web
counter
 

On Loving, and Losing, Pets

By Michael Murray | Posted Under Think Pieces | Comments (96)



Loving Touch.jpg
“And it’s exceedingly short, his galloping life. Dogs die so soon. I have my stories of that grief, no doubt many of you do also. It is almost a failure of will, a failure of love, to let them grow old—or so it feels. We would do anything to keep them with us, and keep them young. The one gift we cannot give.” —Mary Oliver

I’ve never had children and so I really don’t have a clue what sort of parent I might make, but if the way my dog behaves around me is any sort of indicator, the forecast is not good. The dog, much like a contemptuous teen embarrassed to be in the presence of square, old dad, is entitled, bossy and utterly indifferent to my increasingly impotent commands. Clearly, my accidentally anti-Cesar Milan stratagem of infantilization, over protection, ignorance and senseless praise has proven to work just about the way you would expect it to work. No matter, Rachelle and I love our dog dearly and would do anything for her.

Heidi, a Miniature Dachshund with ears like velvet and a scar on her long, needle nose, came into our lives nearly five years ago and immediately, in the way that only animals can, began to pour light into our days. Dogs are remarkable creatures, so sincere, simple and absent of self-pity, they ask little more than the opportunity to give love. Unburdened by the self-serving necessities of language, they project their beautiful spirits through their eyes and poker-tell tails, radiating optimism and instilling in us a simple, warm pleasure that’s as true and uncomplicated as anything we’ve ever known.

randh.JPG

At any rate, you can probably tell where this is headed, and when Rachelle and I returned home from a weekend away we found that our dog had developed a serious back problem. The breed is prone to this, and over the years I’ve allowed the animal to indulge her native athleticism in bounding, jumping, climb-the-stairs kind of ways that others would not. I’m not sure if this renders me negligent or not— it may well— but I simply don’t feel right about preventing a creature from living in a way that fulfills all of it’s natural instincts and potential.

She was in obvious, hear-breaking distress and we took her to a 24 hour vet clinic in the dead of night, imagining only the dimmest traces of what a parent must feel when they have a sick child. Our dog daughter stayed over night with a grim prognosis hanging over her, while we waited at home for the vet to call the next day.

What would have been my morning walk with Heidi — in which we’d touch so many of the points of light surrounding our lives — was marked only by her absence. As melodramatic as it might sound, the day faded from color to a monotone grey, and a depression fell upon me. Beset by dread and anxiety, the surrounding atmosphere felt as laden with disaster as if I had sensed a change in the weather just before the tornadoes touched down to toss the world asunder.

But we were lucky, I think. The vet’s call revealed our dog has degenerative disc disease, but that it looks like it will be manageable, and so she will stay with us for as long as the world will allow. But still, this tremor of mortality was jarring and depressing in fresh ways even though I, like everybody else, has lost pets in the past and is almost certainly destined to do so again.

I grew up in a household that always had a cat as a pet and learned to love them as I’ve now come to love dogs. Years ago I returned to my parent’s house in Ottawa where I grew up to discover that Malcolm, the cherished family cat, was sick. Fragile, his coat was spiky and all his grace had vanished. His movements through the living room were stiff and scared, and although he was trying to be who he once was, he could not. It was heart-breaking, of course, as I had never seen something I had wholly loved degenerate so vividly before me, and I think for the first time I had a partial understanding of how my family must have felt when they had seen me, so very ill with cancer, years before when I was younger. I wanted so much for Malcolm to be better, to get stronger and return to the things he loved. I just wanted to breathe life back into him, but there was nothing I could do.

One day that weekend when I couldn’t find him, I went down to the basement where I understood he had been retreating—a quite place from which he might finally exhale. And I remembered that feeling so well, of being sick and driving through the Gatineau Hills with my mother, wanting nothing more than to go to something green, lie down and return to the earth.

I called out the cat’s name several times, scared to hear either a thin and battered response or the emptiness of nothing at all, when a frail mewling answered me. Disoriented, he had jammed himself between the washing machine and work bench. I moved a few things and he squeezed his ruined body toward me, his eyes now reddish and clouded.

My old friend.

My mother came down and cleaned all the basement dust off his coat with a comb and blanket. She swaddled him like a baby and held him to her breast, rocking him, speaking to him gently. Scooping cat food out of the tin with her finger, she tried to feed him and gave him water from an eyedropper. She transported him around the house in a laundry basket so he was never alone. She did everything she possibly could for him, and as I watched her I saw everything that she and all of my family had done for me when I was sick.

Wiping tears from her eyes she told me that they would have to put him down in the morning, that there was nothing more that could be done for him. I was nodding my head, sitting beside them, knowing that this was the last time that I would see Malcolm, the cat I gave to my mother for Christmas a dozen years before. The cat whose presence helped see me through my darkest days when I’d recoil from human contact, worried that I would break if touched or disgust the healthy, and Malcolm, I am sure, sensing that, would curl against me on the bed, lending me his heat and weight, purring while I stroked his coat with my bony hand.

momcat.jpgAnd so I sat there on the sofa telling the cat all the things that he had done for me, all the good things that he was and how much I loved him, but I was also telling my mother these things about herself, too. And as I praised him, I praised her, for sometimes it’s easier to communicate our love indirectly, through animals, in the hopes that it reaches outward and touches the people we love, too. And speaking in this weird and personal way, tears were streaming down my face and dropping heavily upon the newspaper, and it felt like the cat was giving me a final gift of catharsis.

My cat buddy.

Malcolm who would race like lightning up the stairs. Malcolm who would stare at trees and lose fights. Malcolm whose ears became frosted with grey. My mother and Malcolm, beautiful until the end, she staying up and holding him dear all night long, until the morning when she poured her love into him up until his final moment.

Michael Murray is a freelance writer. He presently lives in Toronto. You can find more of his musings on his blog, or check out his Facebook page.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Pajiba After Dark 8/7/11 | When I See the Way You Paint Your Lips and I Smell Your Perfume: The Worst Fake Blondes









Comments

Sniff!

Posted by: BWeaves at August 5, 2011 11:03 AM

A lot of times I'll be hyperbolic about how I really react to something, my real feelings being only a tenth of what I make them out to be. This is not one of those occasions. This essay was so tragically beautiful that I started tearing up. Thanks for sharing it.

Posted by: Socrates_Johnson at August 5, 2011 11:04 AM

I started reading this and couldn't quite finish. And it's nothing to do with your writing (which I always love), but just how close to home it hit.

Just last week I had a minor breakdown when my mom called me from home to tell me that they're going to have to put one of my three dogs, Matisse, to sleep. Technically they're the family's dogs, but Matisse was mine, if that makes sense. She's very old for a terrier, almost 13, and she's lived a great, long life. But just the thought of me going home this winter and not seeing her, and of not being able to be there for her...well, hell, there I go again. I better stop before I fall asleep exhausted from crying like I did when I heard the news.

I'll just say that I didn't think it would hit me this hard. "It's just a pet", you want to tell yourself. But they're never just that, are they?

Posted by: Figgy at August 5, 2011 11:06 AM

Goddamnit, Michael. I am a 30 year old man. Fuck you for making me cry at my desk at work.

I got my first dog a year ago and I am already terrified at the prospect of losing her 10 years from now. I'm afraid that when she's gone I will be a miserable wreck forever.

Posted by: Seany D at August 5, 2011 11:06 AM

I'm sure this will be a beautiful thread, but I can't stay. I know everything you are going through; I will be doing the same thing with one of my dogs any day now. I can't do this today.

Posted by: PaddyDog at August 5, 2011 11:07 AM

Damn you.

*goes and finds a corner to cry in*

Posted by: Harley at August 5, 2011 11:07 AM

I couldn't get through this. I held my one golden puppy as he died in my arms when he was only 8 months old (he had been hit by a car on a rainy night). I now have a brilliant Welsh Corgi, Elli. If anything ever happened to her, I would be devastated.

Posted by: pajamas at August 5, 2011 11:09 AM

Seany: It does not last forever, but the hole in your heart never quite closes.

Wonderful essay. Masterfully done. Thank you.

Posted by: Bruce W at August 5, 2011 11:14 AM

Yes.

Posted by: Samantha at August 5, 2011 11:16 AM

As someone whose had dachshunds most of his life and loves Heidi's articles on your blog, this sincerely frightened me when I started reading. I'm just happy that she's not gone, even if it seems that day may come sooner than later. I've lost two of the five wiener dogs I've had in my life to back problems. My current dachshund has cataracts and a heart murmur. Even though dachshunds are infamously irritating (they're too smart to care what you think)I love the little guy and I'll be heartbroken when he's gone.

I'm very sorry for the bad news. Please know that Heidi has strangers in the world that will miss her dearly.

Posted by: Paultera at August 5, 2011 11:18 AM

While I was staying with my grandparents one summer at the age of twelve, the rest of the family came to visit. When I rushed to the door (in a very dog-like way) to greet my boarder collie, Lady (who cares about the family, right?) I was told she had been hit by a car that morning. I didn't have another pet until two years ago.

Now, we have our rescue Molly. She's staying with my parents for two weeks and I'm amazed at just how much we miss her stupid, timid, big, black ass around the house. It's going to be hard when she's gone but she made out far better than she would have. Plus, we're going to adopt another rescue. I have a soft spot for the hard luck cases.

Posted by: admin at August 5, 2011 11:21 AM

This is why I cannot own pets. I love both dogs and cats (and other things), but having one is like having a child you KNOW you're going to outlive. I know we should look at it as giving a good home and happiness to an animal for the time they're here. But I just can't do it.

Posted by: Todd at August 5, 2011 11:26 AM

It's funny how such a small unassuming animal can make such an impact on your life. I sincerely hope Heidi is ok, Michael.

This was lovely. I had the sweetest little Shih Tzu (Winnie) for almost 9 years. She was a Christmas present for my siblings and I when I was 12, and two days after my 21st birthday we had to put her down due to breathing and heart trouble. I tried to go to class the next day and halfway through, after trying desperately to hide the face that I was sobbing, I went up to my Psych professor and explained that I had to leave. Her eyes welled up and she said she completely understood, that she went through the death of her dog the previous year.

My family now has Rizzo, a headstrong Pekinese/poodle with the bravado of a German Shepard. He is the funniest dog and has such a huge personality. He turns 9 this month, the same age as Winnie when she died, and I'm terrified.

Posted by: Julie at August 5, 2011 11:28 AM

Just when I've recovered from my wallow in self-pity and Cindy's invitation make ourselves cry over songs (not to mention that article Lauren linked to), Pajiba brings out the big guns and Michael writes a crushing article about losing beloved pets.

STOP MAKING ME CRY PAJIBA!

Posted by: Mrs. Julien at August 5, 2011 11:43 AM

We lost our dog a couple months ago. It was crazy how quickly she went from being perfectly fine to the condition she was finally in before the end. It was awful. One week she was happily farting and snoring in her sleep and within 3 weeks she had to be on IVs. Her nose was clogged with an infection that no amount of antibiotics seemed to clear and since she couldn't breathe through her nose she couldn't sleep for more than a few minutes at a time. Her eyes turned red rimmed and droopy from the lack of sleep.
She spent her last night at the vet, hooked up to IVs and monitors, and when her pappa and I came to be with her for her last few hours, the image that will stay with me is her putting her head into my hubby's head, sighing deeply and while he gently rubbed her head, finally closing her tired tired eyes in peace. The last image she had of this world was her pappa's face. He'd saved her life when she was six weeks old and she was glued to his side ever since.
The energy in the house feels odd now. We find that we still walk around expecting to find her sleeping somewhere around the house. We've removed her things into the storage shed, but I'm still finding old collars and leashes, or chew toys...
and i need to stop typing. People are starting to wonder why i'm crying...

Posted by: Stella at August 5, 2011 11:44 AM

I scanned at some parts, simply because this morning has been lovely and I can't break down and cry right now. My cat is ill. He has diabetes (which is manageable and has just now become a normal part of our lives) but he now probably has the beginnings of renal failure, though the vet suspects that there might be a tumor as well.

When discussing his quality of life, my vet told me, "When Claws (my kitty) stops being Claws, that's when you know that you know when you have to consider other measures."

Well, the little butthead still tries to steal my porkchops and my spot on the couch, so he's still trucking just all right. But I know that someday, sooner than I ever want, I will have to let him go.

Gah. Screw you for making me cry, goddammit.

Beautifully written, by the way.

Posted by: Kala at August 5, 2011 11:45 AM

Awww man I KNEW I shouldn't have read this. Now I'm all sad and miss my cats (RIP.) Damnit, Michael.

Posted by: JenVegas at August 5, 2011 11:51 AM

That was beautiful. I'm sorry about your kitty. I had to put down my kittyfriend of 16 years around this time last year, and it about broke my heart. So hard to get thru. I love that you told your kitty how much you loved him. You have a good heart.

Posted by: ChickaBoom! at August 5, 2011 11:52 AM

Dammit. Now I'm bummed.

My cat, Slash, shuffled off about 4 years ago. She had 18 pretty good years, but still. Sucks, losing a pet.

Posted by: Slashs at August 5, 2011 11:54 AM

Oh goddammit I cried at work.

Posted by: sarahk at August 5, 2011 12:08 PM

My sister and I each recieved a Border Collie (male and female) as a (slightly late) Christmas present in early '95. We also had numerous cats. As my sister and I moved out (college, miltary) the dogs stayed with my mom so she had company. The cats eventually died or ran away so it was just Mom and the dogs for several years. A few years ago, the dog that was my sister's died. She was 12. Once she died, the remaining dog (mine) was very lackadaisical and my mom figured he might have to be put down soon as well.

Since I had a few kittens where I currently live, I asked if she wanted a kitten. She said yes so she would still have company. Once I got the kitten home, my dog imporved immediately. He was playing agian and moving with more pep. Unfortunately, we still knew that he wouldn't last much longer.

A few months ago, as I was planning my next trip home, my mom asked for another cat to keep the other one company after we put the dog down. I brought the cat and we began to make the plans for my dog's final days. We found a vet that would come to the house and conduct the procedure. It was also a memorable time because it was the first time in several years my sister and I were home at the same time. The vet arrived and we went into the backyard. The vet explained what was going to happen. My mom and sister were visibly emotional. I was maintaining a very stoic facade...Until he closed his eyes for the final time.

Posted by: Kargoyle at August 5, 2011 12:13 PM

Of the three dogs that we have, I'm not ashamed to admit that the oldest is my favorite. She was my first dog that was really mine, and though my wife loves her too, she's clearly far more my dog, and I've doted on her and spoiled her pretty much constantly. She quite literally is the best dog in the world.

She's ten years old now, and white around the muzzle, and getting those lumps and bumps that older dogs get. I used to tell myself she would live forever. Now, every night I look at her adorable, greying face and I start to think about... that... and I just can't. I just can't bear to think it, let alone say it out loud.

I just can't.

Posted by: TK at August 5, 2011 12:14 PM

I just put my Golden, Skater, down this Wednesday. It was so hard, but he was 11 and in obvious arthritic pain among other issues. His aging was so gradual though over the last year or so, that I didn't realize just how much he had deteriorated until my mom (he began as the family pet) came for a visit and mentioned that it was obvious this would be the last time she saw him. That was a month ago, it took me that long to come to grips with what I had to do.

Now, I'm sad when I'm home, and I keep catching myself starting our routines, but I expected that. What I didn't expect was the relief. My sweet boy is not in pain and the decision I knew for a while I was going to have to make is done. Oddly, that's made the past couple of days much easier. That and friends all too willing to distract me.

The house isn't the same and won't be for a while, but he'll always be my big guy, even after the next dog...

Posted by: elecamel at August 5, 2011 12:16 PM

...And now I need to find several tissues.

Posted by: Kargoyle at August 5, 2011 12:17 PM

Beautiful. Really beautiful.

When I was on vacation in Florida the summer before I started high school, I got a phone call from my step-dad telling me that he'd accidentally run over my dog, Pokey. She was old and frail and had taken to sleeping under the back bumper of his SUV, where it was cooler for her. He didn't know she was there when he got in to go to work. She was so badly injured, and so old, there was nothing to be done for her. They put her to sleep while I was in Florida. I never even got to say goodbye, or touch her white fur or kiss her nose. She was my best friend and I miss her so much that it still hurts to his day.

So, even though it made me cry, thanks for writing this. Any excuse to think of Pokey, because thinking of her makes me smile more often than not, is a good thing.

Posted by: Kolby at August 5, 2011 12:20 PM

R.I.P. - Sam, Tazia, Cheri (Cheery), Nanook, Fluffy, Miss Patches, Kit, Kassie, Kano.

I know I am forgetting some, but I can't think straight right now. I love you all.

Posted by: Kargoyle at August 5, 2011 12:27 PM

Goodness gracious...

It's so hard trying not to cry at this.

We've had a couple of dogs and a couple of cats that either died, were lost, or had to be given away for one reason or another, but I was too young to really remember anything. The only one was my Mother's Cat, Butter (short for Butterscotch). We got him while we were living in Holland, and then when we moved to Albuquerque ten years later he died. He was outside in the yard. We're not even completely sure what from, but my mom was not far from inconsolable. She couldn't bare to pick him up, and her friend and neighbor had to do it for her. He was a good, patient cat, but I wasn't heartbroken about it. I was only 14 or 15 at the time, and he was my Mom's, not mine.

Now we have a hound dog who is almost eight. (Unbelievably we still get offers for him from strangers. The other day someone pulled out $1500 in cash for him.) He is everything to us, and he is so visibly old now. His face has gone gray, and a little droopy, and has the fat of a happy, old dog. It takes him a few minutes to get up in the morning, but he's pretty good after that. He's gotten use through some really hard times, and I can't imagine life without him. It's something I think about often. Losing him. Because I know he doesn't have long.

Posted by: Candee at August 5, 2011 12:37 PM

They say timing is everything. I just came back from having to put down my cat of fifteen years. Looking for something to read, I came here and the first article I saw was this. RIP, Vader. I miss you already.

Posted by: RJ at August 5, 2011 12:41 PM

I dread losing one of my cats. I love them a million. They're gonna live long, long lives though; they eat a balanced, raw meat diet & don't go outside. And when my cats pass away, I will weep & mourn, but in their honor I will immediately adopt a new cat from the local shelter. That loss is the perfect opportunity to adopt, to save a life.

Posted by: the new transported man at August 5, 2011 12:41 PM

God damnit I couldn't even finish reading this. Once I got to the part about your cat Malcom I started losing it. Heartbreaking.

The only time I ever saw my Dad cry was when we had to put down our cat, Bo when I was about 13. Just near the end my cat spent a night sleeping in my bed, my sister's bed and then my parent's bed before we knew we had to put him down. It was like he was saying goodbye to each of us. RIP Bo.

Posted by: THRILLHO at August 5, 2011 12:52 PM

Chiming in to say fuck you Murray, for making me cry at work. For the second time this week. (Crying, not Murray making me cry.)

My fiance and I have taken in two stray cats from where we live in West Philly. The first, Pigpen, we acquired two years ago and has become a beloved pet. The second, a sweet gray tabby named Lucy who loves tummy wubbies, came into our lives two weeks ago. Before we could integrate her fully into the household with Pigpen and our Australian Shepherd, we took her to a clinic to be spayed, tested, boosted and de-parasited.

The call came in hours after we dropped her off: Feline leukemia. They asked if we wanted to have her euthanized. Through heavy heart we decided, even if it would be putting our other cat at slight risk, that we only had one option here. She could live six months or six years, but goddammit she is going to live a good life until then.

Posted by: stacey nosek at August 5, 2011 12:52 PM

This was a beautiful tribute to Malcolm, Michael. And I hope Heidi will be all right.

Gah. Cannot cry at work. Must keep it together.

I need to go home and snuggle my two cats.

Posted by: MelBivDevoe at August 5, 2011 12:56 PM

this made me cry so hard i had to grab both of my cats and hold them tight for a few minutes.

Posted by: Jeannine at August 5, 2011 1:14 PM

Oy, this hits hard.

I have a rat terrier/whippet that I got 7+ years ago as a rescue. He was already 8 or 9 at that point, so he's now almost 16, and he's very frail, a little senile, half deaf/half blind, and probably not long for the world. It really is the worst feeling in the world.

Thanks, Michael (another MM), for a beautifully written piece.

Posted by: MM at August 5, 2011 1:40 PM

Thank you. The timing was surreal.

Posted by: dinka at August 5, 2011 1:49 PM

Lost my beagle Lilly to my ex-fiancee in the break-up a couple of years ago. Objectively, it was the right choice, since one of us was going to get screwed in the deal, and I was the one moving away/she was the one with time to take care of the dog. I'm sure Lilly is happier with the ex than she would be with my work-twelve-hours-a-day schedule. That's not much consolation.

So, in sum, yeah, you made me cry at work.

Posted by: thegardenhead at August 5, 2011 1:56 PM

I knew I was in trouble just from the title, but I went ahead and read your fine writing in its entirety. :-(

Posted by: DarthCorleone at August 5, 2011 1:59 PM

First Pajiba post that ever brought me to tears. I dread the day when my 1.5 year old lab/border collie, best friend and most constant, happy companion will not be by my side.

Posted by: Parker at August 5, 2011 2:09 PM

I'm sorry, I guess it's because I have a lump of coal for a heart or something, but while reading this I kept thinking of Monica Geller trying to make her parents cry with her wedding toast and was starting to get the giggles.

On second thought, maybe I'm just immature and mired in pop culture.

Posted by: Gentleman Farmer at August 5, 2011 2:09 PM

You're a very good writer. I'm all verklempt now.

Posted by: mswas at August 5, 2011 2:13 PM

I don't get this. I don't understand people who dress their pets up or assign emotions to them that they obviously cannot possess. I don't understand making yourself miserable about an entity's death rather than celebrate what place their held in one's life seems to be the social norm.

I think I have this view point from working on farms and in a vet clinic as a kid. That and serving overseas. Maybe I am just screwed up in the head because I've never been able to get really emotional in the deaths of people close to me. I find that people, at least to me, have this irrational fear of death.

But what the hell do I know...

Posted by: Diablo at August 5, 2011 2:27 PM

Oh. Murray, god damnit.

About this time last year, we lost my boyfriends cat, Gerschwin.

That cat, who birthed two kittens we still have, had been Alex's cat for five years or so. She hated EVERY SINGLE LIVING CREATURE apart from Alex.
As a tiny kitten(she'd been the runt of a litter seperated too early so was teeny) she would sleep on his chest and if he moved her, she'd crawl back up and snuggle up with him.

She'd hiss and spit at her own kittens but sit on Alex's lap, curl up to his chest and purr like a little buzz saw.

One weekend last year, we were at my house for the weekend, miles from Alex's home. His mum called and asked if he'd noticed anything wrong with Gerschwinn when he left that day and he said she'd been sleeping at the top of the stairs. His mum said the cat had been in the same place when she left for work at 8am.

She perked up on the saturday and ate something, but on saturday night, Alex's mother was holding her and stroking her and she just stopped.

She'd been fine in the days before, no sign of sickness, just that sudden deterioration on the friday. We figured since she was a runt, and had always been wheezy, she may have contracted some infection and was just too weak to fight it off.

Her two kittens apparently nuzzled her and meowed at her and seemed distressed for days.

I'm very sad now.

I'm sorry you lost Malcolm.

Posted by: Nadine at August 5, 2011 2:29 PM

Also, my newest kitten was five weeks when we got her, having lost her mother at two weeks so she basically thinks I am her one and only mother.
While I was on vacation the last few weeks she cried at the door every morning even just for me to stick my head out and assure her I was there.

She treats me like Gerschwin treated Alex.

I dread to think of her, or the other cats getting hurt or dying, it makes me sick. I'd be devastated.

Posted by: Nadine at August 5, 2011 2:33 PM

As always, your writing is brilliant and emotionally moving; this time, you hit me where I live. Fortunately, I am at home today and huge, gusting sobs aren't going to be judged by others.
When your novel is published, I will be fortunate enough to say "he is a friend of mine and my life is better for knowing him".

Posted by: Spender at August 5, 2011 2:34 PM

Well, fuck me, and fuck you too. I travel fulltime and it used to be with two cats and a dog, but now it is one cat and a dog. My beautiful Maine Coon developed lymphoma last December and died in my arms two months ago, the night before I had decided that it was the day to help along the way. Bastard.

I had him cremated and his ashes are in a little wooden box on my dash. I reckon he still travels with me but it's not the same, is it?

I miss my Pancho. He was a sweet kitty.

Posted by: Shonda at August 5, 2011 2:38 PM

Oh, silly Pajiba. Just when I think your cold, black hearts are only capable of brilliant snark and spot-on Pop Culture criticism, you make me lose my shit. At work. At my desk. In front of my employees.

Posted by: sara henke at August 5, 2011 2:45 PM

I have 5 minidoxie grand dogs. Mickey broke her back jumping when she was two. This has a happy ending...she is 5 now and quite handicapable. She has a cart for outside and she wears a babies onesy inside to slide to where she needs to go!
For those of you who feel like you couldn't deal with the pain of losing a pet...think of the pain they feel when living in a shelter! Adopt a homeless pet - save a life.

Posted by: Kathy at August 5, 2011 2:58 PM

Sorry for the long post - this topic was worth de-lurking for me.

Losing a pet IS losing a family member and when we had to let our beloved doggie go after 15 years, the difference in people's reaction to our loss was a little stunning. Some understood the utter heartbreak and others seem mystified and said insensitive things like, "it's just a dog".

Deciding to let her go was hands down, bar none, the hardest thing I've ever done. She and I were extremely bonded. She loved my husband and he adored her, but she was my girl for 10 years before he came into our lives. During her last night with us, at one point she looked at me and I just knew that it was time. I didn't want it to be time, but I knew in my heart that it was. And it was devastating.

We held her all night and all morning long before taking her to the vet for the last time. We had made the appointment the day before, not realizing that it would end up being "that appointment". Our vet was truly wonderful on that awful day. He gently examined her and told us, with such kindness and compassion, that he felt that "she was ready". We could have delayed for another day or two, but I could not bear the thought of her suffering because I couldn't find the strength to let her go.


When the time came she was in my lap as she slipped away and found peace, as my heart broke and we all sobbed. I try to look at it as the ultimate act of love - to let them go before they are in constant pain or suffering needlessly. They count on us to take care of them until the end. They count on us to be strong enough to make a choice that rips our hearts out because it is what is best for them.


It has been almost a year and a half since we said goodbye to her and I still cry about it from time to time. Reading this piece, the comments and adding my own has me weepy... Thankfully, that acute, heart-wrenching, can't breathe level of pain does subside over time. My husband and I talk about her often and that helps. We rescued a new dog about 6 months later and she has helped us to heal from our loss. Having doggie joy in the house again is wonderful. We tell our new dog stories about her "big sister".

My heart goes out to all who have lost pets and to those who know that day is close. Watching a beloved pet age is so hard. I wanted to share our story to let you know that it is something you can get through and knowing that others can truly understand your pain and loss, I hope is a comfort. I like to think we'll see them again some day...

If you really want to cry, Google "The Rainbow Bridge". Don't say I didn't warn you though...

Posted by: Vitamin J at August 5, 2011 3:11 PM

This is really painful for me because I just found my 21-year-old cat dead in thhe basement yesterday. He'd been sick for so long, and I knew it wouldn't be long until he passed, but I still spent half of the day crying. I wished I could have done more with him, I wished for my young, vibrant cat back. It just hurt that my friend from childhood, often my only friend, was gone.

Thank you for sharing your feelings.

Posted by: Caitlin at August 5, 2011 3:14 PM

My kitty is 15. I am 30. I have had this animal for half of my life, and she is the sweetest, most loving cat I have ever know. Just thinking about losing her makes me cry -- and I know I've only got a few more years with her. Damn.

Posted by: linny at August 5, 2011 3:22 PM

Diablo, would I be off base to assume that you've never had a pet? And I don't mean a family pet either, but a pet of your own?

When I was a teenager, I remember thinking it was silly that people spent hundreds of dollars and maybe more on their pets for medical treatments. Now that I have two cats of my own? I would do anything to keep them healthy and happy and give them a long life. I couldn't understand that until I experienced that bond between owner and pet for myself.

Posted by: MelBivDevoe at August 5, 2011 4:04 PM

Just when I've recovered from my wallow in self-pity and Cindy's invitation make ourselves cry over songs (not to mention that article Lauren linked to)

I what now? Must be another me . . .

This was very sad. And all your stories are sad. I've never felt such literal heartache in my life as when a pet dies.

Posted by: Lauren at August 5, 2011 4:25 PM

Long time reader, first time posting...

Thanks for making me cry at work!!!

Posted by: SweetHoney at August 5, 2011 4:46 PM

Update to explain a bit...

My first pet as an adult was my cat, Smokey. My husband bought him for me for my birthday 3 years ago this October. He was the best cat you've ever met, and I'm not just saying that. We would hold him by his back legs, or throw him over a shoulder like a doll, he never minded. When we got our rottweiler, Casey about a year later, we finally felt like a complete family. Me and my boys. Smokey always put Casey back in his place, and all was right with the world.
Even my parents, who HATE cats, loved Smoke. He was like a dog in a cat's body. My favorite pet.
Then, three weeks ago, I got home from work and found him in my closet (this was his favorite place)he wasn't moving, just laying there and mewing loudly. He was limp from the neck down. He had soiled himself.
My husband took him to the pet ER by our house, but they weren't able to tell us what had happened. Most likely a stroke. My husband brought him home, and i held him in a towel until he stopped moving. Not only was this my first pet, but my first death as well. I've been lucky to never have anyone close to me die before, but it left me, at 26, completely unprepared for what to feel at that moment.
A week ago, my husband brought home a new kitten. A new little boy who lets us hold him by his back legs. My husband calls him "Lebowski", and he sleeps on my head at night.
I know it will only take time to heal my pain and stop missing Smoke. Thanks you for writing this article, even if it did make me burst out crying on my lunch break.

Posted by: SweetHoney at August 5, 2011 4:58 PM

I am old man for Pajiba at 44. In my time, I have had friends and family die, and lived through the after effects. I've ended real relationships, and faced the empty and broken feeling that ensues. I've done, and had done to me, sharp and terrible things, as life is prone to put in front of you from time to time.

But honestly one of the hardest things I've ever had to do is end time with pets that were mine. I'm not saying it's worse mind you, or that it's the most terrible thing in life, but it's so unique and twisted in the pain it brings. Animals of course are not self aware in the same sense we are, and not rational critters by design, more purely emotional. The special twist of the dagger of fate is that they don't understand what's going on, but you do, and the horror of knowing what you are facing together is yours alone to contemplate.

And the uniquely terrible thing about that for the times I've had to do it (three dogs, two of which had been with me for 15 years, one who had been 10), each time it's been just that, me standing on the precipice of pain and suffering I know will follow, and looking across the chasm of emotion in knowing terror of losing my best friend.

And each time, the animal I was going to have to end, despite their various desperate states that led us to the decision - each time they have tried to help me as I took them be put down, by showing affection and care, a small lick of the face despite pain, a last attempt to bring a ball that can't be thrown. If you heart isn't broken by that kind of display of unconditional love, then honestly I don't know what you are.

For those that don't own pets or have never experienced this before with the ones they now have, please don't get the wrong impression. It's a deep emotional wound to lose them, yes it is. But if you have a healthy relationship with them, it's completely worth it. And for the love all that is humane, when the animal reaches the point of suffering that cannot be assuaged, do the duty of ending it for them. It is your part of the deal they have been paying for with years of love and affection.

For those curious, I would do it again in a heartbeat (have two dogs currently in fact). Rewards > cost, even though the cost is extraordinary.

-Frob

Posted by: frobme at August 5, 2011 5:08 PM

(this turned out longer than I expected, sorry)

Reading these, especially the comments, makes me feel a bit better about not only not overcoming my cat's death seven years ago - but also about considering that to be the most painful experience I've ever had in my life. Mind you, I've never lost anyone so her death is really the closest experience with death I've had so far. Her name was Tiffany (she was HORRIBLE looking when she was a baby so we gave her an "expensive" name to inspire her) and she was, like Stella's dog, perfectly fine one day and then suddenly she was losing weight and simply not moving. The vets didn't find out what was wrong with her until it was too late, and she died while she was receiving a blood transfusion. I was with her, and after she stopped breathing I literally went insane, screaming and running around the office, bumping against the walls. I have no memory of going back home.

I'm not one for spiritualism, but a couple of days after she died, my mother read a poem in the newspaper, in honor of a woman who had just passed. The title was "Butterfly Soul", and it was basically about how this woman wasn't really gone, she had just "transformed" and "flown away". The same day, some people that knew my mother called to say that they had found a kitten in their parking lot, and perhaps she wanted to go have a look? Well, we did, and when we got there we found a tiny tabby kitten, who looked almost exactly like Tiffany, just a tad darker. So we brought Butterfly home to keep her sister company.

Her sister died last year, at 17, but she was old and sick and I had time to grieve before we lost her. Every now and then, though, I see a shadow and still expect to see her little black fur lying in the sun.

Posted by: Holly at August 5, 2011 6:06 PM

michael: i'm so sorry to hear about heidi, and i hope that she's feeling better soon.

TK: my best friend is an 11 year old dog, and you took the words right out of my mouth.

Posted by: celery at August 5, 2011 6:08 PM

I am so touched to hear that there are people who understand that while I have been experiencing the lowest of lows lately, I refuse to give up my dog. Everyone seems to think I could just drop him off somewhere at a moments notice and not be traumatized (and not consider how utterly devastated he would be to be abandoned by his mommy). I am calmed by the emotions brought on from all of your comments and this beautiful story. I know I am doing the right thing, fighting for him, and I will continue to do so under any circumstances.

Posted by: jayem at August 5, 2011 7:03 PM

This is such a lovely article and thread. It has made me go all gooey-eyed and think sweeping thoughts like I wish I could hug you all because you expressed your pain so poignantly and eloquently. But, that's really sappy, I know. Stories like this bring out the worst kind of overblown sentimentality in me.

I have lost several pets over the years, but was recently traumatized by the disappearance of our family cat, Mr.Black, who was born to a stray cat in our garage on Good Friday four years ago. The momcat disappeared; we found her body on the street, and we had to bottle-feed Mr.Black and his littermates. He held his bottle like a human baby, a simple act that forever sealed his fate with our family: The little Stinkies called him their brother.

Mr. Black developed a UTI in May. I brought him to the vet and was given pain killers and antibiotic to administer for 10 days. After I gave him his first dose of painkiller, I realized with the utmost horror that I had given him double the prescribed amount. I watched him waddle around, and then he went outside, through the cat flap, to go to the bathroom. (He's perfect that way; no litter box for him!) He never returned.

I sent out (somewhat) humorous messages to our neighborhood listserv ("My cat was 'high' when he left the house. Please look out for cats behaving strangely --party hat, velvet smoking jacket, asking for a ride to the nearest strip club." By Day 3, I couldn't joke about it anymore. My friends started telling me to accept that he was dead. I was furious with them for suggesting this even though I knew they were right.

At 9 p.m. on Day 3, the magnet on the cat flap clicked open. I heard a faint meow. I called to Mr. Black, "Kitty, is it you??" He looked half-dead. I knew that I must be hallucinating, so I called Mr. Stinky, who was at an art show with the little ones. I used Facetime, so there would be proof that I was not having an LSD flashback. "Do you SEE the CAT?" I shouted at Mr. Stinky. Mr. Stinky, the master of the understatement, said, "Yes."

I had to rush Mr. Black to the vet emergency hospital (his urinary tract was seriously blocked), and three days and $1,400 later, he was back home with us. When I brought him in the house, he passed out into a deep sleep while I cradled him like a prodigal child in my arms. The little Stinkies declared the day "the happiest day in my whole life."

Mr. Black (whose name hails from One Fish, Two Fish, "Brown came back with Mr. Black.") now requires a diet of the most expensive cat food ($1.40 per can) and frequent vet check-ups for UTI-related issues (not cheap), but the truth is: The Stinky clan would gladly sacrifice the family vacation this summer, and then some, to have their cat back.

Diablo, I used to think the same as you, until we had a family pet. (Actually, I used to think the same thing about having children, "OMG! Kids are SO exPENSIVE! Why would any couple in their right minds have children??!!" Pets---and kids--- happen. They rock your world and dramatically alter your way of thinking forever. Maybe for the worst. Who knows? All I know is, my critters (kids included) give me the most unspeakable joy, and if it has dulled my intellect and sharpened my tear ducts, so be it. I am finding that ignorance/idiocy, truly, is bliss.

Posted by: Stinky at August 5, 2011 7:37 PM

Damnit, nothing makes me cry harder than thinking of beloved pets dying or suffering. My dad worked construction and was forever bringing home sickly cats and dogs that had been hiding in half-finished houses. Every time we lost one, or had to put it to sleep, he'd proclaim, "That's it! Never again are we owning another pet!" And a few weeks later he would bring home another.

Rumbles was the first cat I had that I was truly responsible for, and thus I had to make the heart-breaking decision of putting him to sleep. I came home from work to find my mom sitting with him--it was one of his better days, and he was downright perky. "Maybe we can put it off," she suggested. No way. I knew if I put it off, I could never bring myself to do it at all.

We took him to the vet's, which he was used to, but after hoisting him up to the table, he grabbed at the cat carrier as we pulled it away. He just wanted to go home, and never would again. It was the hardest thing I've ever had to do.

I would later adopt a bratty black and white kitty, probably the closest thing I will experience to having a child of my own. I loved that cat more than I loved most people. Small and sassy and full of attitude, he ruled a house of cats not through brute force but through sly, intelligent tactics, and they all loved him.

He was devoted to me and followed me everywhere; when I'd pick him up, he'd drool on my shoulder and purr happily. As he approached old age, I'd pray he'd die in his sleep. Please don't make me make that decision.

But as his legs started failing and he lost weight, I knew I had to face it--I arranged for the vet to come to the house in a few days so he'd die in a place where he had been safe and well-loved for 19 years. He deteriorated badly over the next few days, and on his last day he just lay with his little head propped up on a hot water bottle, waiting. He was done. It was his last gift to me--you always question if you're doing the right thing, if there isn't more time, but he made it clear that he was ready to go.

Thanks, my little Oty. I love you and miss you and think of you every day.

Posted by: DeadBessie at August 5, 2011 8:30 PM

Ah, Michael, that was beautifully written, and I'm so sorry about Malcolm. My condolences to you and your mom. I grew up in a cat family, and right now am trying not to think about losing the Siamese I grew up with (when I was sixteen and she was eighteen), or my first rescue kitty (too young; she had liver problems), or the turtle I had for twelve years (since he was a wee hatchling)...ugh.

*sigh*

So, yeah, how 'bout that local sports team, eh?

Posted by: meaux at August 5, 2011 8:39 PM

Oh, DeadBessie . . . . slam dunk in my sad zone. *sniff*

Posted by: Lauren at August 5, 2011 8:52 PM

I couldn't get through this article. If there's one thing that can reduce the majority of the Internet to tears, it's stories about pets. I just put down my dog last week and it was as devastating as if it were my first dog when I was a little girl. It never gets easier.

Posted by: duckandcover at August 5, 2011 8:53 PM

"All I know is, my critters (kids included) give me the most unspeakable joy, and if it has dulled my intellect and sharpened my tear ducts, so be it. I am finding that ignorance/idiocy, truly, is bliss.
Posted by: Stinky at August 5, 2011 7:37 PM"

Stinky? I love you so hard, right now. Thank you for posting this story. Just... thank you.

Posted by: Spender at August 5, 2011 8:57 PM

This is why I don't own pets now.

An old girlfriend of mine, Deborah, was a rescuer. Officially a rescuer, not an amateur collector of animals, but one who worked with rescue groups to retrieve dogs and cats from the Humane Society and other organizations like them. Contrary to what many believe, unless they specifically say so (and sometimes despite it) they're not too many that are no-kill facilities. One summer she (and I, since I was living with her) rescued over 30 dogs, most of them Dobermans, as the main group she worked with was Florida Doberman Rescue.

Essentially what she did was rescue the dogs from death row and foster them, bring them back up to health, until the group could find new owners for them. One of these rescues was a bit different, however.

Timbo was in the pound because he was discovered roaming wild through a neighborhood. Naturally the sight of a random dobie wandering around would set people on edge. Deborah found him in the pound after they'd brought him in. He was naturally malnourished, as they tend to be, his teeth were broken as well. The belief is that he broke them chewing on rocks out of sheer hunger. More noticeable was his read leg, which looked paralyzed. We found out in time that his hip had been broken, probably from being hit by a car, and the knee and ankle were likely broken as well and had fused stiff. There was still mobility in the hip and he used the leg with little difficulty, but the knee and ankle remained stiff throughout his lifetime.

Even more troubling, when he'd had x-rays taken, it was revealed that he had two rounds from a pellet gun and a couple of birdshot balls from a shotgun in him.

The pound would not release him to her. They said his injuries were too severe, even though it was obvious they were old and had already healed. They were insistent that he would be put down. She argued with them for a long time before demanding to speak to the director of the facility, whom she had come to know through her many visits there. Finally they agreed to give him up, rather than put him down.

Despite all of these horrific things in his short life, he was the sweetest, gentlest dog I've ever known. He loved cats and small dogs to the point of annoying them with his nurturing attention. He never fought with the other dogs, even when the alpha bitch got cranky and felt like enforcing her position. When we took him to the dog park, he'd run like the wind with the other dogs, despite his stiff leg (he'd drag it through the grass like a rudder to make sharp turns), and he never got into a real scrap with any other dog but one, who insisted on constantly singling Timbo out. Even then, he held himself well against the bully, rather than shit himself and cry like other traumatized dogs I've known.

When we found out he had cancer, it was after a relatively short period of illness. He had never shown any signs before then and when we took him to the vet we were told that he was likely in a lot of pain and that he didn't have much time left. We decided to take their advice and have him put down.

I don't think it occurred to me at the time that the vet meant "now", but there we were, being brought into the back room where Timbo was on the table and the assistant had a syringe. They left us to be with him for a few minutes. When they came back, he asked if we were ready and then he gave him the injection into one of the fat veins in his leg. I asked the vet how long it would take and with a slight pause, he said "now". Sure enough, I looked at the face of the dog I'd come to love, and yes, admire, and saw the light go out.

http://protoguy.deviantart.com/art/Timbo-26072536

Posted by: Protoguy at August 5, 2011 9:08 PM

I couldn't finish reading this either. I have six pets. Two dogs, 15 and 4; four cats 14, 14, 11, and 1 1/2 years old. I know I'm in for a lot of heartbreak in the next few years.

Two years ago, my 14 year old cat, Monkey developed fatty liver disease. The vet told me most cats end up dying. I nursed him night and day for two months, force fed him and despite losing 8lbs off his 20lb frame, he made it! Six months later, after regaining most of his weight Monkey was attacked by two stray dogs. Luckily, his regained fat saved him from any major organ damage but he did lose a nipple. This was four days before I moved from Detroit to Tucson, he was a trooper the whole way! In one year I spent over $3000 on him and was worth every cent. Now, my little old man kitty has a thyroid problem and needs medication everyday. He's been worth every cent and every lost moment of sleep; he's given me far more companionship and pleasure than I can ever give back to him. Even when the little bastard hid from me, spit his pink medicine all over and bit me while spitting out the pills and food I had to force on him!

Skully, my son's 15 year old dog was diagnosed with inoperable liver cancer. The vet wanted to put her down right away but she wasn't in pain, just very jaundiced with no appetite. I asked for the medication she could give me, took the dog home hoping for the best. I tried the dog food prescribed by the vet, she wouldn't eat it so I found a low protein diet for her that she would eat. My son was leaving for Marine boot camp and I was going to be damned if I was going to put her down! Yeah, I am stubborn. I nursed the dog and am ecstatic to report that Skully is acting like a puppy again.

I know it's only a temporary respite but she's already out lasted her diagnosis by 4 months and was thrilled when her boy came home from boot camp, as was he to see her in such good shape.

Don't always take the vet's opinion as gospel, learn as much as you can about your pet's condition and liquid Milk Thistle helps with liver problems.

Sorry this is so long but there is always hope.

Posted by: Jennmcn at August 5, 2011 9:19 PM

You people are really killing me these last few days.

/dust in my eye

Posted by: Uriah Creep at August 5, 2011 9:36 PM

Protoguy, you are a good man and my heart hurts for you. Thank you for taking care of Timbo and doing absolutely all of the right things.

Posted by: Spender at August 5, 2011 9:47 PM

Thanks Spender.

I only had to put one other pet down in my life. When my ex-wife bailed on us, she also bailed on her dog, Bear, a Keeshond. The dog I had given her 10 years earlier. So of course when it was his turn to go, cancer again, I had to be the one to do it. She wouldn't even come to the vet. That was a bit more difficult, to be honest.

Posted by: Protoguy at August 5, 2011 10:09 PM

"His head on my knee can heal my human hurts. His presence by my side is protection against my fears of dark and unknown things. He has promised to wait for me... whenever... wherever — in case I need him. And I expect I will — as I always have. He is just my dog." - Gene Hill

I have a 10 year old black lab named Cole. He started limping a few weeks ago and my husband and I assumed that he had just landed wrong getting on and off of the bed in the guest bedroom (which he is not supposed to do). We took him to the vet and the x-ray came back that part of the bone was missing in his paw. Completely gone. Cancer. We took him in and had the part of his paw amputated, thinking that would fix the problem.

The vet called a few days ago to tell us the labs had come back from A&M and it showed that he has the worst cancer a dog can have. We have to monitor him constantly for lumps in his lymph nodes. We have time left with him, but we aren't sure how long.

I have mentioned before that I lost my daughter a few years ago. What I didn't mention is that when she died, he didn't leave my side. He laid beside me in my bed for days and let me sob and hold him. "His head on my knee can heal my human hurts." He has been a constant companion and is infinitely patient with my overzealous 2.5 year old. I cannot bear to think of a world that he is not laying beside my bed and snoring at night.

If you really want to cry, go find the video of Jimmy Stewart reciting the poem "Beau" on Johnny Carson. He says it all.

Posted by: legib at August 5, 2011 10:48 PM

Spender, thanks for your kind comment. It's a bit embarrassing for me to put so much "feeling" out on a message thread, even though cloaked by internet anonymity.

I continue to be amazed and moved by the comments in this message thread. (DeadBessie, jeez, I cried AGAIN; Protoguy, you already know I'm a fan.) But, additionally, I have read recent news reports that city police forces are now investigating cruelty-to-animals complaints because there is a direct link between harsh treatment of animals and crimes against humans. It's sad that it has taken us so long to figure this out. My No. 1 sermon to the little Stinkies is that one NEVER takes out his/her frustrations on a creature that has nothing to do with the problem.

I realize I'm straying from the topic, but, the salient point is: If you lack empathy for the creatures lesser-than-you/dependent on you for their care, then you probably lack empathy for others (even humans); and, unfortunately, that turns put to be the case for a lot of humans.

The thing that's so amazingly, gobsmackingly beautiful to me is that we can love another species to such distraction: We will risk life, limb, financial comfort, for the sake of a ball of fur that likely has no idea why we love it so. On the other hand, there is no doubt in my mind: Something, beyond words, passes between you and your animal. And no one can dissuade me from that thought. There IS interspecies communciation---faulty and fraught with the notions of science though it may be--- our animals KNOW that we love them. To me, this is just the coolest thing in the world.

Posted by: Stinky at August 5, 2011 11:15 PM

Like so many others, this brought me to tears. Beautifully written.

We lost two of our three family dogs in the past year and it's been devastating. The first was Timber, our beautiful Siberian Husky. He grew to be a huge dog but always thought he was a lap dog. He almost put my dad's back out when he jumped up on his lap in a rocking chair.

The other was our bumbling, pudgy pug, Colby. He was always fat and chubby and would do things like walk straight into walls. Such an earnest little fellow.

I knew it was the right time for both of them but that doesn't ease the heartbreak very much. Seeing the husky not being able to run around in the snow outside and seeing our pug struggling to crawl into our laps.. there's nothing worse in the world. One of the worst parts of it is thinking of the third dog, Mitzi, a ditzy little shit-zsu, alone without them now. She's living with my parents and keeping her company but they've told me that she's tried to go looking for them several times now. And now I'm crying again.

Posted by: beckster at August 5, 2011 11:54 PM

I promise. I'll shut up. After this.

legib, although your post came well before mine, I was busy writing mine, and tending to hubby, children and cat (s), so I took several breaks before posting.

I didn't know about the loss of your daughter, but, as any parent knows, there is no greater pain in all the world. I am truly sorry. To hear that you may be losing Cole as well just seems like a grotesque injustice.

I just ... wanted you to know this.

Posted by: Stinky at August 6, 2011 12:13 AM

I knew better than to read this at work, which I'm grateful for because I'm a sobby mess now. I lost my beloved dog on January 18th, after almost 13 years, and not a day goes by that I don't miss him. I just got an e-mail this morning from Petsmart promising a 'birthday coupon' for Tanker, and I lost it. I hadn't even thought about the fact that his birthday is August 23rd, so it's all back in force today. I have 2 other dogs still, but Tanker was my first, my babydog right up to the end, and nothing will ever be the same.

Posted by: Gabs at August 6, 2011 12:24 AM

I do a lot of rescue work for small animals (bunnies, guinea pigs, rats, hamsters etc.) so I've had to put more animals down than I care to even remember.

In December I had to put down my 17 year old cat; he was so very special. Out of all of the animals we've put down his hurt the most and continues to hurt the most. I suspect the pain and loss I feel will last a very long time.

Four years ago we took in an 11 year old English bulldog. My husband fondly referred to her as our broken bulldog; she had so many health problems. She was with us for two years before the vet told us it was time. And it was. She was no longer the goofy, silly girl she had always been.

Our vet clinic is right next to a park. The morning we took her in to be put down, we got to the clinic a half hour early. My husband went to mcDonalds and picked up an ice cream cone and we sat on the grass in the warm sun and fed our sweet Cassie the ice cream cone. Then we took her in, they sedated her and she fell asleep in our arms.

It's a good way to die isn't it? To just fall asleep with the memory of the soft grass under your feet, your skin still warm from the sun and a belly full of ice cream.

Only a month later our other dog, who was only seven, was diagnosed with bone cancer and despite drugs and blood tranfusions we lost him too within two weeks of the diagnosis.

That was a bad summer.

Michael, I'm glad Heidi is doing better and I'm so sorry for the loss of your sweet cat.

Posted by: Kelly at August 6, 2011 1:21 AM

This may sound a little woo-woo, but my roommie has a dachshund who had the same problem which has been whittled away to nothing more than the occasional achy back and a need to not jump on the furniture. What did it? Acupuncture done by a DVM specializing in acupuncture and Chinese medicine. (I'm a bit leery of the Chinese medicine myself, but the acupuncture was amazing.)

If you can find someone in your area who does animal acupuncture, go!! (Of note, the back problem took place when the dog was five, and the normal vet said that without prohibitively expenseive surgery that he'd probably be in so much pain in a few years that she'd have to put him down.) He is ten now, and still trotting around in that grumpy-old man way that dachshunds might have invented.

Posted by: megaera at August 6, 2011 4:13 AM

Sorta off-topic - I'm not what you'd call a proponent of alternative medicine, but acupuncture, combined with TENS therapy fixed my lower back problems. I know that TENS alone can't do that.

Posted by: Protoguy at August 6, 2011 6:12 AM

Sorry to hear about your beloved pets, all of you..

When I was growing up, my parents would get a dog, the dog had issues, the dog was gone. Disposable. I felt like my feelings were disposable too. I vowed when I grew up that any dog I got would be a forever dog. Mr. Kirbyjay and I have had 3 dogs, Magic, a German Shephard for 13 years, Kirby, a Yellow Lab for 12, and Duck now 5 1/2, a rescued yellow lab, we've had for 3 years. I dread the day I have to make the "decision", like I did for my other 2. He is like my bratty, but hysterically funny 5 year old son.

Anyway....My first yellow lab Kirby was old and sick and I happen to be reading Marley and Me at the time. Not a good choice because not only did I cry for Marley but I was crying for Kirby too. Not long after, we had to put him down and the vet and her assistant came to the house. She sat with us for 15 minutes beside Kirby and we chatted about him. He thought he was having a party and even managed to wag his tail and smile. His last moments were happy ones and I will be forever indebted to her for that. She even cried a little, she had loved him too. I did feel relief after because he was no longer in pain. RIP my forever pups.

P.S. Now you know how I got my screenname. J is my initial.

Posted by: kirbyjay at August 6, 2011 7:39 AM

It ain't easy being the one to decide that a family member has to die. And then watch it happen. Which is also why it's very important to explain it to your children - very carefully.

Posted by: Protoguy at August 6, 2011 12:53 PM

Very, very well written.

I am unable to have pets at the place I currently live but by the time I was halfway through this article I was already crying. On my sister's birthday about ten years ago we had to take our family pet, a cat named Syd, to the emergency vet. It did not end well. Every year when her birthday comes around, it is still very bittersweet. I cannot get through the day without thinking about the last six hours we spent with him. We had two other cats at the time but we had to throw out the pet carrier we brought him there in because none of us could even look at it without tearing up.

Posted by: Erin is Scrumtulescent at August 6, 2011 4:34 PM

This made me burst into tears. My husband and I lost our cat this May to fatty liver disease...she was only five years old. We had received military orders for Hawaii and had to leave our two beloved cats behind with a relative until we could meet the insane requirements for bringing pets into this state. After two months of separation one of our cats, our first cat, stopped eating (most likely due to the stress of separation and her new environment) and the relative caring for her didn't even notice she was sick until she had lost half her body weight. We got the call saying she was sick, we paid to have her hospitalized immediately, and three days later she died alone in a fucking cage in a vet's office while we were thousands of miles away.

I'm crying right now, I miss that cat so damn much. She was my little girl. She brought me so much comfort and happiness in her short life and I never thought we would lose her so soon, like this. Life really is not fair. She deserved so much better.

Posted by: LaRhue at August 6, 2011 5:36 PM

I just wanted to say thank you to all who wrote here... I read all the time, but have never posted before.
I am an RVT (registered vet tech, so basically a nurse for animals). It is a job that you do because you love animals, and for no other reason - I am barely paid enough to put food on the table for me and my three furkids. The job takes everything from me some days - it is physically, mentally and above all emotionally exhausting. Also, there are so many days when it feels like you failed - when you tried so hard to fix the unfixable, to make it better when you know it is only going to get worse.
The worst part of my job is helping animals whose owners are indifferent to their suffering. This has been especially hard since I lost my own dear cat this past winter - she would have been 10 years old this week, and that is far too early for a cat to be taken.. but cancer is coming for the young more and more these days. I would have done anything to save my girl, and it kills me to have to help euthanize animals who could easily be saved, because their owners find it easier to just dispose of them.

I have been considering leaving the profession lately - listening to you all talk about your love for your pets reminds me why I became an RVT. Thank you all so much for sharing, and especially to Michael for the essay.

ps Protoguy, I love the picture of Timbo - what a wonderful tribute. He sounds like an amazing dog, I'm glad he had you.

Posted by: honeybee at August 7, 2011 1:09 AM

The worst part of my job is helping animals whose owners are indifferent to their suffering.

Posted by: honeybee at August 7, 2011 1:09 AM

I know these people exist, obviously, but I can't really understand it. They don't deserve pets at all. Keep up your good work, honeybee.

Posted by: Uriah Creep at August 7, 2011 5:59 AM

Honeybee - the people at our vet are all so wonderful and caring. The day we let our girl go, everyone was crying with us. They kept the office open later so that we could take our time. Their kindness on that day and every day we had her in remains with us.

I don't understand how people can treat animals they've chosen to bring into their lives as disposable at any stage. How could you look into an animal's face and not feel anything?

I just wanted to say thank you to you and everyone who works with animals for all that you do for them and for the people who love them.

Posted by: Vitamin J at August 7, 2011 10:23 AM

I started reading this then I stopped, went outside to get my dog, Chloe (a rat terrier), and finished the article holding and petting her. She may be evil at times and eat our pillows, and bills, and terrorize our cat, Kaylee, but she's still a sweet heart. I think because she's a dog I have more affection for her just because dogs seem to give affection back more. But I've had my share of sick (or vanished) cats too, and it does tear your heart out.

On Saturday we brought home 2 10 week old twin kittens (Sookie and Ripley) and Chloe is being remarkably protective of them. Pets can be a pain but the house just doesn't feel like a home to me without animals running around. And no, we aren't hoarders.

Beautiful piece, MM.

Posted by: TylerDFC at August 7, 2011 10:24 AM

I won't own another pet because losing my last one (a guinea pig, many years ago) to old age was too hard.

Posted by: immature at August 7, 2011 2:56 PM

As my cat is sleeping by the window, basking in the summer sun, I am crying and trying to stave off the urge to go, hug him hard, and annoy him for breaking his peaceful slumber.

I've always had dogs, but my soul has never connected to another creature they way its bonded with my cat. I dont even want to think of the day, I have to say goodbye.

Posted by: sara at August 7, 2011 3:09 PM

I lost my cat a couple weeks ago, and it hit much harder than I thought it would. She was only nine years old and it came so fast. A couple days before, she was completely fine, but after the kidney failure set in, she wouldn't eat, move or do anything. On her last days, we sat her on the pillow in the living room and scheduled an appointment to put her down in the morning the next day, but her condition got so bad that night we had to take her to the late-night vet and do it then.

My parents are considering getting a new kitten down the line, but I don't want to because I don't want to deal with that feeling of complete helplessness again. All I could do was pet and hold her as she shut down.

Nicest cat I've ever seen.. always hung around me when I was home, and although it was probably so that she could get food, I'd like to think she enjoyed my company as much as I enjoyed hers.

Posted by: Sam at August 7, 2011 6:02 PM

LaRhue,

I'm so sorry.

Posted by: Candee at August 7, 2011 10:38 PM

Oh no, not Heidi! I loved that little angel so much. She's very famous at my job and we quote her often.

It was very obvious on your blog that you took extra time to really understand her. I think you did the right thing letting her live life to the fullest instead of restricting her. That's how we'd all want it for ourselves, I'm sure.

Sorry, Michael. Heidi will be missed.

Posted by: becks at August 8, 2011 8:41 AM

My boy Sampson died Saturday morning. He was a rescued Rottweiler and I had him for 8 years. Sam was very gentile and affectionate and coming into the house for the first time in a very long time and not having him greet me at the door with his nubby going a mile a minute was tough. He did lead a good life after his rescue, no more abuse, a warm place to sleep, never went hungry and was loved very much.
I am very sad over him not being home but it was his time and he went to sleep and just din't get up.

Posted by: Common Sense at August 8, 2011 10:07 AM

Oh Common Sense, I'm so sorry to hear about Sampson.

Posted by: mswas at August 8, 2011 11:54 AM

I, like many other commenters, had to put my amazing rescue to sleep only two weeks ago. She was my first dog ever, and was only seven. Tuesday morning she was fine, but by that night we took her to the vet because she was weak and (seemingly) peeing blood. She was diagnosed with a sudden auto-immune disorder where her white blood cells were attacking her read blood cells and despite dropping more than a thousand dollars on treatments, they couldn't control it and she was having seizures from lack of oxygen. We put her to sleep, and it was the most awful day of my life, bar none. I thought I had years left with her, although I was already starting to be sad (Oh, she's already seven! I want more than five years left with her) So thank you for this. It makes me feel a little better about being so broken up over my Mina.

Posted by: Ginny at August 8, 2011 1:50 PM

This really honestly brought me to tears. I'm now sitting on my couch cuddling my German shepherd stuffed animal and clutching my shepherd's collar that he wore when he died. I was 17, and he was only 7. He was the love of my life. He really was my dog, not a family dog. I spent the first week he was with me sleeping on a cot by his crate, with my hand through the bars so he could snuggle with it. I spent a month after his hip replacement surgery walking him around with a sling around his hindquarters to help him move while he healed. I lay with my head on his chest and talked to him during some of the worst times of my teenagerhood. He meant the world to me, and it broke my heart when we had to put him down after cancer took over. He went peacefully, but I've never cried harder in my life than I did when I felt his body getting cold and stiff under my hands.

I'm gonna go cry a little more now.

Beautifully written essay, Mr. Murray.

Posted by: GwenBear at August 8, 2011 3:34 PM

Putting down a pet is the very definition of a time when doing the right thing hurts. I tried to make sure when we said goodbye to our kitty Ginger (12 years, had him longer than the kids)that our children understood we had to make this choice out of respect for him. Choosing to prolong his suffering in order to try and avoid the pain we would feel at his death would be selfish.

Second worst day of my life. I went home from the vets and cried the rest of the day.

Posted by: bokchoi at August 8, 2011 4:34 PM

I've recently lost a pet and so those feelings are pretty raw right now. This was a lovely piece of writing.

I was hit hardest by the death of my German Short Haired Pointer. I was due to finish work and head home, but I fancied a drink at the local pub before heading back. I ended up having two or three when I received a call from my mother saying our dog was at the vets and was about to be put down and to get there as soon as I could.

I was in a panic and called a taxi, which should have arrived quickly, but didn't. By the time I got back, she had been put to sleep and I never got to say goodbye because of a few drinks and a slow taxi.

In tears I asked the vet if I could see her even though she had passed, I went in and told her all the things I wanted to and apologised for all the times I'd been too busy to spend time with her. I broke my heart in that room and ever since whenever I lose a pet, I think back to that day.

Posted by: DC at August 22, 2011 11:52 AM