sweet16.jpg

Birthday Party, Cheesecake, Jelly Bean, Boom!

“My Super Sweet 16” / Dustin Rowles

TV Reviews | October 25, 2007 | Comments (186)


For the uninitiated, “My Super Sweet 16,” in a nutshell, is basically what’s wrong with the youth of America. It’s not bad enough that these spoiled, bubbly-letter princesses expect to be thrown lavish birthday parties, but the douchedads and trollop moms are so goddamn smug and amenable that it’s them you want to take out behind the woodshed and unleash a bag of switches upon. What’s worse, at least in my mind, is the number of idiot hangers-on who choose to cling to the birthday girls, and the acne-addled dejected who aren’t even cool enough to be contrarian about it. In the hellish world of “My Super Sweet Sixteen,” everyone wants to be like the birthday girl; there are no gothy counter-culture cliques or punk-rock kids who might reject the mentality behind these parties. There are only the haves — who demand, and cajole, and sulk, and squeal like brats with silver spoons shoved into their alimentary canals — and the slavering have-nots, the truly pathetic who actually aspire to be like them.

The episode I chose to review concerned a bubbly blight on adolescent America, a girl named Savannah, as in “Lights, Camera, Savannah!” Her hair color clearly comes in a bottle, and her chest size from one of those implant drive-thrus they have out in Cali (I feel bad suggesting a 15-year-old girl has implants, but Jesus: In post-apocalyptic America, grave robbers are gonna fetch a handsome price for those puppies). Naturally, she’s an O.C. girl, though if there is one thing I can say for “My Super Sweet 16,” it’s that there’s plenty of diversity: The show features spoiled bitches of all color and stripe: black, white, and even an Iranian-American girl, who was given a stretch Range Rover for her 16th, only to leave it parked in her driveway because it was too big to drive around (she motors around in her mom’s Caddy, instead). There’s even an episode featuring a girl from Little Rock, Arkansas (per capita income $23,000), who could’ve used the cash from her military-themed party to single-handedly put a dent in Little Rock’s 15 percent poverty rate (her jewelry alone cost $165,000 — “Daddy didn’t give me no budget.”). But, you know: Fuck her. And fuck all these bratty twits — they’re not the type to consider anyone but themselves, a habit most picked up from their fathers, who arrange extravagant parties with fake volcanoes in lieu of actual affection, what with being too busy living the goddamn American Dream to do any actual parenting.

Anyway, the beginning of each episode offers a few minutes in which we get to know the birthday girl (or, occasionally, boy), and here, Savannah brags that, “to be a California girl, it takes blonde hair, blue eyes, and a tan. And I have it all.” Savannah claims that “a lot of girls are jealous because of my looks,” though she never considers for a second that girls may not like her because she’s an obnoxious, plasticized fuckwit whose idea of friendship is allowing someone to hold her hair while she regurgitates one of Little Caesars’ gourmet pizza pizzas. “I’m upbeat, I’m happy. And I love shopping,” she exclaims, offering a glimpse into her Playmate Centerfold bio, in five … two year’s time. “Being this cute is a problem these days,” she says without the smallest trace of irony. God Almighty, I hate this girl. Who could raise such a prissy little hellspawn?

That answer arrives in the next segment, in which we meet Savannah’s mother, who makes Jennifer Coolidge (Stifler’s Mom) look positively granola. Someone must have tapped the Alaskan oil reserves to create all the plastic beneath this woman’s cosmetically-deranged epidermis. One of the points of contention in this week’s episode seems to be Savannah’s fear that her mother will overshadow her at her own Sweet 16. “I just hope she realizes this party is about me,” Savannah says. “This is my time to shine.” Clearly, Savannah’s concerns are well-founded — throughout the episode, we return to this theme, when 1) Mom — who must be a former porn star of some sort — insists that she’ll have bigger jewelry than her daughter while giving the camera a knowing look that says, “Fuck me world. Fuck me long and hard and on your M Televisions”; 2) when her mother insists on trying on her daughter’s favorite entrance dress, an $8,000 tiger-print gown that makes her look like 12-inch hot dog stuffed into an eight inch bun; and 3) later in the show, when Savannah asks her gaggle of stylists to make her look better than her mom, clearly afraid that her mother would otherwise steal her fawning admirers. It’s a weird, unfamiliar mother-daughter dynamic, though I suspect it’s common amongst over-the-hill starletards who are deathly afraid their daughters are encroaching upon their territory, though this particular mother may need a wheelbarrow to haul her breasts to the party.

In each of these Sweet 16 parties, all of the birthday girls insist that their party will go down in history, as if historians spend their spare moments documenting gaudiness and excess. Here, Savannah promises to have “the greatest 16th birthday party. Ever,” as if this was a noble, ambitious goal. Themes on “My Super Sweet 16” vary, though they are all equally unapologetic in their gluttonous exorbitance — princess themes are common, though Savannah, whose father’s game room is riddled with exotic wildlife taxidermied to the hilt, chooses a Jungle theme. (My fondest wish: That her party planners mistakenly give her the Upton Sinclair version.) The venue, appropriately, seems to be some wildlife preserve nestled comfortably in Laguna Beach. Oh, and guess what: There’s gonna be an oxygen bar at her party. That’s right — her parents are going to pay thousands of dollars for air!

Before the party, however, invitations must be handed out, and even this task is taken to the extreme. In Savannah’s case, a throng of teenagers is assembled at the beach and asked to await Savannah’s grand entrance, which she performs while lying on a party boat, Pamela-Anderson style. Once she makes her way to the beach, she allows the potential guests to search amongst the Tiki torches for invitations, which look to be laminated photos of her in tiger-print underclothing. Presumably, only the luckiest few are invited, and it is those people who jump around with the same sort of fervor one would expect from a dying man who has finally reached the top of the kidney-donor list.

After this, Savannah meets with a couple of exotic animal handlers who parade out a tiger, a monkey, a bear cub, and a scary motherfucking cougar, which she insists on having: “Mom — this would put it over the top. There’s no way you can say no.” Her mother, of course, cannot — clearly, she hasn’t said “no” to anyone since giant-donged men hoovered coke lines off her back during her Boogie Night days. Following this segment, Savannah trollops around a couple of car dealerships with her Dad — an anthropomorphic beer gut — sidling up to his arm and batting her eyelashes when the dealer says that the BMW she simply must have costs $48,000, which is only a fraction of the $300,000 spent on her birthday-party jewelry.

It is leading up toward the party where the editors of “My Super Sweet 16” usually try in earnest to work up some fake dramatics; in the Little Rock episode, there was a fear the girl’s party would be canceled after the fire department had to be called in to tend to the fake volcano. Here, however, the dramatics are even pettier: The jewelry is late in arriving, and Savannah refuses to make her grand entrance without them. “I need my diamonds. They better get here before we go.” Foot stomp. They arrive, of course, just as Savannah is being whisked away in a stretch Hummer, where one of her closeted private-school classmates squeals, “Ohmygod, you look like Britney in Toxic.” That’s a compliment?

The parties themselves are generally anti-climactic, hardly history-defining. It’s just a jumble of teenagers piled into a room and forced to listen to shitty hip-hop/house music while they rub up against one another and take hits off the oxygen. The grand entrance is made, and the editors splice in several snippets of teenagers utilizing their exclamatory “TRL” speak: “Wooooo! Wooo! Woooo!” Sometimes, as is the case here, the guests of honor have to deal with party-crashers, dumbass kids who aren’t secure enough in their person to stay at home and mock the proceedings for its extravagant lameness. Fortunately, there’s usually enough security to protect the President from a team of Sirhan Sirhans, so the despondent crashers are tossed before their first swig of Red Bull.

And, finally, each episode ends with the birthday girl walking outside and expressing faux surprise at the ridiculously expensive car they’ve been gifted. This, each episode’s capper, is the ultimate symbol of American’s consumerist culture, the belief — likely propagated by car dealerships around the country — that, indeed, parental affection can be bought, and that instant popularity comes with two doors, bejeweled fuzzy dice, and 9.6 miles per gallon. Like an old Western, before the credits roll, the girl drives away into the sunset as, once again, the editors cut to the drooling teens, who express envy and admiration for the birthday girl’s good fortunes (these classmates and friends never articulate even an iota of bitterness or rage, though I suspect most of them are just biding their time until they are feted with the same extravagancies). And it never once occurs to these girls that, on teevees across this great land of ours, she’d be the object of scorn and ridicule, though the Romans likely took little notice of the Ostrogoths before the crumble of the Empire, either. They probably just thought that Odaecer was a jealous little bitch.

So, yeah: I hate this show. And I hate even more the sense of entitlement it instills in the current generation of teenagers, who approach their 16th birthdays either expecting one of these parties, or fantasizing about it. I don’t even know which is worse. But, I can tell you that if ‘lil Pajiba ever came to me and asked for a fountain and a low-rent hip hop star for his 16th birthday, I’d tell the little punchkin that the sweetest thing he’s likely to get is a goddamn Carvel Ice Cream cake and a boot to the ass. And if he wants a theme, we’ll get a cake with “Peanuts” characters on it.

Dustin Rowles is the publisher of Pajiba. He lives with his wife and son in Ithaca, New York. You may email him, or leave a comment below.


I Am America, And So Can You | Pajiba Love 10/25/07





Comments

"Naturally, she's an O.C. girl"

Don't call it that!

Posted by: Armando at October 25, 2007 2:55 PM

[slow clap]....

Nicely done, sir.

"Fuckwit" is one of my favorite terms.

Posted by: Sean at October 25, 2007 2:56 PM

So much to love about this review, but my favorite line was this:

...that makes her look like 12-inch hot dog stuffed into an eight inch bun

Ha! I also like the idea of an unwitting little bitch getting an Upton Sinclair Jungle themed party. Screaming cows and all. And I mean the animals, not the girls' mothers.

I should find a snipit of this show online so I can see it for myself. There's no way I could sit through a whole episode, even if I did have cable.

Posted by: katy at October 25, 2007 3:03 PM

My God I hope their birthday cakes are laced with birth control. I can not stand to watch this show. All of my violent tendencies (that I usually reserve for the state of the union address) boil over until I want to kidnap each one of these kids and strap them to a chair Clockwork Orange style and force them to witness actual suffering...not the kind that involves bitching about a trip to Paris that doesn't result in finding a pretty enough dress. Hate.

Posted by: Julie at October 25, 2007 3:07 PM

This makes me incredibly grateful for the fact that we don't watch television anymore. The ungrateful, over primped fucktards that parade around on these types of shows make me want to retch. As a parent, it's difficult enough to try and instill some good qualities in your kids without Britrislohan or some such twat pontificating on the virtues of celebrity. My hat goes off to you, Dustin, for having the strength to sit through that pile of steaming rhino shit.

Posted by: Manny at October 25, 2007 3:09 PM

"Her mother, of course, cannot -- clearly, she hasn't said "no" to anyone since giant-donged men hoovered coke lines off her back during her Boogie Night days."

Jaysus...I just spewed Five Alive all over my keyboard.
Don't know if I'll make it through the rest of the review.

Posted by: brite at October 25, 2007 3:10 PM

The hell's an oxygen bar? I must be totally out of the loop.

Posted by: Brianne at October 25, 2007 3:11 PM

12-inch hot dog stuffed into an eight inch bun

[must resist . . . too easy . . . can't demean self . . .]

Rome had the Coliseum; America has this nonsense. We're going down, baby, harder than Savannah's mother at the casting call for Ass Blasters 22: The Blasting.

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 25, 2007 3:13 PM

"the sweetest thing he's likely to get is a goddamn Carvel Ice Cream cake and a boot to the ass."

I heart you Dustin. It perfectly echoes my sentiments if 'lil Stella Marie comes to me with a similar request.

Posted by: Stella at October 25, 2007 3:17 PM

Thankyouthankyouthankyouthankyouthankyou!!!!! I knew so many of these girls in high school (naturally in California) and you're right. They never did understand that the rest of us hated them for their personalities, not their looks. The parents on these shows are the most horrendous part, due to the fact that they obviously never did do much parenting. Lil' Pajiba is lucky he has parents that care enough to give him a swift kick in the pants if he earns one.

Posted by: Lauren at October 25, 2007 3:18 PM

you're absolutely right, Socalled. We are going down, and it's not even in a blaze of glory...

Posted by: Stella at October 25, 2007 3:19 PM

Dustin,
I hope you know that during this review, I didn't for one second stop laughing. This sounds like such tripe. Damn, it's seriously not helping out knowing that instead of Daria(Which I'm still missing), MTV now shows THIS kind of crap. White Cali Girls who dress like sluts and act like bitchy Barbie dolls.

Posted by: Ben at October 25, 2007 3:19 PM

God bless you, Mr. Pajiba. God bless you everyone.

This show, this and fucking The Hills, they are the reason why the latest generation of teenagers need to be instantly drafted. While they sit there in their living rooms, texting OMG! Did U Ttly C THAT!!!" on their $440 Sidekicks, on their 40 in plasma flatscreens, bitching because mommy only gave them $100 for their allowance, THIS IS WHAT IS WRONG WITH TEENS.

MTV is far more dangerous to teenagers than any wine cooler, school shooting or rap lyric. I really wish this prostitot's fucking party was "The Jungle" and they ground these sheep into Lamb Shwarma.

Posted by: insertclevernamehere at October 25, 2007 3:22 PM

After attending a grey and rainy graveside service, this was exactly what I needed. I laughed the hard, silent laugh many times, but now I'm left with a really sick feeling in my brain for these people. Sick as in food poisoning sick. Like my brain just wants to barf up the review so the pain will go away.

Posted by: Alabamapink at October 25, 2007 3:22 PM

Cookie Puss! Fudgie the Whale!

This is the best review I've yet read on Pajiba. You can't beat the image of the "The Jungle" party, the reference to "long-donged men", and an appearance by Odoacer (that "jealous little bitch"!). This is why this site exists.

Additionally, an acquaintance-of-an-acquaintance works on this show, and has asserted that there's no creative editing going on: the kids and their parents are just as awful as they're portrayed.

Posted by: The Piglet at October 25, 2007 3:23 PM

Oh, Ben... I miss Daria too!!! That was back in the good old days when there was still some music on MTV! Not much, but more than the 5 or so bad songs that air on TRL every afternoon.

Posted by: Lauren at October 25, 2007 3:24 PM

Jesus tap-dancing Christ. There isn't enough time in the day to dissect everything that is wrong with a show like this. But thanks for giving us a good summary Dustin. You are really taking some licks for the team. "Grey's" and now this. Damn dude you need a Firefly/Serentiy marathon to detox yourself.

Posted by: Dave at October 25, 2007 3:25 PM

I'm in total agreement with everything you wrote, Dustin. I often catch myself watching this and thinking that at least some part of it MUST be fake. It MUST be right? There can't be so many awful people in the world! And I blame it entirely on the parents. I mean come on, you can be a great parent and still end up with a difficult child, but the way these girls (and boys I guess) act is not a result of a naturally surly personality, it's the result of mommy and/or daddy caving in to every whim and telling them constantly that they're the best/smartest/richest/perfectest person in all the land. Just makes me sad, really.

Posted by: bluestar at October 25, 2007 3:30 PM

brite,

They still make Five Alive? I LOVE that stuff!

Posted by: Erin at October 25, 2007 3:32 PM

Parents are such jackasses. Don't they know that even if their daughter is a Rhodes Scholar with a 3.8 out of Swarthmore she'll always be thought of as an idiot if her name is Savannah?

Posted by: Samantha T at October 25, 2007 3:35 PM

I just realized, after reading your article, that the best fucking themed birthday party EVER would be a 'Presidential Assassination' themed party. Sweartogod, somebody has to do that.

Posted by: AJ at October 25, 2007 3:38 PM

Sweet mother of God, this shit is STILL ON and is actually POPULAR!?!

Glad I'm not the only one to see parallels to America and Rome these days, though it is depressing to see something I had otherwise forgotten still pushing for that damn sacking. I wonder if Savannah will be watching Cali burn from her balcony when the time comes. Probably.

Posted by: Spike at October 25, 2007 3:54 PM

The girls look like Playboy models after ten years down the lane. How they can not want to be freshfaced teenagers is beyond me. I detest their friends even more.

Do Laguna Beach or the Hills or wateva they call it next. MTV should be burned down.

Posted by: Jean at October 25, 2007 4:01 PM

Well, it's not a real-time review, but I'll take it.

I'm gonna have a Super Sweet 33 party in March. Of course, it's just gonna be burgers, Miller High Life and Bushmill's Irish.

You guys wanna come?

Posted by: TK at October 25, 2007 4:07 PM

That's it, I'm not having kids.

Posted by: Dingles at October 25, 2007 4:07 PM

This show is the reason I don't watch the "Slice" channel anymore.

Awesome review, my friend.

I think I got a fish tank and a cake for my 16th birthday. My parents couldn't afford anything else.

PS - Spike: apparently California is burning, no?

Posted by: Dagny at October 25, 2007 4:12 PM

I am embarassed to live in Southern California sometimes.

Posted by: nancy at October 25, 2007 4:13 PM

I'm with you 100 percent. I'll go one step beyond that this illustrates what's wrong with teenagers and with parenting. This show perfectly encapsulates everything that is wrong with America. I wonder if any of the people featured on this show will EVER be able to look back on their participation in this farce with a little perspective and be as humiliated as they should be.

Posted by: Darth Corleone at October 25, 2007 4:19 PM

I can't help but watch Dexter every week and feel he is wasting his time and should instead rid the world of all the stupid sweet 16 bitches.

Posted by: Sarah at October 25, 2007 4:22 PM

"Spike: apparently California is burning, no?"

Ba-zing. Too soon?

Posted by: J.D. at October 25, 2007 4:23 PM

But, I can tell you that if 'lil Pajiba ever came to me and asked for a fountain and a low-rent hip hop star for his 16th birthday, I'd tell the little punchkin that the sweetest thing he's likely to get is a goddamn Carvel Ice Cream cake and a boot to the ass

Uh huh,suuuuure. When lil Pajiba turns sixteen, you'll give him everything you can (in good conscious.)

Posted by: that bees chick at October 25, 2007 4:25 PM

TK - I am SO there!!! I'll bring the Coke for the Bushmills!

Posted by: Lauren at October 25, 2007 4:34 PM

I'm not even kidding when I say this:

If I had the power to do it, I would round up all these "parents" and I would torture them, Spanish Inquisition, style for years. (no, I would not end their suffering, I would torture them for as long as their bodies held out.)

The teenagers depicted on this program are some of the most despicable creatures I've ever seen, in my line of work, I have met murderers who garner more sympathy.

WE. ARE. FUCKED, those are the elite of tomorrow A M E R I C A. Generation Douchebag.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at October 25, 2007 4:49 PM

Ugh, I got incredibly frustrated with the state of the world just from reading this review. I didn't participate in the last comment diversion, but I think I would have to make plenty of room on my list for these little pukes (parental and otherwise).

Nice REM reference, though!

Posted by: MO at October 25, 2007 4:50 PM

"My God I hope their birthday cakes are laced with birth control."

brilliant julie... brilliant.

Posted by: Mick at October 25, 2007 4:52 PM

Yea, I hate this show, and along with terrible sequels, and other such nonsense, I begin to tabulate how many college educations could be provided if money was donated, and not spent on a cake that looks like a honda civic.

Posted by: E at October 25, 2007 4:59 PM

Coke for Bushmill's? Aigh, this new generation.

Here's how to drink Bushmill's: Equal parts Bushmill's and Bailey's mixed, on the rocks. I call it the "B-2," both for obvious alliterative reasons and because it will bomb your ass back to the Stone Age. It's also good for dunking Oreos.

Care to weigh in Paddy?

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 25, 2007 5:03 PM

Erin,
They still have it in the pop machine where I work and within the last couple of years they aired some truly bizarre commercials on TV.I'll bring a case to TK's Super Sweet 33rd. :)

Posted by: brite at October 25, 2007 5:06 PM

I absolutely hate the parents on this show for not disciplining their freaking children. And the sense of entitlement from both the parents and their kids, it's sickening.

However, this show is a goddamn trainwreak that I can't help but watch if I hit it while channel surfing. It is so horrible I can't seem to close my eyes.

I read an interview with Anderson Cooper in which he said basically the same thing, that he can't help but watch the show. It made me feel better; I am not the only one with the secret shame of watching it even though I hate it.

Also, this is not just happening in Southern California, or New York, or wherever the majority of the episodes take place. Sadly, the problem is everywhere. I lived in Erie, PA for a number of years, and I couldn't believe it when I saw an episode that took place there. My brother-in-law ended up chartering the same limo and drive from the episode, because in Erie, there is only one limo rental place! It was too bad the driver couldn't actually divulge how this girl really acted, as opposed to what has to be some dialing it up for the camera.

Posted by: Amelia at October 25, 2007 5:13 PM

i hate this show,everyone they show are always spoiled whiny brats.most of the stuff on mtv now sucks anyways.im, always thankful my parents raised me not like that,whenever i flip channels and catch this crap.when i was 16 a couple years ago i did'ent care about a party at all phtt

Posted by: anna at October 25, 2007 5:20 PM

i hate this show,everyone they show are always spoiled whiny brats.most of the stuff on mtv now sucks anyways.im, always thankful my parents raised me not like that,whenever i flip channels and catch this crap.when i was 16 a couple years ago i did'ent care about a party at all phtt

Posted by: anna at October 25, 2007 5:20 PM

My 16th was spent hanging out at my house, and I was much happier than these kids sound. But, if my folks would've had the cash, I would have just bribed MTV into reinstating Daria.

Posted by: Ellipsis at October 25, 2007 5:34 PM

I haven't asked my parents for money since I got a job at sixteen. Fuck these heinous little bitches; this is why I don't care if the Democrats vote to make the rich pay higher taxes because it will maybe deprive their awful children of what they're "owed."

Posted by: Geetch at October 25, 2007 5:39 PM

Question..is that the mother or savannah in the picture??

Posted by: NDR at October 25, 2007 5:39 PM

Short version: So, yeah: I hate this show.

I do, too. My 15-year-old has already dropped hints about her 16th after watching this crap. She'll be lucky if she gets dinner at Chili's. And only if Im going anyway.

Of couse, she'll hate me for it. But she already does anyway.

Posted by: Meander at October 25, 2007 5:40 PM

I managed to sit through two episodes of this show (spaced apart by a few months) and my only joy was knowing these bitches would never know true happiness in their empty meaningless little lives.

But hey, what's with the bashing of Rome? I get that it's popular now a days but we owe a lot to that great little empire and goddamn it ... those visigoths were jealous little bitches :)

Posted by: Maria at October 25, 2007 5:43 PM

How about the southpark episode about Satan's supersweet halloween party?? at least that one was funny to watch instead of being painful and sad.. and Satan knows that he's evil.

Posted by: shel at October 25, 2007 5:45 PM

I watch this show with my mom and go, "Mom you're lucky that's not me." Then she cries and says that I am the best daughter in the world.

Posted by: Emily at October 25, 2007 5:49 PM

I watch this show with my mom and go, "Mom you're lucky that's not me." Then she cries and says that I am the best daughter in the world.

Posted by: Emily at October 25, 2007 5:50 PM

I think the issue is that Rome's excesses helped drive its decline - and yet we never learn from the past... and we're finding ourselves in a similar situation, leaping off the inevitable cliff like so many lemurs (or dodos)...

Posted by: Stella at October 25, 2007 5:55 PM

Not bashing Rome per se -- it's about the indicia of the decline of empire, e.g., the facile fascination of the citizenry with trivial, mean-spirited nonsense and the widespread acceptance of petty materialism and shameless snobbery. A healthy young culture would probably turn these idiots into the street and stone them to death.

All dominant cultures go through it; turns out we're no exception. I do find it encouraging, however, that this thread is five times the length of the Colbert book thread in half the time, which I take to mean that everyone read V's review, nodded their heads, and said, "It's excellent, just as expected. Now I'm going elsewhere to stave in the heads of the stupid."

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 25, 2007 6:03 PM

I have been a long time reader, but I don“t like to comment, cause most of you are much more articulate to say the things I usually think. But a couple of things:

1. Dustin, this has been a great review. Thank you, sir.
2. Socalledonlycousins, you make me want to skip other comments to read yours! Fantastic and Spot on as usual.

Posted by: Nat at October 25, 2007 6:43 PM

Bless you Nat; get in there and mix it up, and good on you. It's more fun when everyone comments, and it probably helps Dustin sell ad space.

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 25, 2007 7:02 PM

My sixteenth birthday was a family dinner (immediate family+grandmother and my favourite cousin) at a local midprice-restaurant, and most of my presents were of the literary variety. And the next day was a snow day. Just what I wanted, really. Nothing exravagant, and exactly the kind of thing I plan on having for my kid.

Posted by: Genevieve at October 25, 2007 7:07 PM

Whoa there.

I think the producers do a good job of making it clear that the show isn't meant to glorify the ridiculous lifestyles of these horrible teenagers and their pushover parents, but instead to mock them. I actually enjoy(ed) this show up to a point, and I think a lot the commenters here may not have actually sat through an entire episode. (Um, you don't really have to, you can just take my word for it).

If you ever have watched the show, you'd know that every effort is made to make these people look like cartoonish idiots. We never find out anything of real substance about these families' actual lives. We just know that they care immensely about stupid shit, and THEY HAVE NO IDEA THAT THEY'RE THE BUTT OF THE JOKE. Which is the best part of the show. In every single episode, some enterprising person is basically stealing hundreds of thousands of dollars from these parents to put on mediocre parties, and they're getting thanked for it!

I understand that the show runs on MTV and the irony may be lost on some of the audience, but I suspect that overall, we're underestimating the intelligence of kids these days. I guess what I'm saying is, let's not get carried away. This is simply a passable guilty pleasure of a tv show, not a sign that our country's about to replicate the fall of Rome (though I'm open to arguments that we might be doing that sooner than later).

Um, first time commenter, longtime lurker. Enjoy the work, Dustin!

Posted by: Mark at October 25, 2007 7:37 PM

I hate MTV so much now. They play the same 2 songs for about 6 weeks, in between crap like Super Sweet 16, that Hogan reality show, shitty dating shows, and other crap. What happened to the 'music' in MTV, where is Daria (hell, even Bevis and Butthead) or Tom Green? Who is watching this crap?

Posted by: Tina at October 25, 2007 7:42 PM

This seems to be a bit ironic, for I am turning 16 in two weeks. Please don't get the wrong idea about America's youth from this review (brilliant as it may be) we are all not a group of horny, materialistic, southern cal bitches. My friends and I are good people, and detest, as well as mock, the people at our school that look and act like this show. I expect nothing more then to go see bee movie in two weeks to celebrate my turning 16. There is hope for America's youth, some of us read Pajiba.

Posted by: Alex McQ at October 25, 2007 7:43 PM

Scratch that, my birthday will be spent watching this show, and mocking these people, with friends.

Posted by: Alex McQ at October 25, 2007 7:56 PM

What I'm wondering is? How come these people have all that disposable income? WHAT. THE. FUCK?
We are paying for three cars, and a mortgage, small business loan, plus two student loans and we barely have enough left for food!

Where's my check?

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at October 25, 2007 7:57 PM

Mark: You are correct; I've never sat through a whole episode. Mrs. socalled watches it occasionally to cluck and chuckle, so I've seen frequent bits and pieces. It's not that I think the creative team is selling it as unironic entertainment, and clearly there's a large audience viewing it for exactly what it is: a train-wreck.

But from the comments I take it that there's a large segment of younger viewers who see it as something to aspire to, not to mention that the legions of hangers-on surrounding the "protagonists" also don't seem to get it, or they wouldn't voluntarily come off as such moronic tools.

I don't think this show is the clock striking midnight; but I think it's symptomatic of a larger ill that's reflected in a lot of other places. It's depiction is amusing; it's existence is frightening.

We didn't doubt you were there, Alex McQ, it's just that your folk seem to be dwindling away in the twilight of the Republic. [cue melodramatic music]

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 25, 2007 8:18 PM

And one day soon, I'll learn the difference between "its" and "it's." Christ, I'm a twit.

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 25, 2007 8:21 PM

Look........
Seriously.

Bushmills is fine Irish Whiskey and should be imbibed as follows and ONLY as follows-

1.) about 3 fingers, neat. Sip slowly and enjoy...

or

2.) shot glass filled to the brim, raise carefully to lips and SLAMIT! Beer chaser optional but highly reccomended.

Posted by: mrmook at October 25, 2007 9:14 PM

mrmook, I admire your passion sir. My fine Scottish genes (7/8ths!) simply cannot tolerate straight Bushmills. The arguing starts at the tonsils, moves to bricks and clubs in the stomach, and turns to religious strife in the intestines. Bailey's is the fine priest who can keep order in the streets but can't seem to keep his hands off the lasses who dust the pews and clean the vestibule. Half the kids in town look like that guy. What were we talking about again?

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 25, 2007 9:22 PM

Dustin...please please please review "Engaged and Underage"- another one of MTV's trainwreck reality shows.

The best one is the episode where the mom and son have this weird sexual undertone, while the fiancee just looks visibly creeped out the whole time.

Posted by: Faye at October 25, 2007 10:16 PM

I have a daughter in her young teens and we don't censor much on tv (she self-censors in the case of stuff she finds embarrassing or too scary) so she was watching this, but I found it so gross and over the top and just....completely disgusting that I asked her to never watch it again.

She complied, God love her. I just couldn't handle it and even though my daughter would be INSANE to even dream of a party like that, why bother watching it anyway? It's shite. And yes, I want to beat the ever-loving SHIT out of every parent on the show.

Posted by: Kathy at October 25, 2007 10:18 PM

Mark, I have seen whole episodes, unfortunately. Where are they mocked? There's absolutely no editorial input from the producers whatsoever. It's your interpretation in which you think they are being mocked, but I think a lot of people would disagree with you.

The only good thing to come out of it is that my daughter did ask me what we did for my 16th. I told her my parents took me for a cheeseburger at Hard Rock Cafe, because since it was my 16th, I guess they felt we should do something more than what they usually did--which was nothing. I told her my boyfriend had just dumped me, I was miserable, the burger wasn't even that good, I have no idea why my parents thought I'd like Hard Rock Cafe and there was no cake and no presents.

She actually hugged me and said she was sorry.

As for people being afraid to have kids because of this stuff, don't be. Just RAISE THEM RIGHT. Say no when it's necessary to. Be consistent. Make them learn about responsibility, hard work, and what it feels like to do a good job at something. Teach them right from wrong and de-emphasize the material stuff.

They'll be fine. You're their biggest influence from birth to the beginning of the teen years and that's a HUGE headstart on crap like this show. There's no way my kid would ever think how these kids act is ok. In fact, I think at one point, I heard her say (in response to a girl on the show) "oh THAT'S a paddlin!" ROFL.

Posted by: Kathy at October 25, 2007 10:28 PM

I'm sad to know that there are girls (& boys) out there who must watch this, without the world wisdom of those commenting here, and look to it as some sort of marker of acceptable or desirable behavior. These rich, narcissistic nitwits learn their ways from their rich, narcissistic fuckwit parents- and since they apparently have more money to pay for these parties than I will make in several years, well we're fucked. I was of a generation heavily influenced by MTV (well mostly due to the fact that I would watch it when my Mother thought I was doing my homework). It was stupid and pointless back then, just with more music videos and a little more social conscience. I have read that MTV is really suffering from low ratings and viewership (same thing?) It is as if they will use any means necessary to grab people's attention, screwing up a lot of young kids in the process.

Posted by: AllGussiedUp at October 25, 2007 11:24 PM

One more reason to kill your television. If I have anything to say about it, my children will never view this vomitrocious tripe. (Also, nice tagline! It's the end of the world as we know it, indeed.)

Posted by: zh at October 25, 2007 11:29 PM

They probably just thought that Odaecer was a jealous little bitch.

Hahahahahhaa
Most meaningful explanation of the Classical World I have heard in a lonnng time.

Shows like this make me so proud of my parents.

Posted by: Lizzie Bennett at October 26, 2007 1:13 AM

Story time!

I actually attended the very first My Super Sweet 16 party filmed by MTV. There were two girls - Jacqueline and Lauren - and I can honestly say that they were two of the nicest, most genuine girls at my high school. They actually used their event to raise money for cancer research, which is something that MTV didn't bother to mention in the episode. So while I agree that many of the people featured are undoubtedly vapid and spoiled and beyond help, I watch this show with the understanding that 20 minutes of screen time can't show you everything about a person.

Posted by: Tammy at October 26, 2007 1:36 AM

I am ashamed to say I've seen this show more than once (but not in a very long time) and it is just as revolting as it ever was. God bless you parents who are raising you're kids right and not like what MTV passes off as typical teenagers and to you, Alex McQ, for proving that the majority of American teens are not whiny, materalistic, brats who think they are entitled to everything and anything.
Lord, I do miss "Daria". There was a show for the truly bitchy among us. RIP Daria.

Posted by: jen310 at October 26, 2007 1:45 AM

Amen, MrMook!

Frank, the bartender/manager at my favorite Irish Pub told me years ago, and I quote, "I'd be president if it wasn't for this stuff" as he poured me a shot of Bushmills. I went with option 2 in this case, chased with a pint of Harp.

Memories.

Don't get me started on the Irish Car Bombs.

Regarding the show, I had no desire to watch it before now. Could be good for a laugh. Probably funnier with the Bushmills option B first. Maybe twice! With the chaser, of course.

I bet the brilliant Pajiba readers and staff could come up with a "My Super Sweet 16 drinking game." Could be a good "diversion" topic.

Posted by: Bill M at October 26, 2007 2:07 AM

However, this show is a goddamn trainwreak that I can't help but watch if I hit it while channel surfing. It is so horrible I can't seem to close my eyes.

I'm in exactly the same position, Amelia - every single time I come across this show, you can guarantee that about fifteen minutes later, one of my housemates will be drawn into the living room by my livid ranting and forced into wiping the spittle flying from my lips from off of the screen.

As for people being afraid to have kids because of this stuff, don't be. Just RAISE THEM RIGHT. Say no when it's necessary to. Be consistent. Make them learn about responsibility, hard work, and what it feels like to do a good job at something. Teach them right from wrong and de-emphasize the material stuff.

Slow clap from me for that comment, Kathy - it's sad to me that such advice needs to be given, and isn't nearly as intrinsic as it clearly should be.

Posted by: Dill The Devil at October 26, 2007 4:08 AM

Yeah...this is exactly why I refuse to give birth to hell spawn. I'd probably bitch slap them if they had the stones to act like this. I loved the South Park parody of it but then I've always had a large amount of affection for Matt and Trey no matter how many poop jokes they use.

Note...According to my Nan only dirty orange Protestant bastards destined for a firey hell drink Bushmills. Real Irish drink Jamiesons.

Posted by: Ms. Parker at October 26, 2007 7:30 AM

My Lord how I LOVE this review. Seriously, I was ill for a couple of weeks last summer and stayed at my parents house - I spent two days watching a marathon of this and ANTM. I could actually hear the fizzling sound of my brain cells slowly dying. I tried explaining it to my Mother, she didn't believe how absolutely awful these people were until she watched the show (under duress) it actually literally made her weep. And then I got the whole "I'm so glad you're my daughter I forgive you anything for not demanding a pink princess dress and trying to push your very own catchphrase into common usage and oh God this program has made me fear for humanity, quick get me some gin" speech. Good times.

But I do actually have a seriousl question: Where the fuck did this concept of a "grand entrance" come from? Why? Why would it even occur to someone that they need one unless they've been watching the show? Who came up with it first?

Posted by: Alex the Odd at October 26, 2007 8:16 AM

My God, I didn't even DREAM of having a party like that. Or even acting like that. I mean, I admit it, I'm 16, I'm a bitch, I can act spoiled sometimes (not my greatest moments)...but...JESUS ICE SKATING CHRIST. I look like the sweetest child on Earth compared to these kids.

Why don't the parents say no? Hey guys, you're supposed to be their PARENTS, not their buddies. Just a few minutes ago I read an article about a woman who let her daughter eat and eat because she just wanted her to be quiet.

I've only seen this show once, when I was flicking through the channels. My jaw just dropped. This boy, standing in the middle of a basketball court with a crowd of teens waiting around him eagerly, whipped out a microphone and said- "I will now call out the names of all the kids who are invited to my party." I think he told them to form a line or something, I can't remember, I just remember sitting there going, why would you do that? Why not walk off and go, gosh, he's a douche...?


And it shits me to no ends when people use internet speak in real life- lol, rofl, wtf

No, you're not "rofl"ing. You're standing up. You haven't "lmao"ed, because as far as I can tell, your arse cheeks are still attached. JUST LAUGH


P.S. RIP Daria

Posted by: Chantelle at October 26, 2007 8:42 AM

I have seen this show a few times. Most of the time I'm catches flies because I am so amazed by the idiocy. But I agree with Mark in that there is a slight mocking undercurrent. I think it's the way that they edit.
The few episodes that I have seen have the worst sort of parent. You can see where the kid gets it from in the episode that Dustin reviewed. The mother is like that ergo, the kid will be too. The worst ones for me are the parents that have such low self esteem that they do whatever their kid wants to insure their love. They look at the camera and say things like "Well, it's expensive but I want the best for her and even though I will be in debt for 45 years I will give it to her." And in the meantime the daughter is shouting at her in the background and throwing shoes at the mother to ask for more! That is just sad. I think that the best thing my mom did for me when I was 16 was make me get a job and pay for my car on my own. It taught me to be independent. And I thank her for it. Of course she didn't do that with my sister and she regrets that...
Good review Dustin!

Posted by: lyricalcatt at October 26, 2007 8:57 AM

....so that's a 'no' on reviewing the movie?

Posted by: The Stew at October 26, 2007 9:58 AM

Oh & I just wanted to say that a lot of the time the party crashers are staged, the producers just tell the kids to do it for the camera.

Posted by: The Stew at October 26, 2007 10:02 AM

"Her mother, of course, cannot -- clearly, she hasn't said "no" to anyone since giant-donged men hoovered coke lines off her back during her Boogie Night days."

My screen is now full of coffee and thanks a lot :)~ That's hilarious! That show represents everything wrong with the US..

Posted by: ebbinflo at October 26, 2007 10:03 AM

I wouldn't know Chantelle if we passed each other on the street, but I like her. A lot. My terror over the next generation of Americans has subsided. A little.

Posted by: Jerce at October 26, 2007 10:12 AM

Ms. Paker,

Keeping the whole Orange/Green debate out of this, (send the British home) and with all due respect to your Nan, sometimes I buy swill beer, usually I buy the good stuff. Depends on the day. Same goes for your Irish Wiskey.

Bushmills goes down like the fires of Hades, but that's the point sometimes, ain't it?!

Back to the show. So, after reading all of these comments I think it's time to set the trusty and well used DVR to catch an episode of the show. Have you ever looked through the program guide for M(and I use the "M" lightly) TV? Ten episodes of "...Top Model" followed by eight episodes of something about some Tila Tequila or something, then another block of "Next" followed by something... followed by anohter block of something else. Everday was a marathon of some swill.

And no sign of Sweet 16. Maybe I should have checked MTV2. Maybe I don't care enough.

Anyway, it's Friday morning, I took the day off so I can stimulae the economy by spening my paycheck while it's still warm. I see a bottle of whiskey in my future as well.

Posted by: Bill Mc at October 26, 2007 10:19 AM

My eleven-year-old was watching this with me, and she thought the girls were brats.

But then she modified it a bit and said she was hoping she could get an inexpensive, reliable small car for her 16th. I told her I could do better than that, and her eyes lit up, until I explained that I meant on her 16th birthday, she would become the proud owner of a seven-year-old minivan.

Now she reminds me to take good care of her Future Ride.

Posted by: Wednesday at October 26, 2007 10:26 AM

MMM...Jameson's....MMM

Sorry, where was I? Right. This show is such a pit of suck. This, however, was one of the best reviews that I have read in a while. Thanks for suffering for this, Dustin!

I just MTV would either die or bring back Daria or Beavis and Butthead or frickin' music! Scratch that, MTV just needs to die. Post Haste.

If I ever do have small people in my house and they were to act like those bitches on that show, so help me, their ass would be working a horrendous retail job and suffering through the holiday shopping season.

Posted by: Melody at October 26, 2007 10:30 AM

I can't seem to let this review out of my head... From the MTV Website:

My Super Sweet 16 takes you on a wild ride behind the scenes for all the drama, surprises and over-the-top fun as teens prepare for their most important coming-of-age celebrations. Meet the kids who are determined to go all out to mark this major turning point in their lives, the parents who lavish every wish, and find out first hand what it's really like to turn 16 these days.

Whether a Sweet 16, Quinceaneara or Coming Out, each week My Super Sweet 16 will document one character's outrageous journey as they plot, plan and prep for the party to end all parties. These kids expect and will only accept the absolute best. Now, it's up to them to make sure jealous siblings, stressed out parents and school rivals don't get in the way. This series gives you an up close and very personal look at the extravagant and sometimes extreme measures teens take to ensure that this milestone in their lives is commemorated by the ultimate celebration. Will their real life Sweet 16 ever live up to their fantasies?

Blow out 16 candles and step in to a world that isn't always as sweet as it seems.

To. Turn. 16. These. Days! They said These Fucking Days!

Call me naĆÆve, I don't think this is a typical sweet 16.

As a result, I'm listening to REM's "These Days" from Life's Rich Pagent. God bless the iTunes' instant-ness for when a lyric is in your head!

We are young despite the years,
we are concern,
we are hope despite the times
.

Despite the times, indeed.

I'm going to try and let this go for now and find some breakfast.

Oh, and if I didn't say earlier: Awesome review, Dustin.

Posted by: Bill Mc at October 26, 2007 10:44 AM

Irony is funny stuff. After my comment posted I saw the name of the review, and it dawned on me it as an REM reference. Didn't even notice that the first time.

Posted by: Bill Mc at October 26, 2007 10:47 AM

Bill Mc - Never fear disrespecting the Nan. She was a vicious Orange hating, drunken old lady who spent 3 masses a day on her knees praying for the salvation of the family after my Gran married a Brit. In our family she's pretty much comic relief. I've only drank Bushmills once though and wasn't overly impressed...so as far as whiskey goes I inherited that prejudice. As for swill beer...you're braver than I.

Posted by: Ms. Parker at October 26, 2007 10:48 AM

And the reference was "It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine."

Very inronic.

Posted by: Bill Mc at October 26, 2007 10:49 AM

this show makes me irrationally angry. i want to stab things when i watch it. and yet, i can't look away. i have a distinct memory of one girl who actually said, "I have to show everyone how rich I am." I wanted to pat her on the head and explain in short words that she does not have money, mommy and daddy have money.

I've also sworn, many a time when stuck in this trainwreck, that even if by some miracle I become that rich, my children will not get parties like that for their 16th. they will get a job, and if they're lucky they will get USE of a used car. because chances are they're going to wreck it anyway. my children will be raised to be decent human beings if it kills them.

Posted by: liz at October 26, 2007 10:53 AM

Ms. Parker,

This is not a cute message board short cut. LOL. I am literally laughing out loud so hard I can barely type.

As far as the beer swill, Miller High Life is my swill. So, not as bad as the swill some folks drink. And that's only the weeks I "stimulated the economy" too much elsewhere.

I still can't stop laughing. Damn that's funny. "Drunken old lady...three masses a day...salvation...a Brit."

I'll never argue Jamison is the better whiskey, but Bushmills has a place. Sometimes you want to feel your booze.

Usually after the first few pints it's a good idea. If we've had several, we'll spend the extra buck and get the Bushmills Black, instead of the Jamison, which makes no sense sober. But, what are you going to do?

Still laughing out loud.

Posted by: Bill Mc at October 26, 2007 10:57 AM

Socalled: Sorry to be late to the party: had to step away from the computer last night. Let's make one thing quite clear: My Super Sweet Sixteen
makes me so angry I would drink rubbing alcohol to take away the pain.

Now to the question of the day: are we talking about regular Bushmills, Black Bush (i.e., Bushmills Black Label) or the single malt 12-years aged?

The 12-year single malt is definitely a non-mixer to be drunk neat or with two cubes of ice if needed. The others need a small dropeen of water to cut them a little. Of course, there was no Bushmills in my house growing up, it being the Protestant distillery and not to be supported under any circumstances. We were strictly a Jamesons family (thank you Melody), but in these happy peace process days, now that we're all friends supposedly, I have come to appreciate the beauty of the odd glass of Bushmills.

By the way, the absolute worst aspect of MSSS is that it has spawned an epidemic of wannabe parties here in my neighbourhood. God knows what debt these parents go into to try to replicate what their daughters see on TV, but what the fuck, they deserve bankruptcy (I say bring back Debtors Prison) for succumbing to that evil.

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 26, 2007 10:59 AM

you tube is full of videos of spoiled whores not getting the right car for there super sweet 16. I weep for the world.

Posted by: 13thDuke at October 26, 2007 11:06 AM

I must say that all this talk of Irish whiskey is very useful for me as my knowledge at the moment really only extends to Scotch. In a couple of weeks time I'll be adopting the Irish heritage (I have a very unique take on nationality - go with it) due to a change in surname and information like this is priceless when it comes to passing myself off as a full blooded member of the clan.

Keep it coming kids!

Posted by: Alex the Odd at October 26, 2007 11:08 AM

Ms. Parker: Upon refreshing I see that you beat me to it on the Bushmills vs. Jameson debate. Your Nan sounds like a great old biddy. My granny refused to believe that the Nazis had put Jews into death camps. She said it had to be the English who did it and made it look like the Germans because only the English were cruel enough to think up something like a gas chamber.

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 26, 2007 11:09 AM

Alex The Odd: I'm dizzy with excitement at the thought of you joining our ranks. Failte! The good news is that your sense of sarcasm and literary abilities already place you squarely in the Celtic camp so it won't be a tough transition. Just remember to answer every question with another question and you're home safe. However, give up on any ideas of your adopted national football team ever winning anything and prepare to join the sorry ranks of the eternally disappointed. But my curiosity gets the better of me: change of surname? Last time I looked there was no current Mr. The Odd. Have things changed dramatically or are you changing to an Irish name just for the craic?

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 26, 2007 11:16 AM

With all this talk of Jameson and Bushmills, I have to chime in with a question of what about Tullamore Dew. Anyone else a fan?

Posted by: mikki at October 26, 2007 11:21 AM

The Irish in my family is way way back, but I do love a good whiskey every so often. I have never been able to tolerate Guinness or Harp though. Jameson's is certainly my favorite whiskey, but alas, I am poor and forced to cheaper liquor more often than not. Damn you grad school. My cheaper alternative is usually the Crown. Not nearly as good, but nice with a splash of coke for color.

Loving the Bushmills vs. Jameson's debate.

Posted by: Melody at October 26, 2007 11:26 AM

Never fear, I haven't decided to elope after a whirlwind romance with a ruggedly handsome and tortured Irish poet... my luck just isn't that good. Alas, I am still Mr. TheOdd-less. I'm ditching the current surname in favour of taking up my step-dad's name as it's a) the name my Mum now uses, b) much cooler than any other logical option and c) sounds fantastic with Alexandra.

Point about constant disappointment absolutely noted, I have no sporting aspirations whatsoever anyway so that shouldn't be a problem. I also look forwards to being justified in my being a very variable drunk, having melancholy days for no apparent reason and my persistant hatred of the sunshine. I think you're right PaddyDog, looks like I'll transition over just fine!

Posted by: Alex the Odd at October 26, 2007 11:38 AM

Two Points:

1. Bushmill's gives me irritated taste buds. I learned to drink it with a single ice cube.

2. Thirteen years ago, my parents bought me a 1991 Pontiac Grand Am with a HOLE IN IT. Seriously. A hole. I asked for a party, and they said, "Your party's sitting the driveway." I was still considered to be probably the most obnoxiously spoiled girl in my high school. I have seen this show many, many times, and live in a suburb outside of Houston where half the residents are wealthy and half are merely pretending. When I worked in retail (while simultaneously working as an attorney) to pay off my debt, a ten year old girl handed my a Platinum Amex to buy a $20 lip gloss. She stormed off when I told her I needed to call her parents to make sure it was okay. [When I was ten I threw a snit when I couldn't have another cupcake.] The school parking lot looks like an import car dealership. 14 year old girls have Louis Vuitton and have Chanel sunglasses, while their mothers carry Coach, and settle for Steve Madden. My twelve year old niece gets her nails done and has a Motorola RAZR. THIS IS REAL PEOPLE! Be afraid.

Posted by: Kitty X at October 26, 2007 12:12 PM

Ah, Irish whiskey (a redundancy; all else is a lesser brew). Although I hail from a southwestern town so small that it is populated only by my family and the cows, I "married" (only allowed in Mass without the quotes) an Irishman almost thirty years ago. (Yeah, I am the oldest living--still semi-mobile--Pajib[i]an.)

It was Kismet: he's Kelly and Burke on both sides and there are only six family names in my lineage for the last four hundred years (amazing that we do not resemble Goya's portrait of the Spanish royal family). *Pauses to take another wee sip* Now where was/am I?

Oh yes, after thirty years, I am "Irish by aggravation," a designation we "non-blooded" relations have all adopted. The best parts of associating with the Celtic Clan are the baptisms, weddings, and funerals, nothing like a green and brown celebration of the cycle of life. All enhanced by "God's gift of dew".

Which, at last, brings me to my comment on Sweet 16: Screw 'em. Better yet, save your energy for something more deserving. They are all already fucking up their own lives and do not really affect mine.

Posted by: rudy at October 26, 2007 12:14 PM

REM's "These Days" from Life's Rich Pagent

Bill Mc: Begin the Begin, baby. Begin the Begin.

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 26, 2007 12:18 PM

are we talking about regular Bushmills, Black Bush (i.e., Bushmills Black Label) or the single malt 12-years aged?

Paddy: I had no idea Bushmills was Protestant-owned! It says Irish Whiskey right on the label -- you! bastards! I know Protestants are allowed to live in Ireland, but I didn't know they were permitted to make hooch.

But obviously I would never mix single malt with anything other than a wee bit o' water from a leprechaun's spring. I'm talking about the regular Bushmills they sell in convenience stores here in the States. As much as I love it, that stuff burns me like Linda Blair in The Exorcist on the way down.

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 26, 2007 12:26 PM

Bill Mc - Glad to know I've still got that razor sharp sense of humour going. I'd been strangely nice to people all week and I feared it was affected. You couldn't pay me to drink any sort of Miller or any American beer-if I'm broke it's Steamwhistle all the way...maybe Keith's if I'm desperate. Black Label Bushmills is actually not bad I have to admit.

PaddyDog - Nan was a real winner with a shrine to the Pope and Paddy Pearce and Bobby Sands. She also refused to speak English around my Grandfather referring to him as 'that man'. This is possibly why the only Irish language we know is swearing. I could easily see her making the same claims since she used to tell us that the Brits engineered the famine.

Welcome to the tribe Alex the Odd

Posted by: Ms. Parker at October 26, 2007 12:27 PM

"Your party's sitting the driveway."

Priceless, Kitty X!

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 26, 2007 12:30 PM

Alex the Odd...it's not a dislike of sunlight so much as an evolutionary based allergy.

Posted by: Ms. Paker at October 26, 2007 12:33 PM

I just home from Iraq and this show reminds me what I was fighting for. God Bless America!

Posted by: HawaiiMarine at October 26, 2007 12:45 PM

ooh! ooh! do super sweet 16 next! please!

Posted by: caro at October 26, 2007 12:54 PM

wait. that's this one. they all run together. do the one where they get married at a retardedly young age. sorry.

Posted by: caro at October 26, 2007 12:56 PM

I think it's "extravagances", not extravagancies...yeah...this comment box just underlined it actually...

Posted by: ph at October 26, 2007 1:35 PM

Alex, I understand the aversion to sunlight. It seems to be one of the few things I got from the Irish part of my heritage. I am paler than a natural redhead friend of mine. It is a sad thing, but I still enjoy it. I get to wear the same shade of powder year round.

Posted by: Melody at October 26, 2007 1:45 PM

I saw this show on our local MTV station and was amazed at the kind of lives American teens lead. I wondered whether it was just a cultural thing, this celebration of vapidity. Seriously, how common is this kind of stuff in the States? The worst part is that the kids here (I'm from Mumbai), think being Americanised is really cool. Unfortunately, they take their cue from MTVs and the OC and such other things. This stuff just scares me.

Posted by: Lilac at October 26, 2007 1:53 PM

Alex: Do yourself a favour and stay as far away as possible from the ruggedly handsome tortured Irish poets. My past is littered with them and they like to share in the tortured soul department. You deserve better.

Socalled: Nothing wrong with Protestants per se, some of the finest Irish patriots kicked with the other foot (as Granny would say): Wolfetone, Robert Emmett, etc. But yeah, Bushmills was blackballed for years because of the position they took on what the Brits euphemistically refer to as "The Irish Question". Not sure why they thought there was a question that needed to be answered. They invaded. They caused all the problems. They need to leave. (And, no it doesn't make me a terrorist for feeling that way)

Ms. Parker: I think we shared the same granny. Mine never referred to my grandfather as anything other than "that man" and never failed to share her dislike for him or the fact that her parents forced her to marry him.

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 26, 2007 2:13 PM

I turned sixteen at boarding school. My present was that my parents drove up to see me and my friends walked into town to get me--I kid you not--a Carvel cake.

My generation is so much better than little demon-shits like Savannah. I promise.

Posted by: Manda at October 26, 2007 2:24 PM

Seriously, how common is this kind of stuff in the States?

Lilac, probably not very common as a percentage of the populace -- it's largely limited to the ugly nouveau riche; old money generally tries to stay out of the limelight -- but alas, it's commonly aspired-to among idiots and low morons. Like most "reality" television, it's on largely because it's sensational and bizarre. That doesn't keep it from shaping behavior, however, here or other places.

PaddyDog: Call me an Orange, call me an Orange! Not by belief any more, but at least by heritage. Say, "Don't mix Bailey's with single malt, you tuilli Orange!"

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 26, 2007 2:31 PM

The venue, appropriately, seems to be some wildlife preserve nestled comfortably in Laguna Beach. Oh, and guess what: There's gonna be an oxygen bar at her party. That's right -- her parents are going to pay thousands of dollars for air!

Hey, I live in Orange County and I could use some oxygenated air right now.

Posted by: schadenfreude at October 26, 2007 2:34 PM

Never has a review sooo made me want to watch something......

anyway, ye can tell yer all Plastic Paddies cause no-one mentioned drinking red with your whiskey (note that real irish whiskey is spelt with an "e").

Usually a Crested 10 & a slash of water for my dad, but Jameson's or Paddy with a drop of red occasionally. Paddy for me in my irish coffee. And that's a skill in itself that I've been known to share with barman outside the borders of home.

Now you can all ask what red is....

Posted by: Donal at October 26, 2007 2:54 PM

Wow, for awhile there, I became the guy who was dumb enough to defend this show. Please remind me to never ever do that again. I guess I've never watched the show through the eyes of a parent with impressionable teenaged children. God, that sounds like no fun at all.

I find the comment from Tammy, who actually attended the first MSS16 taping, to be very interesting. It sounds like perhaps the original concept for the show had some redeeming quality to it, before it was allowed to spiral into the crapfest that it is today. A bit like how the original Real World at least made an effort to portray itself as a social experiement. Now of course, it's an excuse to watch a group of desperate fame whores get drunk and have sex with one another.

To me, this point is intriguing because it suggests that audience demand is what's shaping these shows into what they actually are, and MTV irresponsibly complying. As opposed to MTV proactively leading the way in our gradual social decline. Which is even scarier than the conclusion that Dustin came to in the intial review.

Posted by: Mark at October 26, 2007 3:03 PM

Donal: I specifically left out the concept of "red lemonade" because having to explain it would just take too long. And because it opens the debate of TK or Nash's and then it'll just get ugly. For record, I'm a TK woman myself.

Posted by: PaddyDog at October 26, 2007 3:12 PM

I think comparing spoiled teenage snots to the fall of the Roman Empire is giving said girls too much credit. :)

Posted by: Matt 2.0 at October 26, 2007 3:18 PM

Matt 2.0: Oh come on, everyone knows that spoiled, rich Roman girls brought down Rome by taking up all the good seats at the Coliseum and distracting their patriarchs from the business of the Senate! And those studly barbarians weren't marching south for the olive oil.

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 26, 2007 3:44 PM

This show makes me so irrationally angry (I wanted to hunt down the debutard in the West Palm Beach episode just so I could slap her and walk away).
There is some truth to the previous comment that the kid, her parents and friends are the butt of one big joke. There was an episode with a girl from Gulfview, Florida. She went around handing out invitations, buying dresses, etc. BY HERSELF. Seriously, who plans their own blowout party by themselves? The show made it clear that she had no friends to speak of.
Then came the big moment at her party: Dancing Britney-style in front of everyone in a sparkly outfit (she's one of those "dancing cheerleaders", and thinks she's a fabulous choreographer). Her pants fell down during her dance, nobody told her, MTV kept filming, and everyone laughed and laughed. The birthday girl, of course, had a breakdown and cried that everything was ruined.
There are too many jaw-dropping moments in that show: The bitchette who screamed at her mother because she was presented with a BMW...at the wrong time! You ruined everything, Mom!
Then there was the skank whose reaction to a new Porche was perfect: "Uh, like, I already have one of those."
Kill them all slowly and painfully, with a spoon.

Posted by: wavemaven at October 26, 2007 4:11 PM

"Why a spoon, cousin? Why not an axe?"

"Because it's dull, you twit, it'll hurt more!"

Posted by: Guy of Gisborne at October 26, 2007 4:15 PM

dammit. I wanted so badly to be the first to make an Upton Sinclair joke, but I'm terribly late and clearly, underqualified. Katy's joke yesterday beats mine :(

Posted by: alex at October 26, 2007 4:27 PM

I shall turn sixteen in a few months. Reading this review, one thought stood above all the others:

THANK YOU MERCIFUL GOD, GENETICS, AND ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS THAT I HAVE ASPERGER'S SYNDROME, AND ARE THUS VIRTUALLY IMMUNE TO THIS CULTURE!

My idea of a perfect sixteenth birthday involves books, solitude, and my scale model of the Bastille.

Autism has its upsides, friends.

Posted by: Fortress D at October 26, 2007 4:46 PM

Extremely well written!, My thoughts exactly. Every time I watch this show, I want to go out and kill an endangered species. Is that bad?

Posted by: jaime at October 26, 2007 4:48 PM

Longtime lurker de-lurking for a bit. First to be thankful that I don't have cable TV (so I'm not paying for this crap). And that someone else actually sat through this and lived to write a review of it.



And finally, wondering if myself and my family lived (and continue to live) in a different OC than these kids. For _my_ 16th birthday, I got a car--no party. The car had been my mom's. It was a "Mafia car" (big enough to stash a couple of bodies in the trunk). And the only reason I got the car at all was so I could chauffeur for my younger siblings and grandma.

Posted by: True_Blue at October 26, 2007 5:01 PM

Thank you for making my otherwise dull and monotonous working day better. I had to run to the back and laugh out loud before someone gave me the evil eye for laughing so hard.

Posted by: carrie at October 26, 2007 5:06 PM

I will watch this crap while enjoying a high ball of Wild Turkey and Coke. I'll save the Glenlivet Nadura (with two cubes of ice) for something more refined. Dog the Bounty Hunter, for example.

These Sweet Sixteen silicone-filled skanks are more annoying than an itchy taint.

Posted by: JP at October 26, 2007 6:20 PM

Ms. Paddy, beleive me, Miller is only when I'm hurting, and hurting is an understatemnt for the last six weeks for me. Pouring a cheap beer into a glass helps a ton. Fortunately things are back to normal. Sipping a Stella Artois, and a Dewar's 12 year old scotch. Didn't feel worthy to drink the scotch when all I had was High Life in the house. If only I wasn't out of cigars...

There are plenty of good American beers out there, but I won't even start that off topic conversation.

Socalled... Life's Rich Pagent. My favorite REM album of all. Every song.. Just a Touch!

Back to the topic...

My 16th birthday. I wanted a car, knew my folks couldn't do that. Instead, I asked for car keys. And that's what I got, a set of keys to my Mom's 1983 Oldsmobile Delta 88. Drove the hell out of that car. Never so willing to run errands. Sometimes, due to the excitement of getting to drive, I'd "forget" something, and have to go back to the store...

The keys were attached to a nice padlock shaped key chain with that birthday and maybe my name engraved. Unfortunately the key chain had a tendency to fall apart, and was eventually lost. But, I thought it was a great gift and was thrilled with it.

My folks did eventually help me get a used, bare bones, basic, stipped down, sub-compact. I couldn't of been happier with any other car.

Posted by: BillMc at October 26, 2007 9:28 PM

more annoying than an itchy taint

JP, you bad, bad girl.

Bill Mc: 20 years later, "I Am Superman" is my bring-fatty-home song for the end of my morning run.

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 26, 2007 10:47 PM

"I am Superman" is in my iPod "workout #1" playlist. Never gets old. Ever.

Posted by: Bill Mc at October 27, 2007 1:05 AM

The down fall of the American Empire because of whiny orange bitches, comparisons to the Romans, and of course, a whiskey discussion. God Bless Pajiba. I can't even pick my favorite comment, there all too funny, I truly love all of you. And if the comment that stated that the first show raised money for cancer, and they were actually good people, is true. There is some executive at MTV who takes something interesting and good, and just completely fucks is up beyond ALL recognition. (At the high school where I go to, there are people with Louis Vettion bags, one kid actually drives a brand new Lotus.) *weeps*

Posted by: Alex McQ at October 27, 2007 1:17 AM

These kids are a prime example of why I still feel we should have a universal draft. When they turn 18, send their asses off to the Army, where they can spend some time with lower middle-class kids from Detroit, The Bronx, Mississippi, and (heaven forbid) the less privileged areas of L.A., and see how long it takes until they get an attitude adjustment.

There should be the death penalty for this kind of shit.

Posted by: rob at October 27, 2007 1:27 AM

Socalled -- absent some occasional role playing with my wife, I am not typically called a "bad, bad girl", seeing as I have a penis and all. But thanks for the kind words. Does this mean I write like a girl?

Posted by: JP at October 27, 2007 3:41 AM

The Israelis have got it right. Mandatory military service for every child of the nation. Learn to appreciate the things you have; it's not a right - it's a privilege.
The episode of this show that made my stomach turn was when this snotty spoiled tart received her car in that climactic ending, only to pout because Daddy didn't buy her a convertible like she wanted. But oh wait, just then a SECOND car pulled up, and of course it was a convertible. Bitch got TWO cars for her fucking SIXTEENTH birthday!?!?!? My parents haven't bought me a vehicle in my entire 25 years. I'm happy just to get a plane ticket once a year to fly home and see them.
I would like to take every single child AND their parents who've ever been on this show and burn them at the stake like Salem.

Posted by: RichieRich at October 27, 2007 4:03 AM

Spot on review Dustin, but like a few others here I can't help but watch it and laugh at them all. My 16th B'day was spent taking my drivers licence and once passing the test going for my first drive in 'Fred' the faded red Datsun 1200 that my dad owned in the shopping centre car park! Then it was bbq, cake and pool party with friends.

Posted by: Noo at October 27, 2007 5:58 AM

The show is on right now. Looks like a sweet 16 for twin spoiled bitches, SBs, for now. One of their little purse dogs just shit in the recording studio. The reason they are in a recording studio, it seems the SBs have their own producers, must be the latest teen star on the road to self destruction. She is absolutely freaking out about the dog, and yelling at her Mom about how much work she has to do and can't watch this dog because it's like having a kid an she's getting a drivers licence and she spoke in the same run on style I'm writing with. Now that's comedy, except it wasn't supposed to be.

Aly and Aj it seems are the SBs. The one that looks more like Mary-Kate just past her drivers licence test and can't wait to drive her "pretty BMW" by herself.

Now she just said, in this case refering to her ugly dog, "Look are everything." She got a coloring, the dog that is, and the SB now "loves her more." Not sure if this dog is the shitter or not.

Anyway, the other one is about to take her test, and I already don't care...not that I ever did.

I'll see if I'm tough enough to watch the entire episode. I'm waiting for the super bitchy spoiled brat spoiling and angy outburst and other stuff mentioned above. One alread has a BMW. With twins, it could be twice as good/bad.

Can't resist, one more comment. Mom is really proud of them, they have great character and are great people. I bet we see that conflicted

Posted by: Bill Mc at October 27, 2007 10:26 AM

Kind of disappointing. No major meltdowns, no major tirades. The other one got a Mercedes.

It would be so easy to make this a great show. Let MTV foot the bill, throw a lavish party for some poor or middle class kids. The big ending could be something the entire family needs.

The Michael Jackson Off the Wall b-day is on now. I'm starting to feel ill.

Posted by: Bill Mc at October 27, 2007 10:43 AM

"as if historians spend their spare moments documenting gaudiness and excess"

Um, Rome? Orgies? Nero? France? Marie Antoniette? Biopics? Spain? And now you?

But this is a good contribution to recording history in the making. Scary that with TV and internet writers, we're doing a better job of recording THIS part of history.

Posted by: JS at October 27, 2007 10:47 AM

Socalled -- absent some occasional role playing with my wife, I am not typically called a "bad, bad girl", seeing as I have a penis and all. But thanks for the kind words. Does this mean I write like a girl?

JP: D'oh! Not sure why I thought that -- it was something about the whole Richard Dawkins/TMQ incident (that was you, wasn't it?), after which I've been trying to get back in your good graces for being a bit of a dick. I pander much better to women, so maybe it was subconscious.

Thank goodness you didn't see my invitation to you for the "Women of Pajiba" pictorial.

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 27, 2007 11:14 AM

Socalled- No invitation to be in the Women of Pajiba Pictorial?!? Great. Here I've been practicing my dick tuck-and-stuck move for nothing. And I've been watching the same scene from Clerks 2 over and over to get it right.

Yah, that was me in the Godless vs. Blessed debate ;) No worries. Its all good, clean fun.

Posted by: JP at October 27, 2007 2:14 PM

thanks for sitting through this show and the belly laughs ... i could not. the only episode i saw was about some daisy mae-ish freakazoid in hattiesburg, mizz'ippi who wanted a $200K horse from daddy for her b'day.

i remember thinking that it would be pretty cool to write a swiftian satire for our times about materialistic bratty teenagers being ground into mulch and spread over reforestation areas.

Posted by: mypantswererightthere at October 27, 2007 3:59 PM

Now, I would never defend this show because I hate it but I was talking about this with my girlfriend, and she had a semi-interesting insight. She works in this nice, upscale salon in town and apparently there was a girl in there getting her hair done while filming for this show. They cut the cameras at one point and someone was kinda prodding her because they said she was being "too nice."

I'm sure she was just as vapid and undeserving and self-centered as anyone that would even WANT to be on this show, but it's still t.v. so that just fuels the fire.

Posted by: stephen at October 27, 2007 5:37 PM

I've seen this show and everytime some whiney brat with a name like Savannah starts going on about how she really, really, REALLY needs that black Benz and not the brown Beemer, I can only think:

if maybe her parents were interested in [b]parenting[/b] instead of being their buddies/rivals/sugar-daddies, these kids wouldn't grow up with an overdeveloped sense of entitlement.

Posted by: Fredo at October 27, 2007 7:18 PM

This show literally makes me sick. It's just proof that people forgot how to be parents. You know what, you're not your kid's friend, you're their parent. You're supposed to raise them to be functional in society and hopefully contribute to it. I can only hope these girls get their come-uppance at some point, or at least a hearty slap in the face.

Posted by: Chesnut at October 27, 2007 7:43 PM

"So, yeah: I hate this show." -- like that's so hard to understand or to accept. To me, that statement alone makes you a halfway decent human being. I fear the day i will actually meet fans of this crap or - god forbid - have to exchange words with them.

Posted by: Arthur Dent at October 27, 2007 9:30 PM

Oh, Jerce, you're making me blush


But I'm not American

I'm Australian

Now I should go wrestle some crocs, ey?

While I keep up with the election watch...le sigh. K Dudd vs. J Ho

Oh, I just had a bad thought. The kids on Super Sweet 16, they can vote in two years (or do you have to be 21 over there?)

Posted by: Chantelle at October 28, 2007 6:57 AM

Chantelle: Only 18, so theoretically it would be two years, but rest assured that they won't vote -- not unless they can do it from their sidekicks. Voting would require a modicum of knowledge about civics, e.g., "I can so vote -- it's like [pause] um, democracy ur sum-thin."

For once, that 48% voter turnout works in our favor.

Posted by: socalledonlycousins at October 28, 2007 10:24 AM

Another reason to hate California. Almost everyone I've met there I want to punch in the sternum. It makes even rich New Englanders (I'm from CT and live in MA btw) look 100 times better than those OC pricks. Sometimes I wonder what a carpet bombing of the OC would do.

Posted by: Colin at October 28, 2007 3:59 PM

Colin-- You get my Shit Head of the Week award. You are apparently more of an idiot then these little princesses. You do know that we folks in Southern California have pretty much experienced a carpet bombing for the past week, right? Maybe you didn't see an entire community come together after a horrible natural disaster. What is it you hate about CA so much? The progressive laws and environmental practices? Support of our military? That we pay more to the Federal System than we get back? That without our agriculture you would be eating mudd for breakfast? Maybe its our contributions to technology? Or the arts? Is it that we have warm weather? Is is our beautiful beaches? Deserts? Mountains? Yosemite? Do we have too many immigrants? I know we don't have Harvard or MIT, but we seem to have a couple of nice colleges you may have heard of. Apparently you are so dense you think Laguna Beach is a fair representation of Orange County. Come visit Santa Ana or Garden Grove one of these days. Maybe you meet so many assholes because they tend to run in the same circles.

Posted by: JP at October 28, 2007 8:40 PM

Sorry, I'm really late to the party, but can we not use this as an excuse to toss out my entire generation? I'm 20 and have plenty of teenage friends, the majority of whom are in school and/or working their asses off to support themselves and help support their families. And even the ones that aren't, tend to be a lot smarter (and cooler) than the spoiled bitches on this show, and are completely disgusted at their sense of entitlement.

Sorry - I know some people had already made that point, I just wanted to put my two cents in. A woman who was in line behind me at the grocery store this morning was complaining non stop about her spoiled kids and used that to generalize about how "you just can't trust these kids nowadays" and I had to struggle to bite my tongue.

Posted by: hellcat at October 28, 2007 9:23 PM

Heh, hellcat... when I was 16, I was visiting patients at the hospital, where I volunteered throughout high school. So on this one day, I visited this elderly woman who ranted for two hours about how awful and self-centred young people were. And I just listened, because I figured she was tired and stressed out from being in the hospital and that maybe she was so upset because no one was visiting her.

And as for parents spoiling their kids: I've never gotten a car or anything, but I'm pretty spoiled. I'm in my twenties and my mother still regularly buys me clothes. My parents grew up in extreme poverty in a third world country and it makes them happy to provide my siblings and I with more than what they had, and so we wouldn't need to work to pay for school. They didn't care about us "becoming independent," because that's not really a key value in our culture.

Posted by: prairielily at October 29, 2007 3:19 AM

Don't worry, young ones. Adults have ALWAYS bitched about teenagers. It's like our job or something:

Plato complained about the youth of the day, also. "What is happening to our young
people? They disrespect their elders, they disobey their parents. They ignore the law. They riot in the streets inflamed with wild notions.
Their morals are decaying. What is to become of them?"

"I see no hope for the future of our people if they are dependent on frivolous youth of today, for certainly all youth are reckless beyond words...When I was young, we were taught to be discreet and respectful of elders, but the present youth are exceedingly wise(disrespectful) and impatient of restraint" (Hesiod, 8th century BC)

But seriously? The kids are alright. MOST teenagers are nothing like the kids on Super Sweet Sixteen. Most of them know they aren't going to get some lavish party and presents on their birthday. Many, many teenagers work jobs, sometimes to support their families. Sometimes it's to pay their cell phone bill and put gas in the car, but I've known plenty who handed over part of their paycheck so that the lights would stay on in their house.

Personally, I think all the level-headed teenagers should be quite verbal and let their feelings be known every single time corporations such as MTV try to sell them short. And they do it a LOT.

(I'm a high school teacher at a very low socio-economic school. I love teenagers. They're awesome, they make me laugh, sometimes they make me want to claw my face, but at the end of the day, they're awesome.)

Posted by: Kathy at October 29, 2007 9:36 AM

It's a weird, unfamiliar mother-daughter dynamic, though I suspect it's common amongst over-the-hill starletards who are deathly afraid their daughters are encroaching upon their territory . . .

This brings to mind the image of Snow White's wicked stepmother chanting, "Mirror, mirror on the wall, who's the fairest one of all?"

Posted by: Roland at October 29, 2007 3:43 PM

"MTV is far more dangerous to teenagers than any wine cooler, school shooting or rap lyric. I really wish this prostitot's fucking party was ..."

This is the first time I've posted here, although I've been reading the reviews (and comments, obviously) for years. But I felt I had to say that the word prostitot is so brilliantly, caustically funny that it is now going to become part of my daily lexicon. Thank you for that!

And I heartily agree with the rest of the comments...I've always told those close to me that shows like this (reality shows in general, really) are going to cause the downfall of civilization.

Posted by: Shadows of Dakaron at October 29, 2007 4:30 PM

Ladies and gentlemen I now introduce you to your priveleged leaders of the future generation. I wonder what Bush's sweet 16 was like?

Posted by: grooldog at October 29, 2007 5:33 PM

I agree COMPLETELY but I want to say to the people who now refuse to have kids -- realize that most of it has to do with parenting. Your kid's not going to be one of these automatic robot brats as soon as you pop it out, as long as you devote some time and care to it.

Posted by: Cait at October 29, 2007 7:04 PM

Oh, and I'd like to add that I am a teenager myself, and while I know a few spoiled kids who constantly demand for stuff, we're not all like that. We have well-developed opinions & thoughts, thirst for not bling but knowledge, empathy, and we aren't afraid to express ourselves.

So stop selling us short.

Posted by: Cait at October 29, 2007 7:09 PM

These spoiled teens could take a page from my parents' friends who had the most wonderful redneck wedding a few months ago. It was held next to a farmer's soybean field. There were lines painted on the lawn for people to line up their lawn chairs. Bride, groom, and the rest of the wedding party all wore camouflage shirts, pants, or jackets from a nearby farm supply store (to celebrate the groom's prowess as a deer hunter). Yes, this means the bride was not in a dress, though there were cream-colored accents on her camouflage polo. Was the minister in a suit? No. He wore a black shirt that said "Minister" plus camouflage pants. Was there a DJ? Sure, but there wasn't anyone dancing inappropriately. Was there liquor? Only a Budweiser truck full of it. Did it really matter how much money was spent? No. The focus really was on the two people who were choosing to celebrate their lives together. At the end of the day, that was all anyone cared about. It's just too bad the type of people who have extravagant sweet sixteen parties will never know this type of simple happiness.

This makes me wonder if anyone else remembers when MTV actually tried to be taken seriously as a network? I feel the network peaked with its coverage of the 1992 and 1996 coverage of the presidential elections. While there was a clear bias in the coverage, I always enjoyed watching the political programming done when John Norris, Tabitha Soren, and Kurt Loder were on board. As for the entertainment programming, I may not have liked Liquid Television, but I loved Daria. It's too bad that MTV decided the "Kevin and Brittany" types of Daria were more important to their bottom line than the Darias and Janes of the world. I guess this is the real reason Daria never really had a chance.

Posted by: imelda1979 at October 29, 2007 9:48 PM

I agree totally with this whole article. I have a deep hatrage for pretty much everything MTV now. From My Super Sweet 16, of course, to Date My Mom. Mtv is a total shitwad now and should go back to actually playing and showing music videos for nearly all of the shows time, and re-runs of Jackass; which is the only reason I will occasionly check Mtv.

Posted by: KJung at October 30, 2007 1:30 AM

Finally!! I was waiting for a Pajiba on the series..I hate this show!Don't these people know how spoilt they are?? I'd love to slap each and every person who's been featured on this show. Thanks Dustin for "fuckwit". Ideal word for this show.

Posted by: ILOVECHEESE at October 30, 2007 7:36 AM

OMFG........the only possible thing worse than being a party to such excess would be having a job editing this Pajiba shit.

Posted by: jerry at October 30, 2007 8:30 AM

My 16th b-day party had streamers.

Posted by: Ashley at October 30, 2007 11:08 AM

"It's too bad that MTV decided the "Kevin and Brittany" types of Daria were more important to their bottom line than the Darias and Janes of the world. I guess this is the real reason Daria never really had a chance."

Thank you, imelda1979, those are my thoughts exactly. Bring back some good programming, MTV! There are more of us sarcastic, intellectual, social reject-types than the spoiled brats of My Super Sweet 16!

Posted by: Shadows of Dakaron at October 30, 2007 11:08 AM

It seems to me that you "hate" this show so much that you put time into your weekly schedule to make sure that you watch it! People like you who love to watch it and then talk shit about it, are the reason that it's the number two show on MTV.

The sad part is that you sit home watching it and talking about how pathetic everyone is but, in reality, you are worse than them because you think you are better than them when you obviously deep down wish you were like them.

Posted by: alix at October 30, 2007 12:23 PM

It does provide a good window into this kind of life - I wouldn't have known that people like that really existed if it wasn't for that show. I mean the producers must KNOW that noone will like these people. Perhaps it serves as a good lesson on how NOT to be.

Posted by: Ezra Sitt at October 30, 2007 1:28 PM

I saw that episode too and I hated it. Her birthday theme irritated me! She shows a lack of respect for everything.
BTW, these kids do not have the slightest idea of what a REAL party is. All they do is spend more money than needed in adding ridiculous and extravagant sans-exotic items to their parties with the sole purpose of being the "envy of the night" without even considering the fact that the whole thing looks weird, foolish and, somehow, cheap.
Although, in their defense, it's their parent's fault. They should be slapped lol

Posted by: Cecilia at October 30, 2007 1:41 PM

my wife loves this crap show. i'm thinking about getting a divorce now.

Posted by: bob at October 30, 2007 3:38 PM

These kids are so selfish, I would love to see just one episode where one kid takes everything she gets and sells it and opens a home for exploited and abused teenagers. That would restore a little faith in this country. But I doubt it. That kid would probably get more publicity than some stupid MTV show.

Posted by: chris at October 30, 2007 5:36 PM

i saw one episode of this show and i seriously thought it was a joke or like a spoof-ep - like on madtv or something....now i see that IT'S REAL!!! these people - these kids!! they're REAL......eeks! (Shudders)

Posted by: peanutbeanma at October 30, 2007 6:00 PM

for my 16th birthday i had a bunch of friends over for a sleepover and i'll be damned if we didn't get a blizzard, which was cool when we all put on every bit of clothing i owned and went out and played in it...but when they were stuck at my house for a couple of days i wanted to kill them all! we ran out of everything except oatmeal and one girl even lived right down the street and still wouldn't go home.

Posted by: someone at October 30, 2007 10:15 PM

all i wanted for my 17th birthday was an acura TL and i got stuck with some gay bmw 5 series ;\?

Posted by: anon at October 31, 2007 3:56 PM

Thoughts:

My boyfriend is Puerto Rican and when he finally saw this show got all smug and said "You'd never see a Hispanic family give their children that!" and then he saw the bitchy Quinsanera girl and his face dropped.

My parents offered me a used car for my 16th birthday and I said no. I was in a bad car accident when I was young and still don't have a license. I live in New York now so I don't need one. Where did this "car as present" thing come from? I'd rather take a trip to Europe or something.

I also went to a prep school where we were on scholarship and working class and everyone else was rich. On the worst days I'd put my headphones on and listen to Marilyn Manson's "Beautiful People" and fantasize about firebombing their fancy cars in the parking lot.

This generation of kids is by far the fattest, dumbest, laziest, and most spoiled of any age. I am ashamed of 97% of them (I hope about %3 of them turn out alright) and the fact they will be leaders of this country. I have no qualms in saying that at all.

Posted by: Leanne at November 1, 2007 4:24 PM

Thoughts:

My boyfriend is Puerto Rican and when he finally saw this show got all smug and said "You'd never see a Hispanic family give their children that!" and then he saw the bitchy Quinsanera girl and his face dropped.

My parents offered me a used car for my 16th birthday and I said no. I was in a bad car accident when I was young and still don't have a license. I live in New York now so I don't need one. Where did this "car as present" thing come from? I'd rather take a trip to Europe or something.

I also went to a prep school where we were on scholarship and working class and everyone else was rich. On the worst days I'd put my headphones on and listen to Marilyn Manson's "Beautiful People" and fantasize about firebombing their fancy cars in the parking lot.

This generation of kids is by far the fattest, dumbest, laziest, and most spoiled of any age. I am ashamed of 97% of them (I hope about %3 of them turn out alright) and the fact they will be leaders of this country. I have no qualms in saying that at all.

Posted by: Leanne at November 1, 2007 4:25 PM

THANK YOU for skewering this show with the white-hot pokers of disdain. MTV took a plunge for the worse in 2000 and now seems intent on presenting the worst sides of the younger generation, doing the remaining 99% of teens a disservice. And if people in other countries think these bubble-headed loonies and their "lifestyles" are somethign to aspire too, then *shudder*.

The show may be an ironic depiction of what young women aspire to, but that message too meta for the target audience.

Posted by: Sarah B. at November 2, 2007 4:25 PM

"Birthday Party, Cheesecake, Jelly Bean, BOOM!" FUCKING PERFECT! The end of the world as we know it, indeed. Thanks man.

Posted by: Brian at November 6, 2007 3:25 PM

i love your sweat sixteen party i haveing one may 7 08 i will turn 16 and i was want you to help set it up

Posted by: brittany cummings at November 13, 2007 3:44 PM

i love your sweat sixteen party i haveing one may 7 08 i will turn 16 and i was want you to help set it up and you are so cool

Posted by: brittany cummings at November 13, 2007 3:45 PM

If I have a pool party and invite anyone who wants to come and have a good time, do you think mtv will air it? Or will it make me seem less fortunate, because I am not out putting my parents in doubt? Or should I have them to spend 165,000 on a car for a 16 year old and by the time I am 18 the car probably don't exist anymore, but they are still paying for it. They don't have no money for college tuition cause they are still paying for my 165,000 car.

Posted by: Queen at November 18, 2007 5:23 PM

hey whats ^ girl i really loved ur sweet 16 it was alsome .......... well im hispanice and i m was planning to have a sweet 15th but i changed my mind and im going to have a sweet 16th i want thiis to be the perffect party ever i just wanted to know if u can give me any tips ??..... just email me at carlina.cruz@yahoo.com
thanks love ya
muahzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Posted by: carlina at December 10, 2007 1:33 PM

You are so wrong about Savannah.
If you were smart, you would save judgement for people you know, personally.
Her boobs are not done, she is just "lucky"
She comes from Northern European background and therefore has naturally very blonde hair (ever been to Sweeden?) Doubt it. Doesn't sound like you get out much.

Her mother is delightful, smart and witty. MTV does edit it to make it look differently. If they didn't, they wouldnt have people like you sitting around talking about the show, now would they?

You are entitled to your opinon; albeit it is wrong in my opinion. Though, I do know Savannah and her gracious family personally.

I'm sure you wouldn't like it if I made the judgement that you are some poor blogging looser with nothing better to do than sit around and judge 16 year old girls whose life you envy. I mean, if you hate it that much, why are you watching? Perhaps you should spend your time better--go save the world, plant a tree, raise money for the homeless or whatever your good cause is.

I know it makes you feel better about yourself to sit there and type away. After all, it seems you never got the spoils life; Ithaca, NY is not exactally paradise as I recall.

It's too bad. If you were not so negatively focused, I would consider you a witty writer.

See you on the red carpet.

Posted by: Cassandra at December 18, 2007 3:10 PM

well where all talking bout it,mtv has succeded

Posted by: james at December 28, 2007 5:20 PM

Yup Yup. This reinforces why I don't watch TV much. *phew*

Posted by: Zach at January 1, 2008 9:06 PM

They have adult versions of this show on the WE station. Bridezilla, Rich Bride/Poor Bride, & shows similar to them. Why would you want to start your new marriage $50,000+ in debt on top of whatever debt you had before this? Who, besides you & your wallet, is going to remember your wedding day in 2 years anyway?

Posted by: Snow at January 6, 2008 2:06 AM

you`re right:). i don`t think you should personally meet them so that you can form an opinion, just from the show you realise what brats they are. and this was not envy:))

Posted by: laura at February 4, 2008 4:58 PM

hahaha this is the funniest thing i've ever read
the people who goes on these shows are just full of air.

Posted by: ellie at April 20, 2008 11:37 AM





Video ads popping up after each page view? Try clearing your browser's cookies.