web
counter
 

Sleeping Beauty: Retold

By Malin | Posted Under Book Reviews | Comments (16)



2008_house_of_the_sle.jpg

Yet another fairy tale retelling, this one a modernized take on Sleeping Beauty. Talia is a spoiled and bored princess who since she was old enough to understand what people said to her, has been told that she must avoid spindles, because of a spell placed on her during her christening. Talia doesn’t actually know what a spindle is, as all such things have been banned from the country, but on her sixteenth birthday, as she is wandering through the palace trying on dresses to find the perfect one for her birthday ball, and she finds an old lady who lets her play with her interesting spinning device - and just like that, Talia and the entire kingdom of Euphrasia (right next to Belgium) fall asleep and the country disappears off the map.

Three hundred years later, spoiled and bored American teenager Jack is on a three week, all-expenses paid tour of Europe. Of course, he doesn’t actually appreciate how lucky this makes him, and mainly wants to go back home. He and his friend escape from the scheduled tour and when looking for a beach, fight their way through the thick hedge surrounding Euphrasia, and find the royal palace instead. Jack finds the sleeping princess, and is struck with the overwhelming urge to kiss her, even though in real life, this would be a massively creepy and inappropriate thing to do. His kiss wakes Talia, and as the spell specified that only true love’s kiss could wake her, Talia deduces that the oddly dressed gentleman must be her true love, whether he wants to be or not.

The rest of the kingdom also wake up, and Talia’s parents are not exactly happy, realizing that their kingdom is 300 years behind the times. They blame Talia, who is understandably a bit put out, as the spell was clearly inescapable, and she would have had an easier time avoiding spindles in the first place if she’d actually been shown what one looked like. She forces Jack to take her with him, and soon they are on their way back to the US. Jack wants to bring Talia mainly to piss off his parents, who he feels do not care for him and are never there for him, and Talia just wants to see the world, after having been extremely sheltered for the first sixteen years of her life.

Both the protagonists start out as quite unlikeable, spoiled and self-centered, but over the course of the story, they force each other to view the world in different ways. Jack introduces Talia to modern technology, airplanes, cell phones and hot dogs, while Talia, from a time where modern technology couldn’t effectively make it perfectly possible to get through life without actually ever talking to anyone else, shows Jack that by listening to the people around him, and maybe talking to them instead of shutting them out, he may learn something, and possibly sort out some of the things that have frustrated and annoyed him.

I got A Kiss in Time because I absolutely loved Alex Flinn’s modernized take on Beauty and the Beast in Beastly (coming soon to a cinema near you in what looks like a not very good adaptation starring yer-girl out of High School Musical and yer-man out of that Alex Ryder-movie Stormbreaker that no one ever remembers). While I didn’t in any way dislike A Kiss in Time, it was nowhere near as good, and struggles a bit to make the story plausible. The change in the characters happens a little bit too fast, and a little too neatly, for it to be entirely satisfying. But it was by no means bad, and a more than adequate way to spend a few hours.

This review is part of the Cannonball Read series. For more of Malin’s reviews, check out Malin’s Book of Blogs.









Each Time You Like, Share, Tweet or Stumble a Pajiba Post, An Angel Does the Paul Rudd Dance



George Lucas Needs To Recruit | AT-AT Day Afternoon | Mesrine Trailer: Nobody Kills Me Until I Say So









Comments

Dustin's doing the cannonball read? Cool.

Posted by: denesteak at July 22, 2010 10:29 AM

Being a Weaver and also a hand Spinner, I feel rather qualified to give my take on this story.

1. There are two kinds of spinning wheels. Great wheels and Indian charkas have sharp pointy spikes for their spindles, and you could accidentally prick your finger on one. Then there are Saxony, Norwegian Double Deckers and Castle wheels, which have their spindles as the center of a bobbin, and there's no way you can prick your finger on one, as it's basically a large wooden spool. I'm curious as to how the "interesting spinning device" was described or illustrated.

2. Also there are drop spindles which consist of a spike (the spindle) and a whorl ( a bead or disk used for momentum). This could also have been the interesting spinning device, as the small metal ones could have a sharp pointy bit at the top or bottom.

3. How could she possibly been trying on new dresses? In order to make a dress, you need fabric. In order to get fabric, you have to weave it out of yarn or thread. In order to get yarn or thread, you have to SPIN raw fiber (such as wool, cotton, silk, flax, etc.). So, my take on this story is that everyone has been wearing old clothes for 16 years, or is walking around nekkid.

4. I believe in the original fairy tale, the young man breaks into the enchanted castle, finds the princess, and rapes her while she sleeps, and then leaves. She wakes up to the agony of childbirth, and they all lived happily ever after. The end.

Posted by: BWeaves at July 22, 2010 10:30 AM

Oh I just read through the review and got to the bottom. Good job Malin! I feel like re-tellings of fairy tales can go both ways - either I keep anticipating what's happening because of my knowledge of the fairy tale; or I am just completely surprised by what the author was able to do with the story, completely reinventing it. My favorite is still Ella Enchanted.

Posted by: denesteak at July 22, 2010 10:35 AM

4. I believe in the original fairy tale, the young man breaks into the enchanted castle, finds the princess, and rapes her while she sleeps, and then leaves. She wakes up to the agony of childbirth, and they all lived happily ever after. The end.

WOW. Geezis, BWeaves, you made me choke on my coffee.

WOW.

Posted by: Anna von Beaverdouche at July 22, 2010 10:43 AM

Yes, Anna von B, those Grimm fairy tales were pretty grim.

Posted by: BWeaves at July 22, 2010 10:52 AM

I like BWeaves. She's edumacational.

Posted by: admin at July 22, 2010 10:57 AM

She sure is, admin. She sure is.

Posted by: Anna von Beaverdouche at July 22, 2010 11:13 AM

Hey BWeaves! I'd love your take on Spindle's End, logistically speaking.

In terms of writing quality, McKinley unravels towards the end, as she is wont to do (see what I did there?) but story-wise, I'd call it 3/4 sound. I've had questions about the practicality of her non-pointy spindles, though, which seem...implausible.

Posted by: Salieri2 at July 22, 2010 1:39 PM

Good lord BWeaves, apparently I've never read the Grimm version. Sleeping Beauty is my favorite of all the fairly tales, and I think I might just stick to good ole Walt Disney's vision on this one. Sounds like I might have to check out Beastly, too.

Posted by: Even Stevens at July 22, 2010 2:54 PM

I just looked up "Spindle's End" on Wikipedia, and read:

"Rosie becomes a talented and well-known horse leech, more inclined to wear breeches and whittle spindle ends than wear dresses and practice embroidery."

I have NO IDEA what any of that means. Who whittle's spindle ends and what are spindle ends anyway? Forget that, what the heck is a horse leech?

A spindle is a wooden stick. All of mine have rounded ends or hooks on the ends, not points. I have one Indian book charka (it's shaped like a closed book, and when you open it, it turns into a spinning wheel) that has sharp pointy metal spindles, but you'd certainly never whittle them.

Posted by: BWeaves at July 22, 2010 5:33 PM

BWeaves, I do know the original fairy tale, but do believe that the Grimm one is a more cleaned up one.

Also, in the book, the people of Euphrasia either have to buy their clothes from abroad, and all the dresses the princess can choose from are from famous tailors and seamstresses from all over the world outside Euphrasia, where there is obviously not a spindle ban. Also, the "evil" witch has had spindles all along, and most of the dresses she shows the princess are conjured up by magic. So people did have clothes, they just couldn't make their own (there's actually a bit where the princess talks about how pissed off the population in general is about the spindle ban).

I read "Spindle's End" some years ago, but don't recall it very clearly. Prefer "Beauty", "Rose Daughter" and "Deerskin", when it comes to McKinley's fairy tale retellings.

Posted by: Malin at July 22, 2010 6:45 PM

I used to be wondering the same thing too, nevertheless yourmeans of putting it clears my thoughts up just a little for me ta.

Posted by: Agatha Winslow at March 5, 2011 5:25 AM

Useful ! Thanks you , I love your site ! I' ll come back

Posted by: maryellen moberly at March 6, 2011 11:30 AM

Hey! I was searching on google for sites smiliar to your and luckly fund your site and I'm already a fan! keep up the good work.Please add more new posts daily, because I will definitely come back

Posted by: Tyson F. Gautreaux at March 6, 2011 12:10 PM

Thanks for your suggestions. One thing we have noticed is the fact banks as well as financial institutions know the spending practices of consumers and also understand that most of the people max out their cards around the holiday seasons. They correctly take advantage of this specific fact and then start flooding your own inbox along with snail-mail box along with hundreds of no interest APR credit cards offers shortly when the holiday season comes to an end. Knowing that for anyone who is like 98% of American community, you'll get at the possible opportunity to consolidate card debt and transfer balances towards 0 APR credit cards.

Posted by: Jack Bynes at March 9, 2011 3:04 AM

This is exactly the tip I have been searching for. Just wait till my boss heard about it. Thank You.

Posted by: Be Go at March 18, 2011 8:32 PM