web
counter
 

Fish Sticks and Custard

By C. Robert Dimitri | Posted Under TV Reviews | Comments (82)



Karen-Gillan-Amy-Pond-Matt-Smith-Doctor-Who.jpg

“I’m the Doctor. I’m worse than everybody’s aunt.”

And…we’re off! Thrown right into the action, we find the TARDIS in flames, and our new Doctor (Who? That youngster Matt Smith!) is dangling out the open door of his signature police box as it careens wildly over London. There’s a near miss for the Doctor’s groin with the top of Big Ben that had me wincing in anticipation, but — fear not, fellow Whovians — the great Steven Moffat is our new show-runner, and he has proven that when it comes to writing episodes of Doctor Who (see “The Empty Child” / “The Doctor Dances,” “The Girl in the Fireplace,” “Blink,” and “Silence in the Library” / “Forest of the Dead”), he is not one for the lowbrow.

After we are treated to a new rendition of the appropriately timeless Doctor Who theme, we meet Amelia Pond, a young girl who has an unsettling crack in her bedroom wall from which foreboding voices emanate. One evening Amelia prays to Santa for help with this problem (a nice non-denominational entreaty for those of us who are heathens), and her request is seemingly answered by the crash-landing of the TARDIS in her yard.

Still feeling those pesky physical aftereffects of regeneration, our new disheveled Doctor emerges from the wreckage and bonds instantly with Amelia. I must interject that said bonding is one of the more charming introductions for both a Doctor and his companion in the program’s history.

Now I must interject within the interjection. Hold on — this little girl is the new companion? Didn’t we read that Scottish lass Karen Gillan has the job? Well, they both have red hair, and this is a show that features time-travel, so I’d say the jig is up fairly quickly on that one, Mr. Moffat. The transparent attempt at subterfuge matters little; like I said: charm-ooze.

As Amelia cooks for the hungry Doctor who is trying to learn the preferences of his new taste buds, we learn that she lives with an in absentia aunt. After vehemently and comically rejecting a few foods, the doctor settles on a delicious combination of custard and fish sticks. His craving sated, the Doctor examines the crack in Amelia’s bedroom wall and determines that it’s an inter-dimensional fault in the space-time continuum. (Isn’t an inter-dimensional fault in the space-time continuum just always the way?) The aforementioned voice is searching for “Prisoner Zero,” and temporarily prying open the hole in the wall reveals a giant eye that is on the lookout for the escapee.

The Doctor recognizes the grave danger of the situation and pops off for “five minutes” in the still-ailing TARDIS with the promise of an immediate return. Amelia is absolutely enthralled by the Doctor, and packs up a child’s suitcase complete with teddy bear, presumably to take up residence in the TARDIS indefinitely where she will be able to enjoy the swimming pool and the library. She patiently sits by the spot where the TARDIS disappeared.

The Doctor shows up again on what he presumes is a slightly tardy next morning. Using the always trusty sonic screwdriver, he reenters the locked house and frantically calls for Amelia. A cricket bat to the back of the Doctor’s head leads to him hand cuffed to a radiator, and now we have the big reveal of our new companion, “Amy,” played by Karen Gillan. Amy is looking very cute in a bobby’s uniform. (Please count that sentence as fulfilling my quota for two important obligatory elements in any Doctor Who recap: the ogling of the Doctor’s companion and my feeble attempt at trying to fit in with the British via the use of slang.) She does such a convincing job of being a police officer, feigning surprise that the Doctor is looking for Amelia Pond, and calling for backup, that for a couple minutes I did doubt that she and Amelia were the same person.

The Doctor reveals to Amy a hidden room in her house that has remained just outside the field of her vision ever since the arrival of Prisoner Zero. Still immobile, the Doctor warns Amy not to investigate, but — like so many of the Doctor’s intrepid and curious companions before her — she does so regardless. In this room Amy gazes upon the true form of Prisoner Zero, a terrifying moray-eel-like creature, and retrieves the Doctor’s sonic screwdriver.


d4xc5r7_8g9x7brc9_b.gif


Back in the hall she gives the Doctor the sonic screwdriver so that he can free himself. Prisoner Zero appears before both of them, but this time the “multi-formic” creature has taken the form of a local comatose man and his dog. There’s a brilliant and amusing bit of Moffat doublespeak dialogue by the Doctor that is contingent upon whether or not Amy is a cop who has called for backup that is meant to keep Prisoner Zero at bay, and then the malfunctioning sonic screwdriver finally does its duty, putting he and Amy on the run.

In the course of their escape from the house, the Doctor learns from Amy that she is in fact the same Amelia Pond twelve years later and that she is not a police officer. Instead, she is wearing the trappings of one of her outfits in her work as a “kissagram” girl. Over the years Amelia’s brief encounter with the Doctor has served as the source of her fantasies, stories, and psychiatric sessions.

Meanwhile at the local hospital nurse Rory Williams reports to the physician on duty that the entire coma patient ward has been calling for the “doctor.” He also reveals that he has seen the patients wandering around the village. Rather than looking at the photographic evidence he has recorded on the phone, the disbelieving physician puts him on leave.

The voice searching for Prisoner Zero has returned and is broadcasting over all the local radio and television signals. We learn that this voice is tied to the Atraxi space armada that is now surrounding Earth. Prisoner Zero has been taking advantage of its multi-formic nature to hide amongst the humans, and as a result the Atraxi will incinerate all the planet’s residents if it does not surrender.

The Doctor and Amy investigate the broadcast warning over the television in an elderly neighbor’s house. The neighbor — along with her son Jeff — recognize the Doctor from the “cartoons” of the “raggedy Doctor” that Amelia had created in the interceding years. That’s a cute revelation, but there is business to be done, as the Doctor ascertains that they only have twenty minutes before the Atraxi make good on their threat. The Doctor and Amy bicker a bit more as the Earth’s atmosphere is surrounded by a force field in preparation for incineration, and the Doctor makes the connection that he just saw Rory recording Prisoner Zero in his man-dog-tandem form.

The Doctor questions Rory about this taping and learns of the coma patient situation. He also learns that Rory is Amy’s boyfriend, and Rory echoes the disbelief that this is the “raggedy Doctor” come to life. More amusingly, we learn that Amelia forced Rory to dress up as the Doctor when they were kids.

The Doctor tries to summon the Atraxi to Prisoner Zero’s exact location. This is almost successful, but the sonic screwdriver smokes, sputters, and fails, thus leaving the Doctor without his two most trusty devices for the remainder of the adventure, as the TARDIS has locked him out in order to complete its automated repairs.

The Doctor returns to Jeff so that he can borrow his laptop. He taps into the world emergency conference that is discussing the planet’s imminent crisis, transmits several scientific proofs that are beyond the current level of human knowledge to convince them of his credentials and usefulness, and sends them a computer virus to reset counters across the world at a particular moment. In yet another bit of this episode’s manic comic brilliance, the Doctor leaves Jeff to supervise the world’s leaders before the Doctor runs off to see the plan come to fruition.

Back at the hospital Amy and Rory run into Prisoner Zero, now in a creepy mother-with-twin-daughters tandem form. The Doctor arrives just in time to save them on a commandeered fire engine. The Doctor tells Prisoner Zero to give up and go back through the crack in space-time, but Prisoner Zero taunts the Doctor for not knowing the source of the cracks and is no mood to cooperate.

The Doctor’s plan comes together as the Atraxi track the source of the computer virus to Rory’s camera phone, which has all the images of the coma patients that Prisoner Zero has assumed. Prisoner Zero has one final trick up its sleeve (or up its alien pseudo-reptilian husk, if you will), though, as it renders Amy unconscious and assumes the form of a young-Amelia-Doctor tandem, having established a psychic link with her over the many years since its arrival. The Doctor realizes that Amy is thinking about him and pleads with her to remember Prisoner Zero’s true form that she saw in the secret room. This succeeds, and the Atraxi are finally able to use one of their spacecraft to pinpoint and capture Prisoner Zero.

Perhaps foreshadowing a season-arc to come, Prisoner Zero offers an ominous warning: “Silence, Doctor. Silence will fall.”

The Atraxi leave, but the Doctor summons them back for a tongue-lashing. In a stirring crescendo, the Doctor sifts through new outfits pilfered from the hospital closet as he makes his way to the roof. There he makes certain that the Atraxi are aware that this planet is not to be incinerated under any circumstances, as it has had a most reliable protector over the years. The giant Atraxi eyeball renders a visual projection of Earth’s history and a montage of the preceding Doctors’ adventures as the Doctor states his case, and right on cue the Doctor bursts through the final hologram of our old friend David Tennant in our first look at the Doctor’s new appearance in full (bowtie!).

The Doctor returns to the now fully self-repaired TARDIS and takes it for another quick jaunt. His skip to the moon and back is only a mistaken two years later, much to Amy’s continued chagrin. Now, however, the Doctor is ready to offer a trip to anywhere/when “the girl who waited” would like to go. After a bit more bickering, Amy is too impressed by the TARDIS’s interior to pass up the opportunity, even though we catch the hint that she has an important event the next day. The Doctor and Amy take off in the newly designed TARDIS, and our final image is a pan across Amy’s bedroom. We see the dolls she made as a child of her and the Doctor, but more importantly the final image is Amy’s ready-to-wear wedding dress waiting on a hanger.

Having re-watched the episode and absorbed all the details, I suspect and hope that we are in for a great time with Matt Smith, Karen Gillan, and Steven Moffat. The dialogue, the comedy, and the chemistry are spot-on, as the Brits might say. Matt Smith in particular has believably leaped into the role, delivering the “timey-wimey” vernacular at breakneck speed with the appropriate blend of authority and jest. He should immediately assuage all doubters. Long live David Tennant, of course, but if “The Eleventh Hour” is any indication, Matt Smith is “the man,” even if the Doctor promises in this episode never to use that phrase again.

C. Robert Dimitri spent many of the prime Saturday nights of his youth staying home to watch syndicated episodes of “Doctor Who” on PBS, and his social skills might be beyond repair as a result. He’s not the most hardcore Whovian, but he’s a respectable representative. The first episode he remembers watching was Tom Baker’s “The Creature From the Pit.” At one point he obsessively watched all the Hartnell, Troughton, and Pertwee episodes that were available to him, and sometime around the age of 14 he dragged his mother to a “Doctor Who” convention. All he truly has ever wanted for Christmas is Perpugilliam Brown, but he would be almost as content with K-9.

He would never eat fish sticks.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Trailer: Big Tits Zombie in 3D | You'll Never Forgive Yourself If You Don't Watch It | Pajiba Love 04/20/10









Comments

Hear hear, we are in good hands.

Posted by: Mr. Tusks at April 20, 2010 12:35 PM

I wasn't that taken with the first episode, a lot of it felt like rehashing old themes, it felt very Girl in the Fireplace. Plus her having her own version of Mickey waiting in the wings and all that. And who didn't see the wedding dress coming? I do very much hope it's not going to be another companion in love with the Doctor, it's been done to death.

I didn't like Matt Smith either, he seemed more like he was doing an impression of what the Doctor should be, rather than being it. But the second episode was better, and I think he'll grow on me in time. Not giving up on it yet.

Posted by: Carrie (Teabelly) at April 20, 2010 12:37 PM

I finally got to watch this last night, and I was drawn in and amused and intrigued. There were a few sticking points, but all-in-all, I thought it was a most promising start for the new Doctor team.

Posted by: Drake at April 20, 2010 12:38 PM

who didn't see the wedding dress coming?

Apparently just me. Could just be specifically female intuition, I had to just not say anything when asked "she's gonna get married, right?" a few minutes before that shot last Saturday morning, cursing her for spoiling her own surprise.

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 12:44 PM

I think it's also just me that barely ever watches "The Girl In The Fireplace". It's no "Forest Of The Dead" I'll tell ya!

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 12:45 PM

So I've watched the first few episodes (figured out how to hack the BBC iPlayer) and Matt Smith is growing on me as the doctor. I however don't really like the new companion.

Posted by: DoubleH at April 20, 2010 12:58 PM

That's impressive, but it might be easier to get the videos themselves. I'm just wondering if the Daleks will cause as much "my 12 year old nephews loved it, but not ME!" silly bastard point-missing groaning over here as I've seen the past two days at behindthesofa. Oy.

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 1:05 PM

No, really, that iPlayer is a FUCKER! Makin me hunt down crappy YouTube conversions of two minute interviews.

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 1:19 PM

Phew. Well, that's over with. I dont' have to be 50/50 on the new kid anymore. I actually got to quite like him. Way to go Moffat. There were still some little "first episodes - first time with the new face" kind of thing, but all in all not bad at all.

I especially liked his "Basically? - Run!" line to the aliens. I just wanted to know if he had the weight that Tennant and Eccleston had.

And maybe I'm just a perv, but I like Amy.
Not just because she makes my zipper wiggle. (Scottish Gingers - yum!).
She's got some nice actressing too. We'll see how that all holds up.
It was a bit "Girl in the Fireplace", but that's ok.

So all in all, I am relieved and actually optimistic.

Posted by: Odnon at April 20, 2010 1:31 PM

She's the girl who waited for FOURTEEN YEARS, of course she's not going to fall in love with him.

Posted by: arrrghzi at April 20, 2010 1:33 PM

I need help, people. I've never seen a single episode of Dr. Who. Nev-ar. I want to try it out though, but I'm intimidated by the backlog of old seasons/series/cycles whatever. Am I safe to just pick up with the new Matt Smith series? Should I go back and watch Tennant? Or lastly, and most horrifying and idea, should I go back to the very beginning and watch every series?

Posted by: Mr. Teatime at April 20, 2010 1:39 PM

1. OK. Matt Smith is a little young for my taste, but I thought he did "Doctor" very well, and won me over. Like most of the other actors, it seems to take a couple of episodes to really sink into the role.

2. I liked the humour a lot, and it had a few twists I didn't see coming (although I did predict the wedding dress).

3. I did have a few flashbacks to previous Doctors. Jon Pertwee also stole a medical doctor's clothing as his outfit. Why the MD was wearing Victorian finery and driving a Model T was never explained, but that was his look. Also, both Patrick Troughton and David Tennant had pockets that could hold infinite amounts of stuff without showing weird lumps on the outside(which pocket had the apple with the smiley face?).

4. I liked the idea that the TARDIS got to regenerate itself. I'm just waiting for the next, "You've redecorated. I don't like it." comment from an old companion.

Posted by: BWeaves at April 20, 2010 1:41 PM

aarghzi, I agree, but at least they let her ogle while he was changing. I get sick of the Companions In Luuuurve theme as a rule.

I do still have high hopes, especially after the space-whale. And the Daleks were middling but he gets some good shouty time in there at them. I am pretty sold on Eleven now.

Posted by: Anne (in Reno) at April 20, 2010 1:41 PM

You can start right here and then go back if it catches your interest. I'd say the furthest to start back is the first Eccleston episode, but all three new Doctors' entrances have been newcomer-friendly.

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 1:42 PM

Mr. TeaTime. Just jump in and start watching.
You'll catch on.

If you go back to the beginning, just realize it's been on since 1963.

Posted by: BWeaves at April 20, 2010 1:42 PM

I'm looking forward to the seeing more about the Weeping Angels. I haven't seen a good creepy alien like that since the Daleks and Cybermen were invented.

I'm also looking forward to seeing River Song's backstory.

Posted by: BWeaves at April 20, 2010 1:44 PM

Because now he HAS to tell it!

Doesn't he?

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 1:45 PM

Mr. Teatime, I started with Tennant and went back to Eccleston so that's how I recommend it to other people - Eccleston is a little darker to me so I liked having at least one season of Tennant under my belt first.

Also, I've finally started on the older ones and FYI, Netflix has a bunch of the Tom Baker ones available for streaming. I've been watching the ones that Douglas Adams wrote and they hold up very well. And how awesome is Romana?!

Posted by: Anne (in Reno) at April 20, 2010 1:47 PM

this wk, was....a 'star whale'.. next wk is winston churchill/daleks.... @@..

color me unimpressed.

or as the sayin' in these parts goes...

meh.

Posted by: kikz at April 20, 2010 1:48 PM

Wait, is there a third schedule? Where are you watching from?

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 1:51 PM

I really don't think it's going to be a companion in love with the Doctor arc. He really fucked her up by appearing to her as child (is my imaginary friend real or not) and I think much of this relationship is going to be about some of her personality quirks as result of that.

If I could have a request though, Mr.Dimitri, could we have a little bit more depth in the reviews: there's what happens on the surface and what happens in the subtext and I would love to see more subtext analysis (I know you're new to this so I'm giving you a gentle shove).

By the way, for those of you who like your spin-offs (even the juvenile kind), Russell Davies is writing a special ep of The Sarah Jane Adventures that Jo Grant will be in. YES. That Jo Grant. The Tom Baker companion and famous to legions of small boys many years back for posing topless with a Dalek. What more did you need to know?

Posted by: PaddyDog at April 20, 2010 1:52 PM

"City Of Death", baby, "City Of Death"

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 1:52 PM

more than topless, actually

http://angrywhofan.blogspot.com/2010/04/sja-to-get-matt-smith-and-katy-manning.html

(what, you think I have to say "NSFW"? I just said "more than topless", people!)

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 1:54 PM

I quite loved Matt Smith and while this episode did bite off a few Moffat episodes (Fireplace and Blink most noticeably to me), those are some of my favorite episodes so at least he's mining some great stuff. Smith just gets better and better in my opinion (I've seen the first three) and rises above some inconsistent, but overall charming material. I really love Karen too, I find her to be a sassypants and that's how I prefer my female protagonists.

I think, also, that Moffat is reaching above the Davies era to incorporate some truly intriguing imagery and to explore a lot of the psychology of what happens when TO a companion when they know the Doctor. In the last three iterations (Rose, Martha, Donna) the women were made BETTER, enriched and strengthened by their experience. For Amelia Pond, her interactions with the Doctor so far has rather unhinged her. I thought the imagery of Pond and the Doctor in a close two-shot with him holding up the apple she carved for him as proof was a nice (if, OK, fine, rather obvious) Miltonian allusion. The doctor offers knowledge to Amy, but at what price?

I loved the "Raggedy Doctor" bit and I don't think we'll get another companion mooning after the doctor because that last shot before the (yes, fine, TRULY obvious) wedding dress reveal of all the Doctor dolls and sketches-rather creepy, no?

Posted by: coveredinbees at April 20, 2010 2:01 PM

(sorry I just realized I forgot to mention the whole Donna reset tragedy which-yes-rather undermines my Davies criticism. But, I would argue that Donna is left UNCHANGED by the whole experience, but not damaged. We all view it as tragic because we know what she COULD have been, but, from her perspective. . .same as it ever was.

Posted by: coveredinbees at April 20, 2010 2:03 PM

I remember Jo Grant as Jon Pertwee's companion. She wore really short skirts, go-go boots and a feather coat. I never knew she posed nekkid with a Dalek plunger between her plungee.

Posted by: BWeaves at April 20, 2010 2:04 PM

Exactly. Covered in bees. That's what I was trying to say. I think this is going to be a much more complex relationship than some of the others we've seen.
I also had no problem with echoes of GITFP because there's a nice but tenuous continuity there that mirrors who Eleven is: the same Time Lord and yet not the same Time Lord (I almost used the word "man" there).

Posted by: PaddyDog at April 20, 2010 2:06 PM

I like Matt Smith. He's no David Tennant, but he's funny and (at 3 episodes in) is starting to show some depth. If you've only seen the first one so far, give him a chance. He's definitely grown on me (to the point where I'm at a level 6 *squee* by the end of an episode).
Not too crazy about Amy, but as long as they don't start sleeping together she could turn out OK. Is it just me, or do they keep doing that "we'll shoot him from below her shoulder and her from above his head to make it seem like they're about to kiss" framing technique?

Mr. Teatime, I started with Eccleston and moved to Tennant, which I liked, because it made the story arc work. Also it's like starting at the beginning, only you don't have to watch all the 80s special effects. You definitely could just jump in here, but the Tennant seasons are entirely worth watching. Especially because Matt Smith seems to be emulating the Tennant style a little, and I'd try to get the original first.

Posted by: esme at April 20, 2010 2:07 PM

I loved the "Raggedy Doctor" bit and I don't think we'll get another companion mooning after the doctor because that last shot before the (yes, fine, TRULY obvious) wedding dress reveal of all the Doctor dolls and sketches-rather creepy, no?

Amy's not in love with the Doctor; the next two episodes make that pretty clear without having to have her say it outright. She's a lifelong fantasist (mostly in the idle dreamer way, not the crazypants way) who's running away from her obligations and responsibilities - IE, her wedding.

And she is Significant somehow. This too becomes obvious; CRD's otherwise excellent recap missed the fact that the crack in the universe repeats itself in a TARDIS scanner right at the end, before the Doctor shuts it off so Amy can't see it.

Posted by: mightygodking at April 20, 2010 2:09 PM

Yes! Transition! That was another thing I found rather brilliant, Smith running around in Ten's torn clothing and doing occasional Ten-like vocal tricks to ease the transition and to show he's still cooking. In my opinion, in the future episodes, he's totally made the Doctor his own and left behind the charming (but at this point rather tiresome) "Weeeeeeeeeeell"s and "Right!"s of Tennant's long reign.

But it makes loads of sense. I saw NONE of Eccleston in Tennant's first episode, the emphasis was on how he was different, not what linked him to the whole chain.

Posted by: coveredinbees at April 20, 2010 2:11 PM

Am I the only one who thinks that this time, the Doctor will be the one to fall in love? (And don't give me that "out of character" stuff - this is a series that's older than most people here.)

Posted by: muzz at April 20, 2010 2:12 PM

I read an interview with Smith in which he said that because of his age, he was the first of the new Doctors who didn't grow up with the Doctor (sadly for him his formative years were during the hiatus), so Tennant and Ecclestone (and previously Davison and McGann) all knew the Doctor as a child. It will be interesting to see how he develops the character without that burden/advantage.

Posted by: PaddyDog at April 20, 2010 2:13 PM

You know that's funny mightygodking, I can't decide if he shut it off so she can't see it, or if he himself didn't see it. But yes, there was another indication of something amiss in the third episode which I swear I won't talk about a spoil, all you who are not there yet!

Posted by: coveredinbees at April 20, 2010 2:14 PM

WHOLLY amiss

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 2:17 PM

Cute.

Posted by: coveredinbees at April 20, 2010 2:18 PM

Exactly again, coveredinbees. We didn't need a transition period from Nine to Ten because Rose was there witnessing the whole thing so we had our links established, but here I think the nexus needed to be established with a nice nod to the past, otherwise we start from scratch with a new Doctor and a new companion (that was already done, by necessity, very well with Rose and Nine so why re-do it).

Posted by: PaddyDog at April 20, 2010 2:19 PM

Because Moffat has, himself, said his "Who" will focus more on the fairytale aspect of the genre (which I love-honestly this episode felt very Buffy to me, and that's high praise). I'm wondering what precedent we have, in the ginormous fairytale cannon, of girls damaged by their experience. Usually they become quite brave or marry the Prince as in the Davies model. So what is Moffat going for with Amy who has seen countless shrinks over the years and actually HAS something she oughtn't be running from (as opposed to Rose, Martha and Donna who weren't leaving much behind-sorry Mickey!)

Posted by: coveredinbees at April 20, 2010 2:24 PM

Oh shit, was that a pun?

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 2:24 PM

I'M NOT GONNA WATCH IT!!!!!

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 2:25 PM

Jay - It depends on how you say it...
Hole-y or Hoo-ley.
Hoo-ley sounds funny. Hooly Shit! Run!

Posted by: Odnon at April 20, 2010 2:27 PM

Well, I guess there is a kind of hole that--I can say no more!

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 2:31 PM

I think it depends on what fairy tales he is in to. There's the "happily ever after" genre, and then there's the girl who dances herself to death because she coveted the shoes too much, there's the mermaid who wants to become human but every step in her human feet is excruciatingly painful. In a lot of fairy tales, the girl is destroyed by her experience. Literally. This will be fun.

Posted by: PaddyDog at April 20, 2010 2:34 PM

Yes, let's leave the nice Americans who watch shows when they are legally released alone.

Posted by: coveredinbees at April 20, 2010 2:34 PM

PaddyDog, I SO agree. Did we get a little Red Riding/Big Bad Wolf bit with little Amelia Pond in her red cardigan? And all the eating/food nonsense? (How great was Matt Smith eating the custard off those fish fingers? So great.) And I loooove the dark fairytales (chalk it up to my folks giving me non-bowdlerized Grimm and Anderson books when I was little), so thank you for the reminder.

Posted by: coveredinbees at April 20, 2010 2:37 PM

To the Smith haters: I thought Tennant was a retarded clown in the beginning, and three seasons later I got all misty with "I don't want to go." So let Smith grow on you.

Posted by: Mr. Tusks at April 20, 2010 2:46 PM

YAY Dimitri! Thanks for the great review. As much as my heart aches for my beloved 10th Doctor, I am already falling for the new guy. I am a fickle bitch, easily swayed by new adventures and a pretty face. I agree that the FNG has the chops. He gave us The Doctor in essence while exploring the new man. I felt a sense of relief at the end of this episode, Thank GODTOPUS, we still have The Doctor.

Mr. Teatime
Jump right in, but accept from the beginning that this is not meant to be on the Sci side of Sci-Fi. The producers describe it as more of a fairytale. So, if you can accept the camp and laugh at the jokes, you will probably love it. And of course, remember, if something isn't making sense, it is probably in reference to something from the shows considerable history, or foreshadowing. This show has story arcs that span DECADES to appease the hard core fans, and arcs that encompass entire seasons. The flicker of the screen at the end of this ep, or mentions of
“Silence, Doctor. Silence will fall.” are good examples. Just go with it. And give it a good 4 or 5 eps to settle in. I have faith in the new guy.

Posted by: Lindsey with an 'e' at April 20, 2010 2:57 PM

HOW are you folks in the US watching the show? Do you have BBC America? Is there no other way to enjoy the Doctor?

Seriously. Am I going to have to get cable to watch this??

Posted by: Stella at April 20, 2010 3:01 PM

Stella:

You could wait three years. PBS is currently on Tennant's second season.

Posted by: PaddyDog at April 20, 2010 3:04 PM

I applaud the use of FNG.

Nope, don't need cable, just a little work.

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 3:09 PM

In Canada, we get it on The Space Channel, an episode or two behind Old Blighty.
So it's not too long a wait..

Posted by: Odnon at April 20, 2010 3:10 PM

Stella,

You can purchase Dr. Who through iTunes and Amazon's watch it now.

Posted by: DoubleH at April 20, 2010 3:15 PM

Odnon, damn! "Old Blighty!" I just got an anglophilliac boner.

Posted by: coveredinbees at April 20, 2010 3:18 PM

coveredinbees: "Roger that"!

Posted by: Odnon at April 20, 2010 3:23 PM

I'm watching Dr. Who on BBC America. It's only a couple of weeks late. But previous seasons have been months late, so I'm not complaining.

Posted by: BWeaves at April 20, 2010 3:47 PM

The only problem with BBCA is that they cut about five-seven minutes out of each episode.

Of course, by that I mean the only problem with their Doctor Who coverage. There are many problems with BBCA, not least of which is that they need to stop showing 100 million episodes of Top Gear EVERY SINGLE DAY. I used to love that show. Now I am so sick of the sight of it on the schedule, I want to throw up every time it's mentioned.

Posted by: PaddyDog at April 20, 2010 4:35 PM

I'm reserving judgment on Smith. I find him charming, but something about him doesn't entirely sit right. I'm putting it down to new-actor/old-character teething problems for now. I think Smith is just going through his own actor-y version of deciding on the tie.
As for Amy, Gillan is just ridiculously gorgeous. I noticed they did the same thing with her as they did with Donna and made her awesome in the second episode (okay, third with Donna, but it was the second 'new' Donna ep). Because I'm a sucker, it worked.

So, my fellow 'slightly illegals', what are your thoughts on the um, bad guys in third episode? United Colours of Benneton/Smart Cars? Or utterly brilliant?

Posted by: ScienceGeek at April 20, 2010 4:38 PM

Science Geek, UTTERLY DUMB DUMB DUMB.

Posted by: coveredinbees at April 20, 2010 4:44 PM

Ah, it's already begun.

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 4:52 PM

I mean, I'm not spoiling anything by saying I was mightily, mightily displeased, right?

Posted by: coveredinbees at April 20, 2010 4:56 PM

coveredinbees, I want there to be a great color war now and the winner poops skittles. Or takes over the universe and color-coordinates it or something.

Posted by: Anne (in Reno) at April 20, 2010 5:04 PM

Thanks folks. The cheap side of me doesn't want to pay to view the eps and ha-ha, wait three years for PBS to air it, RIGHT. Like that's gonna happen.

Posted by: Stella at April 20, 2010 5:06 PM

They reminded me of the iMacs from '99 that came in "flavors" like lime and tangerine.

Mmmmmm, skittles.

Posted by: coveredinbees at April 20, 2010 5:12 PM

For anybody who needs a viewing alternative, the new eps are going up within a day or two over at Videostic. They also have all the old ones; no episode titles are listed, so you'll have to know the number if you're looking for older ones.

I'm sold on Smith and Amy, and I say that as someone who's spent months fully prepared to hate on him. Now I just hate his hair.

Posted by: ALR at April 20, 2010 5:38 PM

Coveredinbees and sciencegeek, I had flashbacks to the Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers, myself.

Possible SPOILER ALERT?

.
.
.

I'm disappointed in the ridonkulous overuse of them as a villain anyway. They're supposed to be a BIG FUCKING DEAL, and that doesn't work when they just show up every few episodes and are soundly defeated, or at least turned away for the next 3 episodes and then defeated again. Stuuupiiiid. I think they need to give them a rest for the rest of this season and most, if not all, of the next season, and only bring them out for special occasions. (And also not have them CONSTANTLY casually stand around while the Doctor not only talks but messes around with their equipment, which is just ridiculous) Then maybe they'll actually be scary again.

Same goes for the Cybermen. The more you use an impact villain, the less impact they actually have.

Posted by: Nat Kittyface at April 20, 2010 5:57 PM

Stella, I've had luck with Kickass Torrents, you might try them. So far I've been regularly able to get Saturday night's ep. by Sunday evening.

Nat Kittyface, I totally agree. I want new villains! Or at least new to me, I liked the Sontarans and I looooved the Weeping Angels. But to come back regularly EVERY SEASON for a crushing defeat makes the defeats less exciting, oddly enough.

Posted by: Anne (in Reno) at April 20, 2010 7:03 PM

And Jay, I now have a mental picture of you as the benevolent overseer of all of the Who threads on Pajiba. Possibly in an orange monk's robe.

Posted by: Anne (in Reno) at April 20, 2010 7:10 PM

With the big coutout collar and skullcap too, of course.

But I ain't the only pro.

Posted by: Jay at April 20, 2010 7:21 PM

sciencegeek/coveredinbees, I *spoiler* also thought they were dumb. Seriously? They look like umbrellas.

Also: sciencegeek, you liked Donna? She was by far the worst. Just so annoying! Part of my issue with Amy (other parts include hating her outfits, hating her nail polish, etc) is that she's very Donna-like. Not insofar as competence is concerned, because all the companions have been able to hold their own, but in her manner of smug superiority. "oooh, look at me, I'm traveling around through space and time, haha!" Shut up.

Posted by: esme at April 20, 2010 7:41 PM

If you are looking for ways to watch the show I can offer the following sites. You can't watch there, but they provide links to where you can watch.
wwww.surfthechannel.com
www.sidereel.com

Now to talk about this season. I like the new Doctor quit a bit but his stupid ass bow tie is driving me to distraction. David Sedaris got it right when he claimed that wearing a bow tie sent the message that "I am done with having sex. I will never have sex again." And I completely agree with him. Not that I want to the Doctor to run around snogging everybody but I don't like a sexless vibe either.

Spoiler alert.
As for the new Darleks, oh my gods are they stupid. Someone was clearly inspired by the lollypop ipod commercials. Nat Kittyface, you are spot on. They are great when they do things like steal whole planets, but this penny anti shit has got to go. And how about Amy no remembering her planet getting stolen. That is definitely going to be important as the season plays out.

Posted by: Morgan LaFai at April 20, 2010 8:44 PM

SPOILERS
Oh good, I'm not the only one to hate the new Daleks. I was kinda impressed when the white one rolled out. It looked cool, and a bit of a twist on the traditional 'dark=evil' Daleks. But by the time the last one had rolled out, I was laughing. Not the reaction you're supposed to have, I think. And it's beginning to feel like they're making changes for changes sake. New Doctor, New Tardis, New Companion, New Sonic freaking Screwdriver, and now, New Daleks? Essh!
Anne: Pooping skittles. I'm going to use that.

Natkittyface: Yes, yes, a thousand times yes! The most terrifying episodes have often been the ones with the 'new' enemies, like the angels, or those things in the Library.

esme: I hated Donna in the bride episode, but by Pompeii, I loved her. Rose and Martha were young, inexperienced and in luurrrve with the Doctor, but Donna was older and would have rather eaten her own liver than simpered at him. He'd be all 'I'm a Time Lord, and I'm a genius', and she'd fire back, 'Prove it, space boy.'
I can see why other people found her annoying, but those were the very reasons that I liked her so much. I know people like her, ones who hide their feelings of inadequacy by stomping around extra loud, being inappropriate but never outright cruel. I really enjoyed seeing the Doctor interacting with a companion who didn't worship him, although I think it helped that Tennant and Tate had such great 'bickering siblings' chemistry.

Posted by: ScienceGeek at April 20, 2010 9:39 PM

I think for me the scariest monster was the one in Midnight because we know absolutely nothing about it. Even the DOCTOR knows nothing about it. Even though the last 15 minutes of Midnight turns into really heavyhanded Lord of the Flies "shake the Doctor's faith in humanity by making them all completely unreasonable monsters" allegory, the first 45 are so amazingly tense. What a terrifying monster, and it has no face and no identity other than what it rips from your mind. AMAZING.

I'm in the minority, but I thought the Weeping Angels were a great concept but, again, heavyhanded and cheesy in the execution. Maybe now that Moffat's the showrunner I can expect a slightly more serious treatment, but for me the weeping angels were ruined at the end of Blink with that lights-on-lights-off sequence where every single time the lights came back on, the angels got closer and the music was like "Dun! DUN! DUUUNNNN!!!!!!!!! dundunDUUNNN!!!"

I hope they don't turn into Moffat's Slitheen, either. I was so goddamn sick of the Slitheen and their constant stream of fart jokes. They show up like 6+ times in 3 seasons of Sarah Jane Smith Adventures and I HATE THEM. I hope the Weeping Angels don't end up being a stupid overused gimmick too.

But despite my cranky comments, I am really excited about new Who. I hate Matt Smith's eyebrows and wish someone at the make-up department would pencil them in a bit because eyebrow-less people freak me out (he's not missing them but they are ridiculously sparse), and I'm afraid that Amelia's going to try way too hard to be Doctor Jr., which I think is too precocious and obnoxious, buuuut... I'm still really excited. I just need the Daleks and the Cybermen to TAKE A BREAK for a few seasons.

Posted by: Nat Kittyface at April 20, 2010 10:47 PM

It's clearly fish FINGERS. Damn yanks. This is my first Doctor Who episode ever and I liked it very much, so I'll be giving it a shot if I remember 7:30 Sundays ABC. (Australia)

Posted by: Mit_Huffman at April 20, 2010 10:59 PM

BWeaves, I am totally stealing “Plungee”

It took me half a series to warm to Tennant (I always found his “up” moments a bit cringe-worthy) but I like Matt Smith already so it bodes well. Despite being clearly the youngest and the bow tie GODTHEBOWTIE, he projects the authority required for the role. Combined with Grand Moff’s stewardship, I was glad to see the series is in good hands.

I’m also kinda glad RTD has moved on to greener pastures too. While there is much to be thankful for, he was running on empty. I don’t mind the idea of the Time Lords going wrong as a result of the war, but using them one episode as a pantomime villain plotting to destroy the whole entire space-time continuum YET AGAIN was woefully inadequate. It burned a significant chunk of the DW canon for the sake of tying up a loose end. It would be nice to think future episodes with the new team could explore the idea in a little more depth.

Posted by: Squirrelgripper at April 20, 2010 11:14 PM

I agree that Midnight was the scariest of the episodes because you didn't know anything about the villain and yet it had the ability to steal the Doctor's voice and incapacitate his body. Anything that can do that to the Doctor without ever being seen is pretty impressive.

The other aliens I really liked were the Vashta Nerada from the Library episodes. The Doctor knows the weakness of every alien in the verse and yet his only advice for the Vashta Nerada was to stay out of the shadows and run. If the Doctor doesn't know of a weakness that it not something I want to be around.

Posted by: Morgan LaFai at April 21, 2010 12:37 AM

I also definitely liked the Vashta Nerada, but found it very difficult to FEAR them as it became clear very early on that there was a clear purpose for all of their behavior. So by the end of it, when that clear behavior was revealed, I felt more sorry for them than anything else..

Anyway, for me the worst type of horror is the monster that, for example, sits right beside you and slightly outside your field of vision and you never notice it, and then days later someone says "What happened to that weird guy you were always with?" and you say "What?"

It's that kind of "the monster's right behind you" trope combined with the "there are things I can only see out of the corner of my eye" trope. The human ability to not-quite-see the inhuman. I love that kind of stuff.

Posted by: Nat Kittyface at April 21, 2010 1:09 AM

I loved Amy Pond, but was that just because she is Karen Gillan, or because I love Amy Pond? Whatever, "Basically, run."

I love the Doctor, and Smith is the new one. As for the Doctor-falling-in-love-with-a-companion issue raised above, I contend that that already happened as well. With Rose.

And (spoilers) I loved the spacewhale, even if that episode remained uneven, but I have little to no love for biplanes in space. Or for rainbow genocide.

This WWII episode was no "The Doctor Dances."

And anyone just getting started, start with Eccleston. All of the seasons are grand, but if you're going to go back and catch up at all rather than just run with the new guy, then there is absolutely no reason to skip Eccleston.

Posted by: coryo at April 21, 2010 1:39 AM

I thought this was a decent starter, but I became painfully aware of how weak Moffat is in introducing characters compared to RTD. Also, with the last two episodes, I'm beginning to hate the show's format of one episode for most stories. The pace is so bloody fast, we miss out on so many story details and character developments that would actually make the episodes interesting.

As for the regulars, I haven't disliked any actor playing the Doctor, and Smith is no different. He still seems to be channeling Tennant, but in a less patient and more destructive manner. As for Amy, I can't understand the haters. She's gorgeous and sassy, though I'll admit she's somewhat underdeveloped. We have less of a feel for her character in the first three episodes here than we did for Rose or Martha.

Despite how much I adored his episodes in previous seasons, I'm not sure how I feel about Moffat as head writer yet. I already don't like his characterization, and this signature "crack in time" that presages the great conflict that comes at the end of the series feels so forced. As sick as I was of him by the end, I have to admit, I'm missing RTD.

Posted by: vic at April 21, 2010 3:59 AM

Nat Kittyface, You are in my head...stealing my thoughts. I'm sick to death of the frickin Daleks and Cybermen. 'Ooh we've killed the Daleks, yay...oh wait, where did you come from?' 'We managed to escape through a crack in time.' 'You as well? How many bloody cracks are there?'

All of time and space to play with. Come up with something more interesting. Save the Daleks for series 11 or something, when it might actually be shocking.

Posted by: Carrie (Teabelly) at April 21, 2010 5:02 AM

I'm willing to believe that there's a ridiculously large number of cracks in time because the Time Lords not being there to keep them in check makes everything slowly fall apart, which would be kind of awesome - like everything breaking down after you fire the maintenance man - and play on the Doctor's conceit that he can do the job of his entire race all by himself just by half-assing it. I just don't think the Daleks need to be inside EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM. At this point they're less like a terrifying allegory of the Nazi movement taken to an extreme and more like a really annoying cockroach infestation. "Damn, we just sprayed the crack in time in the kitchen! Turns out there were still some left in the bathroom! Honey, call the exterminator again, would you?"

But I think two ominous cracks shown directly to us is enough. Give us a chance to FORGET about them; that'll make their final reveal more potent at the end as we all go "OH YEAH, THOSE THINGS." Show, Moffat, don't TELL.

I'm willing to believe and justify a lot, just as long as I get enough of what I like.

As for hating on Amy, I don't hate her yet, I just think she was trying too hard to be too sassy in the Dalek episode. It annoys me. I tend to count on a companion to be the one to call the Doctor on his bullshit, a la Donna (who started out obnoxious as hell and evolved into a great lady once she realized she didn't have to grandstand around the Doctor because she didn't have to prove anything to him), but Amy has this unhealthy level of idolizing the Doctor and wanting to be JUST LIKE HIM, which to me is even worse than whinyass Martha who wasted an entire season mooning over him instead of being awesome in her own right. It's not that fun when you have TWO people manically running around plotting and trying to be brilliant and out-brilliant each other. I'd be okay with this as a conscious plot thread presaging a very painful fall from grace for Amy as she realizes that the Doctor is the Doctor and she can only ever be the companion, but until then, I'll just grit my teeth and hope it goes away.

She's adorable and all, I just don't think being cute is enough for a companion. Matt Smith's doing a good job as the Doctor so far, I think. He does channel Tennant a bit, but where Tennant could get really frenetic and full of energy and suck you in that way, Smith has a more earnest sweetness in him that draws you in in its place. Tennant will always be my favorite, but Smith's not bad at all. I like him so far (except his demon eyebrows).

I enjoyed the first episode though, and I totally cried at the whole star whale thing even though it was blatantly emotionally manipulative with the little kids and shit, so the Dalek episode is really the first sour note for me, though I don't really have a problem at all with the single-episode format - more potential new stuff to play with, so if I hate a plot arc, I don't have to wait two episodes for it to be over. I wasn't a huge fan of the weeping angels OR River Song, but I think the weeping angels COULD be good given the right treatment because CONCEPTUALLY they're right up my alley, so uh, we'll see where that takes me I guess.

Although I do have trouble being afraid of them because everyone they affect seems to, um, end up better off than they were before, so er... maybe if they show examples of them actually DESTROYING someone's life rather than taking them back in time to meet their soulmate and have a big happy family and live a long full life, it would be more scary.

Posted by: Nat Kittyface at April 21, 2010 12:16 PM

@Nat Kittyface, I agree completely. I never understood the fear factor of the Weeping Angels, except, well, when they DON'T get you the first time but you wind up rubbing noses with one. That, plus a heart condition, sure, makes sense, otherwise... The Empty Child, now, that's a whole other ballgame. Not a villain, technically, but plays on my deepest fear - zombies. Those things and sewer dwelling piranha get me everytime. What??? You try holding your shit together - literally - when you're 6 and you've just watched a crappy (see what I did here?) movie, your parents are still hours from getting home, you need to go number 2 (because you've already pissed yourself scared at that point, so no need for number 1).
Also, not having yet seen any of the new Doctor episodes, I read the entire recap visualising David Tennant. I'm scared that no matter how good the new kid is, I'll never recover.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jfq5UAk1Bxc - tee-heeee

Posted by: TweeBubblyKlutz at April 22, 2010 10:13 AM

OK, I stopped reading the comments because of all the spoiler alerts - seriously, are we going to have to contend with spoilers in all the recaps?

Nicely done Darth.

I'm down with Matt Smith's demeanor and speech style, but I'm having a really hard time with his head. Dude is hard to look at directly.

Posted by: Cindy at April 24, 2010 9:48 AM

It's interesting to hear how people's reactions are different to these things, personally I rather like the Dalek one but after seeing it a second time I really think the star whale episode is the worst piece of drek to ever call itself
"Doctor Who." The Dalek redesign doesn't bother me because at least they are taller now - the RTD era Daleks were shortened so that Billie Piper could look them in the eye IIRC. My problem with the Daleks is they have been made as powerful as the Time Lords so now you have to destroy them every time or they will destroy the universe. In the old series, they were a longtime enemy of future humans who could hold their own against them militarily. When they occupied Earth guerillas could blow them up with conventional weapons. They were scary because they were evil, not because they were all powerful. Here's hoping the new Daleks can't fly or climb stairs, and focus their efforts on conquering the universe, not on blowing it up.

Posted by: Elwood at April 26, 2010 11:05 AM