web
counter
 

It's Tradition, so Suck It Up

By Steven Lloyd Wilson | Posted Under Think Pieces | Comments (37)



wild-turkey_765_600x450.jpg

If you are reading this, you are most likely either grinding out the last few hours of procrastination before your boss allows you to leave for the long weekend, or you are outside of America and getting irritated that content is tapering off and not looking forward to two more work days with a void of content. Tradition is what this thing called Thanksgiving is all about. Oh, there is a stack of other junk: family, football, enormous quantities of food, but the hinging of all that on this random day is pure tradition.

And it is random. Last Thursday of November? At least Easter only looks random but is actually a convoluted calculation based on cycles of the moon and whether the Pope gets scared back under his hat by his own shadow. Most holidays at least have some universally understood reason. Christmas and Easter are religious. Halloween has to do with the dead. Most national holidays are some variations on anniversaries of independence. Thanksgiving though is just the kind of sort of not really anniversary of a big party between two groups of people, one of whom annihilated the other within a few years. So from that point of view, it’s logical that the holiday traditionally has the entire family get together I suppose.

We’ve got a giant turkey sitting in the refrigerator, waiting to get cooked for several decades tomorrow. Now a turkey is essentially a mutated chicken from a culinary point of view. As far as I can tell from a completely unscientific point of view, it is a chicken with an out of control pituitary gland that made it grotesquely over-sized at the expense of having inferior meat. Why do we cook this thing? Tradition.

I always said that when I had my own house and my own family and my own responsibility for Thanksgiving, I was going to make steaks. Because damn it, a steak is better than a damned turkey. Whether you brine, marinate, season, deep fry, or baste that bird, it is never ever going to be better than a steak, even though it takes approximately a thousand times the effort to make. But even though this is a lonely Thanksgiving, just Mrs. SLW and myself, we’re roasting a 14 pound turkey anyway. Why? Tradition.

Tradition gets a bad rap though. It’s a force that makes us do things that really aren’t worth it, that we would never do from a cost-benefit point of view. Turkey sandwiches are delicious, but they’re not worth cooking that giant bird, so from a purely rational point of view, I’d never get to have turkey sandwiches. But tradition makes me do it, so I get my sandwiches.

It’s the same reason why half of us regularly burn two-thirds of our little four day weekend traveling to distant corners of the country. It is not worth it to drive twenty-two hours each way to Wichita to see your mom. But tradition says that you are going to do that on Thanksgiving, whether you like it or not.

So as you suffer through the next four days of travel nightmares and cooking enormous dry poultry carcasses, remember the sandwiches and the fact that you’re seeing people you wouldn’t manage to ever make the effort to see if not for tradition twisting your arm, best of intentions or not. Tradition might just be good for something.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



5 Shows After Dark 11/23/11 | In 2013 Star Trek 2 Will Boldly Go Where It's Gone Before









Comments

It's also my birthday.

Reason enough.

And if you check my Facebook, I created a long note musing over turning 30 and actually thanked the Pajiba community.

Go forth and read it.

Posted by: scorzi at November 23, 2011 3:16 PM

Pretty turkey

Posted by: ginmuse at November 23, 2011 3:17 PM

Minor pedantry: it's always the fourth Thursday in November, not necessarily the last Thursday of the month.

Posted by: jeem at November 23, 2011 3:19 PM

Turkey is awesome. Turkey with DRESSING is sublime.

Posted by: Craig at November 23, 2011 3:41 PM

According to my MA thesis, Thanksgiving was a holiday that was invented in the 19th century as a part of the ongoing effort to unify and assimilate the growing number of immigrants arriving to the United States. The Puritans were chosen as the common ancestors and the 19th century's ideas of Puritan morality, ideals and values were assumed as the American ideal. I guess what I'm trying to say is that it's not that old a tradition, but it's still useful

Posted by: astounded at November 23, 2011 3:44 PM

Whenever I'm an orphan for Thanksgiving (every two years or so my far scattered family can't visit or vice versa) I forget the turkey and make something new. It could be something I found in the NYT or a mad scientist creation of my owm. I then proceed to gather other orphans and make a glourious day of eating and watching movies. The turkey can go stuff itself. ;)

Posted by: Bob Frapples at November 23, 2011 4:02 PM

And it gave us the excellent movie Pieces of April...

Posted by: Luke at November 23, 2011 4:03 PM

Somebody has to make the turkey so that I may make turkey jambalaya and get the bastard out of the fridge by Saturday.

Posted by: Jerry at November 23, 2011 4:11 PM

@Bob Frapples: I love that idea :)

I would like to thank Turkey Jesus for my aunt's Italian Wedding soup, my mom's stuffing, the 8 lbs of sweet potatoes I plan to eat, the fact that there are so many people at my family party that it requires 3 large turkeys, the tradition of drinking mimosas with my favorite aunt out on the porch, and the fact that I now have a squishy nephew to play with instead of picking at the appetizers. Except I'll still do that.

Posted by: Julie at November 23, 2011 4:42 PM

I love Thanksgiving, it's my favorite holiday. 4 days weekend, you get to have awesome food and hang out afterward drinking wine, beer, and watching football. It's kind of the perfect holiday. Usually the more annoying relatives leave soon after dinner so not even their presence ruins the day. And my parents house is big enough I can meander away when the topic turns to politics. Plus, Pecan Pie. There is no way NOT to win on Thanksgiving.

Posted by: TylerDFC at November 23, 2011 4:52 PM

In New Zealand, the only aspect of thanksgiving that makes it this far in terms of cultural zeitgeist is Football.

And even then it isn't very popular here.
Me, I love that shit though, so myself and about a dozen other lads are taking the day off and watching NFL all day. We might even be lame and get something with turkey in it, but probably not.

Probably just more beer.

Posted by: The Only New Zealander at November 23, 2011 5:00 PM

ben franklin wanted to make turkeys the national bird

Posted by: Utah Dynamo at November 23, 2011 5:09 PM

Ya gotta love Thanksgiving! The turkey, the pie, the football all outweigh having to spend time with your relatives. Especially the pie.

Then at night comes my fave Thanksgiving tradition. In honor of our puritan forefathers the wife dresses up as Hester Prynne and I put on my minister outfit and she earns her scarlet letter. Last year she got an A+!

Posted by: logan at November 23, 2011 5:17 PM

I quit making Thanksgiving dinner for my family the year my brother showed up with takeout burritos for himself.

After that, darling hubby and I stayed at University and invited over a bunch of graduate students who either couldn't get home for Thanksgiving, or were from other countries and had never experienced Thanksgiving before. It was pot luck. I'd make the turkey and dressing, and everyone else would bring a dish. One grad student would bring a friend of his every year who came to visit him. We didn't know the friend, but every year we'd make a big fuss about "long time no see." Every year more people would show up. Keep in mind we didn't own a table, so it was just wall to wall people sitting on the floor. Those were the best Thanksgivings we ever had. We often wonder what ever happened to all the people and if they ever wonder what happened to us.

This year, my family doesn't want to get together, again. They're all too pooped and want the day off. So, I'm cooking and bringing the food over to my parents house (as they are too old to drive and not up to all the fuss). Well, I'm bringing all the veggies (as I'm vegetarian). Mom is making the turkey breast, and it's giving her something to do and get excited about.

Posted by: BWeaves at November 23, 2011 5:54 PM

In advance of tomorrow's festivities, I've been making regalia commemorating a genocide with the Boy . I'm in charge of the millinery for the perpetrator, Little Julien is taking care of the same for the victims. Americans are weird.

Posted by: Mrs. Julien at November 23, 2011 6:08 PM

"In advance of tomorrow's festivities, I've been making regalia commemorating a genocide with the Boy . I'm in charge of the millinery for the perpetrator, Little Julien is taking care of the same for the victims. Americans are weird."

Stop being a pussy and stop being an uppity judgmental dipshit.

Thanks.

Posted by: A Guy. at November 23, 2011 6:25 PM

Right on Mrs. Julien!

I hate thanksgiving for the same reason it's becoming more accepted to not recognize columbus day. It celebrates the start of the process of European colonists stealing land from Native Americans. Also, the pilgrims were a bunch of racist Christian fundamentalists.

But the family still celebrates, so I'm having turkey with them like everyone else tomorrow anyway.

Posted by: Patrick the Bunny at November 23, 2011 6:49 PM

Oh, I'm having turkey. I'm not a complete idiot.

Posted by: Mrs. Julien at November 23, 2011 6:58 PM

I like to ignore Thanksgiving history just like I ignore Christmas history. I get to be with people I'm fond of and eat good food until I'm semi-comatose. I prefer not to dig any deeper than that.

Also, if you don't like turkey, you're cooking it wrong. Turkey is tasty.

Posted by: Anne At Large at November 23, 2011 6:59 PM

You already got Columbus Day (and I'm glad to give it. Let's hear it for Indigenous People's Day).

You can't have Thanksgiving. I'm not giving it to you.

Enjoy your turkey, Tofurky, Turducken, or burrito, everybody.

Posted by: twig at November 23, 2011 7:05 PM

I will go to someone else's house and gladly (for the most part) eat whatever they provide. To do otherwise is colossal assholishness. Other than genuine food allergies, I see no reason to expect people to provide you a "special" meal. I don't sit around and bitch about how much I don't like something, either, I just either eat a little or don't partake of that particular item.

But if I ever host a Thanksgiving, I'm not serving a goddam roast turkey. If someone else wants to bring one, fine. But I'm serving ribs.

Fuck tradition. Roast turkey is overrated by a very large extent.

It's not a political thing, I just don't really like the turkey, the cranberries, the pumpkin or pecan pie. I'm cool with the rest of it.

Posted by: Slash at November 23, 2011 8:25 PM


Yay, Wichita!

Posted by: scotankhamen at November 23, 2011 8:52 PM

This year the giant family Thanksgiving got cancelled, so we get to have all our favorite things with my husband's immediate family (including my adorable nieces), and the only non-vegetarian dish will be the turkey! I'm doing a happy dance!

Posted by: McSquish at November 23, 2011 9:04 PM

This is usually my favorite time of year, and my favorite holiday.

But not this year.

My family is spread out all over the continental US. My younger sister, who has had some mental health issues in the past, has been going through a stressful time at school, and her husband got a job that requires working in town during the week and staying with her on the weekends. We all live pretty far away from one another, but I was able to get to my grandma's for Thanksgiving, my brother ended up at mom's, and she was going to spend Thanksgiving with her in-laws, and they do not get along. At all.

So tonight? She got in a fight with her husband and then proceeded to threaten to kill herself. She attempted suicide in college, so her husband took her threat seriously.

He called the EMTs to take her to the hospital for a psych evaluation.

So just fuck it.

Fuck this holiday in the ass.

All of a sudden, the fact that my mom is in Des Moines, I'm in butt-fuck Illinois with my dad and grandma, my boyfriend is five hours away with his family, and my sister is in New England is not just an inconvenience and a bittersweet "Aww, miss you on Thanksgiving" moment, but is now a fucking chasm that has opened up at my feet. And I have to pretend to my 97 year old grandma that everything is normal after spending twenty minutes alternatively crying with my father and crying on the phone to my boyfriend and just fuck it in the giblets with a turkey baster because this blows. Hard.

Seriously.

I know no family is normal or perfect, and I know that in the grand scheme of things this is going to be a blip on my radar, but I found out about this shit two hours ago and I am finding it hard to be thankful for things. Other than, you know, she just threatened suicide instead of actually trying or god forbid succeeding.

Goddamn.

Life really sucks sometimes.

Posted by: linny at November 23, 2011 11:38 PM

With all due respect to Pieces of April, which is a nice little movie, the best Thanksgiving movie is Planes, Trains, and Automobiles. It epitomizes the craziness that is Thanksgiving travel, and the breadth of emotions wrapped up in the holiday.

Posted by: appwitch at November 24, 2011 1:48 AM

"Stop being a pussy and stop being an uppity judgmental dipshit.

Thanks."


Hey A Guy - too cowardly to post under your usual handle? How about you stop being a whiny little pissant and fuck off?

Posted by: Ender at November 24, 2011 5:19 AM

Right there with ya, Mrs. Julien.

Posted by: zeke the pig at November 24, 2011 6:24 AM

linny,

I'm sorry about your family crisis. Coming from a dysfunctional family myself, I can relate. I hope things get better for you soon.

Posted by: rlr260 at November 24, 2011 8:23 AM

It's not pie, and it's virtual, but I would like to offer a moral support hug to linny.

Posted by: Mrs. Julien at November 24, 2011 8:56 AM

What is this "Thanksgiving" you speak of?

Posted by: FabMax at November 24, 2011 9:52 AM

All families are dysfunctional. All holidays bring out the worst in them. Inevitably, the sum becomes larger than its' parts. Linney, here's a virtual goblet of Merlot to go with the pie.

Posted by: cinekat at November 24, 2011 10:38 AM

Whoa there, back up - did you say TWO WORK DAYS DEVOIS OF NEW CONTENT??? That's it. I'm calling in sick.

Posted by: cinekat at November 24, 2011 10:49 AM

We are having pork at casa-de-Slim this year. Enjoy your blood bird.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at November 24, 2011 11:31 AM

I suspect that the turkey is still too frozen to cook (which is our tradition).....except this time it's not my fault!

Posted by: Mrs. SLW at November 24, 2011 11:59 AM

Thanks, yall.

Pajiba is always my refreshing bit of sanity in an insane world.

In an excellent dysfunctional family moment, we've decided to collectively sweep it under the rug and pretend nothing wrong has happened. Joy.

At least the sweet potatoes were good.

Posted by: linny at November 24, 2011 5:08 PM

Jesus, what a bunch of rambling bullshit. Fucking moron.

Posted by: Twat Swap at November 24, 2011 11:33 PM

Mrs. Julien et al., thanksgiving isn't about celebrating genocide (and I know you're not really saying that mrs. J.). It''s about giving thanks. Thanks for the fortune bestowed upon you by things you have no control over. We all have something to be thankful for, whether it's the mother who pushed us out in hours of brutal labor, or the fathers who made us their priority,, or the children who give us unconditional love, or the spouses who give us comfort and who forgive our bullshit, or the stranger who gave us a random kindness, or the genius who invented cats. I'm thankful good wine is relatively cheap and easy to find. I'm thankful for lots of little miracles. Even the most desperate of you have someone or something to be thankful for. Be thankful at least one day a year. Be bitter and cynical the other 364 days a year. But be thankful today.

Linny, glad your day ended better than it started.

A Guy, no need to be an asshole.

If you don't like turkey, you hate America.

Also, watched Super 8 tonight for the first time with Mrs. Greedy. I now have a thorough understanding of lens flare. Thank YOU, J.J. Abrams.

Posted by: Greedy at November 25, 2011 12:31 AM