web
counter
 

"Game Of Thrones" - "The Pointy End"

By TK | Posted Under TV Reviews | Comments (36)



got8_jpg_627x325_crop_upscale_q85.jpg

“Tell me something, Varys. Who do you truly serve?”

“The realm, my lord. Someone must.”

The eighth episode of “Game Of Thrones, ” cleverly titled “The Pointy End,” is perhaps the pivotal sixty minutes in this first breathtaking season. All of the scheming, machinations and actions taken in the prior seven episodes have now, finally, come to a head. The realm has irreversibly set itself aflame — and now, it is not just winter that is coming, but war, inevitable and unstoppable. It was one of the most powerful of the episodes so far, and most importantly, it is a showcase for the strength of the story, the skill of its actors and an impressive dedication to the production.

The above exchange, between an imprisoned Ned Stark and Varys, The Spider, is perhaps the most telling line in the show to date. Varys, who is a wheedling, unpleasant and untrustworthy creature, demonstrated more honesty in those few minutes than most of the characters in this whole saga — Varys was always one of my favorite characters in the books, and Conleth Hill has breathed life into him. It touched off a series of sequences demonstrating that each of these powers, all intent on the destruction of the others, all serve a different goal, but few of them actually serve the realm itself. It’s one of the most foreboding of lines, as if to say that these forces have set the kingdoms on a path not to peace, but to destruction.

Pride and a hunger for power is what motivates Cersei and her depolorable son Joffrey in King’s Landing, and it’s on full display after they seize control of the castle. Forcing the noble Barristan Selmy out of office, and feeding like leeches off of the pleading of Sansa (who finally managed to acquit herself, as Sophie Turner was able to show a range that extended beyond “petulant twat.”), we can see just what an venal, petty, and deadly lot that particular group of Lannisters can be. I have to admit, it took a few episodes but Lena Headey is beginning to grow into the character nicely.

Vengeance is what drives Robb, as he gathers the forces loyal to Winterfell, desperate to save his father. Richard Madden’s Robb Stark has also finally begun to flex some acting muscle, capturing the essence of a boy forced into more than manhood, but into leadership. The forces that Robb must lead are a brutal, hard-living lot of soldiers and warriors, and Robb’s confrontations with the Greatjon Umber show that despite the forced circumstances, he may well be ready to lead the host to war.

On the other side of the war, desperation forces Tyrion’s hand, as his brilliant talent for manipulation gains him a group of unlikely allies — Shagga and the Hill Tribes, a brutish group of savages that he cleverly persuades to serve his cause, even though, once presented to his father Tywin, it may well be his undoing. It was wonderful to see Dinklage again, and his appearance once again did not disappoint. The dialogue between him, Bronn and the Tribesman was note-perfect Tyrion — sarcastic, caustic, edged with a risky brand of genius. Similarly, his “… and feed it to the goats, yes,” was just right, nailing his resignation and wit, even in the face of overwhelming threats. It may well be that the only match for Tyrion’s wits is Tywin himself, as Charles Dance hits all the notes of regal, sneering, sharp-eyed menace without missing a step.

As for Vas Dothrak, the scale and scope of the army of Khal Drogo still fails to instill the proper amount of awe. In the novels, it’s a vast swarm of horses and blades, a sprawling, howling fury of death and blood that storms the lands. Even without having read the books, it’s hard to imagine that viewers find the horse lords to be too threatening. For sure, the scenes of the individuals are imposing, particularly the fearsome Jason Momoa as Drogo (does it give us some small hope for Conan? Maybe?). Yet the army of the Dothraki continues to simply seem… unimpressive. That said, Emilia Clarke’s Daenerys continues to grow splendidly into a true queen, despite her diminutive stature and fragile beauty. Most important, perhaps, is that she’s one of the few characters in this vicious world that appears capable of mercy, even in the face of overwhelming machismo and violence. Oh, and Drogo’s fight with Mago? Nasty, nasty stuff. But it showcased the savagery of the Dothraki, even if the larger shots of their people fail to do so.

Also? I’d like to thank HBO for pulling its punches with the scene of Daenerys’ mercy. The books place far more emphasis on the plague of rape that the war spreads, and frankly, I’m OK without having to see it firsthand.

Perhaps the most critical development, the piece that’s being overlooked by all of these players, is that of the Wall, where Jon Snow, Sam and the others have their first taste of the otherworldly dangers that the realm may be threatened by. Compounded by Osha’s ominous warnings to Bran in Winterfell, we’re finally learning that there are even greater dangers afoot than this burgeoning war, even if we’re not quite sure what that is.

Of course, I can’t let this end without mentioning my second-favorite character in both the books and the show, little Arya Stark. She didn’t have much to do, but what she had shone. No death struck me more than that of Syrio, fighting to provide her with an opportunity for escape, and no moment was more of a gut punch than Arya, wandering the halls with a wooden sword as the clash of swords and the screams of the dying surrounded her. “Game Of Thrones” is notoriously unkind to children, and Arya’s fate is one that likely left viewers feeling desperately anxious… especially after seeing her kill the stablehand and flee to parts unknown. And that’s what we face from here on out — great unknowns, as the war begins to overtake the world.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



MTV's Teen Wolf Review | Nicholas Hoult, Cut It Out With The Pseudo-Thumbsucking, I Don't Need Anymore Reminders That You Were Once That Cherubic Kid From About A Boy









Comments

I really loved this episode.

I agree that a lot of characters in the show really started coming into their own in this episode. In addition to Cersei and Robb, I felt like Catelyn was also excellent and her character (as annoying as she is) started to take better shape. Same with Dany. I can't help but wonder if it's just the natural progression of these characters on screen or the fact that Martin himself wrote the episode. No one knows these characters like Martin and I think giving him complete rein over the script really helped push these characters forward.

The Drogo fight was the highlight of the episode for me. The entire scene was great, but his fight was fantastic. It really showed just what a complete and total bad ass Drogo is. I always felt like the guy playing Drogo was a built too built/body-builderesque for the role, but they fluidity and grace he moved with during that fight put that thought to rest. He used the man's own weapon to cut his throat and then ripped his tongue out through his neck. That shit was crazy. If I recall from the books, Drogo gets injured off screen, so this was a bit of an improvement in that regard. I thought everything "across the narrow sea" worked very well this episode.

They also didn't disappoint in the Last Stand of Syrio Florel. I liked how they went back to the "What do you say when you meet ths god of death?" quote. I had re-read that fight in the book a couple deays earlier and was a bit surprised that they decided to scale back a bit on the violence there. The fight in the book was more bloody, but Syrio was sufficiently bad ass enough.

I really like The Great Jon. Maybe not exactly as I imagined him, but I liked him a lot and he totally captured the essence of the Great Jon.

Overall, great stuff. Hour goes by ridiculously fast.

Posted by: Forbiddendonut at June 7, 2011 11:45 AM

It was another outstanding episode. I've finally broken down and started reading the book and I can say that it is 100% absolutely must read if you are a fan of the show. It makes you both appreciate what is being done in the television series while also filling in the gaps and fleshing out the world. Speaking as someone who doesn't normally read fantasy (but reads plenty other genres) it's an absolutely amazing book. Both dense with fascinating detail yet incredibly easy to read. I'm going to be hard pressed to stop when I catch up to the show (within the next day most likely).

So having now read the book I can say I agree that the scale is not being communicated. I'm hoping this is on purpose and the final shots of the season will really show the breadth of the armies as they are gathering for the eventual war with the Dothraki and set the stage for season 2. I also really wish they would show The Eyrie and Vale of Arryn as the book described it but I think they would blow out a couple million dollars to pull it off so that may be why they are just avoiding the issue entirely.

Posted by: TylerDFC at June 7, 2011 11:50 AM

In both the book and the show, the death of Syrio is implied rather than shown. I always liked the idea that he might have escaped. Even though that would be cheap and unlike Martin. Does Varys serve the realm? Wasn't he the person Arya hears when she's in the dragon skull?

I reallu hope Conan is as good as this. I'm not ready to let down my guard though. Not unless they put out a press release revealing there is NO COMEDY RELIEF!

Posted by: Mrcreosote at June 7, 2011 11:51 AM

I really, really enjoyed this episode for quite a few reasons but was disappointed with a couple of items. The good:

Syrio and his defense of Arya. I loved his wise cracking character in the book and this confrontation did not disappoint. Also, Arya using the pointy end.

The fight between Drogo and Mago in concert with Daenerys' performance. I think it was excellently done. I also noticed that Mago didn't have much of a pony tail.

The shot of Winterfell when Robb calls the banners. The scene of all the crows flying past the window and then cutting to a shot of the stronghold itself with crows flying every direction. It was masterfully done and conveyed the appropriate sense of mounting dread.

Dinklage.

The... minor annoyances.

Ghost doesn't make a sound. Ever! I think by having him whine and bark they are missing the sense of quiet menace that factors so necessarily into the character.

Catelyns magical appearance at Riverrun. She rides up and my wife says, "She's in Riverrun already?" I understand the need to cut certain parts of the story, but I'm pretty sure Westeros doesn't have Federation transporter technology.

Posted by: admin at June 7, 2011 11:56 AM

LOVED this episode. I agree, everyone felt much more comfortable in character this week. And I loved having Tyrion back. Periods without him in the show (and the book) make me impatient for his return.

So pleased that the direwolves existed in this episode! FINALLY!

My favorite scene may have been between the Stark sons. Robb saying goodbye to Bran, that there always needs to be a Stark at Winterfell, and then little Rickon (hey! he's on the show! WOW!) saying none of them were coming back - powerful stuff. And so simply played by all three boys.

I also loved watching Arya and Syrio, and it broke my heart to have her walk away and know there was no way for Syrio to win, but that in saving her he was already victorious. Syrio has been pitch perfect and it was sad to see him go.

One query to those of you that have read the books (and go ahead and hate me for comparing, all of you who choose to focus on that every week), but was there less urgency in the scene with the wight on screen than there was on the page? I feel like that was a much bigger deal than they made it. Maybe that was just me.

Posted by: KatSings at June 7, 2011 12:01 PM

This episode did a terrific job of highlighting my favorite part of the books: the character growth. Nobody is all evil, all weak, all good. They are all chock-full of flaws and surprises.

Did anyone highlight that better than Sansa? Nobody likes Sansa at the outset. She's prim and starry-eyed and incredibly self-absorbed. Typical teenage girl, especially one who dreams of being the heroine of a romantic Queen. But here we see her trapped and more aware that one bad turn of phrase can not only doom herself, but her entire family. Just fantastic stuff.

Hey, we finally got a scene with Ghost, too, for all you direwolf-fans! Although I don't think the scenes at The Wall carried as much weight as they might have. So much going on in just one hour....

Posted by: Wednesday at June 7, 2011 12:02 PM

Catelyns magical appearance at Riverrun.

Riverrun? I don't think Catelyn, or anyone else (other than Jamie Lannister, who is mentioned off screen as laying seige to Riverrun), ever made it to Riverrun in that episode.

Catelyn left the Ayrie and meets Robb and his army right around Moat Callin, I believe, which really isn't too far from the Ayrie. In order to get to Riverrun they have to cross the river and the only way to do that is at The Twins, which they haven't been to yet.

The sequence of those events tracks pretty closely with the books. That said, I had a similar "minor annoyance" regarding travel time when Roz "magically appeared" at Kings Landing. I know they had the scene where she told Theon she was heading there, but the timing was was totally off. Things at Kings Landing were happening pretty quickly. There was no way she would have made it all the way to Kingslanding in time for her sexposition scene with Littlefinger. Then again, she is the Sexposition Fairy, so perhaps she used fairy dust or some other kind of magicks to *bamf* there or something.

Posted by: Forbiddendonut at June 7, 2011 12:04 PM

Does Varys serve the realm? Wasn't he the person Arya hears when she's in the dragon skull?

Yes it is. He's talking with Master Illyrio, the bearded guy from Pentos that introduced the Targaryens to Khal Drogo and the Dothraki.

Another great, great episode. And what caught me is how much flew past. I kept thinking "And here's where it ends" only to see another scene start.

It was awesome to finally see characters that have been less than welcomed (like Cersei and Sansa) finally get their due. They, in a way, highlight how the story shifts and, eventually, you can't help but look back on the first 5-6 episodes of this show as "the peaceful old days."

And yes, TK, part of Martin's point is to highlight how little the lords desperate to rule the Kingdoms are actually thinking of them. The Lannisters want power. The Starks want vengeance. The Targaryens want to be restored. The Arryns want nothing but to be left alone.

When those in power think more about keeping their power than what it is meant to be used for, the only outcome is suffering.

Posted by: Fredo at June 7, 2011 12:05 PM

"As for Vas Dothrak, the scale and scope of the army of Khal Drogo still fails to instill the proper amount of awe."

As someone else mentioned (maybe TK, or another commenter in an earlier thread), the Dothraki scenes evoke too much Star Trek: TNG. The washed-out too bright lighting, speaking in Klingon, white-ish people in "savage" clothing - all of it doesn't ring quite right to me. Especially compared to the rest of the show where the set design, cinematography, and characters all work together to create (for the most part) a very believable environment.

Posted by: Greedy at June 7, 2011 12:05 PM

The kids on this show are unbelievable. I adore Arya.

I have to admit, it took a few episodes but Lena Headey is beginning to grow into the character nicely

I think it's more like the character grew into Lena Headey's constant I smell poop expression (which she has worn in every role I've seen her play).

Posted by: Cindy at June 7, 2011 12:05 PM

was there less urgency in the scene with the wight on screen than there was on the page? I feel like that was a much bigger deal than they made it. Maybe that was just me.

I'll have to go back and re-read that bit, but I thought they played it well. I think part of it is that, in the book, there are 2 wights that rise up and go on a killing spree and that Jon stumbles onto a corpse or two before confronting the wight he fights outside Lord Mormont's chambers.

Posted by: Fredo at June 7, 2011 12:13 PM

The best episode so far; no doubt due to the fact that Martin himself wrote it. That man, when he gets going, damn can he write!

Loved seeing Syrio again. I really hope he’s not dead. The way he took out the guards with a wooden sword was excellent. “My tongue lied, my eyes shouted the truth.” Great, great writing.

Posted by: Scully at June 7, 2011 12:17 PM

Also, great to see Ghost and Grey Wind featured. And Rickon! We finally got to see the youngest Stark.

Anyone concerned at the rate of Daenerys pregnancy? Shouldn't she look a bit more pregnant at this point?

Posted by: Scully at June 7, 2011 12:21 PM

So many great moments in this ep:

-First and foremost was Syrio's taking down Lannister's men. I screamed at my TV F*** Yeah! Man I hope this isn't the last we've seen of Syrio.

-The full Hodor! Hello!

-Tyrion introducing his new companions.

-After seeing Jason Momoa in action is anyone else excited to see the new Conan movie?

-You want to talk about punch to the gut, every scene with Sansa was heart wrenching.

Best lines:

-"You tell Lord Tywin Winter is coming for him..."

-"He's taller, I'm much better looking..."

-"You wouldn't know him..."

-"Even now I could cut through you like a knife through a cake..."

Posted by: John W at June 7, 2011 12:25 PM

I felt like there was almost too much plot progression this episode, and the next two (there's two left, right?) are going to have to be similarly cramped. I hope they stretch season two to twelve or thirteen episodes, and I hear Martin is in favor of splitting the third book into two seasons (which I doubt will happen, but we'll see).

Good episode, though. The only thing I had problems with were a couple of my favorite lines from the books that were inexplicably changed, like when Cat says, "If you lose in the field, there is no hope for any of us," and Rob says, with quiet strength, "Then I will not lose." I guess TV heroes have to be a little cockier.

Posted by: Todd at June 7, 2011 12:37 PM

I recently finished reading all of the books so I know everything that happens, yet the show still leaves chomping at my nails nervously every week. It was great to Robb (such a hot piece) coming into his own. Tyrion and Bronn continue to delight me:

"And this is Bronn son of..."
"You wouldn't know him."

While I loved Syrio's exit, did anyone else feel that Arya's scene with stableboy was kind of rushed? I did. And because of it, I thought it came off as more of an accident then as something she had to do to survive. I guess they'll have more opportunities to show that, but I would think that since it's her first kill they would give it more weight.

Also, Ser Barristan is fucking boss and I loved watching him drop the mic in Westerosi fashion.

Posted by: jM at June 7, 2011 12:42 PM

Hodor is HUNG!!

Posted by: wow at June 7, 2011 12:46 PM

As someone else mentioned (maybe TK, or another commenter in an earlier thread), the Dothraki scenes evoke too much Star Trek: TNG. The washed-out too bright lighting, speaking in Klingon, white-ish people in "savage" clothing - all of it doesn't ring quite right to me. Especially compared to the rest of the show where the set design, cinematography, and characters all work together to create (for the most part) a very believable environment.

Totally agree (and that might have been me). As a phenomenon/idea, the Dothraki are interesting and intimidating and such. But on screen they are just melodramatic but small-scale Mongol-esque thugs with some Worf thrown in.

Posted by: Brenton at June 7, 2011 12:57 PM

I love all of the Stark children. They are all badass in their own ways. I absolutely love that the Spider said that not even his crows can find Arya. You go, girl! Also, count me among the enormous direwolf fans. Where can I get my very own???

Posted by: jimbob at June 7, 2011 1:14 PM

"The washed-out too bright lighting, speaking in Klingon, white-ish people in "savage" clothing - all of it doesn't ring quite right to me."

I'm always confused when scifi/fantasy nationality that is clearly derived from a fantasy version of a specific ethnic group (the mongol-like dothraki or the arab world of Dune) is presented in TV/movies as white or just ambiguously ethnic.

Is the thinking that white Americans would be turned off by a monolithic asian or arab nationality? It just makes no sense to me; the Dothraki of the novels are just as obviously the Mongol horde as most of Westeros is obviously medieval England. Are the largely arab characters of Dorne going to be all white?

Posted by: h8rade at June 7, 2011 1:22 PM

Aren't we rushing to declare Syrio dead? We didn't see him die, or hear anything other than generic screams and such. I wouldn't count him out.

...That question was mostly rhetorical. If he isn't dead, don't ruin it for me :)

Posted by: JP at June 7, 2011 1:24 PM

Mrcreosote, I don't think it's very much unlike Martin, or even *cheap*, to let people come back or not really be dead - halfway into the last book I had already lost count of how many times that had actually happened. Sad thing is that for a definite answer concerning poor Syrio's fate we'll have to wait until book #6 is published (2020 or something...), since #5 will exclusively be about the p.o.v.'s of those who didn't appear in #4 (or did I overinterpret that ending note?). And Syrio would, of course, re-enter the stage with Arya, wouldn't he?

For some reason, I'm especially fond of the small moments of this episode. Barristan Selmy's expression when being retired, the meeting of Sansa and the Hound, and Bronn going "you wouldn't know him anyway".

Also, is it just me or have the last four episodes all been "pivotal" in which things "came to a head"?

Posted by: Rooks at June 7, 2011 1:46 PM

Ghost doesn't make a sound. Ever! I think by having him whine and bark they are missing the sense of quiet menace that factors so necessarily into the character.

By having him whine and bark, they're not taking up precious time to explain to the viewer why the dog isn't, you know, whining and barking like a normal dog. In a book, you need to give the dog a bit more oomph than "he was a really big dog" to make him imposing. In a TV show, you see the big dog biting the shit out of people and being scary, so it's not necessary to make him a badass mute dog as well.

Posted by: mightygodking at June 7, 2011 1:49 PM

I am going to be very sorry to see this season end. It's a shame we only have two hours left. Yeah, we have quibbles, but I find it difficult to imagine a better job done overall with the constraints. Bravo and thank you, HBO! And greatest thanks to George R.R. Martin. This is a series that I will be re-watching many times over the years. Please give us a dozen episodes to cover A Clash Of Kings!

Posted by: DarthCorleone at June 7, 2011 1:53 PM

I need your opinions!

In ALL of the reviews I read of this episode, the reviewers made some comment about how Robb was giving Tywin Lannister a big FU by saying, "Winter is coming for him. Twenty thousand Northerns marching South to find out if he really does shit gold." That was not at all what I got out of that whole business of sending the scout back with that message.

To me it seemed like he was giving them misdirection. Earlier in the episode Tywin calls him a "green boy"...I think Robb is trying to play the part. I don't think there's any way that Robb would have otherwise said something like that. That message totally

Anyone agree, disagree?

Posted by: baboocole at June 7, 2011 3:38 PM

baboocole I'm not sure how HBO is going to follow the books regarding the battles, but I got the same exact impression you did about misdirection. The knowing look Robb gave Catelyn and Ser Rodrik Cassel quickly calmed them and, as green as he is, the Stark children have been taught well and Robb was being groomed to take over. He knows a thing or two.

Posted by: Scully at June 7, 2011 3:47 PM

Yay, I'm finally all caught up and can finally read the recaps!

Drogo's fight was one of the most badass moments I've seen in forever. The best part of watching it was me saying to my friend, "Why can't that guy be Conan?" Friend, "That is Conan." Me, "No way, really?" Checking IMDB... Me "Holy shit, he is going to be Conan! That movie just got a hell of a lot better."

I am usually Queen Bee when it comes to casting news, that I had forgotten/got confused by all the guy-liner on Drogo, made it an especially happy moment for me.

Also Syrio was also the shit, hope he isn't really dead.

Peter Dinklage is also amazing!

Posted by: Melody Be at June 7, 2011 3:55 PM

baboocole, I think Robb's decision to let the scout go has two purposes.

1. It was misdirection. I think earlier they mentioned that Robb was leading a host of 18,000 men. When they caputred the scout Robb asked how men had he counted before getting caught. The scout replied "20,000". So, the scout believes that, at a minimum, Robb has a larger host than he actuall has. Given that the scout claims he was caught before he was done counting, he is likely to tell Tywin that Robb has more than 20,000. So, that's some misinformation.

2. It was a bit of bravado, but this too is part of his misdirection. He lets the scout go back to Tywin to deliver the message. It's a bold message and a bold move to let a captured scout go. Tywin will likely think that it is more foolish than bold and that he is, indeed, dealing with an advesary who is so green that he pisses grass. The more Tywin believes that Robb is young, foolish and boorish, the more likely he is to under estimate him. That can be a big advantage.

Posted by: Forbiddendonut at June 7, 2011 4:37 PM

Tywin's forces are divided in two. You have Tywin's army and Jaime's army. Robb is brashly telling Tywin which direction he is headed, i.e., straight at Tywin. Guess which direction the bulk of Robb's force is actually going?

Posted by: DarthCorleone at June 7, 2011 6:47 PM

loved it. every episode seems to get better. there are differences from the book but nothing i object to strongly considering the constraints they have to work with. it's nice to know hbo has given the go for a second season and hopefully many more seasons after that.

Posted by: splinter at June 7, 2011 8:38 PM

I think you're 100% wrong about Sophie Turner. Just because this is the first time she's been given scenes that don't present her as a "twat" doesn't mean she was never capable of it. Do you think she just learned how to act that way now? It's not like she's writing the script...

Posted by: sff at June 7, 2011 8:38 PM

oh never mind i get it. "she" refers to Sansa (pronoun confusion)

Posted by: sff at June 7, 2011 8:40 PM

Okay, everyone needs to stop farting around Lena Headey on set so she can do some real acting. Pursed lips and furrowed eyebrows are a specific reaction to specific events, not a general state of facial permanence. She sucks all the testicles and I'm mortified at how she'll butcher the character moving forward.

Somehow, Dinklage is out-Tyrioning Tyrion. A virtuoso performance that will go unrecognized come awards season so we can give Jim Parsons more dildo-shaped statuettes to nervously cram into the suspecting anii of his boy harem.

Posted by: Kballs at June 8, 2011 8:50 AM

While I have always liked Lena Headey more than most, I actually think that, to date, the Cersei character in the TV show is actually a bit of an improvement over the Cersei in the books. She has come across as much more intelligent, cool, calm and, therefore, a more dangerous opponent. In the books she's completely manic, paranoid and resorts to using sex as her one and only option. In the book, she tried to seduce Ned Stark in the godswood in Kings Landing for crissakes! In the show, she just calmly threatened him. I liked the latter over the former.

Posted by: Forbiddendonut at June 8, 2011 9:57 AM

You are so right about Lena Headey, I only recently recalled that she was the Queen in 300. In which she had the exact same expression. Maybe she should get some botox and learn how to act with something other than her face... she might have better range.

And I really hope her character gets killed in a really brutal and demeaning way.

And wow...zombies!

Posted by: MRod at June 8, 2011 10:14 AM

I came to this thread late, but I wanted to say that I'm proud of everyone here for not going all 12-year-old-boy about Hodor's penis. I've seen far too much of this on other reviews of this episode. Here, it's hardly mentioned. Well done.

Posted by: John. G. at June 10, 2011 12:20 AM