web
counter
 

Don't You Want Me, Baby?

By Sarah Carlson | Posted Under TV Reviews | Comments (36)



episode-9-joan-peggy-faye.jpg

We hardly knew ye, Miss Ida Blankenship, Don’s venerable if sometimes laughable personal secretary. Roger’s memoirs depict her as a hellcat in her youth, but in her golden years, she, played by Randee Heller, brought us great comedic and memorable one-liners — “It’s a business of sadists and masochists, and you know which one you are,” she said to Peggy just hours before her untimely death. Apt words, Ida. “Mad Men” is all about the give and take of its characters, and Sunday’s “The Beautiful Girls” focused on a variety of relationships and the members’ desires to appeal to their companions, either as friends, lovers, family or co-workers. Ida was always appealing, more so to the viewers than to Don, but he and others at Sterling Cooper Draper Pryce were sad to see her go. Interestingly, her demise was played out in one of the funniest sequences of the series to date — “Weekend at Bernie’s” on 1965 Madison Avenue. The ninth episode of the season, written by Dahvi Waller and series creator Matthew Weiner and directed by Michael Uppendahl, mixed in drama as well, forming a pleasant chapter in the storyline that continued themes explored in last week’s heavier “The Summer Man” as well as bringing us a chance to laugh. How appealing.

Faye and Don are in the early stages of their relationship, meeting up for an afternoon delight at Don’s apartment before heading back to the office, where Roger and Joan are revisiting their past. Roger is flirting with Joan, trying to play cute but coming across as childish, and Joan isn’t interested. Her husband, Greg, has been called up for Vietnam after basic training, which Roger learns from his secretary, Caroline. Roger’s form of apology is sending a team of masseuses to Joan’s apartment that night for a massage, manicure and pedicure — he knew he was “rubbing her the wrong way,” so he thought he’d find those who could do it the “right” way.

Joyce stops by SCDP to invite Peggy out for drinks, a situation Stan enjoys teasing them about, giggling at the idea of them being lesbians. (Well, Joyce is.) At the bar, though, Abe (Charlie Hofheimer) appears, a writer Peggy met and kissed at a party several months before. He tracked her down, which she admits is flattering, and Abe nervously rambles on about his passions involving politics and hating The Man. But when the topic turns to corporations, Peggy is naive about the agency’s clients, even those that are family owned operations such as Fillmore Auto Parts. That business is worse than a corporation, Abe says, because they won’t hire blacks in their Southern stores, actions that have led to boycotts. Peggy has a hard time believing this news, especially since the topic has never come up at work, and she’s equally naive about the interaction of advertising with society. But then she switches gears, pointing out that most of the things blacks can’t do, she can’t do, and “nobody seems to care.” “All right, Peggy, we’ll have a civil rights march for women,” Abe says sarcastically, which prompts her to call it a night.

Abe shows up at the office the next day, saying Peggy inspired him to write a piece titled “Nuremberg on Madison Avenue,” and he waits in the lobby for her to read it. Joan thanks Roger for the massage gift, but when he invites her out to dinner, she’s again frustrated by him — “You’re incapable of doing something nice without expecting something nicer in return.” Don, Faye and Kenny have a meeting with the owners of Fillmore Auto Parts, who need a campaign to help them reach out to more customers (albeit white ones). Faye’s research shows that “domesticated suburbanites still have a primitive desire to get their hands dirty” and will spend good money at a store such as Fillmore’s to gain that satisfaction. Leonard Fillmore isn’t so sure, throwing out classist comments to Don and Kenny assuming they, as suits, wouldn’t know the first thing about car mechanics. Besides, a blue collar worker might not want to keep shopping at Fillmore’s if they see white collars such as Don around. Leonard’s co-workers object, saying the business needs to reach out to more customers. Kenny’s idea to combine both sides with the strategy, “It’s where the pros go, and everyone’s welcome,” is quickly squashed by Don. He points out that the phrase is two strategies connected by an “and,” and he tells the Fillmores to agree on a strategy before they can continue. The office’s main secretary, Megan (Jessica Pare), interrupts the meeting to get Don.

Sally is in the front reception area, having been brought in by an older woman who found her alone and without money on a commuter train. Sally ran away because she didn’t want to wait two weekends to see Don, she says, and he sends her back to his office as he talks to the lady. Back in his office (“She looks so chubby in the pictures!” Blankenship says about Sally as Don walks past), he phones Betty, who says Sally’s psychiatrist suggested that Sally walk from camp to her doctor’s appointment by herself. “Great idea,” he says. “Thank you, psychiatry.” “Don’t yell at me. She needs to learn responsibility,” Betty says. “You need to learn responsibility,” Don fires back, and Betty says he can just keep looking after Sally until the next evening. Don orders Sally to remain in his office while he rejoins the Fillmore meeting. Meanwhile, Peggy charges out to reception to confront Abe, still sitting there. His piece is incendiary and mentions Fillmore Auto Parts, an aspect that could get Peggy fired, she says, if it’s printed. He says that she’s too good to be wasting her talent as a part of the corporate machine — though she’s not a “war criminal” as are others lambasted in his piece. “You’re not supposed to be insulted, you’re supposed to be flattered,” Abe says, then saying he must have been wrong in his assumptions about Peggy.

Peggy storms back to the office and tries to talk to Blankenship, who is sitting motionless at her desk, her head tilted slightly backward. Peggy tries to rouse her, touching her shoulder, but that just sends Ida crashing forward, forehead to desk. She’s dead. Peggy is shocked and begins rushing around, and soon Megan interrupts Don’s meeting again to tell him about Ida. Joan, Peggy and Caroline are around Ida’s desk, teary-eyed, and they try to decide who to call. Joan says she’ll need a man to help her move Ida, as well as a blanket — there’s one in Harry’s office. Don returns to the Fillmore meeting but can see Ida slumped at her desk through the conference room windows. Behind the Fillmore executives, a farce plays out while Faye tells Don that they’ve decided on a strategy — “For the mechanic in every man.” He’s too busy watching Pete and Joan try to maneuver Ida out from behind her desk and wheel her down the hall, covered in a blanket. Harry arrives in time to call out, “My mother made that!” Megan goes over to Ida’s desk, hands in gloves, to remove the calendar her head had been resting upon. She carries it at arm’s length.

Out of the meeting, Don asks Faye to take Sally back to his apartment and sit with her, which Faye is clearly nervous about. “Hello, my name is Faye,” she says to Sally after Don has already introduced her and left. “I know. My dad just said that,” Sally replies. Ida is wheeled out on a gurney past stunned employees, including Roger and Bert, and Joan follows Roger back to his office. He doesn’t want to die in this office, he says, not like that. “She died like she lived — surrounded by the people she answered phones for.” Joan tries to hold back a smile, and she finally agrees to have dinner with him. Faye and Sally are watching TV at Don’s when he returns, and later that night, Sally asks Don if she can ask him a question. “Yes, I’m still mad at you,” is his immediate reply, but she really wants to know if he’s going to marry Faye. He doesn’t even concede that she’s his girlfriend, but after clever questioning by Sally, Don says that Faye is someone Sally might be seeing again. “Oh,” Sally says.

At dinner, Roger reaches for Joan’s hand and tells her he wishes she would confide in him more. Greg doesn’t like it, Joan says, but Roger says that when he thinks of his life, all of the “good stuff” was with Joan. When they leave, they walk, even though Joan doesn’t like the neighborhood. Sure enough, the two are held up, and the robber takes their jewelry and Joan’s purse. (Did he have to be a black guy, Weiner? The only black person we see all episode? Come on.) Joan panics and Roger takes her around a corner to calm her down, and she quickly kisses him. They keep kissing, and as she tells him not to stop, they have sex.

At Don’s, Sally tells him she wants to live with him all the time, which Don says isn’t possible. He puts her to bed in one of his white undershirts, and he wakes up the next morning to find her making French toast. “What’s on this?” he asks as he takes a bite. “Mrs. Buttersworth,” she says. “Go get it.” As she hands him the “syrup,” he says, “That’s rum. Read labels.” “Is it bad?” she asks. “Not really,” he says, both surprised and approving of the taste as he keeps eating. With very little arm twisting, Sally convinces him to spend the morning with her. Their mutual love for each other is evident, and this is the happiest we’ve seen Sally. She can be herself around her father.

At the office, Joan helps Bert and Roger write Ida’s obituary, the men not knowing what to say and annoyed with themselves for it. “She was born in 1898 in a barn. She died on the 37th floor of a skyscraper. She’s an astronaut,” Bert comments as he leaves Roger’s office. Roger takes the moment to confront Joan about their night, apologizing, but Joan says she isn’t sorry. She’s married, however, and it can’t happen again. “I feel something,” Roger says. “I know you do.” After spending what seems to be all day with Sally, she and Don return to the office to wait for Betty and Don has a meeting with Peggy and Stan to discuss the Fillmore strategy. The clients apparently want a jingle for their ads, and Peggy and Stan list off names of potential singers for the song. Peggy suggests they use the black singer Harry Belafonte, an idea Stan laughs off. She asks why they work for a company that doesn’t hire blacks, but Don’s only answer is that “Our job is to make men like Fillmore Auto, not Fillmore Auto like negroes.”

Sally doesn’t want to leave Don and return to Betty, screaming “No, I’m not going! I’m not leaving! I hate it there!” Don again enlists Faye’s help to deal with Sally, but Sally tells Faye to shut up and runs out of Don’s office. As she heads down the hall, she trips and falls face first, and her commotion has already brought Don, Faye, Peggy, Joan and Megan running. Megan quickly picks Sally up and holds her, telling her everything will be OK, as the rest watch, stunned. She and Don lead Sally out to reception toward to waiting Betty, whose impatience comes across as cruel to the women who have gathered. Don just looks at Betty, seeing what Sally sees. Don tells Sally goodbye, and Sally closes off yet again, turning from screaming to indifferent in a manner she no doubt learned from her mother. Don heads back to his office, where Faye is upset with him for twice putting her in the awkward position of having to take care of Sally. She had wondered if she would meet his children, she says, but while she loves kids, she’s not good with them. “It feels like there was a test, and I failed it,” she says, but Don holds her and reassures her that that is not the case. They make plans to have dinner that weekend.

Peggy is in her office, drinking, when Joyce shows up. Joyce is sorry for the set-up with Abe, but says that Peggy shouldn’t be surprised by his actions — he’s a man, after all, she says. Joyce compares men to soup and women to pots — “Who wants to be a pot?” she says. Peggy isn’t interested in going out for drinks. “Are you angry or lovesick?” Joyce asks. “I don’t know,” Peggy replies.

At day’s end, Joan, Faye and Peggy end up on the same elevator going down together, all trying to figure out where they fit in with the men in their lives.

Ida’s death sequence was almost unbelievable, given that it was occurring during the self-serious “Mad Men.” But that was the series of the past, as Weiner has made clear this season. He’s found a way to entertain the audience and appeal to what we know makes a smart show — drama that knows when to be funny. His characters have never been so compelling.

Sarah Carlson has a front-row seat to the decline of the newspaper industry and lives in Alabama with her overly excitable Pembroke Welsh Corgi.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Alpha and Omega Review | Just Another Date-Rapey Wolf Movie | Alpha and Omega Review | Just Another Date-Rapey Wolf Movie









Comments

Kiernan Shipka is a fantastic actress. Sally was being bratty but I felt so bad for her since both of her parents suck. I also wonder if Megan will have a bigger role in the future since I still don't know what to make of her being the only one to comfort Sally after she fell.

Loved the Joan/Roger scenes as well but I don't want them getting together.

Line of the night goes to Harry: My mom made that!

Posted by: Snrub at September 20, 2010 2:07 PM

Sally was being bratty on the surface but I think underneath it she was on the verge of a panic attack. She clearly is absolutely miserable with her mother and Henry: you have to wonder if she gets any attention at all, and she probably had convinced herself she could stretch out the visit with her dad indefinitely. It turned out what she needed most was a hug and only a complete stranger was able to see that. She's such a lost kid. You just know the drug era is going to consume her in a few years.

Posted by: PaddyDog at September 20, 2010 2:14 PM

I got the feeling Megan was the only one Sally would allow to comfort her at the end, as she was the only one who was being nice to her without trying to tell her what to do.

Abe just completely did not get why Peggy was so upset. She's had to fight enough battles to get where she is. She doesn't necessarily have the ammunition for another one.

Posted by: Todd at September 20, 2010 2:14 PM

Don't you wish they used to have recaps like this for "McMillan and Wife"?

Posted by: Mrs. Julien at September 20, 2010 2:25 PM

I accept that many people like Peggy a lot more than I do, but I'm sick of this myth that she had to fight battles to get where she is. She was a secretary who liked one lipstick so Don super-promoted her into Creative. She had the least fight of any woman I'm aware of who developed a career during those years. Contrast her with Faye who openly admits she had to choose to not have children and remain single in order to further her career. Faye knows she had to make hard choices and that she's judged because of them. Peggy lucked in to where she is.

Posted by: PaddyDog at September 20, 2010 2:31 PM

A comment on a different review site, made reference to the final scene where you see Don barking at Mrs. Blankenship, as viewed from her perspective. Its entirely possible that this is during her stroke, and illustrates how he fails to notice anything being wrong. Just kinda cements the gap between the men, and the women.

Posted by: tariq at September 20, 2010 2:36 PM

Did she have a stroke? I think her body posture was wrong for a stroke. It looked more like a massive heart attack.
I also thought it was strange that we saw Megan taking away the desk pad with gloves on but then wheeling the chair back and sitting down in it because when people die they lose control of functions and that chair would not have been pleasant.

Posted by: PaddyDog at September 20, 2010 2:42 PM

I thought it might be a new chair.

Posted by: coveredinbees at September 20, 2010 2:47 PM

The three women in the elevator in the header pic in addition to the boy issues -

a. wants to have baby, being told to wait
b. had baby, not able to keep it
c. chose not to have babies for sake of career

plus d. Betty has babies she resents

I want to slap Joan whenever she goes near Roger. He didn't choose you last time, why are you going near him this time?

Who do you think Betty fooled by telling Sally, "I missed you" in the lobby when everyone had come to get a look at the gorgon who made that poor child freak out? How hard do you think Sally go slapped in the elevator? Sally is going to love the drug culture, but Betty will beat her to it when she discovers Valium.

Posted by: Mrs. Julien at September 20, 2010 2:50 PM

Peggy didn't exactly fight her way to the top, but she does eat a lot of shit to stay in the middle. So I'm not too hard on her.

I don't know why Megan was tearing up at the end of the episode. Just a delayed reaction to the overall stress of the day, or something else?

I did love the three women in the elevator at the end: the one who uses her femininity to work the system, the one who gave up a big chunk of it to beat the system, and the one who still thinks she can have it both ways.

Posted by: Wednesday at September 20, 2010 2:53 PM

1. Ah crap! They killed off one of the best minor characters ever. I loved Mrs. Blankenship. And while her death definitely was a humor high point in the episode, it's also all over. Sigh!

2. The rum on the french toast bit actually made me laugh out loud. Darling hubby actually came out of the back room to see what I was laughing at, but by then the bit was over.

3. I loved Sally's part this episode, but please, quit putting so much eye makeup on her. She's still a little girl. Let her look like one. Even I don't wear that much eyeliner and mascara. Although I did wear that dress she was wearing in 1965. My sister and cousin had matching dresses.

4. I keep feeling like they're priming Megan for a bigger part, and I've felt that way for several episodes.

5. I thought it was rather prophetic that both Joan and Roger have their wedding bands removed this episode. I think Roger will push, and Joan will be lonely and go alone with it.

6. I think Faye is good for Don. She's mature and sexy, and knows what she needs to be. She's not a housewife, like Betty. She's an equal. I also relate to her not being good with children.

Posted by: BWeaves at September 20, 2010 2:58 PM

Anyone else find it funny that while we are discussing women and their pigeon-holing in 1960s society, WalMart is wooing us with their Swiffer aisle ads?

Posted by: PaddyDog at September 20, 2010 3:03 PM

The actor that played Abe was in an episode of Law and Order SVU years ago in which he had an extreme foot fetish and killed a girl so he could cut off and keep her feet. I cannot look at him without thinking of that, so right away, I figured things with Abe would go south.

I didn't love last week's ep with Don's journal narration, so this episode made me happy, especially when at one point he made out like he was about to write in the journal and closed it instead.

Shirnan Kipka is really shining this season with the extra screen time Sally is getting.

Posted by: Katie at September 20, 2010 3:03 PM

I think if Peggy didn't have an ear for the jingle or the successful ad line she would have been back to answering phones immediately. She may have lucked into the break she got but I think she's risen through the ranks because her talent can't be dismissed and because she and Don make a better team together than either of them could be alone.
I really like Don and Peggy's relationship. I like seeing a strong friendship of mostly-equals between a man and a woman on TV without stupid romantic story lines ruining everything.
I also really like that Peggy's rise has given Joan permission to reach for more.

Posted by: king at September 20, 2010 3:04 PM

Question: Hey Mrs. Julien, why don't you watch those police procedurals on TV? They are so entertaining.

Answer: ...an episode of Law and Order SVU years ago in which he had an extreme foot fetish and killed a girl so he could cut off and keep her feet.


Posted by: Mrs. Julien at September 20, 2010 3:10 PM

King:

Agreed that she has talent that kept her there after her lucky break but comparing her "struggle" with that of Black people in the south, to a Jewish guy who despite being male and White is kept out of the same profession she is in by virtue of religion is more than insulting.

Posted by: PaddyDog at September 20, 2010 3:10 PM

Can we have a moment of silence for Harry Crane's blanket? His mother made that!

Posted by: coveredinbees at September 20, 2010 3:14 PM

And the winner is...Sally Draper! Yeah, Ida was funny, but Sally's story this episode was heartbreaking.

Regarding the makeup, I noticed that too but saw it as intentional: a way to make her look even more like her mother. It's terrible to see a powerless child who wants nothing more than to escape a life of neglect and abuse, but it's even more terrible to realize she's going to become her abusive mother.

This was, I think, my favorite episode of Mad Men this season, and possibly ever.

And also? I hate Joan and Roger together. Something about their personalities together rubs me the wrong way.

Posted by: Vince Noir at September 20, 2010 3:29 PM

I often skip to the comments on these posts (I prefer reviews over recaps, myself). But I did read the recap today, and I noticed a few details that were lacking. The big one is Sally's reaction to falling down - latching on to Megan and crying that "everything is not alright" - was one of the most important moments in the episode.

Posted by: shell at September 20, 2010 3:52 PM

Please, oh please, oh please, God, don't let Joan get sucked into Roger's bullshit. She's too smart for that. He picked that drunken Barbie doll, Jane, over her last time and the only reason that he's sniffing after Joan now is that he's feeling his mortalitiy. I can't stand that husband of hers, but I don't want her ending up with someone who consistently sees her as Plan B, either.

And as for Sally, I know she was being a brat, but I'd love for them to speed the series up even more so that I can see the look on Betty's face when Sally comes home with no bra in a van that says "Free Love" on the side that's driven by her black boyfriend.

Posted by: Carolina Girl at September 20, 2010 4:23 PM

Kiernan Shipka takes every scene she's in, folds it up, sticks it in her pocket, and walks away. I can't believe, in a show that examines office gender politics with such gratifying depth, that it's the kid storyline that I look forward to the most.

Posted by: sansho1 at September 20, 2010 6:18 PM

My favorite line last night: “I would have my secretary do it, but she’s dead.”

Sally is my new favorite character. The kid has spunk and she was reading Nancy Drew. And she pours rum on breakfast foods. Love her!

For Sally's sake I hope Megan is put on Don's desk and he marries her. Then he can have the kids come live with him in the city and Sally can have a nice mommy.

So were Cooper and Mrs. Blankenship bumping uglies back in the day? He knew where she was born, after all. Was that alluded to in previous episodes and I missed it?

When Roger and Joan had their impromptu tryst I immediately wondered if we were going to see a pregnancy scare in future episodes. Can you imagine Joan trying to convince her husband that it is his ("Sure, honey, lots of women have pregnancies that last for 10 months, especially when it is their first.") and then the baby is born with a head full of gray hair. So busted!

Posted by: Cookie at September 20, 2010 7:05 PM

"Freddy" is actually Harry Crane.

Posted by: Nika at September 20, 2010 7:20 PM

Good catch, Nika. It has been corrected.

Posted by: Sarah Carlson at September 20, 2010 8:00 PM

Paddy, you are approximately 47 shades of awesome. That said......I'm glad we're not watching this together.

Posted by: sansho1 at September 20, 2010 10:20 PM

Where did everyone get the idea that Roger picked Jane over Joan? Joan made it perfectly clear in the 1st season that the thing with Roger was just temporary until she found a serious relationship. I certainly don't think that if Roger had offered to dump his wife for Joan she would have said yes. She knew exactly the kind of reception the 2nd wife would get, and she wants to be respectable. I think Joan was already engaged to the jackass when Roger took up with Jane.

The thing with Faye was ridiculous. She's been on one date and an afternoon delight with Don, and she's already thinking about meeting his kids? And when Don wants Faye to talk to his child instead of dealing with her himself, she gets upset about what she thinks is a test, instead of being mad that he can't (or doesn't want to) deal with his kids?

Posted by: Three-nineteen at September 20, 2010 11:05 PM

Also, when I saw Megan had asked Pete to move Mrs. Blankenship, I thought to myself "Joan asked you to get a man, not a weasel."

Posted by: Three-nineteen at September 20, 2010 11:26 PM

Ida’s death sequence was almost unbelievable, given that it was occurring during the self-serious “Mad Men.” But that was the series of the past, as Weiner has made clear this season.

don't you remember when the english guy's foot got cut off by the lawnmower? or when freddie peed his pants in the office? or roger singing in blackface at the garden party? this series has had its fair share of outrageous moments.

Posted by: carolyn at September 20, 2010 11:55 PM

I'm starting to feel sorry for Joan. The world in which she's a smart and in control is evolving into someplace else, and the more she holds on to her outdated, increasingly delusional construct of "dignity", the more it erodes. Roger has always been a silly man, and Joan knows it. He's even sillier now with his stupid, self-important memoirs. It's hard to tell if Joan genuinely likes him, or if fucking him reminds her of when she felt like more of a goddess.

In the end, I'm not sure which would be more pathetic.

Posted by: June Velcro at September 21, 2010 2:38 AM

June Velcro: Very well said. I mentioned there was something I didn't like about that pair but I haven't seen the rest of the series for so long I couldn't place it.

I hate seeing Joan like this. Her power has been stripped away. Of course, her power was mostly sex, but that makes it all the more horrifying that she now has none. What is this woman? Where is my Yo-Sa-Bridge?!

Posted by: Vince Noir at September 21, 2010 4:34 AM

Three-nineteen:

There is a scene in season one where Joan and Roger are in a hotel room post-coital and he says something about not leaving his wife and JOan's face falls and after that she starts dating Dr Rapist. I think she didn't realize until Jane came along that Roger would even consider leaving his wife.

Posted by: PaddyDog at September 21, 2010 8:11 AM

I like what they're doing with Joan. Especially when you think back to her superiority of the early episodes, how she really did try to show Peggy the ropes like a "Shanghai madame". We've all liked Joan in the past because she seemed to know how to navigate a bad situation and make it look not only like it's on her own terms, but beautiful and elegant -- the woman behind the men of Sterling Cooper and now Cooper Draper Price -- but her relationship with her husband puts the lie to that. Every episode it becomes clearer that her carefully constructed persona is becoming obsolete, and she can't adjust.

Excellent storytelling, I think.

Posted by: June Velcro at September 21, 2010 8:21 AM

I don't like Faye.
It's nice to get the female that's successful and not that affected by "I need to date/ I want kids/ I don't want kids/ guys don't like me"....
Or maybe I just thought she was like that because we didn't see much of her. Now I just think she's annoying and the little breakdown with Don over Sally was very much unecessary.
It was just a talk. Didn't go very well, everybody was stressed. Get over it, woman! Not about you...

Posted by: Mariazinha at September 21, 2010 9:34 AM

The Ida sequence played like the season 1 episode where Roger is forced to climb all the stairs and projectile vomits everywhere. Mad Men has always had it's "Really?" comedy moments. Remember the awe over the copy machine in season 2 juxtaposed against Pete's father's death? And don't even get me started on the camp of Betty running over a bird bath in season 1. Whenever there's a very heavy story line, the show throws in some really ridiculous comedy to make it palatable.

Speaking of the heavy story line, I'll concede the black robber was a bit heavy-handed as a through-line to Peggy's discovery that the agency doesn't care about the racial politics of one of its clients, but that's Matt Weiner for you. He. Wants. You. To. Get. It.

Posted by: Robert at September 21, 2010 9:55 AM

One thing I find remarkable about Sally is how much her inflections are almost exactly like her mother's. She really sounds like the daughter of Betty Draper!

I loved loved loved this episode, and the final scene, where the three women are framed by the elevator, was high art!

Posted by: jimbob at September 21, 2010 2:14 PM

I adored this episode and its multi-layered themes - obviously, women and children. Also, when life creeps into work, i.e. Ida's death on the job, Abe coming in to bother Peggy, Sally throwing herself on the ground and screaming, Don dating a colleague, etc.

Sally's whole arc just about broke my heart - I was totally misty when she threw herself on the ground and broke down. I can't bear to see a child legitimately in pain. I think this is going to become a shitshow...and I can't wait to watch!

Okay, I'm going to raise a potentially unpopular point: does anybody else think Doctor Rape isn't all that bad? I feel like that's part of the point of his character. I'd honestly rather see Joan with him than with Roger. Sure, the whole rape thing was creepy and a violation. Goes without saying. However, I think he has more respect for Joan than Roger does in that I do think Doctor R. thinks of himself as lucky for having scored her. Roger is totally tone-deaf. Joan was so upset about her engagement ring getting stolen and Roger, in fairness possibly only to make her feel better, said "Anything can be replaced." True, Roger...when you're rich as hell, which Joan isn't! Also, Joan and Dr. R. have had legitimately tender moments and Joan, plainly, conceives of him as a partner, i.e. asking "Who am I going to talk to?" when he was leaving, having legitimate fights with him as an equal, etc. I don't know. I don't think their marriage is all that terrible, given the times. I'd actually say that it's among the more functional on the show.

Questions for the crowd: does anybody think that Don and Cosgrove are clashing a bit? I think Don thinks Cosgrove hasn't paid any dues and is irritated by his lack of deference.

Posted by: samantha t at September 23, 2010 10:19 AM