Five Better Uses of Your Time Than Seeing 'Magic In the Moonlight'
film / tv / lists / guides / news / love / celeb / video / think pieces / staff / podcasts / web culture / politics / dc / snl / netflix / marvel / cbr

Five Better Uses of Your Time Than Seeing 'Magic In the Moonlight'

By Vivian Kane | Film Reviews | July 30, 2014 | Comments ()


Let’s get this out of the way. Woody Allen did two very good things with Magic in the Moonlight.

1. He brought back the incredible cinematographer Darius Khondji (Midnight in Paris, The Immigrant, Delicatessen).

2. He can cast the shit out of a movie.

Khondji makes this movie visually interesting, even if Woody Allen couldn’t make it any other kind of interesting. And Colin Firth and Emma Stone have a natural banter that creates a sense of intimacy that sure didn’t come from the script. This intimacy, against Khondji’s gorgeous framing, create the illusion of something engaging. But Allen ruins things by adding absolutely nothing else. He insists on plopping at our feet a formulaic pile of mediocrity that somehow has no formula. It’s just a jumble of potential plot points that all sit in a heap, rather than going through the effort of unfolding in a logical, engaging manner.

It should be said, I was fully expecting to have to go into a lengthy discussion regarding Woody Allen as a person when writing about this movie. To address the question of whether we can, truly, separate a monster man from his art and feel decent about ourselves while enjoying his movies. But you know what? Woody Allen saved me from having to go into that. (Thanks, Woody!) Because this is not worth that discussion. This is a lazy, doughy afterthought of a movie. If you were thinking about seeing it, for whatever reason, there are dozens, probably hundreds of better alternatives. In fact, here are just a few:

A List of Better Ways To Spend Your Time Than Watching Magic In the Moonlight

1. Khondji really does paint a beautiful picture of France in the 1920s. But you know where else he did that? In Midnight in Paris. And that movie was actually funny. And charming. And things happened that an audience could care about. So if you’re considering seeing Magic in the Moonlight for the scenery, don’t. Just go watch Midnight in Paris.

2. Colin Firth plays Stanley, a handsome yet bristly curmudgeon (a stretch for him, no?), who is also a world-famous magician. Emma Stone is Sophie, a young woman with (either supposed or actual) clairvoyant powers who can communicate with the dead. If you saw this in the trailer and had an itch to see a movie with some magic in it, this is not for you. Both characters’ abilities are deliberately underwhelming. Instead, go watch The Illusionist. No, not that one… the other one. Oh hell, either one. Or watch The Craft. Or The Sixth Sense or I don’t know, anything else.

3. The main plot of the movie centers on Stanley trying to reveal Sophie as a fraud. Unfortunately, no one actually cares if she’s a fraud or not. Maybe Stanley does a little, but mostly he just wants to make snarky comments and be right about stuff. (Don’t we all?) Sophie doesn’t seem concerned with defending herself. We, the audience, sure as hell aren’t on the edge of their seats, trying to crack this mystery. No, if you want a good caper, a mysterious con that folds in on itself and makes you work to figure it out, watch The Brothers Bloom. If you’ve already seen it, see it again. That’s still, I promise you, is an infinitely better use of your time.

4. If you want to see a love story, go watch ANY OTHER MOVIE EVER MADE EVER. This one is not going to satisfy your desires. And I’m not just talking about the age difference here (although Woody Allen seems to be the only person in the world who doesn’t think it’s worth even mentioning). Firth and Stone, as charming as they are, have zero sexual chemistry. Get these two a buddy cop movie, or a vaudeville show, asap. But a rom-com? Neither actor actually seems committed to the development of that particular story line when it finally comes up. Basically any other movie ever made would have a more convincing love story. Hell, go see Snowpiercer. The undying love of Tilda Swinton and that train is stronger than the sexual pull of these two.

5. Finally, if you (like most of us, I’d assume) just wanted to watch Colin Firth and Emma Stone banter with each other, while being attractive and charismatic, you’d best look elsewhere. Granted, they do do that for a while, but it’s so bogged down in the meandering wasteland that is the movie as a whole, it’s not even enjoyable. Actually, when this movie ends up on Netflix, it would be the perfect thing to put on in the background while you’re cleaning or doing taxes or really anything that guarantees you won’t give it more than half your attention. If you allocate all your brain power to just this movie, you will likely go mad with frustration at the wasted potential of these two actors.

Not to leave you high and dry in want of some Firth and Stone action, here’s a superior alternative to watching Magic in the Moonlight. Instead of suffering through the whole movie, just look at these pictures:


Interspersed with bits of that delightful interview with the two of them.
Firth: There’s this great Groucho quote, “Those are my principles, and if you don’t like them I have others!”

magic-moonlight-stonesolo.jpeg Stone: You never don’t have a quote for something. I know that’s a double negative.


Firth: No, that is a grammatically correct double negative! Am I just a quote-bore?

Stone: “I like you very much… just as you are.”

Firth: She can do it! Jesus.

Stone: That was so good, and you know it! Look at you… you’re all red now. Oh, Colin, you’re so wonderful. [Laughs] You’re my Oscar Wilde.


Firth: But am I a quote-bore?

Stone: You’re a quote whore is what you are. You have so many quotes that I can’t see straight. You’re like the quote village bicycle.

Firth: I’m going to stop now. Crack-Whores and Quote-Bores. That will be the name of my autobiography.

And here’s Eileen Atkins, because she was fantastic.

And even Hamish Linklater playing a ukulele. Because that is worth seeing, if not sitting through the entire movie to see.

And maybe just one more:

There you are. Hopefully your desires have been quenched and you’ll no longer feel the need (if you ever did) to suffer through this pointless movie.

Vivian Kane could watch Hamish Linklater play that ukelele all damn day, but it is just not worth the rest of this film.

What Video Games Say About Our Morality | Drew Barrymore Releases a Statement in the Wake of Her Half Sister's Unfortunate Death

Comments Are Welcome, Bigots and Trolls Are Not

  • Bobby

    "Magic in the Moonlight" is a great film! I'm seeing it twice. The "reviewer" here is just a hater.

  • St

    I like Emma Stone as actress. But I can’t watch her in serious movies. She looks like Emma Stone in every freaking movie she is in. I enjoyed Easy A. she was good in it. And I’m afraid that this is her limit - doing teen comedies.

    She was looking like Emma Stone in The Help. She was completely miscast in Gangster Squad. She looked ridiculous there when she was acting all sexy and vamp. She was boring and forgettable in Amazing Spider-Man. I don’t think she can play dramatic roles. She is not talented enough for it.I saw trailer for this Magic in the Moonlight movie and again she looks like Emma Stone.

    She became It Girl for a moment after Easy A. The was cast in new Spider Man, she is lovable as person, suddenly became very popular and they began casting her in all those movies. But she simply can’t deliver.

    She should stick to comedies or learn how to play different characters and not look like herself in dramatic roles.

  • AliceAyres

    I have nothing to add to the "review". I thought the trailer was rather twee (not in a good way). If I want to see twee and all that comes with it I am going to watch Mood Indigo. But I wanted to thank you for bringing up The Brothers Bloom. This movie is so underrated. Back then Adrien Brody still was a delight on screen, Rachel Weisz is always soo perfect, charming, lively and radiant on screen and what can you possibly say against Mark Rufallo? NOTHING

  • Uriah_Creep

    Don't forget Rinko Kikuchi. Bang Bang was great too.

  • TheOriginalMRod

    I still want to see it, and I think I want to see it even more now.

  • Sara_Tonin00

    I hate her costuming for this movie. Especially the stupid hats.

  • Stephen Nein

    I know we have one professional costumer in this lot . . Ms. Stone looks utterly, typically period to my eye. A touch twee, but that's almost mandatory from the character description.

  • Sara_Tonin00

    I know. I still hate it. :)

    (I actually hate the golly gee expression in her eyes all over these pics too)

  • Abby Cadabby

    Those sailor outfits! She looks like SUCH a kid next Colin in those.

  • laylaness

    I was afraid of this. Emma is lovely in these photos. I loved reading their press junket interviews; they had the best rapport. And, you know, King Firth is always amazing.

  • Ryan Ambrose

    This review may have instilled in me the urge to watch Emma Stone bickering with Colin Firth, rather than dissuaded me from seeing it.

    But I watched Woody Allen's Scoop and thought it was "tolerable", so what the hell do I know about good taste anyway?

  • _Alexander_

    Dude don't even try it. It has Emma Stone. There is no better use of my time then basking if the glorious awesomeness of Emma Stone

  • Blake Shrapnel

    The Prestige was better than the Illusionist, and I will Ziggy Stardust anyone who says otherwise!

  • Mrs. Julien

    The Prestige is one of those movies it is VERY hard to turn away from once you start watching.

  • Berry

    I pretty much hated The Illusionist. Jessica Biel is cute as a button, and seems like a good egg, but she's just too bland for me to take her seriously as an object of all kinds of dark passions. And even Edward Norton seemed to sleepwalk trough the whole thing. Plus they were supposed to be childhood friends and wikipedia tells me Norton is twelve years Biel's senior. So that made no sense. And the plot wasn't very strong either, from what I can remember of it. It looked cool, I'll give it that.

  • Sara_Tonin00

    Oh YES. This is it exactly. Fascinating, driven, ambitious, dark man. The woman? Eh, she's a bit tomboyish, doesn't like to be told what to do. That counts as personality, right?

  • Ian Fay

    I really like both movies, but they're really very different.

    Prestige is about two men at the peak of their craft competing with one another, and the lengths they'll go to.

    Illusionist is about a love triangle, really.

  • Mrs. Julien

    What a delightful and refreshing review.

  • I'm thinking that anyone remotely interested in this movie was, at first, discouraged by the list, but then encouraged by the pics and the Firth/Stone back-and-forth and now can't wait to see them replicate it on the big screen.


  • Mrs. Julien

    See now, I thought she hit the highlights and replaced the lowlights in a way that made me feel like I had seen the best part of the movie and didn't need to bother with the rest.

  • lowercase_ryan

    I would love nothing more than for Woody Allen to end his career with a string of these...misses? Somehow I think box office and critical failure would sting him more than anything else.

  • Berry

    Man, I'd like to swim in that pool. And look charming in an old-timey swim-suit with Colin Firth by the ocean. And have glorious red hair. And sexy voice.

  • Mrs. Julien

    If I stop growing my roots out, I can do one of those things,

blog comments powered by Disqus