Pajiba

Yikes. I'm upset now too.

Adam, I wish I had your zen-like calm in the face of all these unanswered questions. The more I reflect back on the finale, the more upset I get. I knew they were making a lot of it up as they went, but DAMN. Watching this video, there was a whole hell of a lot they would introduce and then abandon and never bring up again, and we'll never know what most of it meant.

Never saw a single episode of Lost. After watching this video, I'm thinking I made the right choice, as I would have been in full "Aw! Fuck this shit!" mode by episode 6, at the latest.

I figured out my own answers for a lot of this, and the advantage to them not answering the questions is that they don't fuck with the ones I created. I mean, is it worse to have no answer, or an answer that is so fucking bad it makes you want to scream. My go to example for this is Star Wars I where we learn that the force has to do with tiny animals that live in your blood stream. I was much happier thinking it was special humans (and aliens) who were able to use more than just 10% of their brain. I guess my point is sometimes getting an answer is worse than not getting an answer.

Too late Optimus.

I'm going to take a deep breath and march on, knowing that I was right. Cop out finale.

Breathe in. Breathe out.

oh cripes. i don't know whether to watch this or not.

i was just thinking about what cindy's reaction will be.

oh frack, i guess i'll watch it.

i'm not pissed! phew. there are a few questions that i would have liked "official" answers to (fertility, the rules, how christian appeared off island, to name three), but a lot of those questions i figured out based on message board chatter and going back and rewatching a handful of episodes from each season prior to sunday night.

serenity yesterday.

THE FORCE IS TINY ANIMALS THAT LIVE IN YOUR BLOODSTREAM?!

How did the "tiny animals" get there? What is the turtle standing on? We could do this all day.

Midichlorians don't remove the mysticism. They just confirm genetic inclination for the Force, which we already knew from the original trilogy.

Thank you myjetski! You have no idea how many people I've had to deal with the past few days hating on how horrible lost is by not answering so many of these questions. You just summed up everything I was thinking and have been trying to explain.

The finale pissed me off. But this, surprisingly enough, calms me down. I'm happy someone else made this video to show just how flawed LOST was. Now I can move on.

Holy crap! Matthew Fox looks like Mitt Romney. That sucks.

I am more annoyed that there was no mention the Hurley bird than at all the unanswered questions the video itself contained.

The turtle is not standing on anything. It is swimming through space, thinking very slow thoughts, and heading towards a star.

myjetski, Amen!

i was actually kind of surprised that so many people on this site wanted things spelled out for them, but whatever. they did answer a lot of the questions i've heard in the last few days--but you did have to pay attention and accept answers that you didn't like.

Sheesh, seriously? A lot of the answers to these questions can be pieced together through a few short leaps of logic. Do we really need them spelled out? Examples: fertility problems were caused by the incident. Food drops were done by the stateside Dharma folks (they maybe knew that the purge occurred, but they also knew somebody was still in the swan station pushing the button). Walt told Locke not to open the hatch because maybe his powers allowed him to see that it would lead Locke down an unfortunate path that would end in his death, etc.

BTW, wasn't the whole point of announcing the show's deadline a few years back that the writers would know exactly how much time they had to finish the story and could begin to start putting together answers to the riddles they'd asked?

So we thought. But, I think it's obvious now that it was just to buy time and save their jobs.

Didn't Dustin say there weren't going to be any more LOST related posts after Monday?

Sigh.

Posted by: Groundloop : Never saw a single episode of Lost. After watching this video, I'm thinking I made the right choice, as I would have been in full "Aw! Fuck this shit!" mode by episode 6, at the latest.

I was in that mode by the second episode. I walked away and never looked back.
~
Posted by: John W : When I think of LOST I think about X-FIles.

You could ask the same amount of questions about that show.

We did ask, I can assure you - we did.
~

Earlier this evening, I was washing my face when pseudo-Mr. vB, from the living room, shouted, "AvB! That was JUST the worst finale ever."

Honestly, I'm fine with the finale. It gave me emotional closure as far as the characters were concerned. I decided earlier today that judging by the way they handled this, or anything since the first season really, any answers they DID give for all the questions would likely have been stupid or half-assed, and no given answer would satisfy more than 20% of the audience. So, I'd rather have the mysteries survive on as mysteries in my head than have stupid, half-assed answers.

I can overlook not getting all of my questions answered. It's not like I really expected everything to be answered from Lost. What I call shenanigans on is that JJ Abrams apparently picked out an ending from an Internet message board, and then he effed it up.

The things that really got me: Lost has the world's worst parents. I loved Sun and Jin, they became these amazing complex characters throughout the show, then they decided to orphan their child. Not cool. But worse than that, Sayid is not spending all of eternity with Shannon. I refuse to believe that. He searched for Nadia across multiple continents and like a decade. He's spending eternity with her, not some stupid blonde chick that he screwed for two weeks while on the world's worst tropical vacation.

I am so glad that other people are angry about the Sayid thing. People keep telling me that maybe he really loved Shannon. I think he liked Shannon. I think he enjoyed having sex with Shannon. I also think that no long-term (like eternity) long relationship is based on two weeks of sandy beach sex.

Anyone who watched the show at this level of detail missed the point. 95% of these questions are irrelevant. The show was always about the characters. The island was just a backdrop.

You can't have a show that's built on mysteries and the unknown, fill it to the brim with so many riddles that an entire side-section of the Internet, full of podcasts, websites and message boards, is created to just catalog and ponder their meaning and then turn around and go, "It was never about the riddles or the mysteries."

It'd be like saying The Sopranos wasn't about the Mafia.

LOST has always had its sympathies with eastern religious tradition, namely Buddhism and Hinduism. A big part of that religious tradition is the focus on questions and questioning and less on universal answers. The belief is that there are very few, if any, universal answers. LOST seemed to hammer that point home over and over again. Locke wants answers, thinks first the answer is in the Hatch and then with Ben and then with Jacob. Each time, those potential sources for answers prove not to have answers at all. Jacob was set up as a Jesus Christ figure and then was revealed to be just a man who had a task to do that he didn't even really choose to do. Meanwhile, the tragedy of Locke is that he couldn't simply appreciate the fact that he was a paraplegic who was now walking around. The obvious contrast was Rose, who simply lived in the moment. No need for answers. She was alive and with the man she loved. That was enough

I found that this was implicit in the LOST story, but unfortunately we have had a lot of shows that fixed on setting up mysteries and then trying to reveal them in somewhat lame ways (X-files and Twin Peaks come to mind). This may have set the expectation for LOST and the writers didn't do anything to dispel that. Let's face it - if Cuse and Lindendorf said, "Hey, LOST is a Buddhist pulp fiction." they could have kissed their shrinking audience goodbye. And so here we are. Anger, confusion, feelings of betrayal. That's what you get if you try to go subtle with a mass medium that's intended to entertain.

I enjoyed the ride, but I also expected very little by way of answers.

"Anyone who watched the show at this level of detail missed the point. 95% of these questions are irrelevant. The show was always about the characters. The island was just a backdrop."

Then why introduce that 95%, those mounds of extraneous and dead-end mysteries? They wrote the show. They made those things up. Why include them at all if you're not going to resolve or justify them, and in fact ignore them completely in the final season? The characters have always been slightly fleshed-out archetypes... I did not watch LOST for the characters.

One more thing:

Did anyone for a second, when the light went out in the Series Finale, that LOST was going to end on a dark note? I was scared...but thrilled in a sick way that the light would actually go out, MIB would actually escape, and the world as we knew it would "come to an end".

Too bad that didn't happen.

gah, fuck it.

Not to derail the finale hatred (or Jedi-like acceptance of it)but has anybody else noticed how tall Elizabeth Mitchell is? I mean in the scene from the video up there where she's got her arm around Jin...I mean, I know he's Asian and all, but I didn't think he was that short. And when her and Claire and her son are standing in line at the concert, I think Claire was about eye level with her kooch. Woman be Amazonian. Me likey.

I think people are taking way too much stock in the purgatory plotline. The way the island story ended was great. The island is blowing up, MIB figures out he has made a huge mistake, and Jack and Locke finally go head to head with intent to kill. That over, mortally wounded Jack makes a desperate last effort to "re start" the light while Sawyer, Kate, etc make it off the island just in time. Sure the cork in the light was kind of simple. But the characters had no idea it was going to be. Do you think Indiana Jones would have gone through everything he did if he had known the Nazis were going to be wiped out with zero effort as soon as they opened the Ark? Hind sight is always 20/20.

The ending of the story was great. The purgatory thing was confusing but it's not what it was about. It was just epilogue, a stab at a "happy" ending after so much death and dispair for these people. The final shot of Jack in the bamboo looking up smiling as the Ajira plane finally escaped the island was fantastic and in my top finale moments right up there with the school bus fleeing Sunnydale and Adama getting shot.

I was surprised the very end wasn't Jack's eye re-opening, back at the crash site, as it all started again. For years I have thought that was going to be the ending. I think it works better then a bright light, so it's kind of the ending I'm going with in my head. And I like the darker ending for a show that has never been all that happy for long.

Many of the questions related to the island are based on the capricious nature of Jacob. His game, his rules. I got the impression he was kind of simple and just made up the rules to the game as he went along. Ultimately, I don't think anyone knew all the answers. Certainly not Jacob, and obviously not MIB either based on his look of sheer confusion when Jack is able to draw blood.

I'm in the opposite camp than many of you, the more I think about the finale, the more I really like it.

RE: Sayid and Shannon. I liked them as a couple. I was under the impression that Sayid felt unworthy of love because of what he had done, and Nadia knew about that and loved him anyway; when he met Shannon, and they started to like (and grow to love) each other, even though he told her what he had done, he recognized that he *was* worthy of being loved in spite of that. Nadia was LONG gone by that time, and Shannon helped him to that realization, so it's fully logical that she would be the one he'd meet. Or, y'know, mostly.

All you satisfied fans bitching about us not satisfied fans bitching need to stop bitching.

Ooooo, good for you. You liked the ending. I am so happy for you all. But I didn’t. And I will bitch and moan and lament all I fucking want. It was a cheap ending compared to all the awesome the show promised; a hot, high end call girl who didn’t get you off and left you with gonorrhea.

Didn’t Cuse & Linedlof say they wanted an ending that people would talk about for years? Well, they got it. But not in the context they wished.

Bad Robot! Bad, bad, BAD ROBOT!

Bahaha! That was funny...oh and they forgot the ultimate Lost mystery: "why didn't Hurley ever lose any weight?" From what I understand the answer is: "Because he was dead." What a bunch of crap. I'd feel cheated if I'd watched the whole thing. So glad I stopped watching at the polar bear episode.

Actually, the vast majority of those questions were answered (though some indirectly-you gotta pay attention) throughout the show. That's not to say there weren't still some loose ends, dead ends or course corrections (there were plenty), but I find it odd that there are people who were apparently looking for the finale to essentially be 2 1/2 hours of exposition. And these are largely the same people who (rightly) bitched about "Across the Sea" for being just that. They must really loathe David Lynch movies.

I'm not an apologist. There were plenty of things I would've liked to see done differently, but leaving aside the "heaven" storyline, pretty much everything else was wrapped up fine. The questions that were answered were the ones the characters themselves sought answers to, as it should be. My take, in case y'all are still reading, they were all brought to the Island to save the world from Smokey and take over for Jacob (who knew he had failed). He brought them all because no one of them could do it alone. Along the way, much like in Fat Albert, they all learned a little about themselves. Some found redemption and life and some died. The end. Given that as the basic story, is it really that important where a toy truck came from?

I've got mixed feelings about this video. Most of them are irrelevant, some of them had been answered either directly or indirectly, and some of them are important, unanswered questions that fans legitimately had a right to know the answer for.

I don't really care what the Hurley Bird was all about, and I can just make an assumption on who built the statue/temple. I know why Dharma was there, and I think I know why Richard said he saw them all die. I honestly don't care about why Eko or the pilot was killed by Smokey.

However..... Waaalt- I understand why he needed to be written off the show in real life, but the way they handled it in-show was to just not address it? Just saying the island was done with him, and he should live his life? That was a copout. The infertility issue is another thing that was never explained, that we deserved an explanation (in-show) for.

My point is that they've been doing this from the beginning, and I think they at some point made a conscious decision to just not explain certain things, maybe before they even brought them up. They made the fatal mistake of thinking "mysterious island is mysterious" would be an acceptable answer. They also made the mistake of letting us think that we would get specific answers.

I'm sorry, but that doesn't change my feeling about the finale, though. Still gripping and emotional. Doesn't change the fact that I had a great time watching it over the years.

Hi fans !

Carlton and I decided that we needed to provide you with some answers that we kept only for you, because we love and respect all the opinions we keep reading on this awesome site that is Pajiba !
So we read that some of you seem to be a bit disappointed by the series finale. We can understand that. We really messed up with all the emotional bullshit, but really, how could we do otherwise ? We tried to explain all the shit we've been dragging with us since the beginning of the show, but it still didn't make no sense !

We watched "The X-Files" finale, and then the one from "The Prisoner" over and over to inspire us; but for us it was too damn difficult to answer it all in only two episodes ! Yeah, I know, we had a whole season to do so... But see, Carlton wanted so much for people not to see that the mysteries were bullshit from the beginning that he made me piling that shit up til the end, when it was too late to undo anything.
So what did we do ? We did like everybody else: when desperate and looking for answers, we turned to religion, like every good mystery (but really, it was all about the characters since day one) TV Show. And so, our message to all LOST fans is really this: go to church, embrace our god (the Christian One - yeh, we did explain this name !), then you'll find all the answers you need. Except the ones for the LOST mysteries, noone has them.

God Be With You,
Carlton&Damon (wefuckugood@hotmail.com).

totally agree w/myjetski and everyone else on here who didnt need every little answer spelled out for them. (although I really do wish they hadn't given up on explaining what Walt was and why the Dharma initiative couldnt deal w/trying to figure him out)
Most of the answers were provided or easy to piece together. Most of those questions are ridiculous and would have equalled alot of stupid full disclosure moments on the show.
Also, I wish people who barely watched the show would quit chiming in about how right they were and how none of it made sense or satisfied...Of course it didnt work for you... you didn't like the show.
To the avid fans who still feel disappointed, its definately sad you couldnt enjoy the way it concluded and feel cheated, but I honestly feel like that finale was completely in sync w/ the themes and tone that the series represented throughout all six years. It wasn't a left field cop out...it just wasnt the aspect of the show that you had been maniacly honing in on. oh well.

Fredo, BSG was an amazing show until the last episode, when it finally became clear that the writers were just pulling it out of their asses. Before Starbuck disappeared like a fart in the wind the show was a must-have box-set purchase for me, but afterwards the entire show became tainted. I can't go back and relive the mystery because I'll know exactly when I'm being cheated. Like someone said, this is the problem with having to publish parts of your story, in order, before you even finish it.

I'm no creator of fiction, but if I were, I wouldn't ask people to buy my shit if I didn't know where it was going. If I ever write a pilot, I'm at least going to THINK about how the show would end and what my story would basically be about. Sure, I'd pump in filler mysteries to ensure long-term employment, but I would still have an objective in mind. I think that's just the responsible thing to do, as it marks the difference between a great storyteller and a hawker of cheap entertainments.

LOST will forever be known as an example of "make it up as you go along" storytelling. And I'm not quite sure that I dislike the show for that reason, or because of the apologists who insist that that isn't the case. BSG fooled me once, shame on me; it didn't happen again.

Let. It. Go.

One question and only one from me. In the first season it was hinted that Walt had these "powers" in a flashback when he is angry a bird flies into his window (later hinted at when they talk about the polar bear and Michael looks at his son in a "you're a freak" way). I'm annoyed that was never answered. They should have made Walt a 13 year old (instead of 10 years old) because then the whole "growing up thing" would have fit with the timeline of the series and they could have kept him.

Why is it impossible to create a series where you have a clear sense of where you are supposed to go and where the show should end up.

I had the opposite reaction after watching this video. That stuff either didn't seem all that important or we pretty much could infer the answers from paying attention all these years.

Simon, I actually thought they had moved the show up three years so that they could fit Walt back into the show, but alas, I was wrong.

Just found this:
http://www.spoilertv.co.uk/forum/viewtopic.php?f=17&t=19342&start=0

It's written by a supposed Bad Robot employee (claims to be a writer for Lost) and he tries to explain the big unanswered questions.

he basically says they intentionally left some things vague so that the viewer could attach their own answers, and ultimately, their own meanings to some of the mysteries of the island.

To me that's what good literature (art? cinema? TV? whatever?) should do: get your mind to thinking without imposing answers upon you. In essence, it should make you think on your own about whatever it is the piece of art sparks in your mind.

Maybe that's why so many painters and writers never really explain what their stuff is about...the works don't mean the same thing to everybody, but as long as they prompt you towards "A" meaning, the art has achieved its purpose.

Excellent job.

I love youtube vids. I sometimes take vids during my holidays and put them up on youtube. I cant get over how many people watch and comment on my vids. Have even made some friends via youtube.It's great!