blogspot
visitor
Avatar: The Last Airbender Review | Pajiba - Scathing Reviews for Bitchy People

avatardad.jpg
The Best Show You Didn’t See

“Avatar: The Last Airbender” / Phillip Stephens

TV Reviews | December 3, 2008 | Comments (66)


In July of this year an awesome, short-lived TV show cascaded into a glorious finale. And it’s sad, not because this underrated gem had to end, but because that end was overlooked by most of Pajiba-land. And it’s such a shame, too, because I’m going to argue that “Avatar: The Last Airbender” is not only the best animated series of the last decade, but one of the best shows ever produced.

This might seem like dubious praise coming from a critic who readily admits to hating almost every television serial on the air. My dislike of TV extends beyond any specific gamut of shows past or present — the format itself seems to result in a fragmented narrative. Televised programs are often, by the nature of their production and broadcast, hampered as devices for storytelling. Shows rarely begin with a clear, totalizing arc — a beginning, exposition, and definitive conclusion; often they are half-formed ideas which take time to cohere or, due to popularity and/or a lack of overarching plot, they meander in the open-ended fashion of certain comic books or soap operas, the story merely functioning to perpetuate itself until someone in the process gets tired and pulls the plug. I’m not saying there aren’t exceptions, or even that shows can’t flourish in this vein, but I’ve always found this format to cause lower-quality narratives which teeter between good and weak episodes while having their overall life cut short or overextended by fickle consumerist demands. Many animes actually have a leg up in this regard.

In “Avatar” I found all the coherence, completeness, and symmetry of a good, closed-circuit narrative wrapped in the youthful vibrancy of a children’s cartoon. I don’t know if the creators were just insanely brilliant in their execution or if the fates aligned in all the right ways during production, but the writing in “Avatar” approaches perfection, at least in terms of an arc — the story begins, gathers momentum, expands, deepens, and then crests as if every second were already mapped. Not one of the series’ 61 episodes is wasted or used as filler; at no point does the show’s objective veer. Every season crescendos; every episode is measured; every sub-plot bears eventual fruit. If this sounds mechanical, it isn’t — rather, everyone behind the series understood the importance of purpose and direction. Even better, when that objective was achieved, the story ended (at the height of its popularity, no less). Good stories have to end in order to really be stories at all … it’s funny how often this is forgotten. We tend to crave more from settings and characters we love, to see the same emotional cycles and relationships play out again and again to our loving familiarity. But in order to deeply, honestly satisfy, a story needs to end.

The world in “Avatar” is a symbolic fantasy realm where humans co-exist with bizarre creatures and spirits. Human civilization is divided into four cultures corresponding to one of the four elements and seasons (Earth/Spring, Fire/Summer, Air/Autumn, and Water/Winter). In addition to taking their dominant cultural motif from a respective element, each culture possesses individuals who are able to “bend” or kinetically manipulate that element. The four nations live in nominal harmony. Every generation, one individual is born who can manipulate all four elements — the avatar, the most powerful bender in the world, who is reincarnated in a cycle among the nations and acts as a planetary guardian and a buffer between the spirit and material worlds. A century before the events of the show, the avaricious ruler of the Fire Nation launched an imperialistic war against the other nations under the guise of “sharing prosperity,” throwing the world into a hell of strife and imbalance. The present avatar dies early in the conflict, passing the torch to Aang (voice of Zach Eisen), a young Air Nomad. Years later, when Aang learns his identity and destiny, he flees, and a storm leaves him suspended in a block of ice near the South Pole. A hundred years pass, in which the Fire Nation’s war ravages the planet, completely eliminating the Air Nomads and all but a few remaining strongholds in the Water Tribe and Earth Kingdom.

“Avatar” begins when two siblings of the dwindling Southern Water Tribe, Katara (Mae Whitman) and Sokka (Jack DeSena), discover Aang and his Sky Bison trapped in the iceberg. Aang learns of the century-long world war which eliminated his people, leaving him the last remaining airbender. After some hesitation, he accepts his destiny to master all four elements and confront Ozai, the new Fire Lord, who is hell-bent on completing his grandfather’s conquest of the planet. As Aang, accompanied by Sokka and Katara, sets off to master the remaining elements and somehow end the war, they’re pursued by Zuko, Ozai’s son and the crown prince of the Fire Nation. Zuko (voiced by Dante Basco…Rufio!) emerges as a complex villain. Years earlier his father scorched half of his face off and banished him simply for speaking out of turn, events which are a constant source of both drive and shame for him throughout the series. Zuko relentlessly pursues Aang, hoping that by capturing the avatar he will regain his lost honor and the respect of his father. Zuko’s scarred face represents the internal turmoil of both his character and his heritage, which produced both the power-hungry imperialists who began the war and the true, honorable characteristics of a balanced Fire Nation. The latter is represented by Zuko’s uncle, Iroh (voice of Mako and Greg Bear), who serves as his mentor and guardian for much of the series. Iroh is a fat, jolly, and rather silly old man, an appearance which belies his actual sagacity and abilities as a warrior. Zuko, though nominally Aang’s nemesis for most of the show, turns out to be the most compelling character of the story, the one who undergoes the most dramatic changes as he realizes in what ways his destiny is tied to the avatar’s.

Each of the show’s three seasons, which consist neatly of twenty half-hour episodes, corresponds to the seasonal time, location, and element that Aang has to master - water, earth, and fire, respectively, before confronting the Fire Lord. Larger forces come to bear, while smaller characters and villains come and go, but each season stays true to its focus, and the entire series drives on to that final confrontation. The characters and their relationships ultimately become paramount - Aang in particular achieves a kind of perfection of balanced qualities, possessing the uncanny power and wisdom inherent to his station while maintaining the inexperience and fun-loving immaturity of his 12-years of age.

I particularly enjoyed the real-life inspirations which so obviously influenced the writers and artists behind “Avatar.” Much of the show obviously takes its cue from Eastern cultures and philosophy, particularly Sinic. Each elemental culture corresponds to a real, historic counterpart of Chinese, Tibetan, or Inuit traditions, and a few others, I’m sure. Most of the philosophical underpinnings of the show come directly from Buddhism, Taoism, and Yoga. For a host of decidedly American writers and producers to show this kind of reverence for Eastern civilization was gutsy; more importantly, it results in an ingenuous tone and setting both fantastical and vaguely familiar. But best of all are the action sequences — each method of elemental bending is represented by a real martial art, meaning that the already fluidly-animated fight scenes look realistic even as the characters hurl boulders, fireballs, and gusts of air or water at one another. Badass.

And really, balance was the key. “Avatar: The Last Airbender” strikes all the right balances — between humor and seriousness, entertainment and wisdom, spectacle and content. This is a show that kids should gobble up since, like many superhero capers, it casts adolescent angst, glee, and romance across supernatural theatrics. Adults shouldn’t be alienated since the youthful vibrancy always remains rooted in a deep, intricate story and impressive, underpinning morality, resulting in an end product as appealing as Harry Potter (and probably just as good!). The episodes range from heartrending (“Appa’s Lost Days”) to hilariously full-blown parody (“The Ember Island Players”). The show frequently utilizes juvenile humor, but never in a way that ultimately subverts the seriousness of the narrative — unlike, say, Joss Whedon, who positively bathes in self-amused irony. And the four-part finale is every bit as momentous as it should be, leaving the viewer with nothing short of full, satisfying closure.

I hate to finish by gushing, but so be it. Almost no other TV show has gotten me this excited, has engaged me visually, emotionally, and mentally at the same time, appealing both to my need to feel challenged and my instinct for youthful immediacy. These kinds of shows shouldn’t be that hard to come by, but unlike “Avatar: The Last Airbender” they rarely strike the balance so well, or so effortlessly. I wish I could convey just how accessible and sad and funny and exciting this show is, and how infinitesimal the outer labels of “children’s show” or “cartoon” seem after fully immersing yourself in the story. And I hate to end with a dumbass platitude, “You just have to see it for yourself.” But you do. You really, really do.


Phillip Stephens is the lead critic and book editor for Pajiba. He lives in Fayetteville, Arkansas and wastes his twenties in grad school(s).


Republican Celebrities | Britney Spears Circus Review





Comments

According to the Lizardspawn, and they would know, "That show is gay. They have violence, but no one ever dies." And I don't think they meant the good, two guys fucking each other in the ass "gay".

Posted by: Lizardqueen at December 3, 2008 2:36 PM

It is damn annoying that I can only get the last season of Avatar as a region 1 import where I am (UK) the first two I got off itunes (they were selling them cheaper than amazon) but I can't get season three that way, despite the fact it's availible from the US itunes site. Not fair :(

Posted by: cockroach at December 3, 2008 2:36 PM

YES! Thank you! I was starting to feel like the only person who'd a) seen this, and b)loved it. My face HURT from laughing all the time. And you summed it up perfectly! I hope people will check it out, it's just too good to miss.

Posted by: Lauren at December 3, 2008 2:40 PM

You fucking bastards.

YOU FUCKING BASTARDS.

You have no idea how hard it is for me to not lose my geeky little mind over this. And I haven't even read it yet.

I love it so much I hate you for talking about it and reminding me it is gone.

Fuck you all sideways with a velvet road paver.

Now I will read this.

Posted by: Vermillion at December 3, 2008 2:40 PM

Loves, loves, LOVES me some Avatar. I happened across it while channel-surfing a couple of years ago, and was hooked after a four episode marathon. Why didn't they have awesome shows like this when I was the target age demographic?

Posted by: kstar at December 3, 2008 2:40 PM

I forgot to add that Toph if one of the fucking BEST female characters ever created.

"I AM MELON LORD!"

Posted by: Lauren at December 3, 2008 2:44 PM

If I had a band I'd name it Velvet Road Paver.

Posted by: bucdaddy at December 3, 2008 2:45 PM

FINALLY! I'm a long time Pajiba lurker but I'm coming out of the shadows for a moment or two to say that It's great to see someone giving this show the praise it deserves. This show is one of the reasons that I'm pursuing a career in animation.

Posted by: Toby at December 3, 2008 2:46 PM

Oh wait ... that's the name of one of the Palin kids. Never mind.

Posted by: bucdaddy at December 3, 2008 2:47 PM

I should also add that I met the creators of Avatar last year and they were every bit as brilliant, funny, and intelligent as you'd expect.

Posted by: Toby at December 3, 2008 2:52 PM

My sister likes this one and tried to get me to watch an episode of it. It was cute and all but I got bored and then weirded out.

Posted by: NotBlonde at December 3, 2008 2:53 PM

I have it all on DVD. I am awesome.

Posted by: Snath at December 3, 2008 3:04 PM

this show actually ended early. it was originally planned to have several more seasons. so your idea of it reaching its goal and ending is a little off, just like my bowels.

Posted by: EricD at December 3, 2008 3:04 PM

YAY! I am not alone!

My husband and I ran across an episode of this a couple of years ago and were completely taken in. We bought the Season 1 DVDs and our daughters both loved them, even though they don't agree on much these days (one is 5, the other 12). It was agonizing to wait for the end of Season 3 to finally air, even though I knew it meant the show would be over. It is such a wonderful, rich, beautiful show. I second the Toph love, but I have to say Uncle Iroh is my favorite character - maybe ever. The overarching themes of balance and coexistence are so beautifully played out. Until you have kids, you don't really realize how much complete crap out there is marketed to children - it's a rare and beautiful thing to find a show like this, that the kids love, and that I love, and that I really am glad they watch, because it's such a strong, positive story.

Posted by: Edith at December 3, 2008 3:12 PM

I was very impressed with the idea that the fighting style should match the elemental influence. It can't even be explained sufficiently with words.

Also, the cabbage cart guy in every episode was a nice shtick.

Posted by: ShannonAnn at December 3, 2008 3:19 PM

Ok ok ok ok, fine, I've been dutifully avoiding it in favor of trying to get some actual work done in this here life of mine but FINE, I'll put it on the list.

Happy now?

Posted by: twig at December 3, 2008 3:20 PM

My cousin used to date Michael Dante DiMartino, one of the co-creators of this show. I met him a few times; good guy. I always felt guilty I never got around to seeing the show.

Posted by: Todd at December 3, 2008 3:38 PM


Let me just add to the praise. Excellent show, engaging, funny, thought-provoking. And a great ending.

Posted by: Drake at December 3, 2008 4:08 PM

If you're not sure you'd like Avatar, try http://www.theavatarportal.org/ Every episode is online.

But you've got to buy it. The online episode quality is not good, and actually pretty distracting. So try the first few, love it, then buy (or Netflix) it.

Posted by: epimethea at December 3, 2008 4:10 PM

Hells yeah. This series is incredible - made me laugh out loud, tear up, breathlessly await the next episode...(in particular, I COULD NOT STAND not knowing what happened to Appa during season 2). This is not just a damned good animated series, it's simply damned good TV. Period.

Posted by: Kowala1000 at December 3, 2008 4:36 PM

Having never heard of this show before, I thought an "airbender" was a fart.

Airbender: In My Pants

Posted by: BWeaves at December 3, 2008 4:43 PM

Our kids got us into the show, but I think the adults appreciated it even more. Definitely a keeper. I even used my kid as an excuse to get a stuffed Appa.

Posted by: lorent at December 3, 2008 4:45 PM

I'm jealous of those of you who have met people responsible for this show. Avatar is nothing but genius. It's meant for kids, but many adult programs are less complex in their portrayal of good and evil. Like, almost all adult programs. The different fighting styles in the show were the best part. And all the strong lady characters. Not to mention all the father-son stuff. And the guys who lived in the trees and traveled via grappling hooks were supposed to be American, right?

Posted by: phquaryn at December 3, 2008 4:53 PM

Yes, this show was awesome. I'm excited about a movie being made, but freaking Shyamalan better not mess it up. He isn't exactly known for humor and humor it has lots of. It's dang near Animaniacs wrapped up in Dragonball Z. In short, loved it and hopeful.

Posted by: Kizer at December 3, 2008 4:57 PM

I've never commented on this site before, but I am a frequent visitor, and I have to say I whooped out loud at work when I saw this up on you page. I am such an HUGE nerd for this show, and never thought it would get an honorable mention on this site.

I have to agree with you, the finale was fantastic. The showdown with Azula? Brought tears to my eyes. For realz.

I disagree with you on filler episodes, however. There's a couple silly ones in there, but considering its a kid's show thats to be expected.


OH! The reason the show's arcs were so well planned out was because it was originally pitched as a three season show, and pretty much had a general completed plot from the beginning.

Nickelodeon showed an interest in continuing on with more seasons, but the creators wanted to keep the integrity of their original idea intact so they refused. Nick might go on with a spinoff series, but it would take place with different characters at a different time.

Posted by: Jackie at December 3, 2008 5:03 PM

Also, Momo is awesomely spectacular. I want him as a pet.

Posted by: Kizer at December 3, 2008 5:09 PM

Meh. I'm a cartoon addict, but this, like most American serialized cartoons, never tripped my trigger.

I prefer the little unrelated shorts that are heavy on the surrealism, a la Flapjack or Superjail. No annoying backstory to try and remember, and if I miss an spisode, no big deal.

That, and the animation of Avatar is not my taste--it's too sanitized. I love me some animae (which this, technically, is not) but this smoothed-out animae inspired style didn't do it for me.

Posted by: frumpiefox at December 3, 2008 5:18 PM

Avatar is very good. I haven't watched the entire thing, but the select few eps I've caught were quite likeable.

But come on. I don't see why everyone's salivating over this one American produced HQ cartoon when there is so much anime out there that of equal / higher quality. You just have to search harder.

Do you guys just like this cartoon because you don't have read subtitles or put up bad dubbing? I have a hunch one of avatars's strengths over japanime is that being American produced, the lipsynch is perfect. Other than that, a cartoon of this calibre would be nothing more than above average in Japan ...

Posted by: Lydia at December 3, 2008 6:14 PM

I have watched the show from the beginning and caught the last season again on one of the Nickelodeon channels this past weekend. If you have a chance to watch this please do. I will miss this show. I hope the move doesn't suck too badly.

Posted by: greer at December 3, 2008 6:27 PM

Lidia, their is good anime, but most anime, just like most T.V., is either mediocre or terrible, and many lack universal appeal. Avatar both deserves to be seen as one of the best cartoons from any country ever, including anime, (I prefer manga), and as one of the best T.V. shows ever.

I loved it, I've seen the whole thing, it was great. And it's criminal how hard it is to find shows with greatness, and universal appeal regardless or age or general interests.

Posted by: George at December 3, 2008 6:35 PM

Lydia, I've seen the best and the worst "japanime" out there, and I loved Avatar for what it was, not what it wasn't. I think they chose to use Japanese style and character design instead of North American because it worked best for the content/message of the series. And I can't blame them for wanting to pick up audiences used to/enamored with anime. I probably wouldn't have checked it out if I hadn't thought it was anime in the first place. But the lipsynch definitely wasn't what kept me interested. Avatar is no Bebop, but it's fun, smart, and engaging. Plus, I'll reiterate: Toph is rad.

Posted by: Lauren at December 3, 2008 6:45 PM

Wait! What? This July's episode was the finale for Avatar the Last Airbender?! Say it isn't so. I mean, sure the Fire Lord was defeated but the finale was a bit cliff-hangery concerning the whereabouts of Zuko's mom and I was sure there would be more episodes in the future. Oh, my kids are going to be so disappointed. Okay, okay, I'll admit it: I am so disappointed. Avatar was the best cartoon series of the past three years and deserved much more publicity and support than it was offered from Nickelodeon.

Posted by: shiningstar at December 3, 2008 7:00 PM

Love this show. LOVE this show. As a one-time anime geek (an obsession which has, thankfully, dwindled to a healthy love of animation since my teens), one of the most impressive parts was the creators' ability to employ anime tropes without utterly bastardizing the form. No other American animators have been able to pull off such a brilliant tribute. Their reverence for Miyazaki, in particular, is always apparent.

On a side note, I only managed to catch Arrested Development after watching the first season of Avatar. I was quite shocked to see Mae Whitman (Katara) as George Michael's unremarkable little girlfriend. If a connection to our oh-so-beloved short-lived sitcom can help stir Pajiban interest in this incredible show, well, there you have it.

Posted by: gatesong at December 3, 2008 8:01 PM

Avatar: The Last Airbender.

Posted by: Lucas at December 3, 2008 8:02 PM

I fucking love Avatar. Thanks for this review.

Posted by: TL at December 3, 2008 8:09 PM

I've seen enough episodes of it to know that it's a tight little well-plotted show...but nothing to sit and watch marathons of. Jeez.

I watch quite a few kids' shows, having a kid and all, and I've seen a whole bunch of crap. This doesn't fall into the "Zoey 101" category of Complete Suck. But really, one of the best shows on TV?

No, I'm afraid not. OK in the background and except for that stupid flying muppet-beast, not annoying.

Posted by: Wednesday at December 3, 2008 8:19 PM

Your review perfectly described my feelings towards this amazing show. My little brother and I have been dedicated to the show since its inception. Everyone of the characters (I second the Toph love, though) is so interesting, the animation is gorgeous and vibrant, and every episode succeeds.

Aw, I'm upset now.

Like Mr. Stevens said, each season is corresponds to an element that Aang has to master, and it's so engaging to watch all of the characters grow, so I recommend watching from the first season.

Posted by: KP at December 3, 2008 8:22 PM

I did the Dance of Joy when I saw this on the home page! Avatar is brilliant, and it's so refreshing to see child characters treated as complex, whole people, especially in a cartoon.

To the folks who are wanking on about anime: get over yourselves. This show is awesome. In Oz the free-to-air channels are only half-way through season 2, but I snaffled them off Amazon as soon as they became available on DVD. Well worth the kidney I sold to pay for postage.

Posted by: YeahButNoBut at December 3, 2008 8:37 PM

I loved this show so much. I was lucky enough to miss all three seasons, so I got to watch each season as a marathon just after it had ended. There is no better way to watch a great show.

Still, were it up to me I would've made it a 4 season show, and put an air season between earth and fire, possibly with Aang reestablishing the air nomad civilisation. Still, great show, I particularly loved Zukoh's arc over the whole series, and I have to [whatever number we're up to now]th the Toph love.

Posted by: Chugga at December 3, 2008 9:42 PM

Ugh, is it weird to admit I watched nearly every episode in a marathon last weekend? Does it make it worse that I had seen nearly all of them before?
From humorous to hitting the heartstrings, this show covered the whole spectrum.

Posted by: dk at December 3, 2008 9:47 PM

YES! I am so glad there are so many people here who've seen this and enjoyed it and that it got the review it deserved. I mentioned it in the diversion about cartoons and got no love (granted, I put season 2 of it up there with seasons of The Wire). I'm not at all against people who would claim this is the best show ever, as a friend of mine just said upon seeing this review, because it overachieves so far beyond its genre. But God Damn, I love this show. I watched all three seasons in 2 weeks. I wish so much there was more. I too am excited/concerned about the movie prospect.

Posted by: birj at December 3, 2008 11:23 PM

Absolutely astounding and spot on. People give me strange looks when I tell them that Avatar, The Last Airbender was probably one of the single best shows on television EVER. Although - and this is quite embarassing - every time I also lend out my DVD collections and force another friend to watch the show (I'm up to over 20 people now!) I have to apologize for the first couple of episodes in advance. Seriously, the very beginning with the large-eyed girl telling Aang, "No, don't go!" is just cringe worthy, but thankfully everything from then on out is sheer perfection.

I'll be showing some of the Nick and ex-Nick guys this review for sure ;)

Posted by: Morri at December 3, 2008 11:49 PM

Can we get a little love for Wang Fire?

Posted by: Rummy at December 4, 2008 1:11 AM

EricD "this show actually ended early. it was originally planned to have several more seasons."

No. In the very first season they established that Aang had to fight the Fire Lord by summer's end, and that was in winter. Each season tv was one uh, season, so how much longer could it have been?

Posted by: fish eye no miko at December 4, 2008 1:44 AM

Why do you guys always put up a feature on a show/forgotten movie/band/etc. within a week after me wondering how the Pajibanites feel about it? Eerie...

I'm all for it, btw. Especially Sokka.

Posted by: Adere at December 4, 2008 2:31 AM

OK. Avatar was awesome. But isn't this the fate of all the really groundbreaking, awesome, challenging, entertaining vs. merely narcotizing shows? Run of the mill makes the numbers because the proles have been trained how to repond. Make them think they're engaging and they'll love you. Actually engage them and they'll hate you. (With apologies to Voltaire.)

I mean, come on. Lost lost it's mind a while back, although it still intrigues. Heroes lost its mind pretty much immediately. Even BSG for all the fandom echo-chamber noise still has a tiny audience. Indeed it asks profound questions, well done for something on TV, and yet it won't change the culture, provoke a debate, educate or etc. because it simply won't reach people. Even BSG simply isn't as cultural impact-y or dollar-wise all that as the next season of Jackass.

We thought when there were more channels, that quality in niches would get some traction. Then along came cable, and we learned that there were in stead, infinitely many lowest common denominators. 500 channels and rather than broadcast the regional theater doing Checkov, we have the home shopping channel. Then along came the interwebs and with 5 million channels it's still, well, just bad. 90% of everything is crap, we can just get at all of it now.

So, yes, wonderful, divine show. Layers and layers of awesome. And *of course* it was canceled and obscure, these things going together. I'll add it to the list of affronts . . .

UFO (Dammit.)
Max Headroom (Dammit.)
Blakes 7 (Dammit.)
The Twilight Zone (Dammit.)
Firefly (Dammit.)
etc.

Voltaire / Swift '12
At least the fireside chats will be literate.

Posted by: BierceAmbrose at December 4, 2008 3:27 AM

George & Lauren: I can see your points. Good art is good art. I welcome good art with arms wide open.

I guess I haven't watched enough to make a fair call on just how unique Avatar is. It just didn't really strike me as anything remarkably groundbreaking/different. I retract what I said. I support shows and writers who'll intellectually credit their audience (children and alike, but children especially). I certainly don't mean to bring down a good piece of work.

In turn, I will be torrenting this as soon as I'm motivated to watch something.

YeahButNoBut: I'm sorry I came off wanking about anime a fair bit. I'm also from oz, and am grateful that ABC2 is giving kids an option to experience this treasure.

Posted by: Lydia at December 4, 2008 5:15 AM

I, too, must chime in simply to say that I LOVE this show. Followed it from the beginning, but I felt jerked around by trying to keep up after the second/third season (so many repeats Nickelodeon!) so I do have to catch up

but it is awesome and my favorite part may have been the well written universe they created for these stories to exist in. like for example the bayou/swamp waterbenders who were 'cousins' to the Katara and Sokka's tribe or the sand benders who were offshoots of the earthbenders.

so much intricacy and..okay you guys have pretty much said it all by now.

Toph, Uncle Iroh, King Bumi, and the badass earthbender gestapo were my favorites

Posted by: VinKong at December 4, 2008 8:00 AM

I did want to add that while the story arcs are beautifully constructed, and while it was clearly conceived to be a 3-season story, I felt like the Iroh/White Lotus story was given short shrift in Season 3, almost certainly because of Mako's death. It was so intriguing and they laid so many clues to it in Season 1 and Season 2, and it's the only storyline that I didn't feel was fully realized in S3. That may be have been intentional - like the fate of Zuko's mother, not everything ties up neatly, Still, I want to know about Iroh's journey in the spirit realm, and why he was able to SEE Aang and the dragon when their spirits flew by in Winter Solstice Part 1! Damnit, now I'm all sad that it's gone. Aside from more Iroh/White Lotus backstory, I really want to know, what, EXACTLY, did Zuko's mom do that fateful night? And I would have loved to see just a little Toph/King Bumi interaction, because those two characters would have so much fun together...

Oh, and I'll second the Sokka love, too. WANG FIRE! It was awesome that he was NOT a bender, but was so integral to their team. He made a great Xander, which every super-hero story needs. Comic relief - but not useless comic relief - an everyman who is as important to their success as any of the more physically powerful characters .

Posted by: Edith at December 4, 2008 9:33 AM

Just bringing more of the Avatar love here. Personally my favourite episode ever was "The Beach," where Zuko, Azula, Mai and Ty Lee became like an evil asskicking Breakfast Club. First time I realized that Azula wasn't really evil: just fecking crazy.

Also, what is it with Mark Hamill and doing the voices of cartoon villains? The Joker, the Skeleton King from SRMTHFGO!, Fire Lord Ozai...

Posted by: Aislinn at December 4, 2008 9:40 AM

I don't necessarily think the show was meant for kids anymore than, say FLCL, Dennou Coil, Cowboy Bebop, GTO or any of the other really excellent anime out there has been specifically kid-focused(that's not to say that I think it was designed not for kids to watch it either though). I think the creators of this show were attempting to, basically, do a high quality U.S. animated show designed to tell a compelling story authentically to any kind of viewer. The only reason it gets labeled as kid-focused, in my view, is because of the network that carried it and the fact that, in the U.S., all animated products are considered kiddy.

As to the Mark Hamill question; two words, Type Casting. The poor bastard really couldn't get any serious live acting work after Star Wars, but animators, having loved his work in those movies, jumped at hiring him for voice work. And lets be honest, he's damn good at it too.

Posted by: Julian at December 4, 2008 10:38 AM

BierceAmbrose: I don't know how much the viewing public deserves the blame for these cancellations compared to the executives of these companies. It is true that many truly innovative and thought provoking shows get middle of the road ratings, but so do most sitcoms, and the typical run for one of those is five years. Many times, such shows get bounced around from time slot to time slot as executives or regional carriers attempt to kill the show by driving off its fanbase, and very few shows, Babylon-5 being a good example, are good enough to carry a significant part of their 9:00 audience with them to 10 or 11 when they get bounced.

Network executives consider quirky shows which don't fit into their idea of what works chancy, and they sometimes go to absurd lengths in killing those shows so they can justify what amounts to artistic snobbery. I would say that the opinions executives hold of how the public thinks plays a larger role in many of these cancellations than the actual viewing habits of the public.

Posted by: Julian at December 4, 2008 10:50 AM

Love Avatar and love the love you have for it!

A truly amazing show for all the reasons you said and while I'm sad to see it end, I'm relieved that it never got neutered by being canceled early.

I

Posted by: Lola at December 4, 2008 1:39 PM

MY DAY IS MADE!!!!!

This show was gorgeous, and put back together the heart rent in two by Samurai Jack's petering out of existance with a whimper.

BTW, Azula? Anyone with a teenage sister will find great comfort in her portrayal. Not to mention, her sweet-talking is the best I've ever heard.

Captain: Princess, I'm afraid the tides won't allow us to bring the ship into port before nightfall.

Azula: I'm sorry, Captain, but I do not know much about the tides. Can you explain something to me?

Captain: Of course.

Azula: Do the tides command this ship?

Captain: I'm afraid I don't understand.

Azula: You said "the tides would not allow us to bring the ship in." Do the tides command this ship?

Captain: No, Princess.

Azula: And if I were to have you thrown overboard, would the tides think twice about having you smashed against the rocky shore?

Captain: No, Princess.

Azula: Well, then, maybe you should worry less about the tides, who've already made up their mind about killing you, and worry more about me, who's still mulling it over...

Posted by: Sweetie Dahling at December 4, 2008 2:10 PM

It's funny, but when this show first aired I was just on the very edge of the age group(s) it was directed at (15, with the range being 6-15) and I thought it was the DUMBEST thing EVER. The "Japanime" look, the terrible dialog, the fart jokes; I watched three episodes and then abandoned it with conviction. With all the praise it's gotten since it ended though, I may give it another chance and grit my teeth through the stupidity. I just wish it were a bit more violent. My god, if you're going to fight with a razor-sharp boomerang (... Yeah.) there should be at least ONE decapitation. ONE!

Posted by: Tintin at December 4, 2008 9:05 PM

Cheers, Lydia, I didn't mean to get stroppy about it!

Heh heh...

"Pants are an illusion, and so is death."

Posted by: YeahButNoBut at December 4, 2008 9:18 PM

My cabbages!

Posted by: Tina at December 5, 2008 1:35 AM

Phillip, I'm so glad you write for this site. At least there's ONE reviewer here that likes anime and isn't afraid to say it. Unlike Dustin "I didn't 'get' Miyazaki" Rowles. Jeez. How the fuck is that even possible?! There's somethin' wrong with that boy.

That said, I'll be seeing if I can check this out one of these days. Thanks again.

Posted by: vic at December 5, 2008 1:54 AM

My 65 y/o mother got me hooked on this. She loathes most animation, but somehow stayed with Avatar long enough to fall deeply, deeply into its universe. I think I watched because Appa is big! And furry! And flies!

I think to appreciate the arc and plot and drive of the series, you have to watch more than a few episodes. The way it comes together, creates more than the sum of parts, is just deeply satisfying.

Katara (with all the love in the world) is kind of a tramp, though.

Posted by: fanny at December 5, 2008 2:39 AM

How Joss Whedon's irony "subverts the seriousness of the narrative" is totally beyond me. Claiming that demonstrates an extraordinary lack of understanding of the structure and style of Whedon's work. Phillip, I usually love your reviews, but that line made me take everything else in this piece a whole lot less seriously (how's that for some subversion?)

Posted by: Zack at December 5, 2008 3:04 AM

I adore this show. (Any teeny problems I ever had with it were easily covered by the fact that it was made for seven-year-olds. I wish some cartoons had respected my intelligence all those decades ago when I WAS seven. I can live with the occasional fart joke -- they let Sokka get reasonable, realistic play! You all know quite well what he set up that tent for, don't deny it.)

DRAGON DANCE.

(Excuse me. That just came out.)

Please note, however, that it was NOT canceled -- it had, from the start, a planned three-season arc and came to an organic end, rather than a sad petering-out (with sequels in the works, although probably not a full series). More shows should try it, actually.

Posted by: Mac at December 5, 2008 10:39 AM

GUH! Seeing this on Pajiba makes me so happy. I only got into Avatar this year and I was astounded by its narrative complexity, its Eastern influences and its sheer intelligence. Without a doubt, it's not only one of the best kids' cartoons ever made but one of the best shows ever, period.

Posted by: Victoria at December 13, 2008 7:58 PM

@tintin:

Avatar didn't have any 'fart jokes'. What show were YOU watching? Only thing close to 'fart jokes' was Toph. She spat, picked her nose, and scratched her butt because she was a 12 year old tom-boy who could level buildings and form metallic suits of armor out of bulkhead doors. Her shtick wasn't for laughs, she just didn't give a crap about manners*.

*even though she was 'well-finished' heiress.

Posted by: lolwut at December 17, 2008 3:04 AM

this show should have been called " Avatar:The Last Good Show On Nickelodeon"

Posted by: noname123 at December 17, 2008 7:23 PM

this show is truly one to remember(and not as a crappy one)

Posted by: noname123 at December 17, 2008 7:26 PM

I have all three seasons on DVD! Hell yeah; anyone who actually buys the merch and supports the show (rather than being a cheapass and watching it online) is the standard of a true fan.

I swear I'm going to keep my DVDs in mint-condish until I have kids of my own to share them with.

And then I'll start it all over when my kids have kids.

It's just such an incredible series with an amazing and intricate story arc. Just by reading these comments, it's obvious that the series appeals to quite a huge audience, despite it targeted demographic. It spans generations; definitely future ones, as well.

OH SHIT. ALMOST FORGOT.

THE MUSIC.

THE MUSIC IS EFFING EPIC.

Mad props to the Track Team.

Posted by: PickyNip at March 4, 2009 7:30 AM





Video ads popping up after each page view? Try clearing your browser's cookies.