free counter with statistics Fox orders Lie to Me as a Midseason Replacement | Pajiba - Scathing Reviews for Bitchy People

mr-orange.jpg


Ok, Here’s a Lie — The Folks at Fox are Geniuses…

Originality Can be Found Weeping in the Corner / Seth Freilich

Trade News | September 24, 2008 | Comments (14)


Man alive. Just the other day, I was telling you about Fox’s wonderful plan for a law show based on Snow White and the Seven Dwarves. I miss those days. Because at least that show was something different.

Now comes word that Fox has given a 13-episode order to “Lie to Me,” which will be a midseason replacement show. The one good thing about the show is that it will star Tim Roth. The bad? The show itself. From the press release:

When you scratch your chin, wring your hands, wrinkle your nose or swallow too much, Dr. Cal Lightman (Roth) knows you’re lying. He doesn’t just think so he knows so. As the foremost deception expert in the country, Dr. Lightman, can uncover the deepest secrets and crack the hardest cases. More accurate than any polygraph, he knows whether those in front of him be they family, friends, criminals or complete strangers are honest or not.

I think I saw this show on CBS last night. It’s called “The Mentalist.” Not a great show, but not terrible either. And I’m willing to bet that it’s better than this. The only way they can redeem this show that I haven’t even seen yet is if they get Emily Richards’ “Lie to Me” for the opening credits. I would then at least think about tuning in for the opening of the first episode.

…Or I am I lying? Tell me, Dr. Lightman.


It's Rashomon's Turn to Be Remade | Slacker Uprising



Comments

It's funny how the (non-existant) demand for more cop shows has caused the industry to just create shows about fake shit. No one like this exists. At least, no one like this exists in the sense that someone can actually do this. Also, how would this guy help prosecute anyone? This guys fake talent wouldn't hold up in court. The point of 'Law and Order' and to a MUCH smaller extent a few early episodes of CSI was to give an inside look into how the system works.

And the reason why we invented a machine to detect lies is because it's impossible for a human to do this. We then found out it is impossible for a machine to do this. This is because sometimes the truth is a lie and vice versa.

Posted by: mark at September 24, 2008 11:19 AM

I'd rather remember the Tim Roth who played the effeminate swordsman in Rob Roy. Not some "if Quincy were a polygraph technician" douche.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at September 24, 2008 11:19 AM

Are we done here? Good, cus I've got a very hot date tonight.

Posted by: Moe at September 24, 2008 11:53 AM

Fucking. Fuck.

I hate official statements with improper spelling, grammar, or punctuation.

"He doesn't just think so he knows so."

"More accurate than any polygraph, he knows whether those in front of him be they family, friends, criminals or complete strangers are honest or not."

Fuck you, Fox, for dumbing down the world. SEE? I just used commas correctly! They have money. What's their excuse for not hiring a proofreader?

Posted by: Lucas at September 24, 2008 11:54 AM

Coincidentally, last night I watched Human Face, a BBC TV miniseries hosted by John Cleese (from my Netflix queue). And one of the tidbits offered by Cleese was that when shown clips of people telling stories, and asked which were liars and which were telling the truth, people are astonishingly bad at telling them apart. The probability of catching liars was no better than chance.

Same goes for people like psychiatrists, judges, police, and yep, even polygraph technicians (so daily exposure to liars doesn't help). The only group of people who beat the odds were spies/secret agents (they could tell liars 80% of the time).

Yes, I know this is a TV show (from FOX at that), but really, could they at least pretend to pay attention to science/reality?

Posted by: True_Blue at September 24, 2008 12:08 PM

So.... you are saying this is a blatant rip-off of the Mentalist, which is a clear rip-off of Pysch. Way to go Fox!

Posted by: NImue516 at September 24, 2008 12:14 PM

Dammit, Fox, put some effort into these releases! You can't just go throwing commas around all willy-nilly. That sort of shit gets you a shanking in prison. Trust me.

Posted by: Macafee at September 24, 2008 12:25 PM

And so once again, Fox's corporate strategy is revealed as "Do what someone else is doing, only trashier". The only thing that can redeem this show is if Dr. Lightman builds a boy robot with an arm cannon.

Posted by: Master Mahan at September 24, 2008 12:27 PM

I actually used to work with a woman who thought she could do this crap. She was a former sales-rep who had "come inside" as they say and taken a job in HR. She insisted on taking all senior job candidates to lunch and then writing a report on their facial expressions, where they cast their eyes when talking, how they fidgeted, etc. She had about 2 brain cells that had ever worked and by the time I met her even those two had seen better days but she swore she knew all about people. She would become inordinately upset if a candidate was hired after she had "caught them lying". But the worst part was that the VP of HR bought into her shit and let it go on.

Posted by: PaddyDog at September 24, 2008 12:28 PM

So I watched the Mentalist last night and I kinda liked it because it wasn't quirky like Psych. Mind you, Psych is like candy, and therefore, has its place in the menu of tv I watch sometimes, but it's mostly Sunday mornings, noodling around the house doing laundry.

I liked the Mentalist because it was a little darker. And I loved how they ripped on the whole "Crossing Over" bit...
I do wish they'd let the actors use their own accents. Do they not let them do that because they think Brit/Aussie accents sound elitist?

Posted by: Stella at September 24, 2008 12:41 PM

I will not watch the Mentalist as it violates a cardinal rule of television: if from the 30 second spot I can fill out the madlib: "It's like __________, except that ____________" that was doubtlessly the show's pitch to the network and feel completely confident as to both its accuracy and comprehensive description of everything about the show then there is no reason to watch the creatively devoid pilot.

For example, the Mentalist is: "It's like Psyche except it's brooding"

"Cooking for Real": "It's like Rachel Ray except she's black."

"CSI: ____": "It's like CSI except in _______"

"CSI": "It's like Law & Order except it's hip and edgy"

"Hole in the Wall": "It's like Jeopardy except it's for people who's only demonstrable skill is thrusting body parts through holes."

Posted by: stipe42 at September 24, 2008 12:55 PM

I believe Sarah Palin is a breath of fresh air to the Political world. She's taken on the Good Old Boys network, she said "thanks, but no thanks" to the Bridge to Nowhere, and she's going to bring much needed experience and expertise to the White House.

What? The show is named Lie To Me? Oh...I thought you were seriously asking us to lie to you? Goddamn...I'll never get the taste of horseshit out of my mouth. Now I know how Rudy Giuliani feels.

"Hole in the Wall": "It's like Jeopardy except it's for people who's only demonstrable skill is thrusting body parts through holes."

I would beg to differ on that one. I hear the big winners are allowed to have "guests" with them when they tape the show. Look at the tapes, you'll see Ken Jennings thrusting back and forth everytime he goes into "Final Jeopardy". Why do you think the podiums are so huge?

Posted by: Mike R. at September 24, 2008 1:12 PM

Most cop shows are recruitment tools that glamorize and make attractive a mind-numbingly monotonous job that involves obsequy and back-biting, not to mention working shoulder-to-shoulder with the scum of the Earth.

And then there's the "fringe benefits".

Insert Dignam's quote from The Departed here:


"Most people just want to slam a ______'s head through a plate-glass window."

Posted by: Recondite at September 24, 2008 3:32 PM

I dont know....I might watch this just because Tim Roth is in it...So long as he gets to play English...I mean even if he dons an accent but...English will be best...


I mean dudes, he's Tim Roth! He's Mister Orange, He's...He' Archibald Cunningham.

Yes this show might be The Mentalist, Monk and Pysch all over again


But this time there's the potential Hulking out, of diamond heists, and of rape for no other reason than being a clever tactition!!!


It might be amazing!

Posted by: nadine at September 25, 2008 8:02 AM