web
counter
 

Not Even the Media Could Completely Spoil the Sincerity of These Events

By Michael Murray | Posted Under TV Reviews | Comments (17)



Chilean-miner-Florencio-A-008.jpg

I came late to the story of the Chilean miners.

It wasn’t until about two weeks ago that I had a clear sense of what was transpiring, and like pretty much everybody on the planet, I was stunned, even a little awestruck. The thought of men being trapped underground for months was unbelievable, as if culled from a horror film. It was beyond the scope of normal imagination, and the few images that were released of the beleaguered miners seemed a surreal invasion of their suffering.



These glimpses were too intimate, somehow, and they threatened to marginalize the men to little more than zoo-like curiosities, but the vulnerability and helplessness of the miners was an empathetic pulse nobody could resist. Instead of becoming an underground version of “Big Brother,” the miners were mercifully allowed their privacy, and the story captured the imagination of the world. In spite of the fact that there was very little to actually broadcast, the media stormed forward with its coverage, discovering that like all good horror films, the enduring power of this story was not in what has happening, but in what we imagined might happen.

Most headline news stories have a visual hook, something that captures our eye and can be easily assimilated at a glance, but this story wasn’t like that. No houses were destroyed, nobody was bleeding on the streets and no celebrities were involved. There was something old-fashioned about it. A largely abstract scenario, the miner’s plight required that we employ our imagination and sit down and think, and this had the effect of slowing down the world rather than accelerating it, as most media does. The forestalled lives of these miners were to become a part of our daily ruminations, and not just a fleeting bit of the news cycle, and as the days passed into weeks and then months, the tension kept mounting.

Even though the story needed no embellishment, the media, with an abundance of time on their hands and without any grabby images to sell, attacked the story from every imaginable angle. We got Computer Graphic Imagery, were delivered miner stats as if from the back of a baseball card, we received lessons on Chile and The President, we learned every detail of the proposed rescue mission and we watched as a portly American correspondent wiggled through a bicycle tire in order to demonstrate the circumference of the rescue capsule. It was almost all ridiculous and hyperbolic, but it didn’t matter. Men were trapped beneath the Earth, and we were going to try to get them out.

In the face of a problem with no quick fixes and ample time for consideration, a collective genius arose. I was amazed at how detailed and well-thought out the rescue mission was. It seemed that not a single detail or contingency was overlooked, and it was both touching and encouraging to see the extreme lengths that humans will go to in order to save those of their own tribe.

The rescue operation, which started on Wednesday, was unhurried and anti-climatic, just as the whole story, now spread out over 69 days, had been.

There was an antique feeling to the whole proceedings, as if we were watching something unfolding from the set of an old Western. The landscape behind the tiny hole in the ground (through which miracles were to emerge) resembled a lunar dessert. The winch that was used to pull the miners to safety was perfect in it’s simplicity. The Chilean flag (that was to obscure the proceedings from the media, but was moved aside when confidence of success surged) looked like a gift from a high school class, and the rescue capsule, also emblazoned with the Chilean colors, so that it looked like a rocket, was nothing short of charming, the sort of thing that Wes Anderson might have put in a movie. In short, everything in the rescue operation, which was brilliantly conceived and executed, looked man-made rather than constructed by high-tech robots from the future. You saw the hand of human industry at work and that was beautiful.


I watched the live feed of the rescue, which initially seemed to feature little more than a hole surrounded by a bunch of legs in orange coveralls ending boots. The footage was jerky, like it was coming from a web cam, and the sound was muddy and indecipherable. When the first miner emerged from the ground, nothing dramatic happened—angels did not descend from the heavens scattering rose petals.




Instead of getting an immediate resolution of tension when the capsule was pulled up from the earth, we had to wait— once again— as Florencio Avalos, behind an obscuring screen of mesh, was slowly and carefully unfastened. Concealed behind protective sunglasses, he stoically walked over to his family, betraying little emotion. However, his seven year-old boy was bawling, and as he hugged his father, he was the perfect stand-in for the rest of us, who unable to marshal the composure that seemed to come so easily to Avalos, sat watching at home with trembling lips and dewy eyes.

No pyrotechnics or movie star heroics defined this story, just a patient and determined commitment to the sanctity of life and love. And as each of the 33 miners rose to the surface over the next 24 hours, we were moved by the sincerity of the love, gratitude and accomplishment that radiated from everybody squeezed onto our TV screen, and were happy to have some of it wash into us, too.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Carnival of Souls Review | The Ghost Inside | Pajiba Love 15/10/10









Comments

And yet because we can never just leave a perfect moment to be itself, we will now have months of Today show interviews and feel-good specials and calendars and you know by Christmas we'll hate the sight of them.

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 15, 2010 11:36 AM

I noticed that many of them broke down on their respective stretchers. It was probably the most comfortable they'd been in months and the physical relief just pushed them over the edge.

That was some good human drama, even though I couldn't understand a fucking word they were saying.

Posted by: Kballs at October 15, 2010 11:50 AM

To both Murray and PaddyDog: Yup.

Posted by: RobP at October 15, 2010 11:51 AM

Agreed.

But why has not a single media outlet (that I know of) talked about the dangers that miners are still facing every day, and about how better measures need to be taken for their protection?

Posted by: Shobhna at October 15, 2010 12:00 PM

Nice article, Michael. I do agree with Paddy though. Now we can kick back and watch the exploitation.

As I was driving home yesterday they were discussing this on the radio. There we a bunch of people upset that others (including some of the miners) were calling the rescue a "miracle" and "God's will". I was a little sickened by the argument that transpired. As far as I'm concerned, whatever those men had to believe to get through living for two fucking months underground is fine by me. Sometimes (okay most of the time) I really hate people.

Posted by: admin at October 15, 2010 12:04 PM

What admin said is true. A lot of people were bothered by the fact that so many Chileans, including our president, thanked God for the success of the rescue mission. In some cases, it was the same people who complain about religious people oppressing them.

The mission was a massive technical feat, flawless and perfectly executed. But there was something else in the air as soon as we got that first proof of life from the inside of the mine. Hope, relief, whatever you wanna call it. It was bigger than everyone involved. For some people it was love, for others it was God, and for others it was both.

We're happy and proud. I'm not particularly religious, but I'm amazed at what faith can do for the human spirit. Faith kept those men alive and gave them the will to be patient. Some people meditate, others jog, others knit. The miners prayed. Maybe it's not what many of us would've done, but I say do whatever works to keep you alive.

Posted by: THE Sofía at October 15, 2010 12:50 PM

It is an amazing uplifting story. An amazing example of what can be done when people are guided by the best in themselves, rather than by greed and self-interest....

Too bad it will inevitably become a schlocky movie, in which only 4 or 5 of the men play large roles (because who has time for 33 main characters?!?!), starring Edward James Olmos, Jimmy Smits, George Lopez, Javier Bardem, Dev Patel, Kal Penn, Adrian Brody, and Jamie Farr, with a special appearance by F. Murray Abraham as the Chilean president. The wives and girlfriends will be played by Selma Hayak, Penelope Cruz, Giselle Bundchen, and Megan Fox, with a special appearance by Jennifer Lopez as Suzanna, the girlfriend of "Doc" Yonni Barros (Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson).

Posted by: Edith at October 15, 2010 3:03 PM

For a few days, it was a welcome change to have the lead story be one of good news.

Also, may I point you at this:

http://twitter.com/Chilean_miner


Ramón suggests we tunnel further down and connect with various farmers' storehouses, but I suspect he has read Fantastic Mr Fox too often

DISASTER! There is a wasp down here!

So glad I didn't bring my iPad to work. Being stuck in here with no Flash video would truly be a nightmare

Posted by: Simon at October 15, 2010 3:11 PM

There are all sorts of dark elements to the story, but they obscure rather than illuminate the true essence of what transpired, I think.

At first the mining company didn't want to pay the workers for their time underground, as they weren't technically "working." This, of course, would have been a PR disaster, and the story did turn into a weird sort of propaganda campaign, full of political opportunists and other miscreants. But the surge of Chilean pride looked utterly sincere and deserved. Hell, in the States USA!!USA!! is chanted whenever a cat nabs a mouse, and in Canada, for the longest time, the focal point in our National anthem sign-off at the end of the night was securing a SILVER medal at the Olympics. I give Chile, and everybody involved in the project their props.

The miners are now being bombarded by all manner of financial opportunity, and are preparing a lawsuit against the mining company. They have decided to split all proceeds equally, and seem honest and humble in their intent, although it's inevitable that our interest in the story will turn it, and some of the men into monsters, but God knows, we've all become monsters with much less cause.

Posted by: Michael Murray at October 15, 2010 3:17 PM


Oh, the talking heads need to stir up an excuse for being there at all. Same with the writing, editing, experts and the rest. "Framing" the story begs why a story need be framed at all, except to tell us what to think about it. Can I hear from someone on the ground (so to speak), but they're usually to busy getting the job done.

Besides, quiet competence doesn't make for the ratings. Neither do courage, stoicism, decency or ... placid complication. One of the miners has a mistress and a wife. The wife's comments are gold.

None of the real stuff makes good fodder for the grazing herds of 7-bellied processors & the flocks that feed on their effluvia. Doesn't stop them from trying.

One of the miners headed North to start over after the earthquake and tsunami. "Oh, how horrible." screech the interpreters. Well, more like bad luck, which happens. He hasn't complained. They're complaining for him, framing a story. Earthquake, tsunami & now mine collapse. He's horribly unlucky to be in the way of such things. But maybe horribly lucky to be alive.

If this guy went North after the flood to try something else, I suspect he's already looking for what's next. I'd bet on him over the whiners any day.

In any case, we haven't heard what he thinks, rather what some office-bound talking head thinks is a hook. How many links of intake to waste do we tolerate between the real stuff and what we willingly consume? "Meta" is just another word for pre-digested.

So, here's the thing, ye snarkley hordes. Do you snark to tear down the good, or snark at what is needlessly bad? Mock aspiration and getting stuff done, or puncture pretense on its own self-importance.

Nice work, Mr. Murray - fine choice of target - as "the media" could be, should be so much more, while those miners and the people who rescued them, well they showed us what's better.

Posted by: BierceAmbrose at October 15, 2010 3:19 PM

Praying is essentially concentrated hoping, and there's not a damn thing wrong with it.

Yet another idea that is corrupted bu those who seek to control how it's done.

Posted by: replica at October 15, 2010 3:29 PM

Replica--Somebody, I think it was C.S. Lewis, said that prayer is the "ordering of love." I like that. And I like "concentrated hoping," too. What prayer means to anybody, or anything beyond us, is anybody's guess, but I know that I always feels better when I hear somebody is praying for me because I know that love is present.

And Ambrose, you're absolutely right. You should write a screenplay, short story, etcetera using one of the miners, perhaps 8 years in the future, as a starting point, working both backwards and forewards to deconstruct the media swirling around him.

Posted by: Michael Murray at October 15, 2010 3:40 PM

I watched most of the rescues on the BBC website, but we tuned in to CNN for the final miner's rescue.

I was shocked (maybe I shouldn't have been) that there was no on the spot translation on CNN as there had been on the BBC.

I ran back to my laptop and watched the rest with the Brits. Their reporter COULD EVEN SPEAK SPANISH with the locals, and he translated their answers to us on the fly. Fancy that!

Chi! Chi! Chi! Le Le Le ! Los mineros de Chile!

Posted by: mswas at October 15, 2010 4:41 PM

Sorkin is writing this one as we speak. Oliver Stone is, you know, slow but he's a faster typist. It flops big time but Ugly Betty wins supporting Oscar and saves the day.

Posted by: schmerpes at October 15, 2010 4:41 PM

Nice piece, Mr. Murray.

I have found that I’m very careful not to say that I’m “praying” for someone, as the mere use of the word and the personal connotation that I attach to it would be completely disingenuous. To say something I find dishonest in a time of trouble seems particularly wrong.

I most frequently resort to "my thoughts are with you," which is accurate, genuine, and concerned. Still, it seems much less elegant and even second-rate. I'm a guy who would not ever acknowledge that making an entreaty to a divine being could possibly create any sort of tangible result. And yet here I am offering my "thoughts" as a pittance, which I truly believe won't make any sort of direct tangible difference? It's not as if I am psychic or have psionic powers like telekinesis.

It just seems paltry next to those cool prayers that other people are able to give out, particularly if I'm hoping to give solace to someone who would believe in the power of prayer. That's not to say that I believe optimistic belief is completely useless. I think it can have an effect on mentality and psychology and thus extend to real-world change.

An atheist's lament, I suppose.

Posted by: DarthCorleone at October 15, 2010 4:55 PM

a lunar dessert.
---
Moon Pie!

Posted by: , at October 15, 2010 7:48 PM

I want to know: in which far-flung chamber of Hell do these individuals who even considered not compensating these men plan to inhabit? All for some dust and chunks in rock? Holy Sierre Madre, I just don't know about people sometimes. It's just utterly mailbox-brained to not consider that perhaps the entire world would take exception to such a brutal betrayal on top of so many pre-existing ones. And now the shameful coda to a story of trauma, in which the men are nigh on ravished by various media news outlets and 'human interest' whores, who feel not a twinge of compunction about flinging themselves wantonly at the survivors in service of 'the big get'. My overgrown cynical side remembers that the miners have already issued a plea for some privacy, and it thinks, 'Well, they're not going to get it until the people with the cameras and mics are good and ready to let that happen. Sorry, miners, this just isn't about you, so try to be more giving, okay?' It thinks about Sorkin, Stone and others (I'm sure), huh? Subtle as a field of daggers that walks, walks, walks. But then, I'm immediately shaken over my sense of superiority that's totally unearned, because everyone is alive. What comes next comes next: everyone's alive.

I had insomnia (shock) the night that the rock had been broken. There was a correspondant announcing that sirens would be sounded when that happened, and damn it all if I didn't sit there, heart racing, twitching involuntarily just a bit in anticipation. It just happened to be Thanksgiving weekend in Canada, so I was at my mother's place. For once, I had people around to awaken and for once, I exploded into a ball of mirth so I running around the place like a tweaking lab rat. So as crass as the coverage is, man, they got out and it's so, so beautiful.

Posted by: Jo 'Mama' Besser at October 17, 2010 7:07 PM