web
counter
 

Should I Stay or Should I Go?

By Tater Barley Banks | Posted Under Comment Diversions | Comments (59)



headfaartbreak.jpg

(Publisher’s Note: Tater has informed me that, following treatment for testicular cancer, he is officially cancer free. Also, minus one testicle. A big congratulations to our Weekend Comment Diversion contributor!)

We never do the hearts and flowers and chocolates crap at the Tater House for Valentine’s Day. Especially the flowers. Bad memories there.

Back in the day when I was dating the future Mrs. Tater, I was seeing another girl at the same time (two-timer, yep, that’s me) but after a couple weeks of this I realized I couldn’t afford them both, so around February I hit on a novel solution: I’d buy a dozen roses and divide them into two bunches of six, and send one bunch to each girl. The one who called to thank me first was in.

The future Mrs. Tater called first.

The other girl never did. I finally called her to ask if she got them and she said, “Oh, yeah, thanks.”

Easiest decision I ever made.

Unfortunately, the dumbest decision I ever made was telling this story to Mrs. Tater; 27 years we’re married and I still have to hear about how cheap I was.

That’s because I’m still … well, I like to think I’ve evolved from miserly to penurious to cheap to frugal. And being so, we don’t do the hearts and flowers and chocolates crap. In fact we generally ignore most of your minor holidays (such as our own birthdays) that were specifically designed by Hallmark and Hershey and FTD to separate you from all your money, $3.95 at a time.

Fortunately, through all this, somehow, for no good reason either of us can think of, we are still (cue the violin music) still very much in love with each other, and I can’t ever see myself with anyone but Mrs. Tater. (Awwwwww……)

Just getting this all up front so you’ll know where I stand on the extremely cruel diversion question I’m about to ask you:

When you wake up tomorrow morning, take a good, hard, serious look across the sheet or the breakfast table or at your S.O.’s picture on your phone — the one he/she sent you of him/her in the shower, doing that special thing you like — and imagine there’s a new federal law in place requiring that on Valentine’s Day you either have to dump your S.O. for good or stay with your S.O. forever. And by “dump” I mean for eternity. And by “forever” I mean for eternity.

So … Love ‘em or leave ‘em? Your call, sweetheart.

Let’s get … um, five breakups and we’ll call it a good day.

TATER BARLEY BANKS is not to be trusted. He probably makes up everything he writes about himself, especially the stuff about living in West Virginia. Don’t be fooled. In truth, he lives in Pajibaland, where he speaks gibberish as , (TCFKAB), spends his time sitting on a park bench, eyeing little girls with bad intent, and is developing a 25-letter alphabet, now that his key doesn’t work. He has no blog, no Facebook page and no MySpace page, so don’t try to find him. If you’re so inclined, you can email Tater.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Katherine Heigl Set to Walk Down the Aisle in "He's the One" | Percy Jackson & The Olympians: The Lightning Thief Review









Comments

SLIM, IS. OUTTA HERE!

/kidding?

Posted by: BarbadoSlim at February 13, 2010 3:41 PM

I can`t possibly imagine being with anyone else so, yeah, I`m keeping her. Now if someone else wishes to partake of our love...

Posted by: admin at February 13, 2010 3:51 PM

So where's the comment diversion for singles?

?

Posted by: Jean at February 13, 2010 3:54 PM

Second on Jean's comment.

Posted by: Puffs253 at February 13, 2010 4:15 PM

When Mrs. Spender was kind enough to accept my proposal some 17 years ago, I considered myself the luckiest man on earth. Still do.
I'll stick with it.

Posted by: Spender at February 13, 2010 4:19 PM

True, it's rather slanted, isn't it? Guy needs to be fired.


Larson always does hers when I'm driving home from work and it's too far gone by the time I get home. Devilish.

Posted by: Jay at February 13, 2010 4:23 PM

Since I'm, what's the phrase ... currently between obsessions, at the moment only my less-better half, temporarially unmated of soul ... this diversion kind of sucks.

How's this? Twice, I've been with someone who, had the little leprechaun of choose for all time popped up with his offer, I'd have said "Yes, and right now." Twice more, could have been. Was growing that way. And I knew with each that it wasn't going to work.

I'm usually immune to Hallmark appreciation day. After this diversion, not so much, so thanks a lot.

Posted by: BierceAmbrose at February 13, 2010 4:49 PM

I believe this question is for singles


Well, no, it's not.

Unless you're being semantical and saying unmarried people are "single".

Posted by: Jay at February 13, 2010 4:53 PM

Hey, I'm all in. Forever and ever, Mr. TWoP. There truly is no one quite as weird as we are and he is the weird-yin to my weird-yang.

Also, he lets me control the money.

We don't bother with V-day on the day. We go out for brunch a few days after on a day off. We're rebels like that.

Congrats ,. Glad you're okay.

Posted by: TWoP_Fan at February 13, 2010 4:58 PM

No SO, yet, so I'm just going to smell my pretty flowers that were sent to help me deal with being in dreary, icy NY, finish filling out my bacon- and sex-filled VD card, await my Super Bouncy Ball, and ignore the question.

Posted by: SaBrina at February 13, 2010 5:14 PM

SaBrina. We might be the same person.

Posted by: DontStopNow at February 13, 2010 5:30 PM

VD card?
Isn't that something you send someone as a reason for breaking up with them?

Posted by: frank (aka frank_247 aka the lone Scotsman) at February 13, 2010 5:44 PM

I'm engaged. So I've made my decision.

(only 6 hours to change mind)

Posted by: superasente at February 13, 2010 5:46 PM

DontStopNow, it's possible that you're one of the manifestations of my schizophrenia. Or that I'm one of your manifestations. Evidence: I am listening to Don't Stop Believing right now.

Posted by: SaBrina at February 13, 2010 5:51 PM

No, a VD card is just a V card with a very special twist.

Posted by: SaBrina at February 13, 2010 5:54 PM

VD isn't just for Valentines Day......

Posted by: frank (aka frank_247 aka the lone Scotsman) at February 13, 2010 5:57 PM

So where's the comment diversion for singles?

Tallmingling.com. Don't you pay attention to Spambot?


Posted by: admin at February 13, 2010 5:58 PM

Yeah, I'm keeping her. She laughs really hard at my stupid jokes, does little dances in the kitchen, and she's just generally awesome.
Last week she literally brought me breakfast in bed. As in, I was dead asleep and she nudged me with a plate and said "Wake up and eat this." So I did. And then she took my plate and I fell back asleep.
Plus, I can't wait to see her when she's old. That's gonna be one foul-mouthed old broad. She won't just tell kids to get off her lawn, she'll call them little cocksuckers, throw dog poo at them, and threaten to beat them with her walker. It will be awesome.

Posted by: MyySharona at February 13, 2010 5:59 PM

In three weeks' time we will have been together seventeen years. I remember how, in early March seventeen years ago, I asked him to a dinner of (Pizza Hut) pizza and red wine. I remember it rained like holy hell that night, like the end of the world. I remember it was a Thursday night, and I called in from work for Friday, and he went in and taught his Friday class (he was a TA) and then came back. And we stayed together four straight days and nights. And that was it.

Two years after that we moved in together. Eight years after that he finally remembered we weren't actually married and proposed. In 2003 we got spliced.

You know that tired old phrase, "the best thing that ever happened to me"? The man is the best thing that ever happened to me in my entire fucking life.

I will kill anyone who tries to take him away from me.

Posted by: Jerce at February 13, 2010 6:10 PM

Oh, I forgot to congratulate ole Uni-Ball on being cancer-free! Really, I am happy for you, and glad to know you'll be around to divert us.

...If you're having trouble walking, maybe you could carry a bunch of fishing weights in your pocket on the, um, "light" side. For balance.

Posted by: Jerce at February 13, 2010 6:14 PM

Too hard to retrain a new one. OK, this one is not really well-trained but he has a fabulous smell and makes really good babies with me. So, a keeper. Now if I could just get his politics a little more in line with mine....

Posted by: lainiefig at February 13, 2010 6:19 PM

I just did my 'woot! Tater beat the cancer!' dance. It was very dramatic, especially when I stood on the cat. He was put out, so I picked him up and explained that Tater's cancer free now, and we should celebrate.
Turns out, cats don't much give a fuck about cancer. You stand on their tail, they'll just want to scratch your eyes out. Little furry arseholes.

As for the ITGeek? I'll stay. Even the Spambots would agree there's no chance I'd ever find somebody better suited for me.

Posted by: ScienceGeek at February 13, 2010 6:29 PM

Ditch. I'm actually in the process of figuring out an exit strategy. Getting a new job in the city and slowly taking my things from his house. Kind of like Tim Robbins in Shawshank, I've been slowly chipping away at the wall until the time I steal away in the middle of the night.

Posted by: Porkchop at February 13, 2010 6:30 PM

When I said that I love him I meant that I love him foreevvvvverrrr...(dun dun duh)...And I'm gonna keep on lovin' him, cuz it's the only thing I wanna dooo...

For reals, though. The Husband and I have been together 10 years in May and married 5 years in June. We finish each others sentences, usually think of the same things at the same time, and we made one hella gorgeous little girl (so far). At the end of the day, I wouldn't want to be without him.
/end sappy explanation

Posted by: Pinky McLadybits at February 13, 2010 6:40 PM

Also, Tyler, congrats and future good health.

Posted by: frank (aka frank_247 aka the lone Scotsman) at February 13, 2010 7:53 PM

What a strange diversion- Not really for the unattached people, not really for those of us who've already made that choice, so...casual daters?

Hijack: Best Valentine's Day tradition (besides sex)
-- Mr. Fungus and I always go through our most fabulous cookbooks (the ones you get for Christmas from people you don't know well that double as coffee table books) and pick out a super-complicated recipe, then spend all day in the kitchen, making a 4-course meal.
--Runner-up: Dan Savage's ceremonial memento-burning. I just think it's a great idea.

Posted by: Phaeolus at February 13, 2010 8:04 PM

I'd have to be a flaming fucking idiot to dump Mr. Snuggie. He's super cute, his personality fits me perfectly, he gets me and/or tolerates me (I think it's a combo deal), he's incredibly devoted, hard-working, interesting, you know what? I don't care how stupid or corny it sounds: he's just my best fucking friend ever. I truly completely enjoy his company. Long after our bits stop working, long after we've both lost our stunning good looks, I'm still going to enjoy just hanging out with his ass, making stupid jokes, watching kung fu and sci-fi movies with him, making him his favorite omelette, taking walks, getting a puppy to be our surrogate child, gossiping about our actual child, dangling grandbabies off our knees, whatever. He's my man.

Posted by: Snuggiepants the Deathbringer at February 13, 2010 8:09 PM

I couldn't be Mrs Smith without Mr Smith, so I guess we're on for eternity. I'm cool with that.

Posted by: Mrs smith at February 13, 2010 9:06 PM

Simple. Ditch her now, get back together on the 15th. According to your law this is only on Valentine's Day. I need more time!

Caveat? Caveat emptor, motherfuckers.

Posted by: pissant at February 13, 2010 9:15 PM

yeah, I'm in the keep him forever camp. He loves me for exactly who I am and he wouldn't change anything about me, not even when I yell at him and spend an entire day mad at him 'cause he was mean to me in a dream. And vicey-versey: I wouldn't change a damn thing about him, not even that he stills puts the dishes away in the wrong places after 14 years because he just doesn't care where they go. He even loves me even though I don't believe in marriage (for me) or Valentine's Day. Though I did get him a chocolate marshmallow heart.

"Caveat emptor, motherfuckers" is my new motto.

Posted by: Anna von Beaverpuppet at February 13, 2010 9:21 PM

Oh, and I said it on one of the other threads, but YAY for cancer-free bucdaddy!!

Posted by: Anna von Beaverpuppet at February 13, 2010 9:25 PM

Oh, I think I'll keep him around--he's funny, kind of cute, and almost disconcertingly blind to my faults. And I'm not yet sick of him after almost 14 years together.

I'll overlook the fact that he once gave me a bottle of lock de-icer (and nothing else) for Valentine's Day. Hey, ,, feel free to use that next time Mrs. Tater calls you cheap: "Why darling, there are romance-starved girls in Canada who'd kill for a half dozen roses, you know!"

Oh, and way to kick cancer in the nards, dude--delighted to hear it!

Posted by: meaux at February 13, 2010 9:26 PM

For me I always to more stock in "I tolerate you" than "I love you". Stay with me.

I would argue that it's it's easy to fall in love someone. It's not a challenge to love the good qualities in someone, and let's be honest, when we're first seeing someone we make stronger efforts to show those parts off. As we do the parts of us we aren't so proud of (even if we don't realize it).

The real trick is for someone to look at and past all the imperfections we all try to hide and decide that those things really aren't all that bad. They are not the dealbreakers we secretly fear but just minor flaws to be accepted.

So does it mean more to love someone because of their good points, or better to see them as great despite the bad ones?

I'd have more confidence that someone has seen me at my worst, warts and all and still thinks I'm special (and I for them) then to be in constant fear of being discovered for who I really might be and keeping a facade up.

That's not to say I would encourage incivility or carelessness, but really if you're not at the "open fart" stage of your relationship, if your closet has more in it that your bad fashion choices, and if they are constantly trying to improve on you because who you are needs fixing- you're not at that stage yet.

So I sit here now and say- "Babe, I am thankful you tolerate me as you do. Because God knows there are some days I can't. And for that I love you." Oh and...I drank all the milk and put the carton back in the fridge again. Honestly I think it's a sickness. I'll go to the store now.

Posted by: bleujayone at February 13, 2010 9:28 PM

@admin: Oh, now you make the offer. Prick.

Posted by: Tracer Bullet at February 13, 2010 10:18 PM

I'm not sure I like this diversion. I'm leaning towards the dump. Great person but I COULD NOT do forever.

So what do I do now??

Posted by: Umm at February 13, 2010 11:10 PM

Definitely stay. Even though I fought with Mrs Ed yesterday, this morning she woke me up with a toe-curling, sweaty, frantic angerfuck - then once business was done, whispered "Happy Valentine's Day...

...prick."

Perfect woman.

Posted by: Ed at February 13, 2010 11:35 PM

Thanks for the well-wishes, y'all. Just to fill in the details: After I had the ballectomy back in December, I had a full-body scan to see if the bastard showed up any place else, and the lymph nodes in my chest lit up. On Friday I had a biopsy done to see what was in there. I had heard everything from "95 percent likely it's cancer" to "eh, could be a lot of things that aren't bad."

Well, the preliminary test results show whatever it is, it appears to be benign. They haven't run the full lab test yet but it appears I have managed to avoid chemo (a full round anyway, I might still end up doing a little chemo light just to be on the safe side) and can get on with my life.

Oh, and the diversion most certainly is for married people, too. For anyone who might be in a bad relationship, I thought maybe it would give you the final little push you need to evaluate your situation and get out if you need to.

On the plus side, I'm enjoying reading about how happy so many of you are with your soul mates, and why you get along so well. Bravo!

(You lonely and wretched and miserable single folks, you have had and will have plenty of other opportunities to ramble on about your miserable lonely wretched single lives. It's Valentine's Day weekend, after all. You'll get your chance on .. um, St. Patrick's Day, when you should be good and drunk, too, and ready for a good self-pitying wallow.)

Posted by: , at February 13, 2010 11:48 PM

I knew my husband was the one when I contemplated 60 years of being with him (my grandparents did it, why can't we?), and I was psyched!

20 years later, I still am.


Here's to the next 40.

Posted by: mswas at February 14, 2010 12:02 AM

With her, I think I'd keep.
She smells like ham.

Posted by: Jim Doggie at February 14, 2010 12:22 AM

After some serious deliberation, I've decided that I'd stay with my S.O. forever.
I just don't think I could live without my right hand, and I know it couldn't do much without me. I mean, we're so in synch. Just look at us now, we're helping each other finish this sentence.

Posted by: Peyton Caldrich at February 14, 2010 12:24 AM

#1. Tater, HUZZAH on the cancer news! Not so much on the minus one testicle, though, but a small price to pay for being free of neoplasms.

#2. S.O. stays or goes, huh? I made that decision after 6 months of deliberation way back in 2003. To this day, I still celebrate June 12th.

I also still refer to The Bride as "The Evil Succubus" and to my divorce as an "exorcism."

Posted by: The Wanderer at February 14, 2010 12:26 AM

Well I guess they're not gonna fire you yet.

Posted by: Jay at February 14, 2010 1:04 AM

Hells yeah on still being alive.

Hells yeah to keeping wifey around - she's my game, set and match.

And admin, don't you think cougarlife.com would be more appropriate around here?

Yeah. I said it. Think of it as a compliment.

Posted by: Xtreme at February 14, 2010 1:11 AM

I have the most glorious man I have ever known in my life right now. He makes me happier than I have been in possibly ever, and I am a better person just for knowing him. At this early stage of the game, if I were given the opportunity to have him and keep him forever, I would have to say Fuck and Yes.

Posted by: Lindsey with an 'e' at February 14, 2010 2:29 AM

Sorry to disappoint, but this boyfriend is my favorite so far, so, given the choice, he's a keeper.

Oh, ew. I just gagged. (You might have guessed that we're not one of those couples. We're more "awesome" than "cute.")

Posted by: Nicole at February 14, 2010 2:40 AM

Wait, I resent this diversion. Firs you alienate a good chunk of folks, collect the predictable yes-I-keep answers (cuz given that choice, you have to be in REALLY messed up relationship to chose dump) that further alienate unattached by rubbing it in and then assume that only thing unattached people can contribute is self-pitying wallows? We can be pretty happy being single you know? It is better than having a bad relationship and- FYI - this will not give them a push they need. Instead it gives them more reason to justify their relationships ("Shit, I mean there's many thing I hate about this SO but much better than being miserable single people") It would be the worst law ever if it gives the person only one year or less to decide that. It will get people marry and divorce by much quicker disastrous rate.

As for my Valentine Tradition, I am going to the Great San Francisco Pillow Fight again this year. I will pounce anyone who would deem it a pathetic and I won't marry anyone who can't enjoy it. so there.

Posted by: yocean at February 14, 2010 2:56 AM

Well, keep him, I guess, since apparently he proposed to me a few days ago and apparently I said yes (I was drunk so I have no recollection of any of this but sure! why not). Also, apparently I somehow managed to slur out, "Well, where the hell's my ring then?" to which he answered, "I already got you one!" I then supposedly replied in a sad voice, "Yeah... but this one is made of wood and cost ten dollars." COME ON it's a cute story.

Posted by: bat at February 14, 2010 9:23 AM

As I'm single for this Valentine's Day, you can all bite me. Not that I'm bitter. I'll just start a Valentine's tradition of curling up in the fetal position in the shower until the hot water runs out.

Posted by: Craig at February 14, 2010 10:51 AM

Posted by: L.O.V.E. at February 14, 2010 11:17 AM

I'm gonna have to go out on a limb here and say, GO. I have no problems with the girl, but we've only been going out a couple weeks, and I am in no way ready to STAY. Therefor, I would have to get the fuck out by default. Hooray for being a cold, heartless bastard!

P.S. Hooray for being cancer-free, Tater!

Posted by: the_wakeful at February 14, 2010 3:01 PM

That's what Daddy likes to hear, baby. Now how about you get me a beer and go polish the Camaro?

Posted by: LWA'e's PIB at February 14, 2010 7:26 PM


Anthem for the as yet un-emblissed (via BoingBoing):

http://www.boingboing.net/2010/02/14/for-valentines-a-mus.html

So, in support of the sweetness and light agenda, off the top of my head five couples, all dear friends of mine, are amazing together & I can't imagine them otherwise. Make that six couples. One got married all over again on their 20th anniversary. The guy's idea, because he "didn't completely understand what it meant" the first time around.

OTOH before the ceremony (II), a few of us were discussing whether arch-daemons could appropriately use diminutive nicknames among themselves. In front of the Wesleyan minister.

He had it coming, but that's another story.

Posted by: BierceAmbrose at February 14, 2010 7:39 PM

I came to this really late, obviously, but I just wanted to share my answer to this question:

I asked her to marry me. And she said yes!

I thought if anyone should know, the Pajibans should.

Posted by: ChristianH at February 15, 2010 11:08 AM

Yea Christian! Congrats!

Posted by: Lindsey with an 'e' at February 15, 2010 12:00 PM

Thanks!

Posted by: ChristianH at February 15, 2010 12:24 PM

Well, I can't look at him over the breakfast table because there's an ocean between us, but given that we've agreed to a divorce, I'd say I fall into the "go" category.

Posted by: Elfrieda at February 15, 2010 12:26 PM

Weird comment diversion, but whatever, sappy married people are adorable.
I currently love Singles Awareness Day. It's like another Thanksgiving, because think of all the dating bs you don't have to deal with every day! Today, I did not find out that the guy I'm dating is obsessed with Dane Cook quotes! Today, I did not discover that the guy I'm dating thinks reading is a 'waste of time'! Today, the guy I'm dating did not express a desire to re-watch Meet the Fockers! Today, no one burped, blew it in my direction, and thought it was hilarious! Today, I didn't have to figure out how to break up with someone without telling them it wasn't me, it was totally them!
Being single is awesome.
Maybe in another few years it'll make me depressed because I'll be 'old' and alone, and at the rate they're going every single person I have ever met in my life will be married, but I doubt it. If I'm single, I enjoy it, if I'm in a relationship, it's a lot more work but I enjoy it, too. Mostly.
Diversion suggestion for the singles who walk among us: What weird traits are must-haves in your hypothetical future SOs? For example, mine must be obsessed with books, and be amenable to building a giant treehouse in our future hypothetical backyard, or it is just not gonna work out.

Posted by: BiblioGeek at February 17, 2010 1:07 AM

YAY, COMMAndo!!!!! Congrats on being cancer-free!!! Here's to you STAYING THAT WAY!! We love you, man!!!

Posted by: Jelinas at February 17, 2010 4:58 PM

I took away a good deal great points from this post and will definitely save it in my bookmarks. Thanks for the effort you took to elaborate on this subject so throroughly. I look forward to future posts.

Posted by: Gabriel Hillis at January 31, 2011 1:22 PM