web
counter
 

You're Only Hurting Yourself

By Brian Prisco | Posted Under Seriously Random Lists | Comments (20)



edward_norton_fight_club-460x345.jpg

Oscar Time! Oscar Time! It’s time for us industry folks to start nominating folks for consideration for awards consideration. And there’s some stiff competition. Now, I know there’ve been instances where an actor has been really good in a lesser film and then been nominated for the more prestigious one. This usually happens to Sam Rockwell. There have been instances where a nomination has been given based on the actor’s role the year prior — the we’re sorry, here’s your trophy or the Peter Jackson award.

But I wonder if the converse is also true. Actors make movies years in advance. Sometimes a film is shot in a month and then rushed into production. Sometimes, films are delayed for release for awards season or to avoid other films. The whole thing is a bit of a chess match. So sometimes, an actor can appear in several films over the course of the year, even though they shot one years before the other. And I wonder if these releases of inferior films with inferior performances hinder and actor’s chances at even getting nominations. Even some trailers can offer a glimpse into a shitty performance. So here’s a few actors who I think have blown their chances of winning (or in some cases of even garnering an award nomination) and the films that did it. To be fair, I haven’t seen Minnie Driver in Barney’s Passion or Michelle Williams in Wendy and Lucy, but I don’t think anyone else will either, so they’re probably safe.


Edward Norton

The funny part is, it’s actually the one that’s asking for consideration that’s the turkey. I personally think Norton was remarkable in Leaves of Grass. And yet, the studio is putting him up for Stone, which is a terribly weak version of his Primal Fear performance, coupled with terrible Detroit wigger lingo.

Natalie Portman

Portman is kind of amazing in Black Swan, putting forth a performance that demonstrates exceptional growth and maturity on her part, and basically forces me to eat my doubt of her a few months ago. And yet, then we look at the two trailers for her upcoming work: Your Highness, where the only thing she’s got going for her is a willingness to show her bare ass, and No Strings Attached, which makes me yearn for the acidic venom of Katherine Heigl. Just when everyone’s gonna be admiring NatPo for her performances, those trailers are going to haunt the chances like the specter of her ass-shaking in Closer.

Milla Jovovich

Maybe I’m the only one who thinks she was amazing in Stone, even though the studio’s pushing hard for nods for that flick. And I think Milla’s the best of that lot of actors. But like everyone else, Milla’s the sci-fi action star. And since they released the fourteenandahalfth Resident Evil film, Resident Evil: Ernest Eats A Camp, everyone’s gonna think of her as a sword wielder and not a gold wielder.

Phylicia Rashad

I think they can put up just about anyone from the cast of For Colored Girls and it would be a deserving nomination. And while I prefer either Thandie Newton, Kerry Washington, and the devine Loretta Devine, Mrs. Huxtable had a dog in this fight. That is, until I finished watching Frankie & Alice. I’ll get into that on Thursday, but let’s just say the Hallmark soapopery of her performance pretty neatly unraveled anything remotely memorable about her fierceness in For Colored Girls.

Robert DeNiro

Stone again. I told you, he locks you in with those eyes, he commands your presence. And then he focks hisself right in the mouth. You can’t escape Little Fockers. And any chance Bobby had of salvaging some of his acting acumen got buttfocked right in the browneye.










Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



"A Game Of Thrones" Trailer | Give Me Sweet Lies, And Keep Your Bitter Truths | Mark Wahlberg To Star In Broken City | I'm The Guy Who Does His Job. You Must Be The Other Guy









Comments

I can't believe you didn't invoke the specter of Eddie Murphy and the Dreamgirls/Norbit fiasco.

Posted by: jthomas666 at November 30, 2010 3:32 PM

Disagree on Portman. If she's not getting in, it's the Academy's bias against horror film acting, not her yearly output. I'm racking my brain to think of the last horror film nomination in acting: The Sixth Sense? Has it really been over a decade? Yes, because I remember being royally pissed that Sergi Lopez couldn't get in for Pan's Labyrinth or Jennifer Carpenter for The Exorcism of Emily Rose. Horrors are technical/directing/writing/scoring showpieces in the industry's eyes, not acting showpieces. And then when they do get critical acclaim for acting, the film magically transforms into a thriller.

I also don't care how good the performance was, Norton was not getting in for the pot dealing film. If it was meth or crack or coke, he'd have a home run. He has a better shot with the deranged criminal role than the drug dealing dual roles.

Posted by: Robert at November 30, 2010 3:45 PM

I can't believe you didn't invoke the specter of Eddie Murphy and the Dreamgirls/Norbit fiasco.

Posted by: jthomas666 at November 30, 2010 3:32 PM

Totally get you...just like Dane Cook getting hosed for Employee of the Month because of Farce of the penguins...

OR Katherine Heigl this year totally screwing herself by being in Killers when she was absofucklutely BRILLIANT in Life As We Know It...

And who can forget Tyler Perry getting completely bent over the hood of a Yugo and taking a pumpkin in the ass because he did Madea's Family Reunion almost immediately in front of Madea Goes to Jail. He was quality in drag in the first, but the just looked like an ex-linebacker with a bad wig in the second.

I hate the academy and its bias.

Posted by: PissBoy at November 30, 2010 3:49 PM

Don't forget the Al Pacino "You mean you don't have one yet?" award.

Posted by: Three-nineteen at November 30, 2010 4:17 PM

I'm in a McDonald's in Midtown Manhattan using its internet. This is totally irrelevant to the post, by the way, I just find it funny that McDonald's has become the ultimate hangout spot because it has internet and fries are cheap.

Posted by: Lucas at November 30, 2010 4:23 PM

Jennifer Carpenter was pretty damn good in "Exorcism of E.R." She's a fabulous actress. Very true about the bias against horror movies.

Posted by: samantha t at November 30, 2010 4:32 PM

I call that award the Jimmy Stewart Award. Didn't win for Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, but wins next year for The Philadelphia Story? I love both, but one was definitely way more deserving of the oscar.

Posted by: AlannaJudith at November 30, 2010 5:03 PM

To be fair, I haven’t seen Minnie Driver in Barney’s Passion or Michelle Williams in Wendy and Lucy, but I don’t think anyone else will either, so they’re probably safe.

Wendy and Lucy is supposed to have been brilliant. I've been meaning to see it. Thanks for the reminder - now it's at the top of my Netflix Instant Queue!

Posted by: Edith at November 30, 2010 5:05 PM

It's true, those Fockers ads are fucking inescapable. They're plastered EVERYWHERE on the train stations here- as if my commute weren't shitty enough -- and every time I see one it makes me want to stab a random commuter. I mean, just...fucking hell, De Niro.

Posted by: figgy at November 30, 2010 5:08 PM

DeNiro has just about parodied himself out of any consideration for anything, ever. Keep slumming it for those paychecks Bobby boy.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at November 30, 2010 5:56 PM

Wendy and Lucy doesn't matter as it was eligible two years ago, not this year. She and Sally Hawkins were both robbed of nominations the same year (by Angelina "I want MY son BACK" Jolie and Meryl "Missed the Point of Doubt" Streep).

Can't we all just agree it's crazy we have to consider a cast member of Dawson's Creek an Oscar-caliber actress? It's scary. Next you'll tell me someone from Beverly Hills 90210 won two Oscars...shit.

Posted by: Robert at November 30, 2010 6:14 PM

What is "Stone"?? Have I missed hearing about a movie that is supposed to be great?

"Wendy and Lucy" was boring and awful and a total downer AND it was out a couple years ago. Doesn't matter, I love Michelle Williams and I'm looking forward to her take on Marilyn Monroe.

Posted by: mslewis at November 30, 2010 7:04 PM

@ PissBoy
you fucking retard. katherine heigl is the epitome of evil, and bad actressing. fuck you

Posted by: Taylor K. at November 30, 2010 8:40 PM

Do you perhaps mean Barney's Version that you're not planning on seeing? If not, why the fuck not? It's got a solid cast, decent director, and is based on a great book by an amazing writer. Personally, I'm stoked to see it.

Posted by: koj at November 30, 2010 8:45 PM

mslewis, fear not. I saw Stone, and it was terrible and pointless. You're not missing anything, and there's no way it's taking home any hardware.

Posted by: sansho1 at November 30, 2010 11:47 PM

Stop the voting! Taylor K has won Eloquent Eloquence this week, and possibly for all time. What delicacy! What style!

Posted by: Ender at December 1, 2010 4:58 AM

Wendy and Lucy was a big ole Meh in my book. It was a movie that was about 10 years past it's due date--slow, brooding indie that you think is going somewhere until it doesn't.

Posted by: gunnertec at December 1, 2010 7:42 AM

I thought Meryl Streep was fantastic in Doubt and that The Exorcism of Emily Rose was a mediocre and ultimately forgettable film and role for Jennifer Carpenter. The Academy definitely overlooks horror (mostly rightfully) but that is not the movie I would make my stand on.

Posted by: becks at December 1, 2010 8:09 AM

Given the politics and other shenanigans that have been recounted here, explain to me why we should pay any more attention to the Oscars than we do to, say, the Teen Choice Awards?

Which is zero in both cases, if you ask ,.

Posted by: , at December 1, 2010 10:46 AM

Posted by: , at December 1, 2010 10:46 AM

As bad as the Oscars are, they're the only televised award show on the planet that still has an ounce of credibility left, though it's a very small fraction of an ounce. It's gotten so bad, the fucking World Wrestling Entertainment Slammy Awards* have more credibility that the Grammies, Emmy's and Tony's.

Though after you can say the phrase "Academy Award Winner Cuba Gooding Jr," I may want to rethink that statement.

*Actual awards

Posted by: Devil Child at December 5, 2010 7:59 PM