web
counter
 

What The Hell Are You Supposed To Be?

By | Posted Under Comment Diversions | Comments (77)



christmas-presents.jpg

I love Halloween. There’s nothing I enjoy more than the opportunity to pretend to be someone or something else for one day out of the year. Having kids can also add to that fun as, if you raised them right, they always want to be something cool and you can use them as a canvas for your twisted imagination. Actually, you can do that every day, but on Halloween you’re less likely to be judged for your deviant parenting techniques. It’s become obvious to me that I wasn’t raised right as, for Halloween; I always wanted to dress up as something that in hindsight was ridiculous. What compounded the problem was that I was also an extremely headstrong product of “Oops I forgot to pull out” so I insisted on making my costumes myself. My clown looked like the makeup had been applied by a five-year-old with palsy and ADHD, my ninja consisted of a scarf and a toque and my vampire required the application of one line of lipstick to the corner of my mouth; because I had been drinking blood, you see.

I put the blame for these travesties squarely upon my parents. To them, Halloween was just another day that necessitated catering to the children and handing out candy to a bunch of little shits that are probably going to egg your house anyway so they never really got into the spirit. I wasn’t allowed to watch scary movies until much later in life so I had no concept of zombies, werewolves or any of the other classic costumes. No I was a kid who actually believed it was perfectly acceptable to fabricate a costume that, once worn, would have been told made him to look like a fucking idiot. That’s what caring parents do, folks. Don’t be one of those parents, like mine, who lets their kids walk around looking like a tool in front of their peers because you don’t want to stifle their creativity or uniqueness. You’re doing an immeasurable amount of damage that stays with the child well into adulthood. If you continue down that path, you’re going to be the parents of that kid that goes on American Idol and sings with the dulcet tones of a cat in heat hacking up a fur ball but can’t figure out why they don’t make it to the next round. We all laugh at them and we are right to. This brings me to my most embarrassing Halloween costume that, thankfully, occurred when I was young and still had no concept of social ostracization. At the end of the day, however, I would know that burning brand of social stigma.

I was in grade four and decided that I wanted to go as a game die for Halloween. Not dice as in the items one uses to randomly generate a numerical value that controls the amount of spaces one moves in every single board game ever created. No. Just one single and solitary little die. It would have been fine if I’d decided to go as a twelve-sided die or something to that effect as it would have a genuinely nerdy appeal, but why would I want to do that? On it’s surface, the costume itself is breathtakingly simple. All you need is a box, some white paper to cover the box and some circles cut out of black construction paper circles to paste onto the box in the proper order and you’re done.

I began experiencing difficulties when it was revealed that we had no white paper, nor black construction paper and my parents were not about to purchase some just so I could throw it away after a day. One has to remember that it was the mid eighties so computer paper wasn’t exactly a standard purchase for most homes. Instead I was forced to make due with a box that was too big and Christmas wrapping paper. At this time any child with even a smattering of awareness would have thought that this might not be the best idea to pursue and my parents tried to tell me, but I would not be swayed. I was determined to press on and see my dreams of creating the most awesome die costume in the history of mankind come to fruition.

Way back in the eighties we still had what was called a costume parade. This is when all the kids in the school would file through every classroom to show off their masterful creations. As I unveiled my Davinci-like handiwork I was greeted with that most humiliating question that has haunted every person at some point in their lives: “What the hell are you supposed to be?” and I was crushed. This question is perfectly cromulent when one has a clever or punnatious response but please be assured that, “I’m a die” is not that type of response. Perhaps it was the shiny red wrapping paper or the shiny green dots representing the pips, but it was apparent that my die costume had now metamorphosized into that of a fucking Christmas present with a head.

Initially I thought that it must just be the obvious mongoloids in my classroom that couldn’t appreciate the brilliance, originality and thought that went into such magnificent accoutrement; but as the day went on, more and more people asked what the hell I was supposed to be. I began to realize that this failing had been my own as kids love Christmas, but when was the last time you saw a fucking Santa Clause at Halloween? It also didn’t help matters that the box was far too big and allowed only my hands to poke out the sides. Due to this engineering faux pas, whenever I tripped, or was tripped (accidentally of course) I would fall directly on my chest and face. In hindsight, I should have just told everybody that I was spotted dick because I surely felt it by the end of the day. It took more than a year to live down my terrible decision because we all know that kids are cruel and everyone was waiting for my cock-up the next Halloween. I played it safe the following year though and went as a soldier - sans camouflage. But I did have an awesome gun.

Today I want to hear about your costuming nightmares. Whether they’re yours or belong to someone else, I want to know about the horrible Halloween decisions that you’ve made or seen. Bonus points if you’ve convinced another person to wear something irredeemably stupid. But, seriously, a fucking red Christmas present with a bad case of the rare and dreaded shiny green herpes.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Pajiba After Dark 10/26/10 | Casey Affleck, Matthew Broderick Join Tower Heist | No One Is Safe From The Ratnerf*cking









Comments

I haven't celebrated Halloween since I was thirteen years old. And I am quite happy about that.

Let's hear about your costuming nightmares suckers.

Posted by: grace b at October 26, 2010 8:16 PM

I once went trick-or-treating dressed as an insurance salesman. My best Sunday suit, my dad's briefcase and a bag for the candy.

Years later, I took part in our local Jaycees' haunted house, partly because I had a white lab coat and partly because I knew the recipe for stage blood.

This year, I'm going as a member of the proletariat (I work Sunday night).

Posted by: The Wanderer at October 26, 2010 8:20 PM

I once tried to go as Salvador Dali, which meant dressing up as a doll with a little tulle skirt and white tights and Mary Jane shoes with a map of El Salvador on my shirt. But things never really gelled so I just ended up looking like a scary clown whore. With a map.

Posted by: Really scary at October 26, 2010 8:21 PM

When I was 2 I was supposed to be a devil. I just remember being terrified of it. Like screaming hysterically, refusing to put the costume on terrified of it.

My mother, pregnant with my sister and in no mood to deal, pretty much said fuckit. Stuck me in my favorite purple sweatsuit and pinned purple balloons all over it. At least if my pudgy self fell over, I'd be uber cushioned.

And then I reprised the costume twenty years later :)

Posted by: Victoria at October 26, 2010 8:22 PM

age 13, 1983, went as dolly parton with balloons under my shirt. boy/girl party. balloons popped within 10 minutes.

i went from dolly parton (blonde wig and flannel along with balloons) to an elderly lesbian.

Posted by: glittergirl at October 26, 2010 8:22 PM

... I was grapes

Posted by: Victoria at October 26, 2010 8:22 PM

My costumes were always rad, 'cause my mom likes to sew. Unfortunately for my poor little brother, she only liked to sew about one costume a year, so he got my last year's hand-me-downs. It wasn't so bad for him when the previous year I'd been a dragon or devil, but I'm pretty sure he was forced to be a unicorn twice. A purple unicorn with pink mane and tail the second time.

Posted by: dr. pisaster at October 26, 2010 8:23 PM

Don Cherry, Victoria? That seems rather tame for what he'd wear. Sorry, Canadian humour.

But things never really gelled so I just ended up looking like a scary clown whore.

Brilliant.

Posted by: Robert Scott at October 26, 2010 8:26 PM

I went as a blond Klingon, made a rubbery, ridgedy foreheaded upper head mask/wig out of latex which was kinda awesome, but ran out of ideas for the body part (I did have an Enterprise C Trek Badge, but that was it). So I wore this giant thick knitted burgundy rug/blanket thing over my shoulder with a belt thinking it looked...Klingon-y and put the badge on and fourteen metric tonnes of makeup to blend it all in. I crimped my waist length hair too. Ugh.

I still think it would have been a 'better than most' outfit, but I somehow ended up in a sporto club called the Roxy (my boyfriend did the murals, got us in free) that had apparently never heard of ugly girls OR Star Trek. I essentially was the 'ugly sweaty broad' all evening long. I never saw so much slutty bewbs and butts costumes in my life.

Utterly demoralizing.

Posted by: replica at October 26, 2010 8:37 PM

My halloween costumes are never really imaginative. Probably because I'm to lazy to do otherwise.

I go as one of the zombie characters from MJ's Thriller.

I do find myself snapping at peeps when they fail to guess though. They just think I look disheveled. Honestly folks!

Posted by: Jean at October 26, 2010 8:37 PM

I was a pale 15-year old girl. So naturally, I went as Martin Luther King Jr.

Posted by: shanmarie at October 26, 2010 8:47 PM

Really scary cracked me up. I love reading about and looking at Halloween costumes--Halloween is almost nonexistent in Honduras, and the only people who dress up are very little kids for school celebrations. Sometimes you'll get a costume party for college kids, but they're pretty sad because no one's used to looking like a jackass once a year, so you just get a lot of cat ears or whatever. I love vicariously through other people's horror stories.

This year, though! I'm gonna be SUPER ORIGINAL and dress up like Charlie Brown in "It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown!" and cut up some holes in a sheet and be a ghost. I'll carry around a paper sack with a rock in it. And underneath I'll be wearing a giant yellow shirt with a black squiggly line and black pants. I know it's been done before, but I've ALWAYS wanted to do it and now it's my chance!

Posted by: figgy at October 26, 2010 8:57 PM

When I was a kid I decided I wanted to go as a gumball machine. I wore red pants, and my mom decided we could easily cut a large clear plastic bag, fill it with balloons, and have me wear that over my shirt.

It's not a bad concept; unfortunately, the balloons we got weren't round, just distended ovals. Also, the bag wasn't round, either, just... bag-shaped. So I was just wearing a bag of lumpy balloons. I remember going to a little kid party with a costume judge and they were so confused trying to figure out what I was. "A... bag of jellybeans?" I was embarrassed, so I just said yes.

Posted by: Pistachio at October 26, 2010 8:59 PM

When I was in college, my roommate invited my boyfriend and me to a Halloween party. Neither he nor I were partying types, but we agreed to dress up. I owned a pair of black jeans and a black and white striped shirt, so I added pair of white suspenders and some white face paint and went as a mime. Of course, most everyone knew what I was supposed to be, but what really aggravated me was that most of them (I guess) expected me to stay completely silent the entire night since someone invariably made stupid cracks about mimes not talking whenever I bothered opening my mouth.

But, what I really want to tell you about is this... Neither my boyfriend nor I were particularly creative and neither one of us managed to come up with a fantadtic costume idea for him. So, he ended up getting one of those white head-to-toe type suits you see folks wearing in a clean room and a respirator from his dad who owned an asbestos removal company at the time. Now, I get that he wasn't really *anything* other than a guy in a white suit with a respirator. But, considering that this was a party thrown and attended by mostly engineering students, you would think he would have gotten a few less "WTF are you supposed to be?" type questions.

It really turned out to be a pretty disappopinting night and only reminded us why we didn't like to go out in the first place.

Posted by: elsie at October 26, 2010 9:09 PM

Oh gawd, I actually planned to be a Christmas Present on year in Junior High. A classmate pushed me over, and the box impeded my ability to get up. Like a turtle, I rocked back and forth until I could get my feet under me again, much to the amusement of everyone in the class. I don't quite remember what happened next, but it involved violence and a trip to the principal's office.

I hate Halloween.

Posted by: Sassy Rouge at October 26, 2010 9:13 PM

Robert, I thought I was the only one (aside from my then girlfriend) who dressed up like a fucking die. (We were a pair of dice).

Yeah, it was a piece of shit, but I was devoted to her and...

Posted by: Uncle JR at October 26, 2010 9:18 PM

Figgy - Do it! Lots of holes in the sheet too. It just feels right!

Pistachio, that idea is awesome, seriously. I knew a kid whose dad made him a wooden refrigerator costume that was hell on earth to wear, but we were all pretty damn impressed. I bet there were a few folks who liked yours too...

Posted by: replica at October 26, 2010 9:27 PM

In 7th grade I went as a geisha. I was also fat and it was my first foray into heavy makeup. I looked like a culturally insensitive transvestite.

Posted by: Erin S at October 26, 2010 9:28 PM

One year I went as Groucho Marx, complete with painted-on mustache and fake cigar. I did the walk, I did the cheesy grin, and I told the jokes. At that point I was already old enough to have all of Duck Soup, Horse Feathers, and A Night at the Opera(Best.Movie.Ever) memorized, so I had a lot of material to work with. It was awesome. Only problem? Nobody knew who I was. They all just thought I was a weird mustached guy. So that fell flat. Stupid ignorant suburbanites.

Posted by: esme at October 26, 2010 9:46 PM

Let's see my favorite holiday is Halloween.

Let's see I've been the Devil, Mad Hatter, Princess Jasmine, Sleeping Beauty, Super Heather, Elizabeth Bennet, Rainbow Brite, a clown, a Men in Black agent, a mummy, and a box of Crayon.

Because of Halloween, I learned how to sew.

Posted by: DoubleH at October 26, 2010 9:50 PM

Wow, I should have read my post before submitting.

Posted by: DoubleH at October 26, 2010 9:54 PM

@esme

I had the same thing happen! Sophomore year of high school I went to my school's Halloween dance as Alex from A Clockwork Orange. I know it's not terribly original, but it was my favorite movie at the time.

I thought I pulled it off pretty well. I had a black bowler; while pants, shirt, and suspenders; black boots; and even the eye makeup. Unfortunately, no one but a few of the teachers had a damn clue who I was.

Posted by: Patrick the Bunny at October 26, 2010 9:55 PM

I hate the over-priced cheap store bought costumes and prefer creative themed or group costumes cobbled together from thrift stores and things lying around the house. So, naturally I get asked "what are you supposed to be?" a lot.

One year I went as Jack from Fight Club and had friends going as Marla and Tyler Durden. Individually there was not much to distinguish the costumes (rumpled dress shirt, khaki pants, bruises and cheek wound for me, red leather jacket, garish t-shirt, spiked hair, and bruises for Tyler, ratty wig, slinky dress, coat, chunky shoes, and too much raccoon makeup for Marla.)

I thought we looked awesome, but the effect was lost on random others at a Halloween Party/ punk show that we ended up at. Nobody got it. Some people didn't even realize we were in costumes. Oh well, fuck them, we were cool.


Last year we had a one-year-old daughter for Halloween, which, in my mind, translates to "awesome prop possibilities". I was really tempted to craft a Hannibal Lecter facemask onto a pacifier and tie her up in a straightjacket/Onesie. The wife could do a ponytail and gray FBI sweatshirt. I would fully commit to Buffalo-Bill tranny make up and a silk robe to make this work but we didn't have anywhere to go where this would be appropriate and it fell apart.

So instead we decided to do a True Romance homage. I was Clarence in Hawaiian Shirt and Elvis glasses, the wife was rocking an Alabama look and we put the baby girl into a toddler-size Elvis costume so she could play the Val Kilmer role.

Once again, it was an inspired home-made group costume. Once again, nobody at the family-friendly Halloween at the local shopping mall had any clue why we were dressed the way we were and why we would dress our girl child as a male Rock n Roll icon.

So basically Halloween is about lovingly crafted elaborate inside jokes that no one else gets, and me looking kind of stupid.

Posted by: Yossarian at October 26, 2010 9:58 PM

One year I went as a kissing booth. Oh, sure, people recognized me easily, but I had failed to realize that everyone, not just the hotties, would try to kiss me. Damn you, flaw in my planning!

The remembrance of scores of wildly drunken/sweaty/smelly dudes very persistantly trying to kiss me (all. night. long.) can still make me shudder a little.

Made fifty bucks, though. Win?

Posted by: noodlestein at October 26, 2010 10:01 PM

I went as Robin.

Posted by: James S at October 26, 2010 10:05 PM

That depends, noodlestein. Did you have to spend the fifty buck on medication for cold sores and/or miscellanious oral maladies?

Posted by: Robert Scott at October 26, 2010 10:09 PM

I was in first or second, maybe third grade, and my mom covered a couple boxes with aluminum foil and cut two arm holes and a head hole in the big one and made a face for the small one and sent me to school like that. I was a robot. Except the big box was too big for me to fit in my desk, so I had to sit on a chair at the front of the room. And at one point my box head started to fall off but I couldn't catch it because the big box impeded my arms, so it fell to the floor and someone had to pick it up for me because I couldn't bend over either.

I don't remember (thankfully) how I went to the restroom like that. Maybe I just held it all day.

Good times, Mom, good fucking times.

*still bitter after 45 years*

Posted by: , at October 26, 2010 10:21 PM

One year I went as a vampire. Riveting, I know. But back in the early 90's, they weren't cliche' tween creations, they were actually scary to 8 year-olds. Promise. Anyways, I decided it would be best to wear all black, because that is apparently frightening.

The only black sweatshirt that I owned had a giant glow-in-the-dark Batman logo on the front.

My Mom suggested I simply turn it inside out, but I was to stubborn to listen to any suggestion, so I decided to just wear it normally. I was vampire batman, with a glowing emblem so you could see me from 200 feet away. Which, in retrospect, is actually pretty fucking sweet.

Last year I scrambled to throw together a costume from the local thrift store so that I had a way to get plastered with my friends. I'm too neurotic to go to a party with normal clothes on, so I would have had to stay home. I was having trouble finding anything, so I ended up buying a bunch of tremendously garish clothes including bright red flannel pants, checkered button up shirt with a shiny purple vest over that, and a green marching band jacket. For a women. So, yeah. It was tiny.

People kept asking me if I was Willy Wonka. It could have been worse, so I went with it.

I seem to luck the fuck out. With costumes.

Twice.

Posted by: Sam at October 26, 2010 10:24 PM

Let's see - I've gone as Monica Lewinsky (splashed white-out on my blue dress + beret; gotta love the 90s), a piece of sushi (orange balloons wrapped with garbage bags for roe), a nun, Ann Darrow from King Kong (with big gorilla hand around waist), an "OD'ing Mia Wallace (complete with syringe sticking out of chest), a (Wo)men in Black, Amy Winehouse and Tomb Raider.

Halloween rocks.

Posted by: chickadee at October 26, 2010 10:25 PM

Worst costume?

"Person who needs coffee." Wore a robe, dark circles under my eyes, carried a coffee cup, and collected candy in a pillow case. The worst thing was that I borrowed my dad's robe, and the pocket had condoms in it, which really kinda grossed out my 4th grade self when I unwittingly stuck my hands in the pockets.

Posted by: linny at October 26, 2010 11:07 PM

When I was 8, my friend and I desperately wanted to go as punks, but my friend's mom was making our costumes and didn't like the idea. Somehow a compromise was reached whereby we became punk babies. Yes, it was as terrible as it sounds. The last thing an 8 year old hanging out with older kids wants to wear is a diaper, and a ducky tattoo makes no one look tough. The one saving grace was getting to use the spray-on hair color. My rainbow fauxhawk was awesome :).

Posted by: McSquish at October 26, 2010 11:25 PM

@Robert Scott

Nah, just spent it on multiple drinks to assuage the sadness in my soul. ;)

Posted by: noodlestein at October 26, 2010 11:26 PM

Yossarian, I am with you on the "baby as untapped Halloween potential". I've been trying to convince my sister of the amazing possibilities. But no, the baby is going as a flower.

My mom made fun costumes for us when we were little. I was: a robot - an appropriately-sized box with things from the hardware store glued on, plus dryer tubing for arms and legs, all spray-painted silver; a princess (of course); a bat; Raggedy Ann; an astronaut (I don't remember what we used as the helmet, but it looked awesome); and a tea party (looked neat, but wasn't very much fun to wear).

In high school, I made a rainbow costume. It was a vanishingly short dress made of strips of different colors (in order). I thought it was awesome, but of course no one had any idea what I was supposed to be.

Posted by: Phaeolus at October 26, 2010 11:27 PM

The worst costume I ever had to wear was Aunt Jemima. My mother dressed my poor pale white 8 year old self up in full blackface and sent me out to trick or treat and to a party hosted by a lovely Indian family who had a very multicultural group of friends. I remember people looking at me a little askance, but wasn't very self aware, so it felt ok at the time. I am horrified just writing it.

A close second was the time in university I dressed up as a bag of jellybeans (on purpose, as opposed to commenters above). I wore a dry cleaner bag filled with balloons with a white body stocking underneath. It was cool, and I won a prize, but every guy there took a turn squeezing the balloons in the boob and butt region, so eventually I was left standing in a giant plastic bag over the nearly see through stocking, with a pair of black heels. A little fetishistic, now that I reflect on it, but I was pretty sober at the time and it was mortifying.

Posted by: llp at October 26, 2010 11:53 PM

I love Halloween, but twice I've ended up the frumpy part of a themed group.

In 4th grade my mom was still coordinating what all us kids wore, so my brother went as Johnny Appleseed and I was an apple tree. She sewed red felt apples onto a green sweatshirt and green hat. My little sister was "random pioneer girl" in my awesome red dress with floral buttons. That was the year I realized "I'm too old for this shit."

Then in college my friend Tiffany and I were obsessed with Napoleon Dynamite the year it came out. She finally wore me down and convinced me to be Napoleon to her Deb. (I have curly hair and my best friend was a Hispanic guy, so there you go.) I embraced it and even made my own "Vote for Pedro" shirt .... then I drove to a party with my other friend Maura, who was going as a Playboy bunny. Oh yeah, I felt attractive.

Posted by: Empress of All the Russias at October 27, 2010 12:06 AM

I threw a party once that a friend of mine flew to town to attend. She dressed up as a pink slip. (She wore pink slip with a bunch of notes that said 'you're fired' on them.) Pretty clever costume. Unfortunately, this was in 2000 and most of the attendees of the party were fellow ex-co-workers from a dotcom that had gone bust a few weeks before. Awkward.

Posted by: SeaKat at October 27, 2010 12:13 AM

Worst costume? In 6th grade, I decided to be Elvira. Except, you know, I was 11 and nearly flat-chested and somehow ended up choosing a black dress that was more Betty Draper Goes to a Funeral. And I had a black CURLY wig. Because that makes sense.

Though honestly, I just wanted to have black hair and my mom wouldn't let me dye my hair and I didn't want to bother with the spray on stuff that year (takes forever to wash out). And "Elvira" was the closest thing I came up with. Some kids tried to take the wig off at the middle school dance and I very nearly tossed one of them to the ground. Oh well. Still had someone to dance with, which was more they could say (ego, I haz/had it).

Best costume?

When all the boys in my neighborhood were Batman (circa 1990), I decided to be the Joker. My costume was awesome. Light purple corduroy pants, dark purple jacket, striped shirt, green scarf, green gloves, a hat, appropriately smeared red lipstick and white pancake on the face. Sprayed some of my hair green.

I had so many people ask me why I didn't want to be Catwoman or Batgirl, and I remember looking at them like they were clearly trying to pat me on the head.

Sort of like the year I got a lot of "Aw, you're a lovely princess!" and I answered, "No. I'm a QUEEN."

Posted by: Sara H at October 27, 2010 12:14 AM

When I was about 11 or 12 I decided to make my own costume. I was a zit. Red paint to exposed skin, pillows and a sheet to make me nice and round and a sign that said "squeeze me, I'm a zit!" Mouth preloaded with marshmallow creme and you could really pop me. I was a geeky litte dude, no question.

Posted by: Steve at October 27, 2010 12:44 AM

I'm actually really glad I'm not doing Halloween this year because I always have such high expectations for my costumes and then no one gets it. I just get way too specific with my characters, which is fine because I love them (that's why I wanna be them) but explaining it twenty times in a night just gets exasperating.

For example, last year, I went as Cameron, the terminator, from the Sarah Connor Chronicles. I had cool metal pieces stuck on the side of my face and I wore her usual outfit of a leather jacket with tank top and boots over grey jeans. Everyone thought I was just a monster... (I really liked that costume though... my face just looked so cool).

And then there was the year I decided to be Queen Gorgo from 300. I thought she was kickass and hot as hell. So i SEWED FROM SCRATCH an exact replica of her outfit from the movie. Everyone thought I was just a Grecian princess. Fuck me. (Though this was my favorite costume because I made it.)

I also wanted to be Sydney Bristow from the pilot episode of Alias, so I got a red wig and a black turtleneck and a black beanie hat and black pants. I was sweating balls all night. I still always want to be Sydney Bristow for halloween though. Maybe a different spy outfit would be good. NEXT YEAR!

My worst costume ever? In high school, i wanted to be a goth, so i did dark eye makeup with dark red lipstick and wore black and just looked... terrible. And kinda runny. AWFUL. I cringe just thinking about the look on my teachers' faces when they saw me. I can't believe my mom let me out of the house looking like such a train wreck.

Posted by: denesteak at October 27, 2010 1:04 AM

The year was 1987, I was 12 years old and wanted to be a punk rocker for Halloween. I found a kick ass purple spikey wig that I begged my mum to let me buy. She was agreeable. I wasn't allowed to wear make up but for my punk rocker outfit I was given the green light. I went all out. My mum didn't wear make up so I was forced to buy that cheap stuff from the dollar store because that's all I could afford with my allowance after the purchase of the kickass purple wig. I got myself all gussied up with my cheap dollar store make up, applying the bright blue eye makeup and the blood red lipstick just how it looked like on all the punk rockers on MTV. I put on my shortest skirt (still well below my knees), my sparkliest tank top, my black shiny nylons and my ankle boots.

Left my room and walked into the living room where my uncle, who had happened to drop by, took one look at me and said to my mother, "Jesus Christ Ann, when did you let Kelly become a hooker?"

My mum laughed so hard she almost wet her pants while my uncle stood there with a smirk on his rotten face. I didn't have a clue what a hooker was but I just knew by the way my mum was blushing and laughing and that awful smirk on my uncle's face that it was something awful. I fled back to the safety of my bedroom; face hot and red, holding back tears and snagging my nylons in the process.

Eventually I did go trick and treating but the night was ruined for me. I remember having this horrible, lingering feeling of shame and embarrassment about my costume, and not even knowing why.

Not mhy worse costume (there was that time I wore all white and completely dusted myself in flour and then it poured rain the entire time I was trick or treating) but definitely the most memorable costume. Afterall, who doesn't love a 12 year old hooker in a purple wig?

Posted by: Kelly at October 27, 2010 1:53 AM

Obsessed with Disney and idolizing all skinny princesses as only chubby little girls can, I absolutely begged my mom to let me be Cinderella in 4th grade. Promises were made, a blue dress was procured, but fit it did not and I rejected the thought of "put a t-shirt on under it" as only my mother would have insisted.

I had to have a costume for Halloween carnival, and this was the solution: White Keds, bunny ears, bunny tail, and my moms god-awful all-white one piece button-up cotton jumpsuit the likes of which I didn't see again until I learned about old-western underclothes. the awesomeness of this was compounded by two major factors: aforementioned chubbiness that gives 4th graders boobs they are embarressed of and subsequently refuse to wear bras for as well as the fact that at said Halloween carnival, I was in charge of the booth with rubber ducks in a small swimming pool and lots of splashing.

I'm pretty sure I didn't wear a white shirt again until highschool.

Posted by: beckells at October 27, 2010 4:12 AM

Worst costume ever? One year my brother decided to go as a fly strip. It seemed like a brilliant, easy to execute idea.White pants, white shirt, with raisins and currants glued to it (the yellow glue doing a pretty good impression of bug guts) and dabs of red here and there.It was so convincing that no one wanted to sit near him all night, most especially the hot babe dressed in black and gold glitter that he was desperate to score with.

Posted by: brite at October 27, 2010 4:34 AM

My costumes are usually pretty good. The lamest one I ripped off from The Addam's Family. I went as a serial killer. I wore normal clothes but went to work with a big ass Michael Myers style real butcher knife. Because serial killers look like everyone else. But the idea now of walking around all day with a foot long knife is kind of ludicrous. I miss the carefree days of 1998.

My friend once dressed as a huge penis. It was horrifying. He made it himself and had this flesh colored suit shaped like a tube and blue strings running down the side for the veins. Then he made big sacks to attach to it with a couple of shredded wigs for the pubes. To top it off he used cotton to simulate cum all over the place. My disgusting description isn't doing it justice, believe me. It was gloriously awful. Very few people were able to figure out what he was because it was designed so poorly.

Posted by: TylerDFC at October 27, 2010 7:10 AM

When I was 5 or 6, I was Wonder Woman. My mother made me put balloons in my shirt b/c Linda Carter was well endowed. Back then I was too little to know about Child Protective Services...
When I was about 9 or 10 I was very into soap operas, for some reason. On one soap there was this fictional character called Ruby Bright. It was actually the alter ego of another character on the show, I think...so it wasn't even a real character. I don't remember much about her except that she wore stuff that reminded me of gypsy type clothing. Anyway...that year I went as Ruby Bright. Nobody knew what the hell that was.
I do remember the school parades, though, that was always my favorite. I used to feel REALLY sorry for the one kid in my class who was never allowed to participate for religious reasons or something, and had to sit in the classroom by himself.
Remember those old horrible 80s costumes that basically consisted of a plastic smock and a terrible plastic mask of whatever you were supposed to be? There were always lots of kids at school in those classic eyesores.
My favorite costume as a kid has to be Jem. I reprised that this year.

Posted by: Whorish Mouth at October 27, 2010 7:40 AM

I always had boring costumes as a kid, so I usually end up going all out for my daughter's outfits. The one she loved the best was Xena. She adored Xena, and it was a pretty easy costume to do.

Later she went as Carmelita Spats from A Series of Unfortunate Events. She was a tap-dancing fairy princess ballerina veterinarian. It took me FOREVER to round up all the stuff. Tap shoes, a lab coat (for a nine-year-old) and stethoscope and stuffed kitten, a tutu, a fairy wand and wings, and a tiara, with her hair all done up in a bun (ballerina-style) and loose curls around her face (fairy princess-style).

This year she's too old for trick-or-treating and her Homecoming dance is the night before. Her first pair of real heels and her first "fancy" party dress. It's a whole different type of costume.

Posted by: Wednesday at October 27, 2010 8:04 AM

We lived on a farm in the middle of nowhere, and my dad didn't think trick-or-treating was cool, so I never went as a kid. But, I still wanted to dress up. So I'd either end up with the plastic beauty-shop-smock-type costume with the horrid plastic mask, or my older sister would dress me as some version of a whore/doll. Then, I would take my sad little trick-or-treat bag out on our front steps, and knock on my own front door to have my own mother open up, act surprised, and hand me candy. Repeat 3 or 4 times, and there you have my childhood Halloween experiences. Oh, and we never carved a pumpkin. I had a basketball with a jack'o lantern face drawn on it. I still have it.

But, one year when I was in jr. high, my mom and I dressed up for a church Halloween party....as aliens. We wore brown garbage bags, with knee-high hose over our heads (like robbers) and homemade deely-bopper antennas, and rubber gloves. I have photos.

Posted by: dammitjanet at October 27, 2010 9:15 AM

oh, and @esme, a couple of years ago, I went as Marlene Dietrich....tux jacket (with tails!), top hat, cane, heels, tights.....the whole thing. Several people thought I was Riff-Raff....and others just thought I was some sort of tranny.

Posted by: dammitjanet at October 27, 2010 9:19 AM

When I was 9 I went to the school hallowe'en fancy dress contest as Dick Turpin. I didn't win but that didn't bother me in the slightest: I knew I was the baddest looking bad-ass in the fucking room.

Posted by: Ballymena Bob at October 27, 2010 9:38 AM

Halloween exists so you can put on an awesomely obscure costume and then find those who get it. They are your people.

Posted by: mswas at October 27, 2010 9:45 AM

Robert Scott, your costume reminded me of high school. I was (am) a drama geek, and our Homecoming theme my freshman year was "Trapped in Paradise". For our float, we used PVC pipe to build two giant squares, and then strung giant black dots across the front of them. We were all inside, miming attempted escapes.

WE thought it was funny...

Hmm, two years ago my corporate office encouraged people to dress up for potential prizes. I figured going "goth" was easiest, plus I could use it as an excuse to brood and ignore people. Score. Well, the only black wig I could afford find was bushy and awful. Think Hagrid shaped. ::shudder:: Did that stop me? Nope. And I got some of those faux lip piercings and wore dark make-up.

I maintain that if it weren't for the horrible wig, it would have looked kind of cool. But everyone else wore NORMAL EFFING CLOTHES, and then 10 minutes before the "party" they threw on something weird and semi-humorous. The guy that won wore a suit and carried a briefcase and wore sunglasses. When he took them off, he had on red contacts. He won, and I had to sit in my cubicle looking stupid all day.

Posted by: Patty O'Green at October 27, 2010 9:45 AM

Best costume ever - when I was 9 (I think), my Mom sewed me a Sylvester the cat (from Looney Tunes) costume, complete with big, stuffed head. It was awesome.

My own best costume ever was Laura Palmer from "Twin Peaks". I painted myself blue-grey and wrapped myself in plastic. Of course, the rubes in my college town asked "What are you supposed to be?" all night long.

Oh, and there was the time I dressed up like Nancy Spungen at a college party at a local hotel. A guy I had been on one (disastrous) date with saw me and thought I was a hooker (for real - he got to the price list before I blew my cover.) At least he didn't ask me out again.

I love Halloween.

Posted by: SugarKane at October 27, 2010 9:46 AM

I blew my cover.
---
So he only had, like, $20 on him?

Posted by: , at October 27, 2010 10:20 AM

Just last Saturday night, Mr Smith and I went to a party dressed as the Plants vs Zombies game. He was the zombie and looked very authentic. I dressed as a Sunflower, but only looked like one as long as I had on my yellow, paper-plate sunflower bonnet which kept wilting and falling in my face. When it was off, I was just a stupid, odd-looking woman in a green hoodie, sweatpants and boots with bad blackface (brown) makeup. Maybe an overly-tanned gardener? Since no one else at the party had ever heard of the game, our attempt to create a cute and timely couple costume, was completely lost on the crowd. I'm just glad I didn't go as a Peashooter or potato bomb. Epic fail.

Posted by: Mrs Smith at October 27, 2010 10:21 AM

In my 20's went as Fred Flintstone (Yabba Dabba) and won a prize, wife was Wilma.

But the best by far was dressing as Elvis, people want to take their picture with you, crowds will bow in awe at "The King"...awesome! Wife was a Las Vegas White Tiger (and her costume had inside pockets for beers!).

However, at 3am, driving home after 10+ Jello Shots and unknown amounts of Tequila, and getting pulled over by the police for making a U-turn (had just moved to the DC area) while dressed as Elvis was a different experience. They must have put out a radio announcement as suddenly 10 cars were lined up behind us.

A female officer came up to my wife's door and noticed her tail was hanging out the door and said "Kitty, your tail is stuck in the door!"

My wife, seriously smashed, opened the door, and wrung the water out of the tail.

The male officer on my side couldn't stop laughing, and then handed me a breathalyzer and said "Blow into this for me King"...

I don't know why, but I blew under 0.8%, and to everyone's amazement they had to let us go (as they had pulled us over without cause)...

True story, I have pictures :)

Posted by: TrickyHD at October 27, 2010 10:24 AM

Ok... so I have two incidents of Halloween costumes ideas gone horribly wrong... both as an adult….Don’t JUDGE ME!

Incident #1
I was a Freshman in college and was at a stage of well...umm basically being a drunken wild child faze ...and that hazy judgment made me and my roommate think dressing as babies, in adult pink onesies, pacifiers, and diapers on the OUTSIDE of the onesies would be a cute idea instead of the whole infantile/slutty combo platter... I wonder if I will have that many offers to change my adult diapers when I will HAVE to wear them later in life.... It’s doubtful I’m sure. We just looked like preschooler hookers.

Incident #2
I offered to take my kid brother and sister out their neighborhood to trick or treat, and even after the disastrous baby whore fiasco, I continued to dress up annually for Halloween. That year I thought it different to dress as a guy. Yeah, not a good idea, since I got propositioned by women who thought I was a pretty boy, and guys who wanted to kick my ass... or maybe fuck me in my ass, because they were really aggressive with their anger...I'm pretty sure they were latent homos.

Let that be a lesson to you to never play transgender roles games unless your name is Tyler Perry and you make millions as stereotypical fat black woman.

Posted by: NGG at October 27, 2010 11:00 AM

My sister & I did ballet for years, and since ballet costumes are expensive, and my parents are cheap, they often doubled as Halloween costumes as well. We would just say we were ice skaters, or princesses or whatever. Unfortunately, where we live, it can be 80 degrees out one Halloween and 40 degrees the next, so sometimes we were princesses in tutus and sweatpants.

Posted by: badkittyuno at October 27, 2010 11:36 AM

I went as a French Canadian one year to a party. Lumberjack look (flannels hirt, suspenders, boots) on bottom with a beret on top. No one got it.

Posted by: Kiddo at October 27, 2010 11:36 AM

Two years ago I was Assasinated Sarah Palin for Halloween. I won two costume contests. It was my magnum opus and I will never be able to top the awesomeness that was that costume. It made for a very polarizing night. Here's a picture of me and the runner up:

http://picasaweb.google.com/baboocole/Halloween2008#5264611177954320338

Posted by: baboocole at October 27, 2010 11:39 AM

"scary clown whore"

I don't know about anyone else, but I think I've found my costume for next year!!

Posted by: That's awesome at October 27, 2010 11:41 AM

I went to Catholic grade school. The school allowed only the first graders to dress up and the first graders paraded around school and over to the nursing home attached to the church. Major caveat, first graders had to dress up as saints. My mother certainly appreciated having to come up with a St. Catherine of Siena costume in addition to the Ninja Turtle costume I wanted to wear that night.

Posted by: cate at October 27, 2010 11:41 AM

@baboocole, that is SPECTACULAR!!! I was also Sarah Palin in 2008. The best part was some little girl came trick-or-treating at the party I was at and SHE was Sarah Palin, too. But she was with her mom and they were 100% serious about it....I tormented them mercilessly.

Posted by: dammitjanet at October 27, 2010 11:56 AM

When we were about 10-years-old my friend and I decided to go as flowers. Doesn't seem so bad until you realize we thought wearing ballet tutus on our heads (the petals) would achieve the proper effect. It didn't. No one knew what we were. We also wore paper streamers on our bodies (the leaves). Our costumes disintegrated througout the night and the next spring, when the snow melted we found bits of green streamer paper all over the neighbourhood. Ahh, those were the days, when it still snowed in October.

Second worst Halloween was actually a perfectly good costume: Anne of Green Gables. The only problem is that I was about 14-years-old and was nearly 5'10" so people thought I was an adult still trick-or-treating. Quite humiliating.

My brother actually did keep on trick-or-treating well until adulthood. He and his friends wore the same costume every year: An elephant made out of a grey blanket thrown over a sled. (With head made out of duct tape.) Since no one was visible under the sled, no one knew how old the people inside it were. Although, when you wear the same thing year after year, your neighbours do tend to catch on. Eventually they decided to patrol the neighbourhood in the elephant giving out candy rather than taking it.

Posted by: Nique at October 27, 2010 11:57 AM

"Halloween exists so you can put on an awesomely obscure costume and then find those who get it. They are your people. "

Truer words were never spoken. I dressed as Dr. Horrible one year, no one got it. It made me sad.

Posted by: Petrie at October 27, 2010 12:07 PM

"In 7th grade I went as a geisha. I was also fat and it was my first foray into heavy makeup. I looked like a culturally insensitive transvestite."

Erin S., I am crying with laughter.

Posted by: samantha t at October 27, 2010 12:08 PM

Regarding horrible Halloween stories, anyone else in here tricking treating in Minnesota back in 1991. That was a bitch of a year. I had an adorable princess costume that was covered up by layers and layer of snowpants, hats and gloves.

Posted by: Petrie at October 27, 2010 12:09 PM

dammitjanet:

I was shocked that I did not see any other Sarah Palin's that year, especially since Madison is such a liberal city. I was also surprised by how many people I genuinely offended with my costume. Damn conservatives can't take a jokey death threat.

Posted by: baboocole at October 27, 2010 12:35 PM

When I was about 8, I discovered the pun. I independently came up with the idea of the cereal killer costume. It was awesome. I created fake wanted posters for myself that I wore made out of the lettering on cereal boxes. I also carried around a box of count chocula that I had stabbed through with a giant knife.

I recognize that people may not immediately figure out what I was supposed to be. But, when I tell you, CEREAL killer...it really isn't that hard to figure out. Unfortunately for me, I lived in indiana. And in my part of indiana, no-one seemed to understood what a pun is. On that day, I told my mother that people in Indiana were "dumb dumb heads" and that I would move somewhere smarter. This then became a family inside-joke, where I would have to run my costume through the dumb-dumb test.

9 years later my mother started trying to sell me on going to a state school. We started getting into a legitimate argument over it and I responded as a mature, elitist bastard ought to by shouting that I do not want to go to college with a bunch of DUMB DUMB HEADS.

In the end, I escaped to the east coast and thank the FSM each halloween that my clever costumes will be recognized by at least a handful of people.

Posted by: "luker" the barbarian at October 27, 2010 1:03 PM

@ "luker" the barbarian & baboocole...go back and read my comments.

I live in south-east Indiana. That should explain pretty much everything.

They are a bunch of DUMB DUMB HEADS.

New license plate slogan: Hoosier daddy? Some DUMB DUMB HEAD

Posted by: dammitjanet at October 27, 2010 1:42 PM

I had no imagination at all, so little I couldn't even come up with a BAD costume. I was a boring Prairie Girl for like 5 years in a row. I had a dress, an apron and a bonnet. I was all set. What lame kid I was.

Posted by: Lee at October 27, 2010 2:21 PM

My mom likes to sew, so I've gotten the chance to get some pretty sweet costumes. I dressed up as Rose from Titanic in 97, and last year she made me a spot on Jem costume, which was awesome.

In reference to the diversion, though, one year I found this awesome plaid skirt at a thrift store and decided to dress up as a Heather. I got a blazer and blouse and gave myself big hair and carried around a croquet mallet, and half the people at my party still didn't get it. Sad.

Posted by: Kristobel at October 27, 2010 4:20 PM

damnitjanet Your story was fantastic. +1000 points, though, for trying that it indiana!

Posted by: "luker" the barbarian at October 27, 2010 4:22 PM

And that is how you do NOT use italics. Or the English language. Fail.

Posted by: "luker" the barbarian at October 27, 2010 4:48 PM

I went as a joint to a costume party about 5 years ago. It was basically a white sheet with a fluorescent green hood. It went over well until a couple assholes kept trying to light my head on fire.

Posted by: Paultera at October 27, 2010 5:19 PM

Halloweening in Illinois can be iffy weatherwise. Sometimes it's 80 degrees, other times it's 20 below.

One of the particularly chilly years, I bought a unicorn outfit for my daughter that also doubled as a coat. She was nice and toasty and cute.

We were trick or treating with my sister in law who was 8 months pregnant and had a hard time seeing the ground in front of her. Walking up a neighbhors sidewalk, my SIL stepped on the the tail of the little unicorn who promptly did a face plant on the sidewalk.

She was on the sidewalk crying, we were on the sidewalk crying with laughter trying not to pee our pants. Cruel but funny. The image still makes me chuckle.

Posted by: wsapnin at October 27, 2010 6:42 PM

My 13 yr old red-headed daughter is going as Carrie this year. God, I love this kid.

Posted by: wsapnin at October 27, 2010 6:45 PM

I love Halloween! I have a reputation for amazing costumes, the most legendary being my junior year of high school choice: Samara (from The Ring). I slicked my long brown hair with enough gel to keep it looking wet all day, wore a white shirt with long, long sleeves and the underneath froofing slip thing from my mom's wedding dress. I had brown clogs that forced me to shuffle all day. In the parking lot before school my friend Leah met me with her extensive array of stage make-up to add the perfect finishing touch. Not everyone understood who I was, but I was so terrifying, that they cut a wide path around me at all times. One of my friends actually ran off sobbing and refused to return to the same class as me. The mood of each room would palpably shift as I entered (slightly late for effect, of course) kind of like what people describe with ghost encounters. I felt like the queen of the (nether)world. Being evil is EXHILARATING.

When I was 9 or 10 I went as Reese's Peanut Butter Cups. The costume itself - the package of the candy - was awesome. I even crinkled. My downfall came when I decided to write "Reese's" on my face to compliment the ensemble. Because I ALWAYS wanted to wear make-up for Halloween. ALWAYS. Everyone was too busy to help, so I did it myself for the first time, in the bathroom mirror. My sisters let me walk around all night with backwards Reese's scrawled across my face without saying anything. Thanks, guys, really, I appreciated that generous dose of crushing shame at night's end.

In kindergarten I went as a pumpkin. My mom stuffed the costume with so many pillows that I was actually round. I couldn't fit in my desk, wear a seat belt in the car, or put my arms down. I could, however, pull my head inside the costume so that only the stem and hat stuck out. I was also coming down with the flu and thus totally listless. It was the most adorable and pathetic thing ever.

Oh, and in 7th grade, I wanted to be goth for Halloween but waited too long to decide, so the only major chain store in town had sold out of black hair dye and wigs. I, being incredibly resourceful, streaked my hair with black lipstick instead. The greasiness. Oh GOD the unyielding, unwashable greasiness.

Posted by: thenchonto at October 27, 2010 11:34 PM

My brother was Larry the Cucumber from Veggie Tales for Halloween one year... he looked like an overexcited green turd.

Posted by: Spoons at October 27, 2010 11:55 PM