web
counter
 

Sexy TARDIS & Her Beautiful Idiot: Doctor Who, "The Doctor's Wife"

By C. Robert Dimitri | Posted Under TV Reviews | Comments (43)



doctorwho_s06_e04_01__large.jpg

“No, you’re not. You’re a bitey mad lady. The TARDIS is up and downy stuff in a big blue box.”

On a distant junkyard asteroid outside the boundaries of the universe, “Auntie,” “Uncle,” and Ood “Nephew” prepare Idris to lose her soul, as it will be painfully replaced with the coinciding imminent arrival of a Time Lord. (Idris, by the way, is a woman. I might not be compelled to point this out save for two factors: the episode’s title, and the existence of one Idris Elba, a.k.a. Stringer Bell, from The Wire.)

Out in deep space, The Doctor, Amy, and Rory receive a literal knock at the TARDIS’ door. A distress cube, characteristically unique to the Time Lords (and used way back in the Doctor Who annals by Patrick Troughton’s Doctor), hurtles through the doorway to notify them that one Time Lord in particular, The Corsair, is in need of help. The Doctor recognizes the Corsair’s Ouroborus sigil on the cube and knows him/her (the Corsair was known to switch genders across regenerations) as a good Time Lord from past experience. The summons takes them to the aforementioned asteroid, and upon landing the TARDIS is drained of its soul, which is transmitted into the waiting Idris.

Outside, The Doctor is intent on tracking down The Corsair and tries to explain the concept behind this location outside the universe (it’s something like a “plughole” in a sink), which could have allowed a Time Lord to survive the purge for which The Doctor was responsible during the Time War against the Daleks. The landscape is littered with detritus against a dark sky, and there they meet Auntie, Uncle, Nephew, and Idris. Idris appears completely mad, nearly mauling The Doctor with bites and kisses. Her grasp of the English language is spotty, and further confusing matters is a cryptic prescience of conversations to come. Nephew’s Ood communication orb is faulty, so The Doctor repairs it and stumbles upon several other Time Lord distress transmissions that are broadcast through it.

Auntie and Uncle reveal that the only other organism at this location is House, the consciousness that inhabits the asteroid itself. House speaks through Auntie and Uncle in a booming, ominous voice (played by none other than Michael Sheen) and offers hospitality to The Doctor and his companions. House speaks glowingly of past Time Lord visitors and says that he takes care of all that visit, having “repaired” Auntie, Uncle, and anyone else.

“We’re not actually going to stay, are we?” Rory asks.
“Well, it seems like a friendly planet. Literally,” The Doctor replies.

The Doctor dashes off to track down the source of the Time Lord distress signals, and Amy is concerned that he is taking this business a little too emotionally. How is he going to explain what happened during the Time War?

“You want to be forgiven, don’t you?” Amy asks.
The Doctor answers, “Don’t we all?”

The Doctor fools Amy and Rory into going back to the TARDIS for his sonic screwdriver so that he can handle “Time Lord business” by himself. He discovers a cabinet full of wailing Time Lord distress cubes, an archive of long-dead victims of House. He confronts Auntie and Uncle, “patchwork people” composed of body parts collected from those same victims of House. Auntie has The Corsair’s arm; Uncle has his kidney and spine, as well as the eyes of a twenty-year-old, mismatched ears, and two left feet.

The Doctor is not happy about his discovery: “You gave me hope, and then you take it away. That’s enough to make anyone dangerous. God knows what it will do to me.”

With resignation Uncle tells him that House is too clever to defeat. The Doctor realizes that Idris correctly predicted “the boxes would make him angry.” He finds her imprisoned in a cage where Nephew left her. Making that wonderful TARDIS materialization noise, she reveals to The Doctor that she is the TARDIS. They trade the sort of banter for which you would hope after all the adventures they have shared together and deduce House’s repeated scheme of extracting time machine consciousnesses so that it is safe to devour the Rift energy each TARDIS has accumulated. Attempting to devour a TARDIS without first removing the consciousness would result in a disastrous hole in space-time at best.

They rush off to warn Amy and Rory, but House - having learned that there are no Time Lords left to be lured to their doom - has already hijacked the TARDIS with his own consciousness and spirits them away in an effort to travel back to the regular universe. As House carries them away, he asks Amy and Rory for a good reason not to kill them. Rory replies that it would be more entertaining to keep them around to sadistically toy with them like his old gym teacher. Wasn’t that the purpose of Auntie and Uncle: oppressed company? This idea appeals to House, as he sends them dashing through the TARDIS corridors on a terrifying chase featuring altered gravity and hallucinations.

Back on the asteroid, The Doctor watches Auntie and Uncle die, as their life force expires without House’s support. There is a wry morbidity in their acceptance, as they do not make much of a fuss about their lot. The Doctor discovers that Idris is dying as well, as the human body is not fit to hold a TARDIS consciousness. She is no longer “Idris,” though, so for lack of a proper name, The Doctor calls her “Sexy,” a moniker we learn he uses when the two of them are alone together.

They find the TARDIS graveyard, housing the mechanical remains of all the time machines that House has devoured over the years, and they hurriedly embark on cobbling together a patchwork TARDIS to catch House.

On the TARDIS, Amy and Rory are separated in the corridors. House haunts her with visions of Rory dying of old age, giving the appearance that time is not passing at the same rate for the two of them. They shake off these hallucinations and flee a more direct physical threat: Nephew, under the influence of House’s mind control, is in the corridors with them with directions to kill them. With the help of telepathic directions from The Doctor and Sexy, now in hot pursuit across the space-time continuum in a retro TARDIS with no proper exterior casing, they find the archived control room of Tennant’s Doctor. A password to enter is not a “password” at all but a telepathic impression: the color crimson, the number eleven, the feeling of delight, and the smell of dust after rain, i.e., “petrichor,” which Sexy earlier told them they would need to know. In case you were wondering, “petrichor” currently is not a legal word in Scrabble, but Australian scientists did coin it in 1964.

In the secondary control room, Rory lowers the shields per Sexy’s instructions, thus enabling The Doctor to materialize his ad hoc TARDIS onto that bridge. Unfortunately for Nephew, that materialization takes place on the space he was occupying, and The Doctor laments another Ood that he failed to save.

House taunts them, demonstrating that he can kill them in a host of ways with his control over the TARDIS, using gravity control, air supply, etc. The Doctor acknowledges that House has the upper hand, but he offers House knowledge in return for sparing their lives. The engines lack the power to escape back into the universe, and The Doctor can tell House how to remedy this. Rooms will need to be ejected, as The Doctor did upon their original transport out of the universe. House agrees to spare them, but upon learning this information, he responds by deleting the secondary control room with The Doctor, Amy, Rory, and Sexy inside. The power boost vaults the blue police box back into the universe we know, and the TARDIS hurtles through space with House’s menacing green glow, an empty control room, and the apparent victory of evil.

The Doctor anticipated House’s duplicity, however, as a failsafe automatically transports all living things in a deleted room to the primary control room. They materialize in the original control room safe and sound. House is not impressed, as he still has the controls and their lives at his disposal. However, as Sexy’s rapidly fading human form is back in the primary control room, she is able to transport her consciousness back into the console. TARDIS interloper House bellows in dying defeat as she reasserts control. Sexy appears to The Doctor as a ghostly apparition so that they can speak one last time, and she uses the opportunity to say something she had always wanted to say: “Hello, Doctor.”

With all back to normal, The Doctor offers to take Rory and Amy to the Eye Of Orion for vacation, a long-running joke from the old days. He uses the TARDIS to rebuild Rory and Amy a new bedroom — this time sans bunk beds per their request. (The Doctor apparently believes a bed-ladder combo to be a staggering innovation.) Rory asks if The Doctor has a room, and he does not answer. (I wonder if this is meant to imply that the main room with his “wife” will always be “his” room.) This marks two episodes in a row with the companions retreating to the bedroom to rest at the end of an adventure, which seems an intuitive and usually unexpressed conclusion to these adventures if you consider it. Alone with the console, The Doctor speaks to the TARDIS, hoping for another hint of the interaction they had shared. She responds with the automatic flip of a switch that will take them to their next destination.

***********

My Whovian friends, this might be the best episode of the Matt Smith era. Thank you, Neil Gaiman, and please feel free to return anytime and bestow another of your stories upon us. Confession: I myself have very little exposure to Gaiman’s work, so I cannot call myself much of a fan. Everyone was so excited about his writing gig that I had great anticipation, and after watching this episode, I am motivated to seek out more of him.

The strength of “The Doctor’s Wife” is in the basic concept, which works on two levels. First, it appeals to us by tapping into The Doctor’s Time Lord roots, an avenue mostly unexplored in the new era of the program, due to the established mythos of the Time War. When I first learned what Eccleston’s Doctor had done just before meeting Rose, I was disappointed, as I always enjoyed all the Gallifrey-related stories of the old days. The Doctor’s history as a Time Lord is an important, untapped part of his character, as evidenced in this tale by The Doctor’s unchecked enthusiasm in tracking down any possibility of a surviving Time Lord. Any opportunity for this Doctor to explore that aspect of his backstory is a welcome one.

Second and more powerfully, though, it deals with The Doctor’s only omnipresent companion throughout all his adventures, the TARDIS, in a new way. (I did learn that if you are familiar with the radio dramas or novelizations, which I am not, placing the TARDIS’s consciousness in a human form is not entirely new, but it is new territory for the television program, unless I am forgetting an episode.) We touch upon the original history of The Doctor and how he stole her so long ago, or how she stole him, if she were telling it. If you are a Doctor Who fanatic, that is a most fundamental topic, and Gaiman does it justice.

Making this click so well is the central guest performance of Suranne Jones as Sexy / The TARDIS / Idris. She credibly delivers a mixture of uncertainty that comes with a machine consciousness inside a human body, the confusion that comes with knowledge that transcends time and space, and the sort of authoritative certainty that would accompany those traits as well. Her chemistry with Matt Smith seems exactly what one might expect from The Doctor with his TARDIS, and the episode needs to be watched twice to fully appreciate all of their dialogue, which reaches its apex with this exchange:

The Doctor: “You didn’t always take me where I wanted to go.”
Sexy: “No, but I always took you where you needed to go.”

I do have minor quibbles. I did not need to hear Rory and Amy remind us that they are haunted by the knowledge of The Doctor’s future death; this seems particularly unnecessary in an episode that almost has no serialized aspect to it. The mysterious metallic eyepatch lady made no appearance to Amy; the only possible reference to the overarching plot was what Sexy told Rory about the future before her human form died: “The only water in the forest is the river.” I might guess this verbiage is a play on “River” Song, but we shall see.

We were inflicted with Rory death fatigue for the second week in a row, but I did think the payoff of Amy’s hallucination of his rotted corpse and walls scrawled with mad ramblings of how much he hated her was a creepy enough payoff to justify it.

Not that it concerns this episode specifically, and I have read many of you complaining about it as well already, but that Amy opening on the BBCA version does need to go. This is not the Amy Pond show, and The Doctor is not “an imaginary friend.” Imagine you are watching the program for the first time and consider The Doctor’s history; the wording of that introduction would be doing you a complete disservice.

That aside, the only true regret I have about this episode is that the resolution seems to preclude our meeting House or the TARDIS incarnate again, which is a shame, because they were both fun characters. If you are left wanting more, it is difficult to call that a failing.

I do wish to note one mental tangent I had over this exchange between House and The Doctor:

House: “Fear me. I’ve killed hundreds of Time Lords.”
The Doctor: “Fear me. I’ve killed all of them.”

House is permanently vanquished moments later. What was House thinking about The Doctor in the interim? We know the mitigating circumstances behind The Doctor’s self-characterization, but House does not. Did House think that The Doctor was a genocidal murderer? Was House frightened by that idea? Not all Time Lords are kind. House seemed supremely confident, but perhaps The Doctor’s delivery of that line prompted House to consider that he finally had bitten off more of the space-time Rift than he could chew.

Next week sees “The Rebel Flesh,” part one of a two-part adventure, penned by Matthew Graham (“Fear Her”). May The Doctor and his sexy TARDIS land in your backyard to take you on a hundred journeys between now and then and return you by Saturday night.

C. Robert Dimitri slept in a bunk bed his sophomore year of college, but he would hope for more luxurious accommodations if he were taking his honeymoon on the TARDIS with its ample freedom over matter and space. At least put a mirror on the ceiling, Doctor. Admittedly, twenty-five years ago when he first started watching Doctor Who, this likely would not have occurred to him.










Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Mindhole Blowers: Cameron Crowe's SINGLES Inspired NBC's Friends and 14 Other Facts About the Movie that Might Explode Your Head | "Game Of Thrones" - "The Wolf And The Lion"









Comments

"And she's a woman. She's the TARDIS and she's a woman!"
"Did you wish really hard?"
"Shut up, not like that."
"I'm...Sexy."
"Still shut up!"

Posted by: Kate at June at May 16, 2011 12:05 PM

Regarding the banner pic, now THAT is a threesome I'd like to see.

Let the Doctor/TARDIS shipping begin. (Continue?)

Posted by: Socrates_Johnson at May 16, 2011 12:15 PM

Did not like this episode at all.

"House" was powerful enough to extract the "soul" of the TARDIS involuntarily out of the TARDIS, but not powerful enough to defeat that soul?

Also, b/c House had eaten 100s of TARDISes in the past with no problem, are we left to understand taht time-lords (except the doctor) really were not that powerful or smart?

Also, leaving the universe?

Is anyone else sick of Amy/Rory? that realtionship doesn't work at all. I've never really liked Amy much, but I like her less with Rory.

The jury-rigged TARDIS? That was silly.

I hated last week's episode (the pirates know how to fly a spaceship?) and this week's was little better. this does not bode well for the series.

Posted by: kerminy at May 16, 2011 12:24 PM

Fantastic episode, but yeah, the first thing I worried about after watching this is how many Doctor/ TARDIS shippers there will be. Even worse that there'd be Fan Fiction about it; however, my friend informed that there already is fan fiction shipping the Doctor and his TARDIS...o__0

Posted by: Corey at May 16, 2011 12:32 PM

I adored this episode.

Posted by: Drake at May 16, 2011 12:40 PM

I liked this episode for many reasons:

1) Amy's head was messed with for once, instead of Rory's.
2) Rory is the pretty one - it's canon!
3) The love of the Doctor's life is not a 19 year-old shop girl, but the only being in the universe (and outside it) that is more powerful than he is. Damn straight! River Song, take note.

Posted by: Three-nineteen at May 16, 2011 12:47 PM

Excellent review. Gaiman's love for the series is obvious, and the fun (and anguish) he expertly injected into this episode makes it a wonderful experience.
I found myself getting bogged down in detail watching (Why is the uncle wearing a French Army uniform circa 1870, with Royal Navy Lt Cdr epaulets from 1865? WHY? WHAT'S THE MEANING?). Finally, I stopped, restarted and enjoyed myself. It was a much better experience.
Some great little details though:
Idris lives for 42 minutes (Nice Douglas Adams nod there).
Corsair regenned as a female. Which might shut up the OMG THE DOCTOR CAN'T BE A WOMAN crowd.
The junkyard at the end of the universe (DA again).
Continuing the rotating DW desktop series
http://i.imgur.com/8QDLb


I'm revising my previous speculations as to the shooter in the spacesuit/Little girl Time Lord. It's the daughter of the Master and Lucy Saxon.
River's still in the mix. Human TARDIS, in the control room, asks for water, and tells Rory "The only water in the forest is the River". Not a Pond.

Posted by: dorquemada at May 16, 2011 1:02 PM

Three-nineteen >> Well said on point 3.

Posted by: C. Robert Dimitri at May 16, 2011 1:03 PM

dorquemada >> I noticed the Hitchhiker's Guide references too. Sneaky Gaiman.

Posted by: C. Robert Dimitri at May 16, 2011 1:05 PM

I thoroughly enjoyed this episode, for all the reasons you mentioned and with each new show I am falling more and more for Matt Smith (quite an accomplishment after Ten). But there is far too much emphasis on Amy and Rory, particularly with Rory's tiresome death dances. Even KG could barely work up emotion this time, though she seems fully capable of frothing up over the Doctor again and again. And thank you for mentioning the horrible opening--it irks me to no end.

I can't wait to see the relevance behind Sexy's forrest/river statement. Suranne Jones was a delight.

Posted by: Cindy at May 16, 2011 1:15 PM

Not a bad episode, but I think it suffered from other people touching it in bad ways. I think it also helped it came after such a dud as last week's episode.

Good- a treasure trove of references made to past Classic Who stories. I had to scrutinize the episode to get all of them, so it's obvious that Gaiman loves his Who roots. Loved House's voice and lines. He was almost charming as baddies go. There was something almost Douglas Adams about him, and speaking of which anyone else pick up Rory;s H2G2 reference when they landed? Rory got a little more positive to do. He was the one who kept House from killing them, he was chosen by Idris as "the pretty one" who got to save the day, and he was the one who stayed brave as I believe everything of him we saw after they got separated was just House screwing with Amy. So I will give the story a mulligan on yet another Rory death as technically it was only an illusion. Still I would have liked to have seen Rory come across a dead Amy too but I suppose Moffat hoped to suggest it was Rory actually aging to death.

Bad- the story seemed a little bit rushed. I'm curious what little tidbits might have been lost either to North American broadcast time restraints or parts of the script edited out so we could hear unnecessary plot recaps. Also a couple things that were altered- One the original title was "House of Nothing" which sounds more Gaiman-esque, and the other was that "Nephew" was supposed to be a Frankenstein monster of the Doctor's past enemies but changed to an Ood for budgetary reasons. I just felt there was more to the story that was exercised since Gaiman is known for being a fairly thorough writer. Once again the Doctor lost control (and possession) of the TARDIS and had the semi-freakout moment he really should have had the week before. I have to say they threw together the piecemeal TARDIS in less than 18 minutes, that seems a bit generous. It wold have made more sense if they had found a TARDIS that another Time Lord had already been working on and just finished the job. Either that or have them take a few days- then Rory and Amy's terror in the haunted TARDIS/House would have seemed more horrifying.

On another note, one exchange I would have liked to have seen between the TARDIS's human avatar and the Doctor is the addressing of the Doctor's abusive treatment of his "beloved" timeship. In every last incarnation he has yelled, cursed, smacked, thumped, hammered, overloaded, dismembered, jury-rigged and even kicked "her" like Ike Turner on Tina any time she didn't perform exactly as he wished. One would have thought she'd take the opportunity to say, "If you hit me ever again and I'll dump you in the nearest white dwarf I come across."

Posted by: bleujayone at May 16, 2011 1:30 PM

I'm also not a fan of the "living TARDIS" concept. It's a stupid concept for this show. Either the Time Lords discovered time travel scientifically, or they simply found a specifies who could time travel and took advantage of that (making them simply adventurers who lucked out, rather than an advanced civilization).

If the TARDIS is alive, then what is with all of the wires, etc., and how can the Doctor be constantly "fixing" it as he is always tinkering on it - even at the end of this episode. What exactly is he "fixing" on a live entity?

Sometimes, in an effort to be clever, one just creates silliness. So now can we look forward to repeated episodes where the TARDIS takes on human form?

And are we to take from the Doctor's absolute ignorance of the idea of sex (bunk beds) that Gallifrians don't procreate? Considering that aside from 2 hearts, the anatomy is the same (even including gender), that seems difficult to believe.

I'm surprised so many liked this episode. I found it just bad on almost every level. Lowering the TARDIS's shields? What, is this Star Trek now?

And when Amy and Rory are running around the TARDIS (until Rory gets his psychic friends message) where exactly are they runnnig to? If House controlled the entire TARDIS, what is running through endless corridors going to accomplish? And, if they wanted to show something different in the TARDIS, why just blank corridors? Show some other room or something.

I don't know what it is that I dislike so much about Amy, but I really don't find her endearing at all.

Posted by: kerminy at May 16, 2011 1:56 PM

kerminy:
Of course The Doctor knows about sex, but he's weird/childish/jealous of Rory -- pick your favorite.

The TARDIS had precisely these TARDIS-merge-preventing shields in "Time Crash", and a trekky forcefield back in "Parting of the Ways".

Amy and Rory aren't running toward anything, they're just running. House ordered them to, and presumably they think it will keep them alive long enough for The Doctor to get back. I felt that in that situation, any room would be a very obvious trap.

Posted by: muzz at May 16, 2011 2:09 PM

Loved this episode, the idea of the TARDIS stealing the only Time Lord mad enough to take her see the universe was amazing, the "Hello Doctor" line was perfect and Rory is totally the pretty one!
One thing though: Rory kept saying House was playing games with THEIR minds, but Amy was the only one affected. Was it because of the whole pregnant-not pregnant thing or just because Auntie touched her face when they met?

Posted by: Me at May 16, 2011 2:10 PM

kerminy >> They aren't running "to" anywhere and there is nothing to "accomplish." House is a sadistic jerk, and he told them to run. The implication is that if they don't entertain him as he says, then he will kill them immediately. Sending them through endless corridors is a cruelty meant to drive them mad. That said, I don't know if it's a rumor, but I did read that Gaiman's original script included a stop at the swimming pool. The lack of variety might have been a budgetary constraint, but I thought it worked on the horrifying level.

Time Lords procreate. I think The Doctor is just having fun with them; he always has had a child-like wonder to him in spite of the many centuries under his belt. An appreciation for bunk beds is meant to be more of a fun line than a line that deserves that sort of Comic-Book-Guy-level scrutiny.

Silliness in the Doctor Who universe has always had its place. The percentage of resolutions in the show's history that stand up to any level of truly hard science is relatively small.

Posted by: C. Robert Dimitri at May 16, 2011 2:12 PM

The only part of the episode I didn't like was Rory dying (yet again). It's become a tiresome trope in the show; they really need to find another damsel in distress or just drop it entirely.

Great episode though. The Doctor Who Confidential aferwards was worth it just for the clips of past Doctor's fawning over the TARDIS.

Posted by: csb at May 16, 2011 2:26 PM

About fixing the TARDIS, kerminy, he's fixing the physical structure - what they kept calling the 'shell'. The alive part of the TARDIS is the matrix. House took the matrix out of the shell and put it into a human body. They had to build another shell and travel in it to get to the phone box shell.

By the way, did anyone else see that the temporary shell was designed by an 11-year old girl who won a contest?

http://www.themarysue.com/doctor-who-contest-winner/

Posted by: Three-nineteen at May 16, 2011 2:38 PM

great ep rory amy doctor river blah blah blah...

"Sexy?"

doesn't BEGIN to cover it. good lord, is that woman gorgeous.

Posted by: matty blue at May 16, 2011 2:50 PM

Re: the hallucinations.

They weren't hallucinations. The TARDIS controls time and space within itself. It's child's play to create a timeline where Rory ages and dies mad and alone and then instantly negate it by creating an alternate time-track where Rory finds Amy a short while after they're separated. Similarly, it's quite simple to create divergent simultaneous timetracks where Rory is dead and Amy in the darkness, and Rory alive and Amy in the light.

Isn't that much creepier than "it was all in their heads"?

Posted by: mightygodking at May 16, 2011 2:55 PM

mightygodking >> Good point. Yes, it is much creepier. Do you have confirmation that is what was happening, or is it theory? Consider my synopsis revised to account for that possibility, although within the context of the show we're not given that level of detail. Amy and Rory only tell us that House is "messing with their heads." Of course, from their perspective that is all that would be happening.

Posted by: C. Robert Dimitri at May 16, 2011 3:30 PM

Great episode but ...sorry but as great as Matt Smith is especially when it comes to more quirky and otherworldly moments he just can't compare to David Tennant when it comes to the more emotional and especially the more intimidating parts.

I think David Tennant would have done this episode a lot more justice.

Posted by: Minto at May 16, 2011 4:30 PM

Idris's cryptic words seem easily decyphered.

"The only water in the Forest is the River"

Think about it:

What episode did River Song die in? "Forest of the Damned".

I think River's time is coming to an end soon, especially since The Doctor is supposedly going to soon find out "who [she] really is". Oh, and Eye Patch Lady is old Amy Pond. Just saying.

Posted by: DoctorControversy at May 16, 2011 4:32 PM

Also, massively unknown fact..."House" is voiced by everyone's favorite virtual night club owner, Michael Sheen.

Posted by: DoctorControversy at May 16, 2011 4:33 PM

We're only 4 episodes in, and we've already seen most of the footage used in the trailer for this series. I'm guessing there will be a second trailer - probably midway through the "break" between eps 7 and 8. I feel like I have no idea where this series it headed . . . and I like it!

Posted by: Lauren at May 16, 2011 5:01 PM

DoctorControversy >> The "Forest" part of the quote and River's history (or The Doctor's history - her future and imminent death) did occur to me too. I think there's more to it than that, though. Otherwise, the reference is not much of a mystery, and it isn't a relevant insight for The Doctor. He already knows about the forest, the library, and what happens there.

I disagree that her time will be ending soon, as there is far more backstory in her relationship that we have yet to see - or so it would seem. I suppose her history with The Doctor could be unwritten as a means to prevent The Doctor's death. Thus, she'd be giving up her love to save his life, and it would be all tragic and bittersweet.

Lauren >> Yeah, I noticed that as well. There are many unknowns around the corner.

Posted by: C. Robert Dimitri at May 16, 2011 5:31 PM

It is clear that the TARDIS soul is River Song. that's why she can drive the TARDIS so well.

Posted by: kerminy at May 16, 2011 5:49 PM


It just occurred to me why I liked the voice of House- he was really

Marvin the Paranoid Android...er..ah...Asteroid with just a little more pep.

Posted by: bleujayone at May 16, 2011 6:10 PM

1. Rory's dead. Must be Saturday. Most actor's read a script, see they've been killed, and start looking for another job. Do you suppose Arthur reads a script, see he's been killed, and thinks, "Must be pay day?"

2. FOOKIN PRAWNS at BBCA can lose the Amy Pond voice over at the beginning of the show ANY TIME.

3. Anyone else think Sexy / TARDIS / Idris was Helena Bonham Carter at first? Just me?

4. Timelords can switch genders! Whoo-hoo! I like that.

5. The TARDIS has at least 30 control rooms archived, and the control room hasn't always changed when the Doctor regenerated, so there could be more than 30 regens. Either that, or other timelords have used this TARDIS.

6. At the beginning, when the Doctor thought there was another timelord out there, I thought we might be finding out more about the little girl from the children's home.

7. When Amy and Rory got separated the first time and Rory said she had been gone 2 hours, they SOULD HAVE HELD ON TIGHT TO EACH OTHER'S HANDS. And when everything went dark for Amy, but not for Rory, Rory sould have gone back and held her hand. Those bits just didn't make sense to me.

Posted by: BWeaves at May 16, 2011 6:35 PM

sould = should. Stupid fingers.

Posted by: BWeaves at May 16, 2011 6:36 PM

kerminy >> Interesting theory with River as the TARDIS. It does seem to fly in the face of her monologue to Rory in the season opener, though. It could perhaps work if you take some of what she said metaphorically. I'm reluctant to agree with it for no other reason than River Song is very much Moffat's story, and it would be odd to let Gaiman jump in with a very related stand-alone episode.

Bweaves >>

1) Indeed.

3) Yes, the Helena Bonham Carter vibe occurred to me. The face, the hair, and the wardrobe were all reminiscent.

5) Since he stole her, I guess it is conceivable that others had flown her. Or perhaps some of the other control rooms are just alternative, customizable features, like power windows or leather bucket seats?

6) I didn't think that, if only because I knew that Gaiman wrote this episode originally for last season and it got bumped back. I was very much hoping we might meet another Time Lord, though. I guess there's still hope that Romana could show up again someday.

7) That occurred to me too. I dismissed it under the assumption that the second Rory was not the real Rory. Or maybe I just see it as narrative shorthand. House could separate them if he wanted to separate them.

Posted by: DarthCorleone at May 16, 2011 7:05 PM

2. FOOKIN PRAWNS at BBCA can lose the Amy Pond voice over at the beginning of the show ANY TIME.

5. The TARDIS has at least 30 control rooms archived, and the control room hasn't always changed when the Doctor regenerated, so there could be more than 30 regens. Either that, or other timelords have used this TARDIS.

Posted by: BWeaves at May 16, 2011 6:35 PM

2. Seriously. Makes it seem like it's "Pond Who". I like Amy, but I'm about bored with the idea that she's so much more important than any other companion/human in the Doctor's life. They better have a damn good explanation for that.

5. At one point TARDIS Idris said that she was in a museum when the Doctor stole her/she stole the Doctor. So I'm guessing your second theory is correct.

And I'm with mightygodking on the idea that House was actually messing with the timelines. They seem to be setting up some resentment between Rory and Amy, first with his confusion over what stupid face she was saying she was in love with in Day of the Moon, then with the "hate Amy kill Amy" scrawlings of mad dead Rory. He already waited 2000 years for her, so think about how agonizing it would be if House actually made him grow old alone, lost in the halls of the TARDIS, waiting for Amy to come back for him. I'm predicting some sort of rift between them in coming eps.


Posted by: JustBill at May 16, 2011 7:05 PM

JustBill she also points out that she was obsolete when he stole her/or she stole him. If I recall way back to the early years there was some suggestion that the TARDIS was at least in part a living organism.

Posted by: clancys_daddy at May 16, 2011 8:42 PM

Post script while I did enjoy the episode I can do without the rory dying thing its starting to annoy.

Posted by: clancys_daddy at May 16, 2011 8:43 PM

I really enjoyed this ep and I love Dr Who and maybe I don't pay that much attention to the details, but what made TARDIS going into Idris different than when it went into Rose in Season 2 (?) Is it because Idris had her soul sucked out of her first? Just curious. Can anyone explain? Thanks!

Posted by: swellegant at May 16, 2011 9:17 PM

5. The TARDIS has at least 30 control rooms archived, and the control room hasn't always changed when the Doctor regenerated, so there could be more than 30 regens. Either that, or other timelords have used this TARDIS.

Posted by: BWeaves at May 16, 2011 6:35 PM

The Doctor brought this up in the episode and the Tardis explained it herself. She said she had archived both past and future control rooms (not necessarily all of them, though).

Does BBC America still edit out bits of the episodes on you folks, or did everyone just miss that exchange? Those two were firing the banter off pretty quickly. Heh.

Posted by: Hazel Dean at May 16, 2011 9:53 PM

Hey CRD, if you are interested in Gaiman I suggest American Gods, Stardust (graphic novel or regular novel), or Good Omens by Terry Pratchett and Neil Gaiman.

I also got the Douglas Adams jokes, which were awesome and a nice nod to Adams who once wrote for Dr. Who.

Posted by: Melody Be at May 16, 2011 10:41 PM

Oh, noooo. The writer of "Fear Her"? That awful episode of the girl who would draw people and they'd disappear? Probably the worst child actor of all time. Ugh.

However, if that episode ends up having David Tennant in Doctor Who garb ACTUALLY LIGHTING THE OLYMPIC TORCH IN 2012 then it was worth it.

Posted by: AlexaCastro at May 17, 2011 3:03 AM

"The only water in the Forest is the River?"

Forest of the Dead? (which was on YESTERDAY when I was home sick...)

LOOOOOVE the idea that kiddie Time Lord is Jr. Saxon...hadn't thought of that!!!

I loved this episode, and wish Idris/Time Lord would stick around with the Doctor more.

Posted by: dammitjanet at May 17, 2011 8:01 AM


I LOVED this episode but have two tiny quibbles.

(1) The corridors on the Tardis were okay but the orange circles looked too Austin Powers and,

(2) At the end of the episode -- the perspective of Idris standing on the stairway looking down at the Doctor -- made her look bigger than him -- rather like Mother and Child.

To read questions put to Neil Gaiman on the episode and his excellent and sometimes very unexpected answers go to this link at:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/tv-and-radio/tvandradioblog/2011/may/16/neil-gaiman-doctor-who-doctors-wife?commentpage=1#comment-10776101

Posted by: Meenakshi at May 17, 2011 9:20 AM

What exactly is he "fixing" on a live entity?

...you do understand the function of a doctor, don't you?

/crickets

"The only water in the forest is the river"

I like the idea that the "only water" means "not POND". It could mean so many things in the coming episodes...

Posted by: Patty O'Green at May 17, 2011 12:24 PM

swellegant >> I'd need to re-watch that scene, as I'm forgetting the exact sequence of events (i.e., how long she had TARDIS energy in her and when The Doctor transferred his own regeneration power to save her). It has been a while. I think the difference you mention is relevant.

Meenakshi >> Thanks for that link! I enjoyed reading his feedback.

And here's a Twitter exchange that I just had with Neil Gaiman...

@neilhimself Did Rory actually live out a tortured alternate lifespan in the TARDIS corridors, or was it merely House's illusion? Thanks!

@crobertdimitri House's illusion. I hope...

Posted by: C. Robert Dimitri at May 17, 2011 5:35 PM

Really liked this episode especially the line "Did you wish really hard?", it's great when Amy's making fun of him. I've not been a fan of the new Doctor, probably some of it bitterness that Matt Smith is younger than me ;) but I really liked him this time and came up with a theory:

Has he reverted to a childlike character after too much trauma? The Tennent Docter (which I've been rewatching in marathons) lost so much, made so many mistakes and got so angry near the end and was really sad to die. Has he gone all childlike to avoid dealing with it? Probably not as I doubt the writers think so seriously about it but it's fun for me to think about.

I'm also giving them the benefit of the doubt and hoping there's more to Rory's deaths. They don't annoy me but I always hope for clues to the future with this show.

Posted by: stainboy at May 17, 2011 6:09 PM

You guys have to look at this for the Rory deaths. I about died when I saw this. http://www.redbubble.com/people/zerobriant/art/7186582-omg-they-killed-rory-posters

Also, @C. Robert Dimitri thanks for replying. I need to rewatch it too! Because I thought Rose was dead when Tardis went into her and so I'm confused. Maybe there is some explanation somewhere.

Posted by: swellegant at May 19, 2011 3:27 PM