web
counter
 

"Boardwalk Empire" -- "Under God’s Power She Flourishes"

By Aggie Maguire | Posted Under TV Reviews | Comments (24)



Boardwalk-Empire-Under-G.jpg

Only once when I was in university did my mother ever attend an event (this was my choice not hers). She came to a cheese and wine thingy and, after scanning the room like a serial killer deciding upon his victims, and making a mental note of all the things she disliked about my friends that she would use against me at a later date, she proceeded to corner a tutor I really looked up to and tell him in a loud voice how summers in Ireland had always been hot and dry until the American moon landing after which weather patterns were changed forever. I was mortified and furious. Still, she didn’t get drunk, go for a quickie with a professor, get me expelled and then rape me, so there’s that to be thankful for. Until this week, I thought of Gillian as a person forced by circumstances to develop into a nasty and vengeful woman. Now I think she’s a sociopath who has no ability to relate to other people’s feelings: it’s all about her own needs. Did she have sex with her own son because she was lonely and needed physical fulfillment? No, it was about control and power, from the faked sexual insult to the rape (and I’m not backing down from the term “rape”): it was all about reacting to the usurping presence of Angela in her son’s life. Spare a thought for little Tommy, readers. He’s going to be raised by this woman.

Jimmy’s way of dealing with the news about Angela is to channel Martin Sheen in Apocalypse Now and cozy up to his booze supply and that heroin sample for three days in Princeton and provide us with enough flash backs to see what drove him into the army. And oh look, they read “The White Devil” in his English lit class, a novel about betrayals and revenge and alliances that keep changing. How prescient. I wonder if the writers just picked it randomly or chose that one for a reason. So then Jimmy returns to Thebes and fulfills the second half of the prophecy by killing Laius and of course it had to happen but I couldn’t believe that they literally staged it like a play. They really thought we wouldn’t get it if it wasn’t framed by curtains with Jimmy sitting on a throne-like chair at the end? Before we leave the classical drama portion of our evening, does anyone know what Harrow picked up out of Angela’s blood on the floor? At first I thought a bullet casing, but then I wondered if it was a piece of bone or something that he’s going to keep as a totem until he gets revenge?

Someone finally remembered that Agent Sebso has been missing for almost a year and Van Alden is now forced to go on the run. Too bad, just as he had come to closure with the wife and was starting to feel warm and fuzzy toward the nanny, truly an oblivious woman, but that is a recipe for a happy life with Van Alden, and I’m sure she would be grateful for all the helpful visual clues if she watched Boardwalk Empire each week. And Margaret is not only continuing her decline into irrationality, she’s proposing to sacrifice Nucky in the process, displaying an incredible degree of ingratitude, even for her when he proposes making over all his assets to her. I ask again, why has Nucky’s lawyer not told him to marry her? Clearly Nucky knows something went down with Sleator, and Margaret for all her new-found piety still can lie when it’s in her interest to do so, but if he was still willing to give her his money, what’s the objection to marriage?

Line of the week: Van Alden: [My parents] don’t enjoy my company. Nanny: How could this be?

Anvil of the week: Jimmy stares out of his Window of Life-Altering Decisions to see carefree Princeton boys drive in one direction while military recruits march past in the other.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Bradley Cooper Confirms Todd Phillips Will Remake 'The Hangover' for a Second Time | The Muppets is Anti-American Propoganda









Comments

I didn't think Harrow picked anything up out of the blood...I think he just touched it. At least I didn't see him take anything.

There was enough drama in this episode without adding incest into the plot. Really? We had to turn the volume up to 11?

Margaret's needed a good ass-kicking for awhile now. Her kid is crippled, and all she can think about is her guilt.

Posted by: Wednesday at December 6, 2011 11:47 AM

The incest was always hinted at.
From the "kissing his winkie" line a few episodes back to the way she just was around him. I didn't think they would come right out and show it, though. I think it worked better as the insidious background tone whenever that crackpot walked into a room.

Posted by: the other courtney at December 6, 2011 11:59 AM

I'm with Wednesday on the whole Harrow thing. I don't think he picked anything up. He just rubbed his fingers in the gross blood slush that was on the ground. And I can't believe that Jimmy actually did his mom. I mean, we know that her relationship with him is creepy and crosses so many boundaries. But I think it would have been better had there just been the strange sexual-like tension there without the actual sex having happened. I, for one, was completely grossed out by that.

Posted by: Lake at December 6, 2011 12:05 PM

And with that Gillian just jumped to the top of "Most loathsome Boardwalk Empire character". I'm sure Van Alden is quite pleased, if he's not busy flogging himself to Leviticus.

As that scene progressed I just kept thinking "Please don't go there, please don't go there..." and then they went there. Accompanied by a train rushing by and the room (world) literally shaking. Because apparently they didn't think we understood the implication to Jimmy and how it fit together with him joining the army.

Heads better be a rolling in the finale, and I'm hoping Gillian is among them. Maybe Manny gets to her, too. He seems to be the only one capable of killing someone on the first try.

Posted by: TylerDFC at December 6, 2011 12:06 PM

You may be right that he didn't pick up anything. I've played it back several times and can't make up my mind. Could be I'm just thinking totem because he seems to place great value on tokens such as his scrap book

Posted by: Aggie Maguire at December 6, 2011 12:16 PM

I have never actively rooted for a character to kill his or her own mother, until now.

Posted by: Quirk at December 6, 2011 12:32 PM

Sebso wasn't missing was he? I think I remember Van Alden smacking a new guy and talking about how Sebso died of a heart attack or something!

And sweet jesus, what'll that man do now that he's on the lam? Anything can happen!

Posted by: MurderBot at December 6, 2011 12:40 PM

I had to leave the room when Gillian and Jimmy 'went there'. I was literally sickened by the whole thing, and by that time begging the BW gods for some puppies and rainbows. To top the whole thing off she proposes to tell Tommy his mommy went away and ABANDONED HIM?? WTF, you vicious monster?? Jimmy better kill that bitch before she ruins his son or I don't know what.

Posted by: sunny at December 6, 2011 1:03 PM

By the by, I did appreciate the whole Shakespearean epic-ness of it all.

Posted by: sunny at December 6, 2011 1:04 PM

worst part for me in the hating gillian club was at the end when little tommy wakes up from a bad dream and asks "wheres mommy?" and gillian replies "im right here"

Posted by: sean at December 6, 2011 1:37 PM

So, now that they got around to noticing that Sebso was murdered, will anyone remember to wonder about that one guy Eli killed? Because I'm pretty sure that's how Eli's testimony is gonna be tossed as well.

Posted by: Angeleno Ewok at December 6, 2011 1:52 PM

Go back to Gillian's introduction in the first season -- when Jimmy brings her that gift that he later has to ask for back. Their interaction was not one of mother-and-son, but one of people who knew each other in a naked fashion.

Posted by: Fredo at December 6, 2011 1:52 PM

This was a doozy of an episode. I felt like I was on heroin while watching it (I wasn't). Terrence Winter sure perfected the dream-ish sequences on the Sopranos and brought it to this ep with a vengeance.

Posted by: Riles at December 6, 2011 1:55 PM

I thought they needed to show the incest scene. It made it clear why Jimmy is such a cynical fuck up. Hinting at it always leaves open the chance that she'd never done more than been creepily clingy around her son.

Gillian broke him that night, got him expelled, ruined his mind. The only thing she said in response was "Nucky will take care of it."

Jimmy's betrayal of Nucky is the hardest thing to watch on the show, at least this episode helped to explain Jimmy's nonsensical approach to life.

Posted by: dunn pernsley at December 6, 2011 1:55 PM

I thought the line of the week was "This is happening."

Posted by: dunn pernsley at December 6, 2011 1:59 PM

In my humble opinion, the Line of the week was delivered by Mickey Doyle: "I don't like the way you loom."

Posted by: Keith at December 6, 2011 2:56 PM

Wincest

Posted by: PG13 at December 6, 2011 3:27 PM

Dude. That was gross.

I've always thought it was Gillian pulling all the strings. Total sociopath and psychopath. I'm thinking Charlie Manson with a woman's touch.... now that is sinister.

And Harrow, he just wanted something for his scrapbook. Poor guy.

Posted by: MRod at December 6, 2011 3:35 PM

I did like "I don't like the way you loom". I considered it strongly but I loved the nanny's oblivious response too much

Posted by: Aggie Maguire at December 6, 2011 3:43 PM

Because apparently I have appointed myself Defender of Hated Female Characters, I did want to step in and say that yes, while Gillian is pretty reprehensible, and has absolutely victimized her son pretty much his entire life, I thought the line about her being the loneliest person in the whole world was pretty spot on, and reminded me that I can spare at least a small amount of sympathy for her. Look at her in the party scene, commanding the attention of everyone around her. And yet, the only person whose love she's every really had is her son's, the very person who she abuses the most. It's goddamn tragic. And it does seem to me that people are awfully quick to forget that Gillian herself was raped as a child by the Commodore. It seems we're missing an important point here about the cycle of abuse. Gillian's past does not excuse her actions, but it does lend her behavior enough context, I think, to where we might question our desire to "kill the bitch." Especially since no one seems to be particularly vocal about the death of serial CHILD rapist, The Commodore.

Posted by: bravesjade at December 6, 2011 4:19 PM

My line of the week was the way Capone called Doyle a mope. Something in the way he said it made me crack up.

Posted by: schrome at December 6, 2011 6:13 PM

Rape is the right word for what Gillian did to Jimmy. It doesn't matter that Jimmy eventually gave in. She is the parent, and she is responsible. Unfortunately, I'm sure some people will say Jimmy was complicit in the act but he wasn't. No child is. And yes at 18 or 19 Jimmy was still the child. Mackenzie Phillips intitially said she had a consensual sexual relationship with her father until she was informed that a child can never really consent to having relations with a parent. The sheer psycholgical weight of the parent's influence and control makes that impossible.

Posted by: Mia at December 6, 2011 6:38 PM

This episode was a mess. Despite a few missteps, I thought this season was fairly strong. Why, oh why spend the penultimate episode on flashbacks? With the exception of the death of the Commodore (who I'm not sad to see go), Jimmy's story could have been served elsewhere.

I also agree that the incest angle was too damn much. I was okay (relatively speaking) with the general creepiness of their relationship. No need to crank the dial up to full blown Greek horror show. "The son has sex with the mother, then - here's the kicker - then he offs the father. Deep, right?!?"

Ugh. No one has ever accused this show of being subtle, but really, no need to make me actually physically vomit.

What the writers have done to Margaret is a crime.

Posted by: Kala at December 8, 2011 1:33 AM

Am I alone, or does anyone else feel like Mickey Doyle is the most sympathetic character left on the show?

Posted by: Baboocole at December 8, 2011 2:25 PM