web
counter
 

The Only Way This Could Be Worse Is if Eliza Dushku Starred and It Aired on Lifetime: Buffy's "Ringer" Trailer

By Cindy Davis | Posted Under Trailers | Comments (39)



sarah-michelle-gellar-.jpg

The one show I watch on the CW is “America’s Next Top Model” and I would never admit that in public. Well, what I mean is, I only watch it to make fun of Tyra and the whole idea that anyone who wins her show will be a model anywhere near the top. Ever heard of any of them? Exactly. But, guilty pleasure that it is, there are always a bunch of crazy girls who think they’re the shit, someone with a sob story about a broken home and another one crying about how her life will be nothing if she can’t be a top model. There’s a whole lot of “fierce” posing and arguing while “smizing,” as J-1 and J-2 mock and berate the contestants (both behind their backs and to their faces.) Tyra wears bad clothes, strange hair and speaks in her best affected voice as she declares the girls worthy or not. But you didn’t come in here about all that. Presumably, you want to know just how bad Sarah Michelle Gellar’s new show is. First, let me say that I was never even close to being a diehard fan of “Buffy;” I found it a little slow and stupid. (Don’t kill me, AvB!) Gellar was decent, if not a little one-dimensional. I did like Spike and his hair, Giles and even Angel (sometimes) but come on now, there were more than a few wooden actors running around that set. Watching this trailer, all I can say about Sarah is, maybe some of that old oak tree rubbed off?

The premise of “Ringers” has potential, but it also sounds like a Lifetime movie plot. Young woman witnesses a professional hit. Instead of going into witness protection, after an extremely fortuitous, unlikely event, she hides out by assuming the identity of her twin sister. You can imagine, for a minute, how the plotline could have gone either way—good or bad—and then you can watch it clearly go bad (though the phone call at the end is interesting):

The music is awful, Gellar is monotonical (yes, I made that word up), her “strikingly handsome” new husband is not handsome at all (looks like he’s had work done), but hey, Richard Alpert is pretty! And all that voiceover stuff, is she talking to herself in the mirror all that time? Who does that? Someone on Lifetime, that’s who.

This role was tailor-made for Eliza Dushku; I don’t know why Gellar took it. You can be sure it’ll be canceled by the end of the first season. But just in case that fantabulousness drew you right in and you’re on the edge of your seat, “Ringer” also stars Nestor Carbonell (“Lost,” The Dark Knight Rises), Ioan Gruffudd (W.), Kristoffer Polaha (“Life Unexpected, Mad Men”), Mike Colter (Salt, Million Dollar Baby) and Tara Summers (“Damages, Boston Legal”). It will air on the CW this fall.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



You Say Re-gee-nah, I Say Re-geye-nah, Let's Say You Just Shut Up: Mispronunciations That Drive Us Mad | I Don't Know How She Does It Trailer: Just Once, I'd Like to See a Movie Where a Woman CAN Balance Work, Family, and Sex









Comments

That music right there is some Nine Inch Nails, so no it's not awful. Poorly cut/used? Yes. But awful? No.

But yes, the show looks atrocious.

Posted by: BalladofMaxwellDemon at May 27, 2011 9:56 AM

Gilles? GILLES???

Posted by: Carrie at May 27, 2011 9:58 AM

I was wondering how you'd look after six years.

Um, probably like you.

Posted by: superasente at May 27, 2011 9:59 AM

I think it looks fine. The trailer needed to be more dynamic but otherwise I'm interested enough to tune in. We are re-watching Buffy straight through with the kids right now (although we are currently mired in the mostly not good season 4) and I'm struck by how good SMG is in that role. She owned Buffy. She seems to do much better when she can inhabit a role completely as opposed to a 2 hour movie. I haven't watched The CW in years, and even then I can't tell you what I did watch. But I'm tuning in for this to check it out and I'm betting a lot of other Buffy fans will to.

Posted by: TylerDFC at May 27, 2011 10:00 AM

Looks weak all the way around.

Never been a Buffy fan, or a GellAR fan for that matter. It doesn't look interesting, it looks annoying and wooden and contrived and bleh. They used to only be able to get away with this kinda nonsensical stupidity in soap operas. No one knew she had a twin sister? No one would figure out that she's not the right one? She's that good at faking rich and disconnected after years of being coked and disaffected? People she hung with and had sex with for years wouldn't be able to spot something wrong immediately? I call bullshit.

And I had no idea that's how you pronounced Siobhan.

Posted by: Protoguy at May 27, 2011 10:08 AM

I believe Gilles is Giles's cousin from France. He looks just like Giles, but smokes constantly and wears a beret.

Posted by: MelBivDevoe at May 27, 2011 10:08 AM

I only watched Buffy out of loyalty for Joss Whedon. I've sat through all of his shows (Buffy, Angel, Dollhouse and the bestest show on the planet Firefly). I loved Willow. And Spike. And...that's about it. Some of the dialogue was fun. There were strong plots throughout. Loved the kickass female message. But SMG is what keeps me from re-watching it. Sure, maybe she was a great Buffy (I can't really picture anyone else in that role), but her acting skills are below average. (There is something to be said about Mr. Whedon's weakness for pretty but untalented actresses.)

This? This looks awful. SMG's acting has not improved.

Posted by: Scully at May 27, 2011 10:15 AM

Still anorexic, I see.

Posted by: Sharif at May 27, 2011 10:16 AM

They laugh alike, they walk alike, at times they even talk alike.

You could lose your mind.

Posted by: , at May 27, 2011 10:20 AM

Whoowee, that was lousy. But, I'm with TylerDFC. I think SMG killed as Buffy (get it?!). At the very least, she made the role completely her own, so much that I've always liked Buffy the Vampire Slayer more than Sarah Michelle the Actress. But, yeah, I'll check this out, hoping that Fox just hired all the good trailer editors for X-Men: First Class.

Posted by: RobP at May 27, 2011 10:25 AM

(There is something to be said about Mr. Whedon's weakness for pretty but untalented actresses.)

Really? I think Amy Acker, Emma Caulfield, Amber Benson, Juliet Landau, Julie Benz, Gina Torres, Jewel Staite, Summer Glau, and Olivia Williams miight have a bone to pick with you, Scully.

Posted by: RobP at May 27, 2011 10:31 AM

Gellar never was the strongest actor on Buffy, I'll give you that. She has taken her stab at movie stardom and is back where she belongs. If this show doesn't work, she'll find another. If she's lucky, she'll be like Alyssa Milano, Courtney Cox-Arquette and Allyson Hannigan who seem to go from long-running show to long-running show because people simply like them. There are worse ways to make a living.

Has Ioan Gruffudd given up on a film career too? I know there is cross-pollination between movies and TV now, but this isn't exactly an HBO show.

Posted by: Mrs. Julien at May 27, 2011 10:36 AM

Love everyone you listed above RobP, I only wished they were the stars of his shows. Sarah Michelle Gellar, Eliza Dushku and Charisma Carpenter? Oy. They were all painful to watch.

Posted by: Scully at May 27, 2011 10:36 AM

I may be hallucinating but I think I saw this about 15 years ago only with Stephanie Powers from Hart to Hart in the leading role and her twin sister lived in Italy.?
Anyone else remember this or am I seriously ill?

Posted by: PaddyDog at May 27, 2011 10:48 AM

Oh, CINDY. *tsk*

Now I have to break up with you. And Scully. And right before a holiday weekend, too. *sigh*

Posted by: Anna von Beav at May 27, 2011 10:52 AM

I'll bake you a delicious cake! Two cakes! And cookies. There will be lots of cookies. Promise.

Posted by: Scully at May 27, 2011 11:02 AM

But will there be a secret ice cream cake in the freezer?

Posted by: Anna von Beav at May 27, 2011 11:07 AM

Like you even have to ask.

Posted by: Scully at May 27, 2011 11:11 AM

Yaaaay!

(I probably wouldn't have *really* broken up with you anyway. I mean, honestly, I *know* SMG's not what you'd call a good actress, and I GUESS people are allowed to be of the erroneous opinion that Buffy's not a good show. Still, cookies and cakes!)

Posted by: Anna von Beav at May 27, 2011 11:20 AM

The trailer is using an oddly dubbed version of NIN's "Right Where It Belongs". As for the show, if it airs after Vampire Diaries, I'll watch. I need something to stop me from retreating to effin' Gray's Anatomy.

Posted by: Melody at May 27, 2011 11:25 AM

Paddydog, yes I do! But that's about all the plot I remember.

Posted by: Carrie at May 27, 2011 11:25 AM

It was called Deceptions.

Posted by: Carrie at May 27, 2011 11:28 AM

I feel like she is collecting projects where there is some weird twin/siblings taking on the others' identity.

Posted by: hattie at May 27, 2011 11:40 AM

I'm not gonna lie. I'd watch it if I had that kind of attention span to keep up with a show for an entire season

Posted by: Candy at May 27, 2011 11:55 AM

It looks like a pretty good soap opera.

Posted by: zito at May 27, 2011 12:01 PM

Well, Scully, we'll just have to agree to disagree on SMG being painful to watch as Buffy. She always clicked for me there. Same with Dushku as Faith, but I do agree that most of her time as Echo wasn't, um, good. Charisma Carpenter grew on me after a while, until her last season on Angel.

Honestly, I just wish Amy Acker could be in everything.

Posted by: RobP at May 27, 2011 12:18 PM

Sarah was amazing as Buffy. I don't know how you ppl can call her performance anything other than that after 7 seasons of playing someone who went through one horrible sh*t after another which culminated in the ultimate sacrifice only to face more sh*t later on.

It's either you ppl didn't watch every episode to understand what the character went through and how well Sarah portrayed it or you ppl have no respect for the universe. I feel sad for the former and I feel nothing for the latter.

Posted by: haplo at May 27, 2011 12:58 PM

Giles was a typo...settle down people.

Paddy, that does sound oddly familiar.

Posted by: Cindy at May 27, 2011 1:08 PM

her “strikingly handsome” new husband is not handsome at all (looks like he’s had work done)

that's Ioan Gruffudd! are you blind?!

the trailer, however, DOES need work. those intertitles gave me open sores on my mouth.
at least that's what I'm going with.

Posted by: shawnp at May 27, 2011 1:21 PM

I second Amy Acker being in everything. That would make the world a much better place.

Posted by: Dave at May 27, 2011 4:21 PM

Ummmm....there was this little movie called "Suture" in 1993 which dealt with pretty much the same issue but a lot more interestingly.

You wanna check that one out. So so good.

Posted by: yocean at May 27, 2011 5:18 PM

I'll have to respectfully agree to disagree with most (if not all) of the above commenters: in both seven seasons of "Buffy" as well as a few films in particular, Sarah Michelle Gellar has proven her talent, range and charm as an actress and is one of the most underrated female thespians working today in film/TV.


Side Note: Man, between Pajiba and The Playlist, it's hard to know for sure who has the "market" cornered on whiny, bitchy write-ups(if anyone actually considers this "entertainment/film journalism").

Posted by: J. Warner at May 27, 2011 5:42 PM

J. Warner - clearly it's not for everyone. Sometimes the snark seems snarky for it's own ends, but I'd rather have a brutally honest, if somewhat jaded, review than a candy-coated "OMG I Lurved it" pablum review any day.

This site, in my opinion, is for the jaded film-goer, for those tired of the same old same old that permeates both film and film review. I feel confident that when I come here I'm getting the unvarnished truth - even if that truth is mere opinion, it's not reviewing just to review, or reviewing for the perks of being a reviewer.

And I have to respectfully disagree. SMG has the range of a rubber band, the charm of DMV employee and the talent of Rene O'Connor.

Posted by: Protoguy at May 27, 2011 5:52 PM

How the hell do you "hide" as your twin sister? If I was the killer, I'd just take you both out because I'd never be sure who really saw me.

Posted by: BWeaves at May 27, 2011 6:24 PM

SMG was awesome as Buffy. She was so awesome as Buffy that I kind of hated Buffy as a character but loved the entire show. It informed my life.

But SMG needed fire her agent about a decade ago. She's seriously got the worst agent.

I actually think this is interesting, but yea, the trailer is poorly cut. (Dude, Bridget was trying to get her sister killed, what??)

Posted by: denesteak at May 27, 2011 9:00 PM

You know what? I loved-loved-LOVED SMG in Cruel Intentions and Buffy.

AH LAHVED HAHR!!!

That being spaghattah-nadled, I have no interest in this show.

Posted by: SPAGHATTAH NADLE (formerly popejenm) at May 27, 2011 10:12 PM

Good god that looks dull

Posted by: Jo at May 29, 2011 12:10 AM

Actually, it's been done on SVU. Or CI. One of the two (or maybe both).

Posted by: bellaluna at May 29, 2011 8:09 AM

Trailer looks awful. I'm not a fan of SMG, but it wouldn't matter if Natalie Portman or Angelina Jolie were playing the lead in this, there's not enough of a plot there to make a show, a couple of ep arc at best.

Posted by: Tom at May 30, 2011 9:22 AM