free counter with statistics HawthoRNe | Pajiba - Scathing Reviews for Bitchy People

hawthorne2.jpg
Dramatic Infarction


"HawthoRNe" / Dustin Rowles

TV Reviews | June 17, 2009 | Comments (23)


Don’t you just adore the way that every goddamn network on television realizes simultaneously that a particular idea has been left untapped and they all pounce on it simultaneously? Showtime debuted “Nurse Jackie,” last week; TNT debuted “HawthoRNE” this week, and next Fall, NBC debuts “Mercy.” It’s good for one thing, at least: It gives critics easy points of comparison. I’ll limit my comparison to this: “Nurse Jackie” is a decent show; “HawthoRNe” is bland, hopelessly idiotic drivel immersed in enough sugar to kill an army of diabetics.

It’s not surprising, I suppose. This is the apparent formula for TNT originals: Take a decent actress, stick her on an island of television cliches, and ask her to oversell her lines, as though she were standing a mile away and was asked to jam her dialogue into your cranial cavity. Ah: But the Emmy’s will never recognize Jada Pinkett Smith for her role in “HawthoRNe.” If you want to be a bad actress who over-delivers, you have to do it in a cringe-worthy Southern accent to get noticed by The Academy of Television Arts and Sciences (see “The Closer” and “True Blood”). Sadly, even though the show is set in Richmond, Jada Pinkett Smith opts instead for just a touch of self-righteous sassmouth.

Here’s the generic set up: Jada Pinkett Smith stars as Christina Hawthorne, the chief nursing officer at Richmond Trinity Hospital. As the show opens, Christina is contemplating the one-year anniversary of her husband’s death when she’s unexpectedly called into the hospital by one of her husband’s old friends, who is about to take a header off the hospital roof. He does, and despite the splat of blood and brain matter on the sidewalk, Christina brings him in and, eventually, helps to nurse him back to consciousness. Christina also has a rebellious teenage daughter because of course she does.

As chief nursing office, it’s also Christina’s duty to be completely infallible, always right, and hold her hands on her hips while over-enunciating her lines. Much of her over-enunciation is directed at the doctors, because nurses are angels and doctors are golf-playing greedy devil spawn only half as smart as the RNs. The Chief of Surgery, Dr. Wakefield (Michael Vartan) isn’t so bad, though, because he sometimes takes the nurses’ side. He’s better looking than the other doctors and therefore an ideal love interest for Christina. Also, he has sad soulful eyes. And candy.

Let’s see. What else: The hot nurse of Indian origin who has a prosthetic leg, and is therefore incapable of finding a good man. Quirky! The hot blonde nurse who gives handies to sleeping patients. Sexy! The emasculated male nurse who is actually straight. Twist! The teenage daughter who chains herself to a vending machine to prove a point. Political! Oh, and also a homeless woman who gives birth to a baby and hides it out in her shopping cart. Melodrama! Don’t forget to cry.

Code Blue, motherfuckers. Oh wait: DOA.

No: Bowel Disimpaction.


"Weeds" Season 5 Review | Re-Do Trailer



Comments

I got nothing and apparently neither does TNT.

Posted by: alphawhiskey at June 17, 2009 5:20 PM

It might be generic, but I liked HawthoRNe. I think Jada does a good job and I actually found the cast interesting, except for the bratty daughter and the slutty blonde nurse. Michael Vartan was pretty bland, though.

This is weird, I wasn't looking forward to Hawthorne and I liked it, but I was looking forward to Royal Pains and I hated that.

Posted by: Brie at June 17, 2009 5:25 PM

I was kind of watching and kind of not...how did the husband die? That's really all I want to know. And why the mother-in-law is so bitchy and gets custody of the ashes. Really, the only two questions I have about the entire show, right there.

Posted by: Nicole at June 17, 2009 5:35 PM

HOW DID SHE WIN AN EMMY FOR TRUE BLOOD??? HOW?!?!

Posted by: Kate at June 17, 2009 5:44 PM

Jada Pinkett seems...fuck. Nevermind. I don't care.

Posted by: courtney at June 17, 2009 5:47 PM

I was all set to play the race card about a black actress finally getting her own show and how whitey is trying to keep her down. But then I thought to myself why not save my race card and use it to defend the next Tyler Perry movie.

Posted by: Guess Who! at June 17, 2009 6:02 PM

The saddest thing is that they probably spent 15 days trying to come up with a show title that could include the cutesy RN in it. ToRN? CoRN? MouRNing?

Gah, they should've just gone with H4wth0RN3 and it would've looked less ridiculous.

Posted by: figgy at June 17, 2009 6:10 PM

I haven't watched this yet, but I will. Only for Michael Vartan though and since Jada makes me want to stick pins in my eyes, I may not last more than one episode.

Sidenote though, I don't get the hate for Kyra Sedgwick's accent in The Closer.

Posted by: Popcultureboy at June 17, 2009 6:14 PM

Michael Vartan is in this? I want to love him, but the only good thing he's ever done is Alias.

Posted by: kelsy at June 17, 2009 6:29 PM

Here's what they should do to make an interesting medical show: Take the sharp, wiseacre, daaaaaaaaark comedy of MASH. Tone down the comedy, most of it, get it to like...Sopranos level dark comedy in an otherwise drama show.

Add the frenetic and breathless pace of some of the original episodes of ER, back when a whole episode really could take place within the shows universe time of a few hours, not a sort of vague few days or even weeks.
Take the murky past/troubled childhood/'dark and tangly'/drug/booze/adrenalin junkie character frames and really really flesh them out, really make them interesting, then subesequently ctually explore these characters history's.
Find a setting in like...the ER from a show like The Wire, some where incredibly dark and gritty and depressing where like, every fifth patient is a kid caught between gang shootings or druggie parents. Like the ER in ER but as a crack baby in a bad foster home.
Put the fucker on HBO and go for blood, gore, sex, language, hardcore drug abuse, complex, tangled shit.
Make the characters anti heroes. And I dont mean good natured ruffians, I mean like if Tony Soprano wore a white coat, essentially criminals but at the same time our protaganists so therefore necassarily sympathetic.
Hire a cast who can act.
And not just a bunch of TV movie/daytime soap survivor semi newbies who can cry on cue- either hire fresh, raw talent, or bring in some big dogs, award winners.
Make sure the cast is gonna stay on for longer than about a month apiece and by the end of the show you dont have only ONE original cast member left.

Mix.
Remove where possible rebellious teenaged offspring and/or sexy ex wives/lovers who appear periodically to mess up the main characters lives while at the same time possibly reigniting the spark that got them together in the first place. If the characters have exes, its because they or the ex was a seriously messed up dude, alkie, druggie, violent, what ever, they're not a person the character will want to get back together with.
Dont go with this 'new kid introduced to whacky doctors' bullshit like every single other fucking show ever, the 'new *insert gender* meets gang of *insert title* in highly regarded *insert business/job* and hijinks ensue*
Just throw us into the middle of it. Or if you MUST bring us in through some ones eyes, make that some one as much a fuck up as the others, not some innocent, wide eyed little lamb who makes mistakes that at first are funny and cute but then end up serious when some one dies. I want some one who's coming to this hospital already strung out on speed and like, a cutter or something.

And go.

THAT would be a...complex, possibly nonsensical but bloody and cuss filled hour of television! Yeah!!

Posted by: Nadine at June 17, 2009 6:33 PM

I think I can go the rest of my life without another lawyer or doctor drama. Just don't care. This show was hyper mercilessly during the "Pre Show Entertainment" before I saw Drag Me To Hell, so I've decided I hate it for being over exposed. Remember when arriving early for a movie meant staring at a curtain and listening to some pop music? Fucking marketers.

On a side note, the cutesy logo makes me want to punch babes. Next, please.

Posted by: TylerDFC at June 17, 2009 6:35 PM

Put all the female nurses in hot, sexy uniforms (you know, with the little pointy hat that real nurses haven't worn since 1947 and tight dresses that stop just below their asses, then white stockings and 4-inch heels) and show them servicing the hot patients (male and female). There you go. Problem solved. That's how nursing is in Porn World, anyway.

I didn't actually watch this show because the promos make it look shitty. Plus, I've been burned by "Royal Pains," which sucks out loud. Wanted to like it, hoped it would be another "Burn Notice," but it isn't, not by a long shot.

Posted by: Slash at June 17, 2009 6:44 PM

I'll be honest...that picture of Jada in the title makes me want to punch her so hard in the face...her or the fuckers who made her pull that 'why yes, I am a damaged but strong and understanding woman who will tackle heartache, both my own and that of my patients, while surrounded by a group of lovable oddballs who will provide nothing more than background comic relief to my being Incredibly Understanding and Non Judgemental no matter you come into the hospital with...also its a well known fact that nurses run hospitals not doctors so i'm also just a little bit smug about being smarter than Vartan'

I mean...Kudos to her skill wise because what i've just written is verbatim what that look, to me, seems to want to say but jesus I want to slap it off her face. Isn't she a fucking death metal singer or something?

Posted by: Nadine at June 17, 2009 6:47 PM

over-enunciate.
over-enunciation.
over-enunciated.

Posted by: alone in the dark at June 17, 2009 6:49 PM

I'm sick of Will Smith, and his raging bulldyke wife, and his fucking kids AAAAAAND his bullshit Scientology lifestyle.

FUCK, these, MOTHER. FUCKERS. and their sickening agenda.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at June 18, 2009 1:07 AM

and hold her hands on her hips while over-enunciating her lines.

And how this is different from every other character Jada Pinkett-Smith has ever played?

Posted by: ceejeemcbeegee at June 18, 2009 1:09 AM

The saddest thing is that they probably spent 15 days trying to come up with a show title that could include the cutesy RN in it. ToRN? CoRN? MouRNing?

Gah, they should've just gone with H4wth0RN3 and it would've looked less ridiculous.

Posted by: figgy at June 17, 2009
---
See, I was wondering, like I do with a lot of shows, which came first, the concept or the title. Some idiot on the way to the studio one day is looking out the window when the bus stops at Hawthorne and 45th, and *bing!* notices the RN in Hawthorne and thinks, "Hey, there's an 'RN' in that word, that means 'registered nurse,' I think. Maybe we can do a show about a nurse named 'Hawthorne' ..."

I think this is how most shows get started.

Posted by: , (the commenter formerly known as bucdaddy) at June 18, 2009 1:33 AM

It's not just TV, Dustin.

Volcano/Dante's Peak.

A Bug's Life/Antz.

Dante's Peak/Armageddon.

And on, and on...

Posted by: Shadowen at June 18, 2009 1:37 AM

Someone please, for the love of God, give Vartan a decent role. Otherwise I'm forced to watch the crap he resigns himself to for all of eternity.

Posted by: Austin asking for trouble at June 18, 2009 3:50 AM

Vartan is an untalented hack. (As is Jennifer Garner, so the pairing in Alias fitted well, but made me cringe numerous times.)

And I don't understand the The Closer hate around here.

Posted by: FabMax at June 18, 2009 6:11 AM

If the characters have exes
---
Nadine,

In your show, ideally several exes should be dead, under mysterious circumstances. A hospital/cop crossover show? Maybe something like:

Cops are investigating a drug ring and possible doctor/murderer at the hospital

whilst

Doctors being investigated try to keep alive two cops shot in a botched sting.

That the kind of black humor you're aiming for?

Posted by: , (the commenter formerly known as bucdaddy) at June 18, 2009 9:15 AM

You know what show needs to be made? A CSI procedural where every week the victim is some dumb ass Hollywood suit.

Posted by: ed newman at June 18, 2009 10:20 AM

I think Jada's pretty, but this does look strained.

Posted by: samantha t at June 18, 2009 1:35 PM