bush1.jpg



Your Name is Bush!

A New Millennium Nigga

Miscellaneous | September 6, 2006 | Comments (78)


I try. I really do try. I try with all my mind, heart, and soul to go through my day and see shit the way others do. But it just doesn’t work for A New Millennium Nigga. Take the picture above. What do you see? A President creating a photo-op with a popular athlete? Maybe you even saw the video and realize that he’s having a little fun with the fact that he and Reggie Bush share the same last name. You may even admire the way that President of the Stepford PTA Laura Bush is literally standing by her man.

See, that’s not what I see.

I see a long, ominous shadow cast. I see a modern media echo of the slave auction.

I might not even have thought of it if Bush — the President, not the player — wasn’t greeting New Orleans as part of an acknowledgement of the Katrina debacle. I might not have thought of it if I hadn’t one year ago offered a heartfelt “Amen!” to Kanye’s simple statement, “George Bush doesn’t care about black people!” I might not have thought it if Bush — the player, not the President — wasn’t a part of the whole spectacle solely because of his physical strength(s). But those are a lot of if’s. And as I’ve been told, “If a frog had a glass ass, he would slide instead of hop.”

So, I did think of it. I thought, “Muthfucka. What the fuck so so funny? Chances are that his last name is Bush because somebody who looked like you kidnapped somebody who looked like him … or bought their ass! That somebody who looked like you probably whupped that somebody who looked like him until he called himself ‘Bush!’”

I might not see it that way if I hadn’t been watching “When the Levees Broke” on my TiVo recently. I might not see it that way if I hadn’t had my heart ripped out of my chest with images of Americans — some, but not all, who had skin like mine — floating and rotting in flood waters that should have been held by those levees. I might not see it that way if it hadn’t taken George W. Bush two weeks to get his ass down to the scene of his crime. I might not see it that way if — as Kanye also pointed out, as Mike Myers and America looked on dumbfounded — black people weren’t described as looting food while whites were described as finding food to survive. But that’s a lot of if’s. And as I’ve been told, “If ‘if’ was a spliff we’d all be high.”

So, all I see here is Massa and Missus showing off their little Black Bush. And it pisses me off. So I laugh to keep from crying. Because sometimes I feel like I see shit that ain’t actually there. And sometimes I feel like I see shit that is actually there, shit that a lot of other muthafuckas just don’t see. And sometimes I wonder how people can be pissed at me for using the term “nigga” when this image is everywhere and nobody seems to notice the bitter irony of a rich white man celebrating his “shared” last name with a faceless black buck.

“Toby Bush,” said the muthafucka who looked like George W. Bush as the muthafucka who looked like Reggie Bush made the whip heavy with his blood. “That’s your name now, Kunta!” And then Louis Gossett, Jr. taught him not to have such a rebellious spirit. And that shit was passed down from generation to generation.

I was taught when I studied biology that there are dominant and recessive genes. A New Millennium Nigga submits that there are also dominant and submissive genes. There’s some shit that seems to be embedded within us, like a compliant reporter in Iraq, that allows us (across the races) to think nothing of it as Bush — the President, not the player — uses Bush — the player, not the President — to have a lighthearted moment over the corpses of men, women, children, and a city who didn’t have to die that way, whom he forgot a little over a year ago, who rotted and drowned and starved to death, whose blood is — at least, in part — on his rich, white hands.

I might not see it that way if he hadn’t told “Brownie” on camera that he was doing a good job. I might not see it that way if I didn’t feel in my heart that it would not have taken two weeks to show up had the tragedy happened on Martha’s Vineyard. I might not see it that way if I didn’t feel he trades on — and perhaps buys into — the “The South Will Rise Again” mentality that exists just beneath the surface of the national political landscape. But that’s a lot of if’s. And as I’ve been told, “If your mom had a dick, she woulda been your dad.”

So, go back and take another look at that picture. And then ask yourself if A New Millennium Nigga saying “nigga” is really the problem facing niggas today. And if you still think I am … then to paraphrase Jack Nicholson in A Few Good Men: That’s why you want me on this blog! That’s why you need me on this blog!

Orlando Bishop, a.k.a., A New Millennium Nigga, is a writer living in L.A. You can find more of his work at The Musings of a New Millennium Nigga.









Wicker Man, The | The Best Movies You've Never Seen













Comments

Silly me, I thought this might turn out to be an actual review of "When The Levees Broke".

Posted by: erin at September 6, 2006 6:09 PM

Because sometimes I feel like I see shit that ain’t actually there. And sometimes I feel like I see shit that is actually there, shit that a lot of other muthafuckas just don’t see.

Damn. For years I've been thinking I was the only one who felt like that. Thank you.

P.S. to erin: Where in the title of this article did you see a reference to 'When The Levees Broke'?

Posted by: Jerce at September 6, 2006 7:24 PM

Unless you and I are having some sort of mutual hallucination...you aren't crazy. I see it, and I can't figure out what everyone ELSE is seeing.

Posted by: karen at September 6, 2006 7:40 PM

I don't know what happened. One minute I'm looking for some cheap (yet slightly intellectual) entertainment and suddenly, without realizing I wasn't reading a movie review I find myself feeling guilty for being so pale. I'm angry at "The Man" for spending millions (or is it billions?) of dollars so people can choose to wallow in their situation rather than pick themselves up and recreate their lives. The tired excuse of long gone historical mistakes seems suddenly fresh and new and relevant to why my life has been so unfairly easy. Thank you, Pajiba, for filling the vacuum where I should have been keeping my morals, responsibilities, and (God forbid) my own opinion. I see the light. And to think it's only taken 2 years of busting on Tyler Perry to lull me into a false sense of trust and security before revealing your cunning plan. Kudos to you, Pajiba. Well played.

Posted by: jen at September 6, 2006 8:23 PM

I have nothing to add, other than to say I'm exceedingly unlikely to buy a logo T-shirt from a company whose ad reads: "It's OK to laugh, We're use to it."

Posted by: sansho1 at September 6, 2006 9:10 PM

This is some right-on truth that feeds me (us) the fresh air to breathe in the corruption of destruction that has been our government. Spike Lee's movie drives home all that is said here as has the simple statement of Kanye West--it needed so much to be said that he just does not care for blacks. For sure. And he does not care for anyone who is not in his wealthy, country club set who rule alone at the top. Thank you Pajiba and thank you New Millenium Nigga.

Posted by: d henry at September 6, 2006 9:21 PM

this is actually an incredible piece. as the photo - not to mention jen's comments - demonstrates, we haven't even begun to deal with the implications of our history or the racism that continues to pervade our society. it is not about guilt, and its not about blame - it is about taking responsibility for *really seeing* what is going on around us. its totally fucked up, and its time we all started talking about it wherever and whenever we have an opportunity.

Posted by: po at September 6, 2006 9:26 PM

The irony of this entire article is that, as I read it now, there is a Google ad for Worldvision imploring me with gut-wrenching images of starving African babies to donate to their cause and "Help feed hungry children in Africa."

I saw no such images of African-AMERICAN babies starving in the streets of New Orleans a year ago. And African-AMERICAN babies starving in the streets RIGHT NOW.

Bush doesn't want to call attention to the situation now, he just wants to pal around like the frat boy he is and make people think he's jus' folks.

Kanye West was right. Bush doesn't give a shit about black people. Surrounding himself with black people only makes that all the more apparent.

Posted by: Big Daddy at September 6, 2006 9:33 PM

jen, honey, there's a fellow named Matt raising hell over in the 'Wicker Man' comments. He'll make you feel all better about your poor, sad, unfair life. You and he should get along like a house on fire.

Posted by: jerce at September 6, 2006 9:36 PM

First off, please don't forget that the city built a Mardi Gras Museum instead of fortifying the levees. The extreme hurricane of Katrina force did happen before in 1965, they live in a bowl for the love of God, they knew it was possible and nothing was done. Fifteen years of Democratic presidents did nothing for them so their hands are on this too. Maybe instead of having Mardi Gras and Superbowls, the city should have put that forty years worth of funding into its levee system.

Oh and as far as Reggie Bush being made fun of, what was his signing bonus??? 30 mill oh and who is that I see on EA college football for video games, Reggie Bush...so boo hoo for the photo op, sometimes it really is all that it is.

Posted by: rich at September 6, 2006 10:06 PM

Oh, jerce, that's so sweet. But if I had followed up on my urge to persue a letter in women's studies along with my major in architecture and my minor in physics I might have taken offense to being called "honey". Or if I had followed up on my urge to persue a letter in women's studies along with blah, blah, blah, self-pedestalling I might use the word "honey" spelled slighty different in order to give it cultural flair in a handel (like "Same shit, different day Hunnay"... catchy?) to post blogs on an enabling socialistic agenda-hiding website because my own website wasn't getting any hits. But instead I chose to raise 2 kids on my own in an apartment building busting at the seams with starving African-AMERICAN babies while I was isolated by their well fed mothers for being the uppity white girl persuing an education. You know "Uppity White Girl" sounds good, too.
MY POINT, which seemed lost on the brothas, is stick with movie reviews if you're going to be a movie review website for bitchy people. There aren't a lot of sites out there for us! And I don't want to have to cancel my T-shirt order. But I will if I have to!

Posted by: jen at September 6, 2006 10:19 PM

Okay, this is coming from a bona fide left-winger:

For Christ's sake, it was just a cheesy photo-op. This guy offered ZERO in the originality department, basically regurgitating the black-militant line. ("Oooh, calling a disagreeable black man a house-slave! How original! No really, I've never heard that before.") His schtick got old sometime round 1969. I'm almost sorry to say it, but I agree with Jen. Stick to what you do best, that being movie/TV reviews. Or at least get a better politcal blogger.

Posted by: Matt (not wicker man Matt, mind you) at September 6, 2006 10:42 PM

Thank God for you, jen. I wonder if NMN thinks that all white people are liberally sprinkled with affluence dust as they lay in their diamond-studded basinettes. Not all blacks are disenfranchized and poverty-stricken, and not all whites are unholy moneygrubbing fiends. I come to this site for its fantastic movie reviews, not for a thinly-veiled study in racism. Please, Pajiba, get back to doing what you do best, and leave the ranting to the political blogs

Posted by: jrae at September 6, 2006 10:43 PM

And yes I spelled "pursuing" wrong. My entire argument is now a farce. I will now crawl back into the block of ice from which I was unfrozen.

Posted by: jen at September 6, 2006 10:43 PM

You owned up to persue but not to handel...?

Have you asked Matt for his phone number yet?

Posted by: jerce at September 6, 2006 10:54 PM

You know, like "George".

Why, oh, why doesn't spell check work in these box thingies?

Just to be clear, I'm now happily married to an even bigger bigot who could tell me what the technical term for "box thingies" is.
Thank you, jerce.

Posted by: jen at September 6, 2006 11:00 PM

Before reading this article the ideas expressed in it never would have occurred to me while looking at that picture--now they always will.

Posted by: ecp at September 6, 2006 11:21 PM

1. I agree with and really enjoyed reading most of NMN's stuff that I saw on here and on his blog

2. I agree with him that too many people are in denial of the fact that in America, African-Americans ARE at a disadvantage from the start because of their race.

3. I think he might be reading a bit much into this picture...idk

Posted by: joe at September 6, 2006 11:28 PM

Eh, I'm thinking that the NMN (I love the addition, btw) is speaking on race relations in general here, but more specifically, this picture in relation to Katrina. No matter what your political beliefs or (or, hey, even your predilictions toward or against racism against minorities), you gotta admit that somewhere, somehow, you knew that something was terribly fucking wrong with what happened down there, and for Bush to take this photo op was just, eh, in my opinion, a little stupid and insensitive. It's just so fucking "good ol' boy" and it makes me sick. "Look! I likes black people! I even gots some named after me! Fuck you Kenya West, I DO care about black people!"

Also, yes, sometimes a cigar is just a cigar, but sometimes--and more often than not--there's something lurking underneath it that sometimes just can't be seen. Wasn't it enough for people to see this with those stupid fucking captions regarding "looting" and "finding"? If that's not as plain as day, I don't know what is.

Posted by: em at September 6, 2006 11:55 PM

And then ask yourself if A New Millennium Nigga saying ?nigga? is really the problem facing niggas today.

It may not be the only problem, but that doesn't mean it's not one of them. Why is having a discussion about that mutually exclusive from the socio-economical ramifications of the Katrina fallout? I understand your point, NMN, but passive-aggressively dissing those who challenged your POV on the use of nigga in the same article really just turned me off. So someone being pissed at you for using nigga equates them to ignoring the travesty of how the federal, state, and local government failed during Katrina? Excuse my French, but that's bullshit. Perhaps you've done so on your blog, but it sure would be nice for someone to call out Mayor Nagin, the black mayor who knew about the conditions of the levees, and didn't have a damn plan in place to evacuate his own people, being that, in the same Spike Lee documentary, it was revealed that he knew well in advance just like the governor. If you're gonna tell like it is, tell ALL of it.

Posted by: Daphne at September 7, 2006 1:23 AM

I wonder what the NMN opinions are of his fellow "brother" Ray Nagin, or the corrupt democratic LA congressmen who funneled money from levees into casinos for the last 20 years, or the popular media who decided to pull stories out of the thin air about all the bad things that were, or in reality, werent, happening in NO after Kat. Here's a deal for you NMN, I'll come to terms and admit the problems that slavery has in todays society, when you grow a pair and stop relying on "the man" to bail you out whenever the going gets tough, then blaming him for not doing enough. Oh, and Kanye west doesnt care about black people either, he just cares about selling records.

Posted by: Fozzy da bear at September 7, 2006 1:51 AM

and if I wanted a political debate, I would have gone to the IMDB. Come on Pajiba, entertain me. Quit trying to make me see the light through BS rants of someone who doesnt have the balls to blame someone whose skin isn't white for Katrina.

Posted by: fozzy at September 7, 2006 1:55 AM

Am I the only one who finds this article slanderous and offensive? The average African subsists on $0.80 or less a day while African-Americans can afford Bentlys and achieve PhDs. My point, this article makes it seem like blacks are shrivelling corpses dying in the streets which is far from the truth. The poorest black in America is still well off than an orphan in Kenya who lost her parents to AIDS.

If people like NMN want to waste their time and our's (I'm here for movie reviews)writing profanity-riddled trash like this ignorant to the fact that in spite of their ancestors hardships they have an oppurtunity now to raise their worth in society not by bitching on a movie blog but by volunteering to rebuild homes in New Orleans, fundraise, stay in school to change the face of America's workforce etc. go right ahead but realize your belligerent anti-white attitude reflects poorly on your race.

Oh and I like the fact you take offense to Bush acknowledging Reggie Bush's slave name when you so freely parade the n-word, the most derrogatory slave terminology known to man.LMFAO!

Posted by: disgusted by hate rhetoric at September 7, 2006 3:17 AM

Here's a thought - why don't the commenters who dislike an already clearly politicized film review site making an explicit attempt to engage with political issues, just not read these bits, instead of filling up the comments section with their idiotic assertions that society loves and welcomes African-Americans unconditionally, that oppression is a thing of the past, and that real, honest reparation has been made? Or that (according to 'disgusted') lazy black people just need to work harder to become like privileged right-wing white people, living out the (violent, exclusive) American dream in order to make things right. I'm a middle-class white woman, and I'm very glad there's someone out there encouraging me to think about the easy assumptions I sometimes make in glancing briefly at images like this. Not so much feeling the hate.

Posted by: Smith at September 7, 2006 4:55 AM

"Disgusted", the landscape of "Black America" is extremely diverse, from those who can afford Bentley's to those (far too many) who are orphaned by AIDS just like those from our ancestral homelands. But I'm pretty sure we are all more offended than a "coloreds only" water fountain by that "reflects poorly on your race" garbage, warning that we should temper our opinions lest they sully the image of millions. In your eyes, why aren't we afforded the same individualism?
I only think your comments reflect poorly on you, not Keifer Sutherland.

Posted by: Real and Original Ray's at September 7, 2006 8:40 AM

NMN - Was that a reference to Tribe Called Quest in there?

"What's the reason for the laughter?"
"I guess I laugh to keep from crying/
so many people killing/
so many people dying"

Just a question.

Also - if "some people" feel guilty about being white, maybe they should remember that being a "cracker" is much like being a "nigger" - it's a state of mind.

We need to stop reading this sort of thing with our little "there goes another angry black man trying to make me feel guilty for having a job" goggles. Maybe the point is more that there IS a culture of racism in this country and that sometimes photo-ops, natural disasters, and wars all collide to form a very sad and very upsetting picture.

Are there poor white people? Are there rich black people? Of course! That's not the effing point! Don't "you people" realise that if ONE person suffers, we ALL suffer? Don't "you people" realise that there is not an actual line that divides us? It's cheesy, but we ARE all connected, whether we study biology or women's studies, philosophy or pottery. It doesn't effing matter. Y'all need to calm down and read this article again, 'cause it's well written and some important things to say.

Jeez

Posted by: Estelle at September 7, 2006 8:58 AM

Here's another thought. Smith -- If you want to be allowed to say your point of view why don't you afford other people the same right? When someone brings up a topic about religion or politics, people are bound to have an opinion and want to express it. Everyone has that right ...

Posted by: Maria at September 7, 2006 9:36 AM

I used to post all the time back when there were only seven or eight posts total.

But now I just read and enjoy.

This last piece by the NMN was an unpleasant piece of thought representing the worst possible level of debate and discussion. Not the start of a free and frank exchange of ideas.

I hope that like the book reviews/political commentary/Brandy Barber/Mary Scott O'Conner and others this column soon becomes part of this sites history.

Posted by: Thaf at September 7, 2006 9:49 AM

"Disgusted", if you take a look at NMN's other articles, you'll see why he uses the term "nigga". And if you're only here for movie reviews, which is cool, then, uh, skip over the NMN. It's that easy. Also, don't even try to tell me that only African children lose their parents to AIDS. If you spend any time around certain neighborhoods doing volunteer work, you'd know that American children lose their parents to AIDS as well.

Plus, I'm gonna quote Chris Rock here and say--"Don't let Shaq fool you. We don't all get a cut of that check!"

Posted by: em at September 7, 2006 9:51 AM

Maria -- what I'm saying is that I don't understand why a few people in this comments section are complaining about Pajiba introducing explicitly political commentary and then leaping in with their own (largely right-wing) political views. In my opinion, it's a great chance to think about these issues and take part in discussion, but if people are going to complain about the fact of political blogging on this site, they should stick to the film reviews. I'm not stamping on anybody's right to free speech, just asking people not to bitch about it at the same time as they take part.

Posted by: Smith at September 7, 2006 10:16 AM

Do Mayor Ray Nagin and Governor Blanco hate black people. After all, they were more responsible for the problem - as state and local officials are responsible for prevention (i.e., evacuation, etc.) and first response, NOT the federal government or FEMA. And Blanco and Nagin failed miserably (not to mention the corrupt politicos who for years did nothing to improve the levees - which party controls N.O. and the Levy boards again, oh yeah, the Democrats). The Federal Government and FEMA's responsiblity has always been clean-up and reconstruction after a disaster. Thus, your entire premise is based on not understanding what you are talking about.

thus, if you think Bush is evil and incompetent, you must positivily despise the Louisiana Democratic Party, Nagin and Blanco.

But, of course, rationality is not the claim here.

- GB

Posted by: Great Banana at September 7, 2006 10:56 AM

Oh God! I resisted and resisted, but it's too much and I have to jump in and comment. What's wrong with putting ones views on a page? That's what blogging is for. The Pajiba guys have created a great site. It's entertaining and some times thought-provoking and it gives a forum to those of us who either have no one else to blab to or who have nasty controlling corporate jobs where we dare not speak our minds. And on the Bush/Bush thing, I totally get it and I'm not Black. I cringe at all of the photo-ops: remember his appearance with the rescued miners who probably all voted for him despite the fact that when they start coughing up black tar-like shit from where their lungs used to be, his (and his party's) policies will guarantee that there will be precious little access to treatment. Remember the visit to Wal-Mart with a bunch of less-than-minimum wage workers wearing big buttons that read "Repeal the Estate Tax", because you know without tax reform, the rent on the trailer may not remain in the family for many generations to come. I could go on and on. No-one is saying the Katrina debacle was all Bush's fault, it's just part of a pattern that's glossed over by a complicit media that loves to have a feel-good clip in case any of us actually notice that over 2,600 body bags have been sent back from Iraq to date. We should all be embarrassed.

Posted by: Siobhan at September 7, 2006 12:12 PM

I love Pajiba more with each passing day. Thanks for bringing New Millenium Nigga onto your site, and thank you, NMN, for lending us your eyes. (please note: I intend not a drop of sarcasm in my reply. For once, I am entirely earnest)

Posted by: Bec at September 7, 2006 12:30 PM

Just a couple quick things:


1. It's Pajiba's site and they can include any damn writers they want. I can choose not to read NMN if I want to. Not that I would...


2. We all have opinions, some choose to forcefully share them here. That doesn't make them right. It just makes them mouthy.


3. So what? Not everyone sees the world out of your eyeholes? Big whoop.


4. Bush is a no-talent ass-clown and poor people get screwed over by Washington all the time, especially poor black people. See? that's my opinion- shared and done.


5. Thanks Pajiba!

Posted by: Go Big Red at September 7, 2006 1:27 PM

I might not see it that way if ? as Kanye also pointed out, as Mike Myers and America looked on dumbfounded ? black people weren?t described as looting food while whites were described as finding food to survive.

There's actually a somewhat reasonable explanation for that:

http://www.snopes.com/katrina/photos/looters.asp

Posted by: Ajax19 at September 7, 2006 2:37 PM

"Bush is a no-talent ass clown".

Hey, the president shares a lot with Paris Hilton!

Posted by: Siobhan at September 7, 2006 2:45 PM

well, as a middle class white woman who has never seen "When the Levees Broke", who tries not to think of Bush (the president) in any way, shape, or form in my daily life, I saw the photo, read the title and immediately thought "Bush (the president), you moron, where do you think he GOT the name?!?!"

Maybe it's because I grew up in a very diverse (now mostly Black) community, or maybe it's because my family is from New England and taught me that people are people no matter what, but I also can't see what others see.

Like Jen, I also have been party to reverse racism (understandable when you are one of the rare white faces in a sea of dark ones), but turning it back around yet again doesn't solve it. I am disgusted by the parts of my family who owned slaves, but I am not guilty for it, because I know better, and I will make damn sure that every generation of my people know better from here on out.

It isn't about blaming the president for all the ills of African Americans in this country, but it is about blaming him for being a stupid, arrogant ass about it.

Posted by: Robin~ at September 7, 2006 2:50 PM

God (may she rest in peace) forbid that a site dedicated to critiquing popular culture should actually let the real world intrude on our snarky, cloistered, couch potato weltanschauung. A blog is like a box of chocolates - you can consume the ones you like and spit out the rest.

Why is it socially acceptable in this little community to debate the relative merits of Will Ferrell vs. Adam Sandler or to track Jim Carrey's Caruso-like career choices but it's not acceptable to toss in some political commentary?

"You people" who advocate evicting NMN for expressing his own opinions are more than welcome to express your own as, indeed, some others have done with varying degrees of lucidity. Why not use this forum to try to stimulate a dialog among folks with some common interests? Those of you who want to cancel your subscriptions to Pajiba for printing something you didn't want to read in the first place, but spent half an hour commenting on, apparently think STFU qualifies as "debate" (see "box of chocolates" reference above). There's no need to get personal here, folks. We all have our own opinions. I suspect the editorial decision to include NMN's commentary was an anguished one, but, hey, it's their blog and if they want to throw in a "While I have your attention, . . . " curveball, it can't hurt us all to think once in a while.

Personally, I think NMN is absolutely on point here and that the vast majority of white folk in this fair country of ours are painfully unaware of the plight of blacks. Of course, there's plenty of blame to go around for the post-Katrina mess but, although the ultimate structural failure may have been that of the Army Corps of Engineers, who built and mantained the levees, the cultural failure belongs to all of us. The fact that the federal government has still not done a damn thing to rebuild New Orleans after a whole year, however, kind of drives home the point NMN and Kanye tried to make. But of course, Americans ain't racists anymore - just check out all those white suburban homeboys emulating their favorite gangstas and thank everyone from MTV to Walmart for homogenizing America. Have we cured racism for the next generation or is this emblematic of the ludicrous hypocrisy of mainstream (commercial) America's co-opting of hip-hop culture to make a buck? Has rap replaced jazz or soul as the voice of black America (discuss among yourselves)? Is Eminem for real (I'd just as soon no one choose this one to discuss)?

By the way, I thought "When the Levees Broke" was riveting and by no means apologetic for the failures of Mayor Nagin or any other democrats.

Posted by: Sanity Clause at September 7, 2006 3:07 PM

No, no, no, NO opinions other than mine allowed anywhere ever!

Posted by: miss mle at September 7, 2006 3:21 PM

My thinking is so skewed, that I look at the picture and think, "Wow, they're proud that they share the same name as a really good football player!"

I don't mean that glibly, I would seriously never think that they'd rate themselves so highly as to think that he'd be proud to share a name with them.

As for all the other political stuff...I don't think that wanting to blame all the parties involved in the Katrina disaster as being right-wing thinking. The president is basically the CEO of the company. Ten-to-one odds that he knows very little of the inner workings of any city in the nation, that's why there's a governor and a congressperson and a mayor hanging about. That's what they get paid for. I'm not saying that Bush isn't responsible-he is. He's the president, he *should* know if there's a disaster about to happen. But those other people dropped the ball, they're just as culpable, and it's just amazing to me that no inquiries were made into where the money was spent, and that there wasn't a grand "Katrina Gate" investigation going on on my TV every night.

Does Bush care about black people? What about white people? Asian? Hispanic? I think he's like all politicians everywhere-he cares about who he needs to in order to gain what he wants.

Posted by: zambonigirl at September 7, 2006 3:28 PM

There is some erroneous information regarding the levees and who is responsible for their construction and maintainence. A Mardi Gras museum??? Where do you get this information? The levees are a FEDERAL responsibility. They are built and maintained by the Army Corp of Engineers, not the city proper. I am a resident of New Orleans and by no means am I suggesting we are free of corruption or poor management (and we are certainly not the only city in this lot) but do not fool yourself into believing that the city of New Orleans is at fault for the levee failure. City officials have been complaining for years of the vulnerability of our levee system to the federal government and Bush then decides to slash funding for the levee system. No doubt there is local and state responsibility to share in this disaster but the Corp has already alluded that they are partly responsible for the failure but note that with the funding they had the levees could not withstand a storm above a category three (which is another topic althogether). As we have seen there is actual footage of Bush, Chertoff and crew getting word of Katrina and the possible levee faliure BEFORE Katrina hit. And although Bush claims they were not expecting a breach, he is splitting hairs as it was suggested by the Corp that the levees would be topped. I am shocked that we as a nation are not more outraged by this footage. Sorry to divert the topic but I am apalled at the people who state ridiculous misinformation as if the are reporting a genuine news story. New Orleans may be in a geographic bowl but California's biggest cities sit on a huge fault line. I do not hear anyone asking them to be prepared to abandon their city if a catastrophic earthquake occurs. Rich...I am glaring in your direction...and thank you Sanity Clause, for noting the Corp's responsibility.

Posted by: Nola at September 7, 2006 4:08 PM

This is my first time posting, so I apologize for the doubel post! And sorry if I seemed a little on edge, but when living in New Orleans you become very sensitive to the subject. I'm certainly aware we all have varying opinions on the matter.

Posted by: Nola at September 7, 2006 4:11 PM

"Does Bush care about black people? What about white people? Asian? Hispanic? I think he's like all politicians everywhere-he cares about who he needs to in order to gain what he wants."

SO well put, zambonigirl!

Anyway, I'm not necessarily opposed to adding a politcal component to this blog (although I still think Pajiba should stick to their bread and butter), I just thought this was a hack article which brought nothing new or interesting to the table. While there may be some truth to what NMN says, I felt this article was a regurgitation of the same arguments I''ve heard over and over again. I mean, I'll eat up anything Pajiba puts up, politcal or otherwise, but I don't see the point in adding what looks like nothing more than a once-a-week dose of glorified race-baiting.

Posted by: Matt at September 7, 2006 4:17 PM

"I am shocked that we as a nation are not more outraged by this footage. "

Count me in on that one!

My biggest pet peeve during the disaster was all of the finger pointing. No one would take responsibility! And they're still not. It should have been far more public (like, on every youtube broadcast and blog available, not to mention CNN and the news stations), and far more devastating to those involved. Instead, the ones devastated were the ones too poor to do anything except be a victim.

Matt-I don't know if I really consider this to be race-baiting, but I do consider it to be somewhat counter-productive. I don't think that there's anyone on this site saying, "I hate X people!", therefore, jawing on about these situations is not condusive to change. I would much prefer someone posting a political opinion followed by an actual suggestion of something that each and every one of us can do in our daily lives to prove that we are against racism in all forms.

I mean, I doubt that there's a white person alive who hasn't experienced reverse racism, and thought to themselves, "Oh, that must be what it feels like to be black" or whatever group was giving them dirty looks (in my case, at the Carniceria down the street while buying yummy homemade tortillas that are SO TOTALLY worth the dirty looks, catcalls, and comments from folks who don't understand how easy it is to learn Spanish), but at the end of the day, there is no way to understand constant bludgering from all sides that a person who is a minority feels pretty much every minute of their life. It would be just as impossible for a man to understand what it's like to be a woman. Yes, there are the jokes that are sent out on the internet, and the reminder that if a woman was paid for all her housework, she'd be pulling in a six-figure salary easily, but at the end of the day, a man is a man, and he can forget the reminder. Just like I am a white woman, and I can go home at the end of the day and pretend like racism doesn't affect me, because I treat everyone the same no matter what.

Posted by: zambonigirl at September 7, 2006 5:17 PM

In line with an earlier comment:

Racism ends when a person does not have to be held up as a credit to his race, and is not considered to be responsible for being a discredit to his race.

Whatever your opinions, please try not to refer to us as an undifferentiated, monolithic and completely uniform mass. Even if it's not what's meant, it's still what is said, and even that can speak volumes. In turn, I'll continue to try not to make reference to 'the white community'.

Posted by: M at September 7, 2006 5:39 PM

"Matt-I don't know if I really consider this to be race-baiting, but I do consider it to be somewhat counter-productive. I don't think that there's anyone on this site saying, "I hate X people!", therefore, jawing on about these situations is not condusive to change. I would much prefer someone posting a political opinion followed by an actual suggestion of something that each and every one of us can do in our daily lives to prove that we are against racism in all forms."

again, well said. most of us 'enlightened' white folks (who make up the vast majority of this blog's readership) acknowledge that racism exists and is a blight on society, so what's the point in writing an article that does nothing more than complain that racism exists and is a blight on society? Preaching to the choir, pal. At least give us something new and original. But anyways, I've enjoyed everything Pajiba has done thus far, so I guess I'm willing to give this guy a chance. I just don't want to be berated for being white every week.

Posted by: matt at September 7, 2006 6:32 PM

I am gratified by so many progressive voices in this comments section, especially the ones refuting some of the angry, knee-jerk reactions to NMN's confrontational brilliance.

I have little to add to what's already been said, except for the use of the word "racist" or "reverse racist" regarding a monority. A minority can be bigoted, certainly, but never racist. Being racist requires the societal power to enforce that bigotry on a grand scale, and make you more than just a little emotionally uncomfortable due to some dirty looks. I'm not saying that minorities can't discriminate on a small scale, as in making you feel unwelcome at a party (such as in Something New, when the white boyfriend is told that he's "lucky to be invited to this Negro spiritual), catcalling, or even being violent. Minorities do not have the kind of historical power needed to be able to ignore one's privilege, as several people in this comments section clearly can. I am reminded of my ethnicity every day, many times, and I am a college educated professional making a good salary. Especially when I'm followed around a store, tailed by a cop, can't get a cab, have to work twice as hard to prove my worth, or am a victim of any number of casually racist practices that are very much with us, and are very much a function of America's racist history. The power to block employment, deny housing, portray an ethnicity negatively in the media, and the like remains firmly in the hands of the majority. And that, my friends, is racism.

Excellent article, NMN. Thank you for your perspective.

Posted by: MaiGirl at September 7, 2006 8:43 PM

First of all, let's lay to rest this idea that Bush cares about anyone beyond himself and maybe a very tiny circle of family and friends. Maybe not even that. It could quite possibly end with himself--I've seen such strong streaks of narcissism in him throughout the years that it wouldn't surprise me one bit.

Secondly, whether or not you agree with NMN, I'm damn glad he said it. I'm white, and I saw that picture earlier today and thought the same damn thing. And I'll bet you five hundred bucks it would never ever occur to anyone in Bush's circle that that particular photo op was....well, tacky. I guaran-damn-tee you it would never cross their minds.

Because they/he don't think deeply on much of anything, much less social/historical issues.

When I was an undergraduate, I became friends with a classmate and we got to talking about last names. His last name was the same as mine. He pointed out that his ancestors most likely did not have that surname, but were given it by their owners. I was struck. I had honestly never thought of it before, but it made complete sense. I later found historical support for this in some texts I was reading at the time.

I saw what NMN saw in this picture. We can't be the only ones. I've come to expect no better, and much worse, from Bush. I'll never forget, for the rest of my days, the pics of him having birthday cake with John McCain on the tarmac of an airport in California and strumming a guitar at the same party, while Americans in New Orleans died, many of them slow deaths, waiting for help that didn't come.

What should matter is that they were Americans. It shouldn't matter where they lived or how much money they had, and certainly not the color of their skin. We're supposed to be more humane than that. To watch them die and then say "well, you shouldn't have been too poor to get out." We're supposed to be better than that.

But in Bush's America, we're not, apparently. I was horrified by the whole thing, and I realized I would never see this country the same way again.

You pay taxes like a Third World country, you get to live in one.

NMN, thanks for saying what you did.

jen, you sound very bitter. I hope you can find your way to getting past that.

Posted by: Kathy at September 7, 2006 10:19 PM

MaiGirl-- Thanks for that. It's astonishing that people can really use 'reverse racism' as a serious term, and ignore all the issues of power, privilege, and economic clout that lie beneath the oppression of a minority group on the basis of their ethnicity.

Posted by: Smith at September 8, 2006 4:02 AM

Bitch.Bitch.Bitch.Bitch.Bitch. What if you just got on with your fucking life and took responsibility for yourself. The "cold boot of the man on my neck" argument is a nice cozy blanket...but it makes you a bitch.

Posted by: jeff at September 8, 2006 9:17 AM

"The Federal Government and FEMA's responsiblity has always been clean-up and reconstruction after a disaster. Thus, your entire premise is based on not understanding what you are talking about."


Uhhh, maybe you should look up the facts before you tell OTHER people they don't know what they are talking about. Recent legislation allows FEMA, in fact, TASKS FEMA, with much more than "clean-up". They are tasked with assisting in emergency relief efforts, in some cases whether or not the states explicitly ask for such help.

In this case, it became clear to those like Nagin that State and Local efforts would never be able to handle the devestation that was about to unfold, and because of this, declared a state of emergency and asked for federal aid. What NO got was barely a response. What they got was a coast guard ship literally miles away with hundreds of beds, and helicopters ready to go to pick up the stranded, yet did nothing. What they got was a FEMA coordinator who needed more time to get to lunch instead of dealing with the Superdome. What they got was a president who denied (or just didn't care) any problems, insisting his incompetent people (who had previous disaster experience... uh.. raising horses?) were doing a heckuva job! What they got was a president so eager to save face, as opposed to actually do anything worthwhile in his office, that he redirected search-and-rescue copters for his little photo-op in NO, when they should have been out rescuing the people who would eventually starve, overheat, or drown due to the complete idiocy and imcompetence from the top down.

There is absolutely no excuse for the federal response to that disaster, and anyone making such excuses, friend, is the one who truly has no idea of what they are talking about.

Posted by: Mangrilla at September 8, 2006 9:38 AM

*sigh*

Oh man, I really didn't want to get involved in this, but I just can't help it.

"A minority can be bigoted, certainly, but never racist."

The definition of "racist" according to the dictionary:

1. The belief that race accounts for differences in human character or ability and that a particular race is superior to others.
2. Discrimination or prejudice based on race.

I know what you are trying to say, that white people obviously have experienced about 1/100,000 of the racism minorities have experienced, and I agree with you, but don't say just cause you are a minority you can't be racist.

I remember back in the day of freshman year of high school when one of the girls in my yearbook class turned to her friend and announced loudly that she hated all white people.

Please don't misunderstand me, I think saying "oh we've suffered reverse racism, boo hoo" is a load of bullshit because while white people might have to deal with it from time to time, minorites have to deal with it EVERY DAY.

Also, obviously Bush is an idiot. I think almost everyone agrees on that. Obviously he doesn't get it. He probably doesn't even get why Kanye West said he hated black people. He's been a rich white guy his whole life.

On New Orleans: I really don't even want to go there, but I have to tell you in Florida, in 2004 when all those hurricanes hit us, you saw NOTHING like the kind of devastation that Katrina brought on N.O. And we were hit FOUR TIMES. If you're going to say, "well, Katrina was below sea level and was a strong hurricane" I'll respond by telling you I was hit dead on by Jeanne, which was the same category hurricane Katrina was, AND I lived near the coast, so I was on sea level, and still all the damage happened to property, mainly.
As much as I hate to give Jeb Bush any credit for anything (I can't stand the fucker, and I'm thrilled he can't rerun for Governor) in Florida we have our shit together for when a Hurricane hits.

Am I absolving "W" of all blame? Fuck no. I'm just saying it wasn't all his fault, either.

I would also like to say that I came to this site this morning to read entertaining reviews of movies, and instead found this article, while though thought provoking, has nothing to do with "scathing reviews for bitchy people." Unless the scathing review's now include Bush. Now I'm all irritated and disgusted all over again at the NO tragedy, and I was just looking for some mindless distraction from the suckitude of daily life.

So Pajiba? I don't mind that you add this kind of thing to your website, but could you please stop advertising your site as a quirky movie-review site if you're going to add political commentary? Thanks.

Sincerely,
A big fan of your website, who also happens to agree with a lot of what this guy has to say, if not all of it.

Posted by: JellyBellys at September 8, 2006 9:58 AM

about FEMA someone writes: "They are tasked with assisting in emergency relief efforts, in some cases whether or not the states explicitly ask for such help."

look up the word "relief". FEMA comes in after the emergancy to help with relief.

As to whether or not the Corps has a role in the Levees, it is true they do, but the N.O. Levy boards had more control over maintenance and upgrades and money - to dispute this is to lie. It was democrat corruption that led to the current state of the Levys.

Moreover, the levy's had been what they were for 50 years. Blaming Bush for the state of the Levys is irrational.

To claim that Nagin and Blanco had no responsibility, or not the main respnsibility, is to not understand our Constitution, or system of government. Bush could not federalize the National Guard in LA w/o Blanco's ok, which she held up for days. Bush had no power to evacuate N.O. - it was Nagin who failed to do that. Bush had no power to get the buses (that were left in a parking lot to drown underwater by Nagin) to help evacuate. Bush had no power to set up, in advance, places for people to go - Nagin and Blanco did.

None of this is to say that the Federal gov't made no mistakes - but the disaster itself was created and strengthed by the imcompetence/corruption of the Levy Boards, Nagin, and Blanco.

To claim it was the result of racism is idiotic. But, if it helps you sleep at night, enjoy.

Posted by: Great Banana at September 8, 2006 10:37 AM

"It's astonishing that people can really use 'reverse racism' as a serious term, and ignore all the issues of power, privilege, and economic clout that lie beneath the oppression of a minority group on the basis of their ethnicity."

Because I clearly used it to say "boo hoo, I'm so opressed" instead of what I actually said which was, "everyone's experienced it, but at the end of the day, you're still white, and America still caters to you so shut your pie-hole about it and realize that you have no clue what it's like to actually be a minority." (And as I am the only one who's used the term "reverse racism", yes I'm taking it personally.)

I do disagree about MaiGirl's definition of racism, however. She is speaking more of opression. Racism is the idea that any one race is better than another, period. I agree with what she has said, though. There is an ideal that was brought to America in the beginning that anyone who is not white must serve those who are. These ideals are still very prevalant in today's society. It is not right, and I would love to do something to stop it on a more national scale than just in my own little way, in my own little town.

Posted by: zambonigirl at September 8, 2006 11:38 AM

Having just read all these comments, I'm baffled at the number of people that say this doesn't belong on Pajiba for two reasons:

1.) This site began as a political blog.

2.) This is obviously "a scathing review for bitchy people".

Posted by: stig o'tracy at September 8, 2006 12:07 PM

Apologies Zambonigirl -- I agreed with your comment overall, but still think 'reverse racism' is not a helpful, or a particularly meaningful category. But I appreciated your thoughtful stance (though not your spoiling for a fight afterwards): my problem is with the various commenters who seem to think that their experience of being picked on by a black guy once means they can dismiss out of hand the sobering realities of the continuing institutional and deeply internalised racism (not to mention sexism and homophobia) that continues to structure American society.

Posted by: Smith at September 8, 2006 12:47 PM

Can't we all just get along? No really... what the hell, I mean, I realize that racism is alive and well in this country. I realize that classism is alive and well in the country. And I realize that George W. Bush is a one star short of the Texas state flag. But if everyone who commented here about the best way to not be racist just shut the hell up and practiced what they preached, things might actually start getting better.

I'm the first one to admit I could shout and beat my chest all day long about injustices and political agendas and blah blah blah. Hell, I'll be the first to admit I've DONE it. But I'm sorry, I simply fail to understand what is so difficult about just treating everyone with respect. Just stop quibbling about whether it's right for African-Americans to use the word "nigga" (or permutations thereof) or if Bush is a closet racist (why quibble?) or whether a poor white person has the right to feel as bad about their situation as a poor black person. (Or is that European American and African American? I'm never sure what's PC anymore.) The golden rule really should apply, folks.

And as far as New Orleans, what matters now more than anything is recovering. (Especially since ultimately the people who might be to blame will be gone soon, or as soon as the people wish them...) If a man lies dying from a heart attack, you do not argue over whether it was his love of bacon or his smoking that did it until you've done the CPR and gotten him to the hospital. (Unless you really dislike him.) Assigning blame can be a fascinating political thought-experiment. I've done it myself... But energy spent that way might have better uses for now. I don't care who's fault it is until New Orleans is beautiful and thriving and whole again. Then I'll care.

Posted by: Mel at September 8, 2006 12:58 PM

"It's astonishing that people can really use 'reverse racism' as a serious term, and ignore all the issues of power, privilege, and economic clout that lie beneath the oppression of a minority group on the basis of their ethnicity."

I didn't use the term or suggest in any way that I have experienced what it is like to be a person of color. What I said is that I have been party to it. And, for the record, when you are one of 5 - 10 non-black students in a class of 30, you are the minority, whether or not you are considered so by the rest of the country.

For the first 15 years or so of my life, my world was split about 40% white, 30% black, 20% hispanic and 10% asian (the second 15 yrs changed a bit, mainly depending on what city I lived in). That was my reality and it was quite a shock when I discovered the true racial breakdown of the US, cause I honestly thought the whole country was mized like my world was.

So, no, I don't know what it's like to be a black person and I don't think that I ever insinuated anything like that, but, until you have lived my life, don't presume that you know what my life has been.

Posted by: Robin~ at September 8, 2006 1:18 PM

Smith-I'm honestly not spoiling for a fight (though I do love a good argument now and then), I was just really frustrated that my post was being misconstrued by more than one person at that point.

And was I the only one who watched the Animal Planet rescues where the Katrina pets were being reunited with their former owners and new owners while bawling into tissue? I mean, you know...hypothetically...

Posted by: zambonigirl at September 8, 2006 1:57 PM

NMN is entitled to his own opinion and all, but seriously, can you write anything that doesn't come down to a defense of your own use of the word "Nigga"? You've had two posts here, and it is already getting old. It seems whiny and self serving within the context of what otherwise could be a thought provoking column. Or is that all you do?

Posted by: seriously at September 8, 2006 4:41 PM

Okay, fair enough, most current dictionaries define racism in that way, but that is a modern definition created to be more inclusive (so we can all be in on the prejudiced fun!). Most other definitions include, or at least imply, oppression. My point is that minorities don't have the numbers or economic/political power base to make a white person's life truly miserable, except in very rare cases. For a minority, racism and opression are so closely tied that it is essentially one in the same, which is also my point. No matter what a person of color said or did to a white person, the continued historical power and persecution simply isn't there

And my issue with "reverse racism" is that there is no possible way that a white person could feel the equivalent of the discrimination of any given person of color, for the reason I just mentioned.
As Smith explained, sporadic confrontations do not oppression make.

Posted by: MaiGirl at September 8, 2006 5:15 PM

NMN,you're a highly educated idiot.

Posted by: Candy at September 8, 2006 5:50 PM

People, people. Look no further. It was I that caused Hurricane Katrina. All me. And by God, as soon as my Hurricane Machine is fixed I'm doing it again. I'm thinking Detroit. Or Atlanta. Or maybe even Birmingham. They've had it too good for too long.

If only I can find enough orphan-souls and puppy blood to power the damn thing. Hurricane Machines don't run off nothing, you know.

Posted by: Matt at September 8, 2006 5:57 PM

Damn, if Reggie Bush's parents had had the foresight to name their child Re'jhyee B'ooche, we wouldn't be having this conversation.

Posted by: YesI'mAWhiteDevil at September 8, 2006 6:02 PM

Bloody hell. Yes what happened in New Orleans AND Mississippi (whose residents seem to have been forgotten in all of this) was horrific, and government on all levels failed these people. But they failed themselves too, the ones who could have gotten out and didn't. Yes, I know not everyone could, but not everyone who stayed didn't have a choice.

DOes racism still exist in America? You bet. Is it only directed at blacks? Not by a long shot. I know I wasn't the only white girl heckled as I walked the halls at school by the groups of black kids in the stairwell. One of my closest friends in junior high, who was black, a straight-A student and a cheerleader, had horrible things said about her for "trying to be white". How horrible is that? This girl was trying to BE somebody in life and her so-called "people" couldn't handle that and viewed it as a negative.

To my mind THAT is the biggest issue facing the African-American community today. It is "acting white" to speak correct English, have an education, to not get pregnant at a ridiculously young age, and to have stable relationships. "Gangsta" and "Ghetto" are glamourized, crime and violence are seen as the way to respect. I see so many little kids whose parents are uneducated, not together, jumping from job to job, living in cramped quarters...and because their parents chose to name them "Precious" or "DejaVu" or "Taj'Mahal" and scream at them and call each other nigger and place no value on education, these sweet kids are going to be EXACTLY THE SAME. It is horrible, and preventable. Education is the key to everything. Not the government stepping in and carrying you through your life.

Posted by: Jen (not the previous poster) at September 8, 2006 6:05 PM

JellyBelly and Great Banana - Thank you for bringing another perspective to all of this. Look, I think Bush is a clueless idiot as much as the next person and am ashamed of our federal gov't, but the majority of the backlash primarily going towards Bush and the fed gov't is getting old. I understand the Corp of Engineers are a federal, not state, entity. But there was nothing stopping local and State government, who knew those levees wouldn't hold, from having a plan to evacuate and aid those who couldn't help themselves. To me, it's like getting angry at the Social Security Administration when I'm ready to retire 40 years from now thinking my income will be that monthly check - only to be told that there is no SS for me. I'm not going to debate how true that is, as I've read articles saying it's true and it's crap, but not having a financial retirement plan in place for myself and my family, just in case, isn't the feds fault - it's mine. Me being representative of local and state gov't and my family of the hurricane victims. I know that analogy may be oversimplifying how local and state gov't work, but I hope it makes sense.

Mel, I get your point. However, I don't see anything wrong with discussing accountability of our government. Especially if it teaches them (and us) what to do and NOT do in the future. And that's what I don't see. All I see is the blame game (mostly directed at the federal level), probably because everyone is ashamed, and no one really stepping up and admitting the mistakes and ensuring the appropriate steps are taken to not let it happen again. I find it ironic that America, in general, is such a litigious society, yet no one likes to admit when they've made a mistake.

And why are people expecting an entire city to be restored within a year, when Ground Zero hasn't been rebuilt after 5 years? Rebuilding after that kind of devastation can't be easy or quick.

Posted by: Daphne at September 8, 2006 8:19 PM

"It is "acting white" to speak correct English, have an education, to not get pregnant at a ridiculously young age, and to have stable relationships. "Gangsta" and "Ghetto" are glamourized, crime and violence are seen as the way to respect." This statement was made just a few posts ago.

Sadly, I agree with this statement.

I sorta feel sick typing that, but its true.

I am a white guy who works at a very integrated school (aproximately 40% white, 30% black, 30% hispanic), and I see it frequently. I see black kids made fun of by other black kids because they're in the library studying. They're usually refered to as "Cracka wanna-bes" or "WITs" (meaning "White-in-Training"). I give all the credit in the world to the kids that can ignore that kind of shit and continue to be themselves, despite the kind of grief they are given.

Granted, it certainly isn't all the black kids in the school that are doing that. There is no doubt in my mind that is just an outspoken minority that is doing it. On the same token, it is that outspoken minorty that gives a "bad" name to most groups.

Not all republicans agree with Bush, and are money hungry dicks who don't care about those without money.

Not all white people are racist.

Not all white people from the south love Nascar.

Not all muslims want to blow up America.

Not all christians are judgmental jerks.

Its just that the most vocal of the groups are like that, and it perpetiuates the stereotypes.

Whats my point? My point is that I believe there are a LOT of people like me out there, regardless of race. There are a lot of us that are stuck in the middle, and despite our large numbers, our voices are drowned out by those of the extremes, both left and right, and it almost seems as if it has been going on so long that we're just letting it happen now, and throwing up our arms and saying "what can we do?"

THAT is the biggest problem facing this country, regardless of race, religion, or any other physical difference we've got.

Posted by: Jason at September 9, 2006 2:37 AM

To anyone besides Jason and me who waits until Saturday morning to catch up with the latest Pajiba reviews: I offer no opinion on NMN's article at all. What I realized is that I AM highly prejudiced about one thing, which is the fact that the Pajiba readers and commentators are the most thoughtful, intelligent, literate and entertaining group of any single site I've ever had the pleasure of reading.
I'm a first-time poster, but I've kept up with Pajiba every week for over 8 months now, and while I absolutely love the reviews, which were what initially kept me returning, I've found an equally gratifying part is hearing from the other people who post regularly in the 'comments' section.
This particular subject sparked a helluva lot of responses, but I highly enjoyed reading each and every one - this turned into an open forum about issues that revealed just how eloquent the commentators can be even when they're not giving an opinion of a movie or its review. Anyone else who would accidentally come across NMN's article would be just as impressed by such a lively, thought-provoking, sometimes hilarious, sometimes numbingly sad debate amongst a large group of commentators that never once had less than a purely professional and non-embarrassing tone (my own one-time commentary perhaps being an exception).
I just know that I read such a fully-rounded discussion that the cumulation of ideas alone satisfied any desire I might have had upon initially reading NMN's article to even feel the need to give my own response - you have all done it for me, and I say that without a trace of sarcasm.
I look forwarding to many more Saturdays of reading. Thanks, Pajiba people.
So I guess I AM prejudiced when I pat myself on the back for discovering, and sticking with, a site that stands out as much for the people who frequently post as it does for the excellent film reviews themselves.

Posted by: Tony at September 9, 2006 11:58 AM

Awww. I'm super fond of your insight too, Tony!

Posted by: Matt at September 10, 2006 2:05 PM

I've read enough comments to guess that most of what I would say has been said already. By now, most of us have chosen to believe what they will about New Orleans and other things. To the NMN, all I have to say is that I'm disappointed. You're standing on the shoulders of giants and squawking a bastardized, hateful version of their vision at people who apparently largely don't know any better than to blindly agree so as not to feel bad about themselves. King railed against a system that was unjust because he wanted to be free. "I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners will be able to sit down together at the table of brotherhood." That's what King said, not "I have a dream that one day on the white pages of Pajiba [kind of surprised you didn't mention those as well], the sons of former slaves will snipe and exhaustively examine pictures for subtext that isn't there and sons of former slave owners and other white people to whom it hasn't even occured that their ancestors arrived after slavery will cower before you and tear their hair and nobody will get along or feel equal and it will be marvelous."
I think it's hilarious that you say "Chances are that his last name is Bush because somebody who looked like you kidnapped somebody who looked like him ... or bought their ass!" because the Bush family was largely in New York and other parts of the north and northeast throughout the 19th century, but your prejudices about his accent and appearance led you to believe that he comes from slave-holding southern stock. That's called irony. And for the record, I don't like W either.

As far as the deeper meaning of the picture, maybe it's "man, we've got the same name and look at how much more he's going to make than me for playing a game."

Posted by: Eep at September 13, 2006 10:51 AM

Wow, I've never seen a "review" with this much commentary. I'm not suprised most are polarised with the ideas and opinios this topic has generated.

When I saw the picture the one thought that popped into my mind was: " Here's a President proudly demonstrating, with his smiling and clueless wife, that his a brother to a " brother." Now, that's hilarious. I couldn't stop laughing.

Posted by: carrie at September 15, 2006 5:56 PM

1. I am creeped out by GWBush from the ends of my hair to the tips of my toes, and I'm hard pressed to find an issue I agree with him on.

2. I agree strongly with about 55% of this article, though I do think you're overreacting to the photo.

3. Of course, except for the photo bit there is not a single original thought in the piece. We've all read it a million times before.

4. WHAT IN GOD'S NAME IS THIS DOING ON PAJIBA??? I mean, I mostly agree with the guy, but the freaking theme of your website is "scathing REVIEWS for bitchy people." Expanding to TV made sense. But essays on race relations? I think you guys have lost focus.

This was like watching an episode of Friends and and having Stokely Carmichael give a 5-minute speech in the coffee shop 20 minutes in. You might agree with what Stokely has to say, but you're still going to think that it's in an inappropriate place, and that it's one crappy episode of Friends.

Posted by: Brian24 at September 16, 2006 1:17 AM

You know, it's a shame about this, but I just read a wonderful post from NMN about 9/11. Too bad that one didn't make it on to this site, as it was very insightful without being.....well, what this one was.

Posted by: Daphne at September 16, 2006 10:04 AM

However you feel about what NMN is saying, it is only so valid to criticize Pajiba for including political commentary. If you read the backstory of the site, that was originally part of what they did as well and if I remember correctly getting away from it wasn't their first choice. Perhaps this is the first foray into re-taking that ground. The comments section has been rife with politics most of the time anyway.

Posted by: Eep at September 16, 2006 11:37 AM

I realize this thread is dead now but I just want to add my .02 cents: "reverse racism" is a racist term. Not only white people can be, are, or have ever been, racist. It's like the term "racism goes both ways", as if only white and black people can be racist. Like the Arabs, the Indians, the Chinese, the Africans, never had any racism. Get real. If you look at world history there's probably been more "same-color" racism perpetrated than "race against race" racism ever. I'll just give a few examples, like India vs. Pakistan, Bosnia vs. Serbia, Hutu vs. Tutsi, Sunni vs. Shiite, et al. You want to tell me that's not racism? Those people have been hating each other for centuries. And before anyone says "oh, that's all just religion", check yourself. It ain't all about religion, it's mostly about land. Oh, and hate. Which is just a pre-cursor to racism.

Posted by: floogl at September 22, 2006 8:11 PM

Oh, and did anyone ask Reggie Bush what he thought?

Posted by: floogl at September 22, 2006 8:12 PM

and could i interject "afro bush" and "good job, brownie" for no good reason?

and could the graphic artiste-in-residence please photoshop in a skull and bone through bush's nose?

Posted by: pa jive-ass at September 28, 2006 1:36 PM

It's not about race anymore (although racism is Not gone) but about CLASS.
Classism is killing out society.

I'm sure 'black' Bush is feeling he's risen above by making all that dough.
And 'white' Bush can't see black but green in his eyes.

To quote a friend,
"They don't care what color her skin is. Oprah's rich. That's it."

Posted by: Joanna at October 4, 2006 1:39 PM


















Viral Hits

>> Pajiba Movie Posters

>> Pop Culture's 20 Greatest Dancing GIFs

>> Mindhole Blowers

>> The 100 Greatest Insults of All Time

>> The "Other" 100 Greatest Movie Quotes

>> The 100 Greatest Movie Threats of All Time

>> The Sean Bean Death Reel

>> Chicks Dig Beards: It's Science

>> The Coolest TV Show Title Sequences

>> The Most Rewatchable Movies

>> The Most Expensive Movies of All Time