![]()
Honey, I Shrunk the Dumbasses
Meet Dave / Phillip Stephens
I know everyone in Pajiba-land will be shocked, but Meet Dave was something of a conundrum for me to review. On the one hand, I would rather down a frothy mug of cat piss than sit through an Eddie Murphy vehicle (ha fucking ha) these days. On the other hand, the film was co-written by Bill Corbett, the awesome actor-scribe behind Crow T. Robot during the Sci-Fi Channel years of “Mystery Science Theater 3000”. Corbett, who has teamed with fellow misties Mike Nelson and Kevin Murphy on the similarly great Rifftrax/Film Crew projects, sits among the pantheon of my personal comedy gods. I can’t stress how pleased I am that a script of his was picked up, even if it has to be manned by Norbit and mangled by other writers to the point of little actual involvement. So, my biased sensibilities and happiness for Mr. Corbett actually had me yearning not to hate Meet Dave.
And, actually, I didn’t. Was it a great comedy? Certainly not, but neither was it the abomination unto God that was Norbit or Pluto Nash. Meet Dave has enough funny moments to be a pretty innocuous experience, even if most of the film’s goodwill is threadbare by the end of the first half hour. It’s serviceable as a comedy, most of the time, and never grating, even as the action becomes larded with platitudes and sentimentality by the end. It’s the kind of film that kids and geriatrics will chuckle over; everyone else may smirk, but shouldn’t sneer.
The premise is a familiar one: tiny people helm man-like craft, fish-out-of-water laughs ensue; think Innerspace meets “Herman’s Head.” The craft, played by Murphy, is maneuvered by a host of tiny, supposedly emotionless people, led by the Captain (Murphy again). The mini-aliens have come to Earth to find a probe meant to suck up the planet’s water supply for transport to their own homeworld. Predictable slapstick follows with the proxy attempts of the aliens to mime human behavior through a gesticulating man-bot. The story, when buoyed solely by physical comedy, is pretty entertaining. Murphy, as we all know, is fairly adroit at gyrating like an imbecile, but a plot like this only works for so long. To stretch this sitcom yarn into a 90-minute film a lot of useless, predictable mush is thrown into the mix — the Murphy machine finds a quasi love interest (Elizabeth Banks) with a beleaguered child (Austyn Myers) who’s oh-so in need of friendship and inspiration. This mood-swing into sentimentality isn’t always a bad thing (see Galaxy Quest), but Meet Dave isn’t quite up to the task of feel-good emoting. A comparable turn of events which leads to a romantic subplot involving Captain Murphy and a subordinate (Gabrielle Union) is never more than dull, as are most of the moments which stray from pure physical comedy.
Meet Dave bumbles along surprisingly well for most of the first half, relying on Murphy’s penchant for unselfconscious lunacy until the plot finally unfurls into mawkishness. Those expecting nothing should be amused; those who expect anything probably won’t be sitting through an Eddie Murphy film. Surely most of us belong to the former. Bill, buddy — you deserve better, but a gig’s a gig. For once, I hope a disposable little comedy makes a pile of money.
Phillip Stephens is the lead critic and book editor for Pajiba. He lives on the Satellite of Love.
Pajiba Love 07/11/08 | | Journey To The Center Of The Earth
Comments
mmmm...Nope. Not even a chance that I will sit through this. "Pretty innocuous experience" or no, not gonna happen.
Also: Danae deserves an afterlife of all Eddie Murphy for that 'first' bullshit.
Posted by: the_wakeful at July 11, 2008 9:52 PM
uh, no.... I'm good thanks.
Posted by: Tsuru at July 11, 2008 10:16 PM
Elizabeth Banks? Elizabeth Banks?!
[clutches head]
I need a drink.
Posted by: Jerce at July 11, 2008 10:29 PM
Am I right then, in deducing that his poop-chute is indeed a poop-chute???? Or a merely an emergency escape portal....
Posted by: Janey at July 11, 2008 10:30 PM
This movie is the final bullet into the black heart of Eddie's dying career.
Posted by: Shaun at July 11, 2008 11:05 PM
I'd rather eat nothing for a weekend and then have a colonoscopy. Wait .. I AM going to eat nothing for a weekend and have a colonoscopy.
At least I'll be blissed out for an hour or two. Maybe they can show this in the OR? Conscious sedation is the only chance it has with me.
What's that? $18.4 million at the box office?
Posted by: bucdaddy at July 11, 2008 11:33 PM
....oh, Bill Corbett.
...I'm going to listen to 'Let's Have a Patrick Swayze Christmas' and cry.
Posted by: Mara at July 12, 2008 12:51 AM
Y'know, this may not have been the stinking cesspool that was Norbit, but it still didn't sound good enough to pull me into the theatre and away from the TV tonight - anybody see Keith Mars in Flashpoint tonight? I think I got the better part of the exchange...Murphy or Mars...hmmm..
Posted by: lordhelmet at July 12, 2008 2:09 AM
This is getting some alright reviews...
But isn't this just the "Sperm Mission Control" sketch from Everything You Wanted To know About Sex*, only PG?
Posted by: monitorman at July 12, 2008 2:17 AM
I so want Eddie Murphy to be funny and edgy again. If he had died after Trading Places, 48 Hours, and Beverly Hills Cop he would have been a legend. Is this really the same guy who used to do Mr. Robinson's Neighborhood?
Posted by: EricD at July 12, 2008 4:43 AM
Monitorman, you beat me to it.
If Bill Corbett wrote the script, do you think the movie would have been better if it had been done as a MST3K treatment (do Meet Dave as the movie Mike and the Bots riff on)?
Posted by: The Wanderer at July 12, 2008 8:07 AM
My apologies to Bill Corrbet, but at this point, I will only see this movie if it comes with a written apology, a full refund, and one coupon to kick Eddie Murphy in the fun stuff.
Posted by: Jeremy at July 12, 2008 8:14 AM
I like Eddie Murphy. I didn't see Norbit, as not to poison myself against him. Eddie is like an old athlete. He should do a movie with Katt Williams.
Posted by: Edgar at July 12, 2008 9:34 AM
He should do a movie with Katt Williams.
Eddie Murphy and Katt Williams star in "The Tranny and the Pimp Chronicles." Only who will play the tranny? Hmmmmmm. Let me take a moment to think this over.
Posted by: greer at July 12, 2008 9:46 AM
Am I the only one reading this and thinking "Oh, Gabrielle..."? I mean, she was in 10 Things I Hate About You and Bring It On, two of my formative "teen" movies. And she was awesome in both! Although I do note, with some dismay, that this is my second "rush to the defence of a Bring It On cast member" comment in the last three days, which probably isn't doing a whole lot for my "film connoisseur" reputation...
Posted by: Shay at July 12, 2008 10:04 AM
Sixteenth!!!!!!!!!! (Seriously people, enough with the lame "First!!" declarations in the comments!)
You couldn't pay me to watch Eddie Murphy. That man has become such a sour jackass. This is someone I loved as a kid in "Coming to America" and "Beverly Hills Cop." To this day, one of my favorite things to yell out at random moments is sexual chocolate. But really, why do people pay to see this goon anymore. What has he done to deserve the working peoples hard earned dollars.
Posted by: AllGussiedUp at July 12, 2008 10:08 AM
Only who will play the tranny?
Brooke Hogan.
It will be a comedy trio the likes of which has never been seen before!
Posted by: PaleoLithchick at July 12, 2008 10:09 AM
Ahem, I guess I was actually SEVENTEENTH!!!!! It was at sixteen when I wrote my comment.
Posted by: AllGussiedUp at July 12, 2008 10:10 AM
Meet Dave -- Starring Mr. Potato Head!
Posted by: JP at July 12, 2008 1:28 PM
"Eddie Murphy is...Eddie Murphy." "Starring Eddie Murphy, Eddie Murphy, and Eddie Murphy." "Eddie Murphy in Eddie Murphy."
I think Eddie Murphy just takes movies where the posters will say his name a million times.
Posted by: Geetch at July 12, 2008 3:21 PM
Hey lordhelmet... how was Flashpoint? Missed it last night which sucks as I was looking forward to some Hugh Dillon time. Dillon is usually scary intense.
Posted by: grinder at July 12, 2008 4:30 PM
it's amazing how much leeway you're giving this film because it was written by bill corbett. and what you're assuming is that anything bad about it was out of corbett's hands. that gives the assumption that all he wrote for MST was good. and not, maybe, that he wrote a lot of bad for MST that was killed before it reached the air. (and/or that other writers were responsible for some of crow t. robot's greatest quips)
this is the same mentality that a lot of people on this site have toward will arnett. all based on one great role, there's constantly utter shock expressed at the consistent bad quality of his other roles. as if he created the character, dialogue and plots of Gob. to say nothing of the fact that everything else good about his performance as Gob may have come from directing and editing.
so "meet dave" was written by someone you admire. so what? it doesn't mean they can't also turn out crap. i love my grandmother, but if she wrote a movie -- even one that would then be mangled by brian robbins and co. -- i'd have to admit that it sucked without any apologies to her being my grandma.
at least you were blatant about your bias.
i'd just hate to think that any writer on this site is turning into harry knowles. ("well, my friend/someone who called me and pretended to be my pal wrote and directed this...and it is awesome!!!")
Posted by: happy camper at July 12, 2008 5:30 PM
I am so glad that Murphy's movie career is almost over, so now he can join the chittlin circuit (for you white folk, the chittlin circuit is a group of black comics that play for predominantly black audiences) anyway. Murphy was very funny back in the day, but strangely enough, he started going down hill after being caught with that pre-op tranny on Sunset Boulevard.
Posted by: Pookie at July 12, 2008 7:05 PM
Grinder, I for one liked Flashpoint. It wasn't excellent but overall I think, especially for a series premiere, it had strong casting, was beautifully shot, ok writing (set up some good potential for some character story arcs) and decent dialogue. There's strong potential for a decent series, however its longevity is in question depending on who you ask. That said, it's the first Canadian series to be run simultaneously in the States since Due South so perhaps there's some network commitment behind it. I think the next episode will better show if Colantoni's character will be a little less stiff and restrained, or if Amy Jo Johnson (cute for 38!) will be more than a concerned second fiddle. At times it seemed a bit slow, but that may just be laying the groundwork for something good. There's incredible attention to detail that may or may not be a weakness.
Anyone else see it? Am I close, or was I just overwhelmed by seeing it in HD?
Posted by: lordhelmet at July 12, 2008 8:58 PM
I stumbled across this question on the Defamer comments section ad it has plagued my mind ever since...
Is Eddie Murphy the black Mike Myers or Mike Myers the white Eddie Murphy?
Posted by: Nevermore at July 13, 2008 7:18 AM
If the best you can expect from a movie is that it will only suck a little Shetland pony dick instead of a Clydesdale dong, it's time to go see something else instead.
Posted by: Kris at July 13, 2008 3:33 PM
I was hoping this would be amazing and no one would go to see it just because Eddie Murphy has squandered all of his good will; that my friends would be beautiful.
I just have two questions, I hear Ed Helms and Frank from 30 Rock are in this, any comment on them?
Also, I have assumed since hearing of this that they come from a giant Eddie Murphy shaped planet. If this is in fact the big twist at the end, feel free not to reveal it. Maybe he brings his love interest back and she sees that it's just a whole world of Eddie Murphys and it becomes a Planet of the Apes moment? A huge Eddie Murphy Statue of Liberty please, maybe even Tim Burton's Eddie Murphy Abe Lincoln.
Posted by: Rex at July 14, 2008 2:46 PM
Thanks lordhelmut! I am rooting for this show.
Posted by: grinder at July 15, 2008 2:51 PM

