Fate, It Seems, Is Not Without a Sense of Irony

By Steven Lloyd Wilson | Trade News | November 16, 2010 | Comments ()

By Steven Lloyd Wilson | Trade News | November 16, 2010 |

In a move assuring the world that they have not the slightest concept of irony, the creators of "What What In The Butt" are suing Viacom and Comedy Central for stealing the idea behind their video. Yes, "South Park" satirized their video as the apex of people thinking that they are entitled to money for posting idiotic videos of themselves online and so now they are suing to get exactly that money.

It reminds me of the (probably overly simplified) explanation of libel from The People vs. Larry Flynt, in which if the depiction in question would not be believed as true by anyone who knows the "victim," then it can't possibly be libel. These guys are trying to strike out on the other side of the law by demonstrating that it can't be libel if it actually is demonstrably true.

Of course it's possibly too much to ask for sanity from these guys, who have been claiming for years that a What What (In the Butt): The Movie is in the works. I'm sure it'll be a touching romantic comedy with a talking dog. Since Justin Bieber got his start on YouTube, he'll probably play the dog. They'll have to teach him to talk though.

The other funny thing? If you've ever endured the original video, you'd note that it satirizes the iconic rose petals scene from American Beauty. So their basic legal argument is that "South Park" was trying to kidnap what they had rightfully stolen. Inconceivable!

(source: IGN)

Get entertainment, celebrity and politics updates via Facebook or Twitter. Buy Pajiba merch at the Pajiba Store.

Cowboys And Aliens Poster | I Dub Thee Unforgiven... With Aliens | Two Beavers Are Better than One | The Latest Addition to "HIMYM" Mythology

Bigots, Trolls & MRAs Are Not Welcome in the Comments

The Pajiba Store


Privacy Policy