web
counter
 

The Bean Trees by Barbara Kingsolver

By badinage | Posted Under Book Reviews | Comments (9)



barbara kingsolver agb 2009s-322x242.gif

Marietta “Missy” Greer lives in a small Kentucky town and has so far avoided the usual trappings of pregnancy and marriage. With her mother’s blessing, she buys an old car and decides to go as far as it will take her before breaking down. Along the way to her eventual stop of Tucson, Arizona, she picks up a new name and a new child.

Originally named after the place she was conceived, she takes a chance and names herself Taylor after the first town her car runs out of gas. While traveling through the Cherokee Nation in Oklahoma, Taylor is handed a child to keep. She soon realizes the woman gave her the child for safekeeping after she finds signs of abuse.

Together they make their way to Arizona before their journey is halted by ruined tires that Taylor cannot afford to replace. Taylor plans to work and save to continue on, but she instead finds a new home and family.

The importance of names is a continuing theme throughout the novel. Missy began when young Marietta demanded to be called “Miss.” She then shed her given name as she ran from a life expected of her. The young child was called Turtle due to her behavior, and then later she was given the name April as a new beginning. Taylor meets a young couple who ran from danger in Guatemala. They dropped their original Indian names for the more acceptable Spanish names Estevan and Esperanza after their political climate shifted. Once they were force to flee Guatemala (and leave a child behind), they changed them again to Steven and Hope.

This book’s political focus is on the issue of illegal immigration. More specifically, the illegal immigration of people whose lives are in danger from corrupt governments. Regardless of their situations, they are deported to face near certain torture and death whenever they are caught in the U.S. Mattie is a friend and employer to Taylor. She is part of an underground movement that houses and helps refugees move to safer locations.

Taylor has to decide where she stands while facing legal issues of her own. She is forced to legalize her custody of April or lose her to the state, and that journey involves searching for her birth parents.

I think this book was better paced than The Poisonwood Bible which dragged after the first half. It ended strongly, though bittersweet, without relying on clichés. The Bean Trees is also a timely read in the midst of the current immigration debates as it offers a view from the other side of the fence.

This review is part of the Cannonball Read series. For more of Diana’s reviews, check out her blog, badinage.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Man vs. Woman vs. Geek | A Pajiba Box-Office Contest | Middle-Aged, Suburban White Man Porn | Freakonomics Trailer and the Average Cost of a Handjob









Comments

I read this after I read The Poisonwood Bible, and was struck by how different it is in tone and scope. This is a much easier, 'breezier' read, even though it does involve some heavy subjects at times. I do love it though, it's just not what I was expecting from Kingsolver. After reading some of her others I found them to be more similar to Bean Trees. This is an enjoyable book, and I really liked Taylor and the other characters. The follow up, Pigs in Heaven, is good too, but not quite on a par with this.

Posted by: Carrie at August 13, 2010 9:15 AM

why woman has no right to have a sugardaddy? and why guys can't have a younger women to spoil? I support all these.
____S u g a r D a d d y H u n t __C_O_M

This club is for those of us that don't discriminate! This is to all my people who don't care about somebody's ethnic background, just how they are on the inside.

If you want to find a sincere relationship. If you are serious. Come and join us!

Posted by: wolton at August 13, 2010 10:57 AM

I think this book is really lovely.
Maybe this is kind of lame, but I find books a lot more enjoyable if they have some humor to them, even when dealing with heavy issues, and this book has a lot of great humor.

Posted by: bat at August 13, 2010 3:14 PM

It's important to contextualize the immigration discussin in the Bean Trees. While certainly applicable to today's current climate, the Bean Trees takes place in the early eighties when people were fleeing the contras in Nicaragua and Guatemala. This theme pops up in other Kingsolver books, including Animal Dreams. The Bean Trees was her first novel and, while I love the book, I find it nowhere near as rich or complex as the Poisonwood Bible.

Posted by: kate at August 13, 2010 5:16 PM

I think I read this many years ago when I was fourteen or fifteen. Can someone refresh my memory - is this the one where the little girl replaces the woman's shampoo with depilatory?

If I'm thinking of the right story, I do recall laughing out loud a few times, once to the point of tears. I may have to give this a re-read just to remember what it was that made me laugh.

Posted by: neurotica at August 13, 2010 5:30 PM

How very strange. I just finished The Bean Trees today and I honestly didn't even know that this was Pajiba's current Cannonball Read!

This is the only Kingsolver novel I've ever read so I can't compare it with her other works, but I was really moved by this book. The scene where Taylor and Estevan are talking about Ismene after Esperanza attempts suicide made me cry a little while I was reading it on the bus (embarrassing!). This scene really put into perspective the different levels (and perhaps depth is the right word?) of disaster that each of the characters were dealing with. While Taylor struggles with homesickness, sudden motherhood, and an inappropriate attraction, Estevan--whom we had only known to struggle from his illegal immigration problems up to that point--has been struggling with the contra, his conscience, and his wife's subsequent suicidal tendencies. Taylor's (and likely the reader's) problems pale in comparison. While Estevan's experience with the Guatemalan contra is not the same as today's immigration debate, the problems faced by Estevan and Esperanza are certainly comparable to the problems facing illegal immigrants in the U.S. today.

My only real qualm with this book is that Taylor doesn't quite feel like a truly developed character. I mean, I basically understand her but she was painted with really broad strokes. I hope that Kingsolver overcame this defect with her later works.

Posted by: LadyHazard at August 13, 2010 6:45 PM

Read this book in college and grew up in Arizona. Loved it for its descriptions of daily life in the American southwest. I remember Taylor saying something like, "I stopped in Tucson because I had never seen clouds that looked like purple elephants." I miss that crazy-ass state sometimes. Miss the sunsets. Great book about finding yourself in unexpected ways.

Posted by: Groovy Violet at August 16, 2010 3:04 PM

I¡¯m delighted that I have noticed this weblog. Lastly anything not a junk, which we undergo incredibly frequently. The website is lovingly serviced and stored up to date. So it have to be, thank you for sharing this with us.

Posted by: colon cleanser at March 18, 2011 6:06 AM

*I am often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has really peaks my interest. I am going to bookmark your site and keep checking for new information.

Posted by: Tyson Mike T at March 22, 2011 5:05 PM