web
counter
 

"It's probably something else"

By Steven Lloyd Wilson | Posted Under Trailers | Comments (36)



being-human-american-version-2.jpg

“Being Human” is a fantastic British horror series about three flat mates who happen to be a werewolf, a vampire, and a ghost. Now after only two series of it, the powers that be have determined that it’s about time for an American remake. Which totally makes sense because like British people talk funny and stuff. It’s debuting on SyFy on January 17th, so I suppose to distinguish it from the British version, I’ll just call it “Beyng Humyn” from now on. Here’s the trailer for it:

Ok, fine it doesn’t look bad, per se. But they’ve got an utterly no win situation here, playing out on two axes: similarity and quality. If it’s similar and shitty they look like idiots. If it’s dissimilar and shitty they really look like idiots. If it’s similar and good, it’s pointless. And if it’s dissimilar and good, one questions why they couldn’t have come up with a different name in the first place. There are in fact many words in both British and American other than the two in this title.

Me, I’m taken with the original, if only because the cast was at Comic-Con last year, and they were the most fun of any panel I went to. You couldn’t have scripted a better hour of sniping, verbal jabs, and raw chemistry between the actors. One of the highlights was the show runner explaining that the show was not originally supposed to be supernatural at all, but was just supposed to be a comedy about three flatmates. Finally after endless meetings of being unable to get anywhere with writing a story, he said at the final meeting before the whole thing was just going to get scrapped: “why don’t we just make George a werewolf? At the very least it’ll give us something to do in the first episode.”

Here’s the first part of that panel (there are four parts total and I believe they link from the end of each).

I’d never bothered with tracking down the DVDs until I read this quote from the show, Mitchell (the vampire) narrating George’s transformation into a wolf:

“He should be dead within 30 seconds. The werewolf heart is about two-thirds the size of a human’s. But in order to shrink, first it has to stop. In other words, he has a heart attack. All of the internal organs are smaller, so while he’s having his heart attack, he’s having liver and kidney failure too. If he stops screaming it’s not because the pain has dulled, his throat, gullet and vocal chords are tearing and reforming. He literally can’t make a sound. By now the pituitary gland should be working overtime, flooding his body with endorphins to ease some of the pain, but that too has shut down. Anyone else would have died of shock long ago. But it won’t kill him and that’s the thing I find most remarkable. It drags him through the fire and keeps him alive and even conscious to endure every second. Nothing like this could just evolve. This… is the fingerprint of God. An impossible lethal curse spread by tooth and claw, victim begets victim begets victim. It’s so cruel, it’s… perfect.”

I just can’t wait to see how they Americanize it! The bright side is that for every time a British show gets unnecessarily Americanized there’s another year’s delay before the inevitable “Doctor Who” Americanization. It’s true. It’s in the Constitution and the Magna Carta.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



The Ward Trailer | I Had A World Where I Still Had You Oh I Wish I Was Crazy Again | The Disapproving Judgement of Used Shop Owners | Tales of A Very Serious Neurotic Disorder









Comments

Ugh, Annie has, like, the exact same sweater? Russell Tovey. . .RUSSELL TOVEEEEEEEY!!

Posted by: coveredinbees at January 4, 2011 11:10 AM

I'm always baffled by the insistence to Americanize things. What's wrong with just buying the rights to the British version and airing that? I would guess it's cheaper than starting a whole new show that has big potential to fail.

Posted by: ang at January 4, 2011 11:17 AM

I'm sorry, but that looks absolutely shit.
Do yourselves a favour and import the BBC DVD of series 1.

FFS - the US version even references Twilight - how much more of a warning bell do you need?!

Posted by: Simon at January 4, 2011 11:17 AM

A new original series? FOOKIN PRAWNS. Liar mouths. It's an old remake of a series. Geez, quit lying.

1. The vampire gives off a Twilight sparkle vibe. Anyone else thing he looks like RPATZ?

2. "I think the werewolf eats it's own poo." OK, I liked that line, and I don't think it's in the original.

3. They live in an expensive townhouse? How American. In the Brit version, they live in a dump.

4. I liked the fact that in the original, the people looked more like real people. The American version looks too pretty.

Posted by: BWeaves at January 4, 2011 11:27 AM

Incidentally, series 2 went off the rails a bit. The acting was still amazing, but the plotting was all over the place and the story's internal logic went for a Burton.


Posted by: Simon at January 4, 2011 11:28 AM

I can't speak to Being Human, but every time I see promotional stuff for the Americanized Shameless, I get pissed. The new show may very well turn out to be good, but why can't people just watch the British version? It's fantastic. Plus, this American one doesn't have The McAvoy.

Posted by: Melissa at January 4, 2011 11:44 AM

1. There's a little bit of geek cred in Sam Witwer. He was what's-his-face in Star Wars: the Force Unleashed. If your claim to fame was a video game, you're welcome in the SciFi community (as well as the SyFy one).

2. "Sally" is totally wearing Annie's sweater.

3. Is anyone else really uncomfortable that simply because they'll be showing less skin here in the US, we'll be seeing less of Sam Huntington than we already did in Jungle-2-Jungle? Everybody feel pervy!

Posted by: ShagEaredVillain at January 4, 2011 11:46 AM

The Amer version looks like it may have slightly better special effects. I remember a scene in the Brit 2nd season where they make a point of showing that Mitchel doesn't have a reflection in a bedroom mirror. Then he walks down the street and you can see his reflection in all the shop windows.

The 2nd season really suffered in that I don't think they knew what to do with Annie. Her storyline had really played out.

Posted by: BWeaves at January 4, 2011 11:48 AM

I have to backup coveredinbees

RUSSELL TOVEEEEEEEY!!

He is the perfect George, and they aren't going to be able to replicate him at all.

Plus, he's gay and adorable. And has those lovely ears.

Posted by: Drake at January 4, 2011 11:48 AM

Thank Godtopus! Trying to decipher British accents is almost as hard as reading subtitles. When will America smarten up, invade Europe and assimilate all THOSE people so that they can speak like a normal 'Murican. Think of the savings with only having to make any movie or show once! Why, I'll bet it pays for the war itself and eliminates America's debt so you won't have to pay for China's military. Speaking of the Chinese, I'd prefer my chop-socky movies in English too. Nudge, nudge wink-wink, say no more.

Posted by: admin at January 4, 2011 11:49 AM

I'm guessing the wolfy sex scenes are going to be crap in the Amer version.

Posted by: BWeaves at January 4, 2011 11:49 AM

Good point Simon, they really are desperate to stress that 'we aren't Twilight, we're so cool' aspect with one little, cringe-worthy line. But the preview makes this version look too cutesy. Like the characters aren't going to have real problems, only poo eating problems.

Posted by: ang at January 4, 2011 11:56 AM

I'm with BWeaves. Why do all American shows have to insist on people living in the coolest places that they couldn't possibly afford? In Boston of all places: shit, why not just put them in a Park Avenue penthouse and have done with it. The two wage earners are hospital porters for Christ's sake!

Posted by: PaddyDog at January 4, 2011 12:05 PM


"Aiden doesn't sleep in a box; he can handle the sun with a pair of cool shades; he can move fast, erase memories and read minds. Aiden, guess what I'm thinking?"

Is it:
'Fuck me. He's wandered into the wrong show. I thought he was supposed to be a regular down-to-earth vampire and yet he appears to have the combined powers of Usain Bolt, Derren Brown and a phial of rohypnol'.*


*Unlike his limey counterpart.

Posted by: Simon at January 4, 2011 12:09 PM

Looks like a big ol' pile of crapola. Where do these sci-fi folks find these generic, souless actors?

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at January 4, 2011 12:12 PM

Is this a sitcom starring a werewolf, a vampire, and a ghost or something more long form in structure?

Oh no, not the SyFy version. The British version. How have I not heard of this?

Posted by: Robert at January 4, 2011 12:16 PM

I REFUSE TO WATCH THIS TRAVESTY!!!

Seriously, we got hooked on the BBC version when it premiered here and my whole family LOOOOOOVES it. The cast is amazing, the writing is brilliant, and godDAMN I want Annie's sweater---she is fooking GORGEOUS!

*not-so-patiently waiting for next season, while lusting over the entire cast*

Posted by: dammitjanet at January 4, 2011 12:17 PM

Here you go Robert - start here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LT0zjvDg5tc&NR=1

Posted by: Simon at January 4, 2011 12:30 PM

How do they meet? These three abombinations, I mean? Probably something mundane, like shopping at WalMart.

[10pm Saturday night -- WalMart]
[There is one last 12 pack of Diet Cherry Dr. Pepper -- two people reach for it at once]
Vampire: Oh...you go ahead.
Werewolf: No, no. You take it. I insist.
Vampire: Are you sure?
Werewolf: Well, I mean my girlfriend asked me to pick it up...
Vampire: So you're not sure.
Werewolf: No. No, I'm sure. Take it.
Vampire: Because you can totally have it if you want. It's cool.
Werewolf: Ummm...boy, I mean I hate to do that. I totally just said you could take it, and now if I take it, I'm going to look like a real dick.
Vampire: It's cool. It's not for me anyway. I'll just say they were out.
Werewolf: Really?
Vampire: Seriously, go for it. I've got someone locked in my trunk that I'm going to murder on the way home and drain the life out of. I'll be good.
Werewolf: Oh, you're a vampire?
Vampire: Born and bred.
Werewolf: What a coincidence. I'm a werewolf. I'm planning on murdering someone later too and ripping the flesh off their bones.
Vampire: You don't say.
Werewolf: Dude, we should totally hang out.
Vampire: Absolutely.
Ghost: What about meeeeeeeee?
Werewolf: Did it just get cold in here?
Vampire: Hard to say; I'm room temperature.

Posted by: superasente at January 4, 2011 12:46 PM

The BBC show was absolutely awesome, one of my favorite shows ever, and the is absolutely no chance the American version will do anything but suck, but on the bright side, maybe a few folks will hear that there was an original series and seek it out, and thus improve their viewing choices.

Posted by: curegirl0421 at January 4, 2011 1:02 PM

Ah yes another pointless remake of a British show. Whilst we watch the US version, the US remakes the UK ones. I can tell you now that you will not be able to replace Russell Tovey. There was a fantastic moment in series 2 when his character did something awful and all I wanted to do was hug him.

And what is with that absolutely dreadful voiceover on the trailer? Could the woman have sounded more bored?!

Posted by: TS at January 4, 2011 1:22 PM

Oh, no no no no no no no. I've seen ads for this all over, but the preview confirms that it sucks worse than I could have imagined. I'll stick to the original, thanks.

Posted by: lorent at January 4, 2011 1:29 PM

I'm not even gonna go in depth on how they whitewashed the show. Ghost-girl is a black girl on the original. If this is not a blatant example of the racism on the part of USA Networks I don't know what is.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at January 4, 2011 2:03 PM

It actually looks cheaper than the original....so what was the point again? I can feel The Inbetweeners and Doctor Who remakes drawing nearer. KEEP YOUR HANDS OFF MISFITS!

Posted by: Katie at January 4, 2011 2:43 PM

dead evil bad trailer.

i'm utterly in love with the BBC original, and furl an eyebrow that american producers can't just import.

that said, i'll probably check it out anyway.

maybe that is the whole point of remaking. reairing might miss the people who watched the original, whereas we can be ensnared with a remake.

that cast can't be replaced though. american annie isn't even a shadow of BBC annie. she makes you want to be a ghost

Posted by: idleprimate at January 4, 2011 3:23 PM

American Being Human: You're doing it wrong.

Having just engulfed the first series like it was a bar of chocolate, I can only contribute to the high praises that this show has received. And really, that voice narrator? Sounded as excited for this bastardization as I am.

And no Russel Tovey?! He's adorable, and makes high pitched screams, and has the gay in him, and those earssss.....Kay, I'm melting.

In short, Being Human US, meet your future: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AqzuakQplEM

No. Mas.

Posted by: Kamikaze Feminist at January 4, 2011 3:44 PM

Add me to the list of those completely enamored of and obsessed with the BBC original, worshipful of the original cast with a great deal of lust thrown in, and not in the least bit looking forward to this one. YES, I also thought that the actor playing the vampire in the American version looked like a poor man's Edward Cullen, which is like being valedictorian of summer school. I wanted to give it a chance, but based on what I've seen so far, the US version is an abomination unto all manner of god, Godtopus, and man.

The main problem with the US remake is that it seems to lack the intensity, sincerity, and chemistry of the original. For example, in one scene from season 1, George gets so frustrated, angry, and worried that the only words he can get out to Mitchell are "Don't eat them!" The line is funny because George is so serious about it. The same line was delivered in the US trailer, and it has that too-clever, too-precious, "wink, wink, we're in on our own joke" vibe that so many American shows have. Sorry, not interested.

Or perhaps I'm overreacting.

Posted by: Jana Jerusalem at January 4, 2011 5:10 PM

Have no fear they'll fuck it up.

Posted by: clancys_daddy at January 4, 2011 6:04 PM

A ski trip I planned with a few friends for today ended up not happening, so I was stuck home alone for a few hours. I've been excited about this show, and this post made me decided to use my free time to check out the UK series before the US version comes about.

I haven't been able to stop watching since. There is NO WAY the SyFy version will measure up. In fact, the only reason I'm writing this comment is because I'm killing time while I wait for megavideo to let me keep watching.

Posted by: Patrick the Bunny at January 4, 2011 7:54 PM

Bonus points for living in Australia means that SyFy here is only available on overpriced satellite TV and we get the original on free-to-air public broadcaster. Yay us!

When I started watching the original, I suspected it would be kind of light. Then about 2/3 of the way through episode 1, the switch happens and my brain was all, "Ohhhh. Sneaky. Yet awesome."

They lost their way a little with Annie in season 2, but it still rocked.

And there's *no way known* SyFy will do the pedophilia storyline from the original. None.

Posted by: trib at January 4, 2011 8:59 PM

I adore the original but I don't think it is perfect in the least bit. There are some issues, the way it looks is a bit dull and it can get a little melodramatic.

I don't know how I feel about the remake, but I don't think that it will hurt the original so I'm not going to be a crybaby about it.

Also BarbadoSlim, how did they whitewash the show? The actress playing "Sally" is obviously not white.

Posted by: KC at January 4, 2011 10:10 PM

I agree with absolutely everyone on this probably sucking monkey balls. And for fuck's sake, enough with the picture perfect pretty. At some point, I want to look at real human beings, not things that look like they're made out of plastic, that some evil mad scientist blasted some 200,000 volts through. And melted their brains in the process.

KC, might just be me, but I think the fact that it looks a bit gloomy is the whole point. This isn't Palms Beach, and in that world you don't go all "Oh, look at the pretty colours." It's bleak and cold, and dark and scary, and the monsters aren't necessarily the ones with fangs and claws as season 2 proved in spades.

Posted by: Kateshi Rinkichiku at January 5, 2011 4:20 AM

ShagEaredVillain, Sam Witwer also played Crashdown in Battlestar Galactica.

Posted by: Uda at January 5, 2011 5:08 AM

Stop Americanizing everything! British accents are awesome and their slang is super fun. Who doesn't like to yell "wanker" or "sod off!" when they're pissed? Just buy the rights to the original, and stop with the shitty remakes.

Posted by: DeadBessie at January 5, 2011 10:58 AM

Wikipedia says it's actually technically a Canadian remake, that's being simultaneously broadcast on SyFy in the US and Space in Canada. Production is in Montreal.

Posted by: Amanda6 at January 5, 2011 9:02 PM

I thought it was going to be some boring old post, but it really compensated for my time. I will post a link to this page on my blog. I am sure my visitors will find that very useful.I think you have done an excellent job with your blog. I will return in the near future.I had bookmark it :)

Posted by: wholesale fashion dresses at January 5, 2011 10:19 PM