18 PM

Before I got married, in pre-marriage counseling, I was taught that love is a decision not a feeling. After 10 years, I think that was good advice. On good days you get the feelings too. On bad days you still take care of each other. I think that's the whole point of the vow. Some days, weeks, months you just don't want to. Feelings are not always trustworthy. But the commitment keeps you on track. I appreciate so much that you opened your heart to us.

Posted by: Amberlark at January 13, 2011 12:23 AM

Is love something that grows from “like?”
---
I think in our case, "like" grew from "love" -- all that heat, smoke and flash that ignites when you first hook up. After time that sort of settles down and you find out you either like who you married or you don't. I'm one of the lucky ones, I really like my wife, and I tell her that. And often that's an even better thing. She's my best friend.

The other ones ... well, at least you don't part loathing each other. Just drifting apart ... maybe that's sadder, somehow. I don't know.

I'm just kind of rambling because I don't know what I could say to console you, Jason, that wouldn't sound moronic. Good luck? Hey, back in the pool!? Man up?

See?

Best wishes to both of you, I guess. It's weak but it's all I can do from here.

Posted by: , at January 13, 2011 12:24 AM

My wife said the same thing to me at the end of 2007. I too have 2 young children. Like the people above suggested I sucked it up and stuck it out. We had made a commitment.

After 15 years of marriage we divorced in September of 2010. The longest and toughest years of my life. Through it all we have remained amicable.

To your child don't you owe her the lesson to not settle in life? Let her know what true love is?

I remember vividly those first 10 years we were together. The happiest days of my life. One day you have to look at yourself in the mirror and ask,"Don't you want to feel that happiness again?"

You are halfway through life. Do you deserve a second chance to feel that way again? I know -it's a tough call.

Posted by: retro at January 13, 2011 12:32 AM

...and suddenly the new tagline seems so fitting.

"I Wish You Love" and "Can't Take That Away from Me" were the two songs that buoyed me through my first real heartbreak (which may be still going on...) Somehow, they perfectly capture that emotion of not just the departure of love, but of a great friend (which in my particular case, makes the former song most accurate because he really wasn't ever a "lover.") It's such a strange place to be: when you hold no ill will toward them, you want them to be happy with whatever will make them happy, but why can't, isn't, won't that be you? At some point in the whole...THING...even after opening yourself bare to complete strangers on the Internets, you still can't seem to find the right words for all that you are feeling, all that is going on; you don't know what more and else can be said.

But you can still find the right song. And after a few more listens, something clicks a little and at least makes you feel a bit like maybe everything's gonna be okay after all.

Sending you and Wondergirl and Debra lots of hope and support.

Posted by: kiyo-chan at January 13, 2011 12:37 AM

Jason,

I'm really sorry to hear your news and hope you all come through it without rancour and remain on good terms.


As someone embarking on a new adventure with a wonderful new partner, I hope and pray that we don't end in a similar situation.

The possibility of that happening is what scares me the most......

Posted by: frank_247 at January 13, 2011 12:42 AM

Jason,
that was heartfelt as usual. I hope the best for you both,no matter what that may be.

Posted by: thecurious at January 13, 2011 12:47 AM

I wish you strength more than anything. You will need it for yourself, but also for Wondergirl.

As for the wedding pictures, I decided to hang on to mine--at least for now. The marriage was a part of my life and there were good times as well as painful ones. Those pictures are a reminder of a time when we were still optimistic and unafraid. If I'm lucky, I'll feel that way again.

Good luck to you, whatever lies ahead.

Posted by: Girl With Curious Hair at January 13, 2011 1:48 AM

Well said, and I sympathize.

I have been with my boyfriend for over 5 years, and there was a period of 6 months of more when I felt very much like your wife is feeling (or so I imagine from your description.) I just could not muster any feelings for the man anymore. And I didn't want anyone else, either. It's like a light turned off and I couldn't find the switch. We almost ended it there, on amicable but desperately sad terms.

I think the reason I didn't was fear of losing him, fear of dating, fear of the unknown. Sounds like a terrible reason to stick with it. But, we've grown so much closer in the 2 years that followed. For us, I think it was being honest about our "dark sides," which was a slow process. And being honest about our fears and doubts. It was incredible to find out after 5 years that he would accept me and be supportive (in his masculine, quiet way) of my deep-seated anxieties and shortcomings.

I know we're not the same, and your relationship is unique to the two of you. And I would never offer relationship advice to a stranger. Just wanted to relate how I felt that empty "I just don't love you anymore" and slowly realized that I did love him. Love isn't magic, and it certainly isn't static.

I wish you and your child and wife the best.

Posted by: Vince Noir at January 13, 2011 2:35 AM

Best piece of seperation advice I ever got was (surprisingly) from my father, who said it's very rare to find someone who's on the same path as you, and if they're following the same direction for even a short while you should count yourself lucky and be thankful.
Of course, that only started to help about 2 years later, at the time the best thing would've been to buy Kleenex stock.
Best thoughts to everyone involved and thanks for your writing.

Posted by: cinekat at January 13, 2011 3:45 AM

You're black?

Posted by: elzupasmonkey at January 13, 2011 5:21 AM

Oh, Jason. I am so, so sorry. This ranks up there with Chez's break-up stories. So awful for both of you.

I know exactly what you mean. Hate is SO much easier, so is anger. Its just when...things fizzle out....with a whimper, not a bang....that hurts so much more.

I'll be thinking of you, and Debra, and Wondergirl, and hoping the best for you.

btw, I do have a hot single daughter....

Posted by: dammitjanet at January 13, 2011 6:12 AM

I'm going through very much the same thing although my wife left it until after Christmas to drop the bomb shell (although I had known something was coming when she decided she'd rather be at work than spend her holiday time with me between Christmas and New Year). I'd just like to say thank you to both Jason for writing a such a lovely peice that explained my feelings in a way I never could and to all the Pajibans who, in giving advice and support to Jason helped me feel a little better. I love how although we're a snarky, sarcastic bunch normally, when one of our herd is threatened we all pull together.

Posted by: hazbear01 at January 13, 2011 6:12 AM

Allow me to offer my condolences to the chorus prior.

This struck way close to home, having been through 2 divorces. (One from each side. i.e. my first wife left me, I left my 2nd wife. 1st marriage lasted about 5 years, second, just under 10)

I've been married to my current wife for 20 years. I think that love is something that grows. When you're first together, everyting is in bright hues, love burns passionately and every day is a new day. (Or a 1st date, if you will)

However, things tend to settle in and a routine developes. the hardest part seems to be adjusting to the routine. Is it one you're comfortable with?

Don't get me wrong. I love my wife more today than the day we first met. However, the love I have for her is one that has built itself up over the past 20 + years, and a whole lot of shared experiences. (3 kids, and all the trauma associated with that.)

The only advice I can give you is...don't rush into another relationship. (see my 2nd marriage as a warning).

And know that you're doing the right thing telling your daughter that it's not her fault. She will have a hard time understanding it, but just keep reminding her how much you love her and how special she is to you.

Above all, never lose faith. I'm certain that somewhere out there is a woman who will fill that empty space. Right now it doesn't seem that way, and the temptation is to force something into it's place.

and know that we, here, at Pajiba, are all behind you.

Posted by: Uncle JR at January 13, 2011 7:34 AM

That was beautifully written and hit me really close to home. I went through something similar but in our case it was less than 2 years after being married. There was no real reason, just a mix of things. Primarily that I was 22 years old, we had constant money problems from trying to find work, and I stopped trying because I didn't know you HAD to try. I was a very, very stupid boy. We were both 18 and in college when we met and were engaged 9 months after starting to date.

It took years to get over her because I made the mistake of still being friends with her because I couldn't stand the thought of losing my wife and my best friend and she was both. As painful as it is to say goodbye, you have to. That is the one piece of advice I can give you. Don't do the friends thing if you really do separate, at least not for several months after. If you still have feelings for her you will never be able to move on. You have to have contact for your child, but keep it as strictly business.

And you are absolutely right, heartbreak is a physical pain. I had no idea until I experienced it first hand.

Stay strong and keep writing. It helps and it does get better eventually. Just don't beat yourself up looking for reason. There is no point and it will drive you crazy.

Posted by: TylerDFC at January 13, 2011 7:43 AM

Very sorry to hear about your situation, stories like this make me glad that my parents taught me reasonably early in life that love doesn't exist. It's more or less something that people convince themselves into and some are better than others at it.

Good luck with everything.

Posted by: Blinky at January 13, 2011 8:56 AM

We need to go drinkin'.

I admire that you've decided to focus on Wondergirl. That's where it should be.

Posted by: admin at January 13, 2011 9:07 AM

Very touching to read. I know some things aren't fixable in a relationship, but some things are and it's worth trying to fix what is fixable. The thing that struck me when you talked about your wife's side of things os that she sounds a lot like me at a couple of points in my life. Both of those points were times when i was suffering from depression and just couldn't really see it or label it at the time. If this is something new for her and she's having this lack of feeling and can't really figure out WHY, I would suggest that she look at other things in her life as well and identify how feelings may have changed. If this isn't the only area of change, it is certainly worth being evaluated for depression. If the problem is depression, leaving you will likely only make things worse instead of better.

Posted by: peachfish at January 13, 2011 9:29 AM

I would like to add that what made me stay with my gf (after periods of thinking we weren't in love) was the sudden realization that we didn't have to be madly in love every single day.
I don't know why I ever thought that we did, but I can only say that we started dating when we were both 19 (is this a magical age or something?!) and I was still young and stupid a few years after that.

My friend's mother, married 45 years now, told me that sometimes you have to fall back in love.

And my new homily to friends who ask me "how do you know it's love"? You know when you're willing to do the work it takes. Because it can take a LOT of work sometimes. I'm glad I grew up enough to figure that out, because I would have lost a wonderful person.

I hope that whatever the outcome, there is at least effort made, on both your parts. Maybe it's just me, but I throw everything I've got at a problem before I deem it unsolvable. I consider it a great tragedy for a marriage to end where no one has tried.

I'm about to erase all of this because it sounds trite and smug. We're all giving you a lot of advice (and hugs) and maybe that's not what you want. But I've been where your wife is, and I guess I want you to know that I came back.

Posted by: MyySharona at January 13, 2011 9:49 AM

Oh, *Harris*.

Posted by: Anna von Beav at January 13, 2011 9:57 AM

I dated my ex-husband on-and-off for ten years before we walked the aisle. We had two years of white-hot passion, followed by a year of tepid insecurity, followed by two years of white-hot getting-divorced hatred.

My boyfriend was with his ex-wife for 15 years, nine of them married, few of them happily. Their marriage was over at least five years before they separated. Despite acknowledging that, it took him over two years to obtain a divorce because she would not. let it. go. The devil she knew was more pleasing to her than being alone.

He and I are moving in together this summer. Neither one of us are in any hurry to walk that aisle again, as marriage as an ideal has sort of been shattered. But we're committed to each other and to the relationship, and we're taking the lessons learned and applying them to our future.

If divorce is the way you're headed, it will suck, no doubt. But, you can get through to the other side, and have the next time be even better. You can be smarter, sadder, wiser, more aware, more careful, have a better idea of what you want and need in a partner. Hold on to those things when it hurts the most.

I wish you luck.

Posted by: Wants To Rule the World at January 13, 2011 10:15 AM

I'm so sorry to hear, Jason. Lots of hugs for you and your little girl. I hope that you and your wife can get through this, whatever the final outcome may be, and that your daughter will know that no matter what happens between them that Mom and Dad both love her.

Posted by: stardust at January 13, 2011 10:19 AM

So sorry, Jason. No advice here, only hugs. You'll get through this.

Posted by: Toph at January 13, 2011 10:30 AM

A) You are a hell of a writer.
B) As a sufferer of depression myself, I have to second peachfish's suggestion: a sudden lack of feeling or loss of interest can very well be a sign of a deeper illness, which may or may not have anything to do with you at all.

It wouldn't be a silver bullet, but if she is willing to explore why she feels this way, you both might find a solution that helps you both heal.

My heart goes out to both of you, and your daughter. A hard road ahead, indeed.

Posted by: Tammy at January 13, 2011 10:54 AM

Your pain. I feel it.

No mushy stuff from me, though I could go that way. I do agree with the whole break-up song idea. Music gets me through just about anything.

I should have known my first marriage was doomed when the future ex-Mrs. Name chose Freebird as our wedding song.

Yes. Really. I still don't think she has actually learned the words and realized how completely innapropriate that was for the beginning of a relationship.

Then again, built-in break-up song!

Posted by: No Pithy Name at January 13, 2011 11:01 AM

Been there, too. It sucks, and I wouldn't wish it on anybody.

My choice (married 3 years, divorced in '94) was to immediately ditch all photographic evidence. Not because I'm unsentimental -- quite the opposite, in fact. I knew I had the capacity to wallow in seeing them, and I knew that wouldn't help. So out they went, and I don't regret it. Best of luck with your own decisions. Do sensible things.

Posted by: sansho1 at January 13, 2011 11:49 AM

I'm so sorry. I'm still married to my first husband, going on 30 years, so I don't have any experience to offer on divorce or breakups.

I do think they are like deaths in that you are going through mourning, and everyone handles that differently.

What do you do with the photos?
Whatever your heart tells you to do.
Just don't do anything rash.
You may want them later.

Posted by: BWeaves at January 13, 2011 12:00 PM

I wish you would have wrote this six years ago when my then wife of five years divorced me for no real reason at all. Fortunately we did not have kids. The great thing is that three and a half years ago I met my current wife and mother of my daughter. If my first wife had not left me I would not be in the beautiful situation that I find myself in today. I am very thankful that she did leave and you have inspired me to write that thank you letter that I have been putting off for a few months now. You will get through this and come out even better than you were. You will learn a lot about yourself in this process I am sure.

Posted by: D at January 13, 2011 12:44 PM

I'm so sorry. Whatever happens, I hope you, your wife and daughter find peace and happiness. You have our thoughts and hearts, Harris.

Posted by: Kayanne at January 13, 2011 12:46 PM

I'm sorry, Harris.

Posted by: stopthemadness at January 13, 2011 12:51 PM

You're a great writer, and you have my condolences. Also, on the whole, I tend to agree with EricD. If there's a kid involved, it's kind of irresponsible to give up on a marriage just because the love isn't there anymore. Anyway, I'll pray for you and your family.

Posted by: jmag at January 13, 2011 12:58 PM

Jason, I'm so sorry for what you're going through and I wish you both strength and compassion and the hope that whatever the outcome, neither of you decides to be bitter or closed off.

Before I got married, in pre-marriage counseling, I was taught that love is a decision not a feeling. After 10 years, I think that was good advice. On good days you get the feelings too. On bad days you still take care of each other. I think that's the whole point of the vow. Some days, weeks, months you just don't want to. Feelings are not always trustworthy. But the commitment keeps you on track. I appreciate so much that you opened your heart to us.

Posted by: Amberlark at January 13, 2011 12:23 AM

Well said Amberlark. I think at the very least you may want to both go to a therapist individually and a marriage counselor, at least to help you through the process.

Posted by: Vee at January 13, 2011 12:59 PM

Oh, and as for the photo, I'd pack it away. You'll be able to look at it again with fond memories one day. And your little girl may want to have it someday too.

Posted by: Anna von Beav at January 13, 2011 1:06 PM

Get yourself a puppy!

Their love is never-ending.

Posted by: Murderbot at January 13, 2011 4:19 PM

Aw, man, that sucks. Sorry.

I've never been married, but both of my sisters have been divorced, not at all amicably. It was several years before my one sister stopped referring to her ex as "the dirty motherfucker" (he dumped her for a 19-year-old he met at a convenience store when their kid was a year old). My other sister got divorced amid much stupid drama on both sides. My brother's baby mama (never married her, fortunately) is a crazy bitch (literally crazy).

So, if it's any consolation, marriage ending without acrimony or fault, just sadness, has gotta be better than the examples above. Maybe slightly easier on the kid, at least.

DO NOT throw away the picture. Your kid might want it someday. Or you might. But once you chuck it, you can't get it back. I am not the nicest person in the world, and that picture makes even me mist up a little bit. So it's gotta mean a whole lot more to the people involved.

Posted by: Slash at January 13, 2011 4:42 PM

Rereading this I remembered your question:

Is love something that grows from “like?” Can you charm someone into loving you? Or is love something that just happens? Is it beyond reason? A bolt from the blue, an all-or-nothing proposition that either happens or doesn’t?

None of those. Love is something you do, along the same lines as it being a decision like others noted above. I think if more people recognized this more marriages and relationships would stay intact.

Still hoping the best for you all.

Posted by: katy at January 13, 2011 5:46 PM

Wow Jason, That's a heaping load of shit to deal with and I'm genuinely sorry it's on your plate. I know we've clashed before but all that shit aside, you seem like exactly the type of guy that can shoulder this whole mess and come out better on the other side. All things are temporary, no matter how much we wish they weren't. That being said, I've got three things.

Keep the picture, because if it hurts this much now, it'll be worth remembering down the line.
This is the best thing you've written for Pajiba. It's honest and heartfelt and every person here obviously had it resonate with them. That's more than some writers can pull off after a lifetime of sorrow.
You'll be alright, ladies love the chocolate.

I hope things settle somewhere comfortable for you man. Good luck.

Posted by: Blank at January 13, 2011 6:23 PM

That was heartbreaking.

It's true that you made a commitment, that vows were made and every effort must be made to fulfill those vows. Not to the detriment of one or the others happiness, though. And especially not in the name of the children. It's a far better thing to be raised by parents who live separately but are united in ensuring the health and happiness of their children than by parents who live together struggling to maintain civility and respect, to recapture something good and lost.

Add my hugs to the supply to draw on when needed.

Posted by: Eyvi at January 13, 2011 6:23 PM

Jason, I am so sorry for what you and your wife are experiencing now.

"Love is a choice" came to my mind too. Now, I am not married so I don't have the years of wisdom that some folks here have, but I've experienced a lot of emotional ups and downs with the Imperial Suitor. There was a day this summer when I had a blast meeting his family, but felt nothing towards him emotionally. I was really worried that the lack of gushy emotion meant my love had died.

But I've decided that he's worth loving, and so every day I decide to show that. Feelings change, euphoria comes and goes, but you always have to choose to put the other person first. Love means giving of yourself, and wanting what is best for the other person. From what you've written it sounds like you already know that.

Posted by: Empress of All the Russias at January 13, 2011 10:05 PM

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lCEZNbwQVy8

This is my favorite words about marriage and relationships. It's work, a lot of it, but it takes two people to make it work.

Good luck, whatever happens. And keep the photo. Wondergirl might want it someday.

Posted by: Melody at January 13, 2011 11:48 PM

I don't come out of hiding much. I have said it before and I'll say it again. Just, *hugs*
If I can do anything, let me know. You were there for me and I want to be there for you. It looks like our stories may have different endings, but hopefully I can help you like you helped me. Even if it is just with dirty jokes ;)
My presence may be spotty lately but, you know how to reach me!

Posted by: Nimue at January 14, 2011 8:28 AM

Thank you for sharing. That takes strength. I hope that it works out for you, your wife, and your daughter. I appreciate that while you are incredibly hurt you are not incredibly angry and bitter. That seems to be very rare on internet blogs. Peace be with you.

Posted by: anikitty at January 14, 2011 9:01 AM

Keep the photos- they will mean a lot to Wondergirl one day.

Hang in there kid- you will get through this, whatever the outcome.

x

Posted by: Amandahugandkiss at January 14, 2011 10:28 AM

Given that my partner of 9 years and I had "the breakup talk" just last night, and I got him to hold out for another month to see if we still feel the same way, this was all a bit TOO timely.

So sorry this is happening, take care of yourself and Wondergirl.

Posted by: Drake at January 14, 2011 12:57 PM

the pain will pass. such quality work will endure. it is no comfort to you now, but one day it will be. i hope you guys can make it

Posted by: rohit arya at January 17, 2011 5:52 AM