free counter with statistics A Thousand Splendid Suns | Pajiba - Scathing Reviews for Bitchy People

9781847371164.jpg
100 Books in One Year: A Thousand Splendid Suns by Khaled Hosseini

Cannonball Read / Figgy

Book Reviews | February 5, 2009 | Comments (10)


Khaled Hosseini is perhaps better known for his breakout novel, The Kite Runner (chosen as one of the best books of the generation, by this site). It’s the story of two boys living and growing up in war-torn Afghanistan, their friendship torn apart by the fact that each is from a different religious faction. With the Kite Runner, I finally understood the complexity and the magnitude of everything that had, and was still happening in that far-off country I had only heard about in the news. I think that (and this might be true for most Westerners) we have become almost numb to the constant reports of so many dead and so many attacks coming from Afghanistan, so that we almost come to forget that there are human lives being torn apart, friendships and families destroyed in a senseless struggle for power. Hosseini, with his simple yet touching prose, brought it all home in his first novel; though the story was fiction and the book had some flaws, he gave us a penetrating, honest look into Afghanistan, probably the first for many readers.

In A Thousand Splendid Suns, Hosseini does the same, but in a much more powerful way. This time, he focuses on the group that is perhaps the most affected by the wars in which they have little or no say at all: the women of Afghanistan. Hosseini, his style much more mature and elegant than in the Kite Runner, tells the story of two very different women: Mariam and Laila. The first part of the book focuses on Mariam, an illegitimate girl raised by a bitter, sad mother. Mariam is visited every now and then by her father, Jalil, a wealthy man whom she adores. She is a happy child until she discovers that her father and his family are ashamed of her, when she isn’t allowed into his house after he breaks a promise to take her somewhere. She is heartbroken, and remains a sad and tragic figure as she is later forcefully married to a much older man. Mariam, a poor, uneducated girl, accepts her life as the isolated wife of an abusive, religiously conservative man, because she knows nothing better. Or rather, she believes she deserves nothing better. All she knows is that she must live the life she has been given, and that to fight it would be useless.

Hosseini leaves Mariam for a while to tell us of Laila, a young girl, who lives down the street from the reclusive Mariam and her husband. Unlike the older woman, Laila has a loving family and a progressive father who believes women have the right to be educated and to work. Laila falls in love with a young man named Tariq, but just before they can be together, Afghanistan is thrown into a cycle of civil wars and invasions that would sink it into a constantly changing, constantly dangerous world in which death is always just around the corner. I won’t spoil the how, but I’ll just say that eventually Laila’s and Miriam’s lives are brought together.

It’s here that Hosseini connects their two stories, and the women’s relationship, tense at first, is the most honest and touching part of the entire book, and I admit it brought tears to my eyes. Laila finally allows Mariam to see that there is more to the world than suffering and sadness, resignation and numbness. The love that grows between them, like a mother and daughter, is beautifully written by Hosseini, their lives being affected but not much changed by the constant warfare in Afghanistan. As women during the reign of the Taliban, they are not allowed to know or to see anything, but Hosseini constantly connects their lives to what is going on in the larger world. They are in many ways helpless, but they learn to survive by their strength and love alone.

I think this last part is why I found this book to be much more real and powerful than The Kite Runner. It’s so rare to hear of war from the point of view of women, let alone Afghanistan, and even more rare to see it done so well as Hosseini does. The two women are so carefully drawn that you come to understand them completely, and there is never a moment when they seem unrealistic; they feel real, and their story has the most impact because of it. It’s never manipulative or cloying: it’s honest.

A Thousand Splendid Suns is a story full of sadness and tragedy, but there are moments of true beauty and happiness in the lives of Mariam and Laila, and these are just as heart-wrenching and powerful. I absolutely loved reading this book, even when it had me sobbing into my shirt in the middle of the night.

This review is part of the Cannonball Read series. Details about here and the growing number of participants and their blogs, from which these reviews are pulled, are here. And check here for more of Figgy’s reviews.


S. Darko Teaser Trailer | The Making of AMC's The Prisoner



Comments

I loved this book too, and so much more than the Kite Runner. I thought the writing was better, and the story of these women was so powerful.

Posted by: Carrie at February 5, 2009 9:26 AM

A very well written and insightful review Figgy. This one line spoke to me in particular:

I think that (and this might be true for most Westerners) we have become almost numb to the constant reports of so many dead and so many attacks coming from Afghanistan..

Being a Canadian I used to get quite upset that the media really "forgot" about Afghanistan once the invasion liberation of Iraq took place. Being that Canada was not involved (directly) in the Iraq conflict, I was dissappointed that most media outlets completely ignored what was happening in Afghanistan.

Upon some reflection, given the day and age we live in, if I really wanted to find out what was happening in Afghanistan I easily could. But I didn't/don't.

I have become comfortably numb.

Posted by: admin at February 5, 2009 9:31 AM

I agree with Carrie, for some reason this story hit me much harder than Kite Runner. Not that that book wasn't powerful, but I just felt like Husseini improved so much with this book.

Great review, Figgy. This book make me cry like whoa too.

Posted by: Marra at February 5, 2009 9:33 AM

I'm such a shameful beast...I still have Kite Runner in my "To Read" stack. Looks like I'll have to get to it, so I can read this one as well.

Great job, Ms. Figgy.

Posted by: Mike R. at February 5, 2009 9:56 AM

The last lines in the book brought tears to my eyes and sobs from my mouth.

Then, I put the book down, looked around, saw a little old lady had witnessed my pussiness and so I kicked her in the shins and called her a crazy old coot, laughed like a madman and went and got myself a latte. Yeah, fuck you old lady. Fuuuck you.

Posted by: Janey at February 5, 2009 10:38 AM

This book was so brutal and yet so gorgeous-nice review Figgy!

Posted by: Julie at February 5, 2009 10:42 AM

Beautiful review, Figgy. I loved The Kite Runner even though it makes me cry even now just thinking about it. (yes, I'm a wuss) I picked this book up, but I haven't yet been able to bring myself to read it. Just reading your review has me all teary! I'll give it a go.

Posted by: MissNev at February 5, 2009 1:47 PM

I have read The Kite Runner but not A thousand Splendid Suns. I thought The Kite Runner read like a typical Bollywood movie. An 80s Bollywood movie. Where the villains are fat and have handlebar moustaches. You can practically hear the bad sound effects "Dushum!" at the end when they fight for the boy. The first part was good, when he was younger and happy and all that, the goodbyes made me tear up a bit and for that I give the writer some credit, but come on! The ending? So contrived.

Posted by: Agony Aunt at February 5, 2009 3:40 PM

Yay! thanks, guys!

By the way, is it just me or is the front-page link to this broken? I could only get here by clicking on the comments link.

Posted by: figgy at February 5, 2009 3:44 PM

Yeah the main link is broken. I had to click on comments.

I LOVED the last line of this review, because that's exactly what I did: when I finished this book, I was sobbing into my shirt in the middle of the night. I will NEVER forget these characters. It's such a powerful book. Thanks for the review, this is one of those books I have in hardcover and won't sell to Half-Price Books, ever.

Posted by: Anastasia Beaverhausen at February 6, 2009 1:28 AM