Lincoln Review: To Care for Him Who Shall Have Borne the Battle
film / tv / lists / guides / news / love / celeb / video / think pieces / staff / podcasts / web culture / politics / dc / snl / netflix / marvel / cbr

Lincoln Review: To Care for Him Who Shall Have Borne the Battle

By Daniel Carlson | Film Reviews | November 16, 2012 | Comments ()


There's a welcome lack of irony and distance in Lincoln that perhaps only Steven Spielberg could've created. Time and again he's circled back in his films to moments of oppression and release, of bondage and freedom, but he does so with a keen ability to balance mourning with hope. He's a passionate and gifted filmmaker precisely to the degree he's able to strip away the artifice from a narrative and present the stark emotions and real people underneath. Is it any wonder that, while his fantasies have dealt with fictional characters, his best dramas have sought to bring history back to life? The stunning achievement of Schindler's List and Saving Private Ryan, staring Nazism in the face. The return to the empty-souled bargains that built America in Amistad and The Color Purple. The beleaguered look at that "night already devoid of stars" in Munich. He's constantly working toward a place of sorrow and honor, of remembering the great evils men can visit upon each other shortly before they demonstrate their best intentions.

As such, Lincoln is powerful yet intimate, the kind of brutal, yearning look at mankind's dueling desire to love and conquer our neighbors that's Spielberg's specialty. It's frank about the ugly ways of human nature, political and otherwise, but it's equally tender about the people that make up that world, and about the relationships that keep them in it. The script from Tony Kushner (Angels in America, Munich) focuses mainly on the weeks in January 1865 leading to the passage of the 13th Amendment and the abolition of slavery, but it does so largely through conversations designed as much to let their participants use rhetoric to grapple with big ideas as they are to actually push the story forward. There's the fraught marriage between Abraham Lincoln (Daniel Day-Lewis) and wife Mary Todd (Sally Field), haunted by the ghost of one dead son and the prospect of losing another to war. There's the push and pull between Lincoln and Secretary of State William Seward (David Strathairn), who each want a peaceful end to the Civil War but disagree about the role abolition can play in such a peace. There are Lincoln's sessions with his cabinet as he battles them over the cost of abolition to the future of the Union. And there are the wars of words in the House of Representatives, particularly the eloquently toxic sparring between Thaddeus Stevens (Tommy Lee Jones), a Republican representative from Pennsylvania championing freedom for all men, and Fernando Wood (Lee Pace), a Democratic representative from New York who argues against equality. Spielberg keeps the story moving by shifting from one chamber piece to the next, letting the tension of the warring political factions and the looming amendment deadline ratchet the tension.

It's a testament to Spielberg's control and execution that, almost 150 years after the fact, he can still imbue the debate over and passage of the amendment with anxiety and dread, as if we stand to lose it all over again. He's focused in earlier films on these moments in which humanity seemed to stand on a precipice, unsure of what it might do to itself, and it's clear that these moments and the way they're handled are what drive him as a filmmaker. There are so many small moments that do so much, like when a politician tells Lincoln that the 13th Amendment is a "rash and dangerous" one shortly before he takes a cup of tea proffered by black hands. We never see the woman's face -- we don't see much more than a tight shot of her hands and torso as she walks to and quickly away from the seated man -- but we know all we need about her role in that world and the way the speaker could so passionately denounce freedom for members of a race while casually being served by one of them. This is masterful work.

Spielberg's blessed with an amazing cast, too. Day-Lewis is almost predictably fantastic as the beleaguered 16th president, a man physically weighed down by the knowledge of his place in history. He's slow to anger but resolved to see his appointed task through, and as the film progresses, Day-Lewis seems to move slower and slower, as if Lincoln himself were withdrawing from the world after having helped his country change irrevocably for the better. Jones is an absolute powerhouse, too, believably torn between knowing what he believes is right and knowing what portion of those beliefs he can voice in the Senate chamber without risking political death or the end of the amendment. Field and Day-Lewis have some electric scenes together, shouting at each other and clawing at their marriage, both unable to come to grips with the losses they've suffered and their failure as partners. Lincoln here is constantly prepared to defend his faith in abolition to any who will listen, but he's just as unable to give voice to the love he feels for those closest to him. When his son Robert (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) insists on joining the Union ranks, Lincoln tries to bully him out of it, and it's not until Robert's stormed off that Lincoln whispers to himself, "I can't lose you." Spielberg paints a man of horrible, damning contrasts, pouring everything he has into his country with nothing left for anyone else.

Perhaps the greatest thing about the film is the way Spielberg deftly weaves together history and myth to comment on the way we make the world in our image. When, in the film's final moments, Lincoln's cabinet is gathered around his deathbed, Secretary of War Edwin Stanton (Bruce McGill) says, "He belongs to the ages now." It's a powerful moment and one that's been enshrined in history lessons for generations, yet there's been debate about whether Stanton actually said "ages" or "angels," not to mention dueling accounts over some of Lincoln's actual statements. Similarly, when Lincoln is shot, the film isn't with him but with his youngest son, Tad (Gulliver McGrath), who's at a different theater for the evening and whose shattered wails at the news of his father's death stand in for the suffering of an aggrieved nation. For Spielberg, the point isn't always to accurately capture what happened in this dark and awful hour in our collective past, but to juxtapose the myths with equally stunning fact. These small scenes might not have happened this way, or at all, but the struggles to outlaw slavery were terribly real. Abraham Lincoln is a giant in American history and remembered here and everywhere for some things that might not have happened, but he's also rightly honored for guiding a fragile nation through a period of strife that dwarfs anything we can imagine unfolding today. Lincoln is a testament to the way myth and fact marry to make legend, and Spielberg chronicles the courtship in beautiful and unforgettable ways.

As with Spielberg's other films about our uncomfortable history, he's able to show how what once passed as victories can feel like something less when we look back. When Stevens stands up for abolition, his opponents warn their fellow representatives of the slippery slope they're on, scaring them into submission with tales of women being allowed to vote and black citizens being elected to office. Such rhetoric can seem laughable now, or at least lamentable, but Spielberg never paints the men making the arguments as buffoons. They aren't cartoon villains: they're simply people who believe, deep down, in what they're saying. By humanizing them, by keeping the action firmly rooted in the real, Spielberg turns any potential judgment back onto us. We look back on these talks and hang our heads, but what will our descendants think of us in a century? When Lincoln speaks of how abolition will benefit not only those currently in bondage but the "unborn millions to come," it's impossible not to hear Itzhak Stern telling Oskar Schindler that "whoever saves one life, saves the world entire." Abolition was a step, not a goal, and Lincoln is a reminder of how far we've come even as we have so far to go. Of how we can destroy ourselves, and how we can be made new again.

Daniel Carlson is the managing editor of Pajiba and a member of the Houston Film Critics Society and the Online Film Critics Society. You can also find him on Twitter.

Eloquent Eloquence: Community Hate Fondle Edition | Anna Karenina Review: Gamble Everything For Love

Comments Are Welcome, Bigots and Trolls Are Not

  • Amanda

    Two words: James Spader. I giggled with unabashed glee when he showed up!

  • PDamian

    Saw it a few hours ago. Magnificent.

    And on a different note: I'm a little nonplussed, and a little sad, that as of this post, there are 18 comments on Lincoln and about 60 on Twilight/Breaking Wind: The Suckening. Oh, well.

  • Enrique del Castillo

    Hating is easier

  • If I had not been with friends, I would have walked out after the first five minutes. Spielberg is as subtle as Gallagher with a mallet.

    The acting was awesome, but the story-telling was as cornball and cliched and heavy-handed as Ryan's Privates.

  • Marlon Berend

    Ben Franklin wrote those word.....and not Abe.... To care for him who shall have borne the battle is from Benjamin Franklin.....

  • annasheart

    I just would like to say that you're wrong this was written in the Abraham Lincoln Second Inaugural Address, dated Saturday, March 4, 1865. I've cited the reputable site (below) for you here:

    The Lincoln Institute.
    (2003-2012). Lincoln's Second Inaugural Speech. Retrieved from http://www.abrahamlincolnsclas...

    It is the last line of his address toward those who give their lives for this country.

  • Stephen Nein

    I'm annoyed that I have another week before it's in full release. I was hoping to send the kids to Wreck-It Ralph while taking the wife.

  • Devin McMusters

    My kids have grown and moved out, so I can take my wife anytime.

  • frank247

    So he dies at the end?

    Jeez, I thought we were meant to write **SPOILER ALERT* or something before we did that....

  • duckandcover


    Everyone who was alive in 1865 is now dead.

  • csb

    So it isn't War Horse in a stovepipe hat? That's good to know.

  • mona_sterling

    I'm trying to work out the potential cognitive dissonance of being hot for DDL as Honest Abe. I don't think I'll feel right about it, but fear it's inevitable.

  • lilianna28

    According to biographer Doris Kearns Goodwin, Lincoln was a hot piece of ass, if that helps.

  • $27019454

    If the movie is as good as this review is written we are in for a treat. Nice job.

    It seems cheap to call what DDL does "acting," -- grouping it together with what Matthew McConahey does. I don't mean to denigrate McConahey ...oh, wait. Yes I do. But as I was saying...I'll see anything with DDL.

  • duckandcover

    This. I fell in love with DDL in Last of the Mohicans and it hasn't stopped since. I've slowly acquired more and more of his work, but shamefully don't watch enough of it.

  • In other forums, people have pooh-poohed the comment I'm about to make, but I'm calling it now: Best Actor, Best Picture, Best Director at the Academy Awards. Seriously - America's favorite director making a movie about one of our best presidents at his darkest hours starring a man who's nominated every time he appears onscreen? It seems like a lock to me.

  • Fredo

    I can see why some might think "No way." It seems so tailor-made to sweep the Oscars that we gotta expect a twist along the way.

    I think you're right though. Definitely nominations for all.

  • L.O.V.E.

    Review well done.

    I'm guessing they waited 'til after the elections to avoid "politicizing" the movie or letting its story get re-purposed?

    Spielberg has tackled aspects of WWI, WWII (often) and now the Civil War. Would enjoy him taking a crack at the Revolution.

  • Ooh, I'd love to see that, too.

  • nosio

    I got chills reading this. Thank you, Dan. I can't wait to see this film; my massive lady boner for DDL is just one of many reasons.

  • Maya

    What a beautifully-written review. I am so excited to see this movie.

blog comments powered by Disqus