web
counter
 

Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell by Susanna Clarke

By Tracy | Posted Under Book Reviews | Comments (38)



jonathan-strange-mr-norrell.jpg

I had put off reading this book for years, and I’m not sure why. It’s not like long books are scary to me, and reviews likened the book to Dickens and Austen, who are two of my faves (well, Austen is. Dickens is a bit of a slog). My brother-in-law had read it a few years ago, and kept asking me if I had. It was getting embarrassing, so I figured I’d better get to it, but started reading with trepidation. Once I started, I had to force myself to put it down. Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell is long and rambling, and the tone and style change throughout the book, but it all works and melds together to form a brilliant story that drew me in and so involved me in the characters’ lives that I would welcome a sequel.

Too much happens in Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell to even begin to summarize the story. So, in the words of Inigo Montoya, let me sum up. In York, there is a society of gentlemen magicians who study, but do not practice, magic. Then, Mr. Norrell shows up, and rocks some real magic by making all the statues in the York cathedral talk. And, boy, do they have some stories. Mr. Norrell makes the York magicians sign a contract to never practice magic, and he starts buying up all of the magic books in England.

He moves to London, and performs some very special magic to save the life of Lady Pole, but he enlists the help of a faerie gentleman, who exacts a terrible price. Not from Mr. Norrell, but from Lady Pole. Norrell grants the faerie half Lady Pole’s life, not realizing that it was going to be the night-time half. Every day. She is whisked off to faerie every night, and spends her days in kind of an exhausted fugue state. And whenever she tries to tell someone about what’s happening, she starts speaking nonsense. She despises Mr. Norrell for doing this to her. Lord Pole’s valet gets sucked into this as well, because the faerie man takes a liking to him.

Jonathan Strange decides he wants to become a magician, and becomes Mr. Norrell’s pupil. They work together to bring magic back to England, but they have differing ideas of what it means to be a magician. After they part ways, Strange goes to the continent to help with the war against France, and begins to publicly question Norrell upon his return.

There is so much more in this novel, including John Uskglass, Strange’s wife, Italy, eternal darkness, escapes from faerie, and a new king of faerie. All I can say is that if you have been thinking about reading this book and putting it off, don’t do what I did. I’m looking forward to next year, when I can read it again.

This review is part of the Cannonball Read series. For more of Tracey’s reviews, check out her blog, The Land of Sidewalks and Curbs.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



Blog Trends from My Bunk 12/15/09 | Prince of Persia Behind the Scenes









Comments

I love this book! There is a chapter in which Jonathan Strange is experimenting and he starts to see pineapples everywhere. I'm not sure what it is about that chapter, but everytime I read it I have an intense bout of the giggles.

Posted by: Scully at December 16, 2009 8:49 AM

Thank you for mentioning this book! I've been pushing it on people for years and only one other person has actually taken my advice, and she ended up loving it. I think a lot of people are intimidated by the size or the fact that to truly experience it you have to read footnotes (oh noes!). Honestly, this is one of the best 'fantasy' books I've ever read.

Posted by: Mr. Teatime at December 16, 2009 8:50 AM

I tried to start this book but didn't continue for some reason. I regularly read 800+ page books, so size isn't important (hee hee!). I'm not a big fan of magic or stories about it which probably had something to do with it. In other words, I have nothing to say.

Posted by: Kballs at December 16, 2009 9:00 AM

I tried to get my mom to read this and she just couldn't get into it, which perplexed the hell out of me. Out of literally every book I've ever read, this is the one I thought she'd enjoy. She only got through about two hundred pages.

I still think it's great, though. Arguably the best fantasy novel I've ever read, though it's one of those works where just calling it "fantasy" seems limiting. (Sort of like calling Jaws "horror.")

Posted by: Todd at December 16, 2009 9:07 AM

Have tried to read this book several times but always give up - doesn't catch my fancy.

to each is own I guess...

Posted by: Ari at December 16, 2009 9:08 AM

Love this book. Kudos to you for including it in your Cannonball Read!

Posted by: mswas at December 16, 2009 9:30 AM

I gave up on it, too. I didn't dislike it while I was reading it, but every time I'd put it down, I'd find myself dreading picking it up again. So it sits on the "to trade or donate" shelf, and I end up with the vague feeling that I should have stuck it out.

Posted by: Wednesday at December 16, 2009 9:32 AM

This is one of those books I keep hearing about but never really had too much interest in. I didn't even know it was a fantasy novel - I think I had gathered that there were magicians but I guess I'd just pictured something about competing stage magicians like "The Prestige" with lots of fun foot notes.
Might actually have to buy it next time I see it in the store now(one more month before I can go to Barnes and Noble again!)

Posted by: Jen K at December 16, 2009 9:39 AM

Loved this book! Recommended it to everyone because it was so much fun and weird and long and windy and spooky and a blast! I don't read much fantasy, but I didn't want to put it down. I'd love a sequel, if it read the same weird way, rambly with things just suddenly happening and magic everywhere. And I know it was long, but I still wanted more.

Posted by: Chickaboom at December 16, 2009 9:43 AM

I ALMOST gave up on this book. I found that if you stuck with it, it kept getting better and better. The first third is like a slow Jane Austen Novel. The second third starts picking up a bit. The third third just starts running and I couldn't put it down.

True story. I was reading the last few chapters one night and I kept telling myself, "Oh, just one more chapter." Finally, I finished it about 2 in the morning. I turned out the lights and went into my bedroom, trying not to wake my husband. There's enough light from the bathroom windows and the security light reflected in my bedroom mirrow to guide my way.

Now, I always keep my walk in closet door closed. So I walk in (in the dark) and I'm feeling my way towards the closet door so I can get undressed in the closet and not wake my husband. I couldn't find it and suddenly everything went pitch black. I spun around with my arms out to feel in all directions and there was nothing. I WAS IN THE CONE OF DARKNESS. AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!

I had to yell to wake hubby and have him turn on a light. Apparently he had left the closet door open so the noise of me opening it wouldn't wake him. Because I thought it was closed, I had walked right into the closet which blocked out all the faint light from the windows and security light. When I spun around, amazingingly I missed touching everything in the closet. I don't know how I mananged that, as it's not that big a closet. Anyway, it freaked my shit out. Those of you who finished the book understand of which I speak.

Posted by: BWeaves at December 16, 2009 9:55 AM

Oh yeah, I forgot about all the fake footnotes. They were fun to read as a diversion.

Posted by: BWeaves at December 16, 2009 10:04 AM

I've heard good things and it looks interesting but I haven't made the commitment to read it yet.

I must say I'm curious about the pineapples...

Posted by: Yossarian at December 16, 2009 10:33 AM

I have this book sitting on my shelf and have not read it yet. I don't know why either. I'm definitely not opposed to long books. I'm in the middle of reading a Stephen King book right now, but maybe I'll start this book after.

Posted by: Peanut_Butter_And_James at December 16, 2009 11:52 AM

I'm wondering why this seems to have the exact same cover as my edition of Good Omens...

Also, very nice review. I might give this a chance.

Posted by: figgy at December 16, 2009 11:53 AM

Sidhe is pronounced She-de.
It's an Irish word, referring to the "Good Folk" formerly the Tuatha de Danan, The People Of Dana, (now fairies to the rest of you)...
one of the first wave of pre-Celtic settlers in Ireland, ousting, if I recall, the Milesians, as partly detailed in the Book of Invasions. The Tuattha de Danan later became the Sidhe when they later went "under the ground" after losing their own battles and also spawning the festival of Samhain, (Halloween) which is one of the 2 days a year they are above ground, travelling from one part of their kingdom to another, through fairy-rings (actually old forts).
Used here by Susanna Clarke is a sort of William Shakespeare Mid-Summers Night Dream kind of way.
I like the book, but when I later heard the audiobook version the constant mispronunciation of this drove me mad.

Posted by: Donalb at December 16, 2009 12:13 PM

This book is worth getting thru despite its length and flowery style. Clarke builds some interesting characters and the novel has a very dark tone overall.. I too would like to see a sequel.

Posted by: stryker1121 at December 16, 2009 1:17 PM

I keep seeing this on must read lists etc. but have been totally intimidated by the size of the book. I guess I'm gonna have to get over that seeing as I've read Dickens and Austen and thoroughly enjoyed them. Thanks for the review.

mmmmmm, grilled pineapple........

Posted by: Fyrehaar at December 16, 2009 1:18 PM

One of the richest, most brilliant, most engrossing (and longest) books i've ever read. I'm now going to read it again. Thanks for the reminder, Tracy.

Posted by: Martin at December 16, 2009 2:08 PM

I wondered, when I first started reading the book, whether I would finish it. It's long, and at times it drags. What's amazing is that it's a debut novel. What editor green-lit a first novel this long? Ballsy.

In the end, it's totally worth the effort. An interesting and at times new approach to the world of magic.

Posted by: Brenton at December 16, 2009 2:59 PM

Loved it. While initially wary by the book's rambling sprawl, I quickly found myself too engrossed in the rich and rewarding story to care anymore.

Posted by: humperdinck at December 16, 2009 3:50 PM

Donalb. I though that "Sidhe" was pronounced like "shee." Hence why Bean Sidhe became anglicized to banshee. Am I wrong?

Posted by: Rowen at December 16, 2009 6:07 PM

Ohh, yay! I'm on it, I'm on it! I've been reading it for two weeks now, only 300 pages to go! (What a tome, really. The script is so small and the paper so thin...)
*SPOILERS*
Jonathan just summoned that goddamn fairy in Italy. The pineapple-bit was hilarious.
Did anyone else cry when Arabella died? I totally didn't see that coming and just shed a tear of shock. I didn't *want* to believe it for another five pages, either.

I'll be very proud of myself when I'm through with it; and I feel richer already. Love it.

Posted by: Padame at December 16, 2009 6:17 PM

Rowen: I thought the same (minus the Banshee reasoning).

Posted by: Brenton at December 16, 2009 10:16 PM

I ALMOST gave up on this book. I found that if you stuck with it, it kept getting better and better. The first third is like a slow Jane Austen Novel. The second third starts picking up a bit. The third third just starts running and I couldn't put it down.

That's it in a nutshell.
It goes from Jane Austen to Neil Gaiman.

BTW, great story about your scare....

Posted by: jules at December 16, 2009 10:30 PM

For those of you still daunted - Susanna Clarke also wrote a book of short stories that captures a little bit of everything in the Big Book. It is called "The Ladies of Grace Adieu" and may spark the mood to try the lengthier one. Long live the Raven King!

Posted by: Trixie at December 17, 2009 2:40 AM

Loved the review, and you and I share the same view of Austen and Dickens! Can't wait to read this book.

Posted by: Jelinas at December 17, 2009 4:53 AM

Best book I read this year. I read her book of short stories, too, because I couldn't get enough. Though I must say, when you run out of words to read, and you have to go back to reading another book, the depression is severe. Medicate. Immediately.

Posted by: Shelley at December 17, 2009 11:39 AM

LOVE THIS BOOK.
Devoured it.

Clarke did write a sort of companion book: The Ladies of Grace Adieu and Other Stories. It's a collection of short stories in the same universe and mostly about the women of magic.

Also: she's writing a sequel that takes place with characters that are "a bit lower down the social scale." DOES THIS MEAN WE GET MORE CHLDERMASS? I will be a happy man.
I'm guessing Vinculus will be there too though.

Posted by: Saint Saturn Sunshine at December 17, 2009 11:56 AM

This is easily one of my all-time favorite books. I reread it every year. I love everything about it, especially the rambling, fake-historic footnotes and spooky atmosphere. It completely sucks you in and you start to believe the parallel-universe history. I read somewhere that it took Susanna Clarke ten years to write it, and I believe it.

Posted by: kate at December 17, 2009 9:46 PM

No non-fiction book has ever used footnotes as amazingly well as Dr. Strange and Mr. Norrel. They have set the bar for footnotes. If only all footnotes were as great as Susanna Clarke's!

Posted by: Gigi at December 17, 2009 10:29 PM

This book stared at me for the longest time from my local bookstore's shelf. Big, black, bird on cover--what the hell is this book? Why am I so drawn to it, yet repulsed at the same time?

Broke down, bought it, pretty much LIVED this book for about 4 days. Started off sorta slow, but once I got into it, I got INTO it.

Brilliant writing, deep storytelling, very funny and very tragic in so many ways.

My #1 desert island book.

Posted by: Lisa at December 26, 2009 5:34 AM

Dickens? A bit of a slog? Every inch of my body and mind disagrees with that! Charles Dickens is by far the greatest writer ever to put pen to paper over 170 years of readers is the proof.

:) but other than that fully enjoyable article.

Posted by: deanjwilliams at December 30, 2009 12:47 PM

This is one of the finest books I have ever read. It touched me deeply. I laughed out loud, I was entranced- I felt it's magic. This novel is transformational.

Posted by: Michael Christensen at January 8, 2010 11:39 PM

I went to a restaurant that serves "breakfast at any time". So I ordered French Toast during the Renaissance.

Posted by: find gyms at March 5, 2011 11:56 PM

Hey! I was searching on google for sites smiliar to your and luckly fund your site and I'm already a fan! keep up the good work.Please add more new posts daily, because I will definitely come back

Posted by: Jason Romero at March 6, 2011 3:12 PM

So greate ! I like your site , I'll come back !

Posted by: Adalberto Mitsakos at March 10, 2011 5:17 PM

Would you be fascinated with exchanging hyperlinks?

Posted by: Cardigan for Men at March 16, 2011 11:35 AM

*After study a few of the blog posts on your website now, and I truly like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and will be checking back soon. Pls check out my web site as well and let me know what you think.

Posted by: Carroll B. hassimp at March 21, 2011 3:10 PM