web
counter
 

This Review Has Been Cancelled

By Dustin Rowles | Posted Under Trade News | Comments (11)



my-generation-abc-tv-show.jpg

So as to mete out my disillusionment with network television more slowly and painfully, I reviewed the network pilots over the course of the last two weeks, leaving reviews of some of the lesser profile shows for week two. Two of those shows, unfortunately, were cancelled before the end of those two weeks (“Lone Star” was the first). I only managed to see half of NBC’s “My Generation” before it’d been cancelled (I held off, assuming the shitcanning was in the works after its first week’s ratings). And unsurprisingly, for a show that’s been cancelled already, I didn’t actively dislike “My Generation.” I didn’t even get a real opportunity to loathe it. It had an interesting conceit: A documentary show, which had followed ten graduating high schoolers, picked up their lives again ten years later. Things that happened in the present day were given context by intercutting footage from a decade ago.

It could’ve been decent. Or it could’ve been television ear wax. Alas, we’ll never know, as ABC gave the show its walking papers the morning after its second airing, giving viewers one more reason not to bother with network television until a show has already been established.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Pajiba After Dark 10/3/10 | The Ten Most Predictably Paranomastic Box-Office Headlines of the Weekend









Comments

I'm so confused by American television. If people are waiting to see if a show is to stay on air before watching or committing to it, surely this affects the viewing figures too? Or do not many people do this? Why do they even bother putting them on air if they're going to pull them two weeks later? Do they really not get that much of a chance? It's just mental.

Posted by: Carrie at October 4, 2010 9:05 AM

WHAT!?

I'm so bummed. Lambast me all you want but I was really enjoying this show...so curious to see what was going to happen! Plus Michael Stahl David is the reason why The Black Donnellys is in my Netflix queue. Man, this sucks. I liked Kenneth!

Guess I'll have to go back to watching Parenthood...

Posted by: grace b at October 4, 2010 9:28 AM

You could tell this show was doomed to fail from its inception. First off, I'm not sure that its target demographic is really interested in drama that even resembles anything introspective or realistic. It wants over the top soap opera drama with a dash of sparkly vampire thrown in.

It seems like ABC Family has carved a little niche for this type of program but focused it on 14 year old girls. Perhaps ABC thought it could draw in that crowd and appeal to their parents nostaglia as well.

I'm sure that ABC will replace it with another form of the Bachelor or other reality schlock. At least they have Modern Family so that their entire week doesn't suck!

Posted by: swingdude at October 4, 2010 9:34 AM

I guess they weren't trying to cause a big sensation.

Posted by: minxwas at October 4, 2010 9:37 AM

This show was shit. The only reason I gave it a chance was because the mousy chick from Lars and the Real Girl was a part of the cast.

I'm actually really tired of television relying on contrived reality/mockumentaries as a source of comedy and drama.

Write a fucking show. With fucking interesting characters. And a fucking story line. I can only take so much awkward silence and then eye contact with the camera.

Posted by: Natalia at October 4, 2010 10:26 AM

I'm not saying this show is in anyway comparable, but the fuck-wits in charge do remember that both MASH and Cheers bombed during their first seasons, don't they?

Sheesh, sometimes shows take a little while to find their feet.


Posted by: Simon at October 4, 2010 10:39 AM

And Seinfeld too, Simon.

Posted by: Bates at October 4, 2010 11:11 AM

This show reminds me of that Simpsons episode, guest starring Eric Idle as an interviewer, where a documentary is made on Homer's grade school class as they grow up, get jobs, and get married.

Posted by: Ellie at October 5, 2010 12:03 AM

There are ads for this show all over NYC and they're annoying. I think this is a case of the marketing campaign killing the product. I didn't see the show and know nothing about it, but seeing posters of a financially comfortable-looking white guy next to a big quote, "I'm through paying for your mistakes, Dad," while I'm on my way to bust my ass at an underpaying restaurant job doesn't make me want to tune in.

Posted by: Lucas at October 5, 2010 9:14 AM

The adds are all over the place, and perhaps a bit too much! However, I really liked the show and while i felt some characters were undeveloped and needed more depth I was very disappointed when I tuned in Thursday to find that show had been cancelled!

Posted by: Yelizaveta at October 8, 2010 11:15 PM

That's really a shame. I'd like to think that I'm right in the middle of the target demographic being high school class of 2000 myself. I have to say, I was really anticipating this show and really enjoyed the two episodes I got. I thought it was a fluke on Hulu last Friday when I tried to watch it, but alas, no. I know for a fact that others my age are not all into over dramatic soap operas and sparkly vampires as swingdude suggested. I really felt like I could have known these characters, like I could get inside of their heads and understand them, like I could pick out from my own class ten people to be them. I enjoyed that sense of connection. Who ever did the research for the character building, they did an amazing job. Sorry to see it go.

Posted by: Erin at October 15, 2010 11:13 AM