free counter with statistics "Weeds" Season 5 Review | Pajiba - Scathing Reviews for Bitchy People

weedsparker.jpg
What Happened to the Ticky Tacky Little Boxes?


"Weeds" Season Five / Dustin Rowles

TV Reviews | June 17, 2009 | Comments (42)


What the hell happened to “Weeds”? It is an absolute shit show. It’s terrible now. It jumped the helicopter hovering over the shark two seasons ago, and now it’s in a free fall. When the inevitable SRL comes out ranking the five shows that were once good but have lost it, “Weeds” may get the lifetime achievement award. It’s depraved bunk, a vile misogynistic sitcom that’s more about showing Mary Louise Parker’s bare ass than anything else. Nancy Botwin used to be a likable, sympathetic, well-developed character. Now she’s just a pair of legs and a hidey-hole for abusive pricks.

Five seasons ago, “Weeds” debuted with a novel concept: A widower, Nancy Botwin (Mary Louis Parker), with no real marketable skills, attempts to keep her family living the lush suburban life by selling a few ounces of weed to the neighborhood blazers and a few soccer moms. Her rebellious son, Silas, was in love with a deaf girl; her younger son, Shane, was a precocious, socially-ostracized grade schooler trying to deal with bullies while coping with the loss of his father. Everybody else was comic relief: Kevin Nealon played a herb-smoking city councilor who couldn’t keep his dick in his pants; Elizabeth Perkins, as Celia, was the stick-in-her-but suburban shrew and president of the PTA; and Justin Kirk’s Andy was, as the irresponsible uncle left to watch after the kids, the best reason to watch the show. “Weeds” was a small, intimate dramedy about a dope-slinging housewife, but it was really a biting satire on suburban life, complete with a brilliant theme song, “Little Boxes,” that not only captured the spirit of the show, but provided a good deal of its thematic resonance. All in all, it was a fun alternative to “Desperate Housewives.”

Now? Nothing from the original season remains, including that theme song — the tone has shifted (it’s no longer funny, for one); the satire is nil; and the characters are the same only in name. It went off the deep end. I thought after Season Three, when the entire suburban community she was from burned to the ground, the show runners would take the opportunity to reboot the show, get it back to its roots, and focus on the difficulties involved raising a family and maintaining appearances while selling just enough reefer to keep the mortgage paid. Instead, in season four, “Weeds” just ratcheted up the increasingly unbelievable dramatic developments and sunk Nancy deeper into criminal enterprises.

The result: The prudish housewife once reluctant to sleep with anyone after her husband died has become something of a whorish drug kingpin, recently assisting in running a front for the transport of illegal aliens, and fucking the corrupt mayor of Mexico City, who wanted her dead after he discovered she ratted him out to the authorities. The catch? Nancy was pregnant with the mayor’s child, and now the mayor can’t decide whether to kill her or fuck her. Meanwhile, Silas has gotten involved in the family business, creating his own special strains of marijuana while trying to find a suitable place to grow it (this after carrying on a sexual relationship with someone his mother’s age last season). What Kevin Nealon is still doing on the show is a bit of a mystery — he just stands around and smokes up, oblivious to everything around him. Andy, who came completely out of left field and professed his love for Nancy, is now fucking Nancy vicariously through her sister (Jennifer Jason Leigh), a wine-soused house mom who has been left to care for Shane, who has nothing left to do but embarrassingly go through puberty on camera. Most ridiculous of all? Celia’s older daughter, who just appeared out of nowhere, kidnapped Celia at the end of last season with the assistance of a Mexican Rebel Leader, with the intent to ransom her back to her family. Now the former PTA president and city councilor appears to be falling in love with that Rebel Leader and arranging his machete’s in order of size. That’s how far this show has traveled.

“Weeds” completely strains credibility, and what’s worse is that this suburban comedy has taken a needlessly dark turn into nihilistic sex and violence. I got no problem with sex and violence, obviously. But it doesn’t make sense in the context of this show, or at least the original version of it that we were fond of. People are frequently capped, and in this week’s half-hour show alone, there were two sex scenes, one of which was cold and violent. Where’s the lighthearted and smart comedy in that? Worse: Nancy, at one time, was doing all of this for her family. Now there’s not even the pretense that she’s a decent mother. She’s not just a horrible mom, she’s a bad fucking person, the occasional crises of consciousness notwithstanding. She’s not just allowed her older son to sell dope, she’s encouraged it, and she’s basically abdicated responsibility for Shane, who has been moved to her sister’s while she waits to get capped and/or fucked.

I understood, I suppose, at the end of season two when Nancy’s DEA boyfriend got a bullet in the head, that “Weeds” would never be able to turn back. It became trapped by its own dramatic momentum, and each season since, it’s had to sink Nancy deeper and deeper into the cesspool of depravity. But it’s gone too far now — the characters aren’t relatable or sympathetic anymore. And instead of being a comedic satire, “Weeds” has become soulless and misanthropic. It’s lost its vision, and at this point, it’s too late to reclaim it.

Dustin Rowles is the publisher of Pajiba. You can email him or leave a comment below.


DVD Sequels You Didn't Even Know Existed | HawthoRNe



Comments

The world is full of little boxes of stuff. No one cares.

-- Steve Wynn

Posted by: Tracer Bullet at June 17, 2009 4:02 PM

Widower? I've seen enough of her body to know that's a lie.

Posted by: Snath at June 17, 2009 4:18 PM

I've never seen this show, but I always knew Mary Louis Parker was in and still looking fine. Now I find out that Elizabeth Perkins and Jennifer Jason Leigh are also in this show?

Hrmm... Me thinks I will have to find some way to watch the earlier, apparently decent seasons for certain, and maybe just fast fowrward the later seasons to those scenes showing Mary Louise Parker’s bare ass.

Thanks!

Posted by: Forbiddendonut at June 17, 2009 4:19 PM

Also, I agree completely. It's really, really sad, but I agree.

Posted by: Snath at June 17, 2009 4:22 PM

I stopped watching after the season 3 finale. There's just no joy in watching it now.

Posted by: Julie at June 17, 2009 4:26 PM

I've never seen this show.

I remember sometime last year seeing a clip of her and a mexican dude in a limo-zeen and the dude pulls her over and spanks the hell out of her and then throws her out of the car.

What the hell?

Posted by: annoyingmouse at June 17, 2009 4:31 PM

I actually really enjoy the direction the show has been heading lately. As much as I was disappointed in seeing the location and some of the characters change (i.e. Conrad), I found it is a much better locale to represent the direction Nancy is headed as a person and a mother. She was never a good person, let alone a decent mother. She admitted early on, the only reason she became a dealer was to maintain the lifestyle she was acustomed to provided by her late husband. Her concern has been for herself, and only herself since season 1. I think she simply is addicted to the danger. Last nights sex (damn near rape) scene showed that she gets off from causing this much chaos and drama amongst 'dangerous' men. The new location, as well as family members, really help in giving Nancy a fleshed out history as to why she behaves the way she does.

The humor I find to still be very much there, albeit subtle, in the supporting cast, of which none have turned out to be decent people either. They are all along for the ride, almost lured into Nancy's web. I love the direction this season is headed, those ticky tacky boxes were just not exciting enough to contain Nancy Botwin.

Posted by: J Stride at June 17, 2009 4:41 PM

I can't disagree that the show has fallen from its peak but its not as bad as you make it out to be in this review.

There is no false pretense that Nancy is a good mother. The show isn't trying to convince anyone otherwise. All I can say is it couldn't go on anymore in its original premise. They tried to take a few risks, but have mostly failed. One big problem was they tried to keep too much of the original cast when they moved from Agrestic, and now they have to come up with increasingly ludicrous plots to service these characters.

It's still worth a half hour of my time a week (mostly for Doug and Andy), but it isn't nearly as good as it once was.

Posted by: ed newman at June 17, 2009 4:45 PM

they should've shot her at the end of season 2 and finished the series right then. i stopped watching after the first couple of episodes of season three. damn shame. i'm always afraid the same thing'll happen to dexter, but so far so awesomest ever.

Posted by: gem at June 17, 2009 4:50 PM

I think you are missing the point, Dustin. Nancy is a rather vile human being. Now she is in mega deep shit because she finally grew a conscience and shut down the tunnel to stop the trafficking of underage Mexican hookers. Now that she had decided to do the right thing she ironically is in even deeper then before. Is it as funny as the earlier seasons? No, but it's not worse because of it. The humor is just much, MUCH darker.

Posted by: TylerDFC at June 17, 2009 4:52 PM

I would have to disagree with one point: Just because it's dark and dramatic doesn't means it's strayed from the original premise or feel of the show. I always kinda expected this show to become darker as it went along. Such a premise acted out in real life would actually be quite dark, when you think about it.

Posted by: ChristianH at June 17, 2009 4:55 PM

Yup - I just decided quit the show after watching this week's episode. You can have a deplorable lead character (see the brilliant second season of "Breaking Bad") without making the show itself miserable and unbearable. But, as you say, this show has gone from fun to beaten and angry. Check, please.

Posted by: seth at June 17, 2009 5:27 PM

The theme song, sung by a variety of artist made me smile... as did just about anything Andy did... now I feel like I'm watching just to watch it get better, as I know what potential it has/had...

Posted by: El L Cool J at June 17, 2009 5:29 PM

What I most dislike the most about the turn that Weeds has taken is it implies that anyone who sells a little bit of pot will end up running guns and fucking the head of a drug cartel.

Posted by: Colyn at June 17, 2009 5:33 PM

The last season sucked, but this season, despite all it's darkness, seems to bring back the show's humor, like when Celia was counseling the rebel leader to leave his abusive relationship.

Posted by: carolyn at June 17, 2009 5:52 PM

it's=/=its.

Posted by: carolyn at June 17, 2009 5:54 PM

That's (correct use here) what you get for posting when tired. Would you believe I'm actually an ESL teacher.

Posted by: Colyn at June 17, 2009 6:02 PM

I don't know, there were a couple funny bits in the first two episodes of this season. But yeah, it all went downhill for me once they moved. It was mostly the loss of Conrad and Heylia---I fucking loved them.
It's definitely changed, and probably not for the better. But I'll watch it anyway, because I get really bored sometimes.

Posted by: Sharon at June 17, 2009 6:04 PM

Only 5? There's a lot more than that, Dustin.

10 Shows that Were Once Good, but Lost It:

10. Happy Days, for inventing the phrase.
9. Family Guy, I despise it, but I hate the earlier episodes a lot less, and understand their appeal.
8. Saturday Night Live, on and off again for decades.
7. St. Elsewhere
6. Seinfeld, I will never get over that fucking finale.
5. Dexter
4. The X Files
3. Law and Order
2. Weeds
1. Heroes

My god, I hate what happened to Heroes. They turned it into total shit.

Posted by: George at June 17, 2009 6:50 PM

Say what you will about last season, but it was worth it if for only one scene: Kevin Nealon narrating a suicide letter to his wife straight out of Shawshank Redemption while looking like he was about to hang himself, only to reveal it was auto-erotic asphyxiation. That shit was priceless.

I also enjoyed the whole coyote storyline from last year. I think I'd be fine, even, with Nancy going through everything she was going through now if there was an ounce of HUMOR to it. It's just pretty mirthless now, aside from maybe thirty seconds of Nealon an episode. Also, bring back Romany Malco, he was pretty awesome.

~mangrilla

Posted by: mangrilla at June 17, 2009 8:01 PM

I totally agree. The characters have changed so much since the first seasons that there's not really much left. Especially Nancy. The first time i realised this was in one of the earlier seasons before the fire. Nancy meets some mexican dude in the street, he threatens her or something - cut scene and shes getting pdeudoraped on his car and liking it!?. I mean what the fuck!? - to hours later and shes whining about silas not finishing high school or some shit. Since then she has practically giving up on her children and just goes about ruining her life and others - i really don't see the comedic value in watching a woman getting drunk and smoking while being pregnant. Basing a show purely on shock value has the sorry outcome of soon going of the deep end. Bring back the comedy of the earlier seasons! :D

Posted by: Joe at June 17, 2009 8:09 PM

Agreed with Joe heartily, I watched this show because it was fabulous and silly and a lot of fun to watch. Just the right kind of mix of humor and desperation under that housewife widow veneer. Now it's absolutely painful to watch, Nancy has just gone off the fucking deep-end (remember how sad it was she couldn't sleep with the DEA guy in the bed she shared with her husband?) Now she bangs everyone from Guillermo in a car some season or 2 ago, to that creepy weird blonde Christian boss of hers (for no god damn reason), Conrad, blargg. I'm all for banging your brains out but they carefully built her up to be this sturdy yet fragile character only to have her turn into the raunchy getting-off-on-dangerous-guys trainwreck.

Damnit I want that fun light-hearted show back. And remember the songs they'd end episodes with?! They made me toss my head back and fucking howl, like when Celia tells her husband to stop smoking pot and a rap song starts in with, "SHUT THE FUCK UP BITCH AND MIND YO' OWN MU'FUCKIN' BUSINESS!"

Posted by: AlexaCastro at June 17, 2009 8:30 PM

i check in every once in a while on this show--my wife still watches. every time i do, i'm still glad i pulled the ripcord after 2 seasons.

Posted by: icecreammang at June 17, 2009 9:40 PM

I still love this show, and still find it hilarious. That scene in last season where MLP is talking to Silas re sleeping with the neighbour spliced in with her talking to Shane re masturbating to photos of her was just gold. And, I totally buy the Andy-loves-Nancy storyline (although, I haven't seen any of this season yet), and I actually thought it was a natural progression of their relationship. And, Andy still makes me laugh more than anyone else on television.

I think the thing about last season (and what sounds like has been continuing this season) is that the pretense that Nancy is a good person (or is trying to be good) has been completely abandoned - even by herself. And in some ways that's disturbing to watch.

But I still really enjoy the show, and it's still better than 95% of the absolute dreck that's on TV.

Posted by: JJ McClay at June 18, 2009 2:52 AM

After watching episode 2 last night I will say that they have got to cut some characters. There are at least 5 different subplots right now and for a half hour show that is WAYYYY too much. I think Jennifer Jason Leigh had as much screen time as MLP in this episode. Drop Silas, drop Shane, put Doug and Andy together again, and bring Celia, Heylia, and Conrad back into the fold. And I really want to see Guillermo get out of prison and fuck Nancy's shit up. The scene with him and Nancy in jail this week was excellent.

Posted by: TylerDFC at June 18, 2009 9:53 AM

I've never seen one episode of this show but isn't Little Boxes an old nursery rhyme or something?

It's the theme song to Weeds? That's funny.

Posted by: kayla at June 18, 2009 11:26 AM

kayla, apparently it -was- the theme song. No longer? :(

That's the saddest thing I've read all day.

Also, I stopped watching around the end of Season 2. My God, what have they done to this show.

Posted by: misterorange at June 18, 2009 5:21 PM

I stopped watching during Season 3. The reason I liked it so much at first was the whole pretense of keeping up appearances and the things we don't know that go on in everyone else's little box.

When the DEA boyfriend wound up dead and then the ex-wife came and went, things started changing. I know the characters have to change, and it's needed to keep the story moving along, but it was so far away from the way they'd set these people up. The stretches got farther and farther, for me culminating with her and the Matthew Modine character.

Most of my friends who watched have let this one go too. A few are still into it, but they even admit it's "just weird" sometimes. I've got my fingers crossed that True Blood keeps getting better, or investing in the first two seasons of Weeds to watch for something good.

Posted by: kellyo at June 18, 2009 9:55 PM

For me the point of Nancy was never that she was good woman. She was a trapped woman stuck in a suburban lifestyle, a woman who always wanted a little more power and say. In many ways she has yet refused to compromise her, albeit selfish, desires for anyone. She loves her husband but I think with his death she was free to explore all those dark little things suburbia didn’t let her. And yes she has spiraled, but her character continues to be a survivor, which was its original hook.
This last episode she disappointed me a little because she gave into Esteban completely. Which pisses me off a little. The wonderful thing about their courtship, the reason he eclipsed Guillermo and everyone else was because he was just as tough and as beautiful and seemingly impenetrable as she was. I really enjoyed the writing in the episodes where they are seducing each other, their first lunch during the shootout etc.
SO basically, the wind this little ramble down, I’d say the number one reason, the only real reason, to watch weeds is Nancy, and though she’s getting a little fuzzy, she’s still very much ‘Nancy’.

Posted by: ani at June 19, 2009 6:51 AM

Esteban is NOT the mayor of Mexico City. Please. Do you even watch the show? He is the mayor of Tijuana.

Posted by: moon at June 23, 2009 12:44 AM

#3 episode in season 3 was one of the funniest episodes ever

Posted by: TJ at June 24, 2009 6:41 PM

I still enjoy the show despite its descent into much darker territory; perhaps I still enjoy it BECAUSE of said descent.

I agree that Nancy's not an admirable protagonist, but so what? Not every television character is likable and sympathetic. In fact, many of the most compelling and well-developed tv characters are deeply flawed. MLP does an excellent job bringing this woman to life.

At the end of season 2, Nancy narrowly escaped death. Any RATIONAL, LIKEABLE, SELFLESS, EMOTIONALLY STABLE, SELF-RESPECTING woman would have gotten the HECK out of the drug business! Therefore, in order to keep this show running, the writers had to explain why she doesn't stop. I believe they did that well.

She doesn't stop selling drugs because she can't stop. She's a trainwreck of a woman who has fallen FAR off the tracks in record time. She deals drugs so she doesn't have to deal with life. And you know what? Our world is full of people like that. Emotional trainwrecks who don't deal with their past/trauma/grief/mistakes and end up putting themselves in dangerous situations/abusive relationships/jail.

If Weeds had just stayed with this same formula -

Mom sells weed in upper-middle class suburb
her rebellious teenagers get in trouble
her friend Celia is a bitch
her accountant Doug gets high
her brother Andy gets high

- it would have gotten pretty old and boring. If you want the same old, hum drum sitcom - that's what shows like 2.5 Men, Everybody Loves Raymond, Friends (and on and on...)are for.

The one thing I do take issue with though is what they've done with the Celia character. I say, either do something interesting with her or write her off the show. EP is an amazing actress and deserves to potray a character with more depth.

Posted by: Dianne at June 29, 2009 3:57 AM

we all have our own opinions, but jeez Dustin Rowles your soo smart, look out all the symbolical language you were able to use when writing this...I bet you check this daily to see who comments on this, your peice of work. I think you need to just relaxed, breath ...it's only a TV show, your life will go on. I think it's really pathetic people get paid to write a "review" about a show they just simply watch...your life must suck!! and I bet it took you all night to wright this up! BORING LOSER!

Posted by: george at June 29, 2009 4:08 AM

While I agree the show has shifted in tone completely since the end of Season 2, I also have to say that I like it just as much. My perception of what it was supposed to be had to shift along with it. I don't think it implies that ANYONE who sells a little bit of dope will end up fucking the leader of a Mexican drug cartel, but it highlights a central character flaw in Nancy that has always existed. She was not the type of person that could ever "just sell a little bit of dope" - she's an empty, directionless soul who thrives on the drama that her actions create. Are the plotlines completely believable? No - but that's where the satire still thrives...and I still think one can learn a lesson in a larger consequence - be careful of the consequences of your actions. Nancy quickly got in over her head, and once she turned that corner, the show had to follow her there; while I agree it's not as funny as it once was (and that plotline about Celia's daughter was just plain bizarre - Elizabeth Perkins really got screwed with that setup), it is no less compelling, if just for different reasons.

Posted by: Matt Buganza at June 30, 2009 12:27 AM

I haven't been able to watch the 5th season but I look forward to it I think the show has definitely taken a dark turn and I don't like Nancy spreading her legs for anything that has a penis but the first 2 seasons hooked me and. I love the characters and will fallow the show wherever it goes

Posted by: coonkiller at June 30, 2009 3:30 PM

I think Dustin got it right on the money. I was consoled by our co-misery about the lackluster descent of a show with so much one-time biting alacrity and promise. Just where it went off the rails is unclear to me but I too stay tuned in the bleak hope it will rebound. Although my last hopes were all but dashed this week when Agent What's-his-face waxes sentimental over the loss of the partner he aims to avenge: "No body puts baby in the Coroner." (Did I actually hear that..?) Perhaps there is another writer's strike in Hollywood. No chance these are the same folks responsible for rip-roaring ensemble scenes like the the motley crew who comes to the rescue of Andy getting his toe eaten by the dog at Team-Pot Headquarters. What I wouldn't give for a reunion of that cast.

Posted by: flydy at July 4, 2009 2:43 PM

Unfortunely I have to admit that I too agree with Dustin's review, as well as with other people's commnments that 1)there are just way too many subplots going on this season, and 2) the main reason I continue to watch it is simply in hopes that it will go back to being as brilliant as it used to be, as it still has the potential to be. Mary Louse Parker is still amazing, that will never change. But the writers have made Nancy stoop to some real low levels in the past 2 1/2 seasons, and quite frankly its hard to watch sometimes. They really shoulda ended the show after season 3, if not season 2, to preserve at least some degree of dignity and originality in people's minds. In the beginning, I felt like Weeds set the bar for writing and acting...it was so unique to t.v., so witty and clever and smart. Now, its just lame. Surprisingly, I think that Celia is the most likeable character this season, as well as Silas, who I used to find extremely annoying. But I like Celia and Silas when they're not so full of themselves. Celia finally seems to have grown at least 1/2 a heart, and Silas is finally acting like a REAL grown up. On the other hand, Shane's gone morally bankrupt, Andy's gotten depressed and serious, Doug's just a waste of space (totally NOT funny anymore), and in the most recent episode, Nancy's chosen to go live with the abusive drug-lord/mayor instead of trying to re-build her family and fleeing with Andy. WTF? She's all about getting wasted and banging whoever is gonna make her life more complicated. To the current writes of Weeds: Can we restore Nancy's brains? See the mayor get killed, and all his little sidekicks just stay out of at least ONE episode?! Can we have another setting change, have the Botwins go take over another town!? And finally, can we please leave Quinn out of this, and give Isabelle a whole lot more screen time?!?!?!

Posted by: Christina at July 10, 2009 7:24 PM

I totally agree. I haven't liked Weeds since the whole thing with the Mexican mafia. It's getting way too weird. Last episode (5X09), Nancy is in pain because she didn't pump the milk out of her breasts while she and Andy were at a restaurant. She goes into the restroom and her breast pump stops working, so what does she do? She calls Andy to come into the restroom and ask him if he can suck the milk of of her breasts for relief. And Andy does it. And he swallows. WTF happened?

Posted by: cannabia at August 4, 2009 11:29 AM

I know Cannabia..... Yuck right... WTF indeed... nancy is a super skank... its creepy really... Andy and Doug do make the show though....
I miss Conrad.

Posted by: kelly at August 5, 2009 4:03 AM

If you assume that the writers started using drugs, heavily, after the 2nd season ended... the plotlines end up making a whole lot more sense.

All of Season 5 is a wash - but the scene in episode 7 where Andy and Nancy escape from Esteban's in his fancy car... has some absolutely wicked acting from Andy. He goes through an emotional roller coaster that's simply stunning.

Posted by: Bobbay at August 9, 2009 10:53 PM

I so, so agree. Nancy Botwin is not only despicable now, she's also a sociopath. Maybe the show writers think that adding a heaping spoonful of misogyny will help balance it all out? If so, presto! They've done it.

Weeds writers, you make me sad. Come back to us. Come back.

Posted by: me-owser at August 12, 2009 11:43 PM

Thank you for writing that wonderfully correct review of Weeds up to season 5. I haven't been able to stand watching Nancy and her bullshit actions on camera and the fact that her and her obnoxious, cheesey Mexican mafia boyfriend are now married is driving me insane. No one else has seemed to agree with me in that the whole Mexican mafia involvement as well as the entirety of season 5 has sucked the long dick of mainstream approval. Why Jenji Kohan couldn't come up with a more original and entertaining mafia to get involved with is besides me. Why they moved to Ren Mar and not somewhere like Humbolt county also doesn't make sense to me.
The only thing that the show retains is decent acting and hopefully Nancy still has the ability to pull a fast one on everybody that works in her favor.

Well what's said is said. Hopefully the show will turn around at the end of the season and get back to it's roots. I mostly continue to watch it just because watching a new episode of King of the Hill is no longer a weekly routine for me, and I've been a fan since the first season.

Posted by: Luke at August 14, 2009 1:00 AM