![]()
Comedy in the Era of Obama
"The Daily Show With Jon Stewart" / Sarah Carlson
As soon as President-Elect Barack Obama’s win was a safe bet, bloggers and pundits began to wonder whether late-night comedy could survive without the fish-in-a-barrel quality of George W. Bush jokes. My main concern has been for a staple in my TV diet these past four years, “The Daily Show With Jon Stewart.” But it’s not that I’m worried Stewart won’t still be funny with a President Obama; he will be. I’m worried he won’t be as relevant.
He’ll still be culturally relevant, but perhaps not as relevant in the sense that he represents something bigger — a movement, a way of thinking, a group of people demanding change. For four years (and many more for others), I’ve sought solace in the roughly 22 minutes broadcast four nights a week. It has been my piece of sanity in an insane world. In an August New York Times interview, Stewart described the sensation:
“In fact, Mr. Stewart regards comedy as a kind of catharsis machine, a therapeutic filter for grappling with upsetting issues. ‘What’s nice to us about the relentlessness of the show,’ he said, ‘is you know you’re going to get that release no matter what, every night, Monday through Thursday. Like pizza, it may not be the best pizza you’ve ever had, but it’s still pizza, man, and you get to have it every night. It’s a wonderful feeling to have this toxin in your body in the morning, that little cup of sadness, and feel by 7 or 7:30 that night, you’ve released it in sweat equity and can move on to the next day.’ ” (“Is Jon Stewart the Most Trusted Man in America?” August 15, 2008)
As much as Stewart tries to deflect the grand accolades thrown his way, claiming his is just a cable comedy show, he has in many ways served as a key voice for people who have nearly clawed their eyes out trying to understand the rationale — if there is any to be found — behind Bush’s policies, or behind the platforms of the Religious Right, or of the reason why Fox News continues to exist. His show has indeed been cathartic, part of a daily healing process as a helpful tonic reminding us we aren’t alone in the world and giving us hope that maybe things could change.
Well, we got the change we demanded. So now what do we do? The dynamic is going to change, but will it be for the better?
Stewart has had a ready-made audience of viewers who can’t stand the president. Now, his audience is largely made up of the Marxists who voted for the president and unabashedly love him. Obama’s presidency won’t be perfect, and members of Congress from both parties and other national and world leaders will continue to be asses and need a watchdog. Even former running mates are still around … and around, and around, and around. But on this we must draw the line. Former Republican Vice Presidential candidate and Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin is doing her best to remain the butt of late-night hosts’ jokes, and even Stewart was jabbing at her and her endless interviews just last night. Perhaps she’ll drift away, or perhaps she’ll become a senator and will never go away. Either way, using her as a reliable punching bag isn’t an option. Bush was perfect for punching because he won — twice — and considered those wins “mandates” to do whatever the hell he wanted. Winning an office automatically sets one up for scrutiny. Palin didn’t win, so continuing to punch her is like punching a dog — a three-legged, blind, dumb, toothless, hairless dog with an ironic sense of self-confidence. You can’t punch it, and you certainly can’t kill it; you just have to let it find its own way to die. Only fair. Plus, wouldn’t it be more fun to live in a world where she doesn’t exist? Let’s start pretending right now!
Finding fresh material and a way to make fun of Obama is up to Stewart and his writers, and I wish them luck. Stephen Colbert and “The Colbert Report” will be fine. All his character is doing is switching from the majority party to the minority. He loved President Bush, so he’ll hate President Obama. Nice and easy. Stewart isn’t playing a character, though. This summer, when he tried to do a joke at Obama’s expense, “The Daily Show” audience had a mixed reaction, which prompted Stewart to break from his script, turn to them and say “It’s OK to laugh at him.” And just listen to the roars of the audience each time Obama’s win is mentioned. Obama fans held their breaths for so long while hoping for an Obama would win that any manner of detraction against the candidate, even a good-humored on, was met with resistance. It was like admitting he was human after all, and that he might lose, or worse — that he wouldn’t be real.
Maybe the answer to a Stewart fan’s dilemma can be found in one of Obama’s lines about his campaign — that it was always about his supporters, not him. Sure, it’s a line, but it’s one that works. The viewers are the ones who are changing; we’re already approaching the show with a different attitude. Maybe, just maybe, things really will change, and we won’t need the same type of pick-me-up from comedy and satire. Maybe we’ll turn to Stewart and others even more so for entertainment than before. The show will continue to reflect the pulse of a large portion of society, only now, that pulse isn’t from a body on life support. The worries of pundits on whether Stewart will still be funny aren’t actual worries — they’re talking points about pop culture that fill up time. My worries on whether Stewart will still be relevant aren’t actual worries, either, just reflections of my own dumbstruck self now that my preferred candidate with a funny name actually won.
It’s a good thing that Stewart and company won’t be some of the main voices of reason. It’s a good thing that the president will now speak in complete sentences and value crazy things like the Constitution. It’s the start of something new. The tears both Stewart and Colbert shed Election Night represent it all — tears of joy and relief and awe that something major had occurred, and that they weren’t the only ones who believed the country could once again live up to its core ideals.
“The Daily Show” will change, but that’s because the country will change. It already has.
Sarah Carlson has a front-row seat to the decline of the newspaper industry and lives in Alabama with her overly excitable Welsh Corgi.
Whiskey Baby Ninja Star T-Shirts on Sale
Eloquent Eloquence 11/13/08 |
| Assassination Vacation Vowell
|
Comments
The biggest reason I love John Stewart is that he and his people are not afraid to call ANYONE on their shit. I love the features where they dig up video to show people directly contradicting themselves, or denying they said something that they're on camera saying. I think he'll still be able to do that with the Obama presidency, but maybe to not as great (or sickening) effect.
Also I love Wyatt Cenac. He's my fake TV pundit boyfriend.
Posted by: Genny (also Rusty) at November 13, 2008 2:13 PM
Well, it was there for years before and still is. I agree with both you and Jon that the catharsis has been wonderful, but it's okay if we don't need as much now. I predict they'll go more underground and local. There's always lunatic fringe and local bastard politics going on somewhere and they've always excelled at the location reports.
Posted by: Jay at November 13, 2008 2:13 PM
People worried about "The Daily Show" having a lack of material over the next four years are on crack. It's just that simple.
Look, people - we are headed into four years that are going to be very, very tough. Just because the President will no longer be an inarticulate bumblefuck doesn't mean that Stewart and Colbert will lack for targets; there's still god knows how many corporations entirely willing to fuck over the public (even while getting desperately needed government assistance!), the mass media smugocracy of dunces, and of course the entire Republican Party.
Repeat this over and over until it becomes clear: There is not going to be a lack of stupid powerful people for "The Daily Show" to mock any time soon.
Posted by: mightygodking at November 13, 2008 2:14 PM
Man, I love The Daily Show so very much. It and the Report are easily two of the funniest things on television right now. I have to thank you guys for alerting me to their existence!
Posted by: Chugga at November 13, 2008 2:23 PM
I'm with mightygodking - senators and congresscritters aren't going to become noble self-effacing paragons of uprightness. Well, not overnight, anyway. If the Cabinet appointments start looking like corporate raider America - they've got material. I just hope they go after Presdient Obama's cabinet (squee!) with some of the vigour they've gone after the Cheney administrations. I am confident they will. This time - their interpretation and analysis might not just get beamed into the void of powerless "Marxists" and inspire and maintain a commitment to keep on the ruling party. They're going to need a lot of oversight too. But yeah:
"There is not going to be a lack of stupid powerful people for "The Daily Show" to mock any time soon."
Posted by: Farfalina at November 13, 2008 2:24 PM
Don't forget, TDS also mocks pundits and journalists. We will have comic fodder on a daily basis FOREVER.
Also, Wyatt Cenac is mine. I saw him first. Can't prove that I did, but I know I have.
Posted by: lilah at November 13, 2008 2:42 PM
Making fun of the Obamessiah.
That's a whuppin'.
Making fun of his National Service Plan.
That's a whuppin'.
Making fun of inevitably higher taxes, higher inflation and lower growth.
That's a whuppin'.
Projection of whatever you want Obama to be - i.e., "it's about his supporters, not him."
Just downright creepy. We don't know a thing about him. And that's worthy of a whuppin'.
Posted by: Chris at November 13, 2008 2:43 PM
From Stewart's first show back on Jan. 11, 1999 (link below):
"I'm sure many of you are curious, 'is my beloved Daily Show going to change?' Well, it might, subtly. And I know change can be painful, but from change comes growth."
The writing staff consistently puts together some of the funniest and most insightful bits around. Papa Bear is the scheduled guest tonight. The fans will stay fans and will be just fine.
P.S. Larry Wilmore is where it's at.
Posted by: branded at November 13, 2008 2:43 PM
"It's a good thing that the president will now speak in complete sentences and value crazy things like the Constitution."
LOL [snort]
Can people just stop with the shorthand and actually write out the full "value things like the parts of the Constitution that I choose to endorse"? I mean, let's be frank shall we and just admit that anyone who respects the entirety of the Constitution is weeded out veeeery early in the election process, with a little lip service from the pandering jackals to show that they're totally legit and down with limitations on government and all that stuff and whatever ooo shiny!
Posted by: Eep at November 13, 2008 2:44 PM
Quit posturing.
Maybe you see a little bit of yourself/ Pajiba in the Jon Stewart/ Daily Show?
It hasn't been relevant since Colbert left. Hell, it hasn't been relevant since Mo Rocca left.
The reviews aren't scathing and we're not THAT bitchy. and That's okay, just don't pretend anymore.
Posted by: christ at November 13, 2008 2:44 PM
And let's not forget, the Republicans are still out there. And the religious right. And she whose name shall not be written but thinks she has a shot at 2012. There will be fodder.
Posted by: Cindy at November 13, 2008 2:48 PM
"We don't know a thing about him."
Two full-on years of intense media scrutiny, nit-picking by his own party for months and then another four months of bashing by the Republicans, and the best you can do is "we don't know him"?
Man, what color is your Koolaid?
Sorry if the best the trash-pickers could find was that Obama attended a frickin' tea party held by a "terrorist" who has been toothless so long he makes the Beverly Hills Chihuahua look petrifying, but maybe...just maybe...there really is no monster under the bed.
Posted by: Wednesday at November 13, 2008 2:54 PM
As long as there are politicians who didn't get the memo that America is supposed to be a place of religious freedom: There is not going to be a lack of stupid powerful people for "The Daily Show" to mock any time soon.
Anyway, I am personally excited to have a leader I can respect and be enthusiastic about. I am excited to drop all the apathy and disengagement. Time to be snarky and bitchy about other things...like movies and television shows. Whoa, was that why I starting visiting this website? ;)
Posted by: VeinsRHiways at November 13, 2008 3:00 PM
God, you people are so pathetic. You ACTUALLY WON!!!! And still you continue to bash and rip apart people who don't walk lock step with your view of the world. Jesus, what's it going to take to make you people HAPPY for once in your life? Get over it. Your guy won. The Evil Bush Hitler has been thrown out of office (or will soon be), and those Dastardly Villainous Republicans have been ousted from power. Go drink champagne and have lots of sex. Stop living in the past and for God's sake, STOP BEING SO BITTER AND MEAN to everyone who doesn't have a "D" at the end of their name. Why are you people always so damn MISERABLE all the time? Stop spending your time making vulgar-filled rants about people you WILL NEVER MEET in blogs and go live your life. Be happy, get married to your gay lover, adopt Cambodian babies, and settle down and enjoy life. Stop worrying so much about the Evils of Fox News, those Dream Crushing Republicans, and Oh So Weak Mother Earth. What is it about you people and your constant need to RAGE AGAINST THE MACHINE all the time? Cripes. Either stop living in the past and keep living your life, or just shoot yourselves already. Either way, your endless tiresome whining has become untolerable. Holy shit, no wonder you people make movies about suicide and call it art. Your lives really ARE full of misery.
Posted by: obamadroneno44451 at November 13, 2008 3:15 PM
The man's not even in the White House yet, he still has years for us to hate him. He has a lot that he can do to make us want to cause him suffering. I've spent half my life in the Bush Administration, and it has jaded my soul to all hope. I hated him before it was cool. And if I've learned anything in my life, it's that the government will always find ways to be a disappointment.
I know most of you may support Obama to the end, this sites political views are just like that. But Obama has to really make things work in order to impress me. And now he has no excuse, he has both the house, and the senate. If he fucks this up, I will never forgive him or any of the democrats. Which will leave 100 percent of politicians on my shit list, possible exception to Ron Paul.
Posted by: George at November 13, 2008 3:21 PM
Should I feed the troll?
I've been told not to, but it looks so hungry, and I'm a big liberal softie...
What is it about you people and your constant need to RAGE AGAINST THE MACHINE all the time?
Yo, we're Democrats, that means we actually like the machine and want it to do more for us.
That's all.
Posted by: Macafee at November 13, 2008 3:23 PM
wow you said everything that i've been thinking.... awesome post.
Posted by: Ted E Blowsevelt at November 13, 2008 3:23 PM
Eep is right. there are parts of the constitution that are pretty blatantly ignored and we seem to be okay with it....?
obamadrone might have a point, but he just can't resist getting all AM radio crazy with it, so I'm not sure where to...find..it. Oh wait. I know whats wrong, its not really a reaction to Sarah's post, just some rant/rave action going on.
And they can make fun of Obama, his party and followers and whatever. Some may resist, but make fun of them, too! All is fair in political humor
Posted by: VinKong at November 13, 2008 3:34 PM
From Macafee: "Yo, we're Democrats, that means we actually like the machine and want it to do more for us."
Yo dude, how far from JFK's "Ask not what your country can do for you..." speech?
Posted by: James S at November 13, 2008 3:34 PM
"We don't know anything about him"
I'm not surprised by your comment Chris, I mean what has Obama really done to explain himself to you besides write two books about his life. It's not your fault, in your real America if it ain't white it ain't right.
Posted by: Pookie at November 13, 2008 3:36 PM
I think Sarah hit the nail on the head with her observation of Stewart's audience not liking jokes against Obama. That, to me, is going to be Stewart's real problem. I like that he'll call anybody (even people he likes) on their shit--but will his audience let him do that with Obama? They're not being too positive about it right now. So it's not so much relevancy that Stewart needs to worry about, but instead his audience letting him do his job. I wish him the greatest of luck.
Posted by: nutmeag at November 13, 2008 3:38 PM
I'm still waiting for the hand holding and Kumbaya singing.
*hands outstretched*
Posted by: Beauregard at November 13, 2008 3:42 PM
So this is where all the conservative nutbags have been hiding through the campaign. This thread.
Ron Paul. Hahahahahaha. Good luck with that one. I believe he is now the ruling King of Montana, and whatever other states were batshit enough to put him on the ballot. Montana being the Alaska of the United States.
Making fun of conservatism will not be old hat until the last of the old guard, or "relevant" conservatives, have died off. Yes, there will always be some bitter individuals raising their teenagers on Rush (not the progressive rock kind, the banal soulless idiot kind), but hopefully this ridiculous sector of American life becomes more marginalized than it already has.
Posted by: tdehr at November 13, 2008 3:52 PM
I like that he'll call anybody (even people he likes) on their shit--but will his audience let him do that with Obama? They're not being too positive about it right now. So it's not so much relevancy that Stewart needs to worry about, but instead his audience letting him do his job.
Fuck his studio audience... right up their buttholes. They aren't anywhere near to being the whole of his total audience, and they are just as likely to be a target -- he calls them on their shit, as well, when they get uppity.
FUCK THEM, if they can't take a joke. EVERYONE is fair game in Stewart's business, and regardless of which "side" he's riffing on, I'll be tuning in to watch.
Posted by: Rykker at November 13, 2008 4:28 PM
It won't be The Daily Show/Colbert Report that suffer because let's face it, political satire is just as relevant on both sides of the isle. Also, both of those shows have genius writers. The person who should be most concerned about their career would have to be Micheal Moore. I was watching an interview with him a couple of weeks before the election and he was trying so hard to establish his political beliefs as being center. It was painful to watch. Without Bush or the Right in command, he's going to have to work a lot harder for the material in his "documentaries."
Posted by: perfectjargon at November 13, 2008 4:58 PM
wait -- isn't *alaska* the alaska of the united states? I didn't realized it had seceded...
Posted by: melia at November 13, 2008 5:00 PM
John Oliver is my Daily Show correspondent crush
Love the tall, pasty Brits!!
Posted by: Plobes at November 13, 2008 5:43 PM
John Oliver is my Daily Show correspondent crush
Love the tall, pasty Brits!!
Posted by: Plobes at November 13, 2008 5:43 PM
"Sorry if the best the trash-pickers could find was that Obama attended a frickin' tea party held by a "terrorist" who has been toothless so long he makes the Beverly Hills Chihuahua look petrifying, but maybe...just maybe...there really is no monster under the bed."
Look, I agree with the sentiment, but...you don't need teeth to make that chihuahua terrifying. Every time I see it's face I want to run screaming and hide under the bed.
Posted by: dsbs at November 13, 2008 6:41 PM
"Sorry if the best the trash-pickers could find was that Obama attended a frickin' tea party held by a "terrorist" who has been toothless so long he makes the Beverly Hills Chihuahua look petrifying, but maybe...just maybe...there really is no monster under the bed."
Look, I agree with the sentiment, but...you don't need teeth to make that chihuahua terrifying. Every time I see it's face I want to run screaming and hide under the bed.
And that's fine, you people take your correspondents. I want Stewart, I have for years, and he is MINE. I'll set the chihuahua on anyone who says otherwise.
Posted by: dsbs at November 13, 2008 6:42 PM
Aw, I'm sorry. I've visited this site for years and this is my first double post. I feel like I've made it through some sort of right of passage. And also like an idiot with restless fingers.
Posted by: dsbs at November 13, 2008 6:49 PM
ummm...
Joe Biden, anyone?
There was a reason why he was locked up the last three weeks of the election...To keep him from saying stupid shit.
In fact, Biden has been saying stupid shit for years. Far longer than a certain soon-to-be-ex-president...
Posted by: Some Guy at November 13, 2008 8:16 PM
Who don't you libs worship?
Posted by: garry. at November 13, 2008 11:35 PM
My only concern is that the humour of the Daily Show returns to being irrelevant to people like me who watch but are not from the United States. Before the elections got underway, some of the jokes were lost on me because they were not relevant to me. I would tune in once in a while and generally enjoyed what I saw. But once the Indecision '08 kicked off... I was so into it. I got it and I laughed hard. Not as hard as when I watch the Colbert Report though, being Un-American and all.
Posted by: Dexter Morgan at November 14, 2008 1:19 AM
I think last night's episode pretty much proved they're still on top. People keep forgetting that they're on four days a week and not every single episode or joke (even during Indecision 2008) is going to be classic.
As Jon told Bill O'Reilly and the rest of Fox News: "Don't be afraid"
Except for Sean Hannity.
Posted by: Le Kim Nguyen at November 14, 2008 5:59 AM
This article is looong for a topic that really doesn't have anyone concerned.
No one is worried that the Daily Show will stop being funny. No one I know anyway. And yes, during the campaign the audience didn't receive Obama jokes well. But just wait til after his first 100 days are up. Even well-liked presidents are easily skewed. People had a field day with Clinton. Jesus, we still make jokes about Jefferson banging his slaves.
Political humor has been around as long as politics. Though we may no longer have the rage-fueled humor of watching a blundering idiot as president, I'm sure Obama & crew will give us plenty of material.
Pajiba-ites know that. Based on reading previous articles, I'm surprised the honchos of this site published this one. Is this Carlson a relative?
Posted by: K at November 14, 2008 6:40 AM
voice for people who have nearly clawed their eyes out trying to understand the rationale -- if there is any to be found -- ... of the reason why Fox News continues to exist.
I love it when the paragons of tolerance get upset when someone disagrees with their worldview and give in to wanting to silent their critics.
As for the Brilliance of Jon Stewart, lets not forget that the Daily show had to go into repeats during the writer's strike. Jon was shown to be a empty suit without his writers.
Posted by: Paul L. at November 14, 2008 8:34 AM
get married to your gay lover
Sorry, but if we allowed gay marriage then squirrels would become carnivorous, swarm out of the forests, and begin devouring the world's puppies and kittens and baby bunnies [citation needed].
Posted by: jeem at November 14, 2008 1:31 PM
I'm sure Jon will have plenty of material to work with in terms of Obama...maybe in terms of his appearance and fashion sense at least. Politically it might be more of a challenge because of the audience, but he'll soon have to go there once issues come up. And I'm sure they will because Obama isn't perfect, nor is he a socialist. As many Right-wingers have tried to argue. In fact, maybe he should interview celeb right-wingers for his show like Victoria Jackson! Hahahahha!
Posted by: ph at November 14, 2008 2:14 PM
Squirrels eat meat AND nuts.
Posted by: Just Amanda at November 14, 2008 2:17 PM
Um, people... It STARTED as a satire of NEWS MEDIA.
And there is still PLENTY to SAT.
Posted by: Maryscott O'Connor at November 14, 2008 5:34 PM
In response to the gentleman who posted this highly intelligent and insightful comment:
I love it when the paragons of tolerance get upset when someone disagrees with their worldview and give in to wanting to silent their critics.
what fucking universe have you been living in? for the past 8 years, liberals and moderates have been told not to criticize George W. Bush and his administration because, if they did, they weren't "supportin' the troops", "anti-American" or "not in the mainstream" (which I never understood since Bush lost the popular vote in 2000 and the election in 2004 was really close). so when conservatives complain that liberals will accuse them of being racist for criticizing Obama (which they haven't done ... they've called people who don't want him to be president because they think he's an Arab/Muslim racist, but that's because they are racist), they should take those hurt feelings all the way to Alaska where they can hang with Palin and Joe the Plumber and secede from the rest of the world (not just the U.S.)
oh! and listening to people who oppose gay marriage or promote intelligent design isn't being open minded, it's humoring people who, maybe, we shouldn't necessarily humor
Posted by: Le Kim Nguyen at November 14, 2008 7:12 PM
Le Kim is right. I don't know how the GOP has been so efficient in silencing all criticism of the Bush administration. It's chilling really.
Posted by: Thatguy at November 14, 2008 7:51 PM
Oh, there will be plenty to zing. Power attracts those interested in power. Our system selects winners willing to engage in the flesh-bartering of electinos, and able to win competing with the other self-appointed Donner-chow.
This process does not select satire-proof people.
Posted by: BierceAmbrose at November 16, 2008 3:03 AM
I think people sometimes miss the fact that a lot (most?) of the jokes on the Daily Show aren't about how shitty politicians are, they're about how shitty modern media coverage of politics is--the stories the media chooses to focus on, the inanity of most "pundits", etc. I'm sure most of the cable news coverage will continue to be worthy of mockery in an Obama administration.
Posted by: Jesse M. at November 16, 2008 7:24 PM

