web
counter
 

The Truth About Celia by Kevin Brockmeier

By MelBivDevoe | Posted Under Book Reviews | Comments (15)



153321__celia_l.jpg

I am a huge fan of Brockmeier. I read his novel A Brief History of the Dead a few years ago, and have been hooked ever since. He’s a gifted writer who draws you in with his vivid descriptions and makes you truly care about his characters. His books are the type that you find difficult to put down — you want to stay in his worlds and find out what happens next.

The Truth About Celia is one of the most beautiful and sorrowful novels I’ve ever read. It’s also a book within a book — it’s a collection of short stories written by a fictional author named Christopher Brooks. Christopher is a successful science fiction author who lives with his wife Janet and seven-year-old daughter Celia. One day, while he is giving a tour of their historical home, Celia, who was playing in their backyard, simply vanishes. Poof. Gone without a sound or trace.

The novel is Christopher’s first work since Celia’s disappearance. In the seven years after, he has written several short stories that all revolve around that tragedy. One story recounts the events of that fateful day over and over, as if by doing so Christopher could find a new piece to the puzzle that explains what happened. Another story starts with one character and moves through the town, bouncing from person to person, showing how they have all been affected by Celia’s disappearance, and ending in a ceremony being held by the townspeople to honor her memory. There are several pieces of fiction that try to give Celia a happy ending — in one, she has fallen into a different world; in another, she’s grown up and is raising a son who wants to become a magician.

The novel is Christopher’s way of coping with their loss. It’s a horrible tragedy — I can’t think of anything worse than simply losing someone. Even when you lose a loved one to death, there is a sense of finality — they’ve passed on and are at rest. With Celia, Christopher and Janet have no idea if she’s dead or alive, if she’s being tortured somewhere, if she’s scared and missing her family. Christopher in particular has been unable to move on since that day, and has spent his time writing not only about that day but trying to give Celia’s story an ending, in order to give himself one as well.

Like I said, the book is absolutely heartbreaking. But it is also one of the most beautifully written novels I’ve ever had the pleasure of reading, and so I wholly recommend it.

This review is part of the Cannonball Read series. For more of MelBivDevoe’s reviews, check out her blog, Impudent Strumpet.










Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



This One's for the Doctor Who/John Barrowman Fans | Doo eee Ooooooo | Trailer: Tangled | Disney's Newest Fairy Tale Is Decidedly Not Grimm









Comments

I will definitely check this out, great review!

Posted by: Nieve 'The Threadkiller Queen' at June 23, 2010 8:41 AM

GAH! I can't even imagine...

Posted by: admin at June 23, 2010 8:54 AM

This sounds fantastic, thanks for the recommendation!

I haven't been reading much these days, but I think it's simply for lack of knowing good current authors who grip in the ways I love. Fantasy/science fiction that doesn't fit the mold, aka speculative fiction, and melancholy both hook me. Harlan Ellison (!!!!!!!!) and Neil Gaiman (non children's books) are some all time favorites.

Posted by: Bonnye at June 23, 2010 9:04 AM

I wish I could read this, but as this is my biggest fear I will NEVER read it. Great review though.

Posted by: karen at June 23, 2010 9:17 AM

It sounds fascinating, but I'm afraid I just don't have the stomach for it. As a father of two, I prefer to have thoughts of such a scenario deeply repressed.

Posted by: boscobarbell at June 23, 2010 11:21 AM

I'll add my voice to the choir: It sounds like a really good book. However, I'm the mother of two, including a seven-year-old daughter, and even this expertly-written and evocative review is going to give me nightmares.

Posted by: Another Kate at June 23, 2010 11:39 AM

I'm with Karen. Losing my son is my greatest fear, and I cannot read books or watch movies about the subject. Same reason I've owned - but never read - The Lovely Bones. Can't do it, won't do it.

But lovely review.

Posted by: cydeleida at June 23, 2010 12:12 PM

I'm also a huge Brockmeier fan. I absolutely loved "A Brief History of the Dead" and have been trying to get my neighborhood book club to read t all year. Unfortunately, they are more interested in "The Help". I will be checking this out immediately: incidentally I also just finished a book of his short stories and they are excellent.

Posted by: PaddyDog at June 23, 2010 1:18 PM

Bonnye: I'm reading one called "The Age of Misrule: World's End". Someone on a Cannonball review a while back commented about it and I looked into it. The writer is Mark Chadbourn and this book is the beginning of a (now finished) trilogy. It's about our world of logic and science giving way to the old ways of magic and is a mix of Celtic and Arthurian legends. So far, pretty great. Much darker tone than I was expecting.

Posted by: TylerDFC at June 23, 2010 1:43 PM

Hey, that's me up there!

PaddyDog, is that the collection with the "choose your own adventure" story? I've read that one and loved it as well.

I totally hear all of you who say you can't read this book. It is a tough subject, but I still recommend the novel. Brockmeier has a way of dealing with tragedy that can be beautiful and even hopeful, especially in the stories that imagine how Celia's life turned out. But yeah, after you read it, maybe go give your kids an extra squeeze and story at bedtime.

Posted by: MelBivDevoe at June 23, 2010 6:08 PM

i've read this and totally agree with your review. it was heartbreaking. it's too bad so many people with kids on this thread won't read it...but i understand that.

i also liked a brief history of the dead; has brockmeier written anything lately? how'd i lose track of him? i'm off to see what amazon says...

Posted by: splinter at June 23, 2010 9:08 PM

Stories like this frighten me. I mean REALLY frighten me...

Our littlest bro Shea has gotten lost once or twice.
Once he wandered off while we were loading two taxis to go home from Tenerife.
It's only that one person from each taxi thought to ask 'Which Taxi is the baby in?' (he was two at the time) that saved us from literally driving off without him. It turned out he'd walked ten feet around the corner and was just standing watching the beach. Literally hundreds of people were around and no one thought to stop and ask if this kid was okay, we just walked over and grabbed him but we could easily have left him.
I feel sick just thinking about it.

I'd read this but like I say, the thought of a child just...vanishing like that...it's awful.
There are so many infamous stories as well, one in particular always stayed with me.
A little UK boy named Ben was in Greece with his family. He was playing in the garden of their house and he too just...vanished. Poof, thin air, gone.
Cops tried to blame a local group of Gypsies who had been seen near the house a few times(it was a rural area with frequent walkers etc) which was a dick move in it's self, but he was never found.
He vanished in 1991. 19 years ago. Damn it.
This is a great review but I will be avoiding this book like the plague...my fragile sanity can't handle it

Posted by: Nadine at June 24, 2010 4:37 AM

Do you still looking for the special place to sell or buy your stock flash components. Stop Looking. FlashJuggler has it ALL!

Posted by: Flash Reseller at March 9, 2011 11:04 PM

You are informed well. Lets hear more about this topic. What do you think?

Posted by: forex trading tips at March 10, 2011 6:23 PM

Thanks i like your blog very much , i come back most days to find new posts like this.

Posted by: Andrew A. Sailer at March 15, 2011 4:53 PM