web
counter
 

Canada: The "What" in "What's New"

By Michael Murray | Posted Under PaEHba Day | Comments (77)



opening-bryan-adams.jpg

I’ve heard that in one form or another, 90 percent of Canadians tuned in to watch the Opening Ceremonies of the 2010 Winter Olympics in Vancouver last Friday. Canada — the country that never gives you any real cause to think about it — was about to have the eyes of the world, or at least those who care about the eccentric niche sports of Nordic countries, trained upon it.

It was a big deal for our country.

Everyone was excited, and not just to see our hockey heroes prevail in a “glamour” sport, but to be center stage for once, and have the rest of the world looking at us, and not those attention-hogging Americans. The Opening Ceremonies would propel us gloriously into the world, making us cool. We would become world-class, and everybody watching would want to come visit, and world leaders and tastemakers would always want to know our opinion.

We would wow the world with our Opening Ceremonies!

Our time had come.

And so I, like everybody else in the country, watched to see us this magical transformation take place.

I watched as fiddlers and tap dancers, all dressed like it was 1988 and they worked in a Celtic themed punk bar, tap-synched and fiddle-synched, as if in a particularly Canadian production of Stomp.

We saw John Furlong, the Games organizer, nervously make a long and boring speech in which he spoke of “the magic of television, ” making it sound like it was 1956, and that TV was still a cutting-edge marvel and not a technology that was quickly being replaced by all sorts of other delivery systems.

A Slam Poet from the Northwest Territories, who without a trace of irony wore a beret and vest, appeared on stage to declare that Canada is the “what” in “what’s new.” He looked quite a bit like how that Stars Wars kid from the YouTube video would have looked had he grown up Amish.

Bryan Adams came out (not of the closet) and sang a song, aboriginals danced, mangled French was spoken, an acrobat floated about the stadium to the strains of Joni Mitchell and a multitude of athletes were shown taking photos of themselves with their iPhones.

Watching all this, I found myself becoming increasingly preoccupied with the winter gear that everybody was wearing and the fake snow that lined the floor of BC Place, the climate-controlled domed stadium in which the ceremonies were taking place. For whatever reasons, people were pretending to be outdoors on a beautiful winter night when they were, in fact, inside. With fake snowflakes being blown about, and music that sounded like it was lifted from a Steven Spielberg movie blasting away, the evening lurched toward its emotional crescendo, the moment when the Olympic flame was to conclude its long journey.

But as this was a Canadian production, and our reach always seems to exceed our grasp, the four hydraulic things (looked a bit like Stonehenge — think Spinal Tap) that were to house the flame, would not ascend on cue. The participants stood nervously by, pretending that everything was going according to plan. Time passed. People exchanged nervous looks. More time passed.

Eventually, somebody told them to just light whatever was available to light. And then Wayne Gretzky was dispatched, via the back of a white pick-up truck — after having to wait in an air lock so that the roof of the domed stadium wouldn’t collapse when they opened the front door — through the mild and rainy streets of Vancouver, to ignite the external cauldron. As he was doing this, nervously looking at the torch as if he fully expected the rain to extinguish it, boozy dudes emerged from the sparse crowd of bystanders and began to run along beside him shouting stuff like “Yeah, Fucken A! Canada, Wooo!”

It might not have been world-class, but it was sweet, if embarrassing.

This is Canada.

What you have to know in order to understand and expect a spectacle such as this is that Canada doesn’t really have any sort of national identity. We tend to define ourselves in opposition to the States, the big brother we watch from afar with jealousy and contempt.

We love you, by the way.

We really do.

We want to be you.

But we’re utterly overwhelmed by your confidence, certainty, and inventiveness, and so, we seek to create virtue out of necessity. If Americans are confident, then to be confident is bad, and we must be modest. If America is a melting pot where everybody becomes united, than we’re a mosaic, a place where everybody is governmentally directed to maintain whatever tribal customs they’ve happened to import. If America is about making money, then Canada is about distributing it. If you have “American Idol,” then we have “Canadian Idol.”

It goes on like this.

Our identity is framed in opposition.

Canada is a default position.

Of course, at the root of this is a powerful insecurity. We lack confidence, having always felt overshadowed by, well, everybody. This stigma is so deep rooted, that we didn’t even produce on our own Opening Ceremonies show, but got a couple of Australians to tour around the country for two years, and then produce something based on what they saw.

Think about that for a moment.

We’re really not that self-reliant of a people.

In Canada, ambition is seen as a bad thing, something obnoxious. It’s not an individual wanting to realize his or her full potential, but a vain attempt to make other people feel badly about not realizing their own. We may be polite, but we’re also unfriendly and inhibited, only too eager to project a moral superiority that’s entirely unearned.

It’s pretty fucked-up.

Watching the Winter Olympics, in which we hope to excel in sports that mightier nations pay scant attention (Short Track Speed Skating!), you can see this. Needy and self-important, we overlook all of our own faults, and pompously simulating a winter wonderland in a domed stadium, we become little more than a big-budget Christopher Guest movie, all the while thinking we’re the “new” in “what’s new?”

Michael_Murray_480.jpg

Michael Murray is a freelance writer. For the last three and a half years he’s written a weekly column for the Ottawa Citizen about watching television. He presently lives in Toronto. You can find more of his musings on his blog, or check out his Facebook page.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



The Trailer Park Boys: Countdown to Liquor Day Review | The History Behind SCTV









Comments

I'm gonna go ahead and say that the part where the acrobat performed to 'Both Sides Now' was one of the most beautiful things I've ever seen.

Posted by: buttercup at February 18, 2010 11:38 AM

I actually loved Shane Koyczan (the "slam poet"). I've seen him live before and he is an extremely powerful speaker. Ya, not much to look at but it's his words that you're paying attention to. I thought it was really great to have him incorporated into the ceremonies.

Posted by: zygomatique at February 18, 2010 11:38 AM

Frankly I'd have a lot more respect for all of you if you'd drop the Commonwealth bullshit. Do you really need to be beholden to an in-bred tax-dodging troll in a palace in London?
Maybe all of that "we're not really a nation" stuff would come to an end if you stood up and became a nation that has an official and democratically elected head of state actually resident in your country.

Posted by: PaddyDog at February 18, 2010 11:39 AM

I love you PaddyDog.

Posted by: admin at February 18, 2010 11:48 AM

Ick, what a cynical article to publish today. Shame on me for loving my country and enjoying the day. Thanks for bringing the mood down.

Posted by: becks at February 18, 2010 11:50 AM

You obviously took the NYT column to heart…

I think it is naïve to believe that Canada, writ large, thought the Olympic Opening Ceremonies were going to be our coming-out party. It was not a debutante ball. It wasn’t our Independence Day.

You were waiting for the Opening Ceremonies to define our country?

Perhaps being born in the “Dallas of the North” has skewed my perception. But I am damn proud to be a Canadian. I am not ashamed of being Canadian. I will not employ passive-aggressive, faux modesty so that others will pat me on the head and say, “Nice Canuck”.

Excelling in obscure sports that mightier nations pay scant attention to? Which mightier nations are not paying attention? USA? UK? Japan? China? They all seem pretty interested in our little “event” going on right now, and kicking our asses in a lot of the sports.

By the power Godtopus and Godtopussy, I would stand on that stage, alongside the Slam Poet and say… Canada. Fuckin’ eh. The vitriol that has been spewed around these Olympics is astounding. It is embarrassing that you repeated it here.

Posted by: Sassy Rouge at February 18, 2010 12:07 PM

Thanks Admin. I was hoping that would be seen as not a slam on the Canadian people (what I know of you I love to bits. You are so much better than that. Afterall, you are the country that gave me my beloved Labrador Retrievers. Truly the best thing EVER to come out of Canada.

Posted by: PaddyDog at February 18, 2010 12:09 PM

Well said Rouge.

Posted by: becks at February 18, 2010 12:09 PM

I'll say this for America's hat: that maple leaf produces some awesome winter gear. While American skiers look like they're in their goddamn jammies, the Canadians are rocking those cool cream-and-scarlet suits. Every time the Winter Olympics roll around, I want to stock on Team Canada gear. I don't because, I mean, it's Canada. But y'all are some well-dressed moose-humpers.

Posted by: Human Centipede - Segment Three at February 18, 2010 12:10 PM

So, Paddy, by "an official and democratically elected head of state" you mean have the leader be the person that wins the largest percentage of the popular vote?

Like you guys?...oh, wait...

Never mind...

Posted by: Groucho at February 18, 2010 12:10 PM

Regarding the Queen: I don't think anybody pays much attention to her or the G-G unless some bullshit *coughproroguecough* comes up. Canada functions as its own nation, aside from Lizzie's head on our currency.

Since many people up here can't tell the difference between a parliamentary democracy and a republic, there's a lot of confusion in Canadian politics, equating the PM with being the President. I can't really tell where the hell I'm going with this, aside from Murrican TV polluting the minds of idiots here and kids not being required to take Canadian history to graduate. I don't know what it will take to develop a Canadian national identity, but it's sure going to be a difficult task since Canada is Really Big, and we've got rocks and trees and trees and rocks and rocks and trees and trees and rocks and WATER.

Posted by: Sulphuraceous at February 18, 2010 12:20 PM

Go Rouge!

I thought we were slamming America today. With love, of course, and little hugs on the side.

My mind locked a bit when I read 'aboriginals danced', until I read that the Aussies were in the director chair.
Wierd..

Inuit don't dance??

Posted by: Magiel at February 18, 2010 12:25 PM

Groucho, maybe Paddy wanted you to learn from our mistake instead of following our example.

We have grown wise(ish) in eight years (well, some of us).

Posted by: esme at February 18, 2010 12:26 PM

Also, if being Canadian means you must unquestionably love every aspect of the Olympics, I say, "Fuck that noise". I'm tired of this "If you're against the war, you're against the troops" mentality. I'm Canadian, and I'll bitch and whine and be as negative as I want. And I won't tell you what I would do differently if I was in charge, either. Ha!

Posted by: Sulphuraceous at February 18, 2010 12:27 PM

Canada is a default position.

Aw, this makes me sad. I'm an unwilling hegemonist. Unwilling!

And PaddyDog has a point. I've spent time amongst Australians and they have the same problem. Throw off the yoke already!

Posted by: Jerce at February 18, 2010 12:29 PM

If you are interested in meeting some Canadians...go to Mexico.

mr.wsapnin & I went in October and we were about the only people from the USA there. They even had a huge sign that said "Welcome Canadians".

mr.wsapnin was chastised on his pronunciation of 'hockey' (we learned that it is 'hawkey' not 'haahhkey') and told "You guys have funny accents, eh."

Posted by: wsapnin at February 18, 2010 12:30 PM

Maybe it's the law student in me, but I'm going to find you and force you to compare and contrast the Canadian and American constitutions, then the Bill of Rights against our Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Then you get to read the speeches and memoirs of Sir John A and Pierre Trudeau. Then tell me with a straight face that Canadians define themselves in opposition to the Americans.

That or I'll lock you in a broom closet with Don Cherry and tell him you hate the Bruins and think his dog Blue's a pussy. Then you'll regret it!

Posted by: lordhelmet at February 18, 2010 12:30 PM

Sassy Rouge, I wish your comment would have been the actual article instead.

Posted by: taylor at February 18, 2010 12:32 PM

What a piss poor, paint every one with the same brush, fucking diatribe. Why don't you fire that insecure shit back into "word", do a "search and replace" on "we're" and replace it with "I'm".
I'm with Sassy Rogue. I'm proud of my country, and her people. We are confident and most of my friends have no fucking desire to be American. No offence but I like my country just fine.
It's stereotypical shit like this that causes misconceptions on both sides of the border. No, my Yankee friends, we (Canadians) do not all share the views expressed here and I'm quite sure (based on many travels South of the border) that most you are not the stereotypical "Americans" that our Rick Mercer and your Jay Leno make fun of.
I can't think of anything else to write but I think I've made my point...

Good Day Eh?

Posted by: East Coast Ugly at February 18, 2010 12:35 PM

Are you really saying Canadians live in a perpetual state of USA-envy? I would argue MOST CERTAINLY NOT..we are the way we are because we are a huge mix of identities that DO NOT form a melting pot - everyone retains their own culture, it does not mix into one "Canadianess." It has nothing to do with the United States and I find this article just appaulingly unrepresentative of Canada in any way.

Posted by: NOVA SCOTIA at February 18, 2010 12:38 PM

Groucho:

I'm not a US citizen: I have no vote in the US so you can't blame me for Bush. But you have to admit it's preposterous to have major event such as the Winter Olympics in a country and the event has to be opened by a representative of a woman who has set foot in that country maybe 10 times in her entire life? And then you have to play a salute that combines "Oh Canada" and "God Save the Queen". "Oh Canada" honours a country and its people. GSTQ basically asks everyone to pray that this one woman will remain alive to "rule over us". It's 2010, time to stop behaving like serfs.

Posted by: PaddyDog at February 18, 2010 12:38 PM

You know, Paddy, I'm getting the feeling you don't have many warm feelings about Royal House's.. eh?

I always think it's a bit naive that, if you support an old tradition, at once you are a serf.

Because there is No serfdom in any liberal, non royal econimic state, eh?

On a non-related note, I'm starting to like this Eh noise.

Posted by: Magiel at February 18, 2010 12:44 PM

I think many Canadians agree with you PaddyDog.

Posted by: becks at February 18, 2010 12:44 PM

Dammit, East Coast Ugly...I was making the wait 'til 5pm to have a brewski my Lent thing...

Now have to pop one open to toast you...the only thing about the Opening Ceremonies that struck me was how badly they effed up the arrangement of "O Canada"...

Posted by: Groucho at February 18, 2010 12:48 PM

Okay, thank god. I don't comment very much so was reluctant to be the first commenter calling out a fellow Canadian for writing such a slam on his own country. But I have to agree with Sassy Rouge and all the other dissenters. I am never overwhelmed by the confidence of others, be they American anyone else, and am proud to stand here and confidently call myself a Canadian, an achiever of great things (some still to come) and unobnoxiously ambitious. Thank you very much.

Posted by: zygomatique at February 18, 2010 12:51 PM

Paddy, all due respect your anti-monarchist sensibilities...but having Liz as our figurehead in no way lessens our position as a "real" country.

I'm sorry that your Granny got run over by a queen, or whatever. Truly.

Posted by: Groucho at February 18, 2010 12:51 PM

I hate hearing all the negative stuff about our Olympics, especially since I live in Vancouver (fine, technically just outside of it). Did the Opening Ceremony go perfectly? I suppose not, but I watched the entire thing and I can't even fully explain how pumped it made me for the Games and how much it made me fall further in love with my province and country. So, I'll be leaving shortly to go be downtown and be proud to be Canadian and from Vancouver, not in terms of comparison of other places, but for its own beauty. And kick assery. VANCOUVER 2010, bitches!!!

Posted by: Bon at February 18, 2010 12:52 PM

Just my Amurrican thoughts...
I loved the Opening Ceremonies.
Considering the budget was somewhere in the 30-50 million range, it was a gorgeous and wonderful production. The use of projectors was innovative and brilliantly utilized. The stories told and sung brought me to tears on several occasions.
In short, well done Canada and thank you for providing a beautiful venue for the 2010 Games.

Posted by: Spender at February 18, 2010 1:08 PM

I am Canadian, and I feel that Canada has a strong national identity, and it has nothing whatsoever to do with compare and contrast. But my supporting argument would run into GYOFB territory, and so I simply say: nuts to you.

Posted by: Melodie at February 18, 2010 1:09 PM

Thanks Groucho...
Guys like the ones who wrote this poor excuse of an article NEED there to be differences between people. They are the same types that work within our own borders to convince us that East Coasters are so much different than Quebecers or Upper Canadians.
Mr Murray, get out of your fucking cube, stop reading your bullshit monthly propaganda journals and take trip around our country AND theirs. You will find, in no uncertain terms, my friend, that we are not very different... As is most often the case it's the loudmouths who have the bullhorn or the soapbox that get the attention and attempt t pass off their own views as universal...

Posted by: East Coast Ugly at February 18, 2010 1:10 PM

One more proud Canadian (who spent the past three years living, and could not be happier to be home) checking in. Our country isn't perfect, but it's also not a British colony or America's little bitch - and it certainly can't be both at the same time, but that fact seems to escape a lot of the people who like to criticize us.

Canada is about different things for different people, and maybe you really have experienced it to be what you wrote here. In that case, I just feel sorry for you. You're missing out. My Canada is about incredibly innovative political and legal mechanisms that have kept very disparate groups living together (relatively) harmoniously. It's about taking a little less for yourself so that everyone can access quality education and health care. It's about a Charter of Rights and Freedoms that has inspired methods of constitutional law around the world. It's about loving sports as stupid as curling (which I do), and saying pop instead of soda, and knowing that it's not actually cold out unless the temperature has gone south of minus ten celsius.

It's about a nation that collectively kicked the shit out of a political party who tried to make an election issue out of an opposition leader's facial paralysis, and a country that managed to stamp out domestic terrorism almost overnight by having even hardcore separatists simply turn their back on the idea of violence. It's about turning out to welcome the Queen while simultaneously demanding accountability from the people who actually run the country. It's about knowing that my ability to obtain an abortion will never be threatened, and that our government will never again put someone to death.

I don't know what caused you to lose your ambition, but my country and I have plenty and we're not ashamed of it. Judging from the screaming crowds of Canadians every time one of our athletes so much as peeks their head out at the Games, I'm not the only one who feels that way.

Posted by: Artemis at February 18, 2010 1:19 PM

Sorry, that should say "living in the U.S." in the first line. Apparently my Canada does not include proofreading.

Posted by: Artemis at February 18, 2010 1:21 PM

I dunno. I read the piece as tongue-in-cheek. Yet our Canadian friends are now in an uproar. Maybe a little too sensitive, eh?

Posted by: Mickey at February 18, 2010 1:22 PM

Well said Artemis...

P.S.
This was the first Olympic opening ceremony that I actually watched from end to end. I though they did an amazing job.

Posted by: East Coast Ugly at February 18, 2010 1:25 PM

Couldn't be, Mickey.
According to Mr. Murry we're all fucking insecure, impassive bitches...

Posted by: East Coast Ugly at February 18, 2010 1:29 PM

Damn skippy Artemis!

Posted by: lordhelmet at February 18, 2010 1:31 PM

I don't think the article was tongue in cheek.

Posted by: becks at February 18, 2010 1:32 PM

It feels a bit like Mr Murray, who writes nice bytheway, would have rather been born in the USA.

Posted by: Magiel at February 18, 2010 1:36 PM

Artemis - that was beautiful. So very well put.

Posted by: Sassy Rouge at February 18, 2010 1:40 PM

You Nucks earn your insecurities because you royally fucked up this Olympics business. You had the Summer Olympics in a city where summer lasts a week and it snows, and the Winter Olympics in a city where it's apparently always April.

Nice job.
+++
That or I'll lock you in a broom closet with Don Cherry and tell him you hate the Bruins and think his dog Blue's a pussy. Then you'll regret it!

Posted by: lordhelmet at February 18, 2010 12:30 PM
---
HAH! Waaaay back when I was in college and a regular attendee at Penguins games (give you an idea how long ago this was: The Penguins' stars were Jean Pronovost and Pierre Larouche), the Pens ended up facing the Bruins in the first round of the Cup playoffs.

Cherry was the Bruins' coach. Before the series he told the press that Blue had predicted Bruins in 6, but after Boston won the first three games easily Blue was calling for the sweep. Cherry also bitched that after game 3 some Pens fan had poured a beer over him, so from now on he was only wearing corduroy in Pittsburgh.

We decided such affronts to our dignity could not stand.

At this time at the Civic Arena, you could get a front row seat in the balcony if you showed up early enough, even for a Cup game. So we found someone in the dorm who had a big stuffed dog and we found someone else who had a length of twine and we made up a big sign that read "BLUE" and we smuggled these into the arena and we got seats in the front row and we taped our "BLUE" sign to the front of the balcony and we tied one end of the twine to the balcony railing and the other end around the dog's neck.

And we waited.

When Cherry came out on the ice before the game, we dropped the dog over the railing and swung it back and forth. Cherry looked up straight at us and ...

At this point the stories differ a little. I thought he waved at us mockingly, but someone else in the party insisted Don Cherry gave us the the finger in front of 15,000 people.

It's not really important now. The key facts were these:

Blue was right. The Bruins kicked Penguins ass again, 4-0, and swept the series.

And:

The incident with Cherry and the stuffed dog made the paper the next day.

Lose some, win some.

Posted by: , at February 18, 2010 1:40 PM

I thought that the opening ceremonies for Beijing couldn't be topped. They were a big, over-the-top, budget-busting spectacle. I mean, there were what, 15,000 performers? So I didn't know what to expect for Vancouver.

And then, as I was watching, a single boy came out onto the floor and performed an absolutely beautifully choreographed acrobatic routine set to one of the most gorgeous songs that I love by Joni Mitchell. And I'm not ashamed to admit that I was moved by the performance. And it struck me that in its simplicity, the performance had set the ceremonies apart from the Beijing ones. The Vancouver ceremonies were in a class of their own.

I've never been a big fan of slam poetry, but I loved Shane Koyczan's performance as well. It was unique, and heartfelt.

Where the Beijing ceremonies were all about spectacle and number, these ceremonies were all about heart and connection, about being one instead of many. At least, that's the way it seemed to me. So kudos, Vancouver.

Posted by: Meli Mel (formerly MelBivDevoe) at February 18, 2010 1:46 PM

Fellow 'Jibans Who Happen to Be Canadian:

I think it's great that you have pride in being Canadian. (As an American, I spend too much time thinking, "How the hell to I share a country with these people?!?") I do, however, think that you are being a bit harsh towards Mr. Murray, who I believe wrote this piece with no small amount of tongue in cheek.

C'mon, this line alone, "...we’re a mosaic, a place where everybody is governmentally directed to maintain whatever tribal customs they’ve happened to import" was hilarious. And the part that preceded it, about the US = a melting pot, where everyone is united, is a clear tip off that he's not being terribly serious, because everyone knows we're a divided mess.

So yes, go on with your celebrating of your homeland--I envy you. But please stop taking this post so seriously.

Also, Groucho, you do know that Paddy's Irish, right? And therefore has very strong feelings (to which she is rightfully entitled) about the British monarchy.

Posted by: tamatha at February 18, 2010 1:48 PM

Just my opinion, but I think the article may have gotten exactly the reaction that Mr. Murray was looking for.

Posted by: admin at February 18, 2010 1:53 PM

As an American who has visited our neighbors to the north on several occasions, the view from down here is a bit different. You have a great and beautiful country with much to be proud of. But you don’t need to be so sensitive to those (inside and outside) that poke fun of you. The American colonies were once Europe’s private bitch. Then we grew some balls, and...., you know the rest. If you’re fed up with the hand you’ve been dealt and how you’ve been treated, then please declare war on the U.S. and/or U.K. and get it over with. (See Grand Fenwick, “The Mouse That Roared”, circa 1959.)

Posted by: Mickey at February 18, 2010 1:53 PM

Just my opinion, but I think the article may have gotten exactly the reaction that Mr. Murray was looking for.

I love you Admin. I know I keep saying that but it doesn't make it less true.

Our Mr. Murray's such a naughty boy...

Posted by: Kelly at February 18, 2010 1:56 PM

Unnecessary wars aren't really our thing.

Posted by: becks at February 18, 2010 1:58 PM

If he truly meant this as a tongue in cheek article then I wish he'd made it a bit more clear. I think there are many people who didn't get the joke.

Posted by: becks at February 18, 2010 2:00 PM

Ooooh, admin, you make a very good point. That Mr. Murray is quite the sneaky Canadian, isn't he?

Posted by: tamatha at February 18, 2010 2:01 PM

becks - but if you follow admin's logic, Mr. Murray has done an excellent job of getting the Canadians all out and up in arms defending their country.

Posted by: tamatha at February 18, 2010 2:03 PM

I like Mickey's idea. I think a tidy little war would be good for both our countries.

To begin with, we'd never see it coming. In fact, it's possible that Canada could invade us for weeks and people would still be going, "You've gotta be kidding me...Canada?"

Michigan could use some foot traffic. Military installations from either side would only help their economy.

Americans would get taken down a peg, which frankly we could do with; while Canadians would get an ego boost.

I can say all this because I live in South Texas, and you hosers would never get this far south; and even if you did, you would just melt anyway.

Posted by: Jerce at February 18, 2010 2:06 PM

I suppose but what a spectacularly un-Canadian way to do that. I guess it is very Pajiba of him though so if these were his intentions then he achieved what he was looking for.

Posted by: becks at February 18, 2010 2:07 PM

Lordy.

Let me first say that however you regard the spectacle and commercial intent of the Olympics, it’s always worth the price of admission to see the joy written in the faces of the athletes. There’s nothing like it. I’ve now seen countless interviews with Canadian athletes—most who did not win a medal—and each one of them has been grateful and modest, positively glowing with beauty and optimism. It does a soul good, it does.

The Opening Ceremonies, which are necessarily self-promotional, are always an awkward mix of kitsch and patriotism and to make fun of them is about as original and difficult as making of fun of The Academy Awards. However, anything that compels 90% of a country to watch has an absolutely massive cultural significance. We, as Canadians, care, and we care deeply. This is obvious from the immediate, and passionate, responses to the article. Who we are, and how we're viewed in the world remains a sensitive topic.

The question, I suppose-- and it’s a very big question-- is why?

At any rate, I won’t go on about why that might be, but I do think it’s worth considering that it might have something to do with the inescapable fact that we’re situated directly beside the United States of America, which for the last 50 years has been the unparalleled cultural, economic and military force in the world.

Personally, I love both Canada and the United States, and my take on the Winter Olympics—which are taking place in one of the few cities in Canada that doesn’t have a winter—was meant to be funny and broad in approach, ironic—which I understand is a Canadian trait—rather than damning.

Posted by: michael murray at February 18, 2010 2:09 PM

I don't really care if the author meant it. When people write stuff like this, even ironically, most of the rest of the world seems to take it to heart. Every time I've turned on NBC for the past week, some commentator has been marvelling over how Canada is surprising everyone by actually wanting to win things. Most of the Americans I know - smart, well educated, nice people - really know nothing about their closest neighbour and believe every word of things like this.

When people write tongue in cheek articles about American stereotypes, a lot of Americans get upset and defensive. I don't understand why people expect something different here.

And Admin: if the author thinks he needs to provoke Canadians into patriotism, he can go fuck himself. I will talk your ear off about this country given the chance, and would happily have done so if someone had written a thoughtful piece instead of this garbage.

Posted by: Artemis at February 18, 2010 2:14 PM

Which was, in all, a beautiful thing to see.

Well played, Murray, well played.

Posted by: Smokin at February 18, 2010 2:16 PM

I've been saying that for years. America needs, as a state, to be invaded on land.

Just to grow up.

Posted by: Magiel at February 18, 2010 2:18 PM

Tamantha

At first, no I didn't. This "not a real country" idiocy is usually directed at us from points south. The nationality of the person spewing it makes no difference to me. We are a "real" country : borders, unique regional cultures, sovereignty...the whole nine. People have died defending this land from foreign aggressors, on more occasions than the 2 you're familiar with. To label Canada "not a real country", is to piss on their sacrifice and is offensive.

And I don't particularly give a rat's ass where you came from when you say it. But it might be that I have some strongly held feelings to which I'm rightfully entitled.

And one of those feelings is that your beef with some institutional figurehead does not entitle you to belittle my country, of which, obviously, I am quite proud.

Posted by: Groucho at February 18, 2010 2:19 PM

Hmm. Well then. Hugs and kisses for everyone, or at least a Beavertail and coffee with Bailey's.

Posted by: Sassy Rouge at February 18, 2010 2:19 PM

"...if someone had written a thoughtful piece instead..."

Artemis: You did. Thank you.

Posted by: Mickey at February 18, 2010 2:20 PM

The politeness, the mosaic, the insecurity, the defensiveness, the strange and unique language, the fucking snow high as your head ... I recognize this place! It's ...

Canada? Oh, for a second I thought y'all were talking about Pittsburgh.

Ahem. Carry on.

Posted by: , at February 18, 2010 2:20 PM

Hee! Jerce you're funny. I like you! Want to be my new American friend?

Posted by: Kelly at February 18, 2010 2:20 PM

Artemis:

On Sunday, the topic of the extremely popular CBC call in radio show Cross Canad Checkup, was "Own the podium." This is a funding program designed to get Canadian athletes to achieve, well, podium performances, and it was considered to be an American-win-at-all-costs sentiment. People from all over the country called in to express their absolute horror and disgust that such a notion could be infecting our culture. There was a self-satisfied piety and hypocrisy to these calls that was really actually quite demoralizing. I mean, what if an athlete, for whatever reason, is driven to be the very best in the world?

Posted by: michael murray at February 18, 2010 2:23 PM

I'm happy you clarified your feelings Michael Murray. I honestly didn't get your joke. I admire your intent at least.

Posted by: becks at February 18, 2010 2:24 PM

I can't remember the last time I watched an Opening Ceremony from start to finish... I really liked the flying acrobat, I loved the poet, I choked up hearing K D Lang, and I seriously wished I could move to Vancouver cuz, DAMN Canada looks fricking beautiful.
I thought the Opening Ceremony was done really really well, even with the technical difficulties.

Oh, and those killer whales 'spouting' water, holy shit, I got chills...

Posted by: Stella at February 18, 2010 3:01 PM

That was my favourite part too Stella!

Posted by: becks at February 18, 2010 3:16 PM

Mr. Murray, I too REALLY enjoyed running a 'what a bunch of hosers' dialogue through the whole ceremony...you'd never know how much I love this place if you'd heard it. But that's family is it not? It's safe to criticize that which you love the most, because you love it, and it can take it.

Plus, there's more than one voice in Canada...sing what you wanna sing!
:)

Posted by: replica at February 18, 2010 3:35 PM

Sigh, Groucho, first of all, when calling somebody out, it's good to spell their name correctly--there's no "n" in tamatha; it is not like Samantha with a "t." As I've suggested to others, when in doubt, copy 'n' paste.

Second, she didn't so much insult Canada, as encourage you to throw off the yoke of the British monarchy. But you seemed to have missed that, and I figured it might help you understand where she's coming from if you knew she wasn't American, but Irish.

Not that Paddy needs any help from me. She is more than capable of handling her own battles. I wouldn't want to cross her.

But don't let me stop you from misinterpreting what she said and getting all riled up. Go on with your Canadian self.

Posted by: tamatha at February 18, 2010 3:58 PM

so sorry,Tamatha

Wasn't calling you out, btw...much too un-Canadian...just responding to a clear implication of what Paddy said : that the "not a real country" sentiment is a function of us being a Commonwealth country...that without Liz on our money, we'd be seen by all as finally being "real".

And I called horse shit. Still do.

Just thought you'd be better able to get my point if you understood where I'm coming from...so I sought to be better understood.

And I didn't even bring up the fact that some of those dead Canucks died defending this country from expat Irish Anti-Monarchists (Fenian Raids...not too well known, but still...), so I thought I was playing nice.

Posted by: Groucho at February 18, 2010 4:20 PM

On behalf of Lord Helmut and East Coast Ugly I must give the a big "lawyered" out to Mr. Murray.

I'm with Kelly ...Jerce you are funny, wanna be my friend too?

Posted by: Mrs. Admin at February 18, 2010 5:18 PM

On a more serious note...Canada/America must not be too bad when we have lived next to each other all these years and not had border skirmishes every other day like some other countries. I thank god everyday that I do not live in the mix of war on my own soil.

Posted by: Mrs. Admin at February 18, 2010 5:22 PM

Canada needs to throw off the yoke of the monarchy and stand up as a nation? Are you kidding me? I think I missed the part where we're oppressed.

Who the shit cares if our titular head of state is a representative of the Queen of England? And before some jackass starts in about the prorogation of parliament: an elected or appointed head of state in a presidential-parliamentary model that we would likely adopt if we did away with the monarchy would have the same powers, it has nothing to do with the Queen.

Posted by: Brenton at February 18, 2010 9:31 PM

becks: *Canada doesn't do unneccesary wars? Might that not be some of that unearned moral superiority I've been hearing about? Because as Noam Chomsky noted, if anyone had bothered to look at the data collected, most Americans didn't actually favor the war in Afghanistan because no one could figure out how the hell the Bush administration had connected that country to the 9/11 attacks.

Since Canada decided to send troops and you guys are apparently so superior at controlling your government, perhaps you could share with us your super-secret intel?

Please. Canada has a history of supporting wars. But, alas, tries to claim moral superiority by not putting troops on the ground. No, peace-loving Canada just supplies munitions or, as with Vietnam, napalm.

I was almost Canadian, it was thisclose, but my mom got papers from the US first. Never ever wished it'd happened the other way.

*I've only made it through about half the books I have concerning Canadian history, and have almost finished my courses on American history. If I've made errors please point them out, but nothing I've read supports this dumb-ass idea that Canada is a peace-loving, tree-hugging, whale-saving land of unicorns where even the crankiest of people shit sunshine.

Posted by: Moira at February 19, 2010 8:02 AM

Wow. I think they have meetings for that Moira.

Posted by: becks at February 19, 2010 11:15 AM

Nucks is spelted 'Nucks.

I rest my case.

vi

Posted by: victor. victor immature at February 19, 2010 12:54 PM

Death to Americanada! Have your winter Olympics, dogs! Nothing personal, and anyway Little Mosque on the Prairie is still my favourite TV programme. We also watch old re-runs of The Beach Combers by sat-feed here in the caves at Tora Bora.

PS. We all think Anne Murray and Joni Mitchell would look hot in a Burka.

Posted by: Gonzoville at February 19, 2010 9:10 PM

I am a proud Canadian. I don't define myself in opposition to the US! WTF? Canada is the greatest country in the world (we think), and who cares if the giant spliffs failed to rise on time? The flame was lit, and Vancouver is a huge party at the moment.
The only thing that has truly sucked about our Games is the freak death of the poor Georgian kid. RIP Nodar...

Posted by: Canuckistani at February 19, 2010 10:00 PM

i was actually AT Opening Ceremonies and I thought they were pretty great. For all the things that have gone wrong at the Games thus far, Vancouver has been a hell of a host city and the US Team is cleaning up.

Posted by: katie at February 20, 2010 2:57 AM

It's sad but true: Some people are embarrassed by expressions of Canadian patriotism. It's also no accident that the author of this despicable, highly inaccurate, rant is a Toronto resident, where America envy is pervasive and obvious to most Canadians who don't live in Southern Ontario. And typically, this article gives the impression that the author's arrogant opinions reflect common Canadian values (or lack of well-defined ones). They don't. They only reflects a highly colloquial inner-city Toronto mentality.

You need travel your county more, instead of holing up in Hogtown and pretending that's Canada.

Maybe you could get a writing job for one of those British rags that love to slag a country they also don't have much of a clue about. You'll probably fit right in.

I thought the opening ceremonies were beautiful and touching.

Posted by: dualie at February 25, 2010 6:13 PM