free counter with statistics Preacher Movie | Pajiba - Scathing Reviews for Bitchy People

Preacher_1_1280x1024.jpg
Friday’s Geek Movie News

More Things I’m Completely Ignorant About / Dustin Rowles

Trade News | October 31, 2008 | Comments (54)


This week, I’m familiar with three of the four geek projects I’m listing today, so I’ll start with the one I’m completely ignorant of, but for the frequent mentions in the comments section here: Sam Mendes (American Beauty, Jarhead) is set to helm an adaptation of the controversial Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon graphic novel, Preacher. And though I didn’t really know much about it before today, the description of the premise sounds absolutely killer: It’s the “story of a down-and-out Texas preacher possessed by Genesis, a supernatural entity conceived by the unnatural coupling of an angel and a demon. Given immense powers, the preacher teamed with an old girlfriend and a hard-drinking Irish vampire and set out on a journey across America to find God — who apparently had abandoned his duties in heaven — and hold him accountable for his negligence.”

I am so fucking down with that. In fact, it’s a project that’s been long in development, having been considered as a one-hour series for HBO. Prior to that, Kevin Smith had even been attached, with James Marsden as the lead. Under Mendes, so far, no writers or cast has been put in place. But I’m sure our fanboys have many suggestions; knowing little of the source material myself, I still can’t help but think that Josh Brolin would be perfect for the title role.

Moving on: In news surprising to no one, Robert Downey, Jr. has officially signed on to Iron Man 2, as well as Iron Man 3 and The Avengers, so he’s in it for the long haul. Jon Favreau has also been signed, but not as directer of The Avengers. So far, he’s still only listed as an executive producer. Terrance Howard is still out as War Machine, while Don Cheadle is still in. Meanwhile, I’m still scratching my head on that. However, I can only imagine what the Comic-Con panel ahead of The Avengers will look like. The floors will be sticky with semen. Geek ladies — watch your step. A slip-and-fall might result in more than a sprained ankle.

In horror-geek news, it’s been confirmed: There will be a Hellraiser remake, which will be written and directed by French-director, Pascal Laugier. Laugier stirred controversy in France with his movie, Martyrs because of the unrelentingly violent nature of the film, which earned an 18+ rating in France. And the French let their toddlers get drunk and watch porn, so you know that shit had to be serious. And a seriously-good original needs a seriously-good director if there’s going to be a remake. I’m cautiously optimistic. In fact, for the Best Deaths lists I had up earlier this week, I’d wanted to include the scene from Hellraiser where a man’s flesh is ripped from his body by hooks, but I couldn’t find a good clip of it. Shame, too: That scene will fuck you up.

Finally, the long, long, long delayed Fanboys has not only got a release date — the cinematic landfill of February 2009 , opposite six other wide releases — but now there’s a movie poster. Is there any hope at all for this movie? Anyway, I’d show you the poster, but most of you would rather see Kristen Bell in a Princess Leia outfit, so here’s that. And you can get the movie poster at the esteemed source.

leiabell.jpg


The Shadow Rising by Robert Jordan | The Best Halloween Treats



Comments

You dropped a quotation mark in the first paragraph there. I'm all about being annoyingly helpful.

Posted by: Raisin'Cookies at October 31, 2008 10:15 AM

There you go again, Dustin. Feigning ignorance.

Well, that or you write these things and run away. Haven't we discussed Preacher to death?

Yes, I think it's the best comic I've ever read, though there's some people around here who feel violently opposed to that stance.

Spose you punks like that shit Frank Quitely calls "art", HUH?!?!?!?

Anyway, Josh Brolin isn't Jesse Custer, but, he could be the Saint of Killers...only he's already Jonah Hex, which is sorta the same genus. But all under the DC umbrella! Hmmmm.

If they could pull off the stupefying gymnastics of getting the plot of one movie out of those 66 stories I'd be speechless. I'm willing to let them try, though. "Constantine" wasn't the best Hellblazer movie one could make, by far, but someone at least tried it. So, I'll agree with Senator Spock: HOPE!

(I really do hate Frank Quitely)

Posted by: Jay at October 31, 2008 10:20 AM

Oh, I almost forgot to curse Sam Mendes at the same time.

Devil got my woman!!

Posted by: Jay at October 31, 2008 10:23 AM

I'd say Preacher would work better as a movie than a series. That way they can cut out the filler, of which there was a lot in the comic. That's probably the main reason I don't rate the comic as highly as many do. When it was good, like John Custer's last lesson to his son, it was amazing. But there were so many useless villains and storylines that had nothing to do with Jesse's mission that it just squandered all the greatness.

Brolin would be good, but he's a little old for Jesse. (I could definitely see him as the Saint, Jay.) I'm not a big Mark Wahlberg fan, but he could be decent.

Posted by: Todd at October 31, 2008 10:25 AM

(I really do hate Frank Quitely)

I am with you on that. Amazing how he can make everyone in a comic book look 80 years old and constipated.

Whoever thought to put him on The Authority (and after THE awesome motherfucker Bryan Hitch) needed to get a steel-toed vasetomy.

Posted by: Vermillion at October 31, 2008 10:27 AM

Jay, I wrote you a hot women over 50 list in that thread from yesterday (just in case you didn't notice). Its heavy on the blonds so I'm sure you'll want to amend it. I'll await revisions.

Posted by: becks at October 31, 2008 10:29 AM

And oooh! That Hollywood Reporter story also says someone's working on Ennis's "The Boys"!

Government squad who that polices and occasionally brings down superheroes who get out of hands. The protagonist is drawn to look like Simon Pegg, and is pretty goddamn bitter about what collateral damage did to his life.

Posted by: Jay at October 31, 2008 10:30 AM

Todd:Brolin would be good, but he's a little old for Jesse. (I could definitely see him as the Saint, Jay.) I'm not a big Mark Wahlberg fan, but he could be decent.

Would Mark be able to then say his character could kiss Batman's ass legitimately?

/Genuinely asking,I've never read any Preacher

Posted by: cockroach at October 31, 2008 10:30 AM

Is Kristin Bell a midgit? I looked at that photo for a full minute trying to figure out if it was an optical illusion.

Posted by: TylerDFC at October 31, 2008 10:32 AM

What did I write that paragraph in a big hurry? Jeez. "no, use 'that' instead of 'who', but don't erase the other, and use one of your patented unintended pluralizing S's too".

Thank you, Vermillion. I've never been able to articulate it. It's always made All-Star Superman hurt a bit for me, and the Authority switch was indeed a tragedy.

Posted by: Jay at October 31, 2008 10:35 AM

I like "Preacher" well enough. It's good read. It tends to meander a bit in the middle and loses its sense of direction more than once, but it picks up. There's a lot of over-the-top vulgarity throughout. Most of it is completely unnecessary, though a lot of it's pretty enjoyable, but that's Garth Ennis for you.

I'm glad someone with talent like Sam Mendes is at the helm. It will be interesting to see exactly how they pull together a story out of all that goes down in the 66 issues. There's a lot there. As noted above, a lot of it's unnecessary, but not enough to really get all the important stuff into a 2 to 3 hour film.

If Mendes doesn't water it down, I can't imagine the outcry from the religious folks. I mean, just remember how outraged people got over something as silly and innocuous as "Da Vinci Code". The comic goes way, way beyond anything implied in the "Da Vinci" code. God, Himself, is depicted as a petty, devout coward. Jesus not only had sex and children, but those children have been inbred over the course of 2,000 years to the point where the sole surviving "heir" is a completely mentally handicapped kid who spends his days in a glass cell picking his nose and flinging his own feeces.

If Mendes hates religion as much as he hates the suburban America, I think he's found his movie.

Posted by: ajax19 at October 31, 2008 10:36 AM

That Hollywood Reporter story also says someone's working on Ennis's "The Boys"!

Christ no, it's the 90's all over again and now it's sneaking into the movies...

Posted by: twig at October 31, 2008 10:45 AM

Please, no Mark Wahlberg as Jesse. Please. He's a horrible actor. He's good at playing the sort of innocent good guy (like he did in "Boogie Nights" and "Three Kings"), but he totally lacks any of the edge or swagger that one needs to pull off Jesse Custer properly.

I agree about Brolin as the Saint. But, it would basically be Jonah Hex 2.0.

Todd, I think you nailed exactly what makes "Preacher" not quite as great as it could be. There is a lot of filler in their that detracted from the main story. Too many odd tangents that just didn't quite work or weren't nearly as compelling as the main arc. When it was "on", it was really on though.

Posted by: ajax19 at October 31, 2008 10:46 AM

"It's the "story of a down-and-out Texas preacher possessed by Genesis, a supernatural entity conceived by the unnatural coupling of an angel and a demon. Given immense powers, the preacher teamed with an old girlfriend and a hard-drinking Irish vampire . . ."

Preacher = Caleb, from Buffy the Vampire slayer
Old girlfriend = The First, from Buffy the Vampire slayer
Hard-drinking Irish vampire = Spike, from Buffy the Vampire slayer (OK, British, fake British, whatever)

Posted by: BWeaves at October 31, 2008 10:47 AM

"The floors will be sticky with semen..."


Once again, Pajiba sets the standard for class...

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at October 31, 2008 10:54 AM

Always with the Buffy, you Buffy people! Jesus!

However, James Marsters ( but as Spike) kinda does look like Cassidy. Fillion doesn't convince me right off, but I can't proclaim it's WRONG. Who are you referring to as The First, though? This Sineya character? Gellar?

Posted by: Jay at October 31, 2008 10:56 AM

I would rub whipped cream all over Preacher's bizness.

Posted by: firedmyass at October 31, 2008 11:02 AM

Oh but wait...it's not a big mental leap around here, but...someone who's worked with both above-mentioned Brolin and Fillion: I think I could see Elizabeth Banks as Tulip.

Vermillion?

Posted by: Jay at October 31, 2008 11:13 AM

"...James Marsden as the lead."

No. Period. There is no way.

Brolin as the Saint of Killers could be good though. The only way I think this could be pulled off is to use a relatively unknown cast. True, there'd be no Hollywood "draw", but it could wind up being a cult flick. I'd rather see that than dump a bunch of well-knowns into the roles.

I'm also with everyone on dumping a lot of the filler material. Assface isn't needed. But if the movie doesn't include Jody & TC, count my ass out.

Posted by: Skitz at October 31, 2008 11:35 AM

Just got the 1st Preacher TPB. Been meaning to for a while.

Is it still being develped as a HBO series?

Posted by: Brian at October 31, 2008 11:36 AM

I think I could see Elizabeth Banks as Tulip.

Possible. AFAIK, she has played characters fairly...er....on the other end of the spectrum from Tulip. But she is good, so maybe this is just the challenge she can handle.

By the way, thanks for the K.Bell pic Dustin, even if no one else appreciates it.

Posted by: Vermillion at October 31, 2008 11:47 AM

Jackie Earle Hailey as Jody. Jennifer Garner would make a good Tulip.

Posted by: Adam C at October 31, 2008 11:52 AM

Preacher is to comics what Pajiba is to movie reviews. There's a lot of over-the-top swearing, violence, drinking, and blasphemy, but damn if it just isn't that much more fun because of it.

As for the important role of the Saint O' Killers, we just need someone who can say "Not enough gun" and mean it. I think we all know that person to be Sam Elliott.

Posted by: Macafee at October 31, 2008 11:58 AM

"Jesus wept.."

*RIIIIIPPPP..Splatter...splatter...

I knew it was just a fluke that you left that one out! Hells-to-the-fucking-yeah, if they get this remake right, I'll... I'll...

Yeah, I got nothing. Brain overload...

Pinhead and the Cenobites scared the ever-loving piss out of me when I first saw this movie... and I was 23.

Posted by: Alexandra at October 31, 2008 11:59 AM

Jesse = Guy Pearce?... I got nuthin, really
Tulip = Katee Sackhoff
Cassidy = James McAvoy
Saint of Killers = Tommy Lee Jones/Viggo Mortensen

Posted by: firedmyass at October 31, 2008 12:00 PM

P.S. Yes, Kristen Bell is a midget. Don't you remember her working her "pixie spy magic?"

Posted by: Alexandra at October 31, 2008 12:03 PM

Jay, I don't remember who The First was played by and I'm too lazy to look it up. It's just that I read the blurb about The Preacher, and knowing nothing else about it, all the Buffy characters just popped into my head.

Speaking of comicbook preachers, how come they're not making a movie about The Confessor, and his sidekick Altarboy? There's an inappropriate superhero, on so many levels. And he turns into a vampire, eventually, so it's all good.

Posted by: BWeaves@cfl.rr.com at October 31, 2008 12:17 PM

Oh holy shit I would love to see Nathan Fillion as Jesse. Not going to happen, but it would be great. Tulip needs to be a little bit butch, like Hillary Swank or something. Like 10 years ago Robert Carlyle would have been a great Cassidy, now we need to find a young Robert Carlyle.

Posted by: Roni at October 31, 2008 12:19 PM

I have it on good authority that Kristen Bell is a dude.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at October 31, 2008 12:26 PM

Of course I would love to see Nathan Fillion as Preacher, because...I would just love to see Nathan Fillion. But Guy Pearce is a really good suggestion; and I'd like to throw in one of his Proposition co-stars, Danny Huston. I haven't seen much of Huston, but dude is intense and that's what Preacher mainly needs.

Posted by: Jerce at October 31, 2008 12:44 PM

Adam C I think you mean JEH would be a fine TC. I have to disagree with attaching Garner to any comic book adaptation, she's done enough.
Does anyone else think Brad Pitt, doing a lighter accent than his one from "Snatch", would be a pretty badass Cassidy?

Posted by: Optimus Rhyme at October 31, 2008 12:46 PM

Mark Wahlberg? Mark Wahlberg???? If you ever make a suggestion like that again, I will hunt you down using googlemaps and I will kill you, Todd. I will kill you dead.

Whoa, that got a little intense. Sorry. But Jesse Custer has been my dream man* since I was fifteen, and I'll be damned if I let anyone ruin that with fucking Mark Walhberg.

I could buy James Marsden, in fact, he could end up really, really, good, but it could also go the other way. And I'm all for putting Nathan Fillion in anything and everything, but he's too old. I'd buy Elizabeth Banks for Tulip, though. Katee Sachoff, too.


*Ok, the whole drugging-your-girlfriend part is kind of a buzzkill, but come on. He's a bad-boy man of the cloth with a texan accent. It's like, my trifecta of inappropriate turn-ons.

Posted by: Marra at October 31, 2008 1:05 PM

Caleb popped in my head, too!
I knew nothing of the Fillion when I saw him on Buffy, and the dude CREEPED me out. He was brilliant. I think he'd make a great preacher. I've never read the stories, but he kinda sounds like a cross between Caleb and Mal? Only ornier? Or hornier, in which case, I can very willingly help with that problem.

Posted by: Stella at October 31, 2008 1:09 PM

Jackie Earle Haley would make a perfect TC. Not sure who I'd want for Jody (the best bad guy in the comic, I think). Clint Eastwood circa-Unforgiven would have been great, but he's too old now. Ron Perlman?

Would Mark be able to then say his character could kiss Batman's ass legitimately?

You mean kick? Maybe. If Bats knew about Jesse's power, Jesse wouldn't stand a chance. If he didn't, Jesse just might be able to get the drop on him.

And ajax19, I don't think Wahlberg's much of an actor, either. But a lot of people think he did a good job playing a vaguely similar character in The Departed (not me so much, but a lot of people), so I'm betting they'd dig him as Jesse. And Sam Mendes, who really knows how to work with actors, could make all the difference.

Posted by: Todd at October 31, 2008 1:11 PM

They should cast Dane Cook as Arseface. He looks the part.

Posted by: Lucas at October 31, 2008 2:10 PM

We've already seen Nathan Fillion as a (pseudo) possessed preacher, and he *fucking* killed it. I can't imagine anyone who would be better suited to do this role - hell, he even looks like the cartoon character. Whoever suggested just recasting James Marsters as another alcoholic vampire was also spot on, and how about another Whedon alum, Eliza Dushku, as the lead female role?

That being said, I also would love to see Robert Downey, Jr. take on the lead role - imagine Tony Stark with (more) pretensions of godhood and with more of a license to be an absolute douchebag.

Posted by: Zack at October 31, 2008 2:14 PM

Downey, Jr. is too old, Fillion's too old, Guy Pearce is too old, and Danny Huston's too old. Jesse is, it must be said, a tough needle to thread.

Maybe Cillian Murphy for Cassidy?

Posted by: Todd at October 31, 2008 2:30 PM

Don't forget the chicken fucking! And the cyclops family...

Posted by: grinder at October 31, 2008 2:36 PM

I did mean TC for JEH...and I liked Garner as Electra.

Posted by: Adam C at October 31, 2008 11:08 PM

Dushku would be terrific as Tullip though. How about Willem Dafoe as Herr Starr?

Posted by: Adam C at October 31, 2008 11:09 PM

The *only* reason Fillon wouldn't be my first choice for Jesse is that Jesse has to do a lot of flashbacks where he's emaciated. Fillon is a big, solid motherfucker. You need a slender cowboy type as much as anything. Honestly, the dude that plays the vampire on True Blood, assuming he has acting depth somewhere, is just about the perfect doppelganger.

Cassidy...should fucking be Glenn Quinn. I can't believe he's dead. That kills me. Cillian Murphy is good, but not as used-looking as he ought to be.

Tulip...are there any hardbodied girls left on the scene that are a little bit ugly? I can't quite see Dushku as a blonde, but she's as close as anyone could be to Tulip (I will kill someone if it's Alba).

Posted by: Kat at November 1, 2008 5:54 AM

Cillian Murphy is good, but not as used-looking as he ought to be.

See, Cassidy's kind of tricky, though. If I remember correctly, he was only sixteen when he became a vampire, but the wear and tear of his "life" since makes him look older. It might require some makeup to get just the right look, so I think just finding the right actor is the most important thing. They can perfect the visual later on.

Though it occurs to me that, looks-wise and since he can do an American accent, Murphy might make a good Jesse, too. And I'd like to see him with red eyes...

Posted by: Todd at November 1, 2008 11:09 AM

Well, ladies? What do you think? Cillian with an eyepatch and a Texas drawl, firing up his Zippo on a horse?


Oh and ya gotta have some white jeans action in there, whoever it is.

Posted by: Jay at November 1, 2008 11:59 AM

Preacher is one of my all-time favorite comic book maxi-series (possibly my #1 spot). That said, I don't think there is any way it could ever possibly be made into a good movie. No way. It just will not happen.

Posted by: Mitch Clem at November 1, 2008 7:35 PM

I will watch Cilian Murphy in anything, anytime, anywhere.

Today I picked up the first TPB of Preacher, so I'll let you know if I think he's right for any of the characters.

Wait, Jay, did you say white jeans? Um, yeah. Cilian is totally right for that character.

Posted by: Anna von Beaverplatz at November 2, 2008 12:53 AM

Ah said White Jeans.

It does get questioned by another character.

Posted by: Jay at November 2, 2008 3:47 AM

I always thought that cover pic of Jesse looked like an evil Jeff Goldblum. However, Jesse is not a stuttering, tightly wound geek, so I wonder why they don`t just go with Michael Madsen, who would be perfect.

Posted by: dan at November 2, 2008 5:52 PM

Michael Madsen? I disagree. Maybe 20 years ago. I love Cilian Murphy, but I don't know if he would work. He'd not only have to pull off the accent, but he'd also have to be, like, classic tough-guy tough. I haven't seen him do that, really. I mean, Red Eye, but still. Madsen can do that, but he's too old and too big. James Marsden seems completely wrong. Not that I have any other suggestions, mind you. We'll all have to think about it some more and let the bigwigs know what we've decided.

What a great story. I love it. Can't wait to get the next one.

Posted by: Anna von Beaverplatz at November 2, 2008 9:28 PM

hmmm I always thought the Saint of Killers was designed for Clint, but how's about Kris Kristoffeson - he's sufficiently grizzled for the role.

Brolin's too old for Custer and Marsden's all sorts of wrong for it... too bad Michael Keaton is too old, he'd have been perfect

Posted by: Colombo at November 3, 2008 7:29 AM

@Anna von Beaverplatz:

So, you're saying Zac Efron as Jesse?

*runs*

Posted by: Kat at November 3, 2008 3:33 PM

Jesse = Timothy Olyphant

Tulip = Katee Sackhoff

Cassidy= Cillian Murphy

Herr Star = Sir Ben Kingsley

Jody= Ron Pearlman

TC = John Hawks

Nana= Glen Close

Posted by: Ken at November 7, 2008 1:29 PM

Colin Farrell would be a dreat cassidy especially the way hes looking at the moment after dropping all the wweight he easily has cass's build. His probably to big know to do a supporting role though and after gettin burned in daredevil he mightent want to do another comic book movie even though his bullseye was the only good thing in that film

Posted by: Wedge at January 13, 2009 4:19 PM

I cant wait for Preacher to come out! Ive been reading those comics for 11 years! awesome!

Posted by: freddie at February 23, 2009 4:04 AM

I cant wait for Preacher to come out! Ive been reading those comics for 11 years! awesome!

Posted by: freddie at February 23, 2009 4:05 AM