![]()
A Very Special Christmas Movie For Me
This Christmas / Claude Weaver III
I know what you’re thinking: Another formulaic movie aimed at African Americans? And a Christmas-themed one at that? Great. Walking in, the whole idea just reeked of failure to me; I assumed I’d make it through no more than ten minutes before nodding off in my popcorn. Only a simulcast colonoscopy could be more painful to watch, right? Well, not so fast. Actually, while This Christmas isn’t going to change your life, it doesn’t try to, either. And while it tries to shoehorn too much story into its two-hour running time, it nevertheless manages to be a pretence-free, moderately entertaining way to pass two hours of your life.
In This Christmas, writer/director/producer Preston A. Whitmore II (Crossover) introduces us to the Whitfields, a large African-American family headquartered in the Los Angeles suburban home of family head “Ma’Dear” (Dreamgirls’ Loretta Devine). The story focuses on the week of Christmas, where Ma’Dear welcomes her children and their significant others. The main theme of the film is the idea of secrets we keep from family, and the false rationale that we are protecting them by doing so. The film even begins with Ma’Dear requesting that her long-time boyfriend, Joe Black (Delroy Lindo, NBC’s short-lived “Kidnapped”) help perpetrate the illusion that he doesn’t live there, for the sake of her children.
The Whitfield children each have their individual secrets, ones that seem enormous at first but once revealed aren’t as destructive as originally believed. The main motivation for all the clandestine behavior is Ma’Dear, who still holds hard feelings against Senior, the Whitfield patriarch who left the family in order to follow a career in music. In an effort to dull the pain, she has essentially banned soul and jazz from her house and subconsciously caused her children (especially her sons) to fear upsetting her with their issues. Of course, by film’s end, all the secrets lay unveiled, (almost) all the problems are addressed, and everyone is able to enjoy their Christmas dinner.
The casting is solid, though the assemblage of talent is more than the movie deserved. Devine was superb in her role as Ma’Dear, and Lindo (who also produced) gets to enjoy saving the day as Joe Black. He could have easily embodied a deus ex machine, but Whitmore manages to keep his heroics on a human level. Chris Brown (Stomp The Yard) plays the role of Baby, the youngest of the family, whose particular secret just so happens to revolve around singing, which leads to both of the film’s major musical performances. Brown holds his own in the acting department, but I wouldn’t want him to quit his day job too soon.
An intriguing casting choice was Regina King (Boondocks, Enemy of the State) as the oldest daughter, Lisa. At first it was confusing, since Lisa was supposed to be the put-upon, weak-willed housewife ignored by her family, and as an actress King is mostly known to be the very opposite of that. While she strained credibility at first, during her character’s immensely entertaining vengeance moment, she shines. This is made even the more interesting when comparing Lisa to her sister Kelli (Sharon Leal, “Boston Public”). In these “family reunion” movies, the older sister is usually the one dispensing advice and butting her head in when it isn’t wanted, while the younger sister is the one making the mistakes and acting unsure of her self-worth. Having the two archetypical roles switched made for an interesting dynamic. Indeed, this tweaking of the staid formula, combined with the solid performances, is the film’s greatest strength.
Unfortunately, this strength also enhances the movie’s largest weakness. In an effort to fit all the stories in, the filmmakers ultimately leave some subplots dangling and create glorified extras out of some of the characters. To use an apt holiday metaphor, Whitmore ends up stuffing this stocking with so many goodies that the seams burst and some of the little treats get lost. You’ll still get some satisfaction, but it won’t feel quite complete.
So there you have it. This Christmas may not be perfect, and it’s certainly not original. And like most holiday films, you need a bit of suspension of disbelief. But unless you have a blackened piece of coal in place of your heart that feeds on only pure unadulterated hatred, you’ll likely enjoy it. It’s definitely a better movie if you bring along the family.
And at least it isn’t a Tyler Perry film.
Claude Weaver III aka Vermillion is a mild-mannered student at Morehouse College and budding reality show star. Oh, and he forgot to mention Regina King is in lingerie. Twice. That alone is worth the price of admission. You can get more over at his blog, Vermillion’s Brain Receptacle.
You Ride It Like a Skeleton Horse Through the Gates of Hell | | Margot at the Wedding
Comments
Good review. Never been the kind of person to enjoy "formulaic movies aimed at African Americans" like this (Tyler Perry's anything, Soul Food, How Stella Got Her Groove Back, etc.), but this sounds like a winner. Plus, I like Regina King in what roles I've seen her in. I really hope that this film makes me forget her role in Miss Congeniality 2, a movie so bad it will haunt my dreams for years to come.
Posted by: jonr at November 26, 2007 12:13 PM
Was on the fence until the mention of Regina King, she IS the Booondocks (in animated form) watching it should be mandatory, for all races. I'll probably have to rent it though, the ain't gonna bring that here.
Posted by: BarbadoSlim at November 26, 2007 12:20 PM
I really enjoy watching Regina King, but can't STAND Loretta Devine.....thus, I am torn.
Posted by: Finn at November 26, 2007 12:30 PM
And at least it isn't a Tyler Perry film.
Yet unfortunately, I doubt this film would have been green-lighted if not for Mr. Perry and his Ma'Dere. Le Sigh.
Like I said somewhere else before, I was surprised to see a Christmas movie about black people. Aside from "Roots: the Gift", have there been many others? At any rate, I applaud their efforts, despite the lackluster script and presence of the squeaky, simple, asthmatic that is Loretta Devine.
Here's to anticipating that next black Christmas movie with Gabrielle Union... I'm sure it's got the same title as an R&B song...
Posted by: Ciji at November 26, 2007 12:43 PM
I don't understand where the hate for Loretta Devine is coming from. She cracks me up... I can't think of a movie of hers where I found her annoying.
And Delroy Lindo. Mmm. There is nothing sexier than a stoic soft spoken man, and he exudes that. And he rocks a mean goatee. It's sad that he seems to have been relegated to Kung Fu Action Movie Sensei/Sidekick roles. (A quick IMDB check just proved that apparently it is *I* that watches too many of those movies).
And finally, while I don't plan on seeing this in the movie theater (mostly cuz I hate Christmasy movies of any sort, unless they're on tv, so I can watch furtively while folding laundry), I don't know if I can buy Regina King as a "put-upon, weak-willed housewife". But if you say she sells it, then I'm game to give her a try.
As a quick aside, you know how sometimes scenes from a movie or a tv show will just stay with you (like my uncanny recollection of The Rock's outfit on Regis and whatsherface Live from a million years ago).... I have a similar memory of Regina King in that Tom Cruise movie, where she thinks Cuba Gooding Jr may be dead, or paralyzed, and one of her relatives makes a stupid comment, and she leaps, LEAPS, over everyone to smack him? I don't know why but I love her for doing that. And as much as I HATED the movie, that scene pops into my head every now and again.
Posted by: Stella at November 26, 2007 1:36 PM
Although this might be more of a rental for me, I'm glad to see the decent review for it. Regina King has always been a fave; she's grown nicely from playing the little sister role to an intelligent grown woman. And yes, she is amazing in The Boondocks. One of the few shows I'll actually watch every week.
The only thing that bothers me is the trailer. Is it just me, or do they pretty much give the secret away w/ Chris Brown's character?
Posted by: Brie at November 26, 2007 1:54 PM
Delroy Lindo! Delroy Lindo! He's one of those actors whose presence in a movie is often its saving grace.
And yeah for Chris Brown, small town Virginia boy who's done pretty well for himself.
Posted by: Alabamapink at November 26, 2007 1:58 PM
Forget Delroy Lindo! Frickin' Stringer Bell is in this movie!! And since I've started to watch The Wire I have vowed to watch Idris Elba in anything he does.
Posted by: Tanner at November 26, 2007 2:15 PM
I'll watch anything with Regina King, and Delroy Lindo is a major bonus.
Posted by: Olivia at November 26, 2007 2:42 PM
Ditto much love for Delroy and Regina. They can make almost anything better.
Posted by: LL at November 26, 2007 3:57 PM
Claude/Vermillion, you can only wish to have the success of Tyler Perry. I wonder if your hypocrisy would stand in the way of appearing in one of his movies if he offered you a part? I have an idea for a reality show. It's about a loser who's followed around town by a camera crew as he goes from one audition to the next trying to get a part in a TP film. And after being turned down for roles in Perry's films he developes a hatred for TP and begins stalking him in a clown suit.
Posted by: Pookie at November 26, 2007 4:35 PM
Idris Elba! Delroy Lindo! They had me at hello. Or whatever.
Posted by: Cara at November 26, 2007 5:16 PM
Wasn't this the basic plot to "A Very Brady Christmas"?
Posted by: muchsarcasm at November 26, 2007 5:58 PM
And at least it isn't a Tyler Perry film.
Exactly. That and the fact the matriarch is actually a woman makes this an automatic upgrade.
Yes, Regina King is awesome. And underrated. She and Nia Long are two of my favorite actresses.
Stella, I think that scene was in Jerry Maguire.
Oh, yeah - Vermillion, marry me! (Drink!)
Posted by: Daphne at November 26, 2007 6:10 PM
I usually avoid movies like this in theaters, since I'm a crybaby, and don't like to humiliate myself in public, but I may try to catch it on cable.
On a side note, the local paper had a very similar review, and while I hesitate to think this means they're actually pulling thier heads out of their asses and paying attention to what's on screen, I suppose there could be hope. Ultimately, though, I'm far more willing to trust Pajiba reviewers. Seems safer that way.
Posted by: pinkcheese at November 26, 2007 6:27 PM
Vermillion? Claude? Weaver? III ??????
Posted by: greer at November 26, 2007 6:44 PM
I also have an idea for a reality show. It's about some asshole named after the teddy bear from Garfield comic strips who sits on his ass, bitches anonymously online, and masturbates while eating creamed corn out of the can. Sometimes he has a point, but most of the time he's just being his douchebaggy self for no reason at all.
The big question is, who do I get to play aforementioned lead? Hmmmm . . .
Posted by: Fernando at November 26, 2007 9:29 PM
Oh, so you don't masturbate?
Posted by: Pookie at November 26, 2007 10:17 PM
while I won't be seeing this movie--I actually "have a blackened piece of coal in place of [my] heart that feeds on only pure unadulterated hatred"--I am glad to see all the Regina King love around here.
she is fabulous on Boondocks, but I have been a fan for years (227?). I really like her, not only because we look a lot alike--seriously, we look like sisters--but she is also a very talented actress.
oh, and good review Claude--Tripp?--ok, Vermillion.
Posted by: pq at November 27, 2007 12:00 AM
A few scattered comments.
Matriarchs are /usually/ women, ya know?
I think we need a whole comment diversion about whom we should cast in the Pookie Movie, as Pookie.
Finally, when I saw the previews for this, I didn't actually think 'formulaic black film' at all. It didn't have that vibe. However, there are a couple of things that annoyed me about the preview.
First of all, I absolutely hate the stylistic cliche of character-says-something-snappy/funny-then-walks out-of-the-shot. It's as lame as the man-walks-away-from-explosion-without-looking-back. I saw this at least twice in the previews.
Secondly, was that "This Christmas" song being sung in a /church/? Am I mistaken or were the lyrics something like "Hang all the mistletoe
I'm gonna get to know you better, yeah". Whoah.
Look, I totally understand that Christmas isn't about Jesus for everyone. It never has been in my family. But...that sure looked like a Church they were sitting in...
Posted by: amea_gari at November 27, 2007 2:13 AM
Ciji, the Christmas movie with Gabrielle Union is opening December 12th: The Perfect Holiday (can't post imdb link, damn u link filter).
As long as Pajiba lets faithful readers/posters give a try at writing reviews, can BarbadoSlim cover it? Please? Pretty please? With cherry on top?
Posted by: irina at November 27, 2007 2:24 AM
As long as Pajiba lets faithful readers/posters give a try at writing reviews, can BarbadoSlim cover it? Please? Pretty please? With cherry on top?
Posted by: irina at November 27, 2007 2:24 AM
------------------------------------------------
Hahahahaha
But seriously, I shall not seek nor will I accept such a task. I would be an affront to those who have the passion and craft to do it right.
Posted by: BarbadoSlim at November 27, 2007 5:20 AM
Matriarchs are /usually/ women, ya know?
amea_gari, I'm pretty sure that Daphne was just saying that she's glad they actually cast a woman for this part, instead of assuming that only a man can play a leader/wise roll, a la Tyler Perry's (and Martin Lawrence's) penchant for dressing up as a woman in order to portray the all knowing, wise "matriarch" in their films.
Posted by: pinkcheese at November 27, 2007 9:46 AM
As for Pookie: The Movie, I vote Dane Cook.
Posted by: Fernando at November 27, 2007 10:26 AM
Dane Cook...
Heh, I can hear the promos...there's only one Aktober, one Puhjiba, there's only one Pookie, that's right, like getting a rectal exam except he ain't a doctor and won't be using sterile gloves...*tight close-up, gives finger*
Posted by: BarbadoSlim at November 27, 2007 12:54 PM
I so love this movie,and I sing every song that was played on the movie all day long.Chris Brown is my teen idol,and I follow and study every move her make,I WANT TO BE THE GIRL VIRGIN OF HIM SOMEDAY.I've got the mover form James Brown to Chris Brown,I sing,dance,crump,mime,I DO IT ALL....Hope to see me and u on the 'Big Screen' together oneday!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Zakeiha at November 27, 2007 7:58 PM
I so love this movie,and I sing every song that was played on the movie all day long.Chris Brown is my teen idol,and I follow and study every move her make,I WANT TO BE THE GIRL VIRGIN OF HIM SOMEDAY.I've got the mover form James Brown to Chris Brown,I sing,dance,crump,mime,I DO IT ALL....Hope to see me and u on the 'Big Screen' together oneday!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Zakeiha at November 27, 2007 7:58 PM
Yeah, what pinkcheese said.
Posted by: Daphne at November 27, 2007 10:16 PM
Didn't they already do a movie about Pookie? Wasn't it Kickin It Old School with Jamie Kennedy?
Posted by: insertclevernamehere at November 28, 2007 11:11 AM
"amea_gari, I'm pretty sure that Daphne was just saying that she's glad they actually cast a woman for this part, instead of assuming that only a man can play a leader/wise roll, a la Tyler Perry's (and Martin Lawrence's) penchant for dressing up as a woman in order to portray the all knowing, wise "matriarch" in their films."
Ah, I got it now! Fine point. Sorry. :)
Posted by: amea_gari at November 28, 2007 1:04 PM
what I couldn't figure out was the 15 minutes of soul train dancing at the end.
Posted by: beltseri at December 4, 2007 11:52 PM
your movie title "this christmas" is it out in store. I have call all over idaho falls. and it not in. I thought it has been release.
Posted by: Felecia at March 6, 2008 11:06 PM

