web
counter
 

Let These 7 Men Show You How To Win Valentine's Day

By Joanna Robinson and The Ladies of Pajiba | Posted Under Miscellaneous | Comments (67)



love-actually-to-me-you-are-perfect.jpeg

(Bleeding Heart Liberal Disclaimer: This piece is about to get real gender stereotyped and real heteronormative real fast, so I want to acknowledge, right off the bat, that sometimes dudes woo dudes, ladies woo ladies, and ladies woo dudes. And that, sometimes, lady wooers are the best of all possible wooers.)

Oi, dudes, come here, sit down, we wanna help you out. We ladies know that sometimes you gents get a little apprehensive when it comes to Valentine’s Day. There’s so much pressure to prove, on this one day, by hook or by Whitman’s Sampler, that your aim is true. I was thinking that, by rounding up a list of romantic gents from film, you might, by studying them over the weekend, get some good ideas about how to properly execute The Romantic Gesture. So I asked for help from the smartest, coolest, most film savvy women I knew…The Lady Pajibans. The resulting list, however, helped me realize something. Sure, we adore the Romantic Gesture (George Bailey lassos the moon! It’s a Wonderful Thing!), but it’s meaningless without the daily affirmations of love. That’s what the Lady Pajibans seem to respond to, a guy who treats his lady like she’s his Valentine every day. It’s not too late, boys.

“But who’s on this list?” you ask. “Is it just populated by those d-bags who make me look bad? I hate those guys.” Whoa, “d-bag” is a little harsh, but I catch your meaning. You’re thinking about that time when you were watching The Princess Bride with your ladyfriend and just after the line “Death cannot stop true love. All it can do is delay it for a while,” you heard her let out a faint little sigh. And then, then you mentally hollered, “Westley, you insufferable d-bag, stop making me look bad.” It’s okay, it was the heat of the moment, we know you didn’t mean to call Westley that. The “Mr. Darcy is a Sh*thead” shirt was going a bit far, though, don’t you think?

Yes there are some of those guys on this list but, listen, it’s ladies’ choice and the ladies of Pajiba, are a mötley crew. They like soft-hearted gallants who will attend to a woman’s every need (Moulin Rouge’s bleeding-heart poet, Christian, and that poor sap there with the cue cards, Christmas music and a baffling soft spot for Keira Knightley). But they also groove on bold, brash, men who recognize strength in their female partner and respond well to it (Shakespeare’s Benedick and A Room With A View’s George Emerson). In other words, pick the Pajiban lady your Valentine most resembles (in the headspace, not the rackspace) and you’ll know which dude to study. So, here’s your curriculum, enjoy.

Patrick Verona—“10 Things I Hate About You”
There are a lot of stories out there about odd, lonely girls who break out of their shell, shed their ugly duckling phase and emerge as beautiful swans. And somehow, once they achieve this level of aquatic avian beauty, the world is able to see the inner beauty that was there all along! It’s heart warming. It’s also a crock of shit. Here’s Patrick Verona; the boy who fell in love with Kat Stratford absent any kind of makeover or personality transformation. He’s not scared of the fact that she uses large words or calls herself a feminist, he takes care of her when she’s drunk and injured, and he buys her a guitar instead of flowers to apologize. He’s also not some movie-dwelling dream of a rich jock with all the girls fawning over him who has the heart of a poet/artist/something else “sensitive” here beating inside him that makes him look past the superficial ways of his peers to find the girl who was there all along and figure out that she’d be really hot with some highlights and a miracle bra. The relationship is less a fairytale romance than it is two people who don’t really like other people all that much slowly learning to like each other, flaws and all. Given the choice between Patrick Verona and Jake Ryan, I’d pick Patrick any day.—Intern Rusty

Colonel Brandon —“Sense & Sensibility”
It’s the way he looks at her when he first meets her. How he just stands there, frozen, while she plays the piano, and you can see his heart just melting at the sight of her. It’s how he selflessly steps aside when he realizes she’s in love with someone else. It’s how he almost goes insane when she gets sick, and how much he cares about her, and how he’s the perfect gentleman. It’s the voice. It’s the fact that it’s Alan Rickman. —figgy

Jareth the Goblin King —“Labyrinth”
My freshman year of undergrad my roommate and I had a monthly ritual. We would order a medium pizza with black olives and cheesesticks with ranch sauce and sit down and re-watch Labyrinth. And at the end we would almost always end up yelling at the screen because that idiot Sarah chose her baby half-brother (not even a whole brother!) over David Bowie in tight pants. Really, that’s all I need out of a romantic movie hero: that he be played by David Bowie in tight pants. The magic kingdom and ability to stop time and juggle glass balls (what else can you do with those nimble fingers, Jareth?) are just icing on the cake. He promises to be her slave and give her anything she wants if she just agrees to stay with him and love him. I would totally let Jareth have my little brother for that life (sorry James).—Dr. Pisaster

Mark Darcy—“Bridget Jones’s Diary”
Another modernized literary hero, Mark Darcy will love you, just as you are. He’ll give you that brain melty, crinkly eye, Colin Firth-esque stare. He’ll also help you cook, save your career, wear embarrassing sweaters his mum got him, get in a fistfight for your honor and deliver a snog so thorough it’s sure to knock your genuinely tiny knickers off. What, nice boys don’t kiss like that? Yes they f*cking do.—nominated by Even Stevens and Courtney Enlow

E. Edward Grey—“Secretary”
A man of his word. A man who accepts a girl for who she is. A man of surprises. A man who takes charge in the bedroom. A man who shows remorse and can admit when he does something wrong. A man who likes to play fun games, who is both firm and gentle. A man who takes care of his woman. A man who, when he finds the right girl, settles down but doesn’t play dead. In Secretary, James Spader’s E. Edward Grey is all these things, wears a suit AND he looks like James Spader. What more could a girl want?—Cindy

Peter Warne—“It Happened One Night”
Gruff, sarcastic, unambitious, and an unemployed alcoholic to boot, this guy is the total package. It’s Clark Gable at his not-giving-a-damnedest, playing Peter as the fast talking, smart-aleck reporter indifferent to celebrity status who won’t hesitate to call Ellie out for being a brat, but will also offer to pick hay out of her teeth with his penknife. In the beginning he’s all snappy dialogue and witty insults punctuated by brief glimpses of tenderness (like loaning Ellie his favorite pajamas or hanging a blanket for privacy between their beds each night), but that gives way to earnest affection as the two get closer to know each other. The real draw of the film, however, is Clark Gable’s pecs. This was one of the first movies to feature a man fully undressed from the waist up. No matter that his pants were nearly up to his armpits, you get to feast your eyes on a few square inches of Man Chest.—nosio

Lloyd Dobler—“Say Anything”
And here he is, last but not least, the king of the Romantic Gesture, Lloyd Dobler. This young man is both a romantic fool and well-aware of the strength and power of Ms. Diane Court. In fact, I was going to call this whole notion of an idealized cinematic lead “The Lloyd Dobler Effect,” but some bastards already named their band that. Bastards. In all honesty, for me, it’s not about Peter Gabriel on the boombox or the post-coital shakes. It’s saying things like this: “What I really want to do with my life - what I want to do for a living - is I want to be with your daughter. I’m good at it.” So, come on, fellas, dare to be great. Dare to be Lloyd Dobler. —Joanna

In summation, bros, if you’re brown-nosing overachievers, you should spend the weekend baring your chest, doning your tightest pants, hoisting a boombox, learning to ride horseback, hiring a marching band, renting a saddle (unrelated to that horseback thing), and loving your f*cking lady friend…just as she is.

Joanna Robinson thanks all the Pajiban chicks who sent her nominations. She regrets she has but one column to give. If your nom didn’t make the cut, you can holler out his name in the comments section, or just mutter mutinously at your monitor. To the gents who don’t have a Valentine this year, you can always call me, but you best bring your Dobler game. My number is 555-867-5309.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



All I Can Think About Is Captain Mustache Plowing My Wife | The Best Lines from NBC's Thursday Night Comedy Block | Let Michael Murray Write Your Online Dating Profile!









Comments

man Heath Ledger in 10 things-- that was the moment i fell in love and realized i could watch coming of age movies without gagging...

Posted by: she at February 11, 2011 11:28 AM

I'll stick to my usual trick: live music. If it's good enough for Ryan Gosling in Blue Valentine when he's playing a totally creepy unstable acoholic stalker dude, it's good enough for me.

Posted by: Robert at February 11, 2011 11:30 AM

I tried the number, but it said it was out of service. Must be a typo.

I can already sing Can't Take My Eyes off of You, I guess it's time to start working on my physique and devil my care attitude. Screw it. I'll just be Cameron. (Happily) We're screwed!

Posted by: L4NkYb at February 11, 2011 11:35 AM

Other than Lloyd Dobler, a directionless sappy loser (I could handle the directionless part if it weren't for the SAP part), this is a pretty awesome list. It's also good for playing marry, fuck, kill.

Kill Lloyd, marry Colonel Brandon, Fuck Spader for sure.

Posted by: Cree83 at February 11, 2011 11:38 AM

That moment in Bridget Jones' Diary when he looks at her across the table at her birthday party? I get heart palpitations. Every single time. Ngh.

Posted by: Figgy at February 11, 2011 11:39 AM

Yeah I was always pissed at Sarah too. Forget about the baby!

I would have loved you, Goblin King.

Posted by: Poptart at February 11, 2011 11:39 AM

The quality of the writing in this post is fine indeed, but the message I disapprove of.

I don't understand romance. It seems to be an offshoot of insecurity to me.

Can't two people just be happy together without the need for periodic grand romantic gestures reinforcing this?

Posted by: zeke the pig at February 11, 2011 11:40 AM

Of course, that is excluding Patrick Verona.

...

In fact I'm not sure anymore how much my post is a direct reply to this post.

More of a tangential thing, methinks.

Posted by: zeke the pig at February 11, 2011 11:42 AM

Robert, do you also look like Ryan Gosling while playing live music? Because if so, that would also be good enough for me.

Unstable alcoholic stalkerness optional.

Posted by: Gabs at February 11, 2011 11:44 AM

What Cree83 said. I have nothing to add.

Posted by: Samantha at February 11, 2011 11:45 AM

Oh God. Colonel Brandon. Yes.

Posted by: sarahk at February 11, 2011 11:50 AM

Wait. I do have something to add. The expression on Brandon's face when he realizes that Mariane is safe, and she thanks him for bringing her mother? Rickman deserves all of the awards for that one moment. ALL OF THEM. It's possibly the most miraculous piece of acting I've ever seen.

Posted by: Samantha at February 11, 2011 11:51 AM

Can't two people just be happy together without the need for periodic grand romantic gestures reinforcing this?

You don't understand.

Posted by: Jay at February 11, 2011 11:55 AM

So basically what these comments are telling me is, I need to watch Sense & Sensibility. I actually kind of like that other one so it shouldn't be too bad. Did she ever write a version of it with zombies, like she did for Pride and Prejudice though? It's really hard to imagine it without the zombies...

Posted by: L4NkYb at February 11, 2011 11:56 AM

Alas, LN4NkYb. MOTHERF*CKING, ALAS.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_jZVE5uF24Q

Posted by: Joanna Robinson at February 11, 2011 11:59 AM

"Really, that’s all I need out of a romantic movie hero: that he be played by David Bowie in tight pants."

Don't forget the music!

You remind me of the babe
What babe? The babe with the power
What power? Power of voodoo
Who do? You do
Do what? Remind me of the babe

Posted by: An Atlantan at February 11, 2011 12:02 PM

Allow me to expand upon my pick, as I was not in the proper physical form last night (the microchip had been compromised). Though Joanna said it perfectly.

Mark Darcy did not need grandiose gestures or over the top declarations of love or promises of a new life to win Bridget. He just needed to say the one thing we all want, nay, need to hear: "I like you very much. Just as you are." A million cue cards, boom boxes and renditions of "Can't Tale My Eyes Off Of You" could not so firmly own my heart as that (though those are awesome moments and I'll certainly taken them). We don't need it, boys. Just like us, just as we are.

Also, I cosign figgy's comment. Shudderquiver. Love it.

Posted by: Courtney at February 11, 2011 12:04 PM

I don't like knowing that Lloyd Dobler haters exist.

And mad props for including E. Edward Grey.

Posted by: elizabeth at February 11, 2011 12:04 PM

WAIT, wait, wait.

You mean to tell me that dropping my pants and saying, "you wanna?" is a no go?

Well, this really changes my weekend plans.

That said, I love all of these, except for Say Anything. Not because Lloyd was a sap (he was), but because I was never particularly fond of Diane Court. She was a little too bland, you know? Which is of course frequently the problem in movies. The guys are dashing and funny and courageous and brilliant. And the woman are dull and humorless in many (but of course, not all) cases.

Posted by: Harkonnen at February 11, 2011 12:10 PM

elizabeth,

Don't ever read/listen to Sex, Drugs, and Cocoa Puffs. Chuck Klosterman devotes and entire chapter to how Lloyd Dobler ruined romance. Granted, I believe he says it's because Lloyd set the bar too high.

The Link Wench responds to me AND Mubarak steps down? It's been a good day.

Posted by: L4NkYb at February 11, 2011 12:13 PM

Saronaded a girl once. In front of her sorority house with all her friends watching. My buddy played the guitar and I sang "Being Around" by The Lemonheads. Then we just left. She shouted after us, "Where are you going?" and I just shouted, "Sleep on it!" It was awesome. I'm very proud of that.

Posted by: superasente at February 11, 2011 12:16 PM

I went to bed early and forgot to send you my thoughts, but I totally would have talked about George from A Room With a View, who at least got a mention. Mmm, George. *sigh* http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=POJeGvFeGe0&feature=related

I also like when Mark Darcy says he likes Bridget's "wobbly bits", though I think that might come in the second sort of crappy movie.

Posted by: pickled tink at February 11, 2011 12:17 PM

Nailed it - thank you.

Posted by: jayco at February 11, 2011 12:23 PM

"Four peas...four peas...OHHHH!"

Posted by: Dingles at February 11, 2011 12:26 PM

Oh, Patrick Verona, I love you forever. Please buy me a guitar.

Posted by: (Not so) Blonde Savant at February 11, 2011 12:36 PM

Courtney, that was the exact reason I picked Mark Darcy too. Had I known you might actually put our comments in the article I would have tried a little harder!

And while I love Patrick Verona and agree with everything up there, I still love JGL as Cameron. He set up a very elaborate scheme just to take Bianca to the dance and he learned French for her!

Posted by: Even Stevens at February 11, 2011 12:36 PM

re: disclaimer. We dont ask gay people to apologize for being gay. Dont apologize for being straight.

*ahem*

Patrick Verona always has been and will always remain my go to example of how to woo a lady. Granted, I lack the looks and the charm but I'll rock the fuck out of leather pants and get you some water at a ska concert.

Posted by: Lennon at February 11, 2011 12:55 PM

I love this list. And Mark Darcy. That is all.

Posted by: KP at February 11, 2011 12:58 PM

Lloyd Dobler FTW!!

Also I'd like to add John Keats to this list. May just have to watch Bright Star this weekend...SO dreamy.

Posted by: grace b at February 11, 2011 1:17 PM

grace b, YES! I was recently telling a friend that my ideal man would be a combination of John Keats (as he is portrayed in Bright Star) and Raylan Givens (from Justified). She doesn't think I'll find him, but I'm going to keep a look out.

Posted by: Mel C. at February 11, 2011 1:35 PM

And also, Lloyd Dobler FTW forever and always.

Posted by: Mel C. at February 11, 2011 1:35 PM

Aw, my poor Burt Farlander wasn't included. I LOVE HIM!

Posted by: Pinky McLadybits at February 11, 2011 2:18 PM

Colonel Brandon
Lloyd Dobler
Patrick Verona
Mark Darcy
YES YES YES YES!

Posted by: Chickaboom at February 11, 2011 2:34 PM

Keep the hope alive Mel C. My other dream guy is Gib from The Sure Thing, and I found him, locked that shit up like a bear trap and am marrying him. Some may say that's a low bar, but Lloyd Dobler isn't real. Gib is attainable and, dammit, I attained it.

Posted by: Courtney at February 11, 2011 2:54 PM

I like this list. Although, as much as I love Colonel Brandon, I think for Austenian men, I'd have to go with Mr. Darcy, as cliche as it is. In real life and in fiction, I just can't resist a guy who's a little (or a lot) of an arrogant jerk.

I love that Jareth and Patrick Verona both made it on here. My favorite of this list though HAS to be E. Edward Grey. Watching Secretary as a teenager taught me SO much about myself.

But assuming TV shows are included, nobody is higher in my affections than Spike from Buffy. Arrogant? Check. Funny? Check. Devoted? Check. Willing to challenge/stand up to his strong-willed lady-love when necessary? Check. And is there any romantic gesture EVER that can top risking your life and battling a demon in order to restore your soul for the woman you love? I think not.

Posted by: GwenBear at February 11, 2011 2:55 PM

L4NkYb - Yes, and then watch it again with the commentary on. Emma Thompson and the producer CRY over Colonel Brandon.

Whenever I see the Marianne sick bed scene when she calls him back, a voice in my head says, "Be kind to Captain Butler. He loves you so."

On a sitcom note, HIMYM does romance well. Did anyone see the two minute date? Or last week which was lame right up to the phone calls to Ted and Zoeseph? If I hadn't already had my heart surgically-removed to make way for more chocolate, I would have gone all mushy inside. As it was, my arteries filled my empty chest cavitity with oxygenated blood and there were platelets everywhere.

Posted by: Mrs. Julien at February 11, 2011 3:01 PM

Thank you, pickled tink, George Emerson was totally one of my suggestions, along with Daniel Day Lewis in The Last of the Mohicans. "Stay alive! I will find you!"

Whew. Hot in here.

Posted by: Shonda at February 11, 2011 3:09 PM

Ditto on the Colonol Brandon and the Spike (Buffy) love. Those two, plus Christian from Moulin Rouge, are completely to blame for my fantastically high standards that no man has yet been able to touch.

Posted by: CrystalW187 at February 11, 2011 3:11 PM

Love, love the inclusion of E. Edward Grey (Secretary).

Posted by: Kathryn at February 11, 2011 3:47 PM

For me it is, and always will be Gilbert Blythe.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LsAPx8POuoM
Sorry for the cheesy music

Posted by: Chipwitch at February 11, 2011 4:07 PM

Peter Warne--yes! Ultimate romantic lead in my book. Whip smart and wears a mustache well.

Posted by: kelsy at February 11, 2011 4:24 PM

Peter Warne, ftw. Especially for this exchange with Ellie's father:

Alexander Andrews: Oh, er, do you mind if I ask you a question, frankly? Do you love my daughter?
Peter Warne: Any guy that'd fall in love with your daughter ought to have his head examined.
Alexander Andrews: Now that's an evasion!
Peter Warne: She picked herself a perfect running mate - King Westley - the pill of the century! What she needs is a guy that'd take a sock at her once a day, whether it's coming to her or not. If you had half the brains you're supposed to have, you'd done it yourself, long ago.
Alexander Andrews: Do you love her?
Peter Warne: A normal human being couldn't live under the same roof with her without going nutty! She's my idea of nothing!
Alexander Andrews: I asked you a simple question! Do you love her?
Peter Warne: YES! But don't hold that against me, I'm a little screwy myself!

Posted by: katiemae at February 11, 2011 4:47 PM

Now that I am in a place that allows me to look at YouTube, I can kick myself for forgetting S&S&SM. Not to be confused with S&S&S&M. That, I'm fairly certain, is a completely different kind of parody.

Posted by: L4NkYb at February 11, 2011 4:57 PM

Colin Firth is so proper-sexy. The kind of English gentleman who would light your cigarette for you with an old fashioned lighter and who would know about some ultra classy sex position like buggy-style or London brigdework.

In that clip of Bridget Jones' Diary I was shocked to find that Renee Zellweger is a little bit cute and sexy herself. She looks like the sun-bleached corpse of that girl today.

Posted by: becks at February 11, 2011 5:32 PM

I skipped my senior prom and went with my two best friends to watch 10 Things I Hate About You instead, not because we knew anything about it but because it was the most interesting looking movie playing at the theater that night.

BEST. DECISION. EVER.

And every one of those guys was awesome at wooing--Patrick, Cameron, and Michael. Everything they did showed they knew and loved their women as they were, the whole package, good and bad. Which is, I think, what any girl would want.

I know my husband knows and loves me when I come home and find not flowers, but a bouquet of Sam Adam's Cream Stout in the fridge he got to surprise me with, just because he knows it's my favorite. Lloyd Dobbler who?

And yes, it was a bouquet. He arranged the bottles in a nice bowl. Classy.

Posted by: leuce7 at February 11, 2011 5:39 PM

well this has been a terrifying look into the effortlessly demanding hearts of women. the species would be extinct if men expected the same.

Posted by: idleprimate at February 11, 2011 5:47 PM

Chipwitch, Yes to Gilbert Blythe! Why is my husband not more like him?

Posted by: pickled tink at February 11, 2011 5:50 PM

I agree with every choice on this list, except Lloyd Dobbler. I prefer the Cusack of Grosse Point Blank , thank you very much.

Absolutely agree that I would have sacrificed that baby in a second to stay with David Bowie in tight pants.

Gilbert Blythe is dreamy. Anne Shirley is a very lucky woman.

Posted by: Malin at February 11, 2011 6:13 PM

The first paragraph reminded me of:

Sometimes men love women
Sometimes men love men
Then there are bisexuals
But some just say they're kidding themselves

...and then I just had to start a Phoebe Buffay Singalong Partay. (The neighbors dredd those.) Also, love the list and I like you, girls, as well. Just the way you are. Except you, Courtney. You I love.

Noooooow chicken!!!

Posted by: schmerpes at February 11, 2011 6:48 PM

"the species would be extinct if men expected the same."

idleprimate, men DO expect the same: they expect women to do all the childbirthin'. The species isn't extinct yet, so somebody's coughing up the goods.

Posted by: Gavin at February 11, 2011 7:35 PM

...

...

I don't think men are unable to carry children through force of will alone.

That'd be a good game show though.

Posted by: Ian at February 11, 2011 9:07 PM

Colonel Brandon in the streets, E. Edward Grey in the bed. With a little Jareth thrown in for when company comes over.

Mmmmmmmmmm. Better than ice cream. or bacon. Better than ice cream WITH bacon. Can I have a guy like that for my birthday? It's a little under two months away, surely he can find me by then?

Posted by: Jami at February 12, 2011 12:08 AM

Jami, you hit the nail on the head. Colonel Brandon + E. Edward Grey = Deep fried chocolate covered gold.

I'd also just like to add another endorsement for Spike. Buffy never deserved him.

Posted by: June Velcro at February 12, 2011 6:13 AM

Poor old Lloyd would have a hard time of it today. Holding your tiny MP3 player above your head doesn't seem like such the grand gesture.

And Joanna, I would have called but the 8 hour time difference makes it difficult to pick a time we'd both be wide awake.

Posted by: Simon at February 12, 2011 6:29 AM

I just don't get the Lloyd Dobler love. But the rest of the list was awesome. Love, love, love Colonel Brandon!

Posted by: nikkers at February 12, 2011 7:58 AM

I like the way the Doctor thinks. Every time I watch that movie I shake my fist at Sarah and about, "Idiot! What kind of dumbass turns down the offer not only to have that guy but to be a queen with what is probably the most awesome wardrobe ever?" (Working on the assumption that the queen's wardrobe is as cool as the king's.) Yup, I believe I'd tell him he could have my brother. I mean, shit, her brother would be right there in the Goblin Kingdom with her. It's not like she would never see him again.

Also, nice one for the inclusion of E. Edward Grey.

Posted by: stardust at February 12, 2011 8:26 AM

@Simon, they actually did that mp3 player over the head thing in an episode of Modern Family, except the guy had it plugged into two tiny external speakers, so instead of standing and staring, he was juggling. It was hilarious.

Posted by: Ian at February 12, 2011 8:51 AM

Here's the thing about Lloyd Dobbler. Six months after they jet off to England, Lloyd comes back alone, because Diane's all 'You couldn't find any job? Really?' And he's all "Nothing that wasn't-" And she says "I KNOW, nothing sold, bought or processed! How about something that makes some damn money!' And he says "I love you Diane! We don't need money, we have each other! And kickbocking, sport of the future!" And she says "I need rent money, asshat! And fuck kickboxing, you don't know the damn future, LLOYD." And he says "You know what? Here's a pen. Write me BACK IN AMERICA!" And she says "Don't let the door hit ya!"

I love that movie.

Posted by: Melissa McKimmey at February 12, 2011 12:40 PM

FYI Melissa McKimmey = TWoP Fan. Now you know.

Posted by: TWoP Fan at February 12, 2011 12:41 PM

There is no James Mcavoy love in here. I'm disheartened by the lack of recognition. For instance, dear Pajibans, his portrayal of Robbie Turner in Atonement is a perfect example of raw sexuality and intense love.

Have we forgotten the library scene? If a guy can make me wet as much as he did in that scene, I'm his... for the night at least.

Posted by: tallulahc at February 12, 2011 2:52 PM

Good to know I'm not the only lady who finds Lloyd (and Diane) less than desirable. And E. Edward Grey is a brilliant inclusion.

I would like to nominate Burt Furlander from Away We Go.

Posted by: Ajoy at February 13, 2011 2:10 PM

Edward Scissorhands.

That is all.

Posted by: Amandahugandkiss at February 13, 2011 3:07 PM

so reading this article I finnaly know who Lloyd Dobler is from the final song on Angels by Dan Lesac vs Scroobius Pip, man I didn't even realize they were people I thought it was just a random name. Gunna have to find the rest now.

Posted by: Ben at February 13, 2011 8:25 PM

Paul Newman in The Long Hot Summer

Posted by: kko at February 14, 2011 3:37 AM

L4NkYb - 'Sense and Sensibility and Sea Monsters'.

Posted by: Limey Bastard at February 14, 2011 4:46 AM

I was trying to think of who was missing from this nearly perfect list... tallulahc, you got it. Robbie is perfection. I also adore his Brian in Starter for 10.

Posted by: Mel C. at February 14, 2011 10:30 AM

No thanks on Colonel Brandon. I find his love way too doting and spaniel-like, and I've always been depressed by the Xanaxed, "tamed & humbled" Marianne settling for that futzy old daddy. It was slightly more tolerable in the more recent BBC version, which I prefer to the Ang Lee one in every way except for its Willoughby and lack of Hugh Laurie.

Another vote for Robbie Turner.

Posted by: Kettle at February 14, 2011 3:04 PM