web
counter
 

Skullduggery in High Places

By Adrienne Saia Isaac | Posted Under TV Reviews | Comments (29)



will-ep13-760.jpg

Well, “Rubicon” ended tonight. And although I fully expected it to go out with a bang, it went out with a whimper. With no network confirmation of a second season (at least at 11:15 pm, MST, as I write this) and few questions answered, this could be one of the most poorly conceived finales in recent memory. Maybe I need to watch it again before I make that judgment, but I really expected more, especially after kinetic pace of the last few episodes. I definitely expected Spangler to kill himself by the end and I wanted more of Kale Ingram. I wanted to know how the hell Andi got involved in this whole debacle and why she couldn’t be this cool all season. Throughout the night I made note of the incredulous expressions of most of the cast during the episode. Now I, too, sit here incredulous: Is that it?

Spangler commands the API staff to singularly focus on finding the culprits behind the explosion in Galveston and puts Will’s team in charge. He wants the truth, a sentiment he can’t deliver without a pregnant pause and a nod to his own shortcomings in the truth department. Will’s also obsessed with the truth, but less concerned with Galveston than with the big picture and Atlas’s involvement. Kale tries to instill the importance of figuring out Galveston to Will and tells him to back off the other stuff for now. He does, however, push Will in the direction of Bloom’s apartment in Williamsburg; it’s not certain whether this was intentional, but methinks that nothing Kale Ingram does is by accident. Will, being pigheaded and somewhat arrogant (two adjectives that a fellow Atlas member will use to describe Spangler later), refuses to heed Kale’s advice and pushes forth with his investigation into the connection between Atlas and David’s murder. To Will, his mission to find David’s killer trumps everything, even if it means putting others in danger.

Will breaks another of Kale’s commandments when he disables the owl bug in his office and proceeds to tell Miles that Atlas has been manipulating intel over the past 20 years. In this case, Spangler is pushing the U.S. to war with Iran. The forced connections that API has made to Iran mirror the real ones that Will makes to link Atlas and Spangler to David’s death. All the connections seem to have come far too easily (this episode, mostly via Hal, who previously wanted nothing to do with Will’s extracurricular sleuthing). The timing of this revelation to Miles felt odd to me: Miles is already super strung out and his and Will’s relationship hasn’t been the tightest lately. Hell, Miles hasn’t even been the MVP of his analysis team. In the end, the exchange seems to hurt Miles more than it ends up helping Will.

Miles isn’t the only one who’s hurt during this episode. By the end, Katherine ends up dead in the middle of Central Park, with both Will and Andi (W.T. F.) shitting the bed on protecting her. Katherine was attempting to deliver her copy of “Meet Me in St. Louis” to Will, as it contains a message from Tom and David. It’s that message that leads Katherine to Andi’s apartment, but we have no idea how Andi and Tom are connected, nor why he thought that Andi could protect Katherine. Before she could give Will the DVD, the black Atlas cohort bumps into her, wearing gloves coated with some type of murder-on-contact substance, and she collapses. Will hovers over her dead body then runs away to API. He then whines to Maggie about merely wanting answers and she kills herself trying to console him. I don’t know how she can just sit and baby him while Katherine is dead. He is almost completely unlikeable by this point, and equal to Spangler in his hubris. Will lays against Maggie’s chest like a child, which is in itself kind of weird, and that’s all we get from the two of them. No answer about the origins of their relationship, nor any indication of where it is going.

This is just one of the glaring unanswered questions at the end of the season. Another one is: Who the fuck is Andi? I really expected them to give us a glimpse into her double life earlier on in the season, rather than suddenly have her be identified by Tom as the only one who can protect Katherine. When the hell did that happen? Also, when did Tom and David suddenly get into cahoots with each other? OH — and one more — since when the fuck is Tanya a published author?? She quits API, a seemingly stupid move on behalf of the writers, as I found Tanya to be one of the more likable characters. So, what, we end her storyline on a weak note? This is the danger of leaving about 9 cliffhanging plot elements without the guarantee of a second season.

The only thing we are guaranteed is that Spangler retains his throne as the king of Not Giving a Fuck. For reals. He promotes Grant and demotes Will without really consulting either man beforehand. He doesn’t give a fuck that the other Atlas members find him to be a liability and are cutting him off after 20 years of business (and 50 years of friendship). And he could really not give a fuck that Will’s got his Atlas/Hadas game figured out. The best scenes in the episode are the ones that feature our ol’ pal Truxton: his interchange with his old Atlas friend and the one with Will on the roof. By the second scene, Spangler’s received the four leaf clover. Will tries to play hardball and ends up looking completely lame as Spangler rebuffs his threats. “Do it,” Spangler says, twice, when Will threatens to go public. He could give a fuck because he knows he’s going to die. But we have zero confirmation of this fact, as he’s alive by the end of the episode. He leaves the clover with Will, alerting Will to his fate but also showing that he’ll be immune to Will’s whistleblowing. It doesn’t matter if he goes public or not; either way Will loses. He’s too late to prevent tragedies (David, the train, Galveston) and has his hands dirtied by killing Bloom and abandoning Katherine, so his credibility is questionable. Spangler wins this one, even though he’s been charged with killing himself.

I seriously expected a [completely unrelated show spoiler alert] “Breaking Bad”-type finale with a jumpcut to black and a gunshot. But, no. Nothing. And I don’t even like the main character enough to want to know what happens to him, but I wanted answers about Katherine, Tom and Andi. As the unsettling trailer for AMC’s horror movie marathon played, I asked myself: “Wait… Is this it?”

So, AMC: Is this it?

Adrienne Saia Isaac is a journalist and Philly expat living in Colorado with two pair of skis, seven Phillies hats and her pit bull mix, Juno. Her main goal in life (besides finding gainful employment) is to drink whiskey out of Lord Stanley’s cup with Chris Pronger. You can read her rants and rambling at Ex-Pat’s and Geno’s.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



First Pics from Hellraiser: Revelations | Pinhead Junior | A Little Dose of Monday Morning Hope for the Future of Mankind | Christian Bale, Mark Wahlberg, and Amy Adams Deliver in New Trailer for "The Fighter"









Comments

I agree with everything you wrote except "kinetic pace of the last few episodes". They were only kinetic in comparison to the glacial norm of this show.

Posted by: ed newman at October 18, 2010 11:19 AM

With a whimper indeed. How disappointing was that? It played more like a penultimate episode than a final.

I called Andi weeks ago as being involved in some way. But what was the point? Couldn't she have watched for people approaching Katherine? Unless she led them to her.

Will is useless. Didn't he see the CD in Katherine's hand? She was waving it around before she collapsed. If he really represents the level of brilliance we have analyzing intelligence in the US, we're in big trouble.

As for Tanya: I get that at some point in the distant past she was intelligent, but for the past 4 eps or so all she's done is sit on the windowsill and stare in bemusement or crave a pill. Why would anyone urge her to stay?

All in all, this is not the way to end a show: unanswered questions that don't leave you wanting to learn more.

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 18, 2010 11:22 AM

One other thing. What attracted me to this show to begin with was the fact that their job was to take piles of miscellaneous intelligence gathered overnight and try to glean some patterns and analysis from it. Then last night, they get the big piece of information from the computer guy? They could have asked him to run Kateb's aliases weeks ago: they could have made the connection to Spangler and possibly got to Kateb before Galveston. So all the solid intelligence work meant nothing compared with a couple of computer inputs.

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 18, 2010 11:51 AM

Those were not Kateb's aliases; they were Donald Bloom's.

I was not disappointed. I liked that the show didn't give Will a big victory. I like that Andi was completely unknowable. She might have failed at protecting Katherine, but it seemed to me that she had brought her to the killing floor. Maybe Andi was an either/or--if Katherine stayed on the good side of Atlas McDowell, then she was to be protected. If she went off the reservation, oh well. Can't make an omelet without breaking eggs. These conspirators play hardball. I liked the way Kale decided it was time to pull back and live to fight another day. I thought Spangler's final line was perfect: "See if anyone gives a shit." If that doesn't describe this culture right now, then what could?

Posted by: alone in the dark at October 18, 2010 12:28 PM

alone:

Thanks. I completely missed that they were talking about Bloom. Time for a re-watch I think.

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 18, 2010 12:40 PM

@ alone: Andi definitely took Katharine to her death, she didn't look happy about it but she did it anyways. Will should have seen the DVD in her hands but I think he'll end up with it next season (there better be a next season) somehow. Maybe he gets her personal effects at the morgue or something. I think Spangler's going rogue, he won't kill himself no matter the arrangement. I love Miles, his whole body screams stressed out genius.

AMC has nothing better to run in it's place and it can't be very expensive to shoot. 1 more year!

Posted by: Renegator at October 18, 2010 12:54 PM

If there is a next season it will not have the pleasure of my company.AMC could do the Saturday morning Stooges reruns and make more sense than much of what we have been presented.

Posted by: TexasVol at October 18, 2010 2:04 PM

Better shows than this have been canceled on cliffhangers. (I'm looking at you The Riches)

I think the episode was good and, considering the pacing of the rest of the show, it was perfect for a season finale. I hope it comes back for a second season, but it would be great if there were a little more action.
However, it's super easy to look up the owner of an aircraft. (I used to do it for work all the time) It's an unforgivable blunder on the part of Atlas that the plane Bloom used was actually owned by their subsidiary. That's completely stupid. There are plenty of charter operations based at Teterboro that wouldn't have left such a neon flashing trail directly back to our baddies.
The searches Computer Guy did for them could have been done with Google. I would expect more from such a high level intelligence agency/conspiracy group that's operated undetected for 20 years.
Also, I think the Atlas-killer injected Katherine with something because he threw away a syringe with the gloves as he was leaving the scene. This is probably an inappropriate suggestion but the killer probably should have chosen a different color glove for that operation. The ones he did choose kind of stood out. As a bystander I think I would remember seeing a guy walking around in latex gloves and then removing them for no apparent reason.

Posted by: king at October 18, 2010 2:31 PM

Leaving his fingerprints and the murder weapon in the same trashcan!!!
The more I think about this the more annoyed I'm getting.

Posted by: king at October 18, 2010 2:37 PM

Adrienne- Edward Roy (Sheeeeeeit) used a syringe on Katherine Rhumer.

I'm having a lot of trouble buying into the Andy story. I would have been much happier if she was just a crazy neighbor showing just how paranoid and untrusting Will had become. IF she was put in place by Hadas and Tom Rhumer to keep an eye on Will and Katherine then she is fucking terrible at her job e.g. Bloom's botched assassination and Roy's successful assassination. I am well aware that they have made her ambiguous since her introduction but her role in this episode feels very contrived. It feels like the kind of cheap writing that I would not expect of this team.

I'm very happy that we might get to see more of Truxton next season. I definitely think he will not go quietly.

I'm pretty sure it was Adrienne who mentioned that she wasn't sure how well the conspiracy plot would carry into a second season and I will agree wholeheartedly. This finale does not fill me with the excitement I had waiting for previous episodes. The idea that the writers are going to drag out the conspiracy over multiple seasons could get old very quickly and seems certain to be a major letdown when all is revealed (I'm thinking Lost here). Andy's affiliation also implies that (since Hadas and Rhumer are dead) there is another secret group trying to stop Atlas. It all seems a little ridiculous for a show that was trying to be realistic.

Posted by: Porkchop Express at October 18, 2010 2:41 PM

I'm not convinced Andi was there to protect Will or Katherine, rather the opposite. I think the reason she showed up at Will's door the night the assassination attempt went awry was to finish off the job.

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 18, 2010 3:08 PM

Paddy- I don't really buy into that idea either. I'm not really sure what was up with the night with the tomato but she had ample opportunity to kill Will off in his sleep if she wanted. I don't think the Andy story will hold up very well if we go back and watch the earlier episodes. The way she picked up the gun she found in Will's bag was like someone who had never touched one before. She would not have alerted Will that Bloom was in his apartment if she was in on it. She actually tried to keep Katherine from going to the park.

The only explanation that I have heard that makes any sense is that Spangler discovered Tom Rhumer's secret hideaway and put his own people (Andy) there. However, that should have made keeping tabs on Will very easy which is not what we have been told by Roy earlier in the season.

Posted by: Porkchop Express at October 18, 2010 3:39 PM

But what if her role was to find out exactly how much Will knew? The she wouldn't kill him immediately and she would need to get close to him to find out who else he had told. I agree with you on the scene where she finds the gun: that doesn't add up, but we found out later that she had a lot of familiarity with handling guns. Doesn't it make sense that she would keep Katherine from going to the park until she had time to alert the assassin that she would be there? I don't know. I've just been looking for ways to make her storyline make sense.
So many things don't make sense. The only character who remained consistent throughout was Grant and I cant take him seriously until he loses the Planet of the Apes hair.

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 18, 2010 4:02 PM

It's not hard at all to pretend that you've never touched a gun before and if Andy was "undercover" it wouldn't make sense for her to tip her hand on something like handling a gun properly. Will would have noticed. I think she played her role beautifully if her purpose was to observe and wait for Katherine to eventually come to her. I definitely don't think she worked for Spangler. If she had, Spangler would have known everything that Will knew because she would have turned over a copy of the file he'd hidden in the bathroom. Possibly she did, but I don't think so.
Spangler knew Will was closing in, but I don't think he knew how much he actually had.
I think it's entirely plausible that Andy was put in place by Rhumer and David to keep tabs on Will's progress, not necessarily to interfere.

Posted by: king at October 18, 2010 5:19 PM

She found Will's gun when she snooped through his bag. He wasn't even around to see so there would be no reason to pretend that she had never held one before. She also went through some should-she or shouldn't-she quandary to decide whether or not to look through his bag. If she were truly spying on Will at that point, it is no contest what the decision would be. I think she is supposed to be working for Rhumer/Hadas but I also think the writers made this up at the last minute as it doesn't really fit with what we have been shown up until now.

Up until this last episode, I was really impressed with the writers. Then, the finale started me thinking that they are just making it up as they go and have no idea how to 1) tie everything up and 2) end the series. I really think that a show built upon a premise like this needs to know how the series will end. And hopefully when.

I suppose that is the problem in modern television unless you decide to create a show based on single episode storylines. The threat of cancellation looms over your head and you never feel that you can plan too far ahead.

I am worried about what is left of Team E back at API. I really liked Tanya and hope that they didn't just write her off the show. Miles seems less interesting now that he is with Julia. Grant is still Grant and it will be interesting to see if he is as good at being the boss as he thinks he is. I really don't know where this leaves Will. How can he go back to work at API after calling Truxton out? How can Truxton let him come back to work? Potentially using API's own information against him? I'm not really sure how Andy fits in anymore now that Maggie is back.

Posted by: Porkchop Express at October 18, 2010 5:55 PM

I agree with Porkchop that a lot of the end seemed to be made up all of a sudden. For several eps we've been waiting for Katherine's role to be meaningful and then she just dies. Kale seemed to know everything that was happening and dropped his little hints to Will but then just decides to move on? Why didn't he accelerate things to nail Spangler or if he was working for the other side why did he let Will get so far. A lot of characters that had been built up in a certain way were just left to dangle at the end. Someone on another thread wrote that this show would have been much better as a solid 6-part miniseries instead of trying to make a sustainable show.

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 18, 2010 6:04 PM

I stand corrected Porkchop. In my memory she peers into the bag and sees the gun but we don't see her holding it until Will picks it up off the table and she takes it from him. I'm getting muddled in my old age.
I loved her in that episode so I'm predisposed to think well of her in general. She made that Three Days of the Condor reference and stole my heart.

Posted by: king at October 18, 2010 7:13 PM

We thought we heard a muffled gunshot at the end, after Spangler walked across the roof, opened the door, and closed the door. We replayed it 5 or 6 times. You clearly hear the door open ("ka-chunk"), then you hear the door close ("ka-click"), then two seconds later, a very muffled, very hard to hear sound that sounded like a gunshot would sound from 30 yards and a steel door away.

The guy that killed Katherine didn't have magic instant-death gloves. He stuck her with a syringe.

Posted by: John Galt at October 18, 2010 7:17 PM

No problem, King.

Andy starts going through Will's bag and finds a heavy bundle of fabric. She picks it up and it unravels, dropping the pistol on the floor. I'm pretty sure she picks it up. Her reactions while doing all of this are clearly not those of someone who does this for a living. To then see that she is some sort of secret agent/spy seems a bit hard to swallow.

Uda will probably be able to fill anything in that I miss as he/she has a photographic memory or all the episodes on DVR.


In case it was unclear from my previous comment, the scene where she is on the fence over whether or not to go through his bag is the clearest to me that she is not a spy. The producers have no reason to show us that unless they are portraying her as a civilian.

Posted by: Porkchop Express at October 18, 2010 8:01 PM

John Galt- I didn't hear a gunshot myself though some folks on another forum have said they also heard one. It is being replayed tonight and I will listen for it.

Posted by: Porkchop Express at October 18, 2010 8:21 PM

I'm really conflicted about how I feel about the series in general, but I'm willing to give it a couple more episodes if it gets brought back and will even be hoping for it's return.

As tedious and painfully slow as things got, I did always at least appreciate the writers/directors/art designers keeping the characters and their surroundings rooted in reality: no fancy Q-like spy gadgets, no elaborate, secret entrances into API. It felt like they really wanted to feel natural. But what the FUCK was that room where the other Atlas conspirators sat in judgement on Spangler? All season they've been gathering in gentleman's clubs and cigar bars, but suddenly they've got to meet in the goddamn Cone of Silence???

Fail.

Posted by: CreativeObsessive at October 19, 2010 12:24 AM

I stand corrected on the syringe. Thanks! But the muffled gun shot thing pisses me off. If you're going to have Truxton Spangler blow his head off at the end of a season, you should turn that shit UP to eleven so there's no mistaking it.

Great conversation on this episode! And to Paddy and Porkchop and everyone else who hung in there with me: thanks, ya'll. It's be a fun, if glacially paced, ride :).

Cheers,
A

Posted by: Adrienne Saia at October 19, 2010 1:23 AM

CreativeObsessive- Dead on about the room. I would love to know what the writers were trying to get across to the viewer by using that room. It was so jarring to see a scene like that against everything before it.

Posted by: Porkchop Express at October 19, 2010 1:26 AM

Thank you Adrienne for all the time and effort you put into these reviews. It is appreciated by everyone who reads them.

Posted by: Porkchop Express at October 19, 2010 11:20 AM

Thanks Adrienne for keeping the recaps up. I thought there would be a lot more love for this show on Pajiba. At least WE know what good TV is (season finale excepted from that comment).

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 19, 2010 7:18 PM

I'd also like to give my appreciation to Adrienne. I missed the finale and didn't realize that AMC wouldn't be replaying it later in the week. So now I have to find some other way to watch it. I'm really annoyed I couldn't really participate this time around in the comments.

Posted by: Uda at October 20, 2010 12:40 AM

I agree that the show can be tedious and boring. Maybe part of the point they're trying to make is that something supposedly as exciting as spy work is just as tedious and boring and full of politics and backstabbing as any other job in corporate America?

That said, I think I recall reading somewhere that AMC bought the building where API is. Like, in real life, so they could film there. If that's true, I'd think they'd lean toward a second season just to justify the expense somewhat. Then again, with all the location work they do, it's got to have been pretty expensive. Maybe they'll just turn it into studio space for other projects.

Posted by: growler at October 20, 2010 1:10 AM

Well, even though I'm sure no one will read this as it's a week and change too late (AMC finally replayed the episode, yay!), but here goes...

Uda will probably be able to fill anything in that I miss as she has a photographic memory or all the episodes on DVR.

I wish. I'm a nerd with way too much time on my hands, so if there's some sort of detail I'm unsure of, I usually just look it up online or see if there's a clip of it on the AMC website. I'm too poor for a DVR, so I get to watch all the commercials, which makes for even slower viewing. Anyway, as far as my memory serves, I remember the scene with Andy going through Will's bag the same way you described it. She was alone and seemed surprised and as though she had never handled a gun.

I would agree that they're making this show up as they go along, and it seems like they inserted a bunch of crap as some sort of quick fix, to either make someone more interesting (Andy) or to write them off the show (Tanya). I'm glad they killed off Katherine, but it seemed like such a cop out. They should've come up with a better way for Will to find out about the connection between the guys of Atlas instead of wasting any time on Katherine. Now not only did she drag down the show in early episodes, but she was completely pointless. And Will was infuriatingly stupid by not picking up the DVD she kept waving around. Oh well, now it'll be filed into evidence unless someone else comes along and takes it.

But what the FUCK was that room where the other Atlas conspirators sat in judgement on Spangler?

That's exactly what I thought. It was ridiculous.

And for the love of God, will someone please cut Grant's hair? I know the actor likes to look like a dirty hobo when he's not in character, but it would be really great if they just cut it anyway.

Posted by: Uda at November 2, 2010 2:00 AM

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaand... canceled.

Bummer, I just got through watching the whole season over the last 2 or 3 days, and NOW I find out AMC canceled it.

Fuck.

Posted by: BELIEVEland at November 24, 2010 2:55 AM