free counter with statistics Surf's Up | Pajiba - Scathing Reviews for Bitchy People

surfsup1.jpg


Tasty Waves and Another Motherfucking Penguin Movie


Surf’s Up / Agent Bedhead

Film Reviews | June 11, 2007 | Comments (32)


Surf’s Up takes place within a parallel universe where penguins alone inhabit the Earth, the occasional chicken and hedgehog notwithstanding. The film rolls within a mockumentary style of narrative with a penguin camera crew, and the action commences within the frigid Antarctic climate of Shiverpool, Antarctica. Our young protagonist, Cody Maverick (Shia LeBeouf), just wants to get the hell out his small-time, fish-throwing life, where the only surfboards are made of ice chunks. Enticed by the surfing legend of Big Z, Cody decides that he wants to be a winner in life and chases that dream to the beaches of Pen Gu Island to compete in the Big Z Memorial Surf-Off. When he arrives, however, the poor little guy finds himself utterly incapable of riding the waves and loses consciousness in a series of wipe-outs and a subsequent sea-creature sting. Cody is rescued by toothsome lifeguard Loni (Zooey Deschanel). She drags Cody through the forest to the home of a mysterious recluse penguin named Geek (Jeff Bridges), whose cure involves promptly urinating on the wee penguin. This noxious deed is actually done fairly tastefully, all things considered, and most of the younger audience members won’t even realize that someone is, uh, getting peed upon.

In the days leading up to the surfing contest, Geek mentors Cody to prepare him for competition against the reigning champion, Tank “The Shredder” Evans (Diedrich Bader), who demonstrates a seriously erotic interest in his trophy collection. While pornlike music plays in the background, Tank introduces his “ladies” with names such as Helga, Chaniqua, and “my dirty girl.” Interspersed throughout the movie are some mildly amusing interview soundbites from Cody’s family, some reality-based surfers (Kelly Slater and Ralph Machado), and a trio of children obsessed with bodily functions. The camera crew is particularly interested in the notion of what it means to be a winner, which as it turns out, is the ultimate lesson explored by Surf’s Up.

Perhaps the most gratifying detail of Surf’s Up is that the cast isn’t all Hugh Jackmaned up with the usual Hollywood A-listers in manner of Happy #@%#ing Feet. Nowadays, the likes of Robin Williams and Nicole Kidman can take a break from the grueling moviemaking lifestyle and stroll into the awesomely easy and over-credited task of voicing an animated character. A few weeks with a microphone translates into a coordinated, negotiated, and highly coveted seven-figure salary for these stars. As a result, celebrity names have migrated from a film’s ending credits to top billing on promotional posters. Does this practice help ticket sales? Undoubtedly. Yet some voices just aren’t suited to come out of a cute little animal’s head. For example, ever since my daughter became enthralled with the Stuart Little trilogy, mice no longer scare me for their disease-breeding potential. Now they terrify the crap out of me because I’m afraid one will open its mouth and speak in the voice of Alex P. Keaton — that’s the real stuff of nightmares.

While Surf’s Up isn’t entirely celebrity free, the star quotient is at a manageable level. The biggest name is Bridges, whose reputation and notoriety seems firmly entrenched within the role of Dude from the The Big Lebowski. He’s not a traditional leading actor or a high-profile Hollywood player with an entourage in tow, but Bridges’ voice is far more adaptable to children’s films, since it doesn’t distract from the film itself. Also to Bridges’ credit is his veteran voice status earned within The Last Unicorn, which for better or worse, served as the prototype for future children’s CGI films (of course, that occurred back in the days when appearing in a children’s film was an altruistic, low-paying gig). Filling out the cast is B-lister and fratboy masturbation material Jon Heder, and because I don’t live in a universe inhabited with the likes of Napoleon Dynamite, I simply pretended that the character of Chicken Joe was voiced by an extra from Night at the Museum.

Visually, the film’s effects are spectacular, with intensely vivid colors and textures; during the surfing sequences, the water animation creates huge, blue waves that lend themselves pretty well to the feeling of riding the tube. Similarly impressive is the joyride sequence through the volcanic tunnels that feature pools of glimmering lava (and glo-worm poop). The action is accompanied by a pretty kickin’ soundtrack helmed by Green Day, and despite some mild language and crude humor, the characters are rather well-developed.

Indeed, as the mother of a six-year-old, I can testify to my unwitting overexposure to the realm of children’s films, and one could definitely suffer worse fates than enduring Surf’s Up. The film runs a mercifully short 81 minutes and, hopefully, will exhaust Hollywood’s current penguin fetish. Next up: mountain-climbing meerkats from Mars.

Agent Bedhead lives in Tulsa, Oklahoma and tries to avoid reality at all costs. She also insults pop culture daily at agentbedhead.com.


Tony from Jersey | Pajiba Love 06/11/07



Comments

Soooo... I'm guessing that, at the production meeting, the phrase "It's like Happy Feet meets Blue Crush" was probably used.

Nice review. As the father of no children, I can testify that I will absolutely take a big pass-ola on this.

Posted by: TK at June 11, 2007 2:38 PM

Through all the negativity, it sounds like you might have actualy liked this movie.

Your review reminded me of my 12 yr. old son refusing to smile despite the fact that he's having a good time. Because he doesn't want us to know he's having a good time because we might actually subject it upon him again. Thus removing him from the television and video games.

I haven't seen Happy Feet, so maybe this one won't seem like such a re-run. Or, better yet, I will make their dad take them to see it. Must begin devising my plan...Mwaahaahaa

Posted by: wsapnin at June 11, 2007 2:54 PM

Peguins are, like, SOOO the new black!!!

Posted by: nexus 6 at June 11, 2007 2:56 PM

Does anyone remember an old Disney short about a penguin trying to escape from the polar temperatures? He eventually sailed away from a bathtub and ended up in the tropics? Or am I making that up?

Anyway, it sounds like a much longer and more dolled up version of that. But with surfing.

Posted by: Siege at June 11, 2007 2:58 PM

Siege, I remember that cartoon! I don't know if it was Disney or not, but I remember the little penguin kicking back with a tropical beverage like it was yesterday.

Posted by: Kolby at June 11, 2007 3:18 PM

Its too damned hot out here for a penguin to be just walking around.

Posted by: phineas g. at June 11, 2007 3:19 PM

chaniqua? does the use of this name for laughs make anyone else's skin crawl? am i alone in this?

Posted by: kb at June 11, 2007 3:24 PM

I too am pissed off at the big stars lining up to do animation voice overs, but I take issue with the claim that it's an over-credited job. There are professional animation voice people who do a damn fine job of really inhabiting a character instead of just putting a recognizable voice on one (as the "stars" do). For them, it's about really giving the character life as opposed to a vanity vehicle. Unfortunately these talented people are losing out in a big way now that the trend is to have these big star names attached to characters. If I hear one more celeb saying they really wanted to do a voice over "for their kids", I will puke.

Posted by: PaddyDog at June 11, 2007 3:28 PM

Does anyone remember an old Disney short about a penguin trying to escape from the polar temperatures? He eventually sailed away from a bathtub and ended up in the tropics? Or am I making that up?

Siege... I think that was Chilly Willy...

Posted by: ciji at June 11, 2007 4:02 PM

"Its too damned hot out here for a penguin to be just walking around."

The people at the zoo are real nice, penguin. They'll treat you all respectable-like.

Posted by: Leaf at June 11, 2007 4:53 PM

I actually enjoyed this flick...I won't say liked and I won't say film...for a Saturday matinee when it's 95 degrees outside it was better than Happy Feet.

And he's an otter in a toupee...not a beaver.

Posted by: Stina at June 11, 2007 5:11 PM

The old Disney cartoon you guys are thinking of is called "The Cold-Blooded Penguin" from the movie "The Three Caballeros" (made in 1944 according to imdb). It starred Donald Duck, and was basically a salute to Latin American culture mixing live action and animation. I only remember this because it was one of my favorite things to watch at my grandma's house when I was little.
That, and I am a nerd. A big one.

Posted by: Jess at June 11, 2007 5:28 PM

On second glance, The Three Caballeros is way trippier than I remembered it being. Thanks for reminding me of it, guys, now I have to go track down a copy. And a bag of shrooms.

Posted by: Jess at June 11, 2007 5:38 PM

Um, not to nitpick but in a surf movie the idea of urinating on a jellyfish sting is just not that bad. Maybe it's not common practice any more but when I was growing up that was the standard operating procedure if you got stung, pee on it if you can or have somebody else do it if you can't. Weird for a kid's movie though, maybe.

The peeing was just weird in the kid's movie context. Also, it was an excessively long, uh, peeing session. - AB

Posted by: Anne (in Reno) at June 11, 2007 8:01 PM

I've had it up to here with all the bad penguin coming off the screen these days.

Back in my day, penguin was actually good. Here's some of that good penguin to help scrub out your brains:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oTWv63RyLP8

Posted by: Ranylt at June 11, 2007 9:00 PM

I am thinking the logline was more like "It's North Shore, but with penguins." Thereby encompassing the nowness of the remake and the penguin.

Posted by: jacque at June 11, 2007 9:43 PM

"...pee on it if you can or have somebody else do it if you can't."

And that, Anne, is why I'm never going to Reno.

Posted by: Betty at June 11, 2007 10:41 PM

"...a mysterious recluse penguin named Geek (Jeff Bridges),....."


Awwwww, dude, you're killing me here.

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at June 11, 2007 10:56 PM

I had the Disney book The Penguin Who Hated The Cold when I was a kid, which was probably the same story as The Cold Blooded Penguin. It was one of my favorite books.

Posted by: katy at June 11, 2007 11:56 PM

Nexus 6, you are so right! I was at MipTV in Cannes earlier this year, and you couldn't move for goddamned Penguin programs. The Koreans, in particular, seemed to have hundreds of the things. Animated penguins were *everywhere*.

Alas, sooner or later all those programs have to get released. Here's hoping it's only in Korea.

Posted by: rocky at June 12, 2007 3:10 AM

All I remember is a short that was part of Woody the Woodpecker..."I'm Chilly Willy the Penguin. I'm frozen through and through. My head is warm but my tail is cold. Ha, hee, achoo!"

Yes, I know more of the words, but I won't subject you to them. Why my brain retains that song 20 years later, I can't tell you.

And no, I won't be seeing this movie, but I'm happy to hear that it's not a load of crapola as I feared.

Posted by: JKo at June 12, 2007 4:03 AM

And maybe next time I'll refresh the window before I post my comment, especially after leaving it open all night long. Perhaps then I would have saved myself from posting the lyrics to Chilly Willy...

Posted by: JKo at June 12, 2007 4:08 AM

I can't watch movies with cute animals as the central characters because I am immediately gripped by a paralysing and irrational fear that something awful is going to happen to them. In fact I still can't watch the first half of Gremlins 2 because I'm terrified that something bad is going to happen to Gizmo, and yes I am completely aware that the film isn't going to suddenly change on the thirtieth viewing but such is the depth of my insanity.

I'll probably give it a miss although I will confess that right now the only appealing thought about the day when I eventually reproduce will be having an excuse to watch really cheesy kids movies again without fear of retribution from my friends and co-workers.

Posted by: Alex the Odd at June 12, 2007 4:31 AM

Chilly Willy was cute, which distracted from the fact that he was kind of a jerk.

PaddyDog, I got the sense that when AB talked about the actors being 'overcredited', it wasn't a swipe at the skill and integrity with which professional voice actors do their job, but the fact that they're being muscled out of their own profession by people who:
A) Do it as a vanity project. 'Oh yeah, can you make this a film where I'm Queen Ever-Beautiful of the Stars, and stuff? Story? Ah, who cares.' Okay, I'm reaching, but you've got to admit that these stories have been getting crappier as the celebrities have become more prominent. Connection?
B) Are terrible and instantly recognisable. No one wants to hear your 'goofy voice'.
C) Get all kinds of press, exposure and other celebrity perks that are never granted to the pros
D) Get paid so much more to do a professional's job, but much worse.
E) Bring in huge amounts of revenue that pros could never hope for, based on nothing but their name.
F) Suck so much of what can be good out of these films to serve their bloated paycheques, and yeah egos. They say they do it for their kids, when was the last time they saw these kids sans photo-op? Cynical? Yeah. Well, so am I.

So to me, her use of the word 'overcredited' was just an acknoweledgement of how piss-poor this aspect of animated films has become. I wouldn't want to put words in her mouth though.

Actually, you're right on the money. - AB

Posted by: M at June 12, 2007 2:27 PM

M posted...


B) Are terrible and instantly recognisable. No one wants to hear your 'goofy voice'.

I completely agree. The Incredibles would have been a pretty good film except for the fact that I could not get past Holly Hunter's speech impediment coming out of Mrs. Incredible's mouth.

Posted by: Wendy at June 12, 2007 3:18 PM

Wendy! You didn't like The Incredibles? I don't know why, but that makes me sad. I thought that was one of the best animated movies of all time. And Holly Hunter's voice was fantastic - the southern accent, a little maternal... mmm...

Ah well. Different strokes and all.

Posted by: TK at June 12, 2007 4:58 PM

Saw it; liked it. Kid liked it, too.

'nuff sed.

Posted by: Maryscott O'Connor at June 13, 2007 2:13 PM

Shia LeBeouf is the lamest piece of shit actor to come out in the past 10 years. He's not talented, he's overexposed, and Steven Spielberg wants to cover him in pure gold. It's obvious how much Steven Spielberg believes in this kid, because his involvement in Shia's career borders on extreme nepotism.

Every movie this kid touches makes me want to throw up. He bugged the crap out of me in "Constantine" and his interviews merely show what a cocky ass he is in real life. Don't believe me? Go watch his pansy interviews on YouTube. It'll make you feel like beating him up.

He's just more untalented crap out of the Disney cookie cutter. Keep an eye on him, because you're going to see much more of him in the future. He's already ruined "The Transformers" for me and now he's going to be playing Indiana Jones' son in the new movie.

I hope he burns out really quick.

Posted by: Steve at June 13, 2007 6:25 PM

Thanks Betty. Too bad I'm not from here and spent plenty of time on the beach and (later on) with nerdy marine biologists, and my parents were both lifeguards. You can just enjoy the burn when you get stung but I don't care who pees on it as long as it stops.

Still VERY weird for a kiddie flick. Not gonna see it, I'm guessing. Vanity casting in this kind of thing makes me feel sad for all the talented voice actors out there. Except after so many years of The Simpsons, I have to say I really wish Kelsey Grammer and Harry Shearer did more of this stuff. Then I might go see it. And Hank Azaria. He saved the Birdcage movie.

Posted by: Anne (in Reno) at June 15, 2007 5:37 PM

My six-year-old niece was in town this weekend. I have no kids of my own, so I'm not sure what to do with them besides movies and Toys-r-Us. Since I was told by my mother that I was NOT to take this child to Shrek 3 (she wanted to take her) I decided to shoot for this film.

I was very surprised at how enjoyable this was, for both me and my niece. The graphics at certain points were so good, that I thought I was in an IMAX and would hurl a little. It's not the best movie ever, but as someone who doesn't view these types of things with their little ones over and over and over and... well, it was a great afternoon diversion. We both really liked it.

I hope Shrek 3 sucks balls so my niece can say that I took her to the cooler movie.

Posted by: Big Red at June 17, 2007 10:33 PM

The plotline was ripped off from that old cheeser 'North Shore', right down to the guru who doesn't like contests, and the bad guy who only cares about winning. The reality-cam interviews after every major dramatic scene got really annoying as well.

You guys go way too easy on the kid movies. They're essentially training a entire generation of future movie goers to settle for and actually enjoy Hollywood schlock, except they're going to be paying $20 a ticket instead of just $8 or $10.

But it did have some nice surfing footage...

Posted by: Steve at June 18, 2007 4:19 PM

Is it just me or was this just a remake of North Shore?

Posted by: Sarah at October 12, 2007 5:40 PM